The ICE hypothesis stands: How the dogma of late Cenozoic tectonic uplift can no longer be sustained in the light of data and physical laws

Journal of Geodynamics

Volumn 50, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 102-111

  Nielsen, S B ^a   Clausen, O R ^a   Jacobsen, B H ^a   Thomsen, E ^a   Huuse, M ^b   Gallagher, K ^c   Balling, N ^a   Egholm, D ^a  

^a AARHUS UNIVERSITY   (Denmark)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITÉ DE RENNES 1   (France)

Author keywords

Climate; Compaction; Hypothesis falsification; Neogene uplift; Thermal maturity

Indexed keywords

CALEDONIAN OROGENY; CENOZOIC; CRUSTAL STRUCTURE; NEOGENE; THERMAL MATURITY; UPLIFT;

ATLANTIC OCEAN; NORTH SEA; SCANDINAVIA;

EID: 77955576373     PISSN: 02643707     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jog.2010.02.002     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. Balling N., Jacobsen B.H., Svenningsen L., Nielsen S.B. Seismological and gravity evidence for a buoyant crustal root beneath the highlands of Southern Norway and tectonic implications. Geophysical Research Abstracts 2008, 10:A-07297.
2. Bartek L.R., Vail P.R., Anderson J.B., Emmet P.A., Wu S. Effect of Cenozoic ice sheet fluctuations in Antarctica on the stratigraphic signature of the Neogene. Journal of Geophysical Research 1991, 96(B4):6753-6778.
3. Brozovic N., Burbank D.W., Meigs A.J. Climatic limits on landscape development in the northwestern Himalaya. Science 1997, 276:571-574.
4. Catuneanu, et al. Towards the standardization of sequence stratigraphy. Earth Science Reviews 2009, 92:1-33.
5. Christensen N.I., Mooney W.D. Seismic velocity structure and composition of the continental crust: a global view. Journal of Geophysical Research 1995, 100(B7):9761-9788.
6. Clausen O.R., Huuse M. Topography of the Top Chalk surface on- and offshore Denmark. Marine and Petroleum Geology 1999, 16(7):677-691.
7. Clausen O.R., Korstgård J.A. Tertiary tectonic evolution along the Arne-Elin trend in the Danish Central trough. Terra Nova 1993, 5(3):233-243.
8. Clausen O.R., Gregersen U., Michelsen O., Sørensen J.C. Factors controlling the Cenozoic sequence development in the eastern parts of the North Sea. Journal of the Geological Society 1999, 156(4):809-816.
9. Corcoran D.V., Doré A.G. A review of techniques for the estimation of magnitude and timing of exhumation in offshore basins. Earth Science Reviews 2005, 72:129-168.
10. Cornford C. Source rocks and hydrocarbons of the North Sea. Petroleum Geology of the North Sea. Basic Concepts and Recent Advances 1998, 377-462. Blackwell Science Ltd. 4th ed. K.W. Glennie (Ed.).
11. Davis W.M. The geographical cycle. Geographical Journal 1899, 14:481-504.
12. De Man E., Ivany L., Vandenbergh N. Stable oxygen isotope record of the Eocene-Oligocene transition in the southern North Sea Basin: positioning the Oi-1 event. Geologie en Mijnbouw 2004, 83:193-197.
13. Danielsen M., Michelsen O., Clausen O.R. Oligocene sequence stratigraphy and basin development in the Danish North Sea sector based on log interpretations. Marine and Petroleum Geology 1997, 14(7-8):931-950.
14. Ebbing J. Isostatic density modelling explains the missing root of the Scandes. Norwegian Journal of Geology 2007, 87:13-20.
15. Egholm D.L., Nielsen S.B., Pedersen V.K., Lesemann J.-E. Glacial effects limiting mountain height. Nature 2009, 884-887.
16. Einsele G. Sedimentary Basins: Evolution, Facies and Sediment Budget 1992, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 628 pp.
17. England R.W., Ebbing J. SCANLIPS-a seismological study of epirogenic uplift of Scandinavia. Geophysical Research Abstracts 2008, 10:2842.
