The national Fire and Fire Surrogate study: Effects of fuel reduction methods on forest vegetation structure and fuels

Ecological Applications

Volumn 19, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 285-304

  Schwilk, Dylan W ^a,b   Keeley, Jon E ^a   Knapp, Eric E ^c   Mciver, James ^d   Bailey, John D ^e   Fettig, Christopher J ^c   Fiedler, Carl E ^f   Harrod, Richy J ^g   Moghaddas, Jason J ^h   Outcalt, Kenneth W ^g   Skinner, Carl N ^c   Stephens, Scott L ^h   Waldrop, Thomas A ^g   Yaussy, Daniel A ^g   Youngblood, Andrew ⁱ  

^a U S GEOLOGICAL SURVEY   (United States)

^b TEXAS TECH UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c PACIFIC SOUTHWEST RESEARCH STATION   (United States)

^d OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^e OREGON STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^f UNIVERSITY OF MONTANA   (United States)

^g USDA FOREST SERVICE   (United States)

^h UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

ⁱ PACIFIC NORTHWEST RESEARCH STATION   (United States)

Author keywords

Delayed mortality; Dry forests; Forest management; Hazard reduction; Prescribed burning; Species richness; Thinning.

Indexed keywords

ALTERNATIVE FUEL; DRY FOREST; ECOLOGICAL IMPACT; FOREST MANAGEMENT; FUELWOOD; HAZARD MANAGEMENT; INVASIVE SPECIES; MORTALITY; PRESCRIBED BURNING; SEEDLING; SNAG; SPECIES RICHNESS; STAND STRUCTURE; THINNING; VEGETATION DYNAMICS; WILDFIRE;

ARTICLE; BIODIVERSITY; COMPARATIVE STUDY; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; FIRE; FORESTRY; HISTOLOGY; METHODOLOGY; POPULATION DENSITY; SEASON; TREE; UNITED STATES;

BIODIVERSITY; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; FIRES; FORESTRY; POPULATION DENSITY; SEASONS; TREES; UNITED STATES;

