Chongqing: Equitable development driven by a "Third Hand"?

Modern China

Volumn 37, Issue 6, 2011, Pages 569-622

  Huang, Philip C C ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b RENMIN UNIVERSITY OF CHINA   (China)

Author keywords

Chongqing experience; economic development; Janos Kornai; land financing; Marxist theory; social equity; third finance

Indexed keywords

COMPETITION (ECONOMICS); ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT; EQUITY; FINANCE; GLOBAL ECONOMY; MARKET CONDITIONS; MARXISM; POLITICAL ECONOMY; SAVINGS;

CHINA; CHONGQING;

EID: 80355137100     PISSN: 00977004     EISSN: 15526836     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0097700411419966     Document Type: Article

References (110)

1. "Amtrak" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
2. Bai Chong-en,Hsieh Chang-Tai,Qian YingyiWashington, DC: Brookings Institution; 2006:61-88.
3. Biddulph SarahCambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press; 2007:.
4. Xiaoying Bo.(China Source) 2008; (Oct.): 23-31.
5. "Bo Xilai" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
6. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source). 2003;16:11-12.
7. Bo Xilai(China Source) (2011a) "(China Source),(China Source)" (Reducing the gap between city and countryside, and rich and poor, is to create history). Jan. 4. www.gx.sdu.edu.cn/2011-01-04.
8. Bo Xilai(Chinese Source)? (2011b) (Chinese Source) (Bo Xilai and Huang Qifan respond to 110 Chinese and foreign media outlets' questions). Mar. 8. www.cq.xinhuanet.com/2011-03/08/content_22223174.htm.
9. Bo Xilai(Chinese Source)(2011c) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)" (Bo Xilai talks with the Hong Kong and Macao media's visiting group to Chongqing: people's livelihood, democracy, sing red, and strike at organized crime). (Chinese Source), May2. http://news.hexun.com/2011-05-02/129205944.html.
10. 'Caifu': Chongqing wei quanqiu xinxing shangwu huanjing zuijia chengshi zhi yi" ": (Chinese Source)[Fortune (magazine): Chongqing is one of best cities for business in the world] (2011)(Chinese Source), July12. http://www.cq.xinhuanet.com/business/2011-07/12/content_23214797.htm.
11. Chan Anita,Unger Jonathan.A Chinese state enterprise under the reforms: what model of capitalism?.China J. 2009;62 (July): 1-26.
12. Chandler Alfred D.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press; 1977:.
13. Chang an qichecheng touzi liangjiang xinqu qianhou" (Chinese Source)[The before and after of the Chang'an's investment in the auto city of the two rivers new district] (2011)(Chinese Source), April16. www.liangjiang.gov.cn/ljxqtzlj/ljxqtzrzqy/2011416/2011416101543.htm.
14. China Development Research Foundation (2005) China Human Development Report. http://hdr.undp.org/en/reports/national/asiathepacific/china/china_2005_en.pdf.
15. "China's Chongqing starts household registration reform" (2010) Xinhua News, English, July29. http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010china/2010-07/29/c_13420830.htm.
16. Chong Gang shougou Aozhou tiekuang"(Chinese Source)[Chongqing Steel purchases Australian iron-ore mine] (2010) (Chinese Source), Oct. 24. http://cq.people.com.cn/news/20101024/2010102402720.htm.
17. "Chongqing dahei gushi, wo yue si yue haipa" (Chinese Source) [The Chongqing strike at organized crime story: the more I think about it the more scared I get] (2009), Sept. 5. www.360doc.com/content/09/0905/00/27104_5595861.shtml.
18. "Chongqing 'dipiao' jixu shi" (Chinese Source) [Chongqing's "land certificate" trial is to be continued] (2011) (Chinese Source)2 (Jan. 18). (Chinese Source)?. www.21bcr.com/index.html.
19. "Chongqing shi di liu ci quanguo renkou pucha zhuyao shuju gongbao"(Chinese Source) 2010(Chinese Source) [Public announcement of the main statistics on Chongqing's sixth national population census] (2011) (Chinese Source), May3. http://news.163.com/11/0503/01/733HTAIV00014AED.html.
20. "Chongqing shi gonganju juzhang Wang Lijun quanpiao dangxuan fushizhang" (Chinese Source) [Chongqing's chief of the public security bureau Wang Lijun is unanimously elected deputy mayor] (2011) (Chinese Source), May27. http://news.ifeng.com/mainland/detail_2011_05/27/6666545_0.shtml.
