Expert knowledge-based assessment of farming practices for different biotic indicators using fuzzy logic

Journal of Environmental Management

Volumn 95, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 132-143

  Sattler, Claudia ^a   Stachow, Ulrich ^a   Berger, Gert ^a  

^a LEIBNIZ CENTRE FOR AGRICULTURAL LANDSCAPE RESEARCH ZALF   (Germany)

Author keywords

Biodiversity; Crop production; Expert judgment; Fuzzy logic; MODAM; Modeling

Indexed keywords

COMPUTER CIRCUITS; CONSERVATION; CROPS; CULTIVATION; FARMS; FUZZY LOGIC; KNOWLEDGE BASED SYSTEMS; RISK ASSESSMENT; TILLAGE;

BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION; BIOTIC INDICATORS; CROP PRODUCTION; EXPERT JUDGMENT; EXPERT KNOWLEDGE; FARMING PRACTICES; FUZZY-LOGIC; KNOWLEDGE BASED; MODAM; MODELING;

BIODIVERSITY;

MINERAL;

AGRICULTURAL PRACTICE; ASSESSMENT METHOD; BIODIVERSITY; BIOINDICATOR; CROP PRODUCTION; FUZZY MATHEMATICS; INTEGRATED APPROACH; KNOWLEDGE; RISK FACTOR; TILLAGE;

ARTICLE; BIODIVERSITY; CONTROLLED STUDY; FARMING SYSTEM; FUZZY LOGIC; HUMAN;

EID: 80855156579     PISSN: 03014797     EISSN: 10958630     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2011.10.004     Document Type: Article

References (78)

