Global clusters of innovation: The case of Israel and Silicon Valley

California Management Review

Volumn 53, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 27-49

  Engel, Jerome S ^a   Del Palacio, Itxaso ^a  

^a NONE

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 80054031358     PISSN: 00081256     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1525/cmr.2011.53.2.27     Document Type: Article

References (77)

1. J. Engel and I. del-Palacio, "Global Networks of Clusters of Innovation: Accelerating the Innovation Process", Business Horizons, 52/5(September 2009):493-503.
2. M. Granovetter, "The Strength of Weak Ties", American Journal of Sociology, 78/6(May 1973):1360-1380.
3. K. M. Eisenhart, "Building Theories for Case Study Research", Academy of Management Review, 14/4(October 1989):532-551.
4. Analyzed by A. Saxenian and C. Sabel, "The New Argonauts, Global Search, and Local Institution Building", Roepke Lecture in Economic Geography Venture Capital in the "Periphery", Economic Geography, 84/4(October 2008):379-394;
5. C. Lee and A. Saxenian, "Coevolution and Coordination: A Systemic Analysis of the Taiwanese Information Technology Industry", Journal of Economic Geography, 8/2(March 2008):157-180;
6. Y. R. Yang and C. J. Hsia, "Spatial Clustering and Organizational Dynamics of Transborder Production Networks: A Case Study of Taiwanese Information-Technology Companies in the Greater Suzhou Area, China", Environment and Planning A, 39/6(June 2007):1346-1363;
7. C. Yang, "Overseas Chinese Investments in Transition: The Case of Dongguan", Eurasian Geography and Economics, 47/5(February 2006):604-621; (Pubitemid 44613133)
8. A. Saxenian and C. Y. Li, "Bay-to-Bay Strategic Alliances: The Network Linkages between Taiwan and the U. S. Venture Capital Industries", International Journal of Technology Management, 25/1-2(2003):136-150; (Pubitemid 35381853)
9. J. Y. Hsu and A. Saxenian, "The Limits of Guanxi Capitalism: Transnational Collaboration between Taiwan and the USA", Environment and Planning A, 32/11(2000):1991-2005;
10. J. A. Mathews, "A Silicon Valley of the East: Creating Taiwan's Semiconductor Industry", California Management Review, 39/4(Summer 1997):26-53.
11. Analyzed by D. Breznitz, Innovation and the State: Political Choice and Strategies for Growth in Israel, Ireland, and Taiwan (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2007);
12. G. Avnimelech and M. Teubal, "Creating Venture Capital Industries that Co-Evolve with High Tech: Insights from an Extended Industry Life Cycle Perspective of Israel Experience", Research Policy, 35/10(December 2006):1477-1498. (Pubitemid 44792236)
13. Compared by T. F. Bresnahan and A. Gambardella, Building High-Tech Clusters: Silicon Valley and Beyond (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004);
14. T. Bresnahan, A. Gambardella, and A. Saxenian, "'Old Economy' Inputs for 'New Economy' Outcomes: Cluster Formation in the New Silicon Valleys", Industrial and Corporate Change, 10/4(December 2001):835-860. (Pubitemid 33146592)
15. See A. Saxenian, Regional Advantage: Culture and competition in Silicon Valley and Route128 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1994);
16. A. Saxenian, Silicon Valley's New Immigrant Entrepreneurs (San Francisco, CA: Public Policy Institute of California, 1999);
17. A. Saxenian, The New Argonauts: The Regional Advantage in a Global Economy (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2006).
18. S. B. Adams, "Stanford and Silicon Valley: Lessons on Becoming a High-Tech Region", California Management Review, 48/1(Fall 2005):29-51.
19. J. A. Mathews, "A Silicon Valley Island of the East: Creating a Semiconductor Industry in Singapore", California Management Review, 41/2(Winter 1999):55-78.
20. R. T. Abdel Jaber, "Silicon Wadi: Can Jordan Develop an Internationally Respected and Competitive Software Industry?" Jordan Times, April 8, 1999.
21. D. Dearlove, "Europe Needs Its Own Silicon Valley", Financial Times, September 27, 2001, p. 7.
22. J. A. Schofield, "Silicon Valley, Meet "Silicon Glen": Technology and Geography Combine to Make Scotland Europe's High-Tech Crossroad", Design News, March 27, 1995, pp. 65-69.
23. Definition of Porterian clusters by Porter. M. E. Porter, The Competitive Advantage of Nations (New York, NY: Free Press 1990);
24. M. Porter, "Clusters and the New Economics of Competition", Harvard Business Review, 76/6(November/December 1998):77-90;
25. M. Porter, "Location, Competition, and Economic Development: Local Cluster in Global Economy", Economic Development Quarterly, 14/1(February 2000a):15-34;
26. M. E. Porter, "Locations, Clusters, and Company Strategy", in G. L. Clark, M. P. Feldman, and M. S. Gertler, eds., The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography (New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2000b).
27. Analyzed by M. E. Porter, "Cluster of Innovation: Regional Foundations of U. S. Competitiveness", Council on Competitiveness, Washington, D. C., 2001.
28. J. Freeman and J. Engel, "Models of Innovation: Startups and Mature Corporations", California Management Review, 50/1(Fall 2007):94-119;
