Product diversification strategy and financial performance: Meta-analytic evidence on causality and construct multidimensionality

Review of Managerial Science

Volumn 3, Issue 3, 2009, Pages 157-190

  Bausch, Andreas ^a,b   Pils, Frithjof ^c  

^a FRIEDRICH SCHILLER UNIVERSITY JENA   (Germany)

^b JACOBS UNIVERSITY BREMEN   (Germany)

^c The Advisory House GmbH   (Germany)

Author keywords

Corporate strategy; Financial performance; Meta analysis; Product diversification

Indexed keywords

EID: 77949273983     PISSN: 18636683     EISSN: 18636691     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11846-009-0027-4     Document Type: Article

References (130)

1. Acar W, Sankaran K (1999) 'The myth of the unique decomposability: specializing the Herfindahl and entropy measures'? Strateg Manag J 20: 969-975. doi: 10. 1002/(SICI)1097-0266(199910)20: 10<969:: AID-SMJ57> 3. 0. CO; 2-0.
2. Amit R, Livnat J (1988a) Diversification and the risk-return trade-off. Acad Manag J 31: 154-166.
3. Amit R, Livnat J (1988b) Diversification strategies, business cycles and economic performance. Strateg Manag J 9: 99-110.
4. Amit R, Livnat J (1988c) A concept of conglomerate diversification. J Manag 14: 593-604.
5. Amit R, Livnat J (1989) Efficient corporate diversification: methods and implications. Manag Sci 35: 879-897.
6. Barney JB (1997) Gaining and sustaining competitive advantage. Addison-Wesley, Reading.
7. Baumol W, Panzer J, Willig R (1982) Contestable markets and the theory of industry structure. Harcourt, New York.
8. Bengtsson L (2000) Corporate strategy in a small open economy: reducing product diversification while increasing international diversification. Eur Manag J 18: 444-453.
9. Berger PG, Ofek E (1995) Diversification's effect on firm value. J Financ Econ 37: 39-65.
10. Bergh DD (1995) Problems with repeated measures analysis: demonstration with a study of the diversification and performance relationship. Acad Manag J 38: 1692-1708.
11. Bergh DD, Lawless MW (1998) Portfolio restructuring and limits to hierarchical governance: the effects of environmental uncertainty and diversification strategy. Organ Sci 9: 87-102.
12. Bettis RA, Hall WK (1981) Strategic management in the multibusiness firm. Calif Manag Rev 24(1): 23-38.
13. Bettis RA, Hall WK (1982) Diversification strategy, accounting determined risk and accounting determined return. Acad Manag J 25: 254-264.
14. Bettis RA, Mahanjan V (1985) Risk/return performance of diversified firms. Manag Sci 31: 785-799.
15. Bowen HP, Wiersema MF (2005a) Foreign-based competition and corporate diversification strategy. Strateg Manag J 26: 1153-1171.
16. Bowen HP, Wiersema MF (2005b) Matching method to paradigm in strategy research: limitations of cross-sectional analysis and some methodological alternatives. Strateg Manag J 20: 625-636.
17. Busija EC, O'Neil HM, Zeithaml CP (1997) Diversification strategy, entry mode and performance: evidence of choice and constraints. Strateg Manag J 18: 321-327.
18. Camisón-Zornosa C, Lapiedra-Alcami R, Segarra-Ciprés M, Boronat-Navarro M (2004) A meta-analysis of innovation and organizational size. Organ Stud 25: 331-361.
19. Caves RE (1981) Diversification and seller concentration: evidence from changes, 1963-72. Rev Econ Stat 63: 289-293.
20. Caves RE, Porter ME, Spence AM, Scott JT (1980) Competition in the open economy. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
21. Chang Y, Thomas H (1989) The impact of diversification strategy on risk-return performance. Strateg Manag J 10: 285-294.
22. Chatterjee S, Blocher JD (1992) 'Measurement of firm diversification: is it robust'? Acad Manage J 35: 874-888.
23. Chatterjee S, Wernerfelt B (1991) The link between resources and type of diversification: theory and evidence. Strateg Manag J 12: 33-48.
