Brain death is not death: A critique of the concept, criterion, and tests of brain death

Reviews in the Neurosciences

Volumn 20, Issue 3-4, 2009, Pages 187-198

  Joffe, Ari R ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Brain death; Brainstem death; Death

Indexed keywords

BRAIN DEATH; BRAIN FUNCTION; BRAIN STEM; CELL DEATH; CONFERENCE PAPER; CONSCIOUSNESS; DEATH; HUMAN; NONHUMAN; PERSONHOOD; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROGNOSIS;

EID: 75649089677     PISSN: 03341763     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1515/REVNEURO.2009.20.3-4.187     Document Type: Conference Paper

References (80)

1. Allen N, Burkholder JD, Molinari GF, Comiscioni J. Clinical criteria of brain death. In: Molinari GF, Walker AE, eds. The NINCDS Collaborative Study of Brain Death. Bethesda, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (NIH Publication No. 81-2286), 1980; 77-147.
2. Appelt EA, Song WS, Phillips WT, Metter DF, Salman UA, Blumhardt R. The "hot nose" sign on brain death nuclear scintigraphy: where does the flow really go? Clin Nucl Med 2008; 33: 55-57.
3. Ashwal S, Smith AJK, Torres F, Loken M, Chou SN. Radionuclide bolus angiography: a technique for verification of brain death in infants and children. J Pediatr 1977; 91: 722-728.
4. Bernat JL, Culver CM, Gert B. On the definition and criterion of death. Ann Intern Med 1981; 94: 389-394.
5. Bernat JL. A defense of the whole brain concept of death. Hastings Center Rep 1998; 28: 14-23.
6. Bemat JL. The whole-brain concept of death remains optimum public policy. J Law Med Ethics 2006; 34: 35-43.
7. Bolton CF, Brown JD, Cholod E, Warren K. EEG and "brain life". Lancet 1976; 307: 535.
8. Brilli RJ, Bigos D. Apnea threshold and pediatric brain death. Crit Care Med 2000; 28: 1257.
9. Byrne PA, O'Reilly S, Quay PM, Salsich PW. Brain death-the patient, the physician, and society. Gonzaga Law Rev 1981/82; 18: 429-516.
10. Combes JC, Chomel A, Ricolfi F, d'Athis P, Freysz M. Reliability of computed tomographic angiography in the diagnosis of brain death. Transplant Proc 2007; 39: 16-20.
11. DeGrazia D. Are we essentially persons? Olson, Baker, and a reply. Philos Forum 2002; 33: 101-120.
12. DeGrazia D. Identity, killing, and the boundaries of our existence. Philos Public Aff 2003; 31: 413-442.
13. Drake B, Ashwal S, Schneider S. Determination of cerebral death in the pediatric intensive care unit. Pediatrics 1986; 78: 107-112.
14. Facco E, Munari M, Gallo F, Volpin SM, Behr AU, Baratto F,. Giron GP. Role of short latency evokedpotentials in the diagnosis of brain death. Clin Neuro physiol 2002; 113: 1855-1866.
15. Fackler JC, Troncoso JC, Gioia FR. Age-specific characteristics of brain death in children. Am J Dis Child 1988; 142: 999-1003.
16. Farragher RA, Laffey JG. Maternal brain death and somatic support. Neurocrit Care 2005; 3: 99-106.
17. Ferbert A, Buchner H, Ringelstein EB, Hacke W. Isolated brain-stem death: case report with demonstration of preserved visual evoked potentials. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1986; 65: 157-160.
18. Flowers WM, Patel BR. Radionuclide angiography as a confirmatory test for brain death: a review of 229 studies in 219 patients. South Med J 1997; 90: 1091-1096.
19. Flowers WM, Patel BR. Persistence of cerebral blood flow after brain death. South Med J 2000; 93: 364-370.
20. Green JB, Lauber A. Return of EEG activity after electrocerebral silence: two case reports. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1972; 35: 103-107.
21. Green MB, Wikler D. Brain death and personal identity. Philos Public Aff 1980; 9: 105-133.
22. Greer DM, Varelas PN, Haque S, Wijdicks EFM. Variability of brain death determination guidelines in leading US neurologic institutions. Neurology 2008; 70: 284-289.
23. Grigg MM, Kelly MA, Celesia GG, Ghobrial MW, Ross ER. Electroencephalographic activity after brain death. Arch Neurol 1987; 44: 948-954.
24. Halevy A, Brody B. Brain death: reconciling definitions, criteria, and tests. Ann Intern Med 1993; 119: 519-525.
25. Jennett B, Gleave J, Wilson P. Brain death in three neurosurgical units. Br Med J 1981; 282: 533-539.
26. Joffe AR. Limitations of brain death in the interpretation of computed tomographic angiography. Intensive Care Med 2007; 33: 2218.
27. Kamm FM. Brain death and spontaneous breathing. Philos Public Aff 2002; 30: 297-320.
