Minimizing environmental impacts of grassland weed management: Can Cirsium arvense be controlled without herbicides?

Grass and Forage Science

Volumn 65, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 159-174

  Pywell, R F ^a   Hayes, M J ^b   Tallowin, J B ^c   Walker, K J ^a   Meek, W R ^a   Carvell, C ^a   Warman, L A ^a   Bullock, J M ^a  

^a CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY   (United Kingdom)

^b ABERYSTWYTH UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^c North Wyke Research   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Biodiversity; Clopyralid; Conservation management; Creeping thistle; Invasive plant; Weed control

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; GRASSLAND; GRAZING MANAGEMENT; HABITAT CONSERVATION; HERB; HERBICIDE; INVASIVE SPECIES; RESTORATION ECOLOGY; WEED CONTROL;

BOS; CIRSIUM; CIRSIUM ARVENSE; OVIS ARIES;

EID: 77953734599     PISSN: 01425242     EISSN: 13652494     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2494.2010.00735.x     Document Type: Article

References (78)

1. Amor RL, Harris RV. Control of Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop. by herbicide and mowing. Weed Research 1977, 17:303-309.
2. Bacher S, Schwab F. Effect of herbivore density, timing of attack, and plant community on performance of creeping thistle, Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop. (Asteraceae). Biocontrol Science and Technology 2000, 10:343-352.
3. Bakker D. A comparative life-history study of Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop., Tussilago farfara L., the most troublesome weeds in the newly reclaimed polders of the former Zuiderzee. The biology of weeds 1960, 205-222. Harper JL. ed, Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications
4. Beck KG, Sebastian JR. Combining mowing and fall-applied herbicides to control Canada Thistle (Cirsium arvense). Weed Technology 2000, 14:351-356.
5. Boeroom CM, Wwyse DL. Selective application of herbicides for Canada Thistle (Cirsium arvense) in birdsfoot trefoil. (Lotus corniculatus). Weed Technology 1988, 2:183-186.
6. Bostock SJ, Benton RA. Dry weight costs and establishment of seeds and vegetative propagules. Acta Oecologia 1983, 4:61-69.
7. Buckley YM, Rees M, Paynter Q, Lonsdale M. Modelling integrated weed management of an invasive shrub in tropical Australia. Journal of Applied Ecology 2004, 41:547-560.
8. Bukun B, Gaines TA, Nissen SJ, Westra P, Brunk G, Shaner DL, Sleugh BB, Peterson VF. Aminopyralid and clopyralid absorption and translocation in Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense). Weed Science 2009, 57:10-15.
9. Bullock JM. Plant competition and community dynamics. The ecology and management of grazing systems 1996, 69-100. Illius AHodgson J. eds, Wallingford, UK, CAB International
10. Bullock JM. A long-term study of the roles of competition and facilitation in the establishment of an invasive pine following heathland fires. Journal of Ecology 2009, 97:646-656.
11. Bullock JM, Marriott CA. Plant responses to grazing and opportunities for manipulation. Grazing management. Occasional symposium 2000, 17-26. Rook AJ, Penning PD. eds, No 34, Reading, UK, British Grassland Society
12. Bullock JM, Clear Hill B, Silvertown J. Demography of Cirsium vulgare in a grazing experiment. Journal of Ecology 1994a, 82:101-111.
13. Bullock JM, Clear Hill B, Dale MP, Silvertown J. An experimental study of vegetation change due to sheep grazing in a species-poor grassland and the role of seedling recruitment into gaps. Journal of Applied Ecology 1994b, 31:493-507.
14. Bullock JM, Franklin J, Stevenson MJ, Silvertown J, Coulson SJ, Gregory SJ, Tofts R. A plant trait analysis of responses to grazing in a long-term experiment. Journal of Applied Ecology 2001, 38:253-267.
15. Bunce RGH, Smart SM, Van De Poll HM, Watkins JW, Scott WA. Measuring change in British vegetation 1999, ECOFACT volume 2, London, UK, Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions
16. Bunemann EK, Schwenke GD, Van Zwieten L. Impact of agricultural inputs on soil organisms - a review. Australian Journal of Soil Research 2006, 44:379-406.
17. Chalak-Haghihi M, Van Ierland EC, Bourdot GW, Leathwick D. Management strategies for an invasive weed: a dynamic programming approach for Californian thistle in New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 2008, 51:409-424.
18. Crofts A, Jefferson RG. The lowland grassland management handbook 1999, 2nd edn, Peterborough, UK, English Nature and the Wildlife Trusts
19. Culliney TW. Benefits of classical biological control for managing invasive plants. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 2005, 24:131-150.
20. D'antonio C, Meyerson LA. Exotic plant species as problems and solutions in ecological restoration: a synthesis. Restoration Ecology 2002, 10:703-713.
21. De Bruijn SL, Bork EW. Biological control of Canada thistle in temperate pastures using high density rotational cattle grazing. Biological Control 2006, 36:305-315.
22. Eber S, Brandi R. Regional patch dynamics of Cirsium arvense and possible implications for plant-animal interactions. Journal of Vegetation Science 2003, 14:259-266.
23. Edwards GR, Bourdot GW, Crawley MJ. Influence of herbivory, competition and soil fertility on the abundance of Cirsium arvense in acid grassland. Journal of Applied Ecology 2000, 37:321-334.
24. Eerens JPJ, Seefeldt SS, Garry G, Armstrong ML. Controlling Californian thistle (Cirsium arvense) through pasture management. Proceedings of the N.Z. Plant Protection Conference 2002, 111-115. Zydenbos SM, ed, , Rotourua NZ, New Zealand Plant Protection Society
25. Emery SM, Gross KL. Effects of timing of prescribed fire on the demography of an invasive plant, spotted knapweed Centaurea maculosa. Journal of Applied Ecology 2005, 42:60-69.
26. Ferrero-Serrano A, Collier TR, Hild AL, Mealor BA, Smith T. Combined impacts of native grass competition and introduced weevil herbivory on Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense). Rangeland Ecology and Management 2008, 61:529-534.
27. Friedli J, Bacher S. Mutualistic interaction between a shoot-base boring weevil and a rust fungus, two parasites of the weed creeping thistle. Oecologia 2001, 129:571-576.
28. Grekul CW, Bork EW. Herbage yield losses in perennial pasture due to Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense). Weed Technology 2004, 18:784-794.
29. Grekul CW, Cole DE, Bork EW. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) and pasture forage responses to wiping with various herbicides. Weed Technology 2005, 19:298-306.
30. Grime JP, Hodgson JG, Hunt R. Comparative plant ecology: a functional approach to common British species 1988, London, UK, Unwin Hyman Ltd
31. Hartley MJ, Lyttle LA, Popay AI. Control of Californian thistle by grazing management. Proceedings of the N.Z. Weed and Pest Control Conference 1984, 24-27. Hartley MJ, ed, , 1984, Christchurch, NZ, New Zealand Plant Protection Society
32. Hayes T, Haston K, Tsui M, Hoang A, Haeffele C, Vonk A. Herbicides: feminization of male frogs in the wild. Nature 2002, 419:895-896.
33. Hunter J. Control of Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) with glyphosate Applied at the bud vs rosette stage. Weed Science 1996, 44:934-938.
34. Hurrell GA, Bourdot GW. Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and mowing independently reduce Californian thistle in a sheep pasture. Proceedings of the N.Z. Plant Protection Conference 1996, 225-228. O'Callaghan M, ed, , 1996, Nelson, NZ, New Zealand Plant Protection Society
35. Julien MH. Biological control of weeds: a world catalogue of agents and their target weeds 1998, Wallingford, UK, CAB International
36. Kluth S, Kruess A, Tscharntke T. Influence of mechanical cutting and pathogen application on the performance and nutrient storage of Cirsium arvense. Journal of Applied Ecology 2003, 40:334-343.
