Contesting danger: A new agenda for policy and scholarship on Central Asia

International Affairs

Volumn 87, Issue 3, 2011, Pages 589-612

  Heathershaw, John ^a   Megoran, Nick ^b,c,d,e  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EXETER   (United Kingdom)

^b NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

^d OSH STATE UNIVERSITY   (Kyrgyzstan)

^e ROSKILDE UNIVERSITY   (Denmark)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 79955511127     PISSN: 00205850     EISSN: 14682346     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-2346.2011.00992.x     Document Type: Article

References (116)

1. John Agnew, Geopolitics: re-visioning world politics (London: Routledge), 2003.
2. Mark Polelle, Raising cartographic consciousness: the social and foreign policy vision of geopolitics in the twentieth century (Oxford: Lexington), 1999.
3. E. Jeffrey Popke, 'Recasting geopolitics: the discursive scripting of the International Monetary Fund', Political Geography 13: 3, 1994, pp. 255-69 at p. 255.
4. Agnew, Geopolitics, p. 5.
5. Klaus Dodds, 'Geopolitics in the Foreign Office: British representations of Argentina 1945-1961', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 19: 3, 1994, pp. 273-90 at p. 276.
6. Gearóid Ó Tuathail and Simon Dalby, 'Introduction: rethinking geopolitics: towards a critical geopolitics', Rethinking geopolitics Gearóid Ó Tuathail and Simon Dalby, eds, (London: Routledge), 1998, p. 5.
7. Peter Hopkirk, The Great Game: the struggle for empire in Central Asia (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 1990
8. Robert Johnson, Spying for empire: the Great Game in Central and south Asia, 1757-1947 (London: Greenhill), 2006.
9. Alexander Morrison, Russian rule in Samarkand, 1868-1910: a comparison with British India (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 2008, p. 87.
10. Gavin Hambly, with Alexandre Bennigsen, David Bivar, Hélène Carrère d'Encausse, Mahin Hajianpur, Alastair Lamb, Chantal Lemercier-Quelquejay and Richard Pierce, Central Asia (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1969), pp. 241-2.
11. William Fierman, Soviet Central Asia: the failed transformation (Boulder, CO: Westview), 1991.
12. Alexandre Bennigsen and Marie Broxup, The Islamic threat to the Soviet state (London: Croom Helm), 1983.
13. Graham Fuller, 'Central Asia: the quest for identity', Current History 93: 582, 1994, pp. 145-9 at p. 149.
14. Barnett Rubin and Nancy Lubin, Calming the Ferghana Valley: development and dialogue in the heart of Central Asia, report of the Ferghana Valley Working Group of the Centre for Preventive Action (New York: Century Foundation), 1999.
15. Anthony Bichel, 'Contending theories of Central Asia: the virtual realities of realism, critical IR and the internet', PhD diss., University of Hawaii, 1997.
16. Nick Megoran, 'Calming the Ferghana Valley experts: a review essay of Calming the Ferghana Valley: development and dialogue in the heart of Central Asia, by Nancy Lubin, Barnett Rubin and the Centre for Preventive Action, New York: The Century Foundation Press, 1999', Central Asia Monitor 2000: 5, 2000, pp. 20-25.
17. Stina Torjesen and S. Neil MacFarlane, Kyrgyzstan: a small arms anomaly in Central Asia? Small Arms Survey occasional paper (Geneva: Small Arms Survey), 2004.
18. John Heathershaw and Stina Torjesen, 'Discourses of danger in Central Asia', Central Asian Survey 24: 1, 2005, pp. 1-96.
19. Saodat Olimova and Igor Bosc, Labour migration from Tajikistan (Dushanbe: International Organization for Migration/Sharq Scientific Research Center), 2003.
20. Colette Harris, Control and subversion: gender relations in Tajikistan (London: Pluto), 2004.
21. Torjesen and MacFarlane, Kyrgyzstan
22. John Heathershaw, 'The paradox of peacebuilding: peril, promise and small arms in Tajikistan', Central Asian Survey 24: 1, 2005, pp. 21-38.
23. Christine Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia (London: Routledge), 2009
24. John Heathershaw, Post-conflict Tajikistan: the politics of peacebuilding and the emergence of legitimate order (London: Routledge), 2009.
25. K. Korostelina, 'The system of social identification in Tajikistan: early warning and conflict prevention', Communist and Post-Communist Studies 40: 2, 2007, p. 235.