24. Christensen HK, Montgomery CA (1981) Corporate economic performance: diversification strategy versus market structure. Strateg Manag J 2: 327-343.
25. Chu W (2004) 'Are group-affiliated firms really more profitable than nonaffiliated'? Small Bus Econ 22: 391-405.
26. Coase R (1937) The nature of the firm. Economica 4(16): 386-405.
27. Cohen J (1988) Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences, 2nd edn. Earlbaum Publishing, Hillsdale.
28. Combs JG, Crook TR, Shook CL (2005) The dimensionality of organizational performance and its implications for strategic management research. In: Ketchen DJ, Bergh DD (eds) Research methodology in strategy and management, vol 2. JAI Press, Greenwich.
29. Datta DK, Rajagopalan N, Rasheed AMA (1991) Diversification and performance: critical review and future directions. J Manag Stud 28: 529-558.
30. D'Aveni RA, Ravenscraft DJ, Anderson P (2004) From corporate strategy to business-level advantage: relatedness as resource congruence. Manag Decis Econ 25: 365-381.
31. Davis R, Duhaime IM (1992) Diversification, vertical integration, and industry analysis: new perspectives and measurement. Strateg Manag J 13: 511-524.
32. Denis DJ, Denis DK, Sarin A (1997) Agency problems, equity ownership, and corporate diversification. J Financ 52: 135-160.
33. Dubofsky P, Varadarajan PR (1987) Diversification and measures of performance: additional empirical evidence. Acad Manag J 30: 597-606.
34. Dundas KHM, Richardson PR (1982) Implementing the unrelated product strategy. Strateg Manag J 3: 287-301.
35. Farjoun M (1998) The independent and joint effects of the skill and physical bases of relatedness in diversification. Strateg Manag J 19: 611-630.
36. Fauver L, Houston JF, Naranjo A (2004) Cross-country evidence on the value of corporate industrial and international diversification. J Corp Financ 10: 729-752.
37. Gassenheimer JB, Keep WW (1998) Generalizing diversification theory across economic sectors: theoretical and empirical considerations. J Mark Theory Pract, Winter, pp 38-47.
38. Geringer JM, Tallman S, Olsen DM (2000) Product and international diversification among Japanese multinational firms. Strateg Manag J 21: 51-80.
39. Glass GV (1976) Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis. Educ Res 5(10): 3-8.
40. Gomez-Mejia LR, Palich LE (1997) Cultural diversity and the performance of multinational firms. J Int Bus Stud Second Quart, pp 309-335.
41. Goold M, Luchs K (1993) Why diversify? Four decades of management thinking. Acad Manag Exec 7(3): 7-25.
42. Goold M, Campbell A, Alexander M (1994) How corporate parents add value to the stand-alone performance of their businesses. Bus Strategy Rev 5(4): 33-55.
43. Gort M, Grabowski H, McGuckin R (1985) Organization capital and the choice between specialization and diversification. Manag Decis Econ 6(1): 2-10.
44. Grant RM, Jammine AP (1988) Performance differences between the Wrigley/Rumelt strategic categories. Strateg Manag J 9: 333-346.
45. Grant RM, Jammine AP, Thomas H (1988) Diversity, diversification, and profitability among British manufacturing companies, 1972-84. Acad Manag J 31: 771-801.
46. Hall EH Jr, St. John CH (1994) A methodological note on diversity measurement. Strateg Manag J 15: 153-168.
47. Hamilton RT, Shergill G (1993) Extent of diversification and company performance: the New Zealand evidence. Manag Decis Econ 14: 47-52.
48. Higgins RC, Schall LD (1975) Corporate bankruptcy and conglomerate merger. J Financ 30: 93-113.
49. Hill CWL (1983) Conglomerate performance over the economic cycle. J Ind Econ 32: 197-211.
