Varicocele and male factor infertility treatment: A new meta-analysis and review of the role of varicocele repair

European Urology

Volumn 60, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 796-808

  Baazeem, Abdulaziz ^a   Belzile, Eric ^b   Ciampi, Antonio ^b   Dohle, Gert ^c   Jarvi, Keith ^d   Salonia, Andrea ^e   Weidner, Wolfgang ^f   Zini, Armand ^g  

^a UMM AL QURA UNIVERSITY   (Saudi Arabia)

^b ST MARY S HOSPITAL   (Canada)

^c ERASMUS MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

^d MOUNT SINAI HOSPITAL   (Canada)

^e SAN RAFFAELE HOSPITAL   (Italy)

^f JUSTUS LIEBIG UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

^g MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Infertility; male; Oligospermia; Pregnancy outcome; Semen and sperm; Sperm count; Sperm motility; Spermatozoa; Varicocele; Varicocelectomy

Indexed keywords

CELL STRUCTURE; CELL ULTRASTRUCTURE; CLINICAL ASSESSMENT; CONCENTRATION (PARAMETERS); DNA DAMAGE; EMBASE; HUMAN; MALE INFERTILITY; MEDICAL LITERATURE; MEDLINE; MICROSURGERY; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; OLIGOSPERMIA; OXIDATIVE STRESS; POSTOPERATIVE PERIOD; PREGNANCY OUTCOME; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROSPECTIVE STUDY; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); RECURRENT DISEASE; REVIEW; RISK FACTOR; SCORING SYSTEM; SPERM; SPERMATOGENESIS; SPERMATOZOON MOTILITY; SURGICAL APPROACH; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THERAPY EFFECT; VARICOCELE; VARICOCELECTOMY;

DNA DAMAGE; HUMANS; INFERTILITY, MALE; MALE; MICROSURGERY; OLIGOSPERMIA; OXIDATIVE STRESS; POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; RECURRENCE; SPERM COUNT; SPERM MOTILITY; TREATMENT OUTCOME; VARICOCELE; VASCULAR SURGICAL PROCEDURES;

EID: 80052260236     PISSN: 03022838     EISSN: 18737560     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.eururo.2011.06.018     Document Type: Review

References (84)

