Policy strategies to reduce waits for elective care: A synthesis of international evidence

British Medical Bulletin

Volumn 95, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 7-32

  Kreindler, Sara A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA   (Canada)

Author keywords

elective surgery; international comparisons; policy; waiting lists; waiting times

Indexed keywords

ELECTIVE SURGERY; HEALTH CARE ACCESS; HEALTH CARE DISTRIBUTION; HEALTH CARE FINANCING; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; MOTIVATION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE; RESOURCE ALLOCATION; REVIEW;

EFFICIENCY, ORGANIZATIONAL; EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE; HEALTH POLICY; HEALTH SERVICES NEEDS AND DEMAND; HUMANS; PUBLIC HEALTH ADMINISTRATION; SURGICAL PROCEDURES, ELECTIVE; TIME FACTORS; WAITING LISTS;

EID: 77956236425     PISSN: 00071420     EISSN: 14718391     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/bmb/ldq014     Document Type: Review

References (88)

1. Hurst J, Siciliani L. Tackling excessive waiting times for elective surgery: a comparison of policies in twelve OECD countries. Paris: OECD, 2003, OECD Working Papers 6.
2. Gorey KM, Luginaah IN, Holowaty EJ et al. Wait times for surgical and adjuvant radiation treatment of breast cancer in Canada and the United States: greater socioeconomic inequity in America. Clin Invest Med 2009;32:E239-E249.
3. Schoen C, Doty MM. Inequities in access to medical care in five countries: findings from the 2001 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey. Health Policy 2004;67: 309-322
4. Horwitz LI, Bradley EH. Percentage of US emergency department patients seen within the recommended triage time: 1997 to 2006. Arch Intern Med 2009;169:1857-1865
5. Levy AR, Sobolev BG, Hayden R et al. Time on wait lists for coronary bypass surgery in British Columbia, Canada, 1991-2000. BMC Health Serv Res 2005;5:22.
6. Masri BA, Cochrane N, Duncan C et al. Priority Criteria for Hip and Knee Replacement: Addressing Health Service Wait Times. Report II: Inventory of Initiatives: Joint replacement: International Approaches to Meeting the Needs. Vancouver, BC: Krueger & Associates, 2005.
7. Pacifico MD, Pearl RA, Grover R. The UK Government two-week rule and its impact on melanoma prognosis: an evidence-based study. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2007;89:609-615
8. Shea BJ, Grimshaw JM, Wells GA et al. Development of AMSTAR: a measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews. BMC Med Res Methodol 2007;7:10.
9. Cochrane Review Effective Practice and Organization of Care Group. Risk of Bias. http://epoc.cochrane.org/sites/epoc.cochrane.org/files/uploads/ Risk%20of%20Bias%2005-01-2009. doc (7 January 2010, date last accessed).
10. Harrison A, Appleby J. The War on Waiting for Hospital Treatment: What has Labour Achieved and What Challenges Remain?. London: Kings Fund, 2005.
11. MacLeod H, Hudson A, Kramer S et al. The times they are a-changing: What worked and what we learned in deploying Ontarios Wait Time Information System. Healthc Q 2009;12:8-15.
12. Schut FT, Van de Ven WP. Rationing and competition in the Dutch health-care system. Health Econ 2005;14:S59-S74.
13. Willcox S, Seddon M, Dunn S et al. Measuring and reducing waiting times: a cross-national comparison of strategies. Health Aff 2007;26:1078-1087
14. Kenis P. Waiting lists in Dutch health care: an analysis from an organization theoretical perspective. J Health Organ Manag 2006;20:294-308.
15. Sheldon T. Dutch waiting lists increase despite £36m campaign. BMJ 2000;321:530.
16. Exter A, Hermans H, Dosljak M et al. Health Care Systems in Transition: Netherlands. Copenhagen: European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, 2004.
17. Daley C, Gubb J. Health Reform in the Netherlands. London: Civitas Institute for the Study of Civil Society, 2007.
18. Westert GP, Berg MJ, van den Koolman X et al. Dutch Health Care Performance Report. Bilthoven: The Netherlands: National Institute for Public Health and the Environment, 2008.
19. Mojon-Azzi SM, Mojon DS. Waiting times for surgical procedures in ten European countries. Gesundheitsokonomie und Qualitatsmanagement 2008;13:92-98
20. Hakkinen U. The impact of changes in Finlands health care system. Health Econ 2005;14:S101-S118.
21. Mascarenhas R. The Manitoba arthroplasty waiting list: impact on health-related quality of life and initiatives to remedy the problem. J Eval Clin Pract 2009;15:208-211
22. Kreindler SA, Bapuji S. Prehabilitation for Total Hip or Knee Replacement: Evaluation of the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority Prehab Program. Winnipeg, MB: Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, 2009, Unpublished draft of forthcoming report.
23. Botten G, Grepperud S, Nerland SM. Trading patients. Lessons from Scandinavia. Health Policy 2004;69:317-327
24. McGowan T. Private management of a public service: what can be learned from the CROS experience? Hosp Q 2003;6:33-38