50. Hill CWL (1994) Diversification and economic performance: bringing structure and corporate management back into the picture. In: Rumelt RP, Schendel DE, Teece DJ (eds) Fundamental issues in strategy: a research agenda. Harvard Business School Press, Boston, pp 297-322.
51. Hill CWL, Hoskisson RE (1987) Strategy and structure in the multiproduct firm. Acad Manag Rev 12: 331-341.
52. Hill CWL, Hitt MA, Hoskisson RE (1992) Cooperative versus competitive structures in related and unrelated diversified firms. Organ Sci 3: 501-521.
53. Hitt MA, Ireland DR (1986) Relationships among corporate level distinctive competencies, diversification strategy, corporate structure and performance. J Manag Stud 23: 401-416.
54. Hoskisson RE, Hitt MA (1990) Antecedents and performance outcomes of diversification: a review and critique of theoretical perspectives. J Manag 16: 461-509.
55. Hoskisson RE, Hitt MA, Johnson RA, Moesel DD (1993) Construct validity of an objective (entropy) categorical measure of diversification strategy. Strateg Manag J 14: 215-235.
56. Huber GP, Miller CC, Glick WH (1990) Developing more encompassing theories about organizations: the centralization-effectiveness relationship as an example. Organ Sci 1: 11-40.
57. Hunter JE, Schmidt FL (1990) Methods of meta-analysis: correcting error and bias in research findings. Sage, Newbury Park.
58. Hunter JE, Schmidt FL (2004) Methods of meta-analysis: correcting error and bias in research findings, 2nd edn. Sage, Thousand Oaks.
59. Hunter JE, Schmidt FL, Jackson GB (1982) Meta-analysis: cumulating research findings across studies. Sage, Beverly Hills.
60. Jahera JS, Oswald SL, McMillan K (1993) The relationship between the effectiveness of risk diversification and corporate performance. J Appl Bus Res 9(3): 1-11.
61. Jensen MC (1986) Agency costs of Free Cash Flow, corporate finance and takeovers. Am Econ Rev 76: 323-329.
62. Johnson G, Scholes K, Whittington R (2006) Exploring corporate strategy, 7th edn. Prentice Hall, Harlow.
63. Jones GR, Hill CWL (1988) Transaction cost analysis of strategy-structure choice. Strateg Manag J 9: 159-172.
64. Keats BW (1990) Diversification and business economic performance revisited: issues of measurement and causality. J Manag 16: 61-72.
65. Keats BW, Hitt MA (1988) A causal model of linkages among environmental dimensions, macro organizational characteristics, and performance. Acad Manag J 31: 570-598.
66. Ketchen DJ Jr, Combs JG, Russell CJ, Shook C, Dean MA, Runge J, Lohrke FT, Naumann SE, Haptonstahl DE, Baker R, Beckstein BA, Handler C, Honig H, Lamoureux S (1997) Organizational configurations and performance: a meta-analysis. Acad Manag J 40: 223-240.
67. Khanna T, Palepu K (1997) Why focused strategies may be wrong for emerging markets. Harv Bus Rev 75(4): 41-51.
68. Khanna T, Rivkin JW (2001) Estimating the performance effects of business groups in emerging markets. Strateg Manag J 22: 45-74.
69. Kim H, Hoskisson RE, Wan WP (2004) Power dependence, diversification strategy, and performance in Keiretsu member firms. Strateg Manag J 25: 613-636.
70. Kim WC, Hwang P, Burgers WP (1989) Global diversification strategy and corporate profit performance. Strateg Manag J 10: 45-57.
71. Koslowsky M, Sagie A (1994) Components of artifactual variance in meta-analysis. Pers Psychol 47: 561-574.
72. Kürsten W (2008) 'Synergies, shareholder value and exchange ratios in "value-creating" mergers. Why shareholders should doubt management's pre-merger promises'. Manag Financ 34: 252-261.
73. Lang LHP, Stulz RM (1994) Tobin's q, corporate diversification, and firm performance. J Pol Econ 102: 1248-1280.
74. Lewellen WG (1971) A pure financial rationale for the conglomerate merger. J Financ 26: 521-545.
75. Lipsey MW, Wilson DB (2001) Practical meta-analysis. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks.