1. B.G. Clarke Incidence of varicocele in normal men and among men of different ages JAMA 198 1966 1121 1122
2. S.H. Greenberg, L.I. Lipshultz, and A.J. Wein Experience with 425 subfertile male patients J Urol 119 1978 507 510 (Pubitemid 8341477)
3. J.I. Gorelick, and M. Goldstein Loss of fertility in men with varicocele Fertil Steril 59 1993 613 616 (Pubitemid 23086322)
4. The influence of varicocele on parameters of fertility in a large group of men presenting to infertility clinics. World Health Organization. Fertil Steril 1992;57:1289-93.
5. J.A. Daitch, M.A. Bedaiwy, and E.B. Pasqualotto Varicocelectomy improves intrauterine insemination success rates in men with varicocele J Urol 165 2001 1510 1513 (Pubitemid 32410226)
6. J.C. Rageth, C. Unger, and D. DaRugna Long-term results of varicocelectomy Urol Int 48 1992 327 331
7. Male Infertility Best Practice Policy Committee of the American Urological Association; Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. Report on varicocele and infertility. Fertil Steril 2004; 82(Suppl 1):S142-5.
8. Practice Committee of American Society for Reproductive Medicine Report on varicocele and infertility Fertil Steril 90 Suppl 5 2008 S247 S249
9. G.R. Dohle, G.M. Colpi, T.B. Hargreave, G.K. Papp, A. Jungwirth, and W. Weidner The EAU Working Group on Male Infertility. EAU guidelines on male infertility Eur Urol 48 2005 703 711
10. National Collaborating Centre for Women's and Children's Health (UK). Fertility: assessment and treatment for people with fertility problems: clinical guideline February 2004. http://www.nice.org.uk:80/nicemedia/pdf/ CG011fullguideline.pdf.
11. R.A. Saleh, A. Agarwal, R.K. Sharma, T.M. Said, S.C. Sikka, and A.J. Thomas Jr. Evaluation of nuclear DNA damage in spermatozoa from infertile men with varicocele Fertil Steril 80 2003 1431 1436 (Pubitemid 37532458)
12. B.M. Baccetti, E. Bruni, and S. Capitani Studies on varicocele III: ultrastructural sperm evaluation and 18, X and Y aneuploidies J Androl 27 2006 94 101 (Pubitemid 43106740)
13. A.W. Zorgniotti, and J. Macleod Studies in temperature, human semen quality, and varicocele Fertil Steril 24 1973 854 863
14. F. Comhaire, and A. Vermeulen Varicocele sterility: cortisol and catecholamines Fertil Steril 25 1974 88 95
15. J. Chakraborty, A.P. Hikim, and J.S. Jhunjhunwala Stagnation of blood in the microcirculatory vessels in the testes of men with varicocele J Androl 6 1985 117 126
16. B.N. Hendin, P.N. Kolettis, R.K. Sharma, A.J. Thomas Jr., and A. Agarwal Varicocele is associated with elevated spermatozoal reactive oxygen species production and diminished seminal plasma antioxidant capacity J Urol 161 1999 1831 1834 (Pubitemid 29420743)
17. R.E. Donohue, and J.S. Brown Blood gases and pH determinations in the internal spermatic veins of subfertile men with varicocele Fertil Steril 20 1969 365 369
18. T.A. Abdel-Meguid, A. Al-Sayyad, A. Tayib, and H.M. Farsi Does varicocele repair improve male infertility? An evidence-based perspective from a randomized, controlled trial Eur Urol 59 2011 455 461
19. I. Madgar, R. Weissenberg, B. Lunenfeld, A. Karasik, and B. Goldwasser Controlled trial of high spermatic vein ligation for varicocele in infertile men Fertil Steril 63 1995 120 124
20. E. Nieschlag, L. Hertle, A. Fischedick, K. Abshagen, and H.M. Behre Update on treatment of varicocele: counselling as effective as occlusion of the vena spermatica Hum Reprod 13 1998 2147 2150 (Pubitemid 28425104)
21. W. Krause, H.H. Müller, H. Schäfer, and W. Weidner Does treatment of varicocele improve male fertility?. results of the 'Deutsche Varikozelenstudie', a multicentre study of 14 collaborating centres Andrologia 34 2002 164 171 (Pubitemid 34639199)
22. V. Ficarra, M.A. Cerruto, and G. Liguori Treatment of varicocele in subfertile men: the Cochrane Review - a contrary opinion Eur Urol 49 2006 258 263 (Pubitemid 43197861)