28. Kato T, Tokumaru A, O'uchi T, Mikami I, Umeda M, Nose K, Eguchi T, Hasegawa M, Okuyama K. Assessment of brain death in children by means of P-31 MR spectroscopy: preliminary note. Radiology 1991; 179:95-99.
29. Kaukinen S, Makela K, Hakkinen VK, Martikainen K. Significance of electrical brain activity in brain-stem death. Intensive Care Med 1995; 21: 76-78.
30. Kerridge IH, Saul P, Lowe M, McPhee J, Williams D. Death, dying and donation: organ transplantation and the diagnosis of death. J Med Ethics 2002; 28: 89-94.
31. Kohrman MH, Spivack BS. Brain death in infants: sensitivity and specificity of current criteria. Pediatr Neurol 1990; 6: 47-50.
32. Kurtek RW, Lai KK, Tauxe WN, Eidelman BH, Fung JJ. Tç-99m hexamethylpropylene amine oxime scintigraphy in the diagnosis of brain death and its implications for the harvesting of organs used for transplantation. Clin Nucl Med 2000; 25: 7-10.
33. Law Reform Commission of Canada. Report: Criteria for the determination of death. Ottawa, Canada: Minister of Supply and Services Canada, 1981.
34. Leclerc X, Taschner CA, Vidal A, Strecker G, Savage J, Gauvrit JY, Pruvo JP. The role of spiral CT for the assessment of the intracranial circulation in suspected brain-death. J Neuroradiol 2006; 33: 90-95.
35. McMahan J. An alternative to brain death. J Law Med Ethics 2006; 34: 44-48.
36. Mejia RE, Pollack MM. Variability in brain death determination practices in children. JAMA 1995; 274: 550-553.
37. Mohandas A, Chou SN. Brain death: a clinical and pathological study. J Neurosurg 1971; 35: 211-218.
38. Molinari GF. The NINCDS collaborative study of brain death: a historical perspective. In: Molinari GF, Walker AE, eds. The NINCDS Collaborative Study of Brain Death. Bethesda, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (NIH Publication No. 81-2286), 1980; 1-32.
39. Newberg A, Alavi A, van Rhijn S, Cotter A, Reilly P. Radiologic diagnosis of brain death. JAMA 2002; 288: 2121-2122.
40. Ogata J, Imakita M, Yutani C, Miyamoto S, Kikuchi H. Primary brainstem death: a clinico-pathological study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1988; 51: 646-650.
41. Okamoto K, Subimoto T. Return of spontaneous respiration in an infant who fulfilled current criteria to determine brain death. Pediatrics 1995; 96: 518-520.
42. Pallis C. On the brainstem criterion of death. In: Youngner SJ, Arnold RM, Schapiro R, eds. The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1999; 93-100.
43. Paolin A, Manuali A, Di Paola F, Boccaletto F, Caputo P, Zanata R, Bardin GP, Simini G. Reliability in diagnosis of brain death. Intensive Care Med 1995; 21: 657-662.
44. Pasternak JF, Volpe JJ. Full recovery from prolonged brainstem failure following intraventricular hemorrhage. J Pediatr 1979; 95: 1046-1049.
45. Potts M, Evans DW. Does it matter that organ donors are not dead? Ethical and policy implications. J Med Ethics 2005; 31: 406-409.
46. Powner DJ, Bernstein IM. Extended somatic support for pregnant women after brain death. Crit Care Med 2003; 31: 1241-1249.
47. President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Defining Death: Medical, Legal and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death. Washington, D.C: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1981.
48. Quesnel C, Fulgencio JP, Adrie C, Marro B, Payen L, Lembert N, Metaoua SE, Bonnet F. Limitations of computed tomographic angiography in the diagnosis of brain death. Intensive Care Med 2007; 33: 2129-2135.
49. Repertinger S, Fitzgibbons WP, Omojola MF, Brumback RA. Long survival following bacterial meningitisassociated brain destruction. J Child Neurol 2006; 21: 591-595.
50. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death. A definition of irreversible coma. JAMA 1968; 205: 85-88.
51. Report of the Medical Consultants on the Diagnosis of Death to the President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Guidelines for the determination of death. JAMA 1981; 246: 2184-2186.
52. Ringel RA, Riggs JE, Brick JF. Reversible coma with prolonged absence of pupillary and brainstem reflexes: an unusual response to a hypoxic-ischemic event in MS. Neurology 1988; 38: 1275-1278.
53. Rodin E, Tahir S, Austin D, Andaya L. Brainstem death. Clin Electroencephalogr 1985; 16: 63-71.
54. Ruiz-Garcia M, Gonzalez-Astiazaran A, Collado-Corona MA, Rueda-Franco F, Sosa-de-Martinez C. Brain death in children: clinical, neurophysiological and radioisotopic angiography findings in 125 patients. Child's Nerv Syst 2000; 16:40-46.