26. Korostelina, 'The system of social identification', pp. 226, 236.
27. Denis Sandole, 'Central Asia: managing the delicate balance between the "discourse of danger", the "Great Game" and regional problem solving', Communist and Post-Communist Studies 40: 2, 2007, pp. 257-67.
28. Sandole, 'Central Asia', pp. 260-61.
29. Sandole, 'Central Asia', pp. 259-60.
30. Sandole, 'Central Asia', pp. 260, 264.
31. Heathershaw and Torjesen, 'Discourses of danger'.
32. Nick Megoran, 'The critical geopolitics of the Uzbekistan-Kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley boundary dispute, 1999-2000', Political Geography 23: 6, 2004, pp. 731-64.
33. David Lewis, The temptations of tyranny in Central Asia (London: Hurst), 2008
34. Kathleen Collins and William Wohlforth, 'Central Asia: defying "Great Game" expectations', Strategic Asia 2003-2004: fragility and crisis R. J. Ellings and A. L. Friedberg, eds, (Seattle, WA, and Washington DC: National Bureau of Asian Research), 2003, pp. 291-317.
35. Shorter Oxford English Dictionary.
36. Zbigniew Brzezinski, The grand chessboard: American primacy and its geostrategic imperatives (New York: Basic Books), 1997
37. S. Frederick Starr, 'Making Eurasia stable', Foreign Affairs 75: 1, 1996, pp. 80-92.
38. Matthew Edwards, 'The New Great Game and the new great gamers: disciples of Kipling and Mackinder', Central Asian Survey 22: 1, 2003, pp. 83-102 For a discussion see.
39. L. Elber, '"West Wing" at ratings crossroads', Associated Press, 22 Oct., accessed 31 July 2009. 2002
40. Interview with Aaron Sorkin, Season 1, DVD box-set special feature.
41. Stephen Armstrong, 'The war on culture', New Statesman, 21 May, accessed 31 July 2009.
42. Simon Philpott and David Mutimer, 'Inscribing the American body politic: Martin Sheen and two American decades', Geopolitics 10, 2005, p. 338.
43. Anthony Bichel, 'Air Force One: the cinematic erasure of Central Asia', Central Asia Monitor 2, 1998, pp. 6-19.
44. The West Wing is not exceptional in being a TV serial drama in which occasional episodes foreground danger emanating from a thinly depicted Central Asia. Other examples are The Agency (CBS, 24 Feb. 2003) and Spooks (BBC1, 18 Oct. 2004), episodes of TV serial dramas about counterterrorist operations against mainland threats originating in Central Asia conducted by the US and UK secret services respectively. In the former, the only Central Asians who feature are terrorists in Tashkent and a prostitute who makes a cameo appearance in Washington.
45. See section below on 'Orientalizing space'.
46. China's role is a variation on Great Game thinking in that it is assigned a pro-democracy position brought about by the inclusion of ethnic Chinese pro-democracy movements and 'Chinese enclaves' in Kazakhstan. However, this position is represented as derivate of wider geopolitical interests which themselves are determined by a need to secure supplies of oil.
47. Shorter Oxford English Dictionary.
48. Edward Said, Orientalism (New York: Vintage), 1979.
49. William Myer, Islam and colonialism: western perspectives on Soviet Asia (London: Routledge/Curzon), 2002.
50. S. Neil MacFarlane, 'The United States and regionalism in Central Asia', International Affairs 80: 3, May 2004, pp. 447-61
51. Fiona Hill, 'The United States and Russia in Central Asia: Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Iran', paper produced for the Aspen Institute Congressional Program, Aug. 2002, p. 17
52. Elizabeth Wishnick, Strategic consequences of the Iraq War: US security interests in Central Asia reassessed (Carlisle, PN: US Army War College, Strategic Studies Institute), 2004.
53. Douglas Lovelace, 'Foreword', Strategic consequences, Wishnick, ed., p. 3.
54. Richard Giragosian, 'The strategic Central Asian arena', China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly 4: 1, 2006, p. 133.
55. Paraphrasing of Jones's testimony in Wishnick, ed., Strategic consequences, p. 4.
56. Hill, 'The United States', p. 18.
57. Henry Plater-Zyberk, Tajikistan: waiting for a storm?, Central Asia series (London: Conflict Studies Research Centre, no. 13, May). 2004
