Progress towards and barriers to implementation of a risk framework for US federal wildland fire policy and decision making

Forest Policy and Economics

Volumn 13, Issue 5, 2011, Pages 378-389

  Calkin, David C ^a   Finney, Mark A ^a   Ager, Alan A ^b   Thompson, Matthew P ^a   Gebert, Krista M ^a  

^a ROCKY MOUNTAIN RESEARCH STATION   (United States)

^b USDA FOREST SERVICE   (United States)

Author keywords

Decision support; Risk management; Wildfire; Wildfire policy

Indexed keywords

ANALYTICAL METHOD; DECISION SUPPORTS; FEDERAL AGENCY; FUEL TREATMENTS; INVESTMENT STRATEGY; LOCAL SCALE; MANAGEMENT DECISIONS; MULTIPLE OBJECTIVES; PUBLIC LANDS; RISK MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK; RISK-BASED DECISIONS; WILDFIRE; WILDFIRE MANAGEMENT; WILDFIRE POLICY; WILDFIRE SIMULATION; WILDLAND FIRE;

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE; DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS; FIRE HAZARDS; FIRES; LAND USE; RISK ANALYSIS; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK MANAGEMENT;

DECISION MAKING;

EID: 79957562537     PISSN: 13899341     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.forpol.2011.02.007     Document Type: Article

References (86)

