Qualitative assessment of the commodity risk for spread of foot-and-mouth disease associated with international trade in deboned beef

Transboundary and Emerging Diseases

Volumn 57, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 115-134

  Paton, D J ^a   Sinclair, M ^b   Rodriguez R ^c  

^a INSTITUTE FOR ANIMAL HEALTH   (United Kingdom)

^b Epidemiology consultant   (South Africa)

^c INSTITUTO NACIONAL DE TECNOLOGÍA AGROPECUARIA INTA   (Argentina)

Author keywords

Commodity trade risk; Deboned beef; Foot and mouth disease

Indexed keywords

ANIMAL; BUFFALO; CATTLE; DEVELOPING COUNTRY; FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE; HEALTH STATUS; HUMAN; MEAT; REVIEW; RISK FACTOR; STANDARD; VETERINARY MEDICINE;

ANIMALS; BUFFALOES; CATTLE; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; FOOT-AND-MOUTH DISEASE; HEALTH STATUS; HUMANS; MEAT; RISK FACTORS; VETERINARY MEDICINE;

BOS; FOOT-AND-MOUTH DISEASE VIRUS;

EID: 77954210418     PISSN: 18651674     EISSN: 18651682     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1865-1682.2010.01137.x     Document Type: Review

References (86)

1. Alexandersen, S., Z. Zhang, A. I. Donaldson, and A. J. M. Garland, 2003: The pathogenesis and diagnosis of FMD. J. Comp. Path. 129, 1-36.
2. AMI 2003: Best Practices for handling vacuum-packed sub-primal beef cuts. Developed by the American Meat Institute, National Meat Association, Southwest Meat Association. September 2003 Version. Available at: http://haccpalliance.org/sub/food-safety/VacPkdBestPrac903.pdf
3. Anonymous 1927. Second Progress Report of the Foot-and-Mouth Disease Research Committee. Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. HMSO, London.
4. Anonymous 1937. Fifth Progress Report of the Foot-and-Mouth Disease Research Committee. Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. HMSO, London.
5. Astudillo, V., P. Sutmoller, V. Saraiva, and A. Lopez, 1997a: Risks of introducing foot and mouth disease through the importation of beef from South America. Rev. sci. tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 16, 33-44.
6. Astudillo, V., B. Cané, D. Geymonat, A. B. Sathler, S. Garay Roman, P. Sutmoller, A. Zottele, and E. Gimeno, 1997b: Risk assessment and risk regionalisation, based on the surveillance system for foot and mouth disease in South America. Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz. 16, 800-808.
7. Bachrach, H. L., S. S. Breese, J. J. Callis, W. R. Hess, and R. E. Patty, 1957: Inactivation of foot and mouth disease virus by pH and temperature changes and by formaldehyde. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. 95, 147-152.
8. Bate-Smith, E. C., 1948: The physiology and chemistry of rigor mortis, with special reference to the ageing of beef. Advances in Food Res., 1, 1-38.
9. Beynon, A. G., 1968: Foot-and-mouth disease in Great Britain. Proc. Ann. Mtg. U.S. Lvstk. Sanit. Assoc. 72, 197-210.
10. Blackwell, J. H., D. A. Rickansrud, P. D. Mc Kercher, and J. W. Mc Vicar, 1982: Effect of thermal processing on the survival of foot-and-mouth disease virus in ground meat. Jour. Food Sc., 47, 388-392.
11. Blackwell, J. H., E. J. Nolan, and D. A. Rickansrud, 1988: Total caloric input of a thermal process as an index of lethality for foot-and-mouth disease virus. Jour. Food Sci. 53, 185-190.
12. Blajan, L., and J. Callis, 1991. International Trade and Foot-and-Mouth Disease (FMD). Proc. 95th Ann. Mtg., U.S. Anim. Health Assoc. 240-260.
13. Burrows, R., 1966: Studies on the carrier state of cattle exposed to foot-and-mouth disease virus. J. Hyg., 64, 81-90.
14. Burrows, R., 1968: Excretion of Foot-and-Mouth disease virus prior to the development of lesions. Vet. Rec., 82, 387-388.
