The "Empty-Shell" Approach: The Setup Process of International Administrations in Timor-Leste and Kosovo, Its Consequences and Lessons

International Studies Perspectives

Volumn 12, Issue 2, 2011, Pages 190-211

  Lemay Hebert, Nicolas ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITÉ DU QUÉBEC À MONTRÉAL   (Canada)

Author keywords

International administration; Intervention; Kosovo; State building; Timor Leste

Indexed keywords

ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT; MARGINALIZATION; POLICY APPROACH; POST-WAR; STATE BUILDING; UNITED NATIONS;

KOSOVO; LESSER SUNDA ISLANDS; SERBIA; SUNDA ISLES; TIMOR; TIMOR-LESTE;

EID: 79955762874     PISSN: 15283577     EISSN: 15283585     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1528-3585.2011.00427.x     Document Type: Article

References (120)

1. ABC [Transcript]. (1999) World Bank Release Plan for Rebuilding East Timor. November 18.
2. Abdela, L. (2003) Kosovo: Missed Opportunities, Lessons for the Future. Development in Practice 13: 208-216.
3. Alford, P. (2000) Rebuilding E Timor is Proving a Thankless Task. The Australian, June 27.
4. Barker, R. (1990) Political Legitimacy and the State. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
5. Beauvais, J. (2001) Benevolent Despotism: A Critique of UN State-Building in East Timor. New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 33: 1101-1178.
6. Berdal, M., and R. Caplan (2004) The Politics of International Administration. Security Governance 10: 1-5.
7. Blair, S. (2002) Weaving the Strands of the Rope. Dalhousie: Centre for Foreign Policy Studies.
8. Braga, I. (2000) Timorese Structures Secondary. Público, December 12.
9. Brahimi, L. (2005) L'ONU entre nécessité et minimalisme [The UN Between Necessity and Minimalism]. Politique Etrangère 2: 297-311.
10. Brand, M. (2003) The Development of Kosovo Institutions and the Transition of Authority from UNMIK to Local Self-Government. Geneva: CASIN Report.
11. Caplan, R. (2005) International Governance of War-Torn Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12. Chesterman, S. (2001) A Nation Waits. The World Today 57: 25-27.
13. Chesterman, S. (2002) Justice Under International Administration: Kosovo, East Timor and Afghanistan. New York: International Peace Academy Report.
14. Chesterman, S. (2004) You, The People: The United Nations, Transitional Administration, and State-Building. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
15. Chesterman, S. (2007) East Timor. In United Nations Interventionism 1991-2004, edited by M. Berdal, and S. Economides Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
16. Chopra, J. (2000) The UN's Kingdom of East Timor. Survival 42: 27-39.
17. Chopra, J. (2002) Building State Failure in East Timor. Development and Change 33: 979-1000.
18. Chopra, J., and T. Hohe (2004) Participatory Intervention. Global Governance 10: 289-305.
19. Clausen, L. (2005) East Timor Judges Fail their Test. TIME, February 8.
20. Cohen, D. (2002) Seeking Justice on the Cheap: Is the East Timorese Tribunal Really a Model for the Future? Asia Pacific Issues 61: 1-8.
21. Conflict Security and Development Group. (2003) A Review of Peace Operations: A Case for Change, Synthesis Report. London: King's College.
22. Corcoran, B. (2000) Temperature Rises in East Timor as UN Digs In. The Sunday Tribune, June 18.
23. Covey, J. (2005) Making a Viable Peace: Moderating Political Conflict. In The Quest for Viable Peace: International Intervention and Strategies for Conflict Transformation, edited by J. Covey, M. Dziedzic and L. Hawley Washington: United States Institute of Peace.
24. Cristalis, I. (2002) Bitter Dawn: East Timor, A People's Story. London: Zed Books.
25. Crossette, B. (1999) Annan Says UN Must Take Over East Timor Rule. The New York Times, October 6.
26. Cunha, R. (2008) EULEX Inside UNMIK, Too Late? ObservatorioBalcani e Caucaso, April 23. Available at (Accessed June 9, 2009.)
27. Dodd, M. (2000a) UN Staff Battle Over East Timor's Independence Policy. Sydney Morning Herald, March 13.
28. Dodd, M. (2000b) UN Peace Mission at War With Itself. Sydney Morning Herald, May 13.