1. Ahrens M., Goretzki J. Langohr leicht im Plus. Unsere Jagd 2001, 1:32-35.
2. Andersen M.C., Watts J.M., Freilich J.E., Yool S.R., Wakefield G.I., McCauley J.F., Fahnestock P.B. Regression-tree modeling of desert tortoise habitat in the central Mojave Desert. Ecological Applications 2000, 10:890-900.
3. Anon. Engpaß im Sommer. Wie Göttinger Feldhasen auf die Landbewirtschaftung regieren - Fünf Jahre Hasentelemetrie auf dem Versuchsgut Reinshof. Niedersächsischer Jäger 1995, 3:136-137.
4. Arlt K., Hilbig W., Illig H. Ackerunkräuter, Ackerwildkräuter 1991, Neue Brehm Bücherei, Ziemsen Verlag, Wittenberg Lutherstadt. 1. Auflage.
5. Bachinger J., Zander P. ROTOR, a tool for generating d evaluating crop rotations for organic farming systems. European Journal of Agronomy 2007, 26:130-143.
6. Berger G., Dürr S., Kretschmer H. Integration von Zielen des Biotop- und Artenschutzes in ackerbauliche Nutzungssysteme am Beispiel von Amphibien. Eberswalder wissenschaftliche Schriften 1997, 3:81-97.
7. Berger G., Schönbrodt T., Langer C., Kretschmer H. Die Agrarlandschaft des Lebusplatte als Lebensraum für Amphibien. Amphibien in der Agrarlandschaft 1999, 81-99. Natur & Text, Potsdam. A. Krone, R. Baier, N. Schneeweiß (Eds.).
8. Bojórquez-Tapia L.A., Sánchez-Colon S., Flore Martinez A. Building consensus in environmental impact assessment through multicriteria modeling and sensitivity analysis. Environmental Management 2005, 36:469-481.
9. Bosshard A. A methodology and terminology of sustainability assessment and its perspectives for rural planning. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 2000, 77:29-41.
10. Cornelissen, A.M.G., 2003. Two Faces of Sustainability. Fuzzy Evaluation of Sustainable Development. Dissertation, University of Wageningen.
11. Daunicht W., Salski A., Nohr P., Neubert C. A fuzzy knowledge-based model of annual production of skylarks. Ecological Modelling 1996, 85:67-73.
12. Delgado A., Moreira F. Do wheat, barley and oats provide similar habitat and food resources for birds in cereal steppes?. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 2002, 93:441-446.
13. Donald P.F., Evans A.D., Buckingham D.L., Muirhead L.B., Wilson J.D. Factors affecting the territory distribution of Skylarks Alauda arvensis breeding on lowland farmland. Bird Study 2001, 48:271-278.
14. Donald P.F., Evans A.D., Muirhead L.B., Buckingham D.L., Kirby W.B., Schmitt S.I.A. Survival rates, causes of failure and productivity of Skylark Alauda arvensis nests on lowland farmland. Ibis 2002, 144:652-664.
15. Dürr S., Berger G., Kretschmer H. Effekte acker- und pflanzenbaulicher Bewirtschaftung auf Amphibien und Empfehlungen für die Bewirtschaftung in Amphibien-Reproduktionszentren. Amphibien in der Agrarlandschaft 1999, 101-116. Natur & Text, Potsdam. A. Krone, R. Baier, N. Schneeweiß (Eds.).
16. Elsen T.v Species diversity as a task for organic agriculture in Europe. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 2000, 77:101-109.
17. Eraud C., Boutin J.M. Density and productivity of breeding Skylarks Alauda arvensis in relation to crop type on agricultural lands in western France. Bird Study 2002, 49:287-296.
18. Flade M., Plachter H., Schmidt R., Werner A. Nature Conservation in Agricultural Ecosystems 2006, Results of the Schorfheide-Chorin Research Project, Quelle & Meyer, Wiebelsheim.
19. Fuchs S., Saacke B. Arable fields as habitat for flora and fauna - a synopsis. Nature Conservation in Agricultural Ecosystems - Results of the Schorfheide-Chorin Research Project 2006, 248-296. Quelle & Meyer, Wiebelsheim. M. Flade, H. Plachter, R. Schmidt, A. Werner (Eds.).
20. Gregory R.D., Baillie S.R. Large-scale habitat use of some declining British birds. Journal of Applied Ecology 1998, 35:785-799.
21. Greiler H.-J. Insektengesellschaften auf selbstbegrünten und eingesäten Ackerbrachen. Agrarökologie 1994, 11:1-136.
22. Heathwaite A.L. Making process-based knowledge useable at the operational level: a framework for modelling diffuse pollution from agricultural land. Environmental Modelling and Software 2003, 18:753-760.
23. Henderson I.G., Cooper J., Fuller R.J., Vickery J. The relative abundance of birds on set-aside and neighbouring fields in summer. Journal of Applied Ecology 2000, 37:335-347.
24. Hilbig W. Möglichkeiten zur Erhaltung bestandsgefährdeter Ackerwildpflanzen und ihrer Pflanzengesellschaften durch extensive Ackernutzung. Ackerlandschaften. Nachhaltigkeit und Naturschutz auf ertragsschwachen Standorten 2005, 173-190. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. U. Hampicke, B. Litterski, W. Wichtmann (Eds.).
25. Hole D.G., Perkins A.J., Wilson J.D., Alexander I.H., Grice P.V., Evans A.D. Does organic farming benefit biodiversity. Biological Conservation 2005, 122:113-130.
26. Hutchings M.R., Harris S. The Current Status of the Brown Hare (Lepus europaeus) in Britain 1996, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough, UK.
27. Kelly K.L. A systems approach to identifying decisive information for sustainable development. European Journal of Operational Research 1998, 109:452-464.