21. Chongqing shi tongji nianjian 2010 (Chinese Source) 2010 [Chongqing statistical yearbook 2010] (2010) (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source). www.cqtj.gov.cn/tjnj/2010/yearbook2010.pdf.
22. "Cong 'ba xiaoshi' dao 'si xiaoshi'" ? "(Chinese Source)?" ? "(Chinese Source)?" [From "eight hours" to "four hours"] (2007) (Chinese Source)?, Dec. 30. www.sohu.com.
23. "Corporation for Public Broadcasting" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
24. JianCui(Chinese Source) (2011) "(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)?" (The third finance of Chongqing: the tying together of state enterprise management and local land income). (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source), Feb. 3. http://finance.sina.com.cn/g/20110203/13589343299.shtml.
25. Zhiyuan Cui(2005) Liberal socialism and the future of China: a petty bourgeoisie manifesto. Pp. 157-74 in Tianyu Cao (ed.), The Chinese Model of Modern Development. London: Routledge
26. ZhiyuanCui(Chinese Source)? (2008a) "(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)" (The fertile meanings of market socialism for economics). Nov. 27. www.humanities.cn.
27. ZhiyuanCui (2008b) "(Chinese Source)--(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)?" (The Chongqing experience: state property appreciation and wealth stored among the people go forward hand-in-hand). Dec. 13. www.tecn.cn.
28. ZhiyuanCui (2009) "(Chinese Source)? '(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)': (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)?" (Coming to an understanding of "market socialism" from Chongqing: appreciation in value of state assets and wealth stored among the people go forward hand-in-hand). (Chinese Source). www.cui-zy.cn.
29. Zhiyuan Cui.(Chinese Source) '(Chinese Source)' (Chinese Source).?(Chinese Source). 2010;14 5 (Oct.): 5-10.
30. ZhiyuanCui (2011a) "(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)?" (Revelations of the Henry George theorem: the two sided nature of land financing). (Chinese Source), Jan. 28. www.cui-zy.cn.
31. ZhiyuanCui (2011b) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)" (Two rivers observations: equity can propel efficiency). (Chinese Source), Mar. 20. http://wen.org.cn/modules/article/view.article.php?a2491.
32. ZhiyuanCui (2011c) "(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'" (The Tennessee Valley Authority of the U.S. and Chongqing's eight big investment firms). April19. www.czy.caogen.com.
33. Dalu jiefang liantiao diaocha.(Chinese Source). 2008;:24-29.
34. "Fanny Mae" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
35. "Foxconn to move 200,000 of its jobs to central China" (2011) Psyorg, Mar. 4. www.physorg.com/news/2011-03-foxconn-jobs-central-china.html.
36. "Freddie Mac" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
37. GeorgeHenry ([1879] 1912) Progress and Poverty: An Inquiry into the Cause of Industrial Depressions and of Increase of Want with Increase of Wealth: The Remedy. www.econlib.org/library/YPDBooks/George/grgPP.html.
38. "Guoqi tuodi Chongqing fazhan guozi cheng zhengfu di san caizheng" (Chinese Source)[State enterprises hold up the bottom for Chongqing's development: state assets become the government's third finance] (2010)(Chinese Source), Dec. 10. www.cs.com.cn/cqzk/05/201012/t20101210_2703802.html.
39. WeifangHe(Chinese Source)? (2011) "(Chinese Source), (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)--(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)" (For the rule of law, for that ideal in our hearts: an open letter to the legal community in Chongqing), April12. http://new.21ccom.net/articles/zgyj/gqmq/2011/0412/33396.html.
40. Heilmann Sebastian.Maximum tinkering under uncertainty: unorthodox lessons from China.Modern China 35. 2009;4 (July): 450-62.
41. JintaoHu(Chinese Source)? (2008) (Chinese Source)(Hu Jintao's report at the Seventeenth Party Congress). Pt. 4. http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2007-10/24/content_6938568.htm.
42. Huang Philip C. C.China's neglected informal economy: reality and theory.Modern China 35. 2009; (July): 405-38.