1. Agee J.K., Bahro B., Finney M.A., Omi P.N., Sapsis D.B., Skinner C.N., van Wagtendonk J.W., Weatherspoon C.P. The use of shaded fuelbreaks in landscape fire management. Forest Ecology and Management 2000, 127:55-66.
2. Ager A.A., Vaillant N., Finney M.A. A comparison of landscape fuel treatment strategies to mitigate wildland fire risk in the urban interface and preserve old forest structure. Forest Ecology and Management 2010, 259:1556-1570.
3. Ager A.A., Finney M.A., Bahro B. Using ArcObjects for automating fireshed assessments and analyzing wildfire risk 2006, http://gis.esri.com/library/userconf/proc06/papers/papers/pap_1547.pdf.
4. Ager A.A., Bahro B., Finney M.A. Automating fireshed assessments and analyzing wildfire risk with ArcObjects and ArcGIS. Forest Ecology and Management 2006, 234S:215.
5. Ager A.A., Finney M.A., Kerns B.K., Maffei H. Modeling wildfire risk to northern spotted owl (Strix occidentalis caurina) habitat in Central Oregon, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 2007, 246:45-56.
6. Andrews P.L., Loftsgaarden D.O., Bradshaw L.S. Evaluation of fire danger rating indexes using logistic regression and percentile analysis. International Journal of Wildland Fire 2003, 12:213-226.
7. Andrews P.L., Finney M.A., Fischetti M. Modeling wildland fires. Scientific American 2007, 297(2):32-39.
8. Bahro B., Barber K., Perrot L., Sherlock J., Taylor A., Wright K., Yasuda D. Using fireshed assessments to measure landscape performance 2006, Portland, Oregon. Abstract. http://www.iawfonline.org/pdf/overview-shtml.pdf.
9. Black A., Gebert K., Steelman T., McCaffrey S., Canton-Thompson J., Stalling C. The interplay of AMR, suppression costs, agency-communication interaction, and organizational performance - a multi-disciplinary approach. Joint Fire Science Program Final Report 08-1-4-01 2010.
10. Black A., Opperman T. Fire Effects Planning Framework: a user's guide. Gen.Tech. Rep.GTR-RMRS-163WWW 2005, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, CO, 63 p.
11. Boyd J. What's nature worth? Using indicators to open the black box of ecological valuation. Resources for Future. Summer 2004, 18-22.
12. Calkin, D., Ager, A., Gilbertson-Day, J., Scott, J., Finney, M., Schrader-Patton, C., Quigley, T., Strittholt, J., Kaiden, J., 2010. Wildland Fire Risk and Hazard: Procedures for the First Approximation. RMRS-GTR-235. 62 p.
13. Calkin, D.E., Thompson, M.P., Finney, M.A., Hyde, K.D., in press. A real-time risk-assessment tool supporting wildland fire decision-making. Journal of Forestry.
14. Calkin D., Jones G., Hyde K. Nonmarket resource valuation in the postfire environment. Journal of Forestry 2008, 106(6):305-310.
15. Canton-Thompson J., Gebert K.M., Thompson B., Jones G., Calkin D., Donovan G. External Human Factors in Incident Management Team Decision making and Their Effect on Large Fire Suppression Expenditures. Journal of Forestry 2008, 106(8):416-424.
16. Chuvieco E., Aguado I., Yebra M., Nieto H., Salas J., Martín M.P., Vilar L., Martínez J., Martín S., Ibarra P., de la Riva J., Baeza J., Rodríguez F., Molina J.R., Herrera M.A., Zamora R. Development of a framework for fire risk assessment using remote sensing and geographic information system technologies. Ecological Modeling 2010, 221:46-58.
17. Cohen, J.D., 1999. Reducing the Wildland Fire Threat to Homes: Where and how much? USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PSW-GTR-173. Pp. 189-195 in A. Gonzalez-Caban and P. N. Omi (tech. coords.), Proceedings of the symposium on fire economics, planning, and policy: bottom lines.
18. Department of Interior Geological Survey, 2009. The National Map LANDFIRE: LANDFIRE National Existing Vegetation Type layer. Retrieved May 5, 2009, http://www.landfire.gov/.
19. Dimopoulou M., Giannikos I. Towards and integrated framework for forest fire control. European Journal of Operational Research 2004, 152:476-486.
20. Dombeck M.P., Williams J.E., Wood C.A. Wildfire policy and public lands: integrating scientific understanding with social concerns across landscapes. Conservation Biology 2004, 18(4):883-889.
21. Dixon G.E., et al. Essential FVS: a user's guide to the Forest Vegetation Simulator. Internal Rep. Fort Collins, CO: USDA, Forest Service, Forest Management Service Center 2003, 193 p.
22. Dombeck M.P., Williams J.E., Wood C.A. Wildfire Policy and Public Lands: Integrating Scientific Understanding with Social Concerns across Landscapes. Conservation Biology 2004, 18(4):883-889.
23. Doan D., O'Lauglin J., Morgan P., Miller C. Barriers to wildland fire use: a preliminary problem analysis. International Journal of Wilderness 2006, 12:36-38.
24. Donovan G.H., Brown T.C. An alternative incentive structure for wildfire management on national forest land. Forest Science 2005, 51(5):387-395.
25. Donovan G.H., Noordijk P. Assessing the Accuracy of Wildland Fire Situation Analysis (WFSA) Fire Size and Suppression Cost Estimates. Journal of Forestry 2005, 103(1):10-13.
26. Donovan G.H., Brown T.C. Be careful what you wish for: the legacy of Smokey the Bear. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2007, 5(2):73-79.
27. Donovan G.H., Prestemon J.P., Gebert K. The effect of newspaper coverage and political pressure on wildfire suppression costs. Society and Natural Resources 2011, 10.1080/08941921003649482.
28. Fairbrother A., Turnley J.G. Predicting risks of uncharacteristic wildfires: application of the risk assessment process. Forest Ecology and Management 2005, 211:28-35.
29. Finney M.A. Fire growth using minimum travel time methods. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 2002, 32(8):1420-1424.
