Earthworm populations in a northern U.S. Cornbelt soil are not affected by long-term cultivation of Bt maize expressing Cry1Ab and Cry3Bb1 proteins

Soil Biology and Biochemistry

Volumn 42, Issue 8, 2010, Pages 1284-1292

  Zeilinger, Adam R ^a   Andow, David A ^a   Zwahlen, Claudia ^a,b   Stotzky, Guenther ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF NEUCHÂTEL   (Switzerland)

^c NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Bacillus thuringiensis; Earthworms; Genetically modified crops; Lumbricidae; Non target effects; Transgenic crops

Indexed keywords

BACILLUS THURINGIENSIS; GENETICALLY MODIFIED CROPS; LUMBRICIDAE; NON-TARGET EFFECTS; TRANSGENIC CROPS;

BACTERIOLOGY; CROPS; ECOSYSTEMS; POPULATION STATISTICS; SOILS;

PLANTS (BOTANY);

BACTERIUM; BIOGEOCHEMISTRY; BIOMASS; CULTIVATION; EARTHWORM; FIELD SURVEY; MAIZE; POPULATION DISTRIBUTION; PROTEIN; SOIL ECOSYSTEM; SOIL MICROORGANISM; TRANSGENIC PLANT;

CORN BELT; UNITED STATES;