15. Burrows, R., J. A. Mann, A. J. M. Garland, A. Greig, and D. Goodridge, 1981: The pathogenesis of natural and simulated natural foot-and-mouth disease infection in cattle. Jour. Comp. Path., 91, 599-609.
16. Caporale, V., A. Giovannini, C. Di Francesco, and P. Calistri,2001: Importance of the traceability of animals and animal products in epidemiology. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 20, 372-378.
17. de las Carreras, A. E. 1993. La Aftosa en la Argentina, un Desafío Competitivo. Ed. Hemisferio Sur S.A., BA, Argentina. ISBN 950-504-517-4. pp 72.
18. CAST, 2005. Global risks of infectious animal diseases. Issue Paper No 28, Council for Agricultural Science and Technology. ISSN 1070-0021. Available at: http://www.cast-science.org
19. CEC, 1986. Investigation on the possible effect of electrical stimulation on pH and survival of foot-and-mouth disease virus in meat and offals from experimentally infected animals. Commission of the European Communities. Directorate-General for Agriculture. Report No CEC - EUR 10048, 43 pp. ISBN:92-825-7009-6.
20. CODEX, 2005. Code of Hygienic Practice for Meat. CAC/RCP 58-2005. Available at: http://www.codexalimentarius.net/download/standards/.../CXP_058e.pdf
21. Cottral, G. E., 1969: Persistence of Foot-and-Mouth disease virus in animals, their products and the environment. Bull. Off. Int Epiz., 71, 549-568.
22. Cottral, G. E., B. F. Cox, and D. E. Baldwin, 1960: The survival of Foot-and-Mouth disease virus in cured and uncured meat. Am. Journal of Vet Research, 21, 228-297.
23. Cox, B. F., G. E. Cottral, and D. E. Baldwin, 1961: Further studies on the survival of Foot-and-Mouth disease virus in meat. Am. J. Vet. Res., 22, 224.
24. Dagg, P. J., R. J. Butler, J. G. Murray, and R. R. Biddle, 2006: Meeting the requirements of importing countries: practice and policy for on-farm approaches to food safety. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 25, 685-700.
25. Doel, T. R., and P. J. Baccarini, 1981: Thermal stability of foot-and-mouth disease virus. Arch. Virol., 70, 21-32.
26. Doel, T. R., L. Williams, and P. V. Barnett, 1994: Emergency vaccination against foot-and-mouth disease: rate of development of immunity and its implications for the carrier state. Vaccine, 12, 592-600.
27. Donaldson, A. I., 1987: Foot-and-Mouth Disease: the principal features. Ir. Vet. J., 41, 325-327.
28. Donaldson, A. I., 1997: Risks of spreading foot and mouth disease through milk and dairy products. Rev. Sci. Tech., 16, 117-124.
29. Donaldson, A. I., and R. P. Kitching, 1989: Transmission of foot and mouth disease by vaccinated cattle following natural challenge. Res. Vet. Sci., 46, 9-14.
30. EU, 2002: The welfare of animals during transport (details for horses, pigs, sheep and cattle). Report of the Scientific Committee on Animal Health and Animal Welfare, Adopted on 11 March 2002. European Commission Health & Consumer Protection Directorate-General. Directorate C - Scientific Opinions. C2 - Management of scientific committees; scientific co-operation and networks.
31. EU, 2004: Specific hygiene rules for food of animal origin. Regulation (EC) No 853/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council, of 29 April 2004, laying down specific hygiene rules for food of animal origin. Available at: http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/food_safety/veterinary_checks_and_food_hygiene/f84002_en.htm
32. EU Council Directive 2002/99/EC, 2002: Animal health rules governing the production, processing, distribution and introduction of products of animal origin for human consumption. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/food/animal/animalproducts/freshmeat/index_en.htm
