Institutional logics and institutional pluralism: The contestation of care and science logics in medical education, 1967-2005

Administrative Science Quarterly

Volumn 55, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 114-149

  Dunn, Mary B ^a   Jones, Candace ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN   (United States)

^b BOSTON COLLEGE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 77954252202     PISSN: 00018392     EISSN: 19303815     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.2189/asqu.2010.55.1.114     Document Type: Article

References (128)

1. Abbott, A. 1988 The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
2. Abelmann, W. 2004 The Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology: The First Twenty Five Years 1970-1995. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
3. Abrahamson, E., and M. Eisenman 2008 Employee-management techniques: Transient fads or trending fashions? Administrative Science Quarterly, 53: 719-744.
4. Abrahamson, E., and G. Fairchild 1999 Management fashion: Lifecycles, triggers, and collective learning processes. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44: 708-740.
5. Alexander, J. A., and T. D. D'Aunno 1990 Transformation of institutional environments: Perspectives on the corporatization of U.S. health care. In S. S. Mick (ed.), Innovations in the Organization of Health Care: Insights into Organization Theory: 53-85. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
6. Alexander, J. A., and T. D. D'Aunno 2003 Alternative perspectives on institutional and market dynamics in the U.S. healthcare sector. In S. S. Mick and M. E. Wyttenbach (eds.), Advances in Health Care Organizational Theory: 45-77. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
7. Arky, R. A. 2006 Shattuck Lecture: The family business: To educate. New England Journal of Medicine, 354: 1922-1926.
8. Arky, R. A. 2007 Abe Flexner, where are you? We need you! Transactions of the American Clinical and Climatological Association, 118: 89-96.
9. Barley, S. R., and G. Kunda 1992 Design and devotion: Surges of rational and normative ideologies of control in managerial discourse. Administrative Science Quarterly, 37: 363-399.
10. Barzansky, B., and S. Etzel 2004 Educational programs in U.S. medical schools. Journal of the American Medical Association, 292: 1025-1031.
11. Beck, A. 2004 The Flexner Report and the standardization of American medical education. Journal of the American Medical Association, 291: 2139-2140.
12. Berman, E. P. 2006 Before the professional project: Success and failure at organizing English doctors 1812-1855. Theory and Society, 35: 157-191.
13. Bloom, S. W. 1988 Structure and ideology in medical education: An analysis of resistance to change. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 29: 294-306.
14. Brennan, R. L., and D. J. Prediger 1981 Coefficient kappa: Some uses, misuses, and alternatives. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 41: 687-699.
15. Brieger, G. 1999 A brief overview of the Johns Hopkins medical curriculum. In C. De Angelis (ed.), The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine Curriculum for the Twenty-first Century: 1-20. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
16. Briscoe, F. 2007 Demographic change and institutional transgression: A case study of doctors and the rise of HMOs. Paper presented at the 23rd Colloquium of the European Group for Organizational Studies, Vienna, Austria.
17. Bucher, R., and A. Strauss 1961 Professions in process. American Journal of Sociology, 66: 325-334.
18. Burke, K. 1969 A Rhetoric of Motives. Berkeley: University of California Press. 1989 On Symbols and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
19. Castilla, E. 2007 Dynamic Analysis in the Social Sciences. London: Academic Press.
20. Christakis, N. 1995 The similarity and frequency of proposals to reform U.S. medical education. Journal of the American Medical Association, 274: 706-711.
21. Colombotos, J., and C. Kirchner 1986 Physicians and Social Change. New York: Oxford University Press.
22. Colyvas, J. A., and W. W. Powell 2006 Roads to institutionalization: The remaking of boundaries between public and private science. In B. M. Staw (ed.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 27: 315-363. New York: Elsevier/JAI.
23. Cox, M., and D. M. Irby 2006 A new series on medical education. New England Journal of Medicine, 355: 1375-1376.
24. D'Aunno, T. D., R. I. Sutton, and R. H. Price 1991 Isomorphism and external support in conflicting institutional environments: A study of drug abuse treatment units. Academy of Management Journal, 34: 636-661.