28. Knauer R. Langohr macht nicht schlapp 2004, Ein Projekt in Brandenburg untersucht, was dem Feldhasen das Leben schwer macht. Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung Nr. 84, 08.04.2004.
29. Kontic B. Why are some experts more credible than others?. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 2000, 20:427-434.
30. Kotze D.J., Samways M.J. Support for the multi-taxa approach in biodiversity assessment, as shown by epigaeic invertebrates in an Afromontane forest archipelago. Journal of Insect Conservation 1999, 3:125-143.
31. Kramer I. Biodiversität von Arthropoden in Wanderbrachen und ihre Bewertung durch Laufkäfer, Schwebfliegen und Stechimmen. Agrarökologie 1996, 17:1-149.
32. Betriebsplanung Landwirtschaft 2006/2007 2008, Landwirtschaftsverlag, Münster. KTBL (Kuratorium für Technik und Bauwesen in der Landwirtschaft) (Ed.).
33. Leeuwis C. Changing views of innovation and the role of science. The 'socio-technical root-system' as a tool for identifying relevant cross-disciplinary research questions. (Pre)Proceedings of the Sixth European IFSA Symposium, 4-7 April, Vila Real, Portugal 2004, vol. II:773-782. Available at:, (last accessed 04.03.11.). http://home.utad.pt/%7Edes/ifsa/ifsa_6th_eu_proceed.pdf.
34. Lewandowski K., Nowakowski J.J. Spatial distribution of brown hare Lepus europaeus populations in habitats of various types of agriculture. Acta Theriologica 1993, 38:435-442.
35. Litterski B., Jörns S., Grabow Meik, Manthey M. Extensiv bewirtschaftete Sandstandorte aus vegetationsökologischer Sicht. Ackerlandschaften. Nachhaltigkeit und Naturschutz auf ertragsschwachen Standorten 2005, 191-206. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. U. Hampicke, B. Litterski, W. Wichtmann (Eds.).
36. Llusia D., Onate J.J. Are the conservation requirements of pseudo-steppe birds adequately covered by Spanish agri-environmental schemes? An ex-ante assessment. Ardeola 2005, 52:31-42.
37. Lotfi A., Howarth M. Experimental design with fuzzy levels. Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing 1997, 8:525-532.
38. Lundström-Gillieron C., Schlaepfer R. Hare abundance as an indicator for urbanisation and intensification of agriculture in Western Europe. Ecological Modelling 2003, 168:283-301.
39. McKenzie A.J., Vickery J.A., Leifert C., Shotton P., Whittingham M.J. Disentangling the effects of fertilisers and pesticides on winter stubble use by farmland birds. Basic and Applied Ecology 2011, 12:80-88.
40. McNeill D., Freiberger P. Fuzzy Logic. Die " unscharfe" Logic erobert die Technik 1996, Droemersche Verlagsanstalt Th. Knaur, München.
41. Mertens M., Huwe B. FuN-Balance: a fuzzy balance approach for the calculation of nitrate leaching with incorporation of data imprecision. Geoderma 2002, 109:269-287.
42. Mitra B., Scott H.D., Dixon J.C., McKimmey J.M. Applications of fuzzy logic to the prediction of soil erosion in a large watershed. Geoderma 1998, 86:183-209.
43. Nötzold R. Kleinräumige Dispersionsmuster zoophager Fliegen (Diptera: Syrphidae, Empidoidea) im Agrarwirtschaftsraum und ihre Bedeutung für das Naturschutzmanagement. Agrarökologie 2000, 39:1-158.
44. Odderskaer P., Prang A., Poulsen J.G., Andersen P.N., Elmegaard N. Skylark (Alauda arvensis) utilisation of micro-habitats in spring barley fields. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 1997, 62:21-29.
45. OECD Environmental Indicators for Agriculture 1997, Paris.
46. Oldham R.S., Latham D.M., Hilton-Brown D., Brooks J.G. The Effect of Agricultural Fertilisers on Amphibians - (D): The Toxicity of Ammonium Nitrate, the Persistence of Fertiliser Granules, the Effect of Organic Manure, the Wider Implication of Fertiliser Impact 1993, De Montfort University Under Contract to English Nature, Contract No. F72-15-10. 1993.
47. Piorr A., Werner W. Nachhaltige landwirtschaftliche Produktionssysteme im Vergleich: Bewertung anhand von Umweltindikatoren 1998, Verlagsunion Agrar, Frankfurt.
48. Poulsen J.G., Sotherton N.W., Aebischer N.J. Comparative nesting and feeding ecology of skylarks Alauda arvensis on arable farmland in southern England with special reference to set-aside. Journal of Applied Ecology 1998, 35:131-147.
49. Poulsen J.G. Behaviour and parental care of Skylark Alauda arvensis chicks. Ibis 1996, 138:525-531.
50. Prato T. Assessing ecosystem sustainability and management using fuzzy-logic. Ecological Economics 2007, 61:171-177.
51. Primdahl J., Vesterager J.P., Finn J.A., Vlahos G., Kristensen L., Vejre H. Current use of impact models for agri-environment schemes and potential for improvements of policy design and assessment. Journal of Environmental Management 2010, 91:1245-1254.
52. Reif, G., 2000. Moderne Aspekte der Wissensverarbeitung. Ein interaktiver Lernbehelf für das Web Based Training. Diploma thesis, Technical University of Graz.
53. Reus J., Leendertse P., Bockstaller C., Fomsgaard I., Gutsche V., Lewis K., Nilsson C., Pussemier L., Trevisan M., Werf H.v.d, Alfarroba F., Blümel S., Isart J., McGrath D., Seppälä T. Comparison and evaluation of eight pesticide environmental risk indicators developed in Europe and recommendations for future use. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 2002, 90:177-187.
