Comparison of two spatial optimization techniques: A framework to solve multiobjective land use distribution problems

Environmental Management

Volumn 43, Issue 2, 2009, Pages 264-281

  Meyer, Burghard Christian ^a   Lescot, Jean Marie ^b   Laplana, Ramon ^b  

^a TU DORTMUND UNIVERSITY   (Germany)

^b CEMAGREF   (France)

Author keywords

Goal programming; Multifunctionality; Multiobjective spatial decision making; Objective function; Optimization

Indexed keywords

AND MODELS; DISTRIBUTION PROBLEMS; ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS; FARMING SYSTEMS; GENERAL FRAMEWORKS; GEOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION SYSTEMS; GERMANY; GOAL PROGRAMMING; GOAL PROGRAMMING MODELS; HABITAT MODELS; HABITAT STRUCTURES; LEIPZIG; MULTI-FUNCTIONAL; MULTIFUNCTIONALITY; MULTIOBJECTIVE SPATIAL DECISION MAKING; OBJECTIVE FUNCTION; OPTIMIZATION TECHNIQUES; SMALL RIVERS; SOIL AND WATER ASSESSMENT TOOLS; SOIL EROSIONS; SPATIAL DEVELOPMENTS; SPATIAL OPTIMIZATIONS; SPATIAL PLANNING; WATER RETENTIONS;

CATCHMENTS; ECOLOGY; ECONOMICS; EROSION; FUNCTIONS; GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS; GEOLOGIC MODELS; LAND USE; MATHEMATICAL MODELS; OCEAN HABITATS; OPTIMIZATION; PROBABILITY DENSITY FUNCTION; RISK ASSESSMENT; RISK MANAGEMENT; SOIL MECHANICS; SOILS; STRUCTURAL OPTIMIZATION;

MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION;

COMPARATIVE STUDY; DECISION MAKING; ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS; FARMING SYSTEM; GIS; HABITAT CREATION; HABITAT STRUCTURE; LAGOMORPH; LAND USE PLANNING; OPTIMIZATION; RISK ASSESSMENT; SOIL EROSION; SPATIAL PLANNING; UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS;

AGRICULTURE; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ECOSYSTEM; FRANCE; GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS; GEOGRAPHY; MODELS, THEORETICAL; PLANNING TECHNIQUES; POLICY MAKING; RIVERS;

LEPUS EUROPAEUS;

EID: 58149458644     PISSN: 0364152X     EISSN: 14321009     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s00267-008-9225-0     Document Type: Article

References (65)

