Navy sonar, cetaceans and the US Supreme Court: A review of cetacean mitigation and litigation in the US

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Volumn 63, Issue 1-4, 2011, Pages 40-48

  Zirbel, K ^a   Balint, P ^a   Parsons, E C M ^a,b  

^a GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Beaked whale; Cetacean; Court cases; Environmental laws; Mitigation measures; Naval sonar

Indexed keywords

BEAKED WHALE; CETACEAN; COURT CASE; ENVIRONMENTAL LAW; MITIGATION MEASURES; NAVAL SONAR;

COASTAL ENGINEERING; COASTAL ZONES; CONSERVATION; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; LAW ENFORCEMENT; MAMMALS; REGIONAL PLANNING; SONAR; UNDERWATER ACOUSTICS;

ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS;

ANTHROPOGENIC EFFECT; CETACEAN; COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT; ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; MITIGATION; SONAR; WHALE;

ARTICLE; CETACEAN; COURT; ECHOLOCATION; ENDANGERED SPECIES; LAW; LAW SUIT; LEGAL ASPECT; MARINE MAMMAL; MILITARY PHENOMENA; MITIGATION; NAVAL SONAR; NOISE POLLUTION; NONHUMAN; ORGANIZATION; SEA; UNITED STATES;

ANIMALS; CETACEA; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ENDANGERED SPECIES; ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY; JURISPRUDENCE; LEGISLATION AS TOPIC; MILITARY PERSONNEL; NOISE; SHIPS; SUPREME COURT DECISIONS; UNITED STATES; WATER POLLUTION;

UNITED STATES;

CETACEA; MAMMALIA; ZIPHIIDAE;

EID: 79958732981     PISSN: 0025326X     EISSN: 18793363     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2011.03.018     Document Type: Article

References (58)