18. Fabricius I.L. Chalk: composition, diagenesis and physical properties. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 2007, 55:97-128.
19. Fossen H., Mangerud G., Hesthammer J., Bugge T., Gabrielsen R.H. The Bjorøy formation: a newly discovered occurrence of Jurassic sediments in the Bergen Arc System. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift 1997, 77:269-287.
20. Frederiksen S., Nielsen S.B., Balling N. A numerical dynamic model for the Norwegian-Danish Basin. Tectonophysics 2001, 343:165-183.
21. Frederiksen S., Nielsen S.B., Balling N. Post Permian evolution of the Central North Sea: a numerical model. Tectonophysics 2001, 343:185-203.
22. Friis H. Heavy-mineral variability in Miocene marine sediments in Denmark: a combined effect of weathering and reworking. Sedimentary Geology 1978, 21(3):169-188.
23. Friis H., Mikkelsen J., Sandersen P. Depositional environment of the Vejle Fjord formation of the upper oligocene-lower Miocene of Denmark: a barrier island/barrier-protected depositional complex. Sedimentary Geology 1998, 117(3-4):221-244.
24. Gradstein F.M., Ogg J.G., Smith A.G. A Geologic Time Scale 2004, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 384-408.
25. Hansen D.L., Nielsen S.B., Lykke-Andersen The post-Triassic evolution of the Sorgenfrei-Tornquist zone-results from thermo mechanical modelling. Tectonophysics 2000, 328:245-267.
26. Hjuler M.L., Fabricius I.L. Engineering properties of chalk related to diagenetic variations of Upper Cretaceous onshore and offshore chalk in the North Sea area. Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 2009, 68:151-170.
27. Huuse M. Detailed morphology of the Top Chalk surface in the eastern Danish North Sea. Petroleum Geoscience 1999, 5:303-314.
28. Huuse M., Lykke-Andersen H. Overdeepened Quaternary valleys in the eastern Danish North Sea: morphology and origin. Quaternary Science Reviews 2000, 19:1233-1253.
29. Huuse M., Lykke-Andersen H., Michelsen O. Cenozoic evolution of the eastern Danish North Sea. Marine Geology 2001, 177:243-269.
30. Huuse M. Cenozoic uplift and denudation of southern Norway: insights from the North Sea Basin. Exhumation of the North Atlantic Margin: Timing, Mechanisms and Implications for Petroleum Generation 2002, 209-233. Geological Society, London, Special Publications 196. A.E. Doré, J. Cartwright, M.S. Stoker, J.P. Turner, N. White (Eds.).
31. Japsen P., Green P.F., Nielsen L.H., Rasmussen E.S., Bidstrup T. Mesozoic-Cenozoic exhumation events in the eastern North Sea Basin: a multi-disciplinary study based on palaeothermal, palaeoburial, stratigraphic and seismic data. Basin Research 2007, 19:451-490.
32. Ketcham R.A., Donelick R.A., Carlson W.D. Variability of apatite fission-track annealing kinetics. III. Extrapolation to geological timescales. American Mineralogist 1999, 84:1235-1255.
33. Ketcham R.A., Donelick R.A., Donelick M.B. AFTSolve: a program for multi-kinetic modeling of apatite fission-track data. Geological Materials Research 2000, 2:1-32.
34. Ketcham R.A., Carter A., Donelick R.A., Barbarand J., Hurford A.J. Improved modeling of fission-track annealing in apatite. American Mineralogist 2007, 92:799-810.
35. Kinck J.J., Husebye E.S., Larsson F.R. The Moho depth distribution in Fennoscandia and the regional tectonic evolution from Archean to Permian times. Precambrian Research 1993, 64:23-51.
36. Knudsen C., Frei D., Rasmussen T., Rasmussen E.S., McLimans R. New methods in provenance studies based on heavy minerals: an example from Miocene sands in Jylland, Denmark. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Bulletin 2005, 29-32.
