A systematic review of cancer related patient outcomes after anterior resection and abdominoperineal excision for rectal cancer in the total mesorectal excision era

Surgical Oncology

Volumn 20, Issue 4, 2011, Pages

  How, P ^a   Shihab, O ^a   Tekkis, P ^b   Brown, Gina ^c   Quirke, P ^d   Heald, R ^a   Moran, B ^e  

^a PELICAN CANCER FOUNDATION   (United Kingdom)

^b ROYAL MARSDEN HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^c ROYAL MARSDEN HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

^d LEEDS GENERAL INFIRMARY   (United Kingdom)

^e NORTH HAMPSHIRE HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

abdominoperineal excision; Anterior resection; Circumferential resection margin; Perforation; Rectal cancer; Recurrence; Review; Survival

Indexed keywords

ABDOMINOPERINEAL EXCISION; ADVANCED CANCER; CANCER ADJUVANT THERAPY; CANCER PATIENT; CANCER RECURRENCE; CANCER SURGERY; CANCER SURVIVAL; CIRCUMFERENTIAL RESECTION MARGIN; DISEASE FREE SURVIVAL; HUMAN; INTERMETHOD COMPARISON; OVERALL SURVIVAL; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RECTUM ANTERIOR RESECTION; RECTUM CANCER; RECTUM SURGERY; REVIEW; SURGICAL APPROACH; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; TREATMENT OUTCOME; TUMOR DIFFERENTIATION; TUMOR PERFORATION;

ABDOMEN; DIGESTIVE SYSTEM SURGICAL PROCEDURES; HUMANS; PROGNOSIS; RECTAL NEOPLASMS; RECTUM; REVIEW LITERATURE AS TOPIC; SURVIVAL RATE;

EID: 80053634998     PISSN: 09607404     EISSN: 18793320     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.suronc.2011.05.001     Document Type: Review

References (40)