25. Davis, G. F., and H. R. Greve 1997 Corporate elite networks and governance changes in the 1980's. American Journal of Sociology, 103: 1-37.
26. Denzin, N. K., and C. J. Mettlin 1968 Incomplete professionalization: The case of pharmacy. Social Forces, 46: 375-381.
27. DeVellis, R. F. 2003 Scale Development: Theory and Applications. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
28. DiMaggio, P. J. 1991 Constructing an organizational field as a professional project: U.S. art museums, 1920-1940. In W. W. Powell and P. J. DiMaggio (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 267-292. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
29. DiMaggio, P. J., and W. W. Powell 1983 The iron cage revisited. Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48: 147-160.
30. Downs, A. 1972 Up and down with ecology- The issue attention cycle. Public Interest, 28: 38-50.
31. Dunn, M. B. 2006 Socialization for innovation: The role of developmental networks. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Organization Studies Department, Wallace E. Carroll School of Management, Boston College.
32. Edelman, L. B. 1992 Legal ambiguity and symbolic structures: Organizational mediation of law. American Journal of Sociology, 97: 1531-1576.
33. Edelman, L. B., S. R. Fuller, and I. Mara-Drita 2001 Diversity rhetoric and the managerialization of law. American Journal of Sociology, 106: 1589-1641.
34. Edelman, L. B., and R. Stryker 2005 A sociological approach to law and the economy. In N. Smelser and R. Swedberg (eds.), The Handbook of Economic Sociology, 2d ed.: 527-551. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
35. Edelman, L. B., C. Uggen, and H. Erlanger 1999 The endogeneity of legal regulation: Grievance procedures as rational myth. American Journal of Sociology, 105: 406-454.
36. Fiss, P. C., and E. J. Zajac 2006 The symbolic management of strategic change: Sensegiving via framing and decoupling. Academy of Management Journal, 49: 1173-1193.
37. Flexner, A. 1910 Medical Education in the United States and Canada. New York: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
38. Fligstein, N. 1987 The intraorganizational power struggle: Rise of finance personnel to top leadership in large corporations, 1919-1979. American Sociological Review, 52: 44-58.
39. Fligstein, N. 1990 The Transformation of Corporate Control. Boston: Harvard University Press.
40. Friedland, R., and R. Alford 1991 Bringing society back in: Symbols, practices and institutional contradictions. In W. W. Powell and P. J. DiMaggio (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 232-263. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
41. Friedson, E. 1970 Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of Medical Care. New York: Atherton Press.
42. Friedson, E. 2001 Professionalism: The Third Logic. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
43. Galperin, R. V. 2010 From context to agent: Organizational intervention and professional competition-The case of retail clinics. Working paper, Sloan School of Management, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
44. Galvin, T. 2002 Examining institutional change: Evidence from the founding dynamics of U.S. health care interest associations. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 673-696.
45. Ghaziani, A., and M. J. Ventresca 2005 Keywords and cultural change: Frame analysis of business model public talk, 1975-2000. Sociological Forum, 20: 523-559.
46. Ghisletta, P., and D. Spini 2004 An introduction to generalized estimating equations and an application to assess selectivity effects in a longitudinal study on very old individuals. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 29: 421-437.
47. Gill, G. 1984 The end of the physicianscientist? American Scholar, 53: 353-369.
48. Goodrick, E., and T. Reay 2009 Florence Nightingale endures: Legitimizing a new professional role identity. Journal of Management Studies, 47: 55-84.
49. Graham, R., R. Roberts, D. Ostergaard, N. Kahn, P. Pugno, and L. Green 2002 Family practice in the United States: A status report. Journal of the American Medical Association, 288: 1097-1101.
50. Greenwood, R., and C. R. Hinings 1996 Understanding radical organizational change: Bringing together the old and new institutionalism. Academy of Management Review, 21: 1022-1054.
51. Greenwood, R., R. Suddaby, and C. R. Hinings 2002 Theorizing change: The role of professional associations in the transformation of institutionalized fields. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 58-80.