37. Korstgård J.A., Lerche I., Mogensen T.E., Thomsen R.O. Salt and fault interactions in the northeastern Danish Central Graben: observations and inferences. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 1993, 40:197-255.
38. Kozlovskaya E., Elo S., Hjelt S.-E., Yliniemi J., Pirttijärvi M. Geophysical Journal International 2004, 158:827-848. SVEKALAPKO Seismic Tomography Working Group.
39. Ksienzyk A., Johansen L., Jacobs J., Fossen H., Emmel B., Wemmer K. Detailed apatite fission-track studies in the Bergen area (southwestern Norway): indication for a fault-dissected basin margin?. Proceedings from the 11th International Conference on Thermochronometry 2008, 147-148. J.I. Garver, M.J. Montario (Eds.).
40. Kuhn T. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions 1970, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 210 pp.
41. Kukkonen I.T., Kuusistol M., Peltonen P. Delamination of eclogitized lower crust: control on the crust-mantle boundary in the central Fennoscandian shield. Tectonophysics 2008, 457:111-127.
42. Leighton, C.A., 2007. The thermotectonic development of southern Norway: Constraints from low-temperature thermocharonology. PhD thesis. University of London, 296 pp.
43. Matmon A., Bierman P.R., Larsen J., Southworth S., Pavich M., Finkel R., Caffee M. Erosion of an ancient mountain range, the Great Smoky Mountains, North Carolina and Tennessee. American Journal of Science 2003, 303:817-855.
44. Medhus, A.B., Balling, N., Jacobsen, B.H., Kind, R., England, R.W., in press. Deep-structural differences in southwestern Scandinavia revealed by P-wave travel time residuals. Norwegian Journal of Geology.
45. Medvedev S., Hartz E.H., Podladchikov Y.Y. Vertical motions of the fjord regions of central East Greenland: impact of glacial erosion, deposition, and isostasy. Geology 2008, 36:539-542.
46. Miall A.D., Miall C.E. Sequence stratigraphy as a scientific enterprise: the evolution and persistence of conflicting paradigms. Earth Science Reviews 2001, 54:321-348.
47. Miall A.D. The Geology of Fluvial Deposits: Sedimentary Facies, Basin Analysis, and Petroleum Geology 1996, Springer, 583 pp.
48. Michelsen, O., Thomsen, E., Danielsen, M., Heilman-Clausen, C., Jordt, H., Laursen, G., 1998. Cenozoic sequence stratigraphy in the eastern North Sea. Mesozoic and Cenozoic sequence stratigraphy of European basins, Society for Sedimentary Geology (SEPM) Special Publication no. 60, 91-118.
49. Mikkelsen J. En Lithofaciesunderøgelse af Ungtertiæret Omkring Vejle Fjord 1983, University of Aarhus, 100 pp.
50. Miller K.G., Kominz M.A., Browning J.V., Wright J.D., Mountain G.S., Katz M.E., Sugarman P.J., Cramer B.S., Christie-Blick N., Pekar S.F. The phanerozoic record of global sea-level change. Science 2005, 310(5752):1293-1298.
51. Miller K.G., Browning J.V., Aubry M.-P., Wade B.S., Katz M.E., Kulpecz A.A., Wright J.D. Eocene-Oligocene global climate and sea-level changes: St. Stephens Quarry, Alabama. GSA Bulletin of the Geological Society of America 2008, 120:34-53.
52. Mitchell S.G., Montgomery D.R. Influence of a glacial buzzsaw on the height and morphology of the Cascade Range in central Washington State, USA. Quaternary Research 2006, 65:96-107.
53. Molnar P. Late Cenozoic increase in accumulation rates of terrestrial sediment: how might climate change have affected erosion rates?. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 2004, 32:67-89.
54. Mosar J. Scandinavia's North Atlantic passive margin. Journal of Geophysical Research 2003, 108(B8, 2360). doi:10.1029/2002JB002134.