33. European Economic Community (EEC), 1986: Directives: Commission decision 86/192/EEC of 9 April 1986 concerning animal health conditions and veterinary certification for the imports of fresh meat from Uruguay as amended by Commission Decision 86/395 of 25 July 1986, and Commission Decision 87/455 of 31 July 1987. Off. J. Eur. Communities, 140, 42.
34. Foegeding, E. A., T. C. Lanier, and H. O. Hultin, 1996: Characteristics of edible muscle tissue. In: Fennema, O. R. (ed), Food, 3rd edn, Vol. 879. Marcel Dekker Inc., NY, USA.
35. Gailiunas, P., G. E. Cottral, and F. W. Scott, 1969: Survival of Foot-and-Mouth disease virus on meat packaging materials. Proc. of 73rd Ann. Meeting of U.S. Animal Health Assoc. 73, 425-436.
36. Garcia-Vidal, W., H. Lazaneo, C. Correa, V. Urrestarazu, S. Huertas, and N. D. Heidelbaugh, 1983: Review of recent progress of the Meat Institute of Uruguay on the development of industrial methods to inactivate Foot-and-Mouth disease virus in meat and meat products. AVMA convention report - Paper #124, July 20.
37. García-Vidal, W., J. H. Blackwell, C. A. Correa, S. Huertas, and V. Urrestarazú, 1988: Virucidal effectiveness of flexible pouch processing of meat products prepared from foot-and-mouth disease affected cattle. Jour. Food Sci., 53, 1650-1652.
38. Gregory, N. G., 2008: Animal welfare at markets and during transport and slaughter. Meat Science 80, 2-11.
39. Henderson, W. M., and J. B. Brooksby, 1948: The survival of foot-and-mouth disease virus in meat and offal. J. Hyg., 46, 394-402.
40. Huang, C.-C., M.-H. Jong, and S.-Y. Lin, 2000: Characteristics of foot and mouth disease in Taiwan. J. Vet. Med. Sci., 62, 677-679.
41. IPCVA, 2008: Handbook for Argentine beef. Argentine Beef Promotion Institute (IPCVA). Available at: http://www.ipcva.com.ar/nomenclador
42. Juleff, N., M. Windsor, E. Reid, J. Seago, Z. Zhang, P. Monaghan, I. W. Morrison, and B. Charleston, 2008: Foot-and-mouth disease virus persists in the light zone of germinal centres. PLoS ONE 3, e3434.
43. Kitching, R. P., 1998: A recent history of Foot-and-Mouth disease. J. Comp. Path., 118, 89-108.
44. Kitching, R. P., 2002: Clinical variation in foot and mouth disease: cattle. Rev. sci. tech. Off. int. Epiz., 21, 499-504.
45. Lasta, J., R. Rodríguez, M. Zanelli, and C. Margaría, 1992a: Bacterial count from bovine carcasses as an indicator of hygiene at slaughtering places. A proposal for sampling. Jour. Food Protec., 55, 271-278.
46. Lasta, J., J. H. Blackwell, A. Sadir, M. M. Gallinger, F. Marcovecchio, M. Zamorano, B. Ludden, and R. Rodríguez, 1992b: Effect of combined treatments on Foot and Mouth disease virus infectivity in bovine tissues. Jour. Food Science, 57, 36-39.
47. Masana, M. O., C. Eisenschlos, H. R. Rodríguez, J. A. Lasta, and N. A. Fondevila, 1995a: Foot and mouth disease virus inactivation in beef frankfurters using a biphasic cooking system. Food Microbiol., 12, 373-380.
48. Masana, M. O., N. A. Fondevila, M. M. Gallinger, J. A. Lasta, H. R. Rodríguez, and B. González, 1995b: Effect of low temperature long time thermal processing of beef cuts on the survival of foot and mouth disease virus. Jour. Food Protec. 58, 165-169.
49. Mc Kean, J. D., 2001: The importance of traceability for public health and consumer protection. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 20, 363-371.
50. McVicar, J. W., and P. Sutmoller, 1976: Growth of foot-and-mouth disease virus in the upper respiratory tract of nonimmunized, vaccinated and recovered cattle after intranasal inoculation. J. Hyg., 76, 467-481.
51. Metcalf, H. E., J. H. Blackwell, and J. A. Acree, 1996: Application of risk assessment to international trade in animals and animal products. Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 791, 280-295.