29. P. G Audia and C. Rider, "A Garage and an Idea: What More Does an Entrepreneur Need?" California Management Review, 48/1(Fall 2005):6-28;
30. A. Saxenian, "Regional Networks and the Resurgence of Silicon Valley", California Management Review, 33/1(Fall 1990):89-112;
31. J. H. Freeman, "Entrepreneurs as Organizational Products: Semiconductor Firms and Venture Capital Firms", Advances in the Study of Entrepreneurship, Innovation, and Economic Growth, 1(1986):33-52.
32. Freeman and Engel, op. cit.; H. W. Chesbrough, "Designing Corporate Venture in the Shadow of Venture Capital", California Management Review, 42/3(Spring 2005):31-49.
33. P. Maskell and L. Kebir, "What Qualifies as a Cluster Theory?" Druid Working Papers, No. 05-09, 2005.
34. B. M. Oviatt and P. P. McDougall, "Toward a Theory of International New Ventures", Journal of International Business Studies, 25/1(1994):45-64.
35. E. G. Carayannis and D. F. J. Campbell, "'Mode 3' and 'Quadruple Helix': Toward a 21st Century Fractal Innovation Ecosystem", International Journal of Technology Management, 46/3-4(2009):201-234.
36. M. Ferrary, "The Gift Exchange in the Social Networks of Silicon Valley", California Management Review, 45/4(Summer 2003):120-138
37. F. Toedtling and M. Trippl, "One Size Fits All? Towards a Differentiated Policy Approach with Respect to Regional Innovation Systems", Research Policy, 34/8(October 2005):1203-1219. (Pubitemid 41260492)
38. B. T. Asheim, L. Coenen, and M. Svensson-Henning, Nordic SMEs and Regional Innovation System, Nordic Innovation Center, Oslo, Norway, 2003;
39. P. Cooke, "The Evolution of Biotechnology in Three Continents: Schumpeterian or Penrosian?" European Planning Studies, 11/7(October 2003):789-804;
40. D. Wolfe, Clusters Old and New: The Transition to a Knowledge Economy in Canada's Regions (Kingston: Queen's School of Policy Studies, 2003);
41. A. Malmberg and P. Maskell, "The Elusive Concept of Localization Economies: Towards a Knowledge-Based Theory of Spatial Clustering", Environment and Planning A, 34/3(2002):429-449. (Pubitemid 34268274)
42. E.g., C. Chaminade and J. Vang, "Globalization of Knowledge Production and Regional Innovation Policy: Supporting Specialized Hubs in the Bangalore Software Industry", Research Policy, 37/10(December 2008):1684-1696;
43. P. Cooke, "Regionally Asymmetric Knowledge Capabilities and Open Innovation Exploring 'Globalization 2'-A New Model of Industry Organization", Research Policy, 34/8(October 2005):1128-1149. (Pubitemid 41260489)
44. There is much at stake here. Where public intervention has not been appropriately defined, results have been limited to relatively weak and local accomplishments. The German Bio-Regio Contest (BRC), for example, aimed to promote cooperative R&D projects among companies of biotechnology located in the same region. In spite of the positive reviews received by this initiative [e.g., D. Dohse, "Technology Policy and the Regions: The Case of the BioRegio Contest", Research Policy, 29(2000):1111-1133;
45. P. Cooke, Knowledge Economies: Clusters, Learning, and Cooperative Advantage (London: Routledge, 2002)], the BRC has been also widely criticized for consuming extraordinary amount of administrative and support resources
46. [A. Eickelpasch and M. Fritsch, "Contests for Cooperation-A New Approach in German Innovation Policy", Research Policy, 34/8(October 2005):1269-1282] and for not having solved fundamental information problems [Dohse (2000), op. cit.]. We believe this program failed to meet expectations of creating a globally connected COI because it did not sufficiently focus on promoting mobility of knowledge, capital, and people, and it did not create mechanisms for encouraging entrepreneurial business practices or aligning incentives and goals of individual participants. In addition, it neither encouraged nor contemplated the possibility of creating global collaborations. As in this case, when attempting transformative innovation processes, if the factors characterizing a COI are not promoted, opportunities for rapid innovation processes driven by entrepreneurship are overlooked, expenditures and efforts are likely to be wasted, partial policies may lead to little innovation and entrepreneurial development, and a global and sustainable competitive advantage is unlikely to be created. (Pubitemid 41260496)
47. H. W. Chesbrough, Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology (Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press, 2003a);
48. H. W. Chesbrough, "Open Platform Innovation: Creating Value from Internal and External Innovation", Intel Technology Journal, 7/3(August 2003b):5-9;
49. H. W. Chesbrough, "The Market for Innovation: Implications for Corporate Strategy", California Management Review, 49/3(Spring 2007):45-66.
50. P. Krugman, "Increasing Returns and Economic Geography", Journal of Political Economy, 99/3(June 1991):483-499;
51. M. Fujita, P. Krugman, and A. Venables, The Spatial Economy: Cities Regions and International Trade (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2000).