55. Nielsen S.B., Paulsen G.E., Hansen D.L., Gemmer L., Clausen O.R., Jacobsen B.H., Balling N., Huuse M., Gallagher K. Exhumation of the North Atlantic Margin: Timing, Mechanisms and Implications for Petroleum Generation 2002, 45-65. Paleocene initiation of Cenozoic uplift in Norway,, Geological Society, London, Special Publications 196. A.E. Doré, J. Cartwright, M.S. Stoker, J.P. Turner, N. White (Eds.).
56. Nielsen S.B., Stephenson R.A., Thomsen E. Dynamics of mid-Paleocene North Atlantic rifting linked with European Paleocene intra-plate deformations. Nature 2007, 450:1071-1074.
57. Nielsen S.B., Thomsen E., Hansen D.L., Clausen O.R. Plate-wide stress relaxation explains European Paleocene basin inversions. Nature 2005, 435:195-198.
58. Nielsen S.B., Gallagher K., Leighton C., Balling N., Svenningsen L., Jacobsen B.H., Thomsen E., Nielsen O.B., Heilmann-Clausen C., Egholm D.L., Summerfield M.A., Clausen O.R., Piotrowski J.A., Thorsen M.R., Huuse M., Abrahamsen N., King C., Lykke-Andersen H. The evolution of western Scandinavian topography: a review of Neogene uplift versus the ICE (isostasy-climate-erosion) hypothesis. Journal of Geodynamics 2009, 47:72-95.
59. Nielsen S.B., Gallagher K., Egholm D.L., Clausen O.R., Summerfield M. Reply to comment regarding the ICE-hypothesis. Journal of Geodynamics 2009, 48:101-106.
60. Nielsen S.B., Hansen D.L. Physical explanation of the formation and evolution of inversion zones and marginal troughs. Geology 2000, 28:875-878.
61. Nielsen S.B., Balling N., Christiansen H.S. Formation temperatures determined from stochastic inversion of borehole observations. Geophysical Journal International 1990, 101:581-591.
62. Pascal C., Olesen O. Are the Norwegian mountains compensated by a mantle thermal anomaly at depth?. Tectonophysics 2009, 475:160-168.
63. Petersen K., Clausen O.R., Korstgard J.A. Evolution of a salt-related listric growth fault near the D-1 well, block 5605, Danish North Sea: displacement history and salt kinematics. Journal of Structural Geology 1992, 14(5):565-577.
64. Rank-Friend M., Elders C.F. The evolution and growth of Central graben salt structures, Salt Dome Province, Danish North Sea. 3D Seismic Techonology 2004, 149-165. Geological Society Memoir. R.J. Davies, J.A. Cartwright, S.A. Stewart, M. Lappin, J.R. Underhill (Eds.).
65. Rasmussen E.S. Neogene inversion of the Central Graben and Ringkøbing-Fyn High, Denmark. Tectonophysics 2009, 465:84-97.
66. Rasmussen E.S. The interplay between true eustatic sea-level changes, tectonics, and climatic changes: what is the dominating factor in sequence formation of the upper Oligocene-Miocene succession in the eastern North Sea Basin, Denmark?. Global and Planetary Change 2004, 41(1):15-30.
67. Rasmussen E.S. Stratigraphy and depositional evolution of the uppermost Oligocene-Miocene succession in western Denmark. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 2004, 51(2):89-109.
68. Rasmussen E.S., Dybkjær K. Excurtion: upper Oligocene-lower Miocene storm and tidal dominated deposits at Lillebælt and Vejle Fjord, Denmark. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Report 1999, 1999/52. 76 pp.
69. Rasmussen E.S., Dybkjær K. Sequence stratigraphy of the upper Oligocene-lower Miocene of eastern Jylland, Denmark: role of structural relief and variable sediment supply in controlling sequence development. Sedimentology 2005, 52(1):25-63.
70. Redfield T.F., Torsvik T.H., Andriessen P.A.M., Gabrielsen R.H. Mesozoic and Cenozoic tectonics of the Møre Trøndelag Fault Complex, central Norway: constraints from new apatite fission track data. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 2004, 29:673-682.