52. Morgan, N., and A. Prakash, 2006: International livestock markets and the impact of animal disease. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 25, 517-528.
53. National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council, 1966: Studies on Foot-and-Mouth disease a Report of the Argentine-United States joint commission of Foot-and-Mouth disease. Publication 1343. Washington, D.C.
54. Ockerman, H. W. 1996: Chemistry of Meat Tissue. Department of Animal Sciences, The Ohio State University and The Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center. Columbus, OH. University Libraries Knowledge Bank. Accessed at: https://kb.osu.edu/dspace/handle/1811/5957
55. OIE (World Organisation for Animal Health), 2004: Handbook on Import Risk Analysis for Animals and Animal Products, Volume 1.
56. OIE (World Organisation for Animal Health) Terrestrial Animal Health Code, 2008a: Accessed at: http://www.oie.int.
57. OIE (World Organisation for Animal Health), 2008b: Report of the first meeting of the OIE ad hoc group on trade in animal products. Paris, 21-23 July 2008. Accessed at: at http://www.oie.int/downld/SC/2008/A_TAHSC_Part%20B_Sep2008.pdf
58. OIE/FAO FMD Reference Laboratory Network Report, 2008c: Accessed at: http://www.wrlfmd.org/ref_labs/fmd_ref_lab_reports.htm
59. Orsel, K., A. Dekker, A. Bouma, J. A. Stegeman, and M. C. M. de Jong, 2005: Vaccination against foot and mouth disease reduces virus transmission in groups of calves. Vaccine, 23, 4887-4894.
60. Pagliaro, A. F., M. O. Masana, E. D. Sanjurjo, N. A Fondevila, and H. R. Rodríguez, 1996: Foot and mouth disease virus inactivation in miniburgers by a continuous dry moist heat cooking system. Jour. Food Protec., 59, 181-184.
61. Pan American Foot-and-Mouth Disease Center & Tuskegee University School of Veterinary Medicine, 1995: Assessment of the risk of foot-and-mouth disease introduction into the CARICOM countries through the importation of meat from Argentina and Uruguay. Scientific and Technical Monograph Series No 19. ISSN 0101-4897. RJ, Brazil.
62. Paton, D. J., J. F. Valarcher, I. Bergmann, O. G. Matlho, V. M. Zakharov, E. L. Palma, and G. R. Thomson, 2005: Selection of foot-and-mouth disease vaccine strains - a review. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 24, 981-993.
63. Paton, D. J., K. J. Sumption, and B. Charleston, 2009: Options for control of FMD: knowledge, capability and policy. Royal Society Philosophical Transactions B. 364, 2657-2667.
64. Perry, B., A. Nin Pratt, K. Sones, and C. Stevens, 2005: An Appropriate Level of Risk: Balancing the Need for Safe Livestock Products with Fair Market Access for the Poor. PPLPI Working Paper No 23, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Accessed at: http://www.fao.org/ag/againfo/projects/en/pplpi/docarc/wp23.pdf.
65. Pharo, H. J., 2002: Foot-and-mouth disease: an assessment of the risks facing New Zealand. N. Z. Vet., 50, 46-55.
66. th Rec. Meat Conf. pp 57-62.
67. Rodríguez, H. R., L. E. Meichtri, C. O. Margaría, N. A. Pensel, A. Rivi, and M. O. Masana, 2000: Shelf life evaluation of refrigerated vacuum packaged beef kept for extended storage. Proc. 46th Internat. Cong. Meat Sc. and Technol., 2, 6.I-2, 6.I-P14, 668-669.
68. Rweyemamu, M., P. Roeder, D. Mackay, K. Sumption, J. Brownlie, and Y. Leforban, 2008: Planning for the progressive control of foot-and-mouth disease worldwide. Transbound. Emerg. Dis. 55, 73-87.
69. Ryan, E., D. Mackay, and A. Donaldson, 2008: Foot-and-mouth-disease virus concentrations in products of animal origin. Transboundary and Emerging Diseases, 55, 89-98.
70. Scoones, I., and W. Woolmer, 2008: Foot-and-mouth disease and market access: challenges for the beef industry in southern Africa, Transboundary animal disease and market access: future options for the beef industry in southern Africa, Working Paper 1, Brighton: Institute of Developmental Studies. Accessed at: http://www.steps-centre.org/ourresearch/vetscience.html