NORTH AMERICA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 65349193856     PISSN: 10510761     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1890/07-1747.1     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Agee, J. K. 1993. Fire ecology of Pacific Northwest forests. Island Press, Washington, D.C., USA.
2. Agee, J. K., and M. R. Lolley. 2006. Thinning and prescribed fire effects on fuels and potential fire behavior in an eastern Cascade forest, Washington, USA. Fire Ecology 2:3-19.
3. Agee, J. K., and C. N. Skinner. 2005. Basic principles of forest fuel reduction treatments. Forest Ecology and Management 211:83-96.
4. Agee, J. K., R. H. Wakimoto, and H. H. Biswell. 1977. Fire and fuel dynamics of Sierra-Nevada conifers. Forest Ecology and Management 1:255-265.
5. Arno, S. F., and J. K. Brown. 1991. Overcoming the paradox in managing wildland fire. Western Wildlands 17:40-46.
6. Arno, S. F., H. Y. Smith, and M. A. Krebs. 1997. Old growth ponderosa pine and western larch stand structures: Influences of pre-1900 fires and fire exclusion. Technical Report 324. USDA Forest Service, Ogden, Utah, USA.
7. Barden, L. S. 1979. Serotiny and seed viability on Pinuspungens in the Southern Appalachians. Castanea 44:44-17.
8. Berry, A. H., and H. Hesseln. 2004. The effect of the wildland-urban interface on prescribed burning costs in the Pacific Northwestern United States. Journal of Forestry 102:33-37.
9. Biswell, H. 1973. Fire ecology in ponderosa pine grassland. Proceedings of the Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference 12: 69-73.
10. Boyle, J. F. 2002. Short-term response of bark beetles to fuel reduction treatments in the Upper Piedmont. Thesis. Clemson University, Clemson, South Carolina, USA.
11. Brockway, D. G., and C. E. Lewis. 1997. Long-term effects of dormant-season prescribed fire on plant community diversity, structure, and productivity in a longleaf pine wiregrass ecosystem. Forest Ecology and Management 96:167-183.
12. Brockway, D. G., K. W. Outcalt, and W. D. Boyer. 2006. Longleaf pine regeneration ecology and methods. Pages 95-134 in S. Jose, E. J. Jokela, and D. L. Miller, editors. The longleaf pine ecosystem. Springer, New York, New York, USA.
13. Brockway, D. G, K. W. Outcalt, D. J. Tomczak, and E. E. Johnson. 2005. Restoring longleaf pine forest ecosystems in the southern U.S. Pages 501-522 in J. A. Stanturf and P. Madsen, editors. Restoration of boreal and temperate forests. CRC Press, New York, New York, USA.
14. Brose, P. H., and D. H. Van Lear. 1998. Responses of hardwood advance regeneration to seasonal prescribed fires in oak-dominated shelterwood stands. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 28:331-339.
15. Brown, J. K. 1974. Handbook for inventorying downed woody material. USDA Forest Service, General Technical Report GTR-INT-16, Washington, D.C., USA.
16. Burnham, K., and D. Anderson. 2002. Model selection and multi-model inference: a practical information-theoretic approach. Second edition. Springer-Verlag, New York, New York, USA.
17. Burns, R. M., and B. Honkala, editors. 1990. Silvics of North America. Volume 1, conifers. Agriculture Handbook 654. USDA Forest Service, Washington, D.C., USA.
18. Collins, B. M., J. J. Moghaddas, and S. L. Stephens. 2007. Initial changes in forest structure and understory plant community following fuel reduction activities in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 239:102-111.
19. Connell, J. H. 1978. Diversity in tropical rain forests and coral reefs. Science 199:1302-1310.
20. Converse, S., G C. White, and W. M. Block. 2006. Small mammal responses to thinning and wildfire in ponderosa pine-dominated forests of the southwestern USA. Journal of Wildlife Management 70(6)1711-1722.
21. Cooper, C. F. 1960. Changes in vegetation, structure, and growth of southwestern pine forests since white settlement. Ecological Monographs 30:129-164.
22. Covington, W. W., and M. M. Moore. 1994. Southwestern ponderosa forest structure: changes since Euro-American settlement. Journal of Forestry 92:39-47.
23. Cowell, C. 1998. Historical change in vegetation and disturbance on the Georgia Piedmont. American Midland Naturalist 140:78-89.
24. Crow, T. R., and A. H. Perera. 2004. Emulating natural landscape disturbance in forest management: an introduction. Landscape Ecology 19:231-233.
25. Dodson, E. K., and C. E. Fiedler. 2006. Impacts of restoration treatments on alien plant invasion in Pinus ponderosa forests, Montana, USA. Journal of Applied Ecology 43:887-897.
26. Farris, K. L., and S. Zack. 2005. Woodpecker-snag interactions: an overview of current knowledge in ponderosa pine systems. Pages 183-195 in M. W. Ritchie, D. A. Maguire, and A. Youngblood, technical coordinators. Proceedings of the symposium on ponderosa pine: issues, trends, and management. General Technical Report PSW-GTR-198. USDA Forest Service, Albany, California, USA.