EID: 77954819263     PISSN: 00380717     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.soilbio.2010.04.004     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Ahl Goy P., Warren G., Whit J., Pivalle L., Fearing P.L., Vlachos D. Interaction of insect tolerant maize with organisms in the ecosystem. Proceedings of the Key Biosafety Aspects of Genetically Modified Organisms 1995, 50-53. Blackwell, Berlin, Berlin-Dahlem.
2. Ahmad A., Wilde G.E., Zhu K.Y. Detectability of Coleopteran-specific Cry3Bb1 protein in soil and its effect on non-target surface and below-ground arthropods. Environmental Entomology 2005, 34:385-394.
3. Ahmad A., Wilde G.E., Zhu K.Y. Evaluation of effects of Coleopteran-specific Cry3Bb1 protein on earthworms exposed to soil containing corn roots or biomass. Environmental Entomology 2006, 35:976-985.
4. Andow D.A. Negative and positive data, statistical power, and confidence intervals. Environmental Biosafety Research 2003, 2:75-80.
5. Andow D.A., Hilbeck A. Science-based risk assessment for non-target effects of transgenic crops. Bioscience 2004, 57:637-649.
6. Andow D.A., Lovei G.L., Arpaia S. Ecological risk assessment for Bt crops. Nature Biotechnology 2006, 24:749-751.
7. Baumgarte S., Tebbe C.C. Field studies on the environmental fate of the Cry1Ab Bt-toxin produced by transgenic maize (MON810) and its effect on bacterial communities in the maize rhizosphere. Molecular Ecology 2005, 14:2539-2551.
8. Baveco J.M., De Roos A.M. Assessing the impact of pesticides on Lumbricid populations: an individual based modelling approach. Journal of Applied Ecology 1996, 33:1451-1468.
9. Bartlett M.D., Harris J.A., James I.T., Ritz K. Inefficiency of mustard extraction technique for assessing size and structure of earthworm communities in UK pasture. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2006, 38:2990-2992.
10. Berry E.C., Karlen D.L. Comparison of alternative farming systems. II. Earthworm population density and species diversity. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 1993, 8:21-26.
11. Bhadauria T., Ramakrishnan P.S. Earthworm population dynamics and contribution to nutrient cycling during cropping and fallow phases of shifting agriculture (jhum) in North-East India. Journal of Applied Ecology 1989, 26:505-520.
12. Bhadauria T., Ramakrishnan P.S., Srivastava K.N. Population dynamics of earthworms during crop rotation under rainfed agriculture in central Himalayas, India. Applied Soil Ecology 1997, 6:205-215.
13. Birch A.N.E., Griffiths B.S., Caul S., Thompson J., Heckmann L.H., Krogh P.H., Cortet J. The role of laboratory, glasshouse, and field scale experiments in understanding the interactions between genetically modified crops and soil ecosystems: a review of the ECOGEN project. Pedobiologia 2007, 51:251-260.
14. Binet F., Hallaire V., Curmi P. Agricultural practices and the spatial distribution of earthworms in maize fields: relationships between earthworm abundance, maize plants, and soil compaction. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 1997, 29:577-583.
15. Bohlen P.J., Edwards W.M., Edwards C.A. Earthworm community structure and diversity in experimental agricultural watersheds in Northeastern Ohio. Plant and Soil 1995, 170:233-239.
16. Bouché M.B. Stratégies lombriciennes. Ecological Bulletins 1977, 25:122-132. (in French with English abstract).
17. Brown G.G., Edwards C.A., Brussaard L. How earthworms affect plant growth: Burrowing into the mechanisms. Earthworm Ecology 2004, 13-50. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. C.A. Edwards (Ed.).
18. Capowiez Y., Bastardie F., Costagliola G. Sublethal effects of imidacloprid on the burrowing behaviour of two earthworm species: modifications of the 3D burrow systems in artificial cores and consequences on gas diffusion in soil. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2006, 38:285-293.
19. Chan K.Y., Munro K. Evaluating mustard extracts for earthworm sampling. Pedobiologia 2001, 45:272-278.
20. Clark B.W., Phillips T.A., Coats J.R. Environmental fate and effects of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) proteins from transgenic crops: a review. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2005, 53:4643-4653.
21. Clark B.W., Coats J.R. Subacute effects of Cry1Ab Bt corn litter on the earthworm Eisenia fetida and the springtail Folsomia candida. Environmental Entomology 2006, 35:1121-1129.
22. Cook A.G., Critchley B.R., Critchley U., Perfect T.J., Yeadon R. Effects of cultivation and DDT on earthworm activity in a forest soil in the sub-humid tropics. Journal of Applied Ecology 1980, 17:21-29.
23. Cortet J., Andersen M.N., Caul S., Griffiths B., Joffre R., Lacroix B., Sausse C., Thompson J., Krogh P.H. Decomposition processes under Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) maize: results of a multi-site experiment. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2006, 38:195-199.
24. Curry J.P. Factors affecting the abundance of earthworms in soils. Earthworm Ecology 2004, 91-114. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. C.A. Edwards (Ed.).