37. Knezevic SZ, Smith D, Kulm R, Doty D, Kinkaid D, Goodrich M, Stolcpart R. Purple loosestrife (Lythrum salicaria) control with herbicides: single-year application. Weed Technology 2004, 18:1255-1260.
38. Kocourkova D, Fuksa R, Hakl J, Hlavickova D, Mrkvicka J. The weed infestation of extensively managed grass stands. Journal of Plant Diseases and Protection 2008, 21:561-564.
39. Lovett-Doust J, Lovett-Doust L, Groth AT. The biology of Canadian weeds 95 Ranunculus repens. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 1990, 70:1123-1141.
40. Lundkvist A, Salomonsson L, Karlsson L, Gustavssone AMD. Effects of organic farming on weed flora composition in a long term perspective. European Journal of Agronomy 2008, 28:570-578.
41. Marshall EJP, Brown VK, Boatman ND, Lutman PJW, Squire GR, Ward LK. The role of weeds in supporting biological diversity within crop fields. Weed Research 2003, 43:77-89.
42. Matarczyk JA, Willis AJ, Vranjic JA, Ash JE. Herbicides, weeds and endangered species: management of bitou bush (Chrysanthemoides monilifera ssp rotundata) with glyphosate and impacts on the endangered shrub, Pimelea spicata. Biological Conservation 2002, 108:133-141.
43. Maxwell SE, Delaney HD. Designing experiments and analysing data 2003, 2nd edn, Mahwah, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
44. Menalled FD, Gross KL, Hammond M. Weed aboveground and seedbank community responses to agricultural management systems. Ecological Applications 2001, 11:1586-1601.
45. Mesbah AO, Miller SD. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) control in established alfalfa (Medicago sativa) grown for seed production. Weed Technology 2005, 19:1025-1029.
46. Miller PCH, Pywell RF, Lane AG, Walker KJ, Nowakowski M. The control of injurious weeds of herb-rich grassland in environmentally sensitive areas 1997, OC9321, A report to the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, London, Ministry of Agriculture Fisheries and Food
47. Mitchell RB, Abernethy RJ. The effect of topping and repeat grazings on Californian thistle and pasture production. Proceedings of the N.Z. Plant Protection Conference 1995, 189-193. Popay AJ, ed, , 1995, Hastings, NZ, New Zealand Plant Protection Society
48. Mitchell RB, Davis LT. Effect of control treatments on the root reserves of Californian thistle (Cirsium arvense). Proceedings of the N.Z. Plant Protection Conference 1996, 229-233. O'Callaghan M, ed, , 1996, Nelson, NZ, New Zealand Plant Protection Society
49. Nuzzo V. Element stewardship abstract for Cirsium arvense. 2000, http://www.invasive.org/gist/esadocs/cirsarve.html, Weeds on the Web: The Nature Conservancy Wildland Invasive Species Program. URL: (Accessed 7 August 2009)
50. O'donovan JT, Blackshaw RE, Harker KN, Mcandrew DW, Clayton GW. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) management in canola (Brassica rapa) and barley (Hordeum vulgare) rotations under zero tillage. Canadian Journal of Plant Science 2001, 81:183-190.
51. Ormerod SJ. Restoration in applied ecology: editor's introduction. Journal of Applied Ecology 2003, 40:44-50.
52. Pakeman RJ, Small JL, Le Duc MG, Marrs RH. Recovery of moorland vegetation after aerial spraying of bracken (Pteridium aquilinum (L.) Kuhn) with asulam. Restoration Ecology 2005, 13:718-724.
53. Peel S, Jones AT. Control of creeping thistle on an ancient grazed common. Grassland management in environmentally sensitive areas, occasional symposium 1997, 276-277. Sheldrick RD, ed, No. 32, Reading, UK, British Grassland Society
54. Perez GL, Torremorell A, Mugni H, Rodriguez P, Vera MS, Do Nascimento M, Allende L, Bustingorry J, Escaray R, Ferraro M, Izaguirre I, Pizarro H, Bonetto C, Morris DP, Zagarese H. Effects of the herbicide roundup on freshwater microbial communities: a mesocosm study. Ecological Applications 2007, 17:2310-2322.
55. Popay I, Field R. Grazing animals as weed control agents. Weed Technology 1996, 10:217-231.