27. Fettig, C. J., K. D. Klepzig, R. F. Billings, A. S. Munson, T. E. Nebeker, J. F. Negron, and J. T. Nowak. 2007. The effectiveness of vegetation management practices for prevention and control of bark beetle outbreaks in coniferous forests of the western and southern United States. Forest Ecology and Management 238:24-53.
28. Fowells, H. 1965. Silvics of forest trees of the United States. Number 271 in USDA Forest Service Handbook. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., USA.
29. Frost, C. 2006. History and future of the longleaf pine ecosystem. Pages 9-12 in S. Jose, E. J. Jokela, and D. L. Miller, editors. The longleaf pine ecosystem. Springer, New York, New York, USA.
30. Glitzenstein, J. S., W. J. Platt, and D. R. Streng. 1995. Effects of fire regime and habitat on tree dynamics in North Florida longleaf pine savannas. Ecological Monographs 65:441-476.
31. Harrod, R. J., B. H. McRae, and W. E. Hard. 1999. Historical stand reconstruction in ponderosa pine forests to guide silvicultural prescriptions. Forest Ecology and Management 114:433-146.
32. Harrod, R. J., N. A. Povak, and D. W. Peterson. 2007. Comparing the effectiveness of thinning and prescribed fire for modifying structure in dry coniferous forests. Pages 327-346 in B. W. Butler and W. Cook, compilers. The fire environment: innovations, management, and policy; conference proceedings, 26-30 March 2007, Destin, Florida. Proceedings RMRS-P-46CD. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA.
33. Hessburg, P., and J. Agee. 2003. An environmental narrative of inland northwest US forests, 1800-2000. Forest Ecology and Management 178:23-60.
34. Johnson, P. S., S. R. Shifley, and R. Rogers. 2002. The ecology and silviculture of oaks. CABI Publishing, New York, New York, USA.
35. Keeley, J. E., and C. J. Fotheringham. 2005. Plot shape effects on plant species diversity measurements. Journal of Vegetation Science 16:249-256.
36. Keeley, J. E., D. Lubin, and C. J. Fotheringham. 2003. Fire and grazing impacts on plant diversity and invasives in the southern Sierra Nevada. Ecological Applications 13:1355-1374.
37. Keeley, J. E., and T. W. McGinnis. 2007. Impact of prescribed fire and other factors on cheatgrass persistence in a Sierra Nevada ponderosa pine forest. International Journal of Wildland Fire 16:96-106.
38. Keeley, J. E., and N. L. Stephenson. 2000. Restoring natural fire regimes to the Sierra Nevada in an era of global change. Pages 255-265 in D. N. Cole, S. F. McCool, W. T. Borrie, and J. O'Loughlin, compilers. Wilderness science in a time of change conference: wilderness ecosystems, threats, and management; May 23-27, 1999, Missoula Montana. Proceedings RMRS-P-15, Volume 5. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Ogden, Utah, USA.
39. Keeley, J. E., and P. J. van Mantgem. 2008. Community ecology of seedlings. Pages 255-273 in M. A. Leak, V. T. Parker, and R. L. Simpson, editors. Seedling ecology and evolution. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
40. Keifer, M., J. W. van Wagtendonk, and M. Buhler. 2006. Long-term surface fuel accumulation in burned and un-burned mixed conifer forests of the central and southern Sierra Nevada, CA (USA). Fire Ecology 2:53-72.
41. Kerns, B. K, W. G. Thies, and C. G. Niwa. 2006. Season and severity of prescribed burn in ponderosa pine forests: Implications for understory native and exotic plants. Ecoscience 13:44-55.
42. Kilgore, B. 1973. The ecological role of fire in Sierran conifer forests: its application to national park management. Quaternary Research 3:496-513.
43. Knapp, E. K, J. E. Keeley, E. A. Ballenger, and T. J. Brennan. 2005. Fuel reduction and coarse woody debris dynamics with early season and late season prescribed fire in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 208:383-397.
44. Knapp, E. K, D. W. Schwilk, J. M. Kane, and J. E. Keeley. 2007. Role of burning season on initial understory vegetation response to prescribed fire in a mixed conifer forest. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 37:11-22.
45. Kobziar, L., J. J. Moghaddas, and S. L. Stephens. 2006. Tree mortality patters following prescribed fires in a mixed conifer forest. Canadian Journal of Forestry Research 36:3222-3238.
46. Leopold, S. A., S. A. Cain, C. A. Cottam, I. N. Gabrielson, and T. L. Kimball. 1963. Wildlife management in the national parks. American Forestry 69:32-35,61-63.
47. Liu, Y., J. J. Qu, X. Hao, and W. Wang. 2005. Improving fire emission estimates in the eastern United States using satellite-based fuel loading factors. Pages 1-4 in EastFIRE Conference Proceedings, Fairfax, Virginia, May 11-13. George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia, USA.
48. McHugh, C. W., and T. E. Kolb. 2003. Ponderosa pine mortality following fire in northern Arizona. International Journal of Wildland Fire 12:7-22.
49. Mclver, J., A. Youngblood, and S. L. Stephens. 2009. The national Fire and Fire Surrogate study: ecological consequences of fuel reduction methods in seasonally dry forests. Ecological Applications 19:283-284.
