A critique of the UK's JNCC seismic survey guidelines for minimising acoustic disturbance to marine mammals: Best practise?

Marine Pollution Bulletin

Volumn 58, Issue 5, 2009, Pages 643-651

  Parsons, E C M ^a,b   Dolman, Sarah J ^c,d   Jasny, Michael ^e   Rose, Naomi A ^f   Simmonds, Mark P ^c   Wright, Andrew J ^g  

^a GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION   (United Kingdom)

^c WHALE AND DOLPHIN CONSERVATION   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITY OF ABERDEEN   (United Kingdom)

^e Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)   (United States)

^f Humane Society of the United States   (United States)

^g Leviathan Sciences   (United States)

Author keywords

Cetacean; Conservation; Mitigation measures; Oil and gas industry; Seismic surveys; Underwater noise

Indexed keywords

CETACEAN; MITIGATION MEASURES; OIL AND GAS INDUSTRY; SEISMIC SURVEYS; UNDERWATER NOISE;

ACOUSTICS; CONSERVATION; EARTHQUAKES; GAS INDUSTRY; GEOLOGICAL SURVEYS; LIQUEFIED PETROLEUM GAS; NOISE POLLUTION;

MAMMALS;

ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION; MARINE MAMMAL; MITIGATION; NATURE CONSERVATION; SPECIES CONSERVATION; UNDERWATER NOISE;

ARTICLE; AUDITORY DISCRIMINATION; MARINE MAMMAL; NOISE POLLUTION; SPECIES CONSERVATION;

ACOUSTICS; ANIMALS; EXTRACTION AND PROCESSING INDUSTRY; GEOLOGY; GREAT BRITAIN; GUIDELINES AS TOPIC; MAMMALS; MARINE BIOLOGY; NOISE;

CETACEA; MAMMALIA; PHOCOENIDAE; ZIPHIIDAE;

EID: 65449138021     PISSN: 0025326X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2009.02.024     Document Type: Article

References (62)