29. Dodd, M. (2000c) Gusmão Gives UN Team a Serve: 'We Don't Want a Legacy of Cars'. Sydney Morning Herald, October 10.
30. Dodd, M. (2000d) Give Us a Free Hand or We Quit. Sydney Morning Herald, December 5.
31. Dodd, M. (2000e) East Timor Gets Ready for Tricky Birth. Sydney Morning Herald, December 13.
32. Dodd, M. (2001) People to Have Their Say-But So Will the UN. Sydney Morning Herald, June 29.
33. Dolinski, L. (2000) Timor Peace also has Discontents. The San Francisco Chronicle, December 8.
34. Dos Reis, M. (2003) Reconstruction in East Timor-Critical Issues on UNTAET. La'oHamutuk Research Note. Available at (Accessed June 8, 2009.)
35. Dunn, J. (2000) UNTAET After Nine Months. Asian Analysis. Available at (Accessed June 8, 2009.)
36. Dunn, J. (2003) East Timor: A Rough Passage to Independence. New South Wales: Longueville.
37. Elrich, R. (2000) Rebuilding East Timor. St. Petersburgh Times, June 16.
38. Fointuna, Y. (2002) Unemployment a Major Problem Plaguing East Timor. The Jakarta Post, March 28.
39. Fox, J. (2001) East Timor: Assessing UNTAET's Role in Building Local Capacities for the Future. Paper Presented at the Council for Asia Europe Co-operation Conference, "Comparing Experiences with State Building in Asia and Europe: the Cases of East Timor, Bosnia and Kosovo, "Bali, October.
40. Franks, J., and O. Richmond (2008) Coopting Liberal Peace-Building: Untying the Gordian Knot in Kosovo. Cooperation and Conflict 43: 81-103.
41. Friedrich, J. (2005) UNMIK in Kosovo: Struggling with Uncertainty. Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 9: 225-293.
42. Goldstone, R. (2002) Whither Kosovo? Whither Democracy? Global Governance 8: 143-147.
43. Goldstone, A. (2004) UNTAET with Hindsight: The Peculiarities of Politics in an Incomplete State. Global Governance 10: 83-98.
44. Höfer-Wissing, N. (2002) UNMIK Holds on to a Share of Power. Focus Kosovo, February 11.
45. Hohe, T. (2004) Local Governance After Conflict: Community Empowerment in East Timor. Journal of Peacekeeping and Development 1: 45-56.
46. Hohe, T., and R. Nixon (2003) Reconciling Justice: 'Traditional' Law and State Judiciary in East Timor. Report prepared for the United States Institute of Peace [on file with authors].
47. Hughes, C., and V. Pupavac (2005) Framing Post-Conflict Societies: International Pathologisation of Cambodia and the Post-Yugoslav States. Third World Quarterly 26: 873-889.
48. Independent International Commission on Kosovo. (2000) Kosovo Report: Conflict, International Response, Lessons Learned. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
49. Independent International Commission on Kosovo. (2001) The Follow-Up of the Kosovo Report: Why Conditional Independence? Solna: Tryckeriet Åsbrink Grafiska.
50. International Crisis Group. (1999a) Kosovo: Let's Learn from Bosnia: Models and Methods of International Administration. Balkans Report No. 66, May 17.
51. International Crisis Group. (1999b) The New Kosovo Protectorate. Balkans Report No. 69, June 20.
52. International Crisis Group. (2001) Kosovo: Landmark Election. Balkans Report No. 120, November 21.
53. Joly, J. (2000) Respect for UN Mission is Falling, Warns Local Adviser. South China Morning Post, March 15.
54. Kaldor, M. (2000) Governance, Legitimacy, and Security: Three Scenarios for the Twenty-First Century. In Principled World Politics, edited by P. Wapner, and E. Ruiz Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
55. Kaminski, M. (1999) UN Struggles with a Legal Vacuum in Kosovo: Team Improvises in Effort to Build a Civil Structure. Wall Street Journal, August 4.
56. Kerr, R., and E. Mobekk (2007) Peace and Justice: Seeking Accountability After War. London: Polity.
57. Kifner, J. (1999) Laying Claim to Govern in the Ruins of Kosovo. The New York Times, July 16.
58. King, S. (2000) Discrimination in East Timor. Green Left Weekly, 19 February.
59. King, I., and W. Mason (2006) Peace at Any Price: How the World Failed Kosovo. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
60. Knezevic, N. (2005) Timor-Leste: Background Paper on Human Rights, Refugees and Asylum Seekers. AWritenet Report commissioned by the UNHCR. Available at: (Accessed April 8, 2011.)