23. T. Jain, and R.S. Gupta Trends in the use of intracytoplasmic sperm injection in the United States N Engl J Med 357 2007 251 257 (Pubitemid 47080389)
24. Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine - levels of evidence (March 2009). Oxford Centre for Evidence Based Medicine Web site. http://www.cebm.net/ index.aspx?o=1025.
25. M. Egger, G.D. Smith, and D.G. Altman Systematic reviews in health care: meta-analysis in context ed 2 2001 BMJ Books London
26. H. Cooper, L.V. Hedges, and J.C. Valentine The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis 2009 Russell Sage Foundation Publications New York
27. J.L. Evers, J.A. Collins, and P. Vandekerckhove Surgery or embolisation for varicocele in subfertile men Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2001 CD000479
28. J.L. Evers, and J.A. Collins Surgery or embolisation for varicocele in subfertile men Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2004 CD000479
29. J.H. Evers, J. Collins, and J. Clarke Surgery or embolisation for varicoceles in subfertile men Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2008 CD000479
30. J.H. Evers, J. Collins, and J. Clarke Surgery or embolisation for varicoceles in subfertile men Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2009 CD000479
31. J.L. Marmar, A. Agarwal, and S. Prabakaran Reassessing the value of varicocelectomy as a treatment for male subfertility with a new meta-analysis Fertil Steril 88 2007 639 648 (Pubitemid 47368241)
32. W. Weidner, and T. Diemer Re: Reassessing the value of varicocelectomy as a treatment for male subfertility with a new meta-analysis Eur Urol 54 2008 465 466
33. A. Agarwal, F. Deepinder, and M. Cocuzza Efficacy of varicocelectomy in improving semen parameters: new meta-analytical approach Urology 70 2007 532 538 (Pubitemid 47464479)
34. D. Moher, K.F. Schulz, and D.G. Altman The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomised trials Lancet 357 2001 1191 1194 (Pubitemid 32378696)
35. J.S. Laven, L.C. Haans, W.P. Mali, E.R. te Velde, C.J. Wensing, and J.M. Eimers Effects of varicocele treatment in adolescents: a randomized study Fertil Steril 58 1992 756 762
36. Y. Gat, G.N. Bachar, K. Everaert, U. Levinger, and M. Gornish Induction of spermatogenesis in azoospermic men after internal spermatic vein embolization for the treatment of varicocele Hum Reprod 20 2005 1013 1017 (Pubitemid 40667849)
37. G.J. Matthews, E.D. Matthews, and M. Goldstein Induction of spermatogenesis and achievement of pregnancy after microsurgical varicocelectomy in men with azoospermia and severe oligoasthenospermia Fertil Steril 70 1998 71 75 (Pubitemid 28294625)
38. D. Sakkas, and J.G. Alvarez Sperm DNA fragmentation: mechanisms of origin, impact on reproductive outcome, and analysis Fertil Steril 93 2010 1027 1036
39. A. Palomo Radical cure of varicocele by a new technique; preliminary report J Urol 61 1949 604 607
40. R. Bernardi Varicocele: results obtained with a personal technic in 500 cases [in Spanish] Rev Asoc Med Argent 72 1958 57 64
41. O. Ivanissevich, and H. Gregorini Una nueva operaciûn para curar el varicocele Semana Med 25 1918 575
42. S.J. Silber Microsurgical aspects of varicocele Fertil Steril 31 1979 230 232 (Pubitemid 9110900)
43. J.L. Marmar, T.J. DeBenedictis, and D. Praiss The management of varicoceles by microdissection of the spermatic cord at the external inguinal ring Fertil Steril 43 1985 583 588 (Pubitemid 15086710)
44. R.A. Aaberg, T.G. Vancaillie, and W.W. Schuessler Laparoscopic varicocele ligation: a new technique Fertil Steril 56 1991 776 777
45. R. Tauber, and N. Johnsen Antegrade scrotal sclerotherapy for the treatment of varicocele: technique and late results J Urol 151 1994 386 390 (Pubitemid 24047003)
46. V. Iaccarino A nonsurgical treatment of varicocele: trans-catheter sclerotherapy of gonadal veins Ann Radiol (Paris) 23 1980 369 370 (Pubitemid 10145080)
47. R. Gonzalez, P. Narayan, A. Formanek, and K. Amplatz Transvenous embolization of internal spermatic veins: nonoperative approach to treatment of varicocele Urology 17 1981 246 248 (Pubitemid 11137104)
