Towards a simple dynamic process conceptualization in rainfall-runoff models using multi-criteria calibration and tracers in temperate, upland catchments

Hydrological Processes

Volumn 24, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 260-275

  Birkel, C ^a,b   Tetzlaff, D ^b   Dunn, S M ^a   Soulsby, C ^b  

^a SCOTTISH CROP RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ABERDEEN   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Dominant hydrological Processes; Dynamic saturation areas; Gran alkalinity; Models; Multi criteria calibration; Tracers

Indexed keywords

DOMINANT HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES; GRAN ALKALINITY; HYDROLOGICAL PROCESS; MULTI-CRITERIA; MULTI-CRITERIA CALIBRATION;

CALIBRATION; CATCHMENTS; LANDFORMS; PH EFFECTS; RUNOFF; STREAM FLOW; TIME SERIES; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

DYNAMIC MODELS;

CALIBRATION; CATCHMENT; COMPUTER SIMULATION; FLOW MODELING; HYDRODYNAMICS; HYDROLOGICAL RESPONSE; MULTICRITERIA ANALYSIS; OVERLAND FLOW; RAINFALL-RUNOFF MODELING; RUNOFF; STREAMFLOW; TIME SERIES ANALYSIS; TRACER;

CAIRNGORM MOUNTAINS; GRAMPIAN HIGHLANDS; SCOTLAND; UNITED KINGDOM;

EID: 77949641348     PISSN: 08856087     EISSN: 10991085     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/hyp.7478     Document Type: Article

References (79)