61. Knoll, B. (2007) Legitimacy and UN Administration of Territory. Journal of International Law and Policy 4: 1-15.
62. Lederach, J. P. (1995) Preparing for Peace: Conflict Transformation Across Cultures. New York: Syracuse University Press.
63. Lemay-Hébert, N. (2009a) Statebuilding Without Nationbuilding? Legitimacy, State Failure and the Limits of the Institutionalist Approach. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 3: 21-45.
64. Lemay-Hébert, N. (2009b) State-Building from the Outside-In: UNMIK and its Paradox. Journal of Public and International Affairs 20: 65-86.
65. Lusa. (2000) East Timor: Parties Must Prove They 'Really Prepared' for Independence, December 5.
66. Marshall, D., and S. Inglis (2003) The Disempowerment of Human Rights-Based Justice in the United Nations Mission in Kosovo. Harvard Human Rights Journal 16: 95-146.
67. Martin, I., and A. Mayer-Rieckh (2005) The United Nations and East Timor: From Self-Determination to State-Building. International Peacekeeping 12: 125-145.
68. Mearns, D. (2001) Variations on a Theme: Coalitions of Authority in East Timor. A Report on the Local and National Justice Systems as a Basis for Dispute Resolution. Report for Australian Legal Resources International with the Assistance of the Australian Agency for International Development.
69. Melkert, A. (2007) Peut-on Encore Sauver le Kosovo [Can We Still Save Kosovo]? Le Figaro, August 11.
70. Mertus, J. (2001) The Impact of Intervention on Local Human Rights Culture: A Kosovo Case Study. The Global Review of Ethnopolitics 1: 21-36.
71. Murphy, D. (2001) UN Makes Feeble Timor Midwife. Christian Science Monitor, February 14.
72. Mydans, S. (2000) Emerging from its Crisis, East Timor Rebuilds. The New York Times, October 18.
73. Narten, J. (2006) Building Local Institutions and Parliamentarism in Post-War Kosovo: A Review of Joint Efforts by the UN and the OSCE from 1999-2006. Helsinki Monitor 17: 144-159.
74. Nixon, R. (2006) The Crisis of Governance in New Subsistence States. Journal of Contemporary Asia 36: 75-101.
75. Norling, T. (1999) Past, Present, Future: East Timor's Leader Speaks Out. Taipei Times, November 13.
76. Ospina, S., and T. Hohe (2001) Traditional Power Structures and the Community Empowerment and Local Governance Project. Final Report Presented to CEP/PMU, ETTA/UNTAET and the World Bank.
77. Poppen, J. (2005) Prospects for Securing Peace in Haiti Look Bleak. Jane's Intelligence Review, May 23.
78. Power, S. (2008) Chasing the Flame: Sergio Vieira de Mello and the Fight to Save the World. New York: Penguin Press.
79. Priest, D., and B. Graham (1999) NATO Faces Daunting Task of Governing Kosovo. The Washington Post, June 19.
80. RDP Antena 1 [Transcript]. (2000) Unhappy East Timorese Leaders Threaten to Resign from Interim Administration. December 2.
81. Reuters. (2002) Almost Half of East Timor Go Hungry: Survey. March 6.
82. Riley, M. (2000a) Selfish Bureaucrats Ruining East Timor, Says Ex-UN Planner. Sydney Morning Herald, May 6.
83. Riley, M. (2000b) Time for UN to Go: Timor Leaders. Sydney Morning Herald, May 24.
84. Salamun, M. (2005) Democratic Governance in International Territorial Administration. Baden-Baden: Nomos-Verlagsges.
85. Smith, M., and M. Dee (2003) Peacekeeping in East Timor: The Path to Independence. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
86. Sohlstrom, T. (2007) Address. In Post-Status Status: International Oversight in Kosovo, edited by RIINVEST/Soros Foundation. Pristina: Forum 2015.
87. South East Europe TV Exchanges. (2007) What Future EU Mission in Kosovo. Available at (Accessed April 7, 2010.)
88. Stahn, C. (2005) Accountability and Legitimacy in Practice: Lawmaking by Transitional Administrations. Paper Presented at the European Society of International Law Research Forum, Geneva, May 26-28.
89. Steele, J. (2002) Nation Building in East Timor. World Policy Journal 19: 76-87.
90. Strait Times. (2000) Dawn of a New Nation: Difficult Birth for East Timor. February 13.