25. Eriksen-Hamel N.S., Whalen J.K. Impacts of earthworms on soil nutrients and plant growth in soybean and maize agroecosystems. Agriculture, Ecosystems, and Environment 2007, 120:442-448.
26. Escher N., Käch B., Nentwig W. Decomposition of transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis maize by microorganisms and woodlice Porcellio scaber (Crustacea: Isopoda). Basic and Applied Ecology 2000, 1:161-169.
27. Fitzpatick L.C., Muratti-Ortiz J.F., Venables B.J., Goven A.J. Comparative toxicity in earthworms Eisenia fetida and Lumbricus terrestris exposed to cadmium nitrate using artificial soil and filter paper protocols. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 1996, 57:63-68.
28. Flores S., Saxena D., Stotzky G. Transgenic Bt plants decompose less in soil than non-Bt plants. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2005, 37:1073-1082.
29. Fragoso C., Brown G.G., Patron J.C., Blanchart E., Lavelle P., Pashanasi B., Senapati B., Kumar T. Agricultural intensification, soil biodiversity and agroecosystem function in the tropics: the role of earthworms. Applied Soil Ecology 1997, 6:17-35.
30. Fragoso C., Kanyonyo J., Moreno A., Senapati B., Blanchart E., Rodriguez C. A survey of tropical earthworms: taxonomy, biogeography, and environmental plasticity. Earthworm Management in Tropical Agroecosystems 1999, 1-26. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, UK. P. Lavelle, L. Brussard, P. Hendrix (Eds.).
31. Griffiths B.S., Caul S., Thompson J., Birch A.N.E., Scrimgeour C., Cortet J., Foggo A., Hackett C.A., Krogh P.H. Soil microbial and faunal community responses to Bt-maize and insecticide in two soils. Journal of Environmental Quality 2006, 35:734-741.
32. Griffiths B.S., Heckmann L.H., Caul S., Thompson J., Scrimgeour C., Krogh P.H. Varietal effects of eight paired lines of transgenic Bt maize and near-isogenic non-Bt maize on soil microbial and nematode community structure. Plant Biotechnology Journal 2007, 5:60-68.
33. Griffiths B.S., Caul S., Thompson J., Birch A.N.E., Cortet J., Andersen M.N., Krogh P.H. Microbial and microfaunal community structure in cropping systems with genetically modified plants. Pedobiologia 2007, 51:195-206.
34. Gunn A. The use of mustard to estimate earthworm populations. Pedobiologia 1992, 36:65-67.
35. Hale C.M., Reich P.B., Frelich L.E. Allometric equations for estimation of ash-free dry mass from length measurements for selected European earthworm species (Lumbricidae) in the Western Great Lakes Region. American Midland Naturalist 2004, 151:179-185.
36. Hale C.M., Frelich L.E., Reich P.B. Exotic European earthworm invasion dynamics in northern hardwood forests in Minnesota, USA. Ecological Applications 2005, 15:848-860.
37. Hilbeck A., Schmidt J.E.U. Another view on Bt proteins - how specific are they and what else might they do?. Biopesticides International 2006, 2:1-50.
38. Hilbeck A., Arpaia S., Birch A.N.E., Chen Y., Fontes E.M.G., Lang A., Le T.T.H., Lovei G.L., Manachini B., Nguyen T.T.C., Nguyen V.H., Nguyen V.T., Phan V.L., Pham V.T., Pires C.S.S., Sujii E.R., Trac K.L., Underwood E., Wheatley R.E., Wilson L.J., Zwahlen C., Andow D.A. Non-target and biological diversity risk assessment. Challenges and Opportunities with Bt Cotton in Vietnam 2008, vol. 4:115-137. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, UK. D.A. Andow, A. Hilbeck, V.T. Nguyen (Eds.).
39. Holdsworth A.R., Frelich L.E., Reich P.B. Regional extent of an ecosystem engineer: earthworm invasion in northern hardwood forests. Ecological Applications 2007, 17:1666-1677.
40. Hönemann L., Zurbrügg C., Nentwig W. Effects of Bt-corn decomposition on the composition of the soil meso- and macrofauna. Applied Soil Ecology 2008, 40:203-209.
41. Hubbard V.C., Jordan D., Stecker J.A. Earthworm response to rotation and tillage in a Missouri claypan soil. Biology and Fertility of Soils 1999, 29:343-347.
42. Huerta E., Rodriguez-Olan J., Evia-Castillo I., Montejo-Meneses E., de la Cruz-Mondragon M., Garcia-Hernandez R., Uribe S. Earthworms and soil properties in Tabasco, Mexico. European Journal of Soil Biology 2007, 43:190-195.
43. Icoz I., Stotzky G. Cry3Bb1 protein from Bacillus thuringiensis in root exudates and biomass of transgenic corn does not persist in soil. Transgenic Research 2007, 17:609-620.
44. Icoz I., Stotzky G. Fate and effects of insect-resistant Bt crops in soil ecosystems. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2008, 40:559-586.
45. Icoz I., Saxena D., Andow D.A., Zwahlen C., Stotzky G. Microbial populations and enzyme activities in soil in situ under transgenic corn expressing Cry proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis. Journal of Environmental Quality 2008, 37:647.
46. Jiménez J., Lavelle P., Decaëns T. The efficiency of soil hand-sorting in assessing the abundance and biomass of earthworm communities. Its usefulness in population dynamics and cohort analysis studies. European Journal of Soil Biology 2006, 42:S225-S230.
47. Jordan D., Miles R.J., Hubbard V.C., Lorenz T. Effect of management practices and cropping systems on earthworm abundance and microbial activity in Sanborn Field: a 115-year-old agricultural field. Pedobiologia 2004, 48:99-110.