25. Ciampolini J, Hubble MJ. Early failure of total hip replacements implanted at distant hospitals to reduce waiting lists. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2005;87:31-35
26. Hanna SA, Saksena J, Legge S et al. Sending NHS patients for operations abroad: is the holiday over? Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2009;91:128-130
27. Harrison A, Appleby J. Reducing waiting times for hospital treatment: lessons from the English NHS. J Health Serv Res Policy 2009;14:168-173
28. Mason C. Public-private health care delivery becoming the norm in Sweden. CMAJ 2008;179:129-131
29. Dawson D, Jacobs R, Martin S et al. Is patient choice an effective mechanism to reduce waiting times? Appl Health Econ Health Policy 2004;3:195-203.
30. Rachlis MM. Public Solutions to Health Care Wait Lists. Ottawa, ON: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, 2005.
31. Colombo T, Tapay N. Private Health Insurance In Australia: A Case Study. OECD Health Working Papers No. 8. Paris: OECD, 2003.
32. Deber R. Delivering Health Care Services: Public, Not-For-Profit, or Private? Discussion Paper No. 17, Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada, August, 2002.
33. Cancer Care Ontario. Radiation Treatment Wait Times. 2009. http://www.cancercare.on.ca.proxy1.lib.umanitoba.ca/ocs/wait-times/radiationwt (21 January 2010, date last accessed).
34. Devereaux PJ, Choi PT, Lacchetti C et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies comparing mortality rates of private for-profit and private not-for-profit hospitals. CMAJ 2002;166:1399-1406
35. Devereaux PJ, Heels-Ansdell D, Lacchetti C et al. Payments for care at private for-profit and private not-for-profit hospitals: a systematic review and meta-analysis. CMAJ 2004;170:1817-1824
36. Donaldson C, Currie G. The Public Purchase of Private Surgical Services: A Systematic Review of the Evidence on Efficiency and Equity (Working Paper 00-9). Calgary, AB: Institute of Health Economics, 2000.
37. Dawson D, Gravelle H, Jacobs R et al. The effects of expanding patient choice of provider on waiting times: evidence from a policy experiment. Health Econ 2007;16:113-128
38. Dhalla I. Private health insurance: an international overview and considerations for Canada. Healthc Q 2007;10:89-96.
39. The OECD Health Project. Private Health Insurance in OECD Countries. Paris: OECD, 2004.
40. Duckett SJ. Private care and public waiting. Aust Health Rev 2005;29:87-93.
41. Tuohy CH, Flood CM, Stabile M. How does private finance affect public health care systems? Marshaling the evidence from OECD nations. J Health Polit Policy Law 2004;29:359-396
42. Williams B, Whatmough P, McGill J et al. Impact of private funding on access to elective hospital treatment in the regions of England and Wales: National records survey. Eur J Public Health 2001;11:402-406
43. The National Treatment Purchase Fund. Dublin: NPTF, 2008, Annual Report.
44. Richardson JR, Segal L. Private health insurance and the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme: how effective has recent government policy been? Aust Health Rev 2004;28: 34-47.
45. Cormack M. Private health insurance: the problem child faces adulthood. Aust Health Rev 2002;25:38-51.
46. Hanning B. Has the increase in private health insurance uptake affected the Victorian public hospital surgical waiting list? Aust Health Rev 2002;25:64-71.
47. Hopkins S, Frech HE III. The rise of private health insurance in Australia: early effects on insurance and hospital markets. Economic Labour Relations Rev 2001;12:225-238
48. Hopkins S, Zweifel P. The Australian health policy changes of 1999 and 2000 an evaluation. Appl Health Econ Health Policy 2005;4:229-238
49. Powers N, Sundararajan V, Gillett S et al. The effect of increased private health insurance coverage on Victorian public hospitals. Aust Health Rev 2003;26:6-10.
50. Hurley J, Vaithianathana R, Crossley T et al. Parallel Private Health Insurance in Australia: A Cautionary Tale and Lessons for Canada. (Centre for Health Economics and Policy Analysis Working Paper 2001-12.). Hamilton, ON: CHEPA, 2001.
51. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Australian Hospital Statistics 2007-2008. Health services series no. 33. Cat. no. HSE 71. Canberra: AIHW, 2009.
52. Kreindler SA. Watching your wait: evidence-informed strategies for reducing health care wait times. Qual Manag Health Care 2008;17:128-135
53. Health Council of Canada. Wading Through Wait Times: What Do Meaningful Reductions and Guarantees Mean? Ottawa, ON: Health Council of Canada, 2007.
54. Elkhuizen SG, Limburg M, Bakker PJ et al. Evidence-based re-engineering: re-engineering the evidence - a systematic review of the literature on business process redesign (BPR) in hospital care. Int J Health Care Qual Assur 2006;19:477-499
55. Alexander A. The National Demonstration Hospitals Program. Aust Health Rev 2000;23: 198-204.
