A tale of two scenes: Civic capital and retaining musical talent in Toronto and Halifax

Canadian Geographer

Volumn 55, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 365-382

  Hracs, Brian J ^a   Grant, Jill L ^b   Haggett, Jeffry ^c   Morton, Jesse ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO   (Canada)

^b DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^c Regional Municipality of Wood   (Canada)

Author keywords

capital civique; dynamique sociale; Halifax; musique; Toronto

Indexed keywords

LOCATION DECISION; MUSIC;

CANADA; HALIFAX; NOVA SCOTIA; ONTARIO [CANADA]; TORONTO;

EID: 80052298718     PISSN: 00083658     EISSN: 15410064     Source Type: Trade Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1541-0064.2011.00364.x     Document Type: Article

References (71)

1. Atkinson, C. Z., 1997 Whose New Orleans? Music's place in the packaging of New Orleans for tourism ' in Tourists and Tourism: Identifying with People and Place, ed., S. Abram, J. D. Waldren, and, D. V. L. MacLeod, (Oxford, UK: Berg), 91-106
2. Bank of Canada. 2010 Inflation calculator (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
3. Banks, A., 2007 The Politics of Cultural Work (London, UK: Palgrave McMillan)
4. Bennett, A., 2001 Cultures of Popular Music (London, UK: Open University Press)
5. Berman, S., 2009 This Book is Broken: A Broken Social Scene Story (Toronto, ON: House of Anansi Press)
6. Brooks, C., Cooper, P., Corcoran, M., Flinn, C., O'meara, J., and, Powell, C., 2009 Cities of song: get into the groove in these hot cities for music lovers CAA Magazine Summer, 26-33
7. Brown, A., O'connor, J., and, Cohen, S., 2000 Local music policies within a global music industry: cultural quarters in Manchester and Sheffield Geoforum 31, 437-451
8. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation. 2009 Rental Market Report Halifax CMA ' (Ottawa, ON: Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation)
9. Canadian Independent Recording Artists' Association. 2010 FAQ (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
10. Carniol, N., 2005 Music industry sings the blues The Toronto Star 27 October, D1
11. Cohen, S., 1997 More than the Beatles: popular music, tourism and urban regeneration ' in Tourists and Tourism: Identifying with People and Place, ed., S. Abram, J. D. Waldren, and, D. V. L. MacLeod, (Oxford, UK: Berg), 71-90
12. Conference Board of Canada. 2008 Valuing culture: measuring and understanding Canada's creative economy ' (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
13. Connell, J., and, Gibson, C., 2003 Sound Tracks: Popular Music, Identity, and Place (London, UK: Routledge)
14. Currid, E., 2007 The Warhol Economy: How Fashion, Art, and Music Drive New York City (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press)
15. Dale, D., 2010 Demolished building was site of Toronto music history The Toronto Star 19 August (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
16. Delisle, F., and, Shearmur, R., 2010 Where does all the talent flow? Migration of young graduates and nongraduates, Canada 1996-2001 The Canadian Geographer 54 (3), 305-323
17. Face of Poverty Coalition. 2007 Poverty is policy-created ' (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
18. Florida, R., 2002a The Rise of the Creative Class: and How it's Transforming Work, Leisure, Community and Everyday Life (New York, NY: Basic Books)
19. -. 2002b Bohemia and economic geography Journal of Economic Geography 2, 55-71
20. -. 2005 The Flight of the Creative Class: The New Global Competition for Talent (New York, NY: Harper Business, Harper Collins)
21. Florida, R., and, Jackson, S., 2010 Sonic city: the evolving economic geography of the music industry Journal of Planning Education and Research 29 (3), 310-321
22. Florida, R., Mellander, C., and, Stolarick, K., 2010 Talent, technology, and tolerance in Canadian regional development The Canadian Geographer 54 (3), 277-304