1. JCJH Aerts MF Goodchild GBM Heuvelink 2003 Accounting for spatial uncertainty in optimization with spatial decision support systems Transactions in GIS 7 2 211 230
2. Arnold JG, Srinivasan P, Muttiah RS, Williams JR (1998) Large area hydrologic modeling and assessment; part I; model development. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 34(1):73-89
3. R Backhaus M Bock S Weiers 2002 The spatial dimension of landscape sustainability Environment, Development and Sustainability 4 3 237 251
4. Bastian O, Schreiber K-F (1994) Analyse und ökologische Bewertung der Landschaft [Analysis and ecological assessment of the landscape]. G. Fischer Verlag, Jena/Stuttgart
5. Bastian O, Steinhardt U (eds) (2002) Development and perspectives of landscape ecology. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht
6. JL Bayliss V Simonite S Thompson 2005 The use of probabilistic habitat suitability models for biodiversity action planning Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 108 3 228 250
7. R Benayoun J de Montgolfier J Tergny O Laritchev 1971 Linear programming with multiple objective functions: step method (STEM) Mathematical Programming 1 366 375
8. Brandt J, Tress B, Tress G (eds) (2000) Multifunctional landscapes: interdisciplinary approaches to landscape research and management. Conference, Roskilde, Denmark, October 18-21, 2000
9. Brooke A, Kendrick D, Meeraus A (1992) GAMS: a user's guide. Release 2.25. Scientific Press. Available at: www.gams.com
10. Büchs W (2003) Biodiversity and agri-environmental indicators-general scopes and skills with special reference to the habitat level. In: Büchs W (ed) Biotic indicators for biodiversity and sustainable agriculture. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 35-78
11. BUWAL (Bundesamt für Umwelt, Wald und Landschaft) (2002) Feldhase. Schlußbericht 1991-2000. Schriftenreihe Umwelt Nr. 334. Wildtier, Bern
12. Cairol D, Perret E, Turpin N (2006) Results of the multagri project concerning indicators of multifunctionality and their relevance for SEAMLESS-IF. SEAMLESS report 11:100. Available at: http://www.seamless-ip.org/Reports/ Report-11-PD2.3.1.pdf. Accessed September 5, 2007
13. P Caron T Le Cotty 2006 A review of the different concepts of multifunctionality and their evolution European Series on Multifunctionality 10 176
14. GM Carter ED Stolen DR Breininger 2006 A rapid approach to modeling species-habitat relationships Biological Conservation 127 2 237 244
15. DE Chamberlain S Gough JA Vickery LG Firbank S Petit R Pywelland RB Bradbury 2004 Rule-based predictive models are not cost-effective alternatives to bird monitoring on farmland Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 101 1 1 8
16. Chuvieco E (1993) Integration of linear programming and GIS for land-use modelling. International Journal of Geographical Information Systems 7:71-83
17. G Dewess 1985 Zum spieltheoretischen Kompromiss in der Vektoroptimierung Optimization 16 1 29 39
18. Dykstra DP (1984) Mathematical programming for natural resource management. McGraw-Hill, New York
19. PJ Edwards MR Fletcher P Berny 2000 Review of the factors affecting the decline of the European brown hare, Lepus europaeus (Pallas, 1778) and the use of wildlife incident data to evaluate the significance of paraquat Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 79 2-3 95 103
20. SI Gass 1986 A process for determining priorities and weights for large-scale linear goal programmes Journal of the Operational Research Society 37 779 785
21. C Gaucherel N Giboire V Viaud T Houet J Baudry F Burel 2006 A domain-specific language for patchy landscape modeling: the Brittany agricultural mosaic as a case study Ecological Modeling 194 1-3 233 243
22. Grabaum R (1996) Verfahren der polyfunktionalen Bewertung von Landschaftselementen einer Landschaftseinheit mit anschließender., Multicriteria Optimization" zur Generierung vielfältiger Landnutzungsoptionen. Shaker-Verlag, Aachen
23. R Grabaum BC Meyer 1998 Multicriteria optimization of landscapes using GIS-based functional assessments Landscape and Urban Planning 43 1-3 21 34
24. Grabaum R, Meyer T, Gerung J, Wolf T, Friedrich KE, Kildal T, Schreiner V, Meyer BC (2006) The digital user manual for the multi-criteria assessment and optimization method (MULBO). In: Meyer BC (ed) Sustainable land use in intensively used agricultural regions. Alterra Report No. 1338. Landscape Europe, Wageningen, pp 127-132
25. Haines-Young R, Weber J-L (2006) Land accounts for Europe 1990-2000: towards integrated land and ecosystem accounting. EEA Report No 11/2006:112. European Environment Agency, Copenhagen
26. J Hoffmann JM Greef 2003 Mosaic indicators-theoretical approach for the development of indicators for species diversity in agricultural landscapes Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 98 1-3 387 394
27. JM Holland MAS Hutchison B Smith NJ Aebischer 2006 A review of invertebrates and seed-bearing plants as food for farmland birds in Europe Annals of Applied Biology 148 1 49 71
28. DM Jansen ST Buijze HL Boogaardet 1999 Ex-ante assessment of costs for reducing nitrate leaching from agriculture-dominated regions Environmental Modeling and Software 14 6 549 565
29. Jedicke E (1997) Die roten Listen. Gefährdete Pflanzen, Tiere. Pflanzengesellschaften und Biotoptypen in Bund und Ländern. Verlag Ulmer, Stuttgart
30. Jessel B (2006) Indicators and assessment of multifunctionality- operationalising the concept for planning applications in landscapes. In: Meyer BC (ed) Sustainable land use in intensively used agricultural regions. Alterra Report No. 1338. Landscape Europe, Wageningen, pp 36-47
31. JC Kilgo DL Gartner BR Chapman JB Dunning KE Franzreb SA Gauthreaux CH Greenberg DJ Levey KV Miller SF Pearson 2002 A test of an expert-based bird-habitat relationship model in South Carolina Wildlife Society Bulletin 30 3 783 793
32. A Laaribi JJ Chevallier JM Martel 1996 A spatial decision aid: a multicriterion evaluation approach Computers, Environmental and Urban Systems 20 6 351 366
