Bridging the solution divide: comprehensive structural analyses of dynamic RNA, DNA, and protein assemblies by small-angle X-ray scattering

Current Opinion in Structural Biology

Volumn 20, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 128-137

  Rambo, Robert P ^a   Tainer, John A ^a,b  

^a LAWRENCE BERKELEY NATIONAL LABORATORY   (United States)

^b SCRIPPS RESEARCH INSTITUTE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

DNA; RIBOZYME; RNA;

ACCURACY; CONFORMATIONAL TRANSITION; DNA PROTEIN COMPLEX; DNA STRUCTURE; DNA SYNTHESIS; MACROMOLECULE; MOLECULAR DYNAMICS; MOLECULAR MODEL; NONHUMAN; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE SPECTROSCOPY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROTEIN ASSEMBLY; PROTEIN STRUCTURE; REVIEW; RIBOSWITCH; RNA STRUCTURE; RNA SYNTHESIS; STRUCTURE ANALYSIS; THERMODYNAMICS; X RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY;

ANIMALS; DNA; HUMANS; PROTEINS; RNA; SCATTERING, SMALL ANGLE; SOLUTIONS; X-RAY DIFFRACTION;

EID: 77749311718     PISSN: 0959440X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.sbi.2009.12.015     Document Type: Review

References (49)

