A review of nursing workforce policies in five European countries: Denmark, Finland, Ireland, Portugal and United Kingdom/England

Journal of Nursing Management

Volumn 19, Issue 6, 2011, Pages 786-802

  Attree, Moira ^a   Flinkman, Mervi ^b   Howley, Breeda ^c   Lakanmaa, Riitta Liisa ^b   Lima Basto, Marta ^d   Uhrenfeldt, Lisbeth ^e  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TURKU   (Finland)

^c UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN   (Ireland)

^d UNIVERSITY OF LISBON   (Portugal)

^e HORSENS REGIONAL HOSPITAL   (Denmark)

Author keywords

International; Nursing workforce; Policy review

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DENMARK; FINLAND; HUMAN; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; IRELAND; NURSE; NURSING; POLICY; PORTUGAL; UNITED KINGDOM;

DENMARK; ENGLAND; FINLAND; GREAT BRITAIN; HUMANS; INTERNATIONALITY; IRELAND; NURSES; NURSING; POLICY; PORTUGAL;

EID: 80052543315     PISSN: 09660429     EISSN: 1365263X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2834.2011.01214.x     Document Type: Article

References (123)

1. Administração Central do Sistema de Saúde (ACSS). (2007) Relatório Anual do ano 2006 ACSS Annual Report 2006. Accessed Dec 26 2007.
2. Agostinho L.M. (2007) Liderança em reflexão. Nursing (Portuguese edition), 17 (220), 14-16.
3. Aiken L.H., Clarke S., Sloane J.A., Sochalski R. & Silber J.H. (2002) Hospital nurse staffing and patient mortality, nurse burnout and job satisfaction. Journal of the American Medical Association 288 (16), 1987-1993.
4. Aiken L.H., Buchan J., Sochalski J., Nochols B. & Posell M. (2004) Trends in International nurse migration. Health Affairs 22 (3), 69-77.
5. Albaugh J.A. (2003) Keeping nurses in nursing: the professions' challenge for today. Urologic Nursing 23 (3), 193-199.
6. Almeida H. (2004) A exceleência do exercício - a perspectiva do Conselho de Enfermagem. Ordem dos Enfermeiros 15 Dec, 35-38.
7. An Bord Altranais. (2008) Available at: ). accessed 9 March 2008.
8. Appelqvist-Schmidlechner K. & Nikkola E. (2006) Back to working life from dugout. Sairaanhoitaja 79 (1), 23-25.
9. Auerbach D.I., Buerhaus P.I. & Staiger D.O. (2007) Better late than never: workforce supply implications of later entry into nursing. Health Affairs 26 (1), 178-185.
10. Baumann A. & Blythe J. (2003) Restructuring, reconsidering reconstructing: implications for health human resources. International Journal of Public Administration 26 (14), 1561-1579.
11. Baumann A., Yan J., Degelder J. & Malikov K. (2006) Retention Strategies for Nursing: A Profile of Four Countries. Human Health Resource. Series Number 5, Nursing Health Service Research Unit, ON, Canada.
12. Black L., Spetz J. & Harrington C. (2008) Nurses working outside of nursing; societal trend or workplace crisis? Policy, Politics, & Nursing Practice 9 (3), 143-157.
13. Buchan J. (2002) Global nursing shortages. Are often a symptom of wider health system or societal ailments. British Medical Journal 30, 751-752.
14. Buchan J. & Seccombe I. (2003) More Nurses Working Differently. A Review of the UK Nursing Labour Market. Royal College of Nursing, London.
15. Buchan J. & Sochalski J. (2004) The migration of nurses: trends and policies. Bulletin World Health Organisation 82, 587-594.
16. Burgoyne J.G. & Turnbull-James K. (2006) Towards best or better practice in corporate leadership development: issues in Mode 2 and design science research. British Journal of Management 17 (4), 303-316.
17. Danish Nurses Council. (2009) Available at:, accessed 12 February 2010.
18. Danish Nurses Council (DSR). (2008) Available at:, accessed 7 August 2009.
19. DePalma J. (2002) Proposing an evidence-based policy process. Nursing Administration Quarterly 26 (4), 55-61.