1. R.J. Heald, R.K. Smedh, A. Kald, R. Sexton, and B.J. Moran "Abdominoperineal excision of the rectum-an endangered operation. Norman Nigro Lectureship" Dis Colon Rectum 40 7 1997 747 751 (Pubitemid 27295041)
2. R.J. Heald, B.J. Moran, R.D. Ryall, R. Sexton, and J.K. MacFarlane Rectal cancer: the basingstoke experience of total mesorectal excision, 1978-1997 Arch Surg 133 8 1998 Aug 894 899 (Pubitemid 28374285)
3. P.P. Tekkis, A.G. Heriot, J. Smith, M.R. Thompson, P. Finan, and J.D. Stamatakis Association of coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland. Comparison of circumferential margin involvement between restorative and nonrestorative resections for rectal cancer Colorectal Dis 7 4 2005 Jul 369 374 (Pubitemid 40894866)
4. R. Marr, K. Birbeck, J. Garvican, C.P. Macklin, N.J. Tiffin, and W.J. Parsons The modern abdominoperineal excision: the next challenge after total mesorectal excision Ann Surg 242 1 2005 Jul 74 82 (Pubitemid 40917970)
5. I.D. Nagtegaal, C.J. van de Velde, C.A. Marijnen, J.H. van Krieken, and P. Quirke Dutch colorectal cancer group; pathology review committee. Low rectal cancer: a call for a change of approach in abdominoperineal resection J Clin Oncol 23 36 2005 Dec 20 9257 9264
6. A. Wibe, A. Syse, E. Andersen, S. Tretli, H.E. Myrvold, and O. Søreide Norwegian rectal cancer group. Oncological outcomes after total mesorectal excision for cure for cancer of the lower rectum: anterior vs. abdominoperineal resection Dis Colon Rectum 47 1 2004 Jan 48 58 (Pubitemid 38040245)
7. G. Salerno, I. Chandler, A. Wotherspoon, K. Thomas, B. Moran, and G. Brown Sites of surgical wasting in the abdominoperineal specimen Br J Surg 95 9 2008 Sep 1147 1154
8. E.W.L. Chuwa, and F. Seow-Choen Outcomes for abdominoperineal resections are not worse than those of anterior resections Dis Colon Rectum 49 2006 Jan 41 49 (Pubitemid 41830654)
9. O.C. Shihab, G. Brown, I.R. Daniels, R.J. Heald, P. Quirke, and B.J. Moran Patients with low rectal cancer treated by abdominoperineal excision have worse tumors and higher involved margin rates compared with patients treated by anterior resection Dis Colon Rectum 53 1 2010 Jan 53 56
10. A. Chiappa, R. Biffi, E. Bertani, A.P. Zbar, U. Pace, and C. Crotti Surgical outcomes after total mesorectal excision for rectal cancer J Surg Oncol 94 2006 182 193 (Pubitemid 44289982)
11. D.P. Taggart, R. D'Amico, and D.G. Altman Effect of arterial revascularization on survival: a systematic review of studies comparing bilateral and internal mammary arteries Lancet 358 2001 870 875 (Pubitemid 32900568)
12. Wells GA, Shea B, O'Connell D, Robertson J, Peterson J, Welch V, et al. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for assessing the quality of non-randomized studies in meta-analyses. Paper presented at 3rd symposium on systematic reviews: beyond the basics, Oxford, 2000.
13. W. Chambers, and L. Hancock Changes in the management and outcome of rectal cancer over a ten year period in oxford Colorectal Dis 2010 Jul 1
14. M. Den Dulk, L. Collette, C.J. van de Velde, C.A. Marijnen, G. Calais, and L. Mineur Quality of surgery in T3-4 rectal cancer: involvement of circumferential resection margin not influenced by preoperative treatment. Results from EORTC trial 22921 Eur J Cancer 43 2007 1821 1828 (Pubitemid 47241247)
15. E. García-Granero, R. Martí-Obiol, J. Gómez- Barbadillo, J. García-Armengol, P. Esclapez, and A. Espí Impact of surgeon organization and specialization in rectal cancer outcome Colorectal Dis 3 3 2001 May 179 184 (Pubitemid 32782807)
16. W. Hohenberger, S. Merkel, K. Matzel, B. Bittorf, T. Papadopoulos, and J. Göhl The influence of abdomino-peranal (intersphincteric) resection of lower third rectal carcinoma on the rates of sphincter preservation and locoregional recurrence Colorectal Dis 8 1 2006 Jan 23 33 (Pubitemid 43372255)
17. M. Konn, T. Morita, R. Hada, Y. Yamanaka, M. Sasaki, and H. Munakata Survival and recurrence after low anterior resection and abdominoperineal resection for rectal cancer: the results of a long-term study with a review of the literature Surg Today 23 1 1993 21 30 (Pubitemid 23011277)
18. W.L. Law, and K.W. Chu Abdominoperineal resection is associated with poor oncological outcome Br J Surg 91 11 2004 Nov 1493 1499 (Pubitemid 39518088)
19. T. Nakagoe, H. Ishikawa, T. Sawai, T. Tsuji, K. Tanaka, and S. Hidaka Survival and recurrence after a sphincter-saving resection and abdominoperineal resection for adenocarcinoma of the rectum at or below the peritoneal reflection: a multivariate analysis Surg Today 34 2004 32 39 (Pubitemid 38067891)