71. Redfield T.F., Braathen A., Gabrielsen R.H., Osmundsen P.T., Torsvik T.H., Andriessen P.A.M. Late Mesozoic to early Cenozoic components of vertical separation across the Møre-Trøndelag fault comples, Norway. Tectonophysics 2005, 395:233-249.
72. Rohrman M., van der Beek P.A., Andriessen P.A.M., Cloetingh S. Meso Cenozoic morphotectonic evolution of southern Norway: neogene domal uplift inferred from apatite fission track thermochronology. Tectonics 1995, 14:704-718.
73. Schiøler P., Andsbjerg J., Clausen O.R., Dam G., Dybkjær K., Hamberg L., Heilmann-Clausen C., Johannessen E.P., Kristensen L.E., Prince I., Rasmussen J.A. Lithostratigraphy of the Palaeogene-lower Neogene succession of the Danish North Sea. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Bulletin 2007, 12:1-77.
74. Spjeldnæs N. Palaeogeography and Facies distribution in the Tertiary of Denmark and Surrounding Areas. Geological Survey of Norway 1975, 316:289-311.
75. Stratford W., Thybo H., Faleide J.I., Olesen O., Tryggvason A. New Moho map for southern Norway. Geophysical Journal International 2009, 178:1755-1765.
76. Suggate R.P. Relations between depth of burial, vitrinite reflectance and geothermal gradient. Journal of Petroleum Geology 1998, 21:5-32.
77. Sweeney J.J., Burnham A.K. Evaluation of a simple model of vitrinite reflectance based on chemical kinetics. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin 1990, 74:1559-1570.
78. Ter-Borch N. Geological map of Denmark. Structural map of Top Chalk Group (1:500000). Geological Survey Denmark 1990, Map Series 7.
79. Vandenberghe N., Brinkhuis H., Steurbaut E. The Eocene/Oligocene boundary in the North Sea area: a sequence stratigraphic approach. From Greenhouse to Icehouse. The Marine Eocene-Oligocene Transition 2003, 419-437. Columbia University Press. D.R. Prothero, L.C. Ivany, E.A. Nesbitt (Eds.).
80. Vejbæk O.V., Andersen C. Post mid-Cretaceous inversion tectonics in the Danish Central Graben. Bulletin of the Geological Society of Denmark 2002, 49:129-144.
81. Vejbæk O.V., Bidstrup T., Britze P., Erlstroem M., Rasmussen E.S., Sivhed U. Chalk structure maps of the Central and eastern North Sea. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, Report 2003, 106. 55 pp.
82. Vejbæk O.V., Bidstrup T., Britze P., Erlstroem M., Rasmussen E.S., Sivhed U. Chalk depth structure maps, Central to Eastern North Sea, Denmark. Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland Bulletin 2007, 9-12.
83. Whipple K.X., Kirby E., Brocklehurst S.H. Geomorphic limits to climate-induced increases in topographic relief. Nature 1999, 401:39-43.
84. Via R.K., Thomas D.J. Evolution of Atlantic thermohaline circulation: early Oligocene onset of deep-water production in the North Atlantic. Geology 2006, 34:441-444.
85. Weidle C., Maupin V. An upper-mantle S-wave velocity model for Northern Europe from Love and Rayleigh group velocities. Geophysical Journal International 2008, 175:1154-1168.
86. Weidle C., Maupin V., Ritter J., Kværna T., Schweitzer J., Balling N., Thybo H., Faleide J.I. MAGNUS (MAntle investiGations of Norwegian Uplift Structure)-a flying start into Topo Europe. Geophysical Research Abstracts 2007, 9:3820.
87. Zachos J.C., Dickens G.R., Zeebe R.E. An early Cenozoic perspective on greenhouse warming and carbon-cycle dynamics. Nature 2008, 451(7176):279-283.
88. Ziegler P. Geological Atlas of Western and Central Europe 1990, Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B.V., The Hague, 238 pp.