23. Gertler, M., Florida, R., Gates, G., and, Vinodrai, T., 2002 Competing on Creativity: Placing Ontario's Cities in North American Context. A report prepared for the Ontario Ministry of Enterprise, Opportunity and Innovation and the Institute for Competitiveness and Prosperity (Available at, accessed 31 March 2011)
24. Gertler, M., Tesolin, L., and, Weinstock, S., 2006 Imagine a Toronto: Strategies for a Creative City (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
25. Gibson, C., and, Davidson, D., 2004 Tamworth, Australia's "country music capital": place marketing, rurality, and resident reactions Journal of Rural Studies 20, 387-404 (Pubitemid 39259564)
26. Grant, J. L., Haggett, J., and, Morton, J., 2009 The Halifax Sound: Live Music and the Economic Development of Halifax. ISRN Halifax Working Paper Series (Available at:, accessed 31 March 2011)
27. Grant, J. L., and, Kronstal, K., 2010 The social dynamics of attracting talent in Halifax The Canadian Geographer 54 (3), 347-365
28. Grazian, D., 2004 The symbolic economy of authenticity in the Chicago Blues scene ' in Music Scenes: Local, Translocal, and Virtual, ed., A. Bennett, and, R. A. Peterson, (Nashville, TN: The Vanderbilt Press), 31-47
29. Green, J. P., and, Spier, S., 2011 University of Toronto The Canadian Encyclopedia (Available at:, accessed 31 March 2011)
30. Haggett, J., 2009 Make a little noise: performance venues on the Peninsula of Halifax. Bachelor of Community Design Honours Thesis, Dalhousie University, Halifax
31. Halfacree, K. H., and, Kitchin, R. M., 1996 Madchester rave on: placing the fragments of popular music Area 28 (1), 47-55
32. Hauge, A., and, Hracs, B. J., 2010 See the sound, hear the style: collaborative linkages between indie musicians and fashion designers in local scenes Industry and Innovation 17 (1), 113-129
33. Hracs, B. J., 2007 Toronto's culturally driven gentrification: the creative class of West Queen West UnderCurrents: Journal of Critical Environmental Studies 16, 34-36
34. -. 2009a Beyond bohemia: geographies of everyday creativity for musicians in Toronto ' in Spaces of Vernacular Creativity: Rethinking the Cultural Economy, ed., T. Edensor, D. Leslie, S. Millington, and, N. M. Rantisi, (London, UK: Routledge), 75-88
35. -. 2009b Building Ontario's Music Economies (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
36. Hudson, R., 1995 Making music work? Alternative regeneration strategies in a deindustrialized locality: the case of Derwentside Transactions of the British Institute of Geography 20, 460-473
37. Hyatt, D., 2008 An Overview of the Financial Impact of the Canadian Music Industry (Toronto, ON: Ontario Media Development Corporation) (Available at:, accessed 4 May 2011)
38. James, A., 2006 Critical moments in the production of "rigorous" and "relevant" cultural economic geographies Progress in Human Geography 30 (3), 289-308 (Pubitemid 43960341)
39. Jick, T. D., 1979 Mixing qualitative and quantitative methods: triangulation in action Administrative Science Quarterly 24 (4), 602-611
40. Knox, C., 2007 Halifax fights for its indie crown: city bursts with music as it hosts the '07 ECMA awards The Ottawa Citizen 16 February, D1
41. Kruse, H., 1993 Subcultural identity in alternative music culture Popular Music 12 (1), 33-41
42. Lepawsky, J., Phan, C., and, Greenwood, R., 2010 'Metropolis on the margins: talent attraction and retention to the St. John's city-region The Canadian Geographer 54 (3), 324-346
43. Leslie, D., and, Rantisi, N. M., 2006 Governing the design economy in Montreal, Canada Urban Affairs Review 41 (3), 309-337 (Pubitemid 43032980)
44. Leyshon, A., 2001 Time-scale (and digital) compression: software formats, musical networks, and the reorganization of the music industry Environment and Planning A 33, 49-77
45. -. 2003 Scary monsters? Software formats, peer-to-peer networks, and the spectre of the gift Environment and Planning D 21, 533-558