48. N. Simforoosh, S.A. Ziaee, S. Behjati, F.M. Beygi, A. Arianpoor, and H. Abdi Laparoscopic management of varicocele using bipolar cautery versus open high ligation technique: a randomized, clinical trial J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A 17 2007 743 747
49. S. Al-Said, A. Al-Naimi, and A. Al-Ansari Varicocelectomy for male infertility: a comparative study of open, laparoscopic and microsurgical approaches J Urol 180 2008 266 270
50. A. Zucchi, L. Mearini, E. Mearini, E. Costantini, V. Bini, and M. Porena Treatment of varicocele: randomized prospective study on open surgery versus Tauber antegrade sclerotherapy J Androl 26 2005 328 332 (Pubitemid 40628968)
51. T. Sautter, T. Sulser, S. Suter, H. Gretener, and D. Hauri Treatment of varicocele: a prospective randomized comparison of laparoscopy versus antegrade sclerotherapy Eur Urol 41 2002 398 400 (Pubitemid 35333935)
52. S. Cayan, S. Shavakhabov, and A. Kadioglu Treatment of palpable varicocele in infertile men: a meta-analysis to define the best technique J Androl 30 2009 33 40
53. S. Cayan, D. Acar, S. Ulger, and E. Akbay Adolescent varicocele repair: long-term results and comparison of surgical techniques according to optical magnification use in 100 cases at a single university hospital J Urol 174 2005 2003 2006 discussion 2006-7 (Pubitemid 41547008)
54. P. Gontero, G. Pretti, F. Fontana, A. Zitella, G. Marchioro, and B. Frea Inguinal versus subinguinal varicocele vein ligation using magnifying loupe under local anesthesia: which technique is preferable in clinical practice? Urology 66 2005 1075 1079 (Pubitemid 41587164)
55. M. Grasso, C. Lania, M. Castelli, L. Galli, and P. Rigatti Bilateral varicocele: impact of right spermatic vein ligation on fertility J Urol 153 1995 1847 1848
56. D. Scherr, and M. Goldstein Comparison of bilateral versus unilateral varicocelectomy in men with palpable bilateral varicoceles J Urol 162 1999 85 88 (Pubitemid 29420886)
57. M. Yamamoto, Y. Tsuji, M. Ohmura, H. Hibi, and K. Miyake Comparison of artery-ligating and artery-preserving varicocelectomy: effect on post-operative spermatogenesis Andrologia 27 1995 37 40
58. N. Zampieri, V. Zuin, M. Corroppolo, C. Chironi, R.M. Cervellione, and F.S. Camoglio Varicocele and adolescents: semen quality after 2 different laparoscopic procedures J Androl 28 2007 727 733 (Pubitemid 47401770)
59. P.T. Chan, E.J. Wright, and M. Goldstein Incidence and postoperative outcomes of accidental ligation of the testicular artery during microsurgical varicocelectomy J Urol 173 2005 482 484
60. M. Grasso, C. Lania, M. Castelli, L. Galli, F. Franzoso, and P. Rigatti Low-grade left varicocele in patients over 30 years old: the effect of spermatic vein ligation on fertility BJU Int 85 2000 305 307 (Pubitemid 30088524)
61. D. Unal, E. Yeni, A. Verit, and O.F. Karatas Clomiphene citrate versus varicocelectomy in treatment of subclinical varicocele: a prospective randomized study Int J Urol 8 2001 227 230 (Pubitemid 34225059)
62. M. Yamamoto, H. Hibi, Y. Hirata, K. Miyake, and T. Ishigaki Effect of varicocelectomy on sperm parameters and pregnancy rate in patients with subclinical varicocele: a randomized prospective controlled study J Urol 155 1996 1636 1638 (Pubitemid 26126966)
63. M.A. Elbendary, and A.M. Elbadry Right subclinical varicocele: how to manage in infertile patients with clinical left varicocele? Fertil Steril 92 2009 2050 2053
64. Y.Q. Zheng, X. Gao, Z.J. Li, Y.L. Yu, Z.G. Zhang, and W. Li Efficacy of bilateral and left varicocelectomy in infertile men with left clinical and right subclinical varicoceles: a comparative study Urology 73 2009 1236 1240
65. F.F. Pasqualotto, A.M. Lucon, and P.M. de Góes Is it worthwhile to operate on subclinical right varicocele in patients with grade II-III varicocele in the left testicle? J Assist Reprod Genet 22 2005 227 231 (Pubitemid 40864088)