1. Fink A.L. Natively unfolded proteins. Curr Opin Struct Biol 15 (2005) 35-41
2. Wright P.E., and Dyson H.J. Linking folding and binding. Curr Opin Struct Biol 19 (2009) 31-38
3. Putnam C.D., Hammel M., Hura G.L., and Tainer J.A. X-ray solution scattering (SAXS) combined with crystallography and computation: defining accurate macromolecular structures, conformations and assemblies in solution. Q Rev Biophys 40 (2007) 191-285
4. Tsuruta H., and Irving T.C. Experimental approaches for solution X-ray scattering and fiber diffraction. Curr Opin Struct Biol 18 (2008) 601-608
5. Hura G.L., Menon A.L., Hammel M., Rambo R.P., Poole II F.L., Tsutakawa S.E., Jenney Jr. F.E., Classen S., Frankel K.A., Hopkins R.C., et al. Robust, high-throughput solution structural analyses by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Nat Methods 6 (2009) 606-612. This article presents an automated system and data analysis pipeline for SAXS data collection. The results on 50 samples indicate the relatively small amounts of material needed, the robust features of SAXS for efficient throughput, and the high percentage of samples for which structural data can be obtained.
6. Glatter O. New method for evaluation of small-angle scattering data. J Appl Crystallogr 10 (1977) 415-421
7. Moore P.B. Small-angle scattering - information-content and error analysis. J Appl Crystallogr 13 (1980) 168-175
8. Svergun D.I. Determination of the regularization parameter in indirect-transform methods using perceptual criteria. J Appl Crystallogr 25 (1992) 495-503
9. Hansen S. Bayesian estimation of hyperparameters for indirect Fourier transformation in small-angle scattering. J Appl Crystallogr 33 (2000) 1415-1421
10. Hong X.G., and Hao Q. High resolution pair-distance distribution function P(r) of protein solutions. Appl Phys Lett 94 (2009)
11. Glatter O., and Kratky O. Small Angle X-ray Scattering (1982), Academic Press, London/New York
12. Williams R.S., Moncalian G., Williams J.S., Yamada Y., Limbo O., Shin D.S., Groocock L.M., Cahill D., Hitomi C., Guenther G., et al. Mre11 dimers coordinate DNA end bridging and nuclease processing in double-strand-break repair. Cell 135 (2008) 97-109. SAXS was used to determine the correct crystallographic dimer in solution and to further test the residues involved in the Mre11 dimerization interface. SAXS of the Mre11 mutants demonstrated a mixed monomer-dimer population suggesting disruption of the interface can be achieved by the incorporation of charged residues in the hydrophobic interface.
13. Chrencik J.E., Brooun A., Zhang H., Mathews I.I., Hura G.L., Foster S.A., Perry J.J., Streiff M., Ramage P., Widmer H., et al. Structural basis of guanine nucleotide exchange mediated by the T-cell essential Vav1. J Mol Biol 380 (2008) 828-843
14. Garst A.D., Heroux A., Rambo R.P., and Batey R.T. Crystal structure of the lysine riboswitch regulatory mRNA element. J Biol Chem 283 (2008) 22347-22351
15. Nishimura N., Hitomi K., Arvai A.S., Rambo R.P., Hitomi C., Cutler S.R., Schroeder J.I., and Getzoff E.D. Structural mechanism of abscisic acid binding and signaling by dimeric PYR1. Science (2009) 1181829
16. Mills R.D., Trewhella J., Qiu T.W., Welte T., Ryan T.M., Hanley T., Knott R.B., Lithgow T., and Mulhern T.D. Domain organization of the monomeric form of the Tom70 mitochondrial import receptor. J Mol Biol 388 (2009) 1043-1058. The X-ray crystal structure of Tom70 crystallized as a dimer where each monomer was composed of discrete N-terminal and C-terminal domains. The linker region between the two domains was missing from the electron density map, which consequently made the assignment of the correct domain topology ambiguous. Comparison of the SAXS profile with the two plausible models resolved the ambiguity and a further ab initio shape reconstruction provided additional support for the correct choice.
17. Bernstein N.K., Hammel M., Mani R.S., Weinfeld M., Pelikan M., Tainer J.A., and Glover J.N. Mechanism of DNA substrate recognition by the mammalian DNA repair enzyme, Polynucleotide Kinase. Nucleic Acids Res 37 (2009) 6161-6173. SAXS combined with advanced computational approaches were employed to characterize the SAXS to define the shapes and conformations of mPNK complexes including their functional flexibility. On the basis of several thousand conformations of mPNK and their calculated SAXS profiles, the SAXS validated best-fitting model had the FHA linker in an extended conformation. To test the position of DNA predicted from SAXS envelopes, the authors performed an exhaustive search of the protein-DNA interfaces by an EMAP docking approach, an algorithm that searches for the minimal ensemble (MES) of the conformations from the pool of all generated conformations in MD simulations. The combined envelopes for DNA complexes and flexible attachment of the FHA domain to the catalytic segment, elucidated by SAXS, suggests how flexibility enables the interactions of mPNK with diverse DNA substrates and protein partners required for effective orchestration of DNA-end repair.
18. Fan L., Fuss J.O., Cheng Q.J., Arvai A.S., Hammel M., Roberts V.A., Cooper P.K., and Tainer J.A. XPD helicase structures and activities: insights into the cancer and aging phenotypes from XPD mutations. Cell 133 (2008) 789-800