58. Graham Smith, 'The masks of Proteus: Russia, geopolitical shift and the new Eurasianism', Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 24, 1999, pp. 481-500
59. O. A. Donskikh, 'Eurasianism as a concept and as an instrument for the formation of geopolitical doctrines and strategies', Siberia in focus: proceedings of the conference Euraisa: regional perspectives', June 2-3, 2007, Novosibirsk (Kolkata: Towards Freedom), pp. 93-101.
60. John Schoeberlein, 'Setting the stakes of a new society', Central Eurasian Studies Review 1: 1, 2002, pp. 4-8.
61. S. Frederick Starr, In defence of Greater Central Asia (Washington DC: Johns Hopkins University, Silk Road Studies Programme, Sept.). 2008
62. M. Parvizi Amineh, The Greater Middle East in global politics: social science perspectives on the changing geography of the world politics, international studies in sociology and social anthropology (Leiden: Brill), 2007.
63. Thomas Barnett, The Pentagon's new map: war and peace in the twenty-first century (New York: Berkeley), 2004.
64. Chris Seiple, 'Uzbekistan: civil society in the heartland', Orbis 49: 2, Spring at p. 246, 2005, pp. 245-59.
65. Donald Rumsfeld, Annual Report to the President and to Congress (Washington DC: Department of Defense), accessed July 2009, 2002, p. 11.
66. Interview conducted by one of the authors with Rashid Abdullo, independent political analyst, in Dushanbe, Tajikistan, June 2005.
67. Shorter Oxford English Dictionary.
68. Ralph S. Clem, 'The new Central Asia: prospects for development', Geography and transition in the post-Soviet republics Michael J. Bradshaw, ed., (Chichester: Wiley), 1997, pp. 171-2.
69. Robert Kaiser, The geography of nationalism in Russia and the USSR (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press), 1994, pp. 370-71.
70. Abilabek Asankanov, 'Ethnic conflict in the Osh region in summer 1990: reasons and lessons', Ethnicity and power in the contemporary world Kumar Rupesinghe and Valery Tishkov, eds, (Paris: United Nations University), 1996.
71. M. Haghayeghi, Islam and politics in Central Asia (New York: St Martin's), 1995, p. 186.
72. Daria Fane, 'Ethnicity and regionalism in Uzbekistan', Ethnic conflict in the post-Soviet world: case studies and analysis Leokadia Drobizheva, Rose Gottemoeller, Catherine McArdle Kelleher and Lee Walker, eds, (London: M. E. Sharpe), 1996, p. 275.
73. P. L. Dash, 'Ethnic tussles in the Soviet Muslim republics', Ethnicity and politics in Central Asia K. Warikoo and Dawa Norbu, eds, (New Delhi: South Asian Publishers), 1992, pp. 119-20.
74. Eric McGlinchey, 'Powerless in Kyrgyzstan', RFE/RL Newsline, 13 July 2000.
75. Anna Matveeva, EU stakes in Central Asia, Chaillot paper 91 (Paris: Institute for Security Studies), 2006, p. 9.
76. Randa Slim, 'The Ferghana Valley: in the midst of a host of crises', Searching for peace in Europe and Asia: an overview of conflict prevention and peacebuilding initiatives Paul van Tongeren, Hans van de Veen and Juliette Verhoeven, eds, (London: Lynne Rienner), 2002.
77. Ulugbek Babakulov, 'Kyrgyz-Uzbek border tensions', Reporting Central Asia, 3 Feb. (London: Institute for War and Peace Reporting), accessed 31 March 2011. 2002
78. Christian Caryl, 'Declining democracy', Newsweek web exclusive, 21 Jan., accessed 21 Jan. 2011. 2001
79. Rubin and Lubin, Calming the Ferghana Valley, pp. x, xv-xvi.
80. Gary Shteyngart, Absurdistan (London: Granta), 2006.
81. J. Schoeberlein-Engel, 'Identity in Central Asia: construction and contention in the conceptions of "Ozbek", "Tajik", "Muslim", "Samarqandi" and other groups', PhD diss., Harvard University, 1994.
82. Graham Smith, The post-Soviet states: mapping the politics of transition (London: Arnold), 1999, p. 227.
83. Megoran, 'The critical geopolitics of the Uzbekistan-Kyrgyzstan Ferghana Valley boundary dispute'.
84. Necati Polat, Boundary issues in Central Asia (Ardsley: Transnational), 2002, p. 167.
85. Nick Megoran, 'On researching "ethnic conflict": epistemology, politics, and a Central Asian boundary dispute', Europe-Asia Studies 59: 2, 2007, pp. 253-77.
86. 'The pogroms in Kyrgyzstan', International Crisis Group (ICG), Asia Report 193, 23 Aug., accessed 31 March 2011 2010