20. DoH. (1999a) Making a Difference: Strengthening the Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting Contribution to Health and Healthcare. Stationary Office, London.
21. DoH. (1999b) Improving Working Lives in the NHS. Stationary Office, London.
22. DoH. (2000a) The NHS Plan: A Plan for Improvement and Reform for NHS Staff. Stationary Office, London.
23. DoH. (2000b) A Health Service of all the Talents; Developing the NHS Workforce. Stationary Office, London.
24. DoH. (2000c) Agenda for Change. Stationary Office, London.
25. DoH. (2001) Investment and Reform for NHS Staff - Taking Forward the NHS Plan. Stationary Office, London.
26. DoH. (2002a) Delivering the NHS Plan: Next Steps on Investment, Next Steps on Reform. Stationary Office, London.
27. DoH. (2002b) HR in the NHS Plan. Stationary Office, London.
28. DoH. (2004) Agenda for Change: Final Agreement. DoH, London.
29. DoH. (2006a) Modernising Nursing Careers: Setting the Direction. HMSO, London.
30. DoH. (2006b) Sharing good practice in temporary staffing [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 7 September 2007.
31. DoH. (2007) NHS Foundation Trusts [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 21 January 2008.
32. Doran D. (2003) Nurse Sensitive Outcomes: State of the Science, Jones & Bartlett, Boston, MA.
33. Faulkner J. & Laschinger H. (2008) The effect of structural and psychological empowerment on perceived respect in acute care nurses. Journal of Nursing Management 16, 214-221.
34. Fittall B. (2004) Can we measure how changes in the nursing workforce affect patient care? Journal of Nursing Management 12, 397-402.
35. Gândara M. (2004) Valores universais da prática de enfermagem - comentário às comunicações proferidas. Ordem dos Enfermeiros 15, 24-25.
36. Gaspar M.F. (2005) Cidania organizacional nas organizações de saúde: o caso da enfermagem. Tese de doutoramento em Psicologia Social e Organizacional, Instituto Superior de Ciências do Trabalho e da Empresa.
37. Government of Ireland. (2001) Quality and Fairness: A Health System for You. Stationary Office, Dublin.
38. Government of Ireland. (2002a) The Nursing and Midwifery Resource: Towards Workforce Planning. Stationary Office, Dublin.
39. Government of Ireland. (2002b) Guidance for Best Practice on the Recruitment of Overseas Nurses and Midwives. Stationary Office, Dublin.
40. Government of Ireland. (2002c) Action Plan for People Management. Stationary Office, Dublin.
41. Graneheim U.H. & Lundman B. (2004) Qualitative content analysis in nursing research: concepts, procedures and measures to achieve trustworthiness. Nurse Education Today 24, 105-112.
42. Grönvall U. (2004) Terveysfoorumi 2004, Terveydenhuolto muutoksessa - riittääkö työvoima? Sairaanhoitaja 77 (11), 5-6.
43. Haarala S. & Kiviniemi L. (2007) Development of psychiatric nurses' work in primary health care. [English abstract]. Sairaanhoitaja 80 (9), 13-15.
44. Hasselhorn H.M., Tackenberg P. & Muller B.H. (2003) Working Conditions and Intention to Leaving the Profession among Nursing Staff in Europe. Nurses Early Exit Study, Report 7:2003.
45. Hasselhorn H.-M.P., Muller B.H., Tackenberg P. (2005) NEXT Scientific Report. University of Wuppertal. Wuppertal, Germany. pp. 17-24. Available at: accessed 8 February 2011.
46. Hewison A. (2007) Policy analysis: a framework for nurse managers. Journal of Nursing Management 15, 693-699.
47. Hill M. & Hupe P. (2008) Implementing Public Policy: An Introduction to the study of Organisational Governance, 2nd edn. Sage, London.
48. Houtsonen J. & Wärvik G. (eds) (2009) European Nurses' Life and Work Under Restructuring. Sense Publisher, Rotterdam.
49. Imison C., Buchan J. & Xavier S. (2009) NHS Workforce Planning: Limitations and Possibilities [WWW document]. King's Fund, London. Available at:, accessed 6 January 2010.