50. McRae, D., L. Duchesne, B. Freedman, T. Lynham, and S. Woodley. 2001. Comparisons between wildfire and forest harvesting and their implications in forest management. Environment Reviews 9:223-260.
51. Metlen, K.L., and C. E. Fiedler. 2006. Restoration treatment effects on the understory of ponderosa pine/Douglas-fir forests in western Montana, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 222:355-369.
52. Miller, C, and D. L. Urban. 2000. Modeling the effects of fire management alternatives on Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forests. Ecological Applications 10:85-94.
53. Miller, S. R., and D. D. Wade. 2003. Re-introducing fire at the urban/wildland interface: planning for success. Forestry 76(2)253-260.
54. Moghaddas, E., and S. L. Stephens. 2007. Thinning, burning, and thin-burn fuel treatment effects on soil properties in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 250:156-166.
55. Moghaddas, J. J., R. A. York, and S. L. Stephens. 2008. Initial response of conifer and California black oak seedlings following fuel reduction activities in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 255:3141-3150.
56. Mutch, L. S., and D. J. Parsons. 1998. Mixed conifer forest mortality and establishment before and after prescribed fire in Sequoia National Park, California. Forest Science 44:341-355.
57. Naumburg, E., E. L. DeWald, and T. E. Kolb. 2001. Shade responses of five grasses native to southwestern U.S. ponderosa pine forests. Canadian Journal of Botany 79: 1001-1009.
58. Oliver, C. D., and B. C. Larson. 1996. Forest stand dynamics. John Wiley and Sons, New York, New York, USA.
59. Outcalt, K. W. 2005. Restoring structure and composition of longleaf pine ecosystems of the Gulf Coastal Plains. Pages 97-100 in J. S. Kush, compiler. Proceedings of the 5th Longleaf Alliance Regional Conference, October 12-15, 2004, Hattiesburg, Mississippi. Longleaf Alliance Report No. 8. Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama, USA.
60. Outcalt, K. W., and J. L. Foltz. 2004. Impacts of growing-season burns in the Florida pine flatwoods type. Pages 30-34 in K. F. Connor, editor. Proceedings of the 12th biennial southern silvicultural research conference. General Technical Report SRS-7. USDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Asheville, North Carolina, USA.
61. Parker, A. 1984. A comparison of structural properties and compositional trends in conifer forests of Yosemite and Glacier National Parks. Northwest Science 58:131-141.
62. Parker, T. J., K. M. Clancy, and R. L. Mathiasen. 2006. Interactions among fire, insects, and pathogens in coniferous forests of the interior western United States and Canada. Agricultural and Forest Entomology 8:167-189.
63. Parsons, D. J., and S. H. DeBenedetti. 1979. Impact of fire suppression on a mixed-conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 2:21-33.
64. Phillips, R., and T. Waldrop. 2008. Changes in vegetation structure and composition in response to fuel reduction treatments in the South Carolina Piedmont. Forest Ecology and Management 235:3107-3116.
65. Pickett, S. T. A. 1980. Non-equilibrium coexistence of plants. Bulletin of Torrey Botanical Club 107:238-248.
66. Pyne, S. 1982. Fire in America. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, USA.
67. R Development Core Team. 2005. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. (http://www. R-project.org)
68. Riegel, G M., R. F. Miller, and W. C. Krueger. 1995. The effects of aboveground and belowground competition on understory species composition in a Pinus ponderosa forest. Forest Science 41:864-889.
69. Ritchie, M. W. 2005. Ecological research at the Goosenest Adaptive Management Area in northeastern California. General Technical Report PSW-GTR-192. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Albany, California, USA.
70. Ritchie, M. W., C. N. Skinner, and T. A. Hamilton. 2007. Probability of tree survival after wildfire in an interior pine forest of northern California: effects of thinning and prescribed fire. Forest Ecology and Management 247:200-2008.
71. Ryan, K. C, and E. D. Reinhardt. 1988. Predicting post-fire mortality of seven western conifers. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 18:1291-1297.
72. Schmidt, L., M. G. Halle, and S. L. Stephens. 2006. Restoring northern Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest composition and structure with prescribed fires of varying intensities. Fire Ecology 2:204-217.
73. Schwarz, G. F. 1907. The longleaf pine in virgin forest. A silvical study. Wiley, New York, New York, USA.
74. Schwilk, D. W., E. E. Knapp, S. M. Ferrenberg, J. E. Keeley, and A. C. Caprio. 2006. Tree mortality from fire and bark beetles following early and late season prescribed fires in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 232:36-45.
75. Skinner, C. N. 1995. Change in spatial characteristics of forest openings in the Klamath Mountains of northwestern California, USA. Landscape Ecology 10:219-228.