19. Williams R.S., Dodson G.E., Limbo O., Yamada Y., Williams J.S., Guenther G., Classen S., Glover J.N., Iwasaki H., Russell P., et al. Nbs1 flexibly tethers Ctp1 and Mre11-Rad50 to coordinate DNA double-strand break processing and repair. Cell 139 (2009) 87-99. Nbs1 links the Mre11 nuclease at a DNA double strand break to the CTIP protein that opens DNA surrounding the break. MX, SAXS, and proteolysis results show that the Nbs1 folded core is conserved from pombe to human Nbs1 and that disease-associated Nbs1 mutations fall into the folded and extended N-terminal FHA-BRCT1-BRCT2 domains defined by SAXS and MX. As all parts of a structure contribute to the experimental X-ray scattering, SAXS was used to provide an objective, quantitative measure of structural similarity for pombe and human Nbs1 and to provide molecular insights into the consequences of patient-derived NBS mutations. SAXS shows that the fused, extended, FHA-BRCT1-BRCT2 domains are flexibly linked to C-terminal Mre11-binding and ATM-binding motifs. With the SAXS results, Nbs1 emerges as an extended, flexible binding nexus coordinating interactions of the Mre11-Rad50 core, the checkpoint kinase ATM/Tel1, and the DNA-end-processing factor CTIP.
20. Petoukhov M.V., and Svergun D.I. Analysis of X-ray and neutron scattering from biomacromolecular solutions. Curr Opin Struct Biol 17 (2007) 562-571
21. Lipfert J., Ouellet J., Norman D.G., Doniach S., and Lilley D.M. The complete VS ribozyme in solution studied by small-angle X-ray scattering. Structure 16 (2008) 1357-1367. Building structural models into electron density usually occurs by interpreting an electron density map in terms of the amino or nucleic acid building blocks. Here, the authors interpret a density map in terms of larger helical building blocks and build the entire ribozyme using an ab initio SAXS model.
22. Kozlov G., Maattanen P., Schrag J.D., Hura G.L., Gabrielli L., Cygler M., Thomas D.Y., and Gehring K. Structure of the noncatalytic domains and global fold of the protein disulfide isomerase ERp72. Structure 17 (2009) 651-659
23. Hammel M., Nemecek D., Keightley J.A., Thomas Jr. G.J., and Geisbrecht B.V. The Staphylococcus aureus extracellular adherence protein (Eap) adopts an elongated but structured conformation in solution. Protein Sci 16 (2007) 2605-2617
24. Claridge J.K., Headey S.J., Chow J.Y., Schwalbe M., Edwards P.J., Jeffries C.M., Venugopal H., Trewhella J., and Pascal S.M. A picornaviral loop-to-loop replication complex. J Struct Biol 166 (2009) 251-262
25. Goult B.T., Rapley J.D., Dart C., Kitmitto A., Grossmann J.G., Leyland M.L., and Lian L.Y. Small-angle X-ray scattering and NMR studies of the conformation of the PDZ region of SAP97 and its interactions with Kir2.1. Biochemistry 46 (2007) 14117-14128
26. Dias S.M., Wilson K.F., Rojas K.S., Ambrosio A.L., and Cerione R.A. The molecular basis for the regulation of the cap-binding complex by the importins. Nat Struct Mol Biol 16 (2009) 930-937
27. val. The authors present a general strategy for future combined investigation utilizing both SAXS and RDCs.
28. Wang J., Zuo X., Yu P., Byeon I.J., Jung J., Wang X., Dyba M., Seifert S., Schwieters C.D., Qin J., et al. Determination of multicomponent protein structures in solution using global orientation and shape restraints. J Am Chem Soc 131 (2009) 10507-10515. Correct placement and orientation of individual protein components in a large complex is a challenging problem in folding and EM maps. The authors combine RDCs and SAXS data to develop a straightforward approach for assembling multicomponent structures.
29. Wang J., Zuo X., Yu P., Xu H., Starich M.R., Tiede D.M., Shapiro B.A., Schwieters C.D., and Wang Y.X. A method for helical RNA global structure determination in solution using small-angle X-ray scattering and NMR measurements. J Mol Biol 393 (2009) 717-734. Determining the global architecture of a folded RNA in terms of its helical building blocks can be readily achieved in a combined approach integrating both SAXS and NMR based residual dipolar coupling measurements. The structural periodicity of the RNA helical backbone provides unique RDC measurements for orienting helices. However, an ambiguity arises when measurements are made in one alignment medium. Here, SAXS resolves the ambiguity and provides additional independent data for refining a family of structures.
30. Parsons L.M., Grishaev A., and Bax A. The periplasmic domain of TolR from Haemophilus influenzae forms a dimer with a large hydrophobic groove: NMR solution structure and comparison to SAXS data. Biochemistry 47 (2008) 3131-3142. NMR measurements encompassing both NOEs and RDCs were used to determine the solution structure of the periplasmic domain of TolR. Additional SAXS studies were used to confirm the correct dimer model derived by the NMR studies, providing an independent assessment of the model in solution.
31. Wells M., Tidow H., Rutherford T.J., Markwick P., Jensen M.R., Mylonas E., Svergun D.I., Blackledge M., and Fersht A.R. Structure of tumor suppressor p53 and its intrinsically disordered N-terminal transactivation domain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105 (2008) 5762-5767. The authors use a combined approach of NMR, X-ray crystallography, and SAXS to develop a structural model of p53 in complex with DNA. They reconcile a previous EM structure of the p53-DNA complex and show a remarkable agreement with the SAXS-based model derived from rigid-body modeling. More importantly, the authors demonstrate by SAXS that the tetramerization of p53 does not occur explicitly through C-terminal or N-terminal domains. Systematic truncations of p53 were explored to define the requirements for quaternary structure formation.