43. Huang Philip C. C.Chinese Civil Justice, Past and Present. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield; 2010:.
44. Huang Philip C. C.The theoretical and practical implications of China's development experience: the role of informal economic practices.Modern China 37. 2011a; (Jan): 3-43.
45. Huang Philip C. C.The modern Chinese family: in light of economic and legal history.Modern China 37. 2011b;5 (Sept 497): 459.
46. QifanHuang(Chinese Source)? (2009) "(Chinese Source)" (Building the third finance). Sept. 21. http://cq.people.com.cn/news/2009921/200992124931.htm.
47. QifanHuang (2010a) "(Chinese Source)" (Chongqing's public rental housing is built for millions, not just a trick). (Chinese Source), July3. http://news.ifeng.com/mainland/detail_2010_07/03/1713021_1.shtml.
48. QifanHuang (2010b) "(Chinese Source)" (Use creative wisdom to solve the problem of people's livelihood). (Chinese Source), July30. http://cq.cqnews.net/sz/zwyw/201007/t20100730_4505073.htm.
49. QifanHuang (2010c) "(Chinese Source)-(Chinese Source)" (Using reform and opening as the handle to drive development that is good as well as fast: Mayor Huang Qifan's report at Chongqing University). Sept. 19. http://bbs.city.tianya.cn/tianyacity/content/45/1/1213979.shtml.
50. Qifan Huang.(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source). 2010d;:.
51. QifanHuang (2010e) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)" (Huang Qifan's writes essay to introduce Chongqing's experience in the exchange of farm land: insisting on the five basic principles). (Chinese Source), Nov. 9. http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2010-11/09/c_12753378.htm.
52. QifanHuang (2010f) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source),(Chinese Source)" (Huang Qifan's press conference: the policy system, policy implementation and three months of actual practice of Chongqing city's reform of the system of household registration), pts. 1 and 2. Nov. 14. http://mcrp.macrochina.com.cn/u/60/archives/2010/2083.html.
53. QifanHuang (2010g) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)" (Huang Qifan talks about Chongqing's development: let everything liven up first). (Chinese Source), Dec. 11. www.ifeng.com.
54. QifanHuang (2011a) "(Chinese Source)6-7(Chinese Source)!" (The two-income family can buy a home in 6-7 years!). (Chinese Source), Feb. 16. www.360doc.com/content/11/0227/11/36151_96531059.shtml.
55. QifanHuang (2011b) "(Chinese Source)980?" (Huang Qifan's reveals the secret of how Chongqing's income from land went from 0.2 billion to 98 billion).(Chinese Source), Feb. 18. http://cq.focus.cn/news/2011-02-18/1197488.html.
56. QifanHuang (2011c) "(Chinese Source)2011(Chinese Source)" (Huang Qifan's speech to the work meeting of Chongqing's State Assets Commission). (Chinese Source), Mar. 4. www.chinasoe.com.cn/theory/eco/2011-04-07/448.html.
57. QifanHuang (2011d) "(Chinese Source): '(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)" (Huang Qifan introduces and recommends Chongqing to Japanese enterprises: "creating a new model" adds to Chongqing's attraction). (Chinese Source), May20. www.cq.xinhuanet.com/zhengwu/2011-05/20/content_22813167_2.htm.
58. ZongzhiHuang[Philip C. C. Huang](Chinese Source) (2008) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)"(China's petty bourgeoisie and intermediate classes: a paradoxical social formation). (Chinese Source)6: 1-14. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source). www.lishiyushehui.cn.
59. Zongzhi Huang.(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source). 2010a;:.
60. Zongzhi Huang.(Chinese Source), (Chinese Source).(Chinese Source). 2010b;22 (5): 721-36.
61. "James E. Meade" (2011) www.encyclopedia.com/topic/James_Meade.aspx.
62. ZeminJiang(Chinese Source) (2002) (Chinese Source) (Jiang Zemin's report at the sixteenth party congress). Pt. 5. http://news.xinhuanet.com/ziliao/2002-11/17/content_693542.htm.
63. "Jiedu Chongqing moshi"(Chinese Source)[Deciphering the Chongqing model] (2000) (Chinese Source), Dec. 13. www.aisixiang.com.
64. "Jihuo guoqi: Wenzhou fuzhi Chongqing jingyan" (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)[Livening up state enterprises: Wenzhou copies the Chongqing experience] (2011) (Chinese Source), April14. http://forum.home.news.cn/thread/83661253/1.html.