30. Finney M.A. The challenge of quantitative risk assessment for wildland fire. Forest Ecology and Management 2005, 211:97-108.
31. Finney M.A. An overview of FlamMap fire modeling capabilities. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report RMRS-P-41 2006, 213-220.
32. Finney M.A., Seli R.C., McHugh C.W., Ager A.A., Barho B., Agee J.K. Simulation of long-term landscape-level fuel treatment effects on large wildfires. International Journal of Wildland Fire 2007, 16(6):712-727.
33. Finney M.A., Grenfell A.C., McHugh C.W., Seli R.C., Trethewey D., Stratton R.D., Brittain S. A method for ensemble wildland fire simulation. Environmental Modeling and Assessement 2011, 16(2):153-167.
34. Finney M.A., McHugh C.W., Grenfell I.C., Riley K.L., Short K.C. A simulation of probabilistic wildfire risk components for the continental United States. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment 2011, 10.1007/s00477-011-0462-z.
35. Finney, M.A. In press. Simulation of burn probabilities and fire size distributions for the continental United States. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment.
36. Finney M.A., Grenfell I.C., McHugh C.W. Modeling large fire containment using generalized linear mixed model analysis. Forest Science 2009, 55(3):249-255.
37. Fire Executive Council Guidance for Implementation of Federal Wildland Fire Management Policy 2009, Last Accessed May 28, 2010. http://www.nifc.gov/policies/guidance/GIFWFMP.pdf.
38. Fire Program Analysis Fire Program Analysis website Last accessed April 12, 2010. http://www.fpa.nifc.gov/.
39. Government Accountability Office (GAO) Wildland Fire Management: Federal Agencies Have Taken Important Steps Forward, but Additional Action is Needed to Address Remaining Challenges. GAO-09-906-T 2009, Washington, D.C., July 21, 2009.
40. Gonzalez-Caban A., MacGregor D.G. Improving decision making process for the Forest Service Wildland Fire Situation Analysis. In Proceedings: Third International Conference on Forest Fire Research 1998, Luso, Portugal, November 16-20.
41. Gude P., Rasker R., Van den Noort J. Potential for future development on fire prone lands. Journal of Forestry 2008, 106:198-205.
42. Hummel S., Calkin D.E. Costs of landscape silviculture for fire and habitat management. Forest Ecology and Management 2005, 207(3):385-404.
43. Havis R.N., Crookston N.L., et al. Third forest vegetation simulator conference. 2007 February 13-15; Fort Collins, CO. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Proceedings RMRS-P-54 2008, Fort Collins, CO: 234 p.
44. Hessburg P.F., Reynolds K.M., Keane R.E., James K.M., Salter R.B. Evaluating wildland fire danger and prioritizing vegetation and fuel treatments. Forest Ecology and Management 2007, 247:1-17.
45. Iliadis L.S. A decision support system applying an integrated fuzzy model for long-term forest fire risk estimation. Environmental Modelling and Software 2005, 20(5):613-621.
46. Irwin L.L., Wigley T.B. Relative risk assessments for decision-making related to uncharacteristic wildfire. Forest Ecology and Management 2005, 211(1-2):1-2.
47. Keane R.E., Agee J.K., Fule P., Keeley J.E., Key C., Kitchen S.G., Miller R., Schulte L.A. Ecological effects of large fires on US landscapes: benefit or catastrophe?. International Journal of Wildland Fire 2008, 17:696-712.
48. Kennedy, J.J., Haynes, R.H., Zhou, X., 2005. Line Officers' Views on Stated USDA Forest Service Values and the Agency Reward System. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-632.
49. Kerns B., Ager A.A. Risk assessment for biodiversity in Pacific Northwest forests. Forest Ecology and Management 2007, 246:38-44.
50. Keyes C.R., O'Hara K.L. Quantifying stand targets for silvicultural prevention of crown fires. Western Journal of Applied Forestry 2002, 17:101-109.
51. Kim Y.-H., Bettinger P., Finney M. Spatial optimization of the pattern of fuel management activities and subsequent effects on simulated wildfires. European Journal of Operational Research. 2009, 197:253-265.
52. Konoshima M., Albers H.J., Montgomery C.A., Arthur J.L. Optimal spatial patterns of fuel management and timber harvest with fire risk. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 2010, 40(1):95-108.
53. LaCroix J.J., Ryu S.R., Zheng D., Chen J. Simulating fire spread with landscape management scenarios. Forest Science 2006, 52:522-529.
54. Landkoande M., Yoder J., Wandschneider P. Optimal wildfire insurance in the wildland-urban interface in the presence of a government subsidy for fire risk mitigation Available at:, accessed 1/4/2011. http://ideas.repec.org/p/wsu/wpaper/yoder-9.html.
55. Lehmkuhl J.F., Kennedy M., Ford D.E., Singleton P.H., Gaines W.L., Lind R.L. Seeing the forest for the fuel: integrating ecological values and fuels management. Forest Ecology and Management 2007, 246:73-80.
56. Loureiro C., Fernandes P., Botelho H., Mateus P. A simulation test of a landscape fuel management project in the Marao range of northern Portugal. Forest Ecology and Management 2006, 234S:S245.
57. Massada A.B., Radeloff V.C., Stewart S.I., Hawbaker T.J. Wildfire risk in the wildland-urban interface: a simulation study in northwestern Wisconsin. Forest Ecology and Management 2009, 258:1990-1999.
58. McDaniel J. When things get busy: FSPro and RAVAR. Wildfire Magazine Fall 2006 2006, Available at:. http://www.wildfirelessons.net/Additional.aspx?Page=83.
59. McDaniel J. WFDSS: taking decision support into the 21st century. Wildfire Magazine Fall 2007 2007, Available at:. http://www.wildfirelessons.net/Additional.aspx?Page=96.