32. Tidow H., Melero R., Mylonas E., Freund S.M., Grossmann J.G., Carazo J.M., Svergun D.I., Valle M., and Fersht A.R. Quaternary structures of tumor suppressor p53 and a specific p53 DNA complex. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104 (2007) 12324-12329
33. Hammel M., Yu Y., Mahaney B.L., Cai B., Ye R., Phipps B.M., Rambo R.P., Hura G.L., Pelikan M., So S., et al. Ku and DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) dynamic conformations and assembly regulate DNA binding and the initial nonhomologous end joining complex. J Biol Chem 285 (2010) 1414-1423. The assembly states of DNA-PK were studied by SAXS in the presence of DNA. Two types of structural conversions were observed demonstrating monomeric and dimeric forms of DNA-PKcs. The results show a unique structural comparison of the ab initio SAXS models with previously determined EM reconstructions.
34. Garcin E.D., Hosfield D.J., Desai S.A., Haas B.J., Bjoras M., Cunningham R.P., and Tainer J.A. DNA apurinic-apyrimidinic site binding and excision by endonuclease IV. Nat Struct Mol Biol 15 (2008) 515-522
35. Dalhus B., Arvai A.S., Rosnes I., Olsen O.E., Backe P.H., Alseth I., Gao H., Cao W., Tainer J.A., and Bjoras M. Structures of endonuclease V with DNA reveal initiation of deaminated adenine repair. Nat Struct Mol Biol 16 (2009) 138-143
36. Tubbs J.L., Latypov V., Kanugula S., Butt A., Melikishvili M., Kraehenbuehl R., Fleck O., Marriott A., Watson A.J., Verbeek B., et al. Flipping of alkylated DNA damage bridges base and nucleotide excision repair. Nature 459 (2009) 808-813
37. Forster F., Webb B., Krukenberg K.A., Tsuruta H., Agard D.A., and Sali A. Integration of small-angle X-ray scattering data into structural modeling of proteins and their assemblies. J Mol Biol 382 (2008) 1089-1106. Computational package designed to use SAXS explicitly as a spatial restraint for model building.
38. Alber F., Dokudovskaya S., Veenhoff L.M., Zhang W., Kipper J., Devos D., Suprapto A., Karni-Schmidt O., Williams R., Chait B.T., et al. Determining the architectures of macromolecular assemblies. Nature 450 (2007) 683-694
39. Bernado P., Mylonas E., Petoukhov M.V., Blackledge M., and Svergun D.I. Structural characterization of flexible proteins using small-angle X-ray scattering. J Am Chem Soc 129 (2007) 5656-5664. An important advance for incorporating multiple models in the interpretation of SAXS data is the Ensemble Optimization Method (EOM). An ensemble of atomistic protein models is constructed with missing linkers computationally modeled. Efficient sampling of the conformational space employs a genetic algorithm to efficiently search for the set of models that best fits the data in reciprocal space.
40. Pelikan M., Hura G.L., and Hammel M. Structure and flexibility within proteins as identified through small angle X-ray scattering. Gen Physiol Biophys 28 (2009) 174-189. A robust means to examine the conformational variation manifest in SAXS results. The Minimal Ensemble Search (MES) employs high temperature MD simulation, samples conformational space by a genetic algorithm, and applies an ensemble search algorithm to minimize the ensemble size during the optimization.
41. Jain R., Hammel M., Johnson R.E., Prakash L., Prakash S., and Aggarwal A.K. Structural insights into yeast DNA polymerase delta by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). J Mol Biol 394 (2009) 377-382. DNA polδ is a multisubunit polymerase consisting of a catalytic core Pol3. SAXS data collected on the ternary Pol3-Pol31-Pol32 was used as an empirical constraint for structural modeling using a high-resolution structure of Pol3 and homology models derived from human orthologs. The resulting model is consistent with prior EM studies and demonstrates a model consistent with biochemistry.
42. Datta A.B., Hura G.L., and Wolberger C. The structure and conformation of Lys63-linked tetraubiquitin. J Mol Biol 392 (2009) 1117-1124
43. Petoukhov M.V., Vicente J.B., Crowley P.B., Carrondo M.A., Teixeira M., and Svergun D.I. Quaternary structure of flavorubredoxin as revealed by synchrotron radiation small-angle X-ray scattering. Structure 16 (2008) 1428-1436
44. Rambo RP, Tainer JA: Improving small angle X-ray scattering data for structural analyses of the RNA world. RNA, http://www.rnajournal.org/cgi/doi/10.1261/rna.1946310. A comprehensive examination of folding artifacts and their influences during SAXS data collection and model building. The authors offer a simple but robust approach for making reliable SAXS samples.
45. Parker J.B., Bianchet M.A., Krosky D.J., Friedman J.I., Amzel L.M., and Stivers J.T. Enzymatic capture of an extrahelical thymine in the search for uracil in DNA. Nature 449 (2007) 433-437
46. Franke D., and Svergun D.I. DAMMIF, a program for rapid ab-initio shape determination in small-angle scattering. J Appl Crystallogr 42 (2009) 4. A significantly enhanced version of DAMMIN that incorporates a dynamic search volume for efficient sampling of the search space for generating ab initio bead models.
47. Chacon P., Diaz J.F., Moran F., and Andreu J.M. Reconstruction of protein form with X-ray solution scattering and a genetic algorithm. J Mol Biol 299 (2000) 1289-1302
48. Svergun D.I., Petoukhov M.V., and Koch M.H. Determination of domain structure of proteins from X-ray solution scattering. Biophys J 80 (2001) 2946-2953
49. Montange R.K., and Batey R.T. Structure of the S-adenosylmethionine riboswitch regulatory mRNA element. Nature 441 (2006) 1172-1175