76. Skinner, C. N. 2005. Reintroducing fire into the Blacks Mountain Research Natural Area: effects on fire hazard. Pages 245-257 in M. Ritchie, D. Maguire, and A. Young-blood, editors. Proceedings of the symposium on ponderosa pine: issues, trends, and management. 2004 October 18-21, Klamath Falls, OR. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Albany, California, USA.
77. Skinner, C. N, and C. Chang. 1996. Fire regimes, past and present. Pages 1041-1069 in Sierra Nevada Ecosystem Project: Final Report to Congress. Volume II: Assessments and scientific basis for management options, Center for Water and Wildland Resources, University of California, Davis, California, USA.
78. Stark, N. 1965. Natural regeneration of Sierra Nevada mixed conifers after logging. Journal of Forestry 63:456-457,460-461.
79. Stephens, S. L. 2000. Mixed conifer and upper montane forest structure and uses in 1899 from the central and northern Sierra Nevada, California. Madrono 47:43-52.
80. Stephens, S. L., and M. A. Finney. 2002. Prescribed fire mortality of Sierra Nevada mixed conifer tree species: effects of crown damage and forest floor combustion. Forest Ecology and Management 162:261-271.
81. Stephens, S. L., and J. J. Moghaddas. 2005a. Experimental fuel treatment impacts on forest structure, potential fire behavior, and predicted tree mortality in a mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 215:21-36.
82. Stephens, S. L., and J. J. Moghaddas. 2005b. Fuel treatment effects on snags and coarse woody debris in a Sierra Nevada mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 214: 53-64.
83. Stephens, S. L., J. J. Moghaddas, C. Edminster, C. E. Fiedler, S. Haase, M. Harrington, J. E. Keeley, E. E. Knapp, J. D. Mclver, K. Metlen, C. N. Skinner, and A. Youngblood. 2009. Fire treatment effects on vegetation stucture, fuels, and potential fire severity in western U.S. forests. Ecological Applications 19:305-320.
84. Stephenson, N. L., D. J. Parsons, and T. W. Swetnam. 1991. Restoring natural fire to the sequoia-mixed conifer forest: should intense fire play a role? Pages 321-337 in High intensity fire in wildlands: management challenges and options. Volume 17. Tall Timbers Research Station, Tallahassee, Florida, USA.
85. Taylor, A. H. 2000. Fire regimes and forest changes in mid and upper montane forests of the southern Cascades, Lassen Volcanic National Park, California, U.S.A. Journal of Biogeography 27:87-104.
86. Taylor, A. H. 2004. Identifying forest reference conditions on cut-over lands, Lake Tahoe Basin, USA. Ecological Applications 14:1903-1920.
87. Van Lear, C, and T. Waldrop. 1989. History, use and effects of fire in the Appalachians. General Technical Report SE-GTR-54. USDA Forest Service, Southeastern Forest Experiment Station, Asheville, North Carolina, USA.
88. Waldrop, T. A., D. Yaussy, R. J. Phillips, T. A. Hutchinson, L. Brudnak, and R. A. J. Boerner. 2008. Fuel reduction treatments affect vegetation structure of hardwood Forests in western North Carolina and southern Ohio, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 255:3117-3129.
89. Ware, S., C. Frost, and P. D. Doerr. 1993. Southern mixed hardwood forest: the former longleaf pine forest. Pages 447-493 in W. H. Martin, S. G. Boyce, and A. C. Echternacht, editors. Biodiversity of the southeastern United States: lowland terrestrial communities. John Wiley and Sons, New York, New York, USA.
90. Wayman, R. B., and M. North. 2007. Initial response of a mixed-conifer understory plant community to burning and thinning restoration treatments. Forest Ecology and Management 239:32-14.
91. Weatherspoon, C. P. 2000. A proposed long-term national study of the consequences of fire and fire-surrogate treatments. Pages 117-126 in L. F. Neuenschwander, K. C. Ryan, and G. E. Goldberg, editors. Proceedings of the Joint Fire Science Conference and Workshop. Crossing the millennium: integrating spatial technologies and ecological principles for a new age in fire management. University of Idaho Press, Moscow, Idaho, USA.
92. Youngblood, A., K. T. Max, and K. Coe. 2004. Stand structure in old growth ponderosa pine forests of Oregon and northern California. Forest Ecology and Management 199:191-217.
93. Youngblood, A., K. L. Metlen, and K. Coe. 2006. Changes in stand structure and composition after fuel restoration treatments in low elevation dry forests of northeastern Oregon. Forest Ecology and Management 234:143-163.
94. Youngblood, A., K. Metlen, E. Knapp, K. Outcalt, S. Stephens, T. Waldrop, and D. Yaussy. 2005. Implementation of the Fire and Fire Surrogate Study: a national research effort to evaluate the consequences of fuel reduction treatments. Pages 315-321 in C. E. Peterson and D. A. Maguire, editors. Balancing ecosystem values. General Technical Report PNW-GTR-635. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station, Portland, Oregon, USA.