1. Balcomb K.C., Claridge D.E. A mass stranding of cetaceans caused by naval sonar in the Bahamas. Bahamas Journal of Science 2001, 8:1-12.
2. Barlow J., Gisner R. Mitigating, monitoring and assessing the effects of anthropogenic sound on beaked whales. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 2006, 7:239-249.
3. Bowles A.E., Smultea M., Wursig B., DeMaster D., Palka D. Abundance of marine mammals exposed to transmissions from Heard Island Feasibility Test. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1994, 96:2469-2484.
4. Brownell Jr., R.L., Yamada, T., Mead, J.G., van Helden, A.L., 2004. Mass Strandings of Cuvier's Beaked Whales in Japan: US Naval Acoustic Link? Paper Presented to the Scientific Committee at the 56th Meeting of the International Whaling Commission, 29 June-10 July 2004, Sorrento, Italy, SC56/E37.
5. Brownell R.L., Ralls K., Baumann-Pickering S., Poole M. Behavior of melon-headed whales, Peponocephala electra, near oceanic islands. Marine Mammal Science 2009, 25:639-658.
6. Buck, E., Calvert, K., 2007. Active Military Sonar and Marine Mammals: Events and References. Congressional Research Service. Order Code RL 33133.
7. Clark C.W., Altman N.S. Acoustic detections of blue whale (Balaenoptera musculus) and fin whale (B. physalus) sounds during a SURTASS LFA exercise. Journal of Oceanic Engineering 2006, 31:120-128.
8. Clarke, J.T., Norman, S.A., 2005. Results and evaluation of US Navy shock trial environmental mitigation of marine mammals and sea turtles. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management, 43-50.
9. Cox T.M., Ragen T.J., Read A.J., Vos E., Baird R.W., Balcomb K., Barlow J., Caldwell J., Cranford T., Crum L., D'Amico A., D'Spain G., Fernandez A., Finneran J., Gentry R., Gerth W., Gulland F., Hildebrand J., Houser D., Hullar T., Jepson P.D., Ketten D., MacLeod C.D., Miller P., Moore S., Mountain D.C., Palka D., Ponganis P., Rommel S., Rowles T., Taylor B., Tyack P., Wartzok D., Gisiner R., Mead J., Benner L. Understanding the impacts of acoustic sound on beaked whales. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 2006, 7:177-187.
10. Craig R.K. Beyond Winter v. NRDC: a decade of litigating the Navy's active sonar around the environmental exemptions. Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review 2009, 36:353-378.
11. Cressey, D., 2008. Sonar does affect whales, military report confirms. Nature, doi:10.1038/news.2008.997.
12. Croll D.A., Clark C.W., Calambokidis J., Ellison W.T., Tershy B.R. Effect of anthropogenic low-frequency noise on the foraging ecology of Balaenoptera whales. Animal Conservation 2001, 4:13-27.
13. Crum L.A., Mao Y. Acoustically enhanced bubble growth at low frequencies and its implications for human diver and marine mammal safety. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1996, 99:2907-2989.
14. Crum L.A., Bailey M.R., Guan J., Hilmo P.R., Kargi S.G., Matula T.J. Monitoring bubble growth in supersaturated blood and tissue ex vivo and the relevance to marine mammal bioeffects. Acoustics Research Letters Online 2005, 6:214-220.
15. Eubanks, W.S., 2009. Damage done? The status of NEPA after Winter v. NRDC and answers to lingering questions left open by the court. Vermont Law Review 33, 649-670.
16. Evans, D.L., England, G.R., 2001. Joint Interim Report Bahamas Marine Mammal Stranding Event of 15-16 March 2000. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Washington, DC. Available from: http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/pdfs/health/stranding_bahamas2000.pdf.
17. Fernández A., Arbelo M., Deaville R., Patterson I.A.P., Castro P., Baker J.R., Degollada E., Ross H.M., Herráez P., Pocknell A.M., Rodríguez E., Howie F.E., Espinosa A., Reid R.J., Jaber J.R., Martin V., Cunningham A.A., Jepson P.D. Pathology: whales, sonar and decompression sickness. Nature 2004, 428:1-2.
18. Fernández A., Edwards J.F., Rodriguez F., Espinosa de los Morteros A., Herraez P., Casstro P., Jaber J.R., Martin V., Arbelo M. ''Gas and fat embolic syndrome" involving a mass stranding of beaked whales (Family Ziphiidae) exposed to anthropogenic sonar signals. Veterinary Pathology 2005, 42:446-457.
19. Findley K.J., Miller G.W., Davis R.A., Greene C.R. Reactions of belugas, Delphinapterus leucas, and narwhals, Monodon monoceros, to ice-breaking ships in the Canadian high Arctic. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 1990, 224:97-117.
20. Forney, K.A., 2002. Surveys. In: Perrin, W.F., Würsig, B., Thewissen, J.G.M. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals. Academic Press, London and San Diego, pp. 1203-1205.
21. Frantzis A. Does acoustic testing strand whales?. Nature 1998, 392:29.
22. Fristrup K.M., Hatch L.T., Clark C.W. Variation in humpack whale (Megaptera novaengliae) song length in relation to low-frequency sound broadcasts. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 2003, 113:3411-3424.
23. Gould J.C., Fish P.J. Broadband spectra of seismic survey air-gun emissions, with reference to dolphin auditory thresholds. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1998, 103:2177-2184.
24. Gould J.C., Fish P.J. Response to " comments on 'broadband spectra of seismic survey air-gun emissions with reference to dolphin auditory threshold'" Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1999, 105:2049-2050.
25. Hatch L.T., Wright A.J. A brief review of anthropogenic sound in the oceans. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 2007, 20:121-133.
26. Heisler R. A whale of a tale: NRDC v. US Navy and the attempt to exempt the exclusive economic zone from the National Environmental Policy Act. Southwestern Journal of Law and Trade in the Americas 2003, 10:125-170.
27. Hohn, A.A., Rotstein, D.S., Harms, C.A., Southall, B.L., 2006. Report on Marine Mammal Unusual Mortality Event UMESE0501Sp: Multi Species Stranding of Short-finned Pilot Whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus) Minke Whale (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) and Dwarf Sperm Whales (Kogia sima) in North Carolina, 15-16 January 2005, NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS - SEFSC 537. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Washington, DC.
