Dyslexia: A review of two theories

Clinical and Experimental Optometry

Volumn 91, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 333-340

  Nandakumar, Krithika ^a   Leat, Susan J ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WATERLOO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Dyslexia; Magnocellular pathway deficit; Meares Irlen syndrome; Reading disorder; Scotopic sensitivity syndrome; Specific reading disability

Indexed keywords

ASTHENOPIA; CRITICAL FLICKER FUSION; DYSLEXIA; HUMAN; OPTOMETRY; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PERCEPTION DISORDER; PHYSIOLOGY; PROFESSIONAL STANDARD; REVIEW; VISION; VISUAL SYSTEM;

ASTHENOPIA; DYSLEXIA; FLICKER FUSION; HUMANS; OPTOMETRY; PERCEPTUAL DISORDERS; PERCEPTUAL DISTORTION; PROFESSIONAL ROLE; VISION; VISUAL PATHWAYS;

EID: 45449109040     PISSN: 08164622     EISSN: 14440938     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1444-0938.2008.00277.x     Document Type: Review

References (78)

1. The British Dyslexia Association. Available at: http://www.bda-dyslexia. org.uk. Accessed February 26, 2007.
2. Curtin S, Manis FR, Seidenberg MS. Parallels between the reading and spelling deficits of two subgroups of developmental dyslexics. Reading Writing 2001 14 : 515 547.
3. Evans BJW. The underachieving child. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1998 18 : 153 159.
4. Paulesu E, Demonet JF, Fazio F, McCrory E, Chanoine V, Brunswick N, Cappa SF, Cossu G, Habib M, Frith CD, Frith U. Dyslexia: Cultural diversity and biological unity. Science 2001 291 (5511 2165 2167.
5. August GJ, Garfinkel BD. Comorbidity of ADHD and reading disability among clinic-referred children. J Abnorm Child Psychol 1990 18 : 29 45.
6. Norris JA, Bruning RH. Cohesion in the narratives of good and poor readers. J Speech Hear Disord 1988 53 : 416 424.
7. Vellutino FR, Fletcher JM, Snowling MJ, Scanlon DM. Specific reading disability (dyslexia): what have we learned in the past four decades? J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2004 45 : 2 40.
8. Buchholz J, McKone E. Adults with dyslexia show deficits on spatial frequency doubling and visual attention tasks. Dyslexia 2004 10 : 24 43.
9. Best M, Demb JB. Normal planum temporale asymmetry in dyslexics with a magnocellular pathway deficit. Neuroreport 1999 10 : 607 612.
10. Snowling M. Dyslexia as a phonological deficit: evidence and implications. Child Psychol Psychiatr Rev 1998 3 : 4 11.
11. Borsting E, Ridder WH 3rd., Dudeck K, Kelley C, Matsui L, Motoyama J. The presence of a magnocellular defect depends on the type of dyslexia. Vision Res 1996 36 : 1047 1053.
12. Vidyasagar TR. Attentional gating in primary visual cortex: a physiological basis for dyslexia. Perception 2005 34 : 903 911.
13. Talcott JB, Hansen PC, Willis-Owen C, McKinnell IW, Richardson AJ, Stein JF. Visual magnocellular impairment in adult developmental dyslexics. Neuro-Ophthalmology 1998 20 : 187 201.
14. Evans BJ, Wilkins AJ, Brown J, Busby A, Wingfield A, Jeanes R, Bald J. A preliminary investigation into the aetiology of Meares-Irlen syndrome. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1996 16 : 286 296.
15. Irlen H. Reading by the Colors: Overcoming Dyslexia and Other Reading Disabilities Through the Irlen Method. Avery Publishing Group, 1991.
16. Evans BJ. The need for optometric investigation in suspected Meares-Irlen syndrome or visual stress. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2005 25 : 363 370.
17. Kaplan E. The M, P, and K pathways of the primate visual system. In : Chalpua LM, Werner JS, editors. The Visual Neurosciences. Cambridge, Mass : MIT Press, 2004. p 481 493.
18. Casagrande VA. A third parallel visual pathway to primate area V1. Trends Neurosci 1994 17 : 305 310.
19. Lovegrove WJ, Garzia RP, Nicholson SB. Experimental evidence for a transient system deficit in specific reading disability. J Am Optom Assoc 1990 61 : 137 146.
20. Bednarek DB, Grabowska A. Luminance and chromatic contrast sensitivity in dyslexia: the magnocellular deficit hypothesis revisited. Neuroreport 2002 13 : 2521 2525.
21. Demb JB, Boynton GM, Best M, Heeger DJ. Psychophysical evidence for a magnocellular pathway deficit in dyslexia. Vision Res 1998 38 : 1555 1559.