60. McDaniel J. The emergence and potential of new wildfire risk assessment tools wildfire lessons learned. Fall 2009 2009, Available at:, Accessed 12/15/10. http://www.wildfirelessons.net/Additional.aspx?Page=285.
61. McGaughey R.J. Creating visual simulations of fuel conditions predicted by the fire and fuels extension to the Forest Vegetation Simulator 2002, USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, CO. N.L. Crookston, R.N. Havis (Eds.).
62. Murnane R.J. Catastrophe risk models for wildfires in the wildland-urban interface: what insurers need. Natural Hazards Review 2006, 7:150-156.
63. O'Laughlin J. Conceptual model for comparative ecological risk assessment of wildfire effects on fish, with and without hazardous fuel treatment. Forest Ecology and Management 2005, 211:59-72.
64. Parisien, M-A, Kafka, V., Hirsch, K.G., Todd, J.B., Lavoie, S.G., Maczek, P.D., 2005. Mapping wildfire susceptibility with the BURN-P3 simulation model. Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service, Northern Forestry Centre, Edmonton. Northern Forestry Centre Information Report NOR-X-405. 36 pp.
65. Peterson D.L., Evers L., Gravenmier B., Eberhardt E. A consumer guide: tools to manage vegetation and fuels. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report PNW-GTR-690 2007, Pacific Northwest Research Station, Portland, OR.
66. Peterson R.M., Robertson F.D., Thomas J.W., Dombeck M.P., Bosworth D.N. Statement of R. Max Peterson, F. Dale Robertson, Jack Ward Thomas, Michael P. Dombeck, and Dale N. Bosworth, Retired Chiefs of the Forest Service, on the FY2008 Appropriation for the U.S. Forest Service 2008, Available at:, Last accessed 05 November 2009. http://www.arborday.org/replanting/firechiefs.cfm.
67. Prestemon J.P., Abt K., Gebert K. Suppression cost forecasts in advance of wildfire seasons. Forest Science 2008, 54(4):381-396.
68. Reinhardt E.D., Keane R.E., Calkin D.E., Cohen J.D. Objectives and considerations for wildland fuel treatment in forested ecosystems of the interior western United States. Forest Ecology and Management 2008, 256:1997-2006.
69. Reinhardt, E.D., Keane, R.E., Brown, J.K., 1997. First-order fire effects model:FOFEM 4.0 users guide. General Technical Report INT-GTR-344, USDA Forest Service.
70. Rideout D.B., Ziesler P.S., Kling R., Loomis J.B., Botti S.J. Estimating rates of substitution for protecting values at risk for initial attack planning and budgeting. Forest Policy and Economics 2008, 10:205-219.
71. Roloff G.J., Mealey S.P., Clay C., Barry J., Yanish C., Neuenschwander L. A process for modeling short- and long-term risk in the southern Oregon Cascades. Forest Ecol. Manag. 2005, 211:166-190.
72. Ryu S.R., Chen J., Zheng D., LaCroix J.J. Relating surface fire spread to landscape structure: An application of FARSITE in a managed forest landscape Landscape and Urban Planning 2007, 83:275-283.
73. Schmidt D.A., Taylor A.H., Skinner C.N. The influence of fuels treatment and landscape arrangement on simulated fire behavior, Southern Cascade range. California. Forest Ecology and Management 2008, 255:3170-3184.
74. Stephens S.L., Moghaddas J.J., Edminster C., Fiedler C.E., Haase S., Harrington M., Keeley J.E., Knapp E.E., McIver J.D., Metlen K., Skinner C.N., Youngblood A. Fire treatment effects on vegetation structure, fuels, and potential fire severity in western U.S. forests. Ecological Applications 2009, 19:305-320.
75. Stratton R.D. Assessing the effectiveness of landscape fuel treatments on fire growth and behavior. Journal of Forestry 2004, 102:32-40.
76. Thompson, M.P., Calkin, D.E., Gilbertson-Day, J.W., Ager, A.A., In Press (a). Advancing effects analysis for integrated, large-scale wildfire risk assessment. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. Available at: http://www.springerlink.com/content/652j815302ml3x7k/.
77. Thompson, M.P., Calkin, D.E., Finney, M.A., Ager, A., Gilbertson-Day, J.W., In Press (b). Integrated National-Scale Assessment of Wildfire Risk to Human and Ecological Values. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment.
78. Thompson, M.P., Calkin, D.E., Finney, M.A., In Press (c). Addressing sources of uncertainty in strategic wildland fire planning. Journal of Environmental Management June 3, 2010.
79. Thompson, M.P., Calkin, D.E., Finney, M.A., Gebert, K., (in review). A risk-based premium approach to wildland fire finance and planning. Forest Science.
80. USDA Forest Service Fire and Aviation Management Fiscal Year 2008 Accountability Report 2009, 45 pp.
81. USDA Forest Service Budget Summaries, Justifications, Overviews for FY2004-2011 for the U.S. Forest Service 2010, Accessed on August 5, 2010. http://www.fs.fed.us/aboutus/budget/.
82. Vadrevu K.P., Eaturu A., Badarinath K.V.S. Fire risk evaluation using multicriteria analysis - a case study. Environmental Modeling and Assessment 2009, 10.1007/s10661-009-0997-3.
83. Venn T.J., Calkin D.E. Challenges of socio-economically evaluating wildfire management on non-industrial private and public forestland in the western United States. Small-scale Forestry 2009, 8:43-61.
84. Venn, T.J., Calkin, D.E., In Press. Accommodating non-market values in evaluation of wildfire management in the United States: challenges and opportunities. International Journal of Wildland Fire.
85. Wei Y., Rideout D., Kirsch A. An optimization model for locating fuel treatments across a landscape to reduce expected fire losses. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 2008, 38:868-877.
86. Williamson M.A. Factors in United States Forest Service district rangers' decision to manage a fire for resource benefit. International Journal of Wildland Fire 2007, 16(6):755-762.