66. A. Agarwal, S. Prabakaran, and S.S. Allamaneni Relationship between oxidative stress, varicocele and infertility: a meta-analysis Reprod Biomed Online 12 2006 630 633 (Pubitemid 43674936)
67. S.S. Chen, W.J. Huang, L.S. Chang, and Y.H. Wei Attenuation of oxidative stress after varicocelectomy in subfertile patients with varicocele J Urol 179 2008 639 642
68. M. Smit, J.C. Romijn, M.F. Wildhagen, J.L. Veldhoven, R.F. Weber, and G.R. Dohle Decreased sperm DNA fragmentation after surgical varicocelectomy is associated with increased pregnancy rate J Urol 183 2010 270 274
69. A. Zini, R. Azhar, A. Baazeem, and M.S. Gabriel Effect of microsurgical varicocelectomy on human sperm chromatin and DNA integrity: a prospective trial Int J Androl 34 2011 14 19
70. M. Reichart, F. Eltes, Y. Soffer, E. Zigenreich, L. Yogev, and B. Bartoov Sperm ultramorphology as a pathophysiological indicator of spermatogenesis in males suffering from varicocele Andrologia 32 2000 139 145 (Pubitemid 30337595)
71. K. Ichioka, K. Nagahama, K. Okubo, T. Soda, O. Ogawa, and H. Nishiyama Genetic polymorphisms in glutathione S-transferase T1 affect the surgical outcome of varicocelectomies in infertile patients Asian J Androl 11 2009 333 341
72. M.H. Nasr-Esfahani, H. Abasi, S. Razavi, S. Ashrafi, and M. Tavalaee Varicocelectomy: semen parameters and protamine deficiency Int J Androl 32 2009 115 122
73. A. Balci, S. Karazincir, S. Gorur, H. Sumbas, E. Egilmez, and T. Inandi Long-term effect of varicocele repair on intratesticular arterial resistance index J Clin Ultrasound 36 2008 148 152 (Pubitemid 351441224)
74. C. Ozden, O.L. Ozdal, S. Bulut, O. Guzel, H.H. Koyuncu, and A. Memis Effect of varicocelectomy on serum inhibin B levels in infertile patients with varicocele Scand J Urol Nephrol 42 2008 441 443
75. A.M. Al-Kandari, H. Shabaan, H.M. Ibrahim, Y.H. Elshebiny, and A.A. Shokeir Comparison of outcomes of different varicocelectomy techniques: open inguinal, laparoscopic, and subinguinal microscopic varicocelectomy: a randomized clinical trial Urology 69 2007 417 420 (Pubitemid 46428418)
76. A. Zucchi, L. Mearini, E. Mearini, F. Fioretti, V. Bini, and M. Porena Varicocele and fertility: relationship between testicular volume and seminal parameters before and after treatment J Androl 27 2006 548 551 (Pubitemid 44126267)
77. F.F. Pasqualotto, A.M. Lucon, and P.M. de Góes Testicular growth, sperm concentration, percent motility, and pregnancy outcome after varicocelectomy based on testicular histology Fertil Steril 83 2005 362 366 (Pubitemid 40221789)
78. S. Cayan, T.C. Kadioglu, A. Tefekli, A. Kadioglu, and S. Tellaloglu Comparison of results and complications of high ligation surgery and microsurgical high inguinal varicocelectomy in the treatment of varicocele Urology 55 2000 750 754
79. G.A. Barbalias, E.N. Liatsikos, G. Nikiforidis, and D. Siablis Treatment of varicocele for male infertility: a comparative study evaluating currently used approaches Eur Urol 34 1998 393 398 (Pubitemid 28499722)
80. T. Matsuda, Y. Horii, and O. Yoshida Should the testicular artery be preserved at varicocelectomy? J Urol 149 1993 1357 1360 (Pubitemid 23133850)
81. J. Sayfan, Y. Soffer, and R. Orda Varicocele treatment: prospective randomized trial of 3 methods J Urol 148 1992 1447 1449
82. M. Yamamoto, H. Hibi, S. Katsuno, and K. Miyake Effects of varicocelectomy on testis volume and semen parameters in adolescents: a randomized prospective study Nagoya J Med Sci 58 1995 127 132
83. A. Mancini, D. Milardi, G. Conte, R. Festa, L. De Marinis, and G.P. Littarru Seminal antioxidants in humans: preoperative and postoperative evaluation of coenzyme Q10 in varicocele patients Horm Metab Res 37 2005 428 432 (Pubitemid 41081223)
84. H. Acar, M. Kilinc, S. Guven, T. Yurdakul, and R. Celik Comparison of semen profile and frequency of chromosome aneuploidies in sperm nuclei of patients with varicocele before and after varicocelectomy Andrologia 41 2009 157 162