48. Jung H.G., Sheaffer C.C. Influence of Bt transgenes on cell wall lignification and digestibility of maize stover for silage. Crop Science 2004, 44:1781-1789.
49. Krogh P.H., Griffiths B., Demšar D., Bohanec M., Debeljak M., Andersen M.N., Sausse C., Birch A.N.E., Caul S., Holmstrup M. Responses by earthworms to reduced tillage in herbicide tolerant maize and Bt maize cropping systems. Pedobiologia 2007, 51:219-227.
50. Lang, A., Arndt, M., Beck, R., Bauchhenβ, J., Pommer, G., 2006. Monitoring of the Environmental Effects of the Bt Gene. Bavarian State Research Center for Agriculture, No. 2006/10. Vottinger Strasse 38, 85354 Freising-Weihenstephan, Germany.
51. Latham J.R., Wilson A.K., Steinbrecher R.A. The mutational consequences of plant transformation. Journal of Biomedicine and Biotechnology 2006, 2006:1-7.
52. Lavelle P., Bignell D., Lepage M., Wolters W., Roger P., Ineson P., Heal O.W., Dhillion S. Soil function in a changing world: the role of invertebrate ecosystem engineers. European Journal of Soil Biology 1997, 33:159-193.
53. Lawrence A.P., Bowers M.A. A test of the 'hot' mustard extraction method of sampling earthworms. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2002, 34:549-552.
54. Liu B., Cui J., Meng J., Hu W., Luo J., Zheng Y. Effects of transgenic Bt+ CpTI cotton on the growth and reproduction of earthworm Eisenia foetida. Frontiers in Bioscience: A Journal and Virtual Library 2009, 14:4008-4014.
55. Liu B., Wang L., Zeng Q., Meng J., Hu W., Li X., Zhou K., Xue K., Liu D., Zheng Y. Assessing effects of transgenic Cry1Ac cotton on the earthworm Eisenia fetida. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2009, 41:1841-1846.
56. Ma W., Bodt J. Differences in toxicity of the insecticide chlorpyrifos to six species of earthworms (Oligochaeta: Lumbricidae) in standardized soil tests. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 1993, 50:864-870.
57. Masoero F., Moschini M., Rossi F., Prandini A., Pietri A. Nutritive value, mycotoxin contamination and in vitro rumen fermentation of normal and genetically modified corn (Cry1Ab) grown in Northern Italy. Maydica 1999, 44:205-209.
58. McLean M.A., Parkinson D. Soil impacts of the epigeic earthworm Dendrobaena octaedra on organic matter and microbial activity in lodgepole pine forest. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 1997, 27:1907-1913.
59. Melillo J., Aber J., Muratore J. Nitrogen and lignin control of hardwood leaf litter decomposition dynamics. Ecology 1982, 63:621-626.
60. Mendonça-Hagler L.C., de Mielo I.S., Valadares-Inglis M.C., Anyango B.M., Siqueira J.O., Pham V.T., Wheatley R.E. Non-target and biodiversity impacts in soil. Methodologies for Assessing Bt Cotton in Brazil 2006, vol. 2:225-260. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, U.K. A. Hilbeck, D.A. Andow, E.M.G. Fontes (Eds.).
61. Morgan J.E., Morgan A.J. The accumulation of metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn, and Ca) by two ecologically contrasting earthworm species (Lumbricus rubellus and Aporrectodea caliginosa): implications for ecotoxicological testing. Applied Soil Ecology 1999, 13:9-20.
62. Mungai N.W., Motavalli P.P., Nelson K.A., Kremer R.J. Differences in yields, residue composition and N mineralization dynamics of Bt and non-Bt maize. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 2005, 73:101-109.
63. [NASS] National Agricultural Statistics Service NASS Acreage Report 2008, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Available online:, (accessed 23.03.09). http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/usda/current/Acre/Acre-06-30-2008.pdf.
64. Ortiz-Ceballos A.I., Fragoso C. Earthworm populations under tropical maize cultivation: the effect of mulching with velvetbean. Biology and Fertility of Soils 2004, 39:438-445.
65. Pelosi C., Bertrand M., Capowiez Y., Boizard H., Roger-Estrade J. Earthworm collection from agricultural fields: comparisons of selected expellants in presence/absence of hand-sorting. European Journal of Soil Biology 2009, 45:176-183.
66. Pérez-Losada M., Ricoy M., Marshall J.C., Domínguez J. Phylogenetic assessment of the earthworm Aporrectodea caliginosa species complex (Oligochaeta: Lumbricidae) based on mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 2009, 52:293-302.
67. Pham V.T., Hoang N.B., Anyango B., Zwahlen C., Manachini B., Andow D.A., Wheatley R.E. Potential effects of transgenic cotton on soil ecosystem processes in Vietnam. Challenges and Opportunities with Bt Cotton in Vietnam 2008, vol. 4:258-273. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxfordshire, UK. A. Hilbeck, D.A. Andow, V.T. Nguyen (Eds.).
68. Poerschmann J., Gathmann A., Augustin J., Langer U., Górecki T. Molecular composition of leaves and stems of genetically modified Bt and near-isogenic non-Bt maize-characterization of lignin patterns. Journal of Environmental Quality 2005, 34:1508-1518.
69. Reinecke A.J. The ecology of earthworms in southern Africa. Earthworm Ecology: From Darwin to Vermiculture 1983, 195-207. Chapman and Hall, London. J.E. Satchell (Ed.).