50. International Council of Nurses (ICN). (2004) The global shortage of registered nurses: an overview of issues and actions [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 2 January 2008.
51. International Council of Nurses (ICN). (2006) The global nursing shortage: Priority areas for intervention [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 4 October 2008.
52. Irwin J. (2001) Migration patterns of nurses in the EU. Eurohealth 7 (4), 13-15.
53. Kane R.L., Shamliyan T., Mueller C., Duval S. & Wilt T. (2007) Nursing Staffing and Quality of Patient Care. Evidence Report/Technology Assessment No. 151 (Prepared by the Minnesota Evidence-based Practice Center under Contract No. 290-02-0009.) AHRQ Publication No. 07-E005.
54. Kanste O. (2005) Aktiivinen johtajuus suojaa hoitohenkilöstöä työuupumukselta. Sairaanhoitaja 78 (8), 14-15.
55. Kramer M. (1990) The Magnet hospitals. Excellence revisited. Journal of Nursing Administration 20 (9), 35-44.
56. Kramer M. & Schmalenberg C. (2003) Magnet hospital staff nurses describe clinical autonomy. Nursing Outlook 51 (1), 13-19.
57. Laschinger H.K., Finegan J. & Sharmian J. (2001) The impact of workplace empowerment and organizational trust on staff nurses' work satisfaction and organizational commitment. Health Care Management Review 26 (3), 7-23.
58. Leiwo L. & Heikkilä J. (2003) Qualitative regional prognostication reveals competence and learning needs. [English abstract]. Sairaanhoitaja 76 (11), 8-9.
59. Liimatainen A. & Ikävalko K. (2007) Expert nurse education in South Karelia. [English abstract]. Sairaanhoitaja 80 (11), 42-43.
60. Long A.F. & Mercer G. (1987) Health Manpower: Planning, Production and Management. Croom Helm, Beckenham.
61. Lopes M.J. (2005) Os utentes e os enfermeiros: construção de uma relação. Tese de doutoramento em Ciências de Enfermagem, ICBAS, Universidade do Porto.
62. Maltha N. (2007) Dasys formandsberetning [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 23 September 2009.
63. McCarthy G., Tyrrell M. & Cronin C. (2002) National Study of Turnover in Nursing and Midwifery. Department of Health and Children, Dublin.
64. McConnell C.R. (2003) The managers' approach for employee performance problems. Health Care Manager 22 (1), 63-69.
65. Ministerio da Saúde. (2004) Plano Nacional de saúde: orientações estratégicas para 2004-2010. Ministério da Saúde, Lisboa. Portugal.
66. Ministry of Employment and the Economy. (2008a) Rekrytointiongelmat sekä työvoiman kysyntä ja tarjonta työvoimatoimistoissa [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 29 August 2008.
67. Ministry of Employment and the Economy. (2008b) Työ- ja elinkeinoministeriön lyhyen aikavälin talous- ja työmarkkinaennuste [WWW document]. [English abstract] Available at:, accessed 29 August 2008.
68. Ministry of Social Affairs and Health. (2002) Decision in principle by the council of state on securing the future of health care [WWW document] [English]. Available at:, accessed 26 August 2008.
69. Ministry of Social Affairs and Health.(2003) Target and Action Plan for Social Welfare and Health Care 2004-2007. Publication of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health, Finland. 2003:20. Available at:, accessed 14 February 2011.
70. Ministry of Social Affairs and Health. (2006) Report by the Monitoring Group for the National Health Care Project on Actions in 2005 to the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health [WWW document]. [English abstract]. Available at:, accessed 26 August 2008.
71. Mrayyan M.T. & Al-Faouri I. (2008) Predictors of career commitment and job performance of Jordanian nurses. Journal of Nursing Management 16, 246-256.
72. Muir Gray J.A. (2001) Evidence-Based Health Care: How to Make Health Policy and Management Decisions. Churchill Livingstone, London.