1. Ali GA, Roy AG. 2009. Revisiting hydrologic sampling strategies for an accurate assessment of hydrologic connectivity in humid temperate systems. Geography Compass 3(1): 350-374. DOI:10.1111/j.1749-8198.2008.00180.x.
2. Arnaud P, Bouvier C, Cisneros L, Dominguez R. 2002. Influence of rainfall spatial variability on flood prediction. Journal of Hydrology 260(1-4): 216-230.
3. Balin D. 2004. Hydrological behaviour through experimental and modelling approaches: application to the Haute-Mentue catchment. Unpublished PhD thesis, 3007. Lausanne, Switzerland.
4. Barling RD, Moore ID, Grayson RB. 1994. A quasi-dynamic wetness index for characterising the spatial distribution of zones of surface saturation and soil water content. Water Resources Research 30(4): 1029-1044.
5. Beven K. 1993. Prophecy, reality and uncertainty in distributed hydrological modelling. Advances in Water Resources 16: 41-51.
6. Beven K. 1997. TOPMODEL: a Critique. Hydrological Processes 11: 1069-1085.
7. Beven K. 2006. On under-mining the science. Hydrological Processes 20: 3141-3146.
8. Beven K. 2007. Towards integrated environmental models of everywhere: uncertainty, data and modelling as a learning process. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 11: 460-467.
9. Beven K, Freer J. 2001. A dynamic topmodel. Hydrological Processes 15: 1993-2011.
10. Beven K, Kirkby MJ. 1979. A physically based variable contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrological Sciences Bulletin 24(1): 43-69.
11. Bloeschl G, Sivapalan M. 1995. Scales issues in hydrological modelling-a review. Hydrological Processes 9(3-4): 251-290.
12. Bronstert A. 2004. Rainfall-runoff modelling for assessing impacts of climate and land-use change. Hydrological Processes 18: 567-570.
13. Criss RE, Winston WE. 2008. Do Nash values have value? Discussion and alternate proposals. Hydrological Processes 22: 2723-2725.
14. Dunn SM, Bacon JR, Soulsby C, Tetzlaff D, Stutter M, Waldron S, Malcolm IA. 2008b. Interpretation of homogeneity in d18O signatures of stream water in a nested sub-catchmentsystem in north east Scotland. Hydrological Processes 22: 4767-4782. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.7088.
15. Dunn SM, Bacon JR. 2008c. Assessing the value of Cland υ18O data in modelling the hydrological behaviour of a small upland catchment in northeast Scotland. Hydrology Research 39(5-6): 337-358. DOI: 10.2166/nh.2008.134.
16. Dunn SM, Freer J, Weiler M, Kirkby MJ, Seibert J, Quinn PF, Lischeid G, Tetzlaff D, Soulsby C. 2008a. Conceptualization in catchment modelling: simply learning? Hydrological Processes 22: 2389-2393. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.7070.
17. Dunn SM, Mackay R. 1995. Spatial variation in evapotranspiration and the influence of land use on catchment hydrology. Journal of Hydrology 171: 49-73.
18. Dunn SM, Soulsby C, Lilly A. 2003. Parameter identification for conceptual modelling using combined behavioural knowledge. Hydrological Processes 17: 329-343.
19. Dunn SM, Vinogradoff SI, Thornton GJP, Bacon JR, Graham MC, Farmer JG. 2006. Quantifying hydrological budgets and pathways in a small upland catchment using a combined modelling and tracer approach. Hydrological Processes 20: 349-368.
20. Fenicia F, Savenije HHG, Matgen P, Pfister L. 2007. A comparison of alternative multi-objective calibration strategies for hydrological modelling. Water Resources Research 43: W01402, 1-16.
21. Fenicia F, McDonnell JJ, Savenije HHG. 2008a. Learning from model improvement: on the contribution of complementary data to process understanding. Water Resources Research 44: W06419, 1-13. DOI: 10.1029/2007WR006386.
22. Fenicia F, Savenije HHG, Matgen P, Pfister L. 2008b. Understanding catchment behavior through stepwise model concept improvement. Water Resources Research 44: W01402, 1-13. DOI: 10.1029/2006WR005563.
23. Fenicia F, Savenije HHG, Winsemius HC. 2008c. Moving from model calibration towards process understanding. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Part A, B, C 33(17-18): 1057-1060.
24. Freer JE, McMillan H, McDonnell JJ, Beven KJ. 2004. Constraining dynamic TOPMODEL responses for imprecise water table information using fuzzy rule based performance measures. Journal of Hydrology 291: 254-277.
25. Graeff T, Zehe E, Reusser D, Lueck E, Schroeder B, Wenk G, John H, Bronstert A. 2009. Process identification through rejection of model structures in a mid-mountainous rural catchment: observations of rainfall-runoff response, geophysical conditions and model inter-comparison. Hydrological Processes 23: 702-718. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.7171.
26. Grayson RB, Bloeschl G. 2000. Summary of pattern comparison and concluding remarks. In Spatial Patterns in Catchment Hydrology: Observations and Modeling, Grayson RB, Bloeschl G (eds). Cambridge University Press: New York; 355-367.
27. Gupta HV, Sorooshian S, Yapo PO. 1998. Towards improved calibration of hydrologic models: multiple and noncommensurable measures of information. Water Resources Research 34(4): 751-763.
28. Gupta HV, Wagener T, Liu Y. 2008. Reconciling theory with observations: elements of a diagnostic approach to model evaluation. Hydrological Processes 22: 3802-3813. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.6989.