56. Pritekel C, Whittemore-Olson A, Snow N, Moore JC. Impacts from invasive plant species and their control on the plant community and belowground ecosystem at Rocky Mountain National Park, USA. Applied Soil Ecology 2006, 32:132-141.
57. Provencher L, Forbis TA, Frid L, Medlyn G. Comparing alternative management strategies of fire, grazing, and weed control using spatial modeling. Ecological Modelling 2007, 209:249-263.
58. Pullin AS, Knight TM, Stone DA, Charman K. Do conservation managers use scientific evidence to support their decision-making? Biological Conservation 2004, 119:245-252.
59. Pywell RF, Nowakowski M, Allchin EA, Aldous E. Preliminary studies of the effects of selective herbicides on wild flower species. Aspects of Applied Biology 1996, 44:149-156.
60. Pywell RF, Bullock JM, Hopkins A, Walker KJ, Sparks TH, Burke MJW, Peel S. Restoration of species-rich grassland on arable land: assessing the limiting processes using a multi-site experiment. Journal of Applied Ecology 2002, 39:294-310.
61. Pywell RF, Bullock JM, Hayes M, Tallowin JB, Masters G. Effects of grazing management on creeping thistle and other injurious weeds and integration of grazing with weed control 2003a, BD1437, UK, A report to the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, London, DEFRA
62. Pywell RF, Bullock JM, Roy DB, Warman EA, Rothery P. Plant traits as predictors of performance in ecological restoration schemes. Journal of Applied Ecology 2003b, 40:65-77.
63. Reed CC, Larson DL, Larson JL. Canada thistle biological control agents on two South Dakota wildlife refuges. Natural Areas Journal 2006, 26:47-52.
64. Relyea RA. The impact of insecticides and herbicides on the biodiversity and productivity of aquatic communities. Ecological Applications 2005, 15:618-627.
65. Rodwell JS. British plant communities volume 3: grasslands and montane communities 1992, Cambridge UK, Cambridge University Press
66. Rodwell JK, Sheffield E. Effects of asulam spraying on non-target ferns. Canadian Journal of Botany 2005, 83:1622-1629.
67. SAS/STAT 9.1 users guide 2004, Carey, NC, USA, SAS Institute
68. Shea K, Kelly D. Estimating biocontrol agent impact with matrix models: Carduus nutans in New Zealand. Ecological Applications 1998, 8:824-832.
69. Shea K, Sheppard A, Woodburn T. Seasonal life-history models for the integrated management of the invasive weed nodding thistle Carduus nutans in Australia. Journal of Applied Ecology 2006, 43:517-526.
70. Shennan C. Biotic interactions, ecological knowledge and agriculture. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 2008, 363:717-739.
71. Smith RS, Shiel RS, Millward D, Corkhill P. The interactive effects of management on the productivity and plant community structure of an upland meadow: an 8-year field trial. Journal of Applied Ecology 2000, 37:1029-1043.
72. Solé M, Durka W, Eber S, Brandl R. Genotypic and genetic diversity of the common weed Cirsium arvense (Asteraceae). International Journal of Plant Sciences 2004, 165:437-444.
73. Stewart KEJ, Bourn NAD, Thomas JA. An evaluation of three quick methods commonly used to assess sward height in ecology. Journal of Applied Ecology 2001, 38:1148-1154.
74. Tallowin JRB, Rook AJ, Rutter SM. Impact of grazing management on biodiversity of grasslands. Animal Science 2005, 81:193-198.
75. Tozer KN, Chapman DF, Quigley PE, Dowling PM, Cousens RD, Kearney GA, Sedcole JR. Controlling invasive annual grasses in grazed pastures: population dynamics and critical gap sizes. Journal of Applied Ecology 2008, 45:1152-1159.
76. Trumble JT, Kok LT. Integrated pest management techniques in thistle suppression in pastures of North America. Weed Research 1982, 22:345-359.
77. Tyler C, Pullin AS, Stewart GB. Effectiveness of management interventions to control invasion by Rhododendron ponticum. Journal of Environmental Management 2006, 37:513-522.
78. Wilson RG, Kachman SD. Effect of perennial grasses on Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) control. Weed Technology 1999, 13:83-87.