46. -. 2009 The software slump? Digital music, the democratisation of technology, and the decline of the recording studio sector within the musical economy Environment and Planning A 41, 1309-1331
47. Leyshon, A., Matless, D., and, Revill, G., 1998 Introduction: music, space and the production of place ' in The Place of Music, ed., A. Leyshon, D. Matless, and, G. Revill, (New York, NY: The Guilford Press), 1-30
48. Leyshon, A., Webb, P., French, S., Thrift, N., and, Crewe, L., 2005 On the reproduction of the musical economy after the internet Media, Culture and Society 27 (2), 177-209
49. Markusen, A., and, Schrock, G., 2006a The distinctive city: divergent patterns in growth, hierarchy and specialisation Urban Studies 43 (8), 1301-1323 (Pubitemid 44044315)
50. -. 2006b The artistic dividend: urban artistic specialisation and economic development implications Urban Studies 43 (10), 1661-1686
51. Mcleay, C., 1994 The "Dunedin sound": New Zealand rock and cultural geography Perfect Beat 2 (1), 38-49
52. Mcrobbie, A., 1998 British Fashion Design: Rag Trade or Image Industry ? (New York, NY: Routledge)
53. Morey, C., and, Morris, C., 2011 Canadian opera company The Canadian Encyclopedia (Available at:, accessed 31 March 2011)
54. Morton, J., 2008 There's a Reason Why I Love this Town': Exploring the Halifax Music Scene (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
55. Power, D., and, Jansson, J., 2004 The emergence of a post-industrial music economy? Music and ICT synergies in Stockholm, Sweden Geoforum 35, 425-439 (Pubitemid 38825498)
56. The Royal Conservatory. 2011 About the Royal Conservatory (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
57. Scott, A. J., 2000 The Cultural Economy of Cities (London, UK: Sage)
58. Slater, T., 2004 Municipally managed gentrification in South Parkdale, Toronto The Canadian Geographer 48 (3), 303-325 (Pubitemid 39412189)
59. Statistics Canada. 2007a Census of Canada 2006: Community Profiles: Toronto, Ontario (Code535) (table). 92-591-XWE (2006)
60. -. 2007b Census of Canada 2006: Community Profiles: Halifax, Nova Scotia (Code205) (table). 92-591-XWE (2006)
61. Statistics Canada. 2008a Census of Canada 2006: Labour Force Activity, Highest Certificate, Diploma or Degree, Location of Study, Age Groups and Sex. Topic-based tabulations. 97-564-XCB2006005 (2006)
62. -. 2008b Census of Canada 2006: Labour Force Activity, Highest Certificate, Diploma or Degree, Location of Study, Age Groups and Sex. Topic-based tabulations. 97-f0012-XCB01050 (2001, 1996, 1991)
63. Stein-Sachs, S., 2006 The Canadian Independent Music Industry: An Examination of Distribution and Access (Ottawa, ON: Canadian Heritage)
64. Storper, M., and, Manville, M., 2006 Behaviour, preferences and cities: urban theory and urban resurgence Urban Studies 43 (8), 1247-1274 (Pubitemid 44044313)
65. Toronto. 2010 Report Card on Children: Fact Sheet #2 ∼ Low-Income Children 0-5 Years (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
66. Toronto Symphony Orchestra. 2011 About the TSO (Available at:, accessed 10 January 2010)
67. Valentine, G., 2005 Tell me about: using interviews as a research methodology ' in Methods in Human Geography: A Guide for Students Doing a Research Project, ed., R. Flowerdew, and, D. Martin, (London, UK: Longman), 110-127
68. Wojan, T. R., Lambert, D. M., and, Mcgranahan, D. A., 2007 Emoting with their feet: Bohemian attraction to creative milieu Journal of Economic Geography 7, 711-736 (Pubitemid 47604734)
69. Wolfe, D. A., 2009a Introduction: embedded clusters in the global economy European Planning Studies 17 (2), 179-187
70. -. 2009b Twenty-first Century Cities in Canada: The Geography of Innovation (Ottawa, ON: Conference Board of Canada)
71. Wolfe, D. A., and, Nelles, J., 2008 The role of civic capital and civic associations in cluster policies ' in Handbook of Research on Innovation and Clusters: Cases and Policies, ed., C. Karlsson, (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar), 374-392