20. T. Nymann, P. Jess, and J. Christiansen Rate and treatment of pelvic recurrence after abdominoperineal resection and low anterior resection for rectal cancer Dis Colon Rectum 38 1995 799 802
21. A.C. Okaro, T. Worthington, J.F. Stebbing, M. Broughton, S. Caffarey, and C.G. Marks Curative resection for low rectal adenocarcinoma: abdomino-perineal vs anterior resection Colorectal Dis 8 8 2006 Oct 645 649 (Pubitemid 44363586)
22. A. Ross, C. Rusnak, B. Weinerman, P. Kuechler, A. Hayashi, and G. MacLachlan Recurrence and survival after surgical management of rectal cancer Am J Surg 177 May 1999 392 395 (Pubitemid 29252808)
23. E. Rullier, C. Laurent, J. Carles, J. Saric, P. Michel, and M. Parneix Local recurrence of low rectal cancer after abdominoperineal and anterior resection Br J Surg 84 4 1997 Apr 525 528 (Pubitemid 27196297)
24. J. Tschmelitsch, P. Kronberger, R. Prommegger, G. Reibenegger, K. Glaser, and E. Bodner Survival and local recurrence after anterior resection and abdominoperineal excision for rectal cancer Eur J Surg Oncol 21 6 1995 Dec 640 643 (Pubitemid 26042314)
25. M.R. Weiser, H.M. Quah, J. Shia, J.G. Guillem, P.B. Paty, and L.K. Temple Sphincter preservation in low rectal cancer is facilitated by preoperative chemoradiation and intersphincteric dissection Ann Surg 249 2 2009 Feb 236 242
26. H. Youssef, E.C. Collantes, S.H. Rashid, L.S. Wong, and P. Baragwanath Rectal cancer: involved circumferential resection margin - a root cause analysis Colorectal Dis 11 5 2009 Jun 470 474 [Epub 2008 Jul 15]
27. F.A. Bonadeo, C.A. Vaccaro, M. Benati, G. Ojea Quintana, X. Garione, and M. Telenta Rectal cancer: local recurrence after surgery without radiotherapy Dis Colon Rectum 44 3 2001 374 379 (Pubitemid 32226326)
28. H.S. Tilney, P.P. Tekkis, P. Sains, V. Constantinides, and A. Heriot "Factors affecting circumferential resection margin involvement after rectal cancer excision" Dis Colon Rectum 50 1 2007 29 36
29. H. Ptok, F. Marusch, R. Kuhn, I. Gastinger, and H. Lippert Influence of hospital volume on the frequency of abdominoperineal resection and long-term oncological outcomes in low rectal cancer Eur J Surg Oncol 33 7 2007 854 861 (Pubitemid 47287387)
30. N. Saito, M. Sugito, M. Ito, A. Kobayashi, Y. Nishizawa, and Y. Yoneyama Oncologic outcome of intersphincteric resection for very low rectal cancer World J Surg 33 8 2009 1750 1756
31. E. Morris, P. Quirke, J.D. Thomas, L. Fairley, B. Cottier, and D. Forman Unacceptable variation in abdominoperineal excision rates for rectal cancer: time to intervene? Gut 57 12 2008 Dec 1690 1697 [Epub 2008 Jun 5]
32. H.S. Tilney, and P.P. Tekkis A national perspective on the decline of abdominoperineal resection for rectal cancer Ann Surg 247 1 2008 Jan 77 84
33. J.J. Bannister, L. Abouzekry, and N.W. Read Effect of aging on anorectal function Gut 28 3 1987 Mar 353 357 (Pubitemid 17039059)
34. K. Yamada, S. Ogata, Y. Saiki, M. Fukunaga, Y. Tsuji, and M. Takano Long-term results of intersphincteric resection for low rectal cancer Dis Colon Rectum 52 6 2009 Jun 1065 1071
35. A.Y. Lin, W.D. Wong, J. Shia, B.D. Minsky, L.K. Temple, and J.G. Guillem Predictive clinicopathologic factors for limited response of T3 rectal cancer to combined modality therapy Int J Colorectal Dis 23 3 2008 Mar 243 249 [Epub 2007 Nov 29]
36. H. Zirngibl, B. Husemann, and P. Hermanek Intraoperative spillage of tumor cells in surgery for rectal cancer Dis Colon Rectum 33 7 1990 Jul 610 614 (Pubitemid 20211455)
37. M.T. Eriksen, A. Wibe, A. Syse, J. Haffner, and J.N. Wiig Norwegian rectal cancer group; Norwegian gastrointestinal cancer group. Inadvertent perforation during rectal cancer resection in Norway Br J Surg 91 2 2004 Feb 210 216
38. P. Quirke, P. Durdey, M.F. Dixon, and N.S. Williams Local recurrence of rectal adenocarcinoma due to inadequate surgical resection. Histopathological study of lateral tumour spread and surgical excision Lancet 2 8514 1986 Nov 1 996 999 (Pubitemid 16005611)
39. N.P. West, P.J. Finan, C. Anderin, J. Lindholm, T. Holm, and P. Quirke "Evidence of the oncologic superiority of cylindrical abdominoperineal excision for low rectal cancer" J Clin Oncol 26 21 2008 3517 3522
40. O.C. Shihab, B.J. Moran, I.R. Daniels, R.J. Heald, P. Quirke, and B.J. Moran "MRI staging of low rectal cancer" Eur Radiol 19 3 2009 643 650