76. Lubatkin M, Chatterjee S (1994) 'Extending modern portfolio theory into the domain of corporate diversification: does it apply'? Acad Manag J 37: 109-136.
77. Lubatkin M, Rogers RC (1989) Diversification, systematic risk, and shareholder return: a capital market extension of Rumelt's 1974 study. Acad Manag J 32: 454-465.
78. Lubatkin M, Merchant H, Srinivasan N (1993) Construct validity of some unweighted product-count diversification measures. Strateg Manag J 14: 433-449.
79. Mahoney J, Pandian JR (1992) The resource-based view within the conversation of strategic management. Strateg Manag J 13: 363-380.
80. Markham JW (1973) Conglomerate enterprise and economic performance. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
81. Markides CC (1992) Consequences of corporate refocusing: ex ante evidence. Acad Manag J 35: 398-412.
82. Markides CC, Williamson PJ (1994) Related diversification, core competencies and corporate performance. Strateg Manag J 15: 149-165.
83. Markides CC, Williamson PJ (1996) Corporate diversification and organizational structure: a resource-based view. Acad Manag J 39: 340-367.
84. McDougall FM, Round DK (1984) A comparison of diversifying and non-diversifying Australian industrial firms. Acad Manag J 27: 384-398.
85. Michel A, Shaked I (1984) 'Does business diversification affect performance'? Financ Manag 13(4): 18-25.
86. Milgrom P, Roberts J (1995) Complementarities and fit: strategy, structure, and organizational change in manufacturing. J Account Econ 19 (2/3): 179-208.
87. Miller DJ (2004) Firm's technological resources and the performance effects of diversification: a longitudinal study. Strateg Manag J 25: 1097-1119.
88. Montgomery CA (1982) The measurement of firm diversification: some new empirical evidence. Acad Manag J 25: 299-307.
89. Mukherji A (1998) The relationship between prior performance and diversification: a study of three industries. Manag Decis 36(3): 180-188.
90. Nayyar P (1992) On the measurement of corporate diversification strategy: Evidence from large U. S. service firms. Strateg Manag J 13: 219-235.
91. Nunnally JC, Bernstein IH (1994) Psychometric theory, 3rd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York.
92. Orlitzky M, Schmidt FL, Rynes SL (2003) Corporate social and financial performance: a meta-analysis. Organ Stud 24: 403-441.
93. Palepu K (1985) Diversification strategy, profit performance and the entropy measure. Strateg Manag J 6: 239-255.
94. Palich LE, Cardinal LB, Miller CC (2000a) Curvilinearity in the diversification-performance linkage: an examination of over three decades of research. Strateg Manag J 21: 155-174.
95. Palich LE, Carini GR, Seaman SL (2000b) The impact of internationalization on the diversification-performance relationship: a replication and extension of prior research. J Bus Res 48: 43-54.
96. Park C (2002) The effects of prior performance on the choice between related and unrelated acquisitions: implications for the performance consequences of diversification strategy. J Manag Stud 39: 1003-1019.
97. Penrose E (1959) The theory of the growth of the firm. Blackwell, London.
98. Perreault WD, Leigh LE (1989) Reliability of nominal data based on qualitative judgments. J Mark Res 26: 135-148.
99. Peteraf M (1993) The cornerstones of competitive advantage: a resource-based view. Strateg Manag J 14: 179-191.
100. Pitts RA, Hopkins HD (1982) Firm diversity: conceptualization and measurement. Acad Manag Rev 7: 620-629.
101. Porter ME (1985) Competitive advantage. The Free Press, New York.
102. Prahalad CK, Bettis RA (1986) The dominant logic: a new linkage between diversity and performance. Strateg Manag J 7(6): 485-501.
103. Qian G (1997) Assessing product-market diversification of U. S. firms. Manag Int Rev 37: 127-149.