71. Scott, A., C. Zepeda, L. Garber, J. Smith, D. Swayne, A. Rhorer, J. Kellar, A. Shimshony, H. Batho, V. Caporale, and A. Giovannini, 2006: The concept of compartmentalization Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 25, 873-879.
72. Sellers, R. F., 1971: Quantitative aspects of the spread of foot and mouth disease. The Veterinary Bulletin, 4, 431-439.
73. Sellers, R. F., R. Burrows, J. A. Mann, and P. Dawe, 1968: Recovery of virus from bulls affected with Foot-and-Mouth Disease. Vet. Rec., 83, 303.
74. SENASA, 1994: Estimación del riesgo asociado al comercio de carne. Servicio Nacional de Salud Animal. Secretaría de Agricultura, Ganadería y Pesca, Buenos Aires.
75. Small, A., A. Sikes, and I. Jenson, 2009: Prolonged storage of chilled vacuum packed beef from Australian export processors. Proc. 55th Internat. Cong. Meat Sc. & Technol. 1, 1-2. PS8.06.
76. Sutmoller, P., 2001: Importation of beef from countries infected with foot and mouth disease: a review of risk mitigation measures. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 20, 715-722.
77. Sutmoller, P., and R. Casas Olascoaga, 2003: The risks posed by the importation of animals vaccinated against foot and mouth disease and products derived from vaccinated animals: a review. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 22, 823-835.
78. Sutmoller, P., and D. J. Vose, 1997: Contamination of animal products: the minimum pathogen dose required to initiate infection. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz., 16, 30-32.
79. Sutmoller, P., S. S. Barteling, R. Casas Olascoaga, and K. J. Sumption, 2003: Control and eradication of foot-and-mouth disease. Virus Res., 91, 101-144.
80. Tenzin, A. Dekker, H. Vernooij, A. Bouma, and A. Stegeman, 2008: Rate of foot-and-mouth disease virus transmission by carriers quantified from experimental data. Risk Anal., 28, 303-309.
81. Thomson, G., 2008: A short overview of regional positions on foot-and-mouth disease control in southern Africa, Transboundary animal disease and market access: future options for the beef industry in southern Africa, Working Paper 2, Brighton: Institute of Developmental Studies. Accessed at: http://www.steps-centre.org/ourresearch/vetscience.html
82. Thomson, G. R., T. J. Leyland, and A. I. Donaldson, 2009: De-boned beef - an example of a commodity for which specific standards could be developed to ensure an appropriate level of protection for international trade. Transboundary and Emerging Diseases, 56, 9-17.
83. USDA, 2002: Risk assessment - Importation of fresh (chilled or frozen) beef from Uruguay. Animal Plant Health Inspection Service, APHIS. United States Department of Agriculture, USDA. Accessed at: web01.aphis.usda.gov/db/mtaddr.nsf/2f5c87c0140172cb852564bf0046d1e2/28b03dd2327c029d85256cbf00000340/$FILE/Beef%20Risk%20Assessment%20November-2002.pdf
84. Valarcher, J. F., Y. Leforban, M. Rweyemamu, P. L. Roeder, G. Gerbier, D. K. Mackay, K. J. Sumption, D. J. Paton, and N. Knowles, 2008: Incursions of foot-and-mouth disease virus into Europe between 1985 and 2006. Transbound. Emerg. Di., 55, 14-34.
85. Vermeulen, P., V. Urrestarazú, S. Huertas, J. Baltar, and J. J. Brum, 1993: Organoleptic qualities and foot-and-mouth disease virus stability in beef patties processed by broiler/ continuous beef oven cooking. Jour. Food Protec., 56, 219-222.
86. Yu, P., T. Habtemariam, S. Wilson, D. Oryang, D. Nganwa, M. Obasa, and V. Robnett, 1997: A risk-assessment model for foot and mouth disease (FMD) virus introduction through deboned beef importation. Prev. Vet. Med., 30, 49-59.