73. Mullen C. (2003a) A force for good. Health Service Journal 113, 34-35.
74. Mullen C. (2003b) Commentary: an English perspective. Journal of Advanced Nursing 43 (4), 345-348.
75. National Audit Office (NAO). (2004) Annual report [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 20 December 2007.
76. National Council for Professional Development of Nursing and Midwifery. (2003) Agenda for the Future Professional Development of Nursing and Midwifery. National Council, Dublin.
77. Needleman J., Buerhaus P., Mattke S., Stewart M. & Zelevinsky K. (2002) Nurse-staffing levels and the quality of care in hospitals. New England Journal of Medicine 346 (22), 1715-1722.
78. NHS Confederation. (2006) NHS Confederation Annual Report 2005/6 [WWW document]. Available at: accessed 14 October 2007.
79. Niessen L.W., Gijssels E.W. & Rutten F.F. (2000) The evidence-based approach in health policy and health interventions delivery. Social Science & Medicine 51 (6), 859-869.
80. Nursing and Midwifery Council. (2006) Statistical Analysis of the Register 2005-6. NMC, London.
81. Nursing and Midwifery Council. (2008) Statistical Analysis of the Register 2006-7. NMC, London.
82. O'Brien-Pallas L., Duffield C. & Hayes L. (2006) Do we really understand how to retain nurses? Journal of Nursing Management 14, 262-270.
83. Office of Manpower Economics. (2003) Workforce Survey results for nursing staff, midwives and health visitors [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 3 April 2007.
84. Office of National Statistics. (2006) Public sector employment, quarter 4 [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 14 October 2008.
85. OECD, Registrar. (2009) Available at: Accessed 6 September 2009.
86. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2009) Health at a Glance: OECD Indicators. Paris, France. Accessed at: accessed 31 December 2009.
87. Oxford Centre for Evidence based Medicine (OCEBM). (2001) Levels of evidence and grades of recommendations. Available at:, accessed 14th March 2008.
88. Pawson R. & Tilley N. (1997) Realistic Evaluation. Sage, London.
89. Pearson A. (2007) Reform without analysis or foresight: the malady of modern health care. International Journal of Nursing Practice 13 (1), 1-2.
90. Pedersen K.M. (2008) Manglen på arbejdskraft i sundhedsvæsenet og hvordan man kan tiltrække og fastholde kvalificeret arbejdskraft. Health Economic Papers 2008:2 [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 1 September 2009.
91. Prime Minister's Office. (2007) The programme of Prime Minister Matti Vanhanen's second cabinet, 19 April 2007 [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 2 January 2008.
92. PubMed. (2008) MeSH database [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 26 August 2008.
93. Rafferty A.M., Clarke S., Coles J. et al. (2007) Outcomes of variations in hospital nurse staffing: cross sectional analysis of survey data and discharge records. International Journal of Nursing Studies 44 (2), 175-182.
94. Royal College of Nursing (RCN). (2007) Future nurse future workforce [WWW]. Available at:, accessed 27 July 2009.
95. Santamäki K. (2004) Sairaanhoitajatyöttömyys ja ammattikunnan lohkoutuminen. In Hyvinvointityön ammatit (L. Henriksson & S. Wrede eds), pp. 144-167. Yliopistopaino, Helsinki.
96. Savikko N., Hautala L., Kiviniemi K., Puukka P., Leino-Kilpi H. & Suominen T. (2004) Työn sisäinen hallinta kotisairaanhoidossa ja terveuskeskusten pitkäaikaisosastoilla hoitajien kokemana. Tutkiva Hoitotyö 2, 17-23.
97. Shields M.A. & Ward M. (2001) Improving nurse retention in the national health system in England: the impact of job satisfaction on intention to quit. Journal of Health Economics 20, 677-701.
98. Simoens S., Villeneuve M. & Hurst J. (2005) Tackling Nurse Shortages in OECD Countries. OECD Health Working Papers NO. 19 (WWW document). Available at:, accessed 2 January 2008.