70. Reinecke A.J., Reinecke S.A. Earthworms as test organisms in ecotoxicological assessment of toxicant impacts on ecosystems. Earthworm Ecology 2004, 299-320. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. C.A. Edwards (Ed.).
71. Reynolds J.W. The Earthworms (Lumbricidae and Sparganophilidae) of Ontario 1977, The Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto. Canada, 141 pp.
72. Sanchez-Bayo F., Yamashita H., Osaka R., Yoneda M., Goka K. Ecological effects of imidacloprid on arthropod communities in and around a vegetable crop. Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part B 2007, 42:279-286.
73. SAS Institute Inc SAS/STAT 9.1 User's Guide 2004, SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC.
74. Satchell J.E. Earthworm ecology in forest soils. Earthworm Ecology: From Darwin to Vermiculture 1983, 161-177. Chapman and Hall, London. J.E. Satchell (Ed.).
75. Saxena D., Stotzky G. Bt corn has a higher lignin content than non-Bt corn. American Journal of Botany 2001, 88:1704-1706.
76. Saxena D., Stotzky G. Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxin released from root exudates and biomass of Bt corn has no apparent effect on earthworms, nematodes, protozoa, bacteria, and fungi in soil. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 2001, 33:1225-1230.
77. Schrader S., Münchenberg T., Baumgarte S., Tebbe C.C. Earthworms of different functional groups affect the fate of the Bt-toxin Cry1Ab from transgenic maize in soil. European Journal of Soil Biology 2008, 44:283-289.
78. Schwert D.P. Oligochaeta: Lumbricidae. Soil Biology Guide 1990, 341-356. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, NY. D.L. Dindal (Ed.).
79. Shipitalo M.J., Le Bayon R. Quantifying the effects of earthworms on soil aggregation and porosity. Earthworm Ecology 2004, 183-200. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. C.A. Edwards (Ed.).
80. Sinha B., Hadauria T., Ramakrishnan P., Saxena K., Maikhuri R. Impact of landscape modification on earthworm diversity and abundance in the Hariyali sacred landscape, Garhwal Himalaya. Pedobiologia 2003, 47:357-370.
81. Smeaton T.C., Daly A.N., Cranwell J.M. Earthworm population responses to cultivation and irrigation in a South Australian soil. Pedobiologia 2003, 47:379-385.
82. Söchtig W., Larink O. Effect of soil compaction on activity and biomass of endogeic Lumbricids in arable soils. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 1992, 24:1595-1599.
83. Spurgeon D.J., Weeks J.M. Evaluation of factors influencing results from laboratory toxicity tests with earthworms. Advances in Earthworm Ecotoxicology. Proceedings from the Second International Workshop on Earthworm Ecotoxicology 1998, 15-25. SETAC, Pensacola, FL. S. Sheppard, J. Bembridge, M. Holmstrup, L. Posthuma (Eds.).
84. Spurgeon D.J., Weeks J.M., Van Gestel C.A.M. A summary of eleven years progress in earthworm ecotoxicology. Pedobiologia 2003, 47:588-606.
85. Stotzky G. Persistence and biological activity in soil of the insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis, especially from transgenic plants. Plant and Soil 2004, 266:77-89.
86. Tapp H., Stotzky G. Persistence of the insecticidal toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki in soil. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 1998, 30:471-476.
87. Tarkalson D., Kachman S., Knops J., Thies J., Wortmann C. Decomposition of Bt and non-Bt corn hybrid residues in the field. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 2008, 80:211-222.
88. Taylor B.R., Parkinson D., Parsons W.F.J. Nitrogen and lignin content as predictors of litter decay rates: a microcosm test. Ecology 1989, 70:97-104.
89. Tripathi G., Bhardwaj P. Seasonal changes in population of some selected earthworm species and soil nutrients in cultivated agroecosystem. Journal of Environmental Biology 2004, 25:221-226.
90. Vercesi M.L., Krogh P.H., Holmstrup M. Can Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) corn residues and Bt-corn plants affect life-history traits in the earthworm Aporrectodea caliginosa?. Applied Soil Ecology 2006, 32:180-187.
91. Whalen J.K., Parmelee R.W., Edwards C.A. Population dynamics of earthworm communities in corn agroecosystems receiving organic or inorganic fertilizer amendments. Biology and Fertility of Soils 1998, 27:400-407.
92. Zhiping C., Yuhui Q., Baoqing W., Qin X. Influence of agricultural intensification on the earthworm community in arable farmland in the North China Plain. European Journal of Soil Biology 2006, 42:362-366.
93. Zwahlen C., Andow D.A. Field evidence for the exposure of ground beetles to Cry1Ab from transgenic corn. Environmental Biosafety Research 2005, 4:113-117.
94. Zwahlen C., Hilbeck A., Gugerli P., Nentwig W. Degradation of the Cry1Ab protein within transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis corn tissue in the field. Molecular Ecology 2003, 12:765-775.
95. Zwahlen C., Hilbeck A., Howald R., Nentwig W. Effects of transgenic Bt corn litter on the earthworm Lumbricus terrestris. Molecular Ecology 2003, 12:1077-1086.
96. Zwahlen C., Hilbeck A., Nentwig W. Field decomposition of transgenic Bt maize residue and the impact on non-target soil invertebrates. Plant and Soil 2007, 300:245-257.