Ethical rhetoric: Genomics and the moral content of UNESCO's "universal" declarations

Journal of Medical Ethics

Volumn 34, Issue 11, 2008, Pages

  Harmon, S H E ^a  

^a SCRIPT   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

BIOETHICS; ETHICS; HUMAN; HUMAN GENOME; HUMAN RIGHTS; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; MEDICAL ETHICS; MORALITY; REVIEW; UNITED NATIONS;

BIOETHICS; CODES OF ETHICS; GENOME, HUMAN; HUMAN RIGHTS; HUMANS; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; MORALS; UNITED NATIONS;

EID: 57149147565     PISSN: 03066800     EISSN: 14734257     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/jme.2008.024166     Document Type: Review

References (52)

1. Bennett L. Recurring dilemmas: the law's race to keep up with technological change. UNSW Research Paper No. 2007-21. 2007. http://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/disp.pl/ au/journals/UNSWLRS/2007/21.html? query=law%20morality%20biotechnology (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
2. Brownsword R. Ethical pluralism and the regulation of modern biotechnology. In: Francioni F, ed. Biotechnologies and international human rights. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2007:45-70.
3. Honneth A. The limits of liberalism: on the political-ethical discussion concerning communitarianism. In: Wright C, ed. The fragmented world of the social. NY: NYS Press, 1995.
4. Sandkühler H. Pluralism and the universality of rights. 1998. http://www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Law/LawSand.htm (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
5. Habermas J. Between facts and norms. Boston: MIT Press, 1996.
6. Shavell S. Law versus morality as regulators of conduct. Am Law & Eco Rev 2002;4:227-57.
7. Raz J. Incorporation by law. Legal Theory 2004;10:1-17.
8. IBC. Towards a declaration on universal norms on bioethics - written contributions, SHS/EST/04/CIB-EXTR/INF.1, 25 April 2003:33-4.
9. Schauer F. The social construction of the concept of law: a reply to Julie Dickson. Ox J Legal Studies 2005;25:493-501.
10. Ginsberg M. The enforcement of morals. Brit J Sociology 1961;12:65-8.
11. Unwin N. Morality, law and the evaluation of values. Mind 1985;94:538-49.
12. UNESCO. 29th General Conference, 29 C/Resolution 17, 11 Nov 1997. http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0011/001102/110220e.pdf#page=47 (accessed 11 Aug 2008) at p47, subsequently adopted by the UN General Assembly, per UN General Assembly Resolution A/RES/53/152, UN GAOR, 53rd Sess. (1998).
13. UNESCO. 33rd General Conference, 33 C/Resolution 36, 19 Oct 2005. Available at http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0014/001428/142825e.pdf#page=80 (accessed 11 Aug 2008), p80.
14. Bruce A, Tait J. Interests, values and biotechnological risk. In: Andersson K, ed. Values in decisions on risk proceedings. VALDOR 2003;109-18.
15. Harmon S. Regulation of Human genomics and genetic biotechnology: risks, values and analytical criteria. InnoGen WP-40. 2005. http://www. genomicsnetwork.ac.uk/media/Innogen%20Working%20Paper%2040.pdf (accessed 19 Sep 2008).
16. Harmon S. Solidarity: a (new) ethic for global health policy. Health Care Anal 2006;14:215-36.
17. Waldron J. Particular values and critical morality. Cal Law Rev 1989;77:561-89.
18. Raz J. The role of wellbeing. Phil Persp 2004;18:269-94.
19. For more on how these instruments borrow from the human rights context, see Broussard H. The 'normative spectrum' of an ethically-inspired legal instrument: The 2005 Universal Declaration on Bioethical and Human Rights. In: Francioni F, ed. Biotechnologies and international human rights. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2007:97-127.
20. For a critique of the UDB's assumption about humans, see Asai A, Oe S. A valuable up-to-date compendium of bioethical knowledge. Dev World Bioeth 2005;5:216-19.
21. Harmon S. The Significance of UNESCO's Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human Rights. SCRIPT-ed 2005;2:18-47.
22. Andorno R. Human Dignity and the UNESCO Declaration on the Human Genome. 2004. http://www.ccels.cf.ac.uk/archives/publications/2003/andornopaper. pdf (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
23. Harris J, Keywood K. Ignorance, information and autonomy. TMB 2001;22:415-36.
24. Berger K. Informed consent: information or knowledge? Med Law 2003;22:743-50.
25. Beauchamp T, Childress J. Principles of biomedical ethics. 4th ed. Oxford: OUP, 1994.
26. Aksoy S, Elmali A. The core concepts of the 'four principles' of bioethics as found in Islamic tradition. Med Law 2002;21:211-24.
27. UN Treaty on principles governing the activities of states in the exploration and use of outer space, including the moon & other celestial bodies. 1966.