52. [S. A. Rosenfeld, "Backing into Clusters: Retrofitting Public Policies", Integration Pressures: Lessons from Around the World Conference Proceedings, John F. Kennedy School Symposium, Harvard University, 2001]. A COI can be big or small and can include one of more towns, cities, regions, and countries or a combination of them.
53. W. W. Powell, D. R. White, K. W. Koput, and J. Owen-Smith, "Network Dynamics and Field Evolution: The Growth of Inter-Organizational Collaborations on the Life Sciences", American Journal of Sociology, 110/4(January 2005):1132-1205. (Pubitemid 40912150)
54. P. P. McDougall, B. M. Oviatt, and R. C. Shrader, "A Comparison of International and Domestic New Ventures", Journal of International Entrepreneurship, 1/1(March 2003):59-82; Oviatt and McDougall (1994), op. cit. In previous literature, we can find examples of clusters that fit and do not fit this definition of a COI. A recent book
55. [see S. Casper, Creating Silicon Valley in Europe: Public Policy Towards New Technology Industries, (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2007)] that analyzes biotechnology clusters concludes that while San Francisco and San Diego have been able to support the creation of highly dynamic and profitable clusters of biotechnology companies, in Germany the results of the public policies have not been as fruitful as expected. The study found that the entrepreneurial activity in biotech clusters in Germany is not significant [Casper, p. 82]. In part, this is due to the long-term carrier employment system that takes scientists and engineers to spent most of their life within one firm [Casper, p. 96]. Despite the agglomeration of innovative start-ups and its rapid expansion, limited mobility of resources and low entrepreneurial activity makes this cluster an example of an agglomeration of high-technology companies that does not fit the definition of a COI.
56. P. J. Rentfrow, S. D. Gosling, and J. Potter, "A Theory of the Emergence, Persistence and Expression of Geographic Variation in Psychological Characteristics", Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3/5(2008):339-369.
57. R. Florida, The Rise of the Creative Class (New York, NY: Basic Books, 2002);
58. R. Florida, Who's Your City? (New York, NY: Basic Books, 2008).
59. H. Bathelt, A. Malmbert, and P. Maskell, "Clusters and Knowledge: Local Buzz, Global Pipelines and the Process of Knowledge Creation", Progress in Human Geography, 28/1(February 2004):31-56. (Pubitemid 38300582)
60. O. E. Williamson, "The Economics of Organization: The Transaction Costs Approach", The American Journal of Sociology, 87/3(1981):548-577;
61. O. E. Williamson, The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting (New York, NY: New York Press, 1985), available at .
62. D. Senor and S. Singer, Start-Up Nation: The Story of Israel's Economic Miracle (New York, NY: Twelve, 2009).
63. Central Bureau of Statistics, Statistical Abstract of Israel, 2006, available at .
64. D. Breznitz, "Innovation and the State: Development Strategies for High Technology Industries in a World of Fragmented Production: Israel, Ireland and Taiwan", Enterprise and Society, 7/4(2006):675-685. (Pubitemid 44862749)
65. C. C. de Fontenay and E. Carmel, "Israel's 'Silicon Wadi': The Sources of Its Comparative Advantage in the IT industry", in T. Bresnahan and A. Gambardella, eds., Building High-Tech Clusters: Silicon Valley and Beyond (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).
66. G. Weinreb, "Israel 6th in Europe for Biotech Cos-Report", Globes, Israel's Business Arena, 2007, .
67. B. Goldberg, Cultural Savvy web-based report (date not specified), .
68. J. Baal-Schem, "The Birth of a High-Tech Society: First Steps in Electronics and Computing in Israel", The International Conference on "Computer as a Tool", Warsaw, September 9-12, 2007.
69. G. Haour, "Israel, A Powerhouse for Networked Entrepreneurship" , International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation Management, 5/1-2(2005):39-68.
70. B. Honig, M. Lerner, and Y. Raban, "Social Capital and the Linkages of High-Tech Companies to the Military Defense System: Is there a Signaling Mechanism?" Small Business Economics, 27/4-5(December 2006):419-437 (Pubitemid 44771138)
71. R. Yaël and V. Karen, Israel: The New Silicon Valley, ESG Middle-East MBA, Faculty of Management, 2007; De Fontenay and Carmel, op. cit.
72. Webometrics, "Ranking of World Universities", 2009, .
73. G. Avnimelech, D. Schwartz, and R. Bar-El, "Entrepreneurial High-Tech Cluster Development: Israel's Experience with Venture Capital and Technological Incubators", European Planning Studies, 15/9(October 2007):1181-1198. (Pubitemid 47343390)
74. A. Wooldridge, "Global Heroes: a Special Report on Entrepreneurship", The Economist, March 14, 2009.
75. G. Autler, "The Globalization of High Tech: The Silicon Valley-Israel Connection", unpublished master's thesis, University of California, Berkeley, 2000; Saxenian (2001), op. cit.; De Fontenay and Carmel, op. cit.
76. Eyal Meshulam, Executive of Start-up companies at the Israel Export Institute, 2000.
77. Investment Promotion Service, Invest in Israel, 2009, .