104. Ramanujam V, Varadarajan P (1989) Research on corporate diversification: a synthesis. Strateg Manag J 10: 523-551.
105. Ramaswamy K, Li M, Petitt BSP (2004) Who drives unrelated diversification? A study of Indian manufacturing firms. Asia Pac J Manag 21: 403-423.
106. Riahi-Belkaoui A, Pavlik E (1993) Effects of ownership structure, firm performance, size and diversification strategy on CEO compensation: a path analysis. Manag Financ 19: 33-54.
107. Robins J, Wiersema MF (1995) A resource-based approach to the multibusiness firm: empirical analysis of portfolio interrelationships and corporate financial performance. Strateg Manag J 16: 277-299.
108. Robins JA, Wiersema MF (2003) The measurement of corporate portfolio strategy: analysis of the content validity of related diversification indexes. Strateg Manag J 24: 39-59.
109. Rosenthal R, DiMatteo MR (2001) Meta-analysis: recent developments in quantitative research methods for literature reviews. Annu Rev Psychol 52: 59-82.
110. Rumelt RP (1974) Strategy, structure, and economic performance. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
111. Rumelt RP (1982) Diversification strategy and profitability. Strateg Manag J 3: 359-369.
112. Saloner G (1987) Predation, mergers, and incomplete information. Rand J Econ 18: 165-186.
113. Salter MS, Weinhold WA (1979) Diversification through acquisition: strategies for creating economic value. The Free Press, New York.
114. Sambharya RB (2000) Assessing the construct validity of strategic and SIC-based measures of corporate diversification. Br J Manag 11: 163-173.
115. Schmidt FL, Hunter JE (1977) Development of a general solution to the problem of validity generalization. J Appl Psychol 62: 529-540.
116. Servaes H (1996) The value of diversification during the conglomerate merger wave. J Financ 51(4): 1201-1225.
117. Seth A (1990) Value creation in acquisitions: a re-examination of performance issues. Strateg Manag J 11: 99-115.
118. Singh M, Mathur I, Gleason KC (2004) Governance and performance implications of diversification strategies: evidence from large U. S. firms. Financ Rev 39: 489-526.
119. Srivastata A, Nargunkar S, Green RF (1994) An empirical evaluation of the equivalence of categorical and continuous measures. J Bus Res 29: 145-149.
120. Tanriverdi H, Venkatraman N (2005) Knowledge relatedness and the performance of multibusiness firms. Strateg Manag J 26: 97-119.
121. Teece DJ (1982) Towards an economic theory of the multiproduct firm. J Econ Behav Organ 3: 39-63.
122. Tongli L, Ping EJ, Chiu WKC (2005) International diversification and performance: evidence from Singapore. Asia Pac J Manag 22: 65-88.
123. Varadarajan PR (1986) Product diversity and firm performance: an empirical investigation. J Mark 50: 43-57.
124. Varadarajan PR, Ramanujam V (1987) Diversification and performance: a reexamination using a new two-dimensional conceptualization of diversity in firms. Acad Manag J 30: 380-393.
125. Venkatraman N, Grant JH (1986) Construct measurement in organizational strategy research: a critique and proposal. Acad Manag Rev 11: 71-87.
126. Venkatraman N, Ramanujam V (1986) Measurement of business performance in strategy research: a comparison of approaches. Acad Manag Rev 11: 801-814.
127. Wan C (1998) International diversification, industrial diversification and firm performance of Hong-Kong MNCs. Asia Pac J Manag 15: 205-217.
128. Wan WP, Hoskisson RE (2003) Home country environments, corporate diversification strategies, and firm performance. Acad Manag J 46: 27-45.
129. Weston JF, Mansinghka SK (1971) Tests of the efficiency performance of conglomerate firms. J Financ 26: 919-936.
130. Williamson OE (1975) Markets and hierarchies: analysis and antitrust implications. The Free Press, New York.