65. "Kaifa gongsi moshi de Pudong shijian" (Chinese Source) [The model of development corporations in Pudong's practice] (2010) (Chinese Source), July2. www.pujiangforum.org/tabid/67/ArticleID/73/Default.aspx.
66. Kornai JanosPrinceton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press; 1992:.
67. LarsonChristina (2010) "Chicago on the Yangtze: welcome to Chongqing, the biggest city you've never heard of." Foreign Policy (Sept.-Oct.). www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/08/16/chicago_on_the_yangtze?page=0,0.
68. LeeSherry (2010) "Chongqing mayor Huang Qifan. Reform and innovation: a new path." Commonwealth Magazine 459 (Nov. 11). http://english.cw.com.tw/article.do?action=show&id=12409.
69. Yuanchao Li.(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source). 2011;:.
70. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)Lin George C. S.London: Routledge, 2009; 2009:.
71. Meade James E.
72. MeadeJames E. (1997) "Prize Lecture," 1977. www.nobelprize.org.
73. Overseas Private Investment Corporation" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
74. (Chinese Source). 2010a;:.
75. (Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'. 2010b;:.
76. '(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source). 2010c;:.
77. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)--(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'. 2011a;:.
78. (Chinese Source)20(Chinese Source). 2011b;:.
79. "Sanbai wushi yi! Deguo huagong jutou Basifu zai Chongqing jian jidi" 350?! (Chinese Source) [35 billion! German Giant BASF will build a base in Chongqing] (2011) (Chinese Source), April12. www.cq.xinhuanet.com.
80. "Sanbuwei: tudi churang jing shouyi ke yong gongzufang fazhan" (Chinese Source):(Chinese Source)[The three ministries: the net income from assignment of land may be used for the development of public rental housing] (2010) (Chinese Source)?. Nov. 16. www.stnn.cc.
81. "Sanbuwei yaoqiu quanguo tuiguang Chongqing gongzufang rongzi moshi" (Chinese Source) [The three ministries require that the Chongqing public rental housing's model for raising funds be pushed across the nation] (2010) (Chinese Source), Nov. 17. http://news.ifeng.com/mainland/detail_2010_11/17/3136823_0.shtml.
82. "61 Chinese companies make Fortune 500 List" (2011) Want China Times, July9. www.wantchinatimes.com/news-subclass-cnt.aspx?id=20110709000017&cid=1102.
83. "Social Security" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
84. WeiSu(Chinese Source) (2010) "(Chinese Source)" (The new government of Bo Xilai and the Chongqing model).(Chinese Source). http://finance.ifeng.com/opinion/fhzl/20100609/2294597.shtml.
85. Wei SuFan YangShiwen Liu(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source); 2011:.
86. Szelenyi Ivan.A theory of transitions.Modern China 34. 2008;1 (Jan.): 165-75.
87. RanTao(Chinese Source) and HuiWang(Chinese Source) (2010) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)" (China's uncompleted, transitioning reform of the land system: challenges and the way out). (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)2, pts. 1 and 2. www.usc.cuhk.edu.hk.
88. RanTaoXiLu(Chinese Source), FubingSu(Chinese Source), and HuiWang (2009) "(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source)-(Chinese Source)30(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)" (China's change of track under the evolving pattern of local competition: fiscal incentives and rethinking of the development model: a political-economic reconsideration of the thirty years of high growth with evidence from the perspective of "using land to finance local government"). (Chinese Source)7. www.usc.cuhk.edu.hk.
89. "Tennessee Valley Authority" (2011) www.wikipedia.com.
90. "The 2010 Time 100" (2010) Time Magazine, April29. www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1984685_1984864_1985416,00.html.
91. Tianze jingji yanjiusuo (Chinese Source) [Tianze Institute of Economic Research] (2011) "(Chinese Source), (Chinese Source) (Chinese Source)" (The nature of state-owned enterprises, their performance and reform, newest final draft). www.unirule.org.cn/secondweb/Article.asp?ArticleID=3102.