99. Sinais Vitais. (2005) Falando sobre Enfermagem com Ana Pereira Campos. Sinais Vitais 62, 5-9.
100. Snellman K. (2006) Työvoimapula terveydenhuoltoalalla. Talous ja Yhteiskunta 4/2006, 34-39. Available at:, accessed 15 February 2011.
101. Sørensen E.E. (2006). Sygeplejefaglig ledelse (nursing leadership). Aarhus Universitet, Det Sundhedsvidenskabelige Fakultet, Aarhus Universitet. PhD. Afhandling.
102. Sousa M.A. (2007) Um novo modelo de desenvolvimento professional - certificação de competencies e Individualização de especialidades em Enfermagem. Ordem dos Enfermeiros 26, 1-23.
103. Spilsbury K. & Meyer J. (2001) Defining the nursing contribution to patient outcome: lessons from a review of the literature examining nursing outcomes, skill mix and changing roles. Journal of Clinical Nursing 10 (1), 3-14.
104. Summerskill W. & Valori R.M. (2005). Key Topics in Evidence-Based Medicine. Taylor & Francis, New York, NY.
105. The Danish Healthcare Quality Programme (DDKM) (2007). Available at:, accessed 8 February 2011.
106. Tehy tilastoina (2009) Tehyn tutkimusryhmä, Markkanen M. (toim). Tehyn julkaisusarja D, Tilastoja ja kartoituksia 1/09.
107. Timonen L. & Eriksson E. (2007) Nurses continuing professional education in surgical units of a university hospital [English abstract]. Tutkiva Hoitotyö 5 (4), 21-28.
108. Tourangeau A.E. & Cranley L.A. (2006) Nurses intention to remain employed: understanding and strengthening determinants. Journal of Advanced Nursing 55, 497-509.
109. Tuominen H., Kankkunen P. & Suominen T. (2006) Performance appraisal in supporting professional development - experiences of nurses. [English abstract]. Tutkiva Hoitotyö 4 (1), 16-22.
110. Tussing D. & Wren M.A. (2006) How Ireland Cares: The Case for Healthcare Reform. New Island, Dublin.
111. Uhrenfeldt L. & Hall E.O.C. (2007) Clinical wisdom among proficient nurses. Nursing Ethics 14, 387-398.
112. Uhrenfeldt L. & Hall E.O.C. (2009) Caring for nursing staff among proficient first-line nurse leaders. International Journal for Human Caring 13 (2), 39-44.
113. Vaalgamaa K. & Ohtonen J. (2002) Terveydenhuollon ammattihenkilöt 31.12.2001. Tilastoraportti 5/2002, Stakes.
114. Vahla L. (2003) Rakentamassa parempaa työelämää ja jaksavaa työvoimaa. Sairaanhoitaja 76 (11), 6-7.
115. Vallimies-Patomäki M., Perälä M. & Lindström E. (2003) Success of nurses enhanced roles - systematic literature review [English abstract]. Tutkiva Hoitotyö 1 (2), 10-15.
116. Walle P. (2003) Mentored job-rotation widened nurses' competency. [English abstract]. Sairaanhoitaja 76 (1), 8-10.
117. Wanless D. (2002) Securing our Future Health: Taking a Long-Term Vie. HM Treasury, London.
118. West E. (2004) Nursing Workforce Issues: A Review Of Research And Policy. Macmillan Cancer relief. RCN International Research Conference 2004 symposium Current research on Nursing Workforce Issues.
119. West E., Mays N., Rafferty A.M., Rowan K. & Sanderson C. (2009) Nursing resources and patient outcomes in intensive care: a systematic review of the literature. International Journal of Nursing Studies 46 (7), 993-1011.
120. Wilskman K. (2006) Järkevälle toiminnalle luotava edellytykset. Sairaanhoitaja 79 (8), 12-13.
121. Wilskman K. (2007) Työaikajoustot voivat yhdistää potilaiden ja henkilökunnan toiveet. Sairaanhoitaja 80 (2), 18-19.
122. World Health Organisation (WHO) (2006) The world health report 2006 - working together for health [WWW document]. Available at:, accessed 2 January 2008.
123. Zeutinoglu I.U., Denton M., Davies S., Baumann A., Blythe J. & Boos L. (2006) Retaining nurses in their employing hospitals and in profession. Effects of job preference, unpaid overtime, importance or earnings and stress. Health Policy 79, 57-72.