52. Guillén, M. F. 1994 Models of Management: Work, Authority, and Organization in a Comparative Perspective. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
53. Gujarati, D. N. 2006 Essentials of Econometrics. Boston: McGraw Hill.
54. Gutierrez, C., and P. Scheid 2002 The history of family medicine and its impact in US health care delivery. Paper presented at Primary Care Symposium, University of California, San Diego, CA, May 29.
55. Haveman, H., and H. Rao 1997 Structuring a theory of moral sentiments: Institutional and organizational coevolution in the early thrift industry. American Journal of Sociology, 102: 1606-1651.
56. Heimer, C. A. 1999 Competing institutions: Law, medicine, and family in neonatal intensive care. Law and Society Review, 33: 17-66.
57. Hughes, E. C. 1936 The ecological aspect of institutions. American Sociological Review, 1: 180-189.
58. Institute of Medicine 1988 The Future of Public Health. misctextWashington, D/misctextC: National Academy Press.
59. Institute of Medicine 1994 America's Health in Transition: Protecting and Improving Quality. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
60. Institute of Medicine 2003 Health Professions Education: A Bridge to Quality. A. C. Greiner and E. Knebel (eds.), Committee on the Health Professions Education Summit. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
61. Jaffe, E. 1996 The early history of the Albert Einstein College of Medicine: Special article commemorating the fortieth anniversary of Albert Einstein College of Medicine. Einstein Quarterly Journal of Biology and Medicine, 13: 1.
62. Johnson, H. 2004 Introduction. In W. Abelmann (ed.), The Harvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology: The first twenty five years 1970-1995: xix-xxii. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63. Johnson, L. B. 1964 Remarks upon receiving report of the President's Commission on Heart Disease, Cancer and Stroke. Lyndon B. Johnson Presidential Archives. Retrieved from http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=26751.
64. Jones, C. 2001 Coevolution of entrepreneurial careers, institutional rules and competitive dynamics in American film, 1895-1920. Organization Studies, 6: 911-944.
65. Jones, C., and R. Livne-Tarandach 2008 Designing a frame: Rhetorical strategies of architects. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 29: 1-25.
66. Jones, C., R. Livne-Tarandach, and L. Balachandra 2010 Rhetoric that wins clients: Entrepreneurial firms' use of institutional logics when competing for resources. In W. Sine and R. David (eds.), Research in the Sociology of Work. Amsterdam: Elsevier (forthcoming).
67. Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) 1968 Medical education in the United States. Journal of the American Medical Association, 206: 1988-2022.
68. Kimberly, J. R. 1981 Managerial innovation. In P. C. Nystrom and W. H. Starbuck (eds.), Handbook of Organizational Design, 1: 84-104. New York: Oxford University Press.
69. Kraatz, M., and E. Block 2008 Organizational implications of institutional pluralism. In R. Greenwood, C. Oliver, K. Sahlin-Andersson, and R. Suddaby (eds.), The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism: 243-275. London: Sage.
70. Krippendorff, K. 2004 Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology, 2d ed. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
71. Leblebici, H., G. R. Salancik, A. Copay, and T. King 1991 Institutional change and the transformation of interorganizational fields: An organizational history of the U.S. radio broadcasting industry. Administrative Science Quarterly, 35: 333-363.
72. Leicht, K., and M. L. Fennell 2008 Institutionalism and the professions. In R. Greenwood, C. Oliver, K. Sahlin-Andersson, and R. Suddaby (eds.), The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism: 431-438. London: Sage.
73. Lounsbury, M. 2002 Institutional transformation and status mobility: The professionalization of the field of finance. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 255-266.
74. Lounsbury, M. 2007 A tale of two cities: Competing logics and practice variation in the professionalizing of mutual funds. Academy of Management Journal, 50: 289-307.
75. Ludmerer, K. 1999 Time to Heal: American Medical Education from the Turn of the Century to the Era of Managed Care. New York: Oxford University Press.