92. Tianze jingji yanjiusuo tudi wenti keti zu (Chinese Source) [Land Problem Study Group, Tianze Institute of Economic Research] (2007) "(Chinese Source)" (The implementation and protection of landed property rights under the background of urbanization). www.unirule.org.cn/Secondweb/Article.asp?ArticleID=2516.
93. Trevaskes SusanLanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield; 2007:.
94. Fang Wang.Jinwu Xiong.?'(Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source) 36. 2010;1 (Jan.): 34-43.
95. Shaoguang Wang.Adapting by learning: the evolution of China's rural health care financing.Modern China 35. 2009;4 (July): 370-404.
96. ShaoguangWang(Chinese Source) (2011) "(Chinese Source)3.0:(Chinese Source)" (On Chinese style socialism, version 3.0: the Chongqing experience). (Chinese Source) 2. www.aisixiang.com.
97. BangguoWu(Chinese Source) (2011) (Chinese Source) (Factual report of Wu Bangguo's investigation in Chongqing). (Chinese Source), April10. www.gov.cn.
98. JinpingXi(Chinese Source) (2010) "(Chinese Source)" (Xi Jinping investigates at Chongqing). (Chinese Source), Dec. 8. http://news.ifeng.com/mainland/detail_2010_12/08/3408638_0.shtml.
99. "Xipu gongzufang daikuan zhangben" (Chinese Source) [A detailed analysis of the account books of loans for public rental housing] (2011) 21(Chinese Source), May14. http://cs.xinhuanet.com/fc/03/201105/t20110514_2879080.html.
100. TaoYang(Chinese Source) (2008) "(Chinese Source), (Chinese Source)'(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)" (Striking at "black [organizations]," why do we see "black" but not the "[protective] umbrellas"). (Chinese Source)?, June7. www.360doc.com/content/08/0607/20/142_1315799.shtml.
101. Jian Yuan.(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source). 2003;7:22-25.
102. Gang Zeng.Jianji Zhao.(Chinese Source).(Chinese Source) 29. 2009;3 (Mar.): 357-362.
103. Qizheng Zhao(Chinese Source): (Chinese Source); 2007:.
104. Zhonggong zhongyang guanyu goujian shehui zhuyi hexie shehui ruogan wenti de jueding (Chinese Source) [Resolution of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party concerning certain questions in constructing a harmonious socialist society] (2006) (Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)16(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)(Chinese Source)? (The sixth plenary session of the 16th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China). http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2006-10/18/content_5218639.htm.
105. Zhonggong zhongyang guanyu jianli shehui zhuyi shichang jingji tizhi ruogan wenti de jueding (Chinese Source)[Resolution of the Chinese Communist Party Central Committee concerning certain questions in building a system of socialist market economy] (1993) (Chinese Source)14(Chinese Source)(The third plenary session of the 14th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China). http://finance.ifeng.com/opinion/jjsh/20090906/1199906.shtml.
106. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source) 2007:.
107. (Chinese Source): (Chinese Source); 2009:.
108. Zhonghua renmin gongheguo chengzhen guoyou tudi. (Chinese Source) ((Chinese Source)) [Interim regulations of the People's Republic of China concerning the assignment and transfer of the right to the use of the state-owned land in the urban areas] (1990) www.kuaiyilin.com/html/fanyiwenzhai/3039/.
109. Zhonghua renmin gongheguo guojia tongjiju (Chinese Source)[National Bureau of Statistics of China] (2010) 2009(Chinese Source)(Investigative report on the monitoring of the nongmingong in 2009). www.stats.gov.cn/tjfx/fxbg/t20100319_402628281.htm.
110. Zhonghua renmin gongheguo guotu ziyuan bu (Chinese Source)[Ministry of State Land Resources of the People's Republic of China] (2008) (Chinese Source) (Chinese Source) [2008] 138? (Methods for administering the testing of linking up increased land use for urban development with [decreased] rural (non-agricultural) land use). Issued by Ministry of Land Resources (2008) no. 138. www.mlr.gov.cn/xwdt/zytz/200903/t20090302_115435.htm.