29. Haria AH, Shand P. 2004. Evidence for deep sub-surface flow routing in forested uplands Wales: implications for contaminant transport and stream flow generation. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 8: 334-344.
30. Harmel RD, Cooper RJ, Slade RM, Haney RL, Arnold JG. 2006. Cumulative Uncertainty in measured streamflow and water quality data for small watersheds. American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers 49(3): 689-701.
31. Hewlett JD, Hibbert AR. 1967. Factors affecting the response of small watersheds to precipitation in humid areas. Proceedings of 1st International Symposium on Forest Hydrology; 275-290.
32. Hrachowitz M, Soulsby C, Tetzlaff D, Dawson JJC, Malcolm IA. 2009. Regionalization of transit time estimates in montane catchments by integrating landscape controls. Water Resources Research 45: WO5421 DOI:10.1029/2008WR007496.
33. Jakeman AJ, Hornberger GM. 1993. How much complexity is warrented in a rainfall-runoff model? Water Resources Research 29:37-47.
34. Kendall C, McDonnell JJ. 1998. Isotope Tracers in Catchment Hydrology. Elsevier Science: New York.
35. Khu ST, Madsen H, di Pierro F. 2008. Incorporating multiple observations for distributed hydrologic model calibration: an approach using a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm and clustering. Advances in Water Resources 31: 1387-1398.
36. Kirchner JW. 2006. Getting the right answers for the right reasons: Linking measurements, analyses, and models to advance the science of hydrology. Water Resources Research 42: W03S04. DOI:10.1029/2005WR004362.
37. Kirchner JW, Hooper RP, Kendall C, Neal C, Leavesley G. 1996. Testing and validating environmental models. Science of the Total Environment 183: 33-47.
38. Klemes V. 1983. Conceptualization and scale in hydrology. Journal of Hydrology 65: 1-23.
39. Lane SM, Brookes CJ, Kirkby MJ, Holden J. 2004. A network-indexbased version of TOPMODEL for use with high-resolution digital topographic data. Hydrological Processes 18: 191-201. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.5208.
40. Legates DR, McCabe GJ Jr. 1999. Evaluating the use of goodness-offit measures in hydrologic and hydroclimatic model validation. Water Resources Research 35(1): 233-241.
41. Linsley RK, Paulhus JL, Kohler MA. 1977. Hydrology for Engineers. McGraw-Hill College Division; 512.
42. Lischeid G. 2008. Combining hydrometric and hydrochemical data sets for investigating runoff generation processes: tautologies, inconsistencies and possible explanations. Geography Compass 2(1): 255-280, 10.1111/j.1749-8198.2007.00082.x.
43. Liu Y, Freer F, Beven K, Matgen P. 2009. Towards a limits of acceptability approach to the calibration of hydrological models: extending observation error. Journal of Hydrology 367: 93-103. DOI:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2009.01.016.
44. Malcolm IA, Soulsby C, Youngson AF, Hannah DM, McLaren IS, Thorne A. 2004. Hydrological influences on hyporheic water quality: implications for salmonid survival. Hydrological Processes 18: 1543-1560.
45. Malcolm IA, Soulsby C, Youngson AF. 2006. High frequency logging technologies reveal state dependence of hyporheic process dynamics: implications for hydroecology. Hydrological Processes 20: 615-622.
46. Nash JE, Sutcliffe JV. 1970. River flow forecasting through conceptual models, 1. A discussion of principles. Journal of Hydrology 10: 282-290.
47. Neal C, Hill T, Hill S, Reynolds B. 1997. Acid neutralizing capacity measurements in surface waters and groundwaters in the upper Severn, Plynlimon: from hydrograph splitting to water flow pathways. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 3: 687-696.
48. O'Loughlin EM. 1986. Prediction of surface saturation zones in natural catchments by topographic análisis. Water Resources Research 22(5): 794-804.
49. Rodhe A, Seibert J. 1999. Wetland occurrence in relation to topography: a test of topographic indices as moisture indicators. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 98/99: 325-340.
50. Saulnier GM, Obled C, Beven K. 1997. Analytical compensation between DTM grid resolution and effective values of saturated hydraulic conductivity within the topmodel framework. Hydrological Processes 11: 1331-1346.
51. Scott R, Entekhabi D, Koster R, Suarez M. 1997. Timescales of land surface evapotranspiration response. J. Clim. 10: 559-566.
52. Seibert J, McDonnell JJ. 2002. On the dialog between experimentalist and modeler in catchment hydrology: use of soft data for multicriteria model calibration. Water Resources Research 38: 1241. DOI: 10.1029/2001WR000978.
53. Seibert J, Rodhe A, Bishop K. 2003. Simulating interactions between saturated and unsaturated storage in a conceptual runoff model. Hydrological Processes 17: 379-390.
54. Shand P, Haria AH, Neal C, Griffiths KJ, Gooddy DC, Dixon AJ, Hill T, Buckley DK, Cunningham JE. 2006. Hydrochemical heterogeneity in an upland catchment: further characterisation of the spatial, temporal and depth variations in soils, streams and groundwaters of the Plynlimon forested catchment. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 9: 621-644.
55. Sivakumar B. 2004. Dominant processes concept in hydrology: moving forward. Hydrological Processes 18: 2349-2353.