56. Appleby J, Boyle S, Devlin N et al. Sustaining reductions in waiting times: identifying successful strategies. Final report to the Department of Health. London: Kings Fund, 2005.
57. Fotaki M, Roland M, Boyd A et al. What benefits will choice bring to patients? Literature review and assessment of implications. J Health Serv Res Policy 2008;13:178-184
58. Thomson S, Dixon A. Choices in health care: the European experience. J Health Serv Res Policy 2006;11:167-171
59. Green J, McDowall Z, Potts HW. Does Choose & Book fail to deliver the expected choice to patients? A survey of patients experience of outpatient appointment booking. BMC Med Inform Decis Mak 2008;8:36-43.
60. Siciliani L, Martin S. An empirical analysis of the impact of choice on waiting times. Health Econ 2007;16:763-779
61. Gauld R, Derrett S. Solving the surgical waiting list problem? New Zealands booking system. Int J Health Plann Manage 2000;15:259-272
62. France G, Taroni F, Donatini A. The Italian health-care system. Health Econ 2005;14: S187-S202.
63. Western Canada Waiting List Project. Moving Forward: Final Report. Calgary, AB: WCWL Project, 2005.
64. Grimshaw JM, Thomas RE, MacLennan G et al. Effectiveness and efficiency of guideline dissemination and implementation strategies. Health Technol Assess 2004;8:iii-iv, 1-72.
65. Perlman F. Investigation of elective surgery in Barking, Dagenham and Havering in relation to demand management. Barking, Essex: Public Health Directorate, Barking and Havering Health Authority, 2002.
66. Johnson K, Bowen S, Zhang L et al. Evaluation of the Manitoba demonstration project in physician demand-side control for diagnostic imaging (final report). Winnipeg, MB: Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, 2007.
67. Kreindler SA. Surgery in Canada: Pump Up the Volume? (rapid review) Winnipeg, MB: Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, 2007.
68. Bevan G, Hood C. Have targets improved performance in the English NHS? BMJ 2006;332:419-422
69. Alvarez-Rosete A, Bevan G, Mays N et al. Effect of diverging policy across the NHS. BMJ 2005;331:946-950
70. Besley TJ, Bevan G, Burchardi KB. Naming and Shaming: The Impacts of Different Regimes on Hospital Waiting Times in England and Wales (CEPR Discussion Paper). London: Centre for Economic Policy Research, 2009.
71. Propper C, Sutton M, Whitnall C et al. Did targets and terror reduce waiting times in England for hospital care? BE J Econ Anal Policy 2008;8
72. Propper C, Sutton M, Whitnall C et al. Incentives and Targets in Hospital Care: Evidence from a Natural Experiment. Bristol, UK: The Centre for Market and Public Organisation, 2008.
73. Anell A. Swedish healthcare under pressure. Health Econ 2005;14:S237-S254.
74. Joshi NP, Noseworthy FT, Noseworthy TW. Waiting time care guarantees: necessity or nemesis? Healthc Manage Forum 2006;19:35-39
75. Karlberg HI, Brinkmo BM. The unethical focus on access: a study of medical ethics and the waiting-time guarantee. Scand J Public Health 2009;37:117-121
76. Hanning M, Spangberg UW. Maximum waiting time - a threat to clinical freedom? Implementation of a policy to reduce waiting times. Health Policy 2000;52:15-32.
77. Pomey M, Forest P-G, Sanmartin C et al. Determinants of Waiting Time Management for Health Services (R09-01). Montreal, QC: Groupe de recherche interdisciplinaire en sante, Universite de Montreal, 2009.
78. Hanning M, Lundstrom M. Waiting for cataract surgery-effects of a maximum waiting-time guarantee. J Health Serv Res Policy 2007;12:5-10.
79. Tan E, Levell NJ, Garioch JJ. The effect of a dermatology restricted-referral list upon the volume of referrals. Clin Exp Dermatol 2007;32:114-115
80. Robinson D, Bell CM, Moller H et al. Effect of the UK governments 2-week target on waiting times in women with breast cancer in southeast England. Br J Cancer 2003;89: 492-496
81. Dimakou S, Parkin D, Devlin N et al. Identifying the impact of government targets on waiting times in the NHS. Health Care Manag Sci 2009;12:1-10.
82. Appleby J, Boyle S, Devlin N et al. Do English NHS waiting time targets distort treatment priorities in orthopaedic surgery? J Health Serv Res Policy 2005;10:167-172
83. Canadian Institute for Health Information. Surgical Volume Trends Within and Beyond Wait Time Priority Areas. Analysis in Brief. Ottawa, ON: CIHI, 2007.
84. Propper C, Burgess S, Gossage D. Competition and Quality: Evidence from the NHS Internal Market 1991-9. Econ J 2008;118:138-170
85. Propper C, Croxson B, Shearer A. Waiting times for hospital admissions: the impact of GP fundholding. J Health Econ 2002;21:227-252
86. Walley P, Silvester K, Steyn R. Knowledge and behaviour for a sustainable improvement culture. Healthc Pap 2006;7:26-33. Discussion 74-77
87. Stoop AP, Vrangbaek K, Berg M. Theory and practice of waiting time data as a performance indicator in health care. A case study from The Netherlands. Health Policy 2005;73:41-51.
88. Martalog J, Bains S. Turning data into meaningful information. Healthc Q 2009;12:76-77.