55. Schlake HP, Bottger IG, Grotemeyer KH, Husstedt IW, Brandau W, Schober O. Determination of cerebral perfusion by means of planar brain scintigraphy and 99mTc-HMPAO in brain death, persistent vegetative state and severe coma. Intensive Care Med 1992; 18: 76-81.
56. Schroder R. Later changes in brain death. Signs of partial recirculation. Acta Neuropathol (Berl) 1983; 62: 15-23.
57. Shemie SD, Doig C, Dickens B, Byrne P, Wheelock B, Rocker G, Baker A, Seland TP, Guest C, Cass D, Jefferson R, Young K, Teitelbaum J; Pediatric Reference Group; Neonatal Reference Group. Severe brain injury to neurological determination of death: Canadian forum recommendations. CMAJ 2006; 174: S1-S12.
58. Shemie SD. Diagnosis of brain death in children: technology and the inadequate lexicon of death. Lancet Neurol 2007; 6: 87-88.
59. Shemie SD. Brain arrest, cardiac arrest and uncertainties in defining death. J Pediatr (Rio J) 2007; 83: 102-104.
60. Shewmon DA. Chronic "brain death": meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology 1998; 51: 1538-1545.
61. Shewmon DA. Brainstem death, brain death and death: a critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. Issues Law Med 1998; 14: 125-145.
62. Shewmon DA. Hypothesis: spinal shock and 'brain death': somatic pathophysiological equivalence and implications for the integrative-unity rationale. Spinal Cord 1999; 37: 313-324.
63. Shewmon DA. The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating brain death with death. J Med Philos 2001; 26: 457-478.
64. Shewmon DA. Mental disconnect: 'physiological decapitation' as a heuristic for understanding 'brain death'. In: Msgr Marcelo Sanchez Sorondo HE, ed. Working Group on the Signs of Death, 11-12 September 2006. Vatican City: Pontifica Academia Scientiarum, 2007; 292-333.
65. Singh NC, Reid RH, Loft JA, Frewen TC, Parker BL, Dhillon JS. Usefulness of (Tc 99m) HM-PAO scan in supporting clinical brain death in children: uncoupling flow and function. Clin Intensive Care 1994; 5: 71-74.
66. Thompson JR, Ashwal S, Schneider S, Hasso AN, Hinshaw DB Jr, Kirk G. Comparison of cerebral blood flow measurements by xenon computed tomography and dynamic brain scintigraphy in clinically brain dead children. Acta Radiol Suppl 1986; 369: 675-679.
67. Truog RD. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Center Rep 1997; 27: 29-37.
68. Truog RD, Robinson WM. Role of brain death and the dead-donor rule in the ethics of organ transplantation. Crit Care Med 2003; 31: 2391-2396.
69. Vardis RV, Pollack MM. Increased apnea threshold in a pediatric patient with suspected brain death. Crit Care Med 1998; 26: 1917-1919.
70. Walker AE, Diamond EL, Moseley J. The neuropathological findings in irreversible coma: a critique of the "respirator brain". J Neuropathol Exp Neurol 1975; 34: 295-323.
71. Walker AE. Neuropathological findings in the brains of patients admitted to the collaborative study. In: Molinari GF, Walker AE, eds. The NINCDS Collaborative Study of Brain Death. Bethesda, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (NIH Publication No. 81-2286), 1980; 33-76.
72. Walker AE, Molinari GF. Criteria of cerebral death: a critique. In: Molinari GF, Walker AE, eds. The NINCDS Collaborative Study of Brain Death. Bethesda, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (NIH Publication No. 81-2286), 1980; 181-203.
73. Wang MY, Wallace P, Gruen JP. Brain death documentation: analysis and issues. Neurosurgery 2002; 51: 731-735.
74. Wijdicks EFM, Bernat JL. Chronic "brain death": meta-analysis and conceptual consequences [Letter]. Neurology 1999; 53: 1369-1370.
75. Wijdicks EFM. Brain death worldwide: accepted fact but no global consensus in diagnostic criteria. Neurology 2002; 58: 20-25.
76. Wijdicks EFM, Pfeifer EA. Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology 2008; 70: 1234-1237.
77. Yatim A, Mercatello A, Coronel B, Bret M, Colpart JJ, Moscovtchenko JF, Peyrin JO. 99m HMPAO cerebral scintigraphy in the diagnosis of brain death. Transplant Proc 1991; 23: 2491.
78. Youngner SJ, Bartlett ET. Human death and high technology: the failure of the whole-brain formulations. Ann Intern Med 1983; 99: 252-258.
79. Zamperetti N, Bellomo R, Defanti CA, Latronico N. Irreversible apnoeic coma 35 years later: towards a more rigorous definition of brain death? Intensive Care Med 2004; 30: 1715-1722.
80. Zwarts MJ. Clinical brainstem death with preserved electroencephalographic activity and visual evoked response. Arch Neurol 2001; 58: 1010.