28. UN Convention for the protection of the world cultural and natural heritage. 1972.
29. UN Agreement governing activities of states on the moon & other celestial bodies. 1979.
30. UN Law of the sea convention. 1982.
31. Pavoni R. Biodiversity and biotechnology? consolidation and strains in the emerging international legal regimes. In: Francioni F, Scovazzi T, eds. Biotechnology and international law. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2006:29-57.
32. Ida R. Human genome as common heritage of humankind. In: Fujiki N, Macer D, eds. Bioethics in Asia. Tsukuba: Eubios Ethics Institute, 1998:59-63.
33. Francioni F. Genetic resources, biotechnology and human rights: the international legal framework. In: Francioni F, ed. Biotechnologies and international human rights. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2007:3-32.
34. With regard to European approaches to solidarity between generations, see European Commission, promoting solidarity between the generations, COM(2007) 244, 10 May 2007. http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/news/2007/may/ 244_en. pdf (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
35. UN High Commissioner's Expert Group on human rights and biotechnology, "conclusions", 25 Jan 2002. http://www.unhchr.ch/ biotech/conclusions.htm (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
36. Francioni F. Genetic resources, biotechnology and human rights: the international legal framework. In: Francioni F, ed. Biotechnologies and international human rights. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2007:3-32, at 21.
37. For more on genetic determinism, see Glick D & Soreg H. Ethics, public policy and behavioural genetics. Int Med Ass J 2003;5:83-86.
38. Reilly P. Public concern about genetics. Ann Rev Genomics & H Gen 2000;1:485-506.
39. Caplan A. Handle with care: race, class and genetics. In: Murphy T, Lappe K, eds. Justice and the human genome project. Berkeley: U. of Cal. Press, 1994.
40. For more on genetic discrimination, see Motoc I. Special rapporteur, specific human rights issues: human rights and the human genome, E/CN.4/Sub.2/2004/38, 23 July 2004. http://daccessdds.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G04/ 155/02/PDF/G0415502.pdf?OpenEleme.
41. Li-Sun J. Supreme Court: until labour, the foetus is not a human being. Asia News 12 Jul 2007. Available at http://www.asianews.it/index. php?l=en&art= 9806&size=A (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
42. UNESCO. Advice of the IBC on the patentability of the human genome, IBC, 8th Session, Paris, 14 September 2001. http://portal.unesco. org/shs/en/files/2140/10510219961advice_english.pdf/advice%2Benglish.pdf (accessed 19 Sep 2008).
43. For more on liberal tenets of good government, see Burley J. An abstract approach to the regulation of human genetics: law, morality and social policy. In:Somsen H, ed. The regulatory challenge of biotechnology: human genetics, food and patents. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2006:63-92.
44. For more on the multiplicity of conceptions of democracy, see Collier D. Levitsky S. Democracy with adjectives: conceptual innovation in comparative research. World Politics 1997;29:430-51.
45. Selgelid M. Universal norms and conflicting values. DWB 2005;5:267-73.
46. Andorno R. Biomedicine and international human rights law: in search of a global consensus. WHO Bull 2002;80:959-63.
47. Boyle A. Some reflections on the relationship of treaties and soft law. ICLQ 1999;48:901-13.
48. Andorno R. The invaluable role of soft law in the development of universal norms in bioethics. 2007. http://www.unesco.de/1507.html?&L=0 (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
49. Convention for the protection of human rights and dignity of the human being with regard to the application of biology and medicine, Oviedo, ETS No. 164, 1997. Available at http://conventions.coe.int/treaty/en/treaties/html/164. htm (Accessed 18 Aug 2008).
50. Paris convention for the protection of industrial property (1970) available at http://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ip/paris/trtdocs_wo020.html#P19_137 (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
51. Agreement on trade-related aspects of intellectual property rights, Annex 1C, Marrakech agreement establishing the World Trade Organization, Marrakech, Morocco, 15 April 1994, available at http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/ trips_e/t_agm0_e.htm (accessed 18 Aug 2008).
52. WTO Ministerial declaration, WT/MIN(01)/DEC/1, 20 November 2001, available at http://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/minist_e/min01_e/mindecl_e.pdf (accessed 18 Aug 2008).