1. Agardy, T., Aguilar, N., Cañadas, A., Engel, M., Frantzis, A., Hatch, L., Hoyt, E., Kaschner, K., LaBrecque, E., Martin, V., Notarbartolo di Sciara, G., Pavan, G., Servidio, A., Smith, B., Wang, J., Weilgart, L., Wintle, B., Wright, A., 2007. A Global Scientific Workshop on Spatio-Temporal Management of Noise. Report of the Scientific Workshop.
2. Bain, D.E., Williams, R.W., 2006. Long range effects of airgun noise on marine mammals: responses as a function of received sound level and distance. In: Paper Presented to the Scientific Committee at the 58th Meeting of the International Whaling Commission, 26 May-6 June 2006, St. Kitts, SC58/E35.
3. Barlow J., and Gisiner R. Mitigating, monitoring and assessing the effects of anthropogenic sound on beaked whales. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 7 (2006) 239-249
4. Beale C.M. The behavioral ecology of disturbance responses. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 20 (2007) 111-120
5. Beale C.M., and Monaghan P. Behavioral responses to human disturbance. a matter of choice. Animal Behavior 68 (2004) 1065-1069
6. Bowles A.E., Smultea M., Würsig B., DeMaster D.P., and Palka D. The relative abundance and behaviour of marine mammals exposed to transmissions from the Heard Island Feasibility Test. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 96 (1994) 2469-2484
7. Clark, C.W., Gagnon, G.C., 2006. Considering the temporal and spatial scales of noise exposures from seismic surveys on baleen whales. In: Paper Presented to the Scientific Committee at the 58th Meeting of the International Whaling Commission, 26 May-6 June 2006, St. Kitts, SC58/E9.
8. Cox T.M., Ragen T.J., Read A.J., Vos E., Baird R.W., Balcomb K., Barlow J., Caldwell J., Cranford T., Crum L., D'Amico A., D'Spain G., Fernandez A., Finneran J., Gentry R., Gerth W., Gulland F., Hildebrand J., Houser D., Hullar T., Jepson P.D., Ketten D., MacLeod C.D., Miller P., Moore S., Mountain D.C., Palka D., Ponganis P., Rommel S., Rowles T., Taylor B., Tyack P., Wartzok D., Gisiner R., Mead J., and Benner L. Understanding the impacts of acoustic sound on beaked whales. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 7 (2006) 177-187
9. Department of Trade and Industry, 2002. Strategic Environmental Assessment of Parts of the Central and Southern North Sea SEA 3. .
10. DeRuiter S.L., Tyack P., Lin Y.-T., Newhall A.E., Lynch J.F., and Miller P.J.O. Modeling acoustic propagation of airgun array pulses recorded on tagged sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus). Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 120 (2006) 4100-4114
11. Dolman S.J. Spatio-temporal restrictions as best practise precautionary response to ocean noise. Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy 10 (2007) 219-224
12. Dolman, S.J, Weir, C.R., Jasny, M., 2008. Comparative review of naval marine mammal guidance implemented during naval exercises. In: Presentation to the Institute of Acoustics Conference, Southampton, UK, 13-14 October 2008.
13. Fernández A., Arbelo M., Deaville R., Patterson I.A.P., Castro P., Baker J.R., Degollada E., Ross H.M., Herráez P., Pocknell A.M., Rodríguez E., Howie F.E., Espinosa A., Reid R.J., Jaber J.R., Martin V., Cunningham A.A., and Jepson P.D. Pathology: whales, sonar and decompression sickness. Nature 428 (2004) 1-2
14. Findley K.J., Miller G.W., Davis R.A., and Greene C.R. Reactions of belugas, Delphinapterus leucas, and narwhals, Monodon monoceros, to ice-breaking ships in the Canadian high Arctic. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 224 (1990) 97-117
15. Gordon J., and Tyack P. Acoustic techniques for studying cetaceans. In: Evans P.G.H., and Raga J.A. (Eds). Marine Mammals: Biology and Conservation (2002), Kluwer Academic, New York 293-324
16. Gould, J.C., Coates, R.F.W., 2006. Near Source, high frequency air-gun signatures. In: Paper Presented to the Scientific Committee at the 58th Meeting of the International Whaling Commission, 26 May-6 June 2006, St. Kitts, SC58/E30.
17. Gould J.C., and Fish P.J. Broadband spectra of seismic survey air-gun emissions, with reference to dolphin auditory thresholds. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 103 (1998) 2177-2184
18. International Whaling Commission. Report of the standing working group on environmental concerns. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 9 Suppl. (2007) 227-296
19. Jepson P.D., Arbelo M., Deaville R., Patterson I.A.P., Castro P., Baker J.R., Degollada E., Ross H.M., Herráez P., Pocknell A.M., Rodríguez F., Howiell F.E., Espinosa A., Reid R.J., Jaber J.R., Martin V., Cunningham A.A., and Fernández A. Gas-bubble lesions in stranded cetaceans: was sonar responsible for a spate of whale deaths after an Atlantic military exercise?. Nature 425 (2003) 575-576
20. JNCC (Joint Nature Conservation Committee), 2004. Guidelines for minimizing acoustic disturbance to marine mammals from seismic surveys. Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough. .
21. JNCC (Joint Nature Conservation Committee), 2008. The deliberate disturbance of marine European Protected Species. Guidance for English and Welsh territorial waters and the UK offshore marine area. Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough. .
22. Koschinski S., Culik B.M., Henriksen O.D., Tregenza N., Ellis G., Jansen C., and Kathe G. Behavioural reactions of free-ranging porpoises and seals to the noise of a simulated 2 MW windpower generator. Marine Ecology Progress Series 265 (2003) 263-273
23. MacKenzie D. Seismic surveys may kill giant squid. New Scientist 184 2467 (2004) 15
24. MacLeod K., Simmonds M.P., and Murray E. Abundance of fin (Balaenoptera physalus) and sei whales (B. borealis) amid oil exploration and development off northwest Scotland. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 8 (2006) 247-254
25. Madsen P.T., Johnson M., Miller P.J.O., Aguilar Soto N., Lynch J., and Tyack P. Quantative measures of air gun pulses recorded on sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus) using acoustic tags during controlled exposure experiments. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 120 (2006) 2366-2379
26. McCauley, R.D., Duncan, A.J., 2001. Marine Acoustic Effects Study, Blue Whale Feeding Aggregations, Otway Basin, Bass Strait Victoria. Project CMST 319. Report R2001-7.
27. McCauley R., Jenner M., Jenner C., McCabe K., and Murdoch J. The response of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) to offshore seismic survey: preliminary results of observations about a working seismic vessel and experimental exposures. APPEA Journal 692 (1998) 706