28. Hooker S.K., Baird R.W. Deep-diving behaviour of the northern bottlenose whale, Hyperoodon ampullatus (Cetacea: Ziphiidae). Proceedings of the Royal Society B 1999, 266:671-676.
29. Houser D.S., Howard R., Ridgway S. Can diving-induced tissue nitrogen supersaturation increase the chance of acoustically driven bubble growth in marine mammals?. Journal of Theoretical Biology 2001, 213:183-195.
30. International Whaling Commission, 2005. Report of the scientific committee. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 7 (Suppl.), 1-62.
31. International Whaling Commission, 2005. Report of the IWC Scientific Committee workshop on habitat degradation. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 8 (Suppl.), 313-335.
32. International Whaling Commission, 2006. Report of the IWC scientific committee workshop on habitat degradation. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 8 (Suppl .), 313-335.
33. Jepson P.D., Arbelo M., Deaville R., Patterson I.A.P., Castro P., Baker J.R., Degollada E., Ross H.M., Herráez P., Pocknell A.M., Rodríguez F., Howiell F.E., Espinosa A., Reid R.J., Jaber J.R., Martin V., Cunningham A.A., Fernández A. Gasbubble lesions in stranded cetaceans: was sonar responsible for a spate of whale deaths after an Atlantic military exercise?. Nature 2003, 425:575-576.
34. Jepson P.D., Deaville R., Patterson I.A.P., Pocknell A.M., Ross H.M., Baker J.R., Howie F.E., Reid R.J., Colloff A., Cunningham A.A. Acute and chronic gas bubble lesions in cetaceans stranded in the United Kingdom. Veterinarian Pathology 2005, 42:291-305.
35. Ketten, D.R., 2005. Beaked Whale Necropsy Findings for Strandings in the Bahamas, Puerto Rico, and Madeira, 1999-2002. WHOI Technical Reports. WHOI-2005-09. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute, Massachusetts.
36. Lubchenco, J., 2010. Letter from NOAA Administrator to the US Council onEnvironmental Quality, January 19th, 2010. (retrieved from 31.03.10). http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/pdfs/permits/lubchenco_letter.pdf.
37. Malakoff, D., 2001. A roaring debate over ocean noise. Science 291(5504), 576-578.
38. Maybaum H. Responses of the humpback whales to sonar sounds. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1993, 94:1848-1849.
39. Miller P.J.O., Biassoni N., Samuels A., Tyack P.L. Whale songs lengthen in response to sonar. Nature 2000, 405:903.
40. National Research Council, 2003. Ocean Noise and Marine Mammals. National Academies Press, Washington, DC.
41. NMFS (National Marine Fisheries Service), 2005. Assessment of Acoustic Exposures on Marine Mammals in Conjunction with USS Shoup Active Sonar Transmissions in the Eastern Strait of Juan de Fuca and Haro Strait, Washington 5 May 2003. NMFS, Office of Protected Resources. Available at: http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/pdfs/acoustics/assessment.pdf.
42. Norman, S.A., Raverty, S., McLellan, B., Pabst, A., Ketten, D., Fleetwood, M., Gaydos, J.K., Norberg, B., Barre, L., Cox, T., Hanson B., Jeffries, S., 2004. Multidisciplinary Investigation of Stranded Harbor Porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) in Washington State with an Assessment of Acoustic Trauma as a Contributory Factor (2 May - 2 June 2003). NMFS Tech. Memo. NMFS-NWR-34. National Marine Fisheries Service, Seattle, Washington.
43. Parsons E.C.M., Dolman S.J., Wright A.J., Rose N.A., Burns W.C.G. Navy sonar and cetaceans: just how much does the gun need to smoke before we act?. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2008, 56:1248-1257.
44. Parsons E.C.M., Dolman S., Jasny M., Rose N.A., Simmonds M.P., Wright A.J. A critique of the UK's JNCC Seismic Survey Guidelines for minimizing acoustic disturbance to marine mammals: best practice?. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2009, 58:643-651.
45. Rendell L.E., Gordon J.C.D. Vocal response of long-finned pilot whales (Globicephala melas) to military sonar in the Ligurian Sea. Marine Mammal Science 1999, 15:198-204.
46. Reynolds, J.R., Kiekow, T.G., Smith, S.Z., 2009. No whale of a tale: legal implications of Winter v. NRDC. Ecology Law Quaterly 36, 753-774.
47. Schaffner A. National security vs. whales: the Navy and the Natural Resources Defense Counsel[sic] battle their way to the Supreme Court. Sea Grant Law and Policy Journal 2008, 1:82-96.
48. Scott K. International regulation of undersea noise. International and Law Quarterly 2004, 53:287-324.
49. Simmonds, M.P., Lopez-Jurado, L.F., 1991.Whales and the military. Nature 351, 448.
50. Southall, B.I., Braun, R., Gulland, F.M.D., Heard, A.D., Baird, R.W., Wilkin, S.M., Rowles, T.K., 2006. Hawaiian Melon-headed Whale (Peponocephala electra) Mass Stranding Event of 3-4 July 2004. NOAA Technical Memorandum NMFS-ORP-31.
51. Stone, C.J., 2003. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1998-2000. JNCC Report 323. Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
52. Wang J.Y., Yang S.C. Unusual cetacean stranding events of Taiwan in 2004 and 2005. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 2006, 8:283-292.
53. Watkins W.A., Moore K.E., Tyack P. Sperm whale acoustic behaviors in the southeast Caribbean. Cetology 1985, 49:1-15.
54. Watkins W.A., Daher M., Fristrup K.M., Howald T.J., Notarbartolo di Sciara G. Sperm whales tagged with transponders and tracked underwater by sonar. Marine Mammal Science 1993, 9:55-67.
55. Weilgart L.S. A brief review of known effects of noise on marine mammals. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 2007, 20:159-168.
56. Whitt, L., Wilk, K., 1983. Antisubmarine warfare: passive vs. active sonar. The Two-Year College Mathematics Journal1 4(5), 434-435.
57. Wright A.J., Rose N.A., Parsons E.C.M., Dolman S. Urging cautious policy applications of captive research data is not the same as rejecting those data. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2009, 58:314-316.
58. Zirbel K., Balint P., Parsons E.C.M. Public awareness and attitudes towards naval sonar mitigation for cetacean conservation: a preliminary case study in the DC Metro area. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2011, 63:49-55.