54. Ricketts T.H., Dinerstein E., Olson D.M., Loucks C. Who's where in North America. Bioscience 1999, 49:369-381.
55. Roßberg D., Gutsche V., Enzian S., Wick M. NEPTUN 2000-Erhebung von Daten zum tatsächlichen Einsatz chemischer Pflanzenschutzmittel im Ackerbau Deutschlands. Berichte aus der Biologischen Bundesanstalt für Land- und Forstwirtschaft 2002, 98:1-27.
56. Sattler C., Kächele H., Verch G. Assessing the intensity of pesticide use in agriculture. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 2007, 119:299-304.
57. Sattler, C., 2008. ökologische Bewertung und Akzeptanzanalyse pflanzenbaulicher Produktionsverfahren. Dissertation, Humboldt University of Berlin. Available at: (last accessed 16.09.11.). http://www.zalf.de/home_zalf/download/soz/mitarbeiter/sattler/CS_Diss_Druckversion_21_08_2008.pdf.
58. Sauberer N., Zulka K.P., Abensperg-Traun M., Berg H.-M., Bieringer G., Milasowszky N., Moser D., Plutzar C., Pollheimer M., Storch C., Tröstl R., Zechmeister H., Grabherr G. Surrogate taxa for biodiversity in agricultural landscapes of eastern Austria. Biological Conservation 2004, 117:181-190.
59. Schacherer A. Ackerwildkräuter 1992, Hannover.
60. Schoen M. Long-lived sustainable microhabitat structures in arable ecosystems, and Skylarks (Alauda arvensis). Journal for Nature Conservation 2011, 19:143-147.
61. Shanteau J., Weiss D.J., Thomas R., Pounds J.C. Performance-based assessment of expertise: how to decide if someone is an expert or not. European Journal of Operational Research 2002, 136:253-263.
62. Stachow U., Hufnagel J., Glemnitz M., Berger G., Bachinger J., Zander P., Sattler C. Indicators of landscape functions related to modifications and patterns of agricultural systems. Paper Presented at the NIJOS/OECD Expert Meeting on Agricultural Landscape Indicators on October 7-9, 2002 in Oslo 2002, Available at:, (last accessed 16.09.11.). http://www.nijos.no/Publikasjoner/Rapporter/2003/oecd/16_Stachow.pdf.
63. Stoate C., Boatman N.D., Borralho R.J., Rio Carvalho C., de Snoo G.R., Eden P. Ecological impacts of arable intensification in Europe. Journal of Environmental Management 2001, 63:337-365.
64. Tapper S.C., Barnes R.F.W. Influence of farming practice on the ecology of the brown hare (Lepus europaeus). Journal of Applied Ecology 1986, 23:39-52.
65. Topping C.J. The impact on skylark numbers of reductions in pesticide usage in Denmark. Predictions using a landscape-scale individual-based model. NERI Technical Report 2005, 527:1-32.
66. Traeger D.H. Einführung in die Fuzzy-Logik 1994, B. G: Teubner, Stuttgart.
67. Van der Werf H.M.G., Zimmer C. An indicator of pesticide environmental impact based on a fuzzy expert system. Chemosphere 1998, 36:2225-2249.
68. Vane-Wright R.I., Smith C.R., Kitching I.J. Systematic assessment of taxic diversity by summation. Systematics and Conservation Evaluation 1994, 309-326. Clarendon Press, Oxford. P.L. Forey, C.J. Humphries, R.I. Vane-Wright (Eds.).
69. Vaughan N., Lucas E.A., Harris S., White P.C.L. Habitat associations of European hares Lepus europaeus in England and Wales: implications for farmland management. Journal of Applied Ecology 2003, 40:163-175.
70. Vickery J., Carter N., Fuller R.J. The potential value of managed cereal field margins as foraging habitats for farmland birds in the UK. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 2002, 89:41-52.
71. Wakeham-Dawson A., Aebischer N.J. Factors determining winter densities of birds on environmentally sensitive area arable reversion grassland in southern England, with special reference to skylarks (Alauda arvensis). Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 1998, 70:189-201.
72. Weibull A.-C., östman ö, Granqvist A. Species richness in agroecosystems: the effect of landscape, habitat and farm management. Biodiversity and Conservation 2003, 12:1335-1355.
73. Wilson J.D., Evans J., Browne S.J., King J.R. Territory distribution and breeding success of skylarks Alauda arvensis on organic and intensive farmland in southern England. Journal of Applied Ecology 1997, 34:1462-1478.
74. Zadeh L.A. Fuzzy logic equals computing with words. IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems 1996, 4:103-111.
75. Zadeh L.A. From computing with numbers to computing with words - from manipulation of measurements to manipulation of perceptions. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I-Fundamental Theory and Applications 1999, 45:105-119.
76. Zander P., Kächele H. Modelling multiple objectives of land use for sustainable development. Agricultural Systems 1999, 59:311-325.
77. Zander, P., 2003. Agricultural Land Use and Conservation Options - a Modelling Approach. Dissertation, University of Wageningen. Available at: (last accessed 16.09.11.). http://library.wur.nl/wda/dissertations/dis3372.pdf.
78. Zimmermann H. Fuzzy Set Theory and its Applications 2001, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston.