Reflexive Governance in biobanking: On the value of policy led approaches and the need to recognise the limits of law

Human Genetics

Volumn 130, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 347-356

  Laurie, Graeme ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BIOBANK; HEALTH CARE FACILITY; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MEDICAL PRACTICE; MEDICAL RESEARCH; PRIORITY JOURNAL; ETHICS; LEGAL ASPECT; MANAGEMENT; PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE; QUALITY CONTROL; SOCIAL BEHAVIOR; SOCIAL CONTROL; UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

BIOLOGICAL SPECIMEN BANKS; GREAT BRITAIN; POLICY MAKING; PROFESSIONAL AUTONOMY; QUALITY CONTROL; SOCIAL CONTROL POLICIES; SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY; UNITED STATES;

EID: 80053306411     PISSN: 03406717     EISSN: 14321203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00439-011-1066-x     Document Type: Article

References (48)

1. Academy of Medical Sciences (2011) A new pathway for regulation and governance of health research. http://www.acmedsci.ac.uk/p99puid209.html
2. Andrews L (2001) A conceptual framework for genetic policy: comparing the medical, public health and fundamental rights models. Wash Univ Law Q 79:221-285
3. Ashcroft RE (2003) The ethics and governance of medical research: what does regulation have to do with morality? New Rev Bioethics 1(1):41-58
4. UK Biobank (2011) www.ukbiobank.ac.uk. Accessed 25 Apr 2011
5. Biobanking and Biomolecular Resources Research Infrastructure (BBMRI). www.bbmri.eu. Last visited 25 April 2011
6. Collingridge D (1982) The social control of technology. St Martin's Press, London
7. Cutter AM, Wilson S, Chadwick R (2004) Balancing powers: examining models of biobank governance. J Intern Biotech Law 1(5):187-192
8. Fullerton SM, Anderson NR, Guzauskas G, Freeman D, Fryer-Edwards K (2010) Meeting the governance challenges of nextgeneration biorepository research. Sci Transl Med 2:15cm3
9. Gertz R (2004) An analysis of the Icelandic Supreme Court judgement on the Health Sector Database Act. SCRIPTed 1(2):241-258
10. Gibbons SMC (2007) Are UK genetic databases governed adequately? Leg Stud 27(2):312-342
11. Gottweis H, Lauss G (2010) Biobank governance in the post-genomic age. Pers Med 7(2):187-195
12. Gottweis H, Zatioukal K (2007) Biobank governance: trends and perspectives. Pathobiology 74(4):206-211 (Pubitemid 47294501)
13. Guston DH (2008) Innovation policy: not just jumbo shrimp. Nature 454:940-941
14. Haddow G, Cunningham-Burley S, Murray L (2011) Can the governance of a population genetic data bank effect recruitment? Evidence from the public consultation of Generation Scotland. Public Underst Sci 20(1):117-129
15. Häyry M, Takala T (2007) Bioethical analysis of the results: how well do laws and regulations address people's concerns? In: Häyry M, Chadwick R, Árnason V, Árnason G (eds) The ethics and governance of human genetic databases, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 249-256, at 252
16. Hendriks CM, Grin J (2007) Enacting reflexive governance: the politics of Dutch transitions to sustainability. J Environ Policy Plan 9(4):333-350
17. Holm S (2009) Me, myself, I-against narcissism in the governance of genetic information. In: Widdows H, Mullen C (eds) The governance of genetic information: who decides?. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 37-50
18. House of Lords Science and Technology Committee (2009) Genomic Medicine. Second Report of Session 2008-2009, para 6.15
19. Hunter KG, Laurie G (2009) Involving publics in biobank governance: moving beyond existing approaches. In: Widdows H, Mullen C (eds) The governance of genetic information: who decides?. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 151-177
20. Jones D, MacKellar C (2009) Consent for biobank tissue in somaticcell nuclear transfer. Lancet 374(9693):861-863
21. Karinen R, Guston DH (2010) Towards anticipatory governance: the experience of nanotechnology. Sociol Sci Yearb 27(4):217-232. doi:10.1007/978-90-481-2835-1-12
22. Kaye J (2006) Do we need a uniform regulatory system for biobanks across Europe? Euro J Hum Genet 14:245-248. doi:10.1038/sj.ejhg.5201530 (Pubitemid 43135869)
23. Knoppers BM (2009a) Genomics and policymaking: from static models to complex systems? Hum Genet 125:375-379