22. Livingstone MS, Rosen GD, Drislane FW, Galaburda AM. Physiological and anatomical evidence for a magnocellular defect in developmental dyslexia. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1991 88 : 7943 7947.
23. Livingstone M, Hubel D. Segregation of form, color, movement, and depth: anatomy, physiology and perception. Science 1988 240 (4853 740 749.
24. Evans BJ, Drasdo N, Richards IL. An investigation of some sensory and refractive visual factors in dyslexia. Vision Res 1994 34 : 1913 1926.
25. Chase CPD, Dougherty RF, Ray NPD, Fowler SDBO, Stein JF. L/M speed-matching ratio predicts reading in children. Optom Vision Sci 2007 84 : 229 236.
26. Everatt J, Bradshaw MF, Hibbard PB. Visual processing and dyslexia. Perception 1999 28 : 243 254.
27. Romani A, Conte S, Callieco R, Bergamaschi R, Versino M, Lanzi G, Zambrino CA, Cosi V. Visual evoked potential abnormalities in dyslexic children. Funct Neurol 2001 16 : 219 229.
28. Demb JB, Boynton GM, Heeger DJ. Functional magnetic resonance imaging of early visual pathways in dyslexia. J Neurosci 1998 18 : 6939 6951.
29. Chase C, Ashourzadeh A, Kelly C, Monfette S, Kinsey K. Can the magnocellular pathway read? Evidence from studies of color. Vision Res 2003 43 : 1211 1222.
30. Skottun BC. The magnocellular deficit theory of dyslexia: the evidence from contrast sensitivity. Vision Res 2000 40 : 111 127.
31. Barnard N, Crewther SG, Crewther DP. Development of a magnocellular function in good and poor primary school-age readers. Optom Vis Sci 1998 75 : 62 68.
32. Graves RE, Frerichs RJ, Cook JA. Visual localization in dyslexia. Neuropsychology 1999 13 : 575 581.
33. Skottun BC, Parke LA. The possible relationship between visual deficits and dyslexia: examination of a critical assumption. J Learn Disabil 1999 32 : 2 5.
34. Williams MJ, Stuart GW, Castles A, McAnally KI. Contrast sensitivity in subgroups of developmental dyslexia. Vision Res 2003 43 : 467 477.
35. Breitmeyer BG. Unmasking visual masking: a look at the 'why' behind the veil of the 'how Psychol Rev 1980 87 : 52 69.
36. Lovegrove W. Weakness in the transient visual system: a causal factor in dyslexia? Ann N Y Acad Sci 1993 682 : 57 69.
37. Cornelissen P, Hansen P. Motion detection, letter position encoding, and single word reading. Ann Dyslexia 1998 48 : 155 188.
38. Steinman SB, Steinman BA, Garzia RP. Vision and attention. II: Is visual attention a mechanism through which a deficient magnocellular pathway might cause reading disability? Optom Vis Sci 1998 75 : 674 681.
39. Facoetti A, Paganoni P, Lorusso ML. The spatial distribution of visual attention in developmental dyslexia. Exp Brain Res 2000 132 : 531 538.
40. Galaburda A, Livingstone M. Evidence for a magnocellular defect in developmental dyslexia. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1993 682 : 70 82.
41. Solan HA, Shelley-Tremblay J, Hansen PC, Silverman ME, Larson S, Ficarra A. M-cell deficit and reading disability: a preliminary study of the effects of temporal vision-processing therapy. Optometry 2004 75 : 640 650.
42. Meares O. Figure/ground, brightness contrast, and reading disabilities. Visible Language 1980 14 : 13 29.
43. Irlen H. Reading problems and Irlen coloured lenses. Dyslexia Rev 1997 : 4 7.
44. Wilkins A, Huang J, Cao Y. Visual stress theory and its application to reading and reading tests. J Res Reading 2004 27 : 152 162.
45. Carroll TA, Mullaney P, Eustace P. Dark adaptation in disabled readers screened for scotopic sensitivity syndrome. Percept Mot Skills 1994 78 : 131 141.
46. Coyle B. Use of filters to treat visual-perception problem creates adherents and sceptics. Can Med Assoc J 1995 152 : 749 750.
47. Helveston EM. Scotopic sensitivity syndrome. Arch Ophthalmol 1990 108 : 1232 1233.
48. Wilkins AJ, Baker A, Amin D, Smith S, Bradford J, Zaiwalla Z, Besag FM, Binnie CD, Fish D. Treatment of photosensitive epilepsy using coloured glasses. Seizure 1999 8 : 444 449.
49. Wilkins AJ. Visual Stress. Oxford : Oxford University Press, 1995.
50. Evans BJ, Busby A, Jeanes R, Wilkins AJ. Optometric correlates of Meares-Irlen syndrome: a matched group study. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1995 15 : 481 487.