28. McCauley R.D., Fewtrell J., Duncan A.J., Jenner C., Jenner M.-N., Penrose J.D., Prince R.I.T., Adhitya A., Murdich J., and McCabe K. Marine seismic surveys - a study of environmental implications. APPEA Journal 692 (2000) 708
29. McCauley R.D., Fewtrell J., and Popper A.N. High intensity anthropogenic sound damages fish ears. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 113 (2003) 638-642
30. Miller G.W., Moulton V.D., Davis R.A., Holst M., Millman P., MacGillivray A., and Hannay D. Monitoring seismic effects on marine mammals-southeastern Beaufort Sea, 2001-2002. In: Armsworthy S.L., Cranford P.J., and Lee K. (Eds). Offshore Oil and Gas Environmental Effects Monitoring: Approaches and Technologies (2005), Battelle Press, Columbus, Ohio 511-542
31. National Research Council. Low-Frequency Sound and Marine Mammals. Current Knowledge and Research Needs (1994), National Academies Press, Washington, DC
32. Nieukirk S.L., Stafford K.M., Mellinger D.K., Dziak R.P., and Fox C.G. Low-frequency whale and seismic airgun sounds recorded in the mid-Atlantic Ocean. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 115 (2004) 1832-1843
33. Nowacek D.P., Johnson M.P., and Tyack P.L. Right whales ignore ships but respond to alarm stimuli. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 271 (2004) 227-231
34. Parente C.L., de Araújo J.P., and de Araújo M.E. Diversity of cetaceans as a tool in monitoring environmental impacts of seismic surveys. Biota Neotropica 7 (2007) 1-7
35. Parsons E.C.M., Dolman S., Wright A.J., Rose N.A., and Burns W.C.G. Navy sonar and cetaceans: just how much does the gun need to smoke before we act?. Marine Pollution Bulletin 56 (2008) 1248-1257
36. Rachlinski J.J. Protecting endangered species without regulating private land owners: the case of endangered plants. Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 8 (1998) 1-36
37. Richardson W.J., Greene C.R., Malme C.I., and Thomson D.H. Marine Mammals and Noise (1995), Academic Press, San Diego 576p
38. Richardson W.J., Miller G.W., and Greene C.R. Displacement of migrating bowhead whales by sounds from seismic surveys in shallow waters of the Beaufort Sea. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 106 (1999) 2281
39. Rivera J., and de Leon P. Is greener whiter? Voluntary environmental performance of western ski areas. The Policy Studies Journal 32 (2004) 417-437
40. Simmonds M.P., and Isaac S.J. The impact of climate change on marine mammals: early signs of significant problems. Oryx 41 (2007) 19-26
41. Simmonds M., and Lopez-Jurado L.F. Whales and the military. Nature 337 (1991) 448
42. Stone, C.J., 1997. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1996. JNCC Report 228, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
43. Stone, C.J., 1998. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1998. JNCC Report 278, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
44. Stone, C.J., 2000. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1998. JNCC Report 301, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
45. Stone, C.J., 2003a. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1998-2000. JNCC Report 323, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
46. Stone, C.J., 2003b. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 1999. JNCC Report 316, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
47. Stone, C.J., 2003c. The Effects of Seismic Activities on Marine Mammals in UK Waters 2000. JNCC Report 322, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
48. Stone, C.J., 2006. Marine Mammal Observations During Seismic Surveys in 2001 and 2002. JNCC Report 359, Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
49. Stone C.J., and Tasker M.L. The effects of seismic airguns on cetaceans in UK waters. Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 8 (2006) 255-263
50. Tolstoy M., Diebold J.B., Webb S.C., Bohnenstiehl D.R., Chapp E., Holmes R.C., and Rawson M. Broadband calibration of R/V ewing seismic sources. Geophysical Research Letters 31 L14310 (2004) 1-4
51. Tyack P.L., Johnson M., Aguilar Soto N., Sturlese A., and Madsen P.T. Extreme diving of beaked whales. Journal of Experimental Biology 209 (2006) 4238-4253
52. Wakefield, 2001. The vocal behaviour and distribution of the short-beaked common dolphin Delphinus delphis L. (1785) in the Celtic Sea and adjacent waters, with particular reference to the effects of seismic surveying. MSc Thesis. School of Ocean Sciences, University of Wales, Bangor.
53. Watkins W.A., and Schevill W.E. Sperm whales (Physeter catodon) react to pingers. Deep Sea Research 22 (1975) 123-129
54. Watkins W.A., Moore K.E., and Tyack P. Investigations of sperm whale acoustic behaviors in the southeast Caribbean. Cetology 49 (1985) 1-15
55. Weilgart L.S. The impacts of anthropogenic ocean noise on cetaceans and implications for management. Canadian Journal of Zoology 85 (2007) 1091-1116
56. Weir C.R., and Dolman S.J. Comparative review of the regional marine mammal mitigation guidelines implemented during industrial seismic surveys, and guidance towards a worldwide standard. Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy 10 (2007) 1-27
57. Wier C.R. Short-Finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus) respond to an airgun ramp-up procedure off Gabon. Aquatic Mammals 34 (2008) 349-354
58. Wier C.R. Overt responses of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae), sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus), and Atlantic spotted dolphins (Stenella frontalis) to seismic exploration off Angola. Aquatic Mammals 34 (2008) 71-83
59. Wiley D.N., Moller J.C., Pace R.M., and Carlson C. Effectiveness of voluntary conservation agreements: case study of endangered whales and commercial whale watching. Conservation Biology 22 (2008) 451-457
60. Wintle B.A. Adaptive management, population modelling and uncertainty analysis for assessing the impacts of noise on cetacean populations. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 20 (2007) 237-249
61. Wright A.J., Aguilar Soto N., Baldwin A.L., Bateson M., Beale C., Clark C., Deak T., Edwards E.F., Fernández A., Godinho A., Hatch L., Kakuschke A., Lusseau D., Martineau D., Romero L.M., Weilgart L., Wintle B., Notarbartolo di Sciara G., and Martin V. Anthropogenic noise as a stressor in animals: a multidisciplinary perspective. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 20 (2007) 250-273
62. Wright A.J., Aguilar Soto N., Baldwin A.L., Bateson M., Beale C., Clark C., Deak T., Edwards E.F., Fernández A., Godinho A., Hatch L., Kakuschke A., Lusseau D., Martineau D., Romero L.M., Weilgart L., Wintle B., Notarbartolo di Sciara G., and Martin V. Do marine mammals experience stress related to anthropogenic noise?. International Journal of Comparative Psychology 20 (2007) 274-316