76. MacBride, O. 1973 An Overview of the Health Professions Educational Assistance Act, 1963-1971. Report No. A1. New Brunswick, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
77. Maguire, S., C. Hardy, and T. Lawrence 2004 Institutional entrepreneurship in emerging fields: HIV/ AIDS treatment advocacy in Canada. Academy of Management Journal, 47: 657-680.
78. Melnick, D. 2006 From defending the walls to improving global medical education: Fifty years of collaboration between the ECFMG and the NBME. Academic Medicine, 81: s30-s35.
79. Melnick, D. E., G. F. Dillon, and D. B. Swanson 2002 Medical licensing examinations in the United States. Journal of Dental Education, 66: 595-599.
80. Merritt, A. 2009 Retail health clinics move to treat complex illnesses, rankling doctors. Wall Street Journal, September 10, Health Edition, B1.
81. Merton, R. W. 1968 Social Theory and Social Structure. New York: Free Press.
82. Meyer, J. W., J. Boli, G. M. Thomas, and F. O. Ramirez 1997 World society and the nationstate. American Journal of Sociology, 103: 144-181.
83. Meyer, R. E., and G. Hammerschmid 2006 Changing institutional logics and executive identities: A managerial challenge to public administration in Austria. American Behavioral Scientist, 49: 1000-1014.
84. Mick, S. S., and M. E. Wyttenbach 2003 Themes, discovery and rediscovery. In S. S. Mick and M. E Wyttenbach (eds.), Advances in Health Care Organization Theory: 1-22. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
85. Mills, C. W. 1940 Situated actions and vocabularies of motive. American Sociological Review, 5: 904-913.
86. Mullan, F. 2002 Big Doctoring in America: Profiles in Primary Care. Berkeley: University of California Press.
87. Neuman, W. R. 1990 The threshold of public attention. Public Opinion Quarterly, 54: 159-176.
88. Nigam, A., and W. Ocasio 2009 Event attention, environmental sensemaking, and change in institutional logics: An inductive analysis of the effects of public attention to Clinton's health care reform initiative.Organization Science, published online before print December 30, 2009, DOI:10.1287/orsc.1090.0490.
89. Ocasio, W. 1997 Toward an attention-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 18: 187-206.
90. Ocasio, W., and J. Joseph 2005 Cultural adaptation and institutional change: The evolution of vocabularies of corporate governance, 1972-2003. Poetics, 33: 163-178.
91. Peabody, F. W. 1927 The care of the patient. Journal of the American Medical Association, 88: 877-882.
92. Powell, W. W. 1991 Expanding the scope of institutional analysis. In W. W. Powell and P. J. DiMaggio (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 183-203. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
93. Purdy, J. M., and B. Gray 2009 Conflicting logics, mechanisms of diffusion, and multilevel dynamics in emerging institutional fields. Academy of Management Journal, 52: 355-380.
94. Rao, H., P. Monin, and R. Durand 2003 Institutional change in Toque Ville: Nouvelle cuisine as an identity movement in French gastronomy. American Journal of Sociology, 108: 795-843.
95. Reay, T., and C. R. Hinings 2005 The recomposition of an organizational field: Health care in Alberta. Organization Studies, 26: 351-384.
96. Reay, T., and C. R. Hinings 2009 Managing the rivalry of competing institutional logics. Organization Studies, 30: 629-653.
97. Rosenberg, C. E. 1987 The Care of Strangers: The Rise of America's Hospital System. New York: Basic Books.
98. Rothstein, W. G. 1987 American Medical Schools and the Practice of Medicine, a History. New York: Oxford University Press.
99. Ruef, M. 1999 Social ontology and the dynamics of organizational forms: Creating market actors in the healthcare field 1966-1994. Social Forces, 77: 1403-1432.
100. Ruef, M. 2000 The emergence of organizational forms: A community ecology approach. American Journal of Sociology, 106: 658-714.
101. Ruef, M. 2002 For whom the bell tolls: Ecological perspectives on industrial decline and resurgence. Industrial and Corporate Change, 13 (1): 61-89.