24. Knoppers BM (2009b) Challenges to ethics review in health research. Health Law Rev 17(2-3):47-52
25. Laurie G (2009) The role of the UK Biobank Ethics and Governance Council. Lancet 374(9702):1676
26. Laurie G, Bruce A, Lyall C (2009) The role of values and interests in the governance of the life sciences: learning lessons from the "Ethics?" approach of UK Biobank. In: Lyall C, Papaioannou T, Smith J (eds) The limits to governance: the challenges of policymaking for the new life sciences. Ashgate, Farnham, pp 51-77
27. Laurie G et al (2010) Managing access to biobanks: how can we reconcile individual privacy and public interests in genetic research? Med Law Int 10(4):315-337
28. Lenoble J, Maesschalck M (2010) Renewing the theory of public interest: the quest for a reflexive and learning-based approach to governance. In: de Schutter O, Lenoble J (eds) Reflexive governance: redefining the public interest in a pluralistic world. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 3-21
29. Lowrance WW, Collins FS (2007) Identifiability in genomic research. Science 317:600-602 (Pubitemid 47240914)
30. Meslin EM (2010) The value of using top-down and bottom-up approaches for building trust and transparency in biobanking. Public Health Genomics 13(4):207-214
31. Mitchell R et al (2011) Genomics, biobanks, and the trade-secret model. Science 332(6027):309-310
32. O'Doherty KC, Hawkins A (2010) Structuring public engagement for effective input in policy development on human tissue biobanking. Public Health Genomics 13:197-206
33. Otlowski M (2009) Developing an appropriate consent model for biobanks: in defence of 'broad' consent. In: Kaye J, Stranger M (eds) Principles and practice in biobank governance. Ashgate, Farnham, pp 79-92
34. Public Population Project in Genomics (P3G) (2011) www.p3g.org. Last visited 25 April 2011
35. Ruyter KW et al (2010) From research exemption to research norm: recognizing an alternative to consent for large scale biobank research. Med Law Int 10(4):287-313
36. Schön D (1994) The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action. Ashgate, Farnham
37. Schröder C, Heidtke KR, Zacherl N, Zatloukal K, Taupitz J (2010) Safeguarding donors' personal rights and biobank autonomy in biobank networks: the CRIP privacy regime. Cell Tissue Bank. doi:10.1007/s10561-010-9190-8
38. Shickle D, Griffin M, El-Arifi K (2010) Inter- and intra-biobank networks: classification of biobanks. Pathobiology 77(4):181-190
39. Stranger M, Bell E, Nicol D, Otlowski M, Chalmers D (2008) Human genetic databases in Australia: indications of inconsistency and confusion. New Genet Soc 27(4):311-321
40. Sutrop M (2007) Trust. In: Häyry M, Chadwick R, Árnason V, Árnason G (eds) The ethics and governance of human genetic databases. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 190-198
41. Taylor MJ, Townend D (2010) Issues in protecting privacy in medical research using genetic information and biobanking: the PRIVILEGED project. Med Law Int 10(4):253-268
42. Vincent-Jones P, Mullen C (2010) From collaborative to genetic governance: the example of healthcare services in England. In: de Schutter O, Lenoble J (eds) Reflexive governance: redefining the public interest in a pluralistic world. Hart Publishing, Oxford, pp 147-178
43. Wallace S, Bédard K, Kent A, Knoppers BM (2008) Governance mechanisms and population biobanks: building a framework for trust. GenEdit 6:1-11. http://www.humgen.umontreal.ca/int/GE/en/2008-2.pdf
44. Williams R (2006) Compressed foresight and narrative bias: pitfalls in assessing high technology futures. Sci Cult 15(4):327-348
45. Winickoff D (2007) Partnership in UK Biobank: a third way for genomic property? Journal of Law. Med Ethics 35(3):440-456
46. Winickoff D (2009) From benefit sharing to power sharing: partnership governance in population genomics research. In: Kaye J, Stranger M (eds) Principles and practice in biobank governance. Ashgate, Franham, pp 53-66
47. Wynne B (1992) Uncertainty and environmental learning: reconceiving science and policy in the preventive paradigm. Glob Environ Change 2(2):111-127
48. Yarborough M, Fryer-Edwards K, Geller G, Sharp RR (2009) Transforming the culture of biomedical research from compliance to trustworthiness: insights from nonmedical sectors. Acad Med 84(4):472-477