91. Strohmeyer, H. (2001a) Collapse and Reconstruction of a Judicial System: The United Nations Missions in Kosovo and East Timor. American Journal of International Law 95: 46-63.
92. Strohmeyer, H. (2001b) Making Multilateral Intervention Work: The UN and the Creation of Transitional Justice Systems in Kosovo and East Timor. Fletcher Forum of World Affairs 25: 107-128.
93. Suara Timor Lorosae. (2001) Violence in Baucau: One Mosque Burnt, UN Vehicles Stoned. March 9.
94. Surkhe, A. (2001a) Reason and Reconstruction: the Multiple Logics of UNTAET. Paper presented at the NFR Conference, Oslo, January 18-19 [on file with author].
95. Surkhe, A. (2001b) Peacekeepers as Nation-Builders: Dilemmas of the UN in East Timor. International Peacekeeping 8: 1-20.
96. Tansey, O. (2009) Independence and Tutelage. Journal of Democracy 20: 153-166.
97. Thompson, P. (2007) Interview with Peter Cosgrove [Transcript]. Talking Heads [ABC Channel], July 2.
98. Traub, J. (2000) Inventing East Timor. Foreign Affairs 79: 74-89.
99. UNDP and USAID. (2009) Early Warning Report 26: November 2009. Available at (Accessed March 21, 2010.)
100. United Nations. (1999a) Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Interim Administration in Kosovo. UN. Doc. S/1999/779, July 12.
101. United Nations. (1999b) Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Interim Administration in Kosovo. UN. Doc. S/1999/1250, December 23.
102. United Nations. (2000a) Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor. UN. Doc. S/2000/53, January 26.
103. United Nations. (2000b) Head of UN Transitional Administration in East Timor Briefs Security Council. UN. Doc. SC/6799, February 3.
104. United Nations. (2000c) UNTAET Regulation 2000/11: On the Organization of Courts in East Timor. UN. Doc. UNTAET/REG/2000/11, March 6.
105. United Nations. (2000d) Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo. UN. Doc. S/2000/538, June 6.
106. United Nations. (2000e) Security Council Briefed by Sergio Vieira de Mello, Special Representative for East Timor. UN. Doc. SC/6882, June 27.
107. United Nations. (2004) Report of the Secretary-General on the Rule of Law and Transitional Justice in Conflict and Post-Conflict Societies. UN Doc. S/2004/616, August 23.
108. United Nations. (2005) Letter Dated 7 October 2005 from the Secretary General Addressed to the President of the Security Council. UN. Doc. S/2005/635, October 7.
109. United Nations. (2006) Opening First Session of Peacebuilding Commission, Secretary-General Stresses Importance of National Ownership, Building Effective Public Institutions. UN. Doc. SG/SM/10533, PBC/2, June 26.
110. United Nations. (2008) Civil Administration in Kosovo 1999-2007: Achievements, Challenges and Lessons Learned. UN internal document [on file with author].
111. United Nations Development Program (UNDP). (1999) Conceptual Framework for Reconstruction, Recovery and Development of East Timor (Draft). Available at (Accessed March 21, 2010).
112. United Nations Development Program (UNDP). (2004) Practice Note, March 9.
113. United States Agency for International Development (USAID). (2004) Report on Research Findings and Policy Recommendations for a Legal Framework for Land Dispute Mediation. Timor-Leste Land Law Program.
114. Waran, K. (2000) E Timor Experiment Going Well. New Straits Times, October 1.
115. Ward, M. (2006) The Case for International Trusteeship in Haiti. Canadian Military Journal 7: 25-34.
116. Weiner, T. (2003) An Evolving Idea for Liberia Envisions UN Trusteeship. The New York Times, August 17.
117. Welch, A. (2006) Achieving Human Security After Intra-State Conflict: The Lessons of Kosovo. Journal of Contemporary European Studies 14: 221-239.
118. World Bank. (1999) Report of the Joint Assessment Mission to East Timor, December 8.
119. Zaalberg, T. (2006) Soldiers and Civil Power: Supporting or Substituting Authorities in Modern Peace Operations. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
120. Zaum, D. (2004) Kosovo's Economic Predicament. Presentation at the International Conference "Successes and Failures of International Civil and Military Involvement." St. Anthony's College, Oxford: European Studies Center.