87. Luke Harding, 'Kyrgyzstan killings are attempted genocide, say ethnic Uzbeks', Guardian, 17 June 2010, p. 1.
88. Craig Murray, 'Kyrgyzstan: death, dictators and the Soviet legacy', Daily Telegraph, 17 June 2010
89. Edward Stourton, 'Stalin's deadly legacy', Guardian, 21 June 2010, p. 29
90. 'Stalin's harvest', The Economist, 17 June, accessed 31 March 2011. 2010
91. Some earlier reports identify, even more spuriously, Lenin as the culprit (Harding, 'Kyrgyzstan killings', p. 1).
92. Madeleine Reeves helped clarify our thinking on this point.
93. Abdujalil Abdurasulov, 'Lawlessness and change in the interaction between Uzbeks and Kyrgyz in southern Kyrgyzstan', paper given to round table on Kyrgyzstan, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, 22 May 2010.
94. The ICG's Aug. 2010 report acknowledges that 'the international community' did not pay significant attention to the events of May 2010 in Jalalabat, suggesting that had they done so the Osh events of June 2010 might have been mitigated or prevented. See ICG, 'The pogroms in Kyrgyzstan', p. 7.
95. Mark Duffield, Global governance and the new wars: the merging of development and security (London: Zed), 2002.
96. Nick Megoran, Gaël Raballand and Jérôme Bouyjou, 'Performance, representation, and the economics of border control in Uzbekistan', Geopolitics 10: 4, 2005, pp. 712-42.
97. Christine Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia (London: Routledge), 2009.
98. Christine Bichsel, 'In search of harmony: repairing infrastructure and social relations in the Ferghana Valley', Central Asian Survey 24: 1, 2005, pp. 53-66.
99. Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia, pp. 121-2.
100. Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia, pp. 90-94.
101. Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia, p. 82.
102. Bichsel, Conflict transformation in Central Asia, p. 70.
103. Heathershaw, Post-conflict Tajikistan.
104. John Heathershaw, 'Tajikistan's virtual politics of peace', Europe-Asia Studies 61: 7, Sept. 2009, pp. 1315-36.
105. Christoph Zürcher and colleagues, Analysis of peace and conflict potential in Rasht Valley, Shuraobad District and GBAO (Berlin: Analysis Research Consulting, March 2004); Michael Barnett and Christoph Zürcher, 'The peacebuilder's contract: how external state-building reinforces weak statehood', in Roland Paris and Timothy Sisk, eds, The dilemmas of statebuilding (London: Routledge), 2009.
106. Barry Buzan, Ole Waever and Jaap de Wilde, Security: a new framework for analysis (Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner), 1998.
107. Madeleine Reeves, 'Locating danger: konfliktologiia and the search for fixity in the Ferghana Valley borderlands', Central Asian Survey 24: 1, 2005, pp. 67-81.
108. Myer, Islam and colonialism, p. 269.
109. Marat Alykulov (director), Chek ara (Bishkek: Kyrgyzfil'm / Oy Art, 2006).
110. Johnson's Russia List, Oxford analytica and ambassador's response [re: Tajikistan], 17 March, accessed 18 July 2006. 2006
111. Madeleine Reeves, 'Border-work: an ethnography of the state at its limits in the Ferghana Valley', PhD diss., Cambridge University, 2007.
112. Johan Rasanayagam, 'Healing with spirits and the formation of Muslim selfhood in post-Soviet Uzbekistan', Journal of the Royal Anthropological Society (n.s.) 12: 2, 2006, pp. 377-93.
113. Jakob Rigi, 'The conditions of post-Soviet dispossessed youth and work in Almaty, Kazakhstan', Critique of Anthropology 23: 1, 2003, pp. 35-49.
114. Caroline Kennedy-Pipe, 'Whose security? State-building and the "emancipation" of women in Central Asia', International Relations 18: 1, 2004, pp. 91-107.
115. Madeleine Reeves, 'Travels in the margins of the state: everyday geography in the Ferghana Valley borderlands', Everyday life in Central Asia: past and present Jeff Sahadeo and Russell Zanca, eds, (Bloomington: Indiana University Press), 2007.
116. A. C. G. M. Robben and Carolyn Nordstrom, 'Introduction: the anthropology and ethnography of violence and sociopolitical conflict', Fieldwork under fire: contemporary studies of violence and survival Robben and Nordstrom, eds, (Berkeley: University of California Press), 1995, p. 14.