56. Sivapalan M, Takeuchi K, Franks SW, Gupta VK, Karambiri H, Lakshmi V, Liang X, McDonnell JJ, Mendiondo EM, O'Connell PE, Oki T, Pomeroy JW, Schertzer D, Uhlenbrook S, Zehe E. 2003. IAHS decade on Predictions in Ungauged Basins (PUB), 2003-2012: shaping an exciting future for the hydrological sciences. Hydrological Sciences Journal 48: 857-880.
57. Sivapalan M, Young PC. 2005. Downward approach to hydrological model development. In Encyclopedia of Hydrological Sciences, Anderson MG and McDonnell JJ (eds) John Wiley: Hoboken; 2081-2100.
58. Son K, Sivapalan M. 2007. Improving model structure and reducing parameter uncertainty in conceptual water balance models through the use of auxiliary data. Water Resources Research 43: WO1415. DOI: 10.1029/2006WR005032.
59. Soulsby C, Reynolds B. 1993. Influence of soil hydrological pathways on stream aluminium chemistry at Llyn Brianne, Mid-Wales. Environmental Pollution 81: 51-60.
60. Soulsby C, Chen M, Ferrier RC, Jenkins A, Harriman R. 1998. Hydrogeochemistry of shallow groundwater in a Scottish catchment. Hydrological Processes 12: 1111-1127.
61. Soulsby C, Dunn SM. 2003. Towards integrating tracer studies in conceptual rainfall-runoff models: recent insights from a sub-arctic catchment in the Cairngorm Mountains, Scotland. Hydrological Processes 17: 403-416. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.1132.
62. Soulsby C, Neal C, Laudon H, Burns DA, Merot P, Bonell M, Dunn SM, Tetzlaff D. 2008. Catchment data for process conceptualization: simply not enough? Hydrological Processes 22: 2057-2061.
63. Soulsby C, Malcolm IA, Youngson AF, Tetzlaff D, Gibbins CN, Hannah DM. 2005. Groundwater-surface water interactions in uplannd Scottish rivers: hydrological, hydrochemical and ecological implications. Scottish Journal of Geology 41(1): 39-49.
64. Soulsby C, Rodgers P, Petry J, Hannah DM, Malcolm IA, Dunn SM. 2004. Using tracers to upscale flow path understanding in mesoscale mountainous catchments: two examples from Scotland. Journal of Hydrology 291: 174-196.
65. Soulsby C, Rodgers P, Smart R, Dawson J, Dunn S. 2003. A tracerbased assessment of hydrological pathways at different spatial scales in a mesoscale Scottish catchment. Hydrological Processes 17: 759-777.
66. Soulsby C, Tetzlaff D, Dunn SM, Waldron S. 2006a. Scaling up and out in runoff process understanding-insights from nested experimental catchment studies. Hydrological Processes 20: 2461-2465.
67. Soulsby C, Tetzlaff D, Rodgers P, Dunn SM, Waldron S. 2006b. Runoff processes, stream water residence times and controlling landscape characteristics in a mesoscale catchment: an initial evaluation. Journal of Hydrology 325: 197-221.
68. Soulsby C, Tetzlaff D, van den Bedem N, Malcolm IA, Bacon PJ, Youngson AF. 2007. Inferring groundwater influences on surface water in montane catchments from hydrochemical surveys of springs and streamwaters. Journal of Hydrology 333: 199-213.
69. Tetzlaff D, McDonnell JJ, Uhlenbrook S, McGuire KJ, Bogaart PW, Naef F, Baird AJ, Dunn SM, Soulsby C. 2008a. Conceptualising catchment processes: simply too complex? Hydrological Processes 22: 1727-1730.
70. Tetzlaff D, Soulsby C, Bacon PJ, Youngson AF, Gibbins CN, Malcolm IA. 2007b. Connectivity between landscapes and riverscapes-a unifying theme in integrating hydrology and ecology in catchment science? Hydrological Processes 21: 1385-1389.
71. Tetzlaff D, Seibert J, Soulsby C. 2009a. Inter-catchment comparison to assess the influence of topography and soils on catchment transit times in a geomorphic province; the Cairngorm mountains, Scotland. Hydrological Processes 23: 1874-1886. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.7318.
72. Tetzlaff D, Seibert J, McGuire KJ, Laudon H, Burns DA, Dunn SM, Soulsby C. 2009b. How does landscape structure influence catchment transit times across different geomorphic provinces? Hydrological Processes 23: 945-953.
73. Tetzlaff D, Soulsby C, Youngson AF, Gibbins CN, Bacon PJ, Malcolm IA, Langan SJ. 2005. Variability in stream discharge and temperature: a preliminary assessment of the implications for juvenile and spawning Atlantic salmon. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 9: 193-208.
74. Tetzlaff D, Soulsby C, Waldron S, Malcolm IA, Bacon PJ, Dunn SM, Lilly A. 2007a. Conceptualisation of runoff processes using GIS and tracers in a nested mesoscale catchment. Hydrological Processes 21: 1289-1307.
75. Tetzlaff D, Uhlenbrook S, Eppert S, Soulsby C. 2008b. Does the incorporation of process conceptualization and tracer data improve the structure and performance of a simple rainfall-runoff model in a Scottish mesoscale catchment? Hydrological Processes 22: 2461-2474. DOI: 10.1002/hyp.6841.
76. Uhlenbrook S, Roser S, Tilch N. 2004. Development of a distributed, but conceptual catchment model to represent hydrological processes adequately at the meso scale. Journal of Hydrology 291: 278-296.
77. Vache KB, McDonnell JJ. 2006. A process-based rejectionist framework for evaluating catchment runoff model structure. Water Resources Research 42: WO2409. DOI: 10.1029/2005WR004247.
78. Viville D, Ladouche B, Bariac T. 2006. Isotope hydrological study of mean transit time in the granitic Strengbach catchment (Vosges massif, France): application of the FlowPC model with modified input function. Hydrological Processes 20: 1737-1751.
79. Wagener T, Sivapalan M, Troch P, Woods R. 2007. Catchment classification and hydrologic similarity. Geography Compass 1(4): 901-931.