33. SM Lenton JE Fa JP Del Val 2000 A simple non-parametric GIS model for predicting species distribution: endemic birds in Bioko Island, West Africa Biodiversity and Conservation 9 7 869 885
34. K Lewandowski JJ Nowakowski 1993 Spatial-distribution of brown hare Lepus europaeus populations in habitats of various types of agriculture Acta Theriologica 38 4 435 442
35. Lonergan S, Prudham S (1994) Modeling global change in an integrated framework: a view from the Social Sciences. In: Meyer WB, Turner II BL (eds) Changes in land use and land cover: a global perspective. New York, John Wiley, pp 411-435
36. L Madureira T Rambonilaza I Karpinski 2007 Review of methods and evidence for economic valuation of agricultural non-commodity outputs and suggestions to facilitate its application to broader decisional contexts Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 120 1 5 20
37. Malczewski J (1999) GIS and multi-criteria decision analysis. Wiley, New York
38. J Malczewski 2006 GIS-based multicriteria decision analysis: a survey of the literature International Journal of Geographical Information Science 20 7 703 726
39. Mander Ü, Mueller F, Wrbka T (eds) (2005) Functional and structural indicators: upscaling and downscaling problems. Ecological Indicators 5(4):267-272
40. Meyer BC (1997) Landschaftsstrukturen und Regulationsfunktionen in Intensivagrarlandschaften im Raum Leipzig-Halle. Regionalisierte Umweltqualitätsziele-Funktionsbewertungen-multikriterielle Landschaftsoptimierung unter Verwendung von GIS. UFZ-Bericht 24/1997, Leipzig
41. BC Meyer R Grabaum 2008 MULBO-model framework for multicriteria landscape assessment and optimization-a support system for spatial land use decision Landscape Research 33 2 155 179
42. Meyer BC, Mühle H, Grabaum R (2001) Landschaftsbewertung und -optimierung sowie Entwicklung von Szenarien nach der Methode der multikriteriellen Landschaftsoptimierung. In: Mühle H (ed) Einfluß der Landnutzung auf Landschaftshaushalt und Biodiversität in agrarisch dominierten Räumen. UFZ-Bericht 16/2001, pp 7-30
43. Meyer BC, Zander P, Karpinski I, Michel B (2005) Multifunctionality of agriculture in Germany. Country Report MultAgri/WP 3. Available at: http://www.multagri.net/section/deliverable/index.php?section=5. Accessed September 3, 2007
44. UM Moertberg B Balfors WC Knol 2007 Landscape ecological assessment: a tool for integrating biodiversity issues in strategic environmental assessment and planning Journal of Environmental Management 82 4 457 470
45. Y Natuhara 2006 Landscape evaluation for ecosystem planning Landscape and Ecological Engineering 2 1 3 11
46. Neitsch SL, Arnold JG, Kiniry JR, Williams JR (2001) Soil and Water Assessment Tool user's manual. Version 2000
47. H Noesel M Ahrens 1997 Niederwildprojekt Thüringen: Ergebnisse der Felduntersuchungen Beiträge zur Jagd- und Wildforschung 22 117 125
48. H Nyenhuis 1999 Distribution and density of the brown hare (Lepus europaeus P.) tested after the influence of land use in North West-Germany Allgemeine Forst und Jagdzeitung 170 2 28 33
49. P Panek R Kamieniarz 1999 Relationships between density of brown hare Lepus europaeus and landscape structure in Poland in the years 1981-1995 Acta Theriologica 44 1 67 75
50. S Petit D Chamberlain K Haysom R Pywell J Vickery L Warman D Allen L Firbank 2003 Knowledge-based models for predicting species occurrence in arable conditions Ecography 26 5 626 640
51. Rimathe R (1977) Zur saisonalen Abundanzdynamik des Feldhasen (Lepus europaeus Pallas) im Schweizerischen Mittelland. Dissertation. University of Zürich
52. C Romero 2001 Extended lexicographic goal programming: a unifying approach Omega 29 1 63 71
53. C Romero 2004 A general structure of achievement function for a goal programming model European Journal of Operational Research 153 3 675 686
54. WAH Rossing P Zander E Josien JCJ Groot BC Meyer A Knierim 2007 Integrative modeling approaches for analysis of impact of multifunctional agriculture: a review for France, Germany and The Netherlands Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 120 1 51 57
55. E Skop JS Schou 1999 Modeling the effects of agricultural production. An integrated economic and environmental analysis using farm account statistics and GIS Ecological Economics 29 3 427 442
56. RK Smith NV Jennings S Harris 2005 A quantitative analysis of the abundance and demography of European hares Lepus europaeus in relation to habitat type, intensity of agriculture and climate Mammal Review 35 1 1 24
57. Späth V (1989) Untersuchungen zur Populationsökologie des Feldhasen (Lepus europaeus Pallas) in der Oberrheinebene. Institut für Forstzoologie, Freiburger Waldschutz Abhandlungen. Bd. 8
58. Straßenbauamt Döbeln-Torgau (2002) Verkehrszählung für Bundesstraßen (2000) und Kreisstraßen (2001). Not published
59. WJ Sutherland 2006 The identification of 100 ecological questions of high policy relevance in the UK Journal of Applied Ecology 43 617 627
60. M Tamiz D Jones C Romero 1998 Goal programming for decision making: an overview of the current state-of-the-art European Journal of Operational Research 111 3 569 581
61. Wierzbicki AP (1979) The use of the reference objectives in multiobjective optimization. IIASA wp:79-66
62. H Wiggering C Dalchow M Glemnitz K Helming K Mueller A Schultz U Stachow P Zander 2006 Indicators for multifunctional land use-linking socio-economic requirements with landscape potentials Ecological Indicators 6 1 238 249
63. GAA Wossink DL Osmond 2002 Farm economics to support the design of cost-effective Best Management Practice (BMP) programs to improve water quality: nitrogen control in the Neuse River Basin, North Carolina Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 57 4 213 220
64. Wright J, Revelle C, Cohon J (1983) A multiobjective integer programming model for the land acquisition problem. Regional Science and Urban Economics 13(1):31-53
65. K Yoon 1989 The propagation of errors in multiple-attribute decision analysis: a practical approach Journal of the Operational Research Society 40 7 681 686