102. Schneiberg, M., and E. S. Clemens 2006 The typical tools for the job: Research strategies in institutional analysis. Sociological Theory, 24: 195-227.
103. Schweitzer, S. 2007 Veterinary schools turn increasingly female: Surge tied to flexibility, attractiveness of field. Boston Globe, August 22.
104. Scott, W. R., and J. Meyer 1983 Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
105. Scott, W. R., M. Ruef, P. Mendel, and C. Coronna 2000 Institutional Change and Healthcare Organizations: From Professional Dominance to Managed Care. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
106. Seo, M. G., and W. E. D. Creed 2002 Institutional contradictions, praxis, and institutional change. Academy of Management Review, 27: 222-247.
107. Shrank, W. H., V. A. Reed, and G. C. Jernstedt 2004 Fostering professionalism in medical education: A call for improved assessment and meaningful incentives. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 19: 887-892.
108. Starr, P. 1982 The Social Transformation of American Medicine. New York: Basic Books.
109. Stinchcombe, A. L. 1965 Social structure and organizations. In J. G. March (ed.), Handbook of Organizations: 144-193. Chicago: RandMcNally.
110. Stryker, R. 1994 Rules, resources, and legitimacy processes: Some implications for social conflict, order, and change. American Journal of Sociology, 99: 847-910.
111. Suchman, M. 1995 Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review, 20: 571-610.
112. Suddaby, R., and R. Greenwood 2005 Rhetorical strategies of legitimacy. Administrative Science Quarterly, 50: 35-67.
113. Thornton, P. H. 2002 The rise of the corporation in a craft industry: Conflict and conformity in institutional logics. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 81-101.
114. Thornton, P. H. 2004 Markets from Culture: Institutional Logics and Organizational Decisions in Higher Education Publishing. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
115. Thornton, P. H., C. Jones, and K. Kury 2005 Institutional logics and institutional change in organizations: Transformations in accounting, architecture and publishing. In C. Jones and P. Thornton (eds.), Research in the Sociology of Organizations, 23: 127-172. New York: Elsevier/JAI.
116. Thornton P. H., and W. Ocasio 1999 Institutional logics and the historical contingency of power in organizations: Executive succession in the higher education publishing industry, 1958-1990. American Journal of Sociology, 105: 801-843.
117. Thornton P. H., and W. Ocasio 2008 Institutional logics. In R. Greenwood, C. Oliver, K. SahlinAndersson, and R. Suddaby (eds.), The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism: 99-129. London: Sage.
118. Townley, B. 1999 Practical reason and performance appraisal. Journal of Management Studies, 36: 287-306.
119. Townley, B. 2002 The role of competing rationalities in institutional change. Academy of Management Journal, 45: 163-179.
120. Washington, M., and M. J. Ventresca 2004 How organizations change: The role of institutional support mechanisms in the incorporation of higher education visibility strategies, 1874-1995. Organization Science, 15: 82-96.
121. White, K. L. 1991 Healing the Schism: Epidemiology, Medicine, and the Public's Health. New York: Springer-Verlag.
122. Willard, W. R. 1966 Meeting the Challenge of Family Practice. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on Education for Family Practice of the AMA Council on Medical Education. Chicago: American Medical Association.
123. Wolfe, S. 1986 Professional dominance and the medical profession. American Journal of Public Health, 76: 11-12.
124. Wolfe, S. M. 2002 The destruction of medicine by market forces: Teaching acquiescence or resistance and change? Academic Medicine, 77: 5-7.
125. Wynn, R. 2000 Saints and sinners: Women and the practice of medicine throughout the ages. Journal of the American Medical Association, 283: 668-669.
126. Zajac, E. J., and J. D. Westphal 2004 The social construction of market value: Institutionalization and learning perspectives on stock market reactions. American Sociological Review, 69: 433-458.
127. Zerhouni, E. A. 2005 Translational and clinical science-Time for a new vision. New England Journal of Medicine, 353: 1621-1623.
128. Zuckerman, H. 1977 Scientific Elite: Nobel Laureates in the United States. New York: Free Press.