51. Scott L, McWhinnie H, Taylor L, Stevenson N, Irons P, Lewis E, Evans M, Evans B, Wilkins A. Coloured overlays in schools: orthoptic and optometric findings. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2002 22 : 156 165.
52. Simmers AJ, Bex PJ, Smith FK, Wilkins AJ. Spatiotemporal visual function in tinted lens wearers. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2001 42 : 879 884.
53. Lopez R, Yolton RL, Kohl P, Smith DL, Saxerud MH. Comparison of Irlen scotopic sensitivity syndrome test results to academic and visual performance data. J Am Optom Assoc 1994 65 : 705 714.
54. Evans BJ, Cook A, Richards IL, Drasdo N. Effect of pattern glare and colored overlays on a stimulated-reading task in dyslexics and normal readers. Optom Vis Sci 1994 71 : 619 628.
55. Wilkins AJ, Patel R, Adjamian P, Evans BJ. Tinted spectacles and visually sensitive migraine. Cephalalgia 2002 22 : 711 719.
56. Kriss I, Evans BJW. The relationship between dyslexia and Meares-Irlen syndrome. J Res Reading 2005 28 : 350 364.
57. Wilkins AJ, Sihra N, Myers A. Increasing reading speed by using colours: issues concerning reliability and specificity, and their theoretical and practical implications. Perception 2005 34 : 109 120.
58. Lightstone A, Lightstone T, Wilkins A. Both coloured overlays and coloured lenses can improve reading fluency but their optimal chromaticities differ. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1999 19 : 279 285.
59. Wilkins A, Sihra N, Smith IN. Technical Note: How precise do precision tints have to be and how many are necessary? Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2005 25 : 269.
60. Wilkins A. Coloured overlays and their effects on reading speed: a review. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2002 22 : 448 454.
61. Chan LKS, Robinson GLW. The effects of comprehension monitoring instruction for reading disabled students with and without tinted lenses. Aust J Special Educat 1989 13 : 4 13.
62. Winter S. Irlen lenses: an appraisal. Aust Educat Develop Psychol 1987 4 : 1 5.
63. Menacker SJ, Breton ME, Breton ML, Radcliffe J, Gole GA. Do tinted lenses improve the reading performance of dyslexic children? A cohort study. Arch Ophthalmol 1993 111 : 213 218.
64. Evans BJ, Patel R, Wilkins AJ, Lightstone A, Eperjesi F, Speedwell L, Duffy J. A review of the management of 323 consecutive patients seen in a specific learning difficulties clinic. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1999 19 : 454 466.
65. Shute RH. Psychology in Vision Care. Jordan Hill, Oxford : Butterworth Heinemann, 1991.
66. Wilkins AJ, Evans BJ, Brown JA, Busby AE, Wingfield AE, Jeanes RJ, Bald J. Double-masked placebo-controlled trial of precision spectral filters in children who use coloured overlays. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 1994 14 : 365 370.
67. Blaskey P, Scheiman M, Parisi M, Ciner EB, Gallaway M, Selznick R. The effectiveness of Irlen filters for improving reading performance: a pilot study. J Learn Disabil 1990 23 : 604 612.
68. Robinson GL, Foreman PJ. Scotopic sensitivity/Irlen syndrome and the use of coloured filters: a long-term placebo controlled and masked study of reading strategies using analysis of miscue. Percept Mot Skills 1999 88 : 35 52.
69. Robinson GL, Foreman PJ. Scotopic sensitivity/Irlen syndrome and the use of coloured filters: a long-term placebo controlled and masked study of reading achievement and perception of ability. Percept Mot Skills 1999 89 : 83 113.
70. Bouldoukian J, Wilkins AJ, Evans BJ. Randomised controlled trial of the effect of coloured overlays on the rate of reading of people with specific learning difficulties. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2002 22 : 55 60.
71. Shepherd AJ. Visual contrast processing in migraine. Cephalalgia 2000 20 : 865 880.
72. Evans B, Patel R, Wilkins A. Optometric function in visually sensitive migraine before and after treatment with tinted spectacles. Ophthalmic Physiol Opt 2002 22 : 130 142.
73. Riddell PM, Wilkins A, Hainline L. The effect of colored lenses on the visual evoked response in children with visual stress. Optom Vis Sci 2006 83 : 299 305.
74. Roorda A, Williams DR. The arrangement of the three cone classes in the living human eye. Nature 1999 397 (6719 520 522.
75. Stein J. Visual motion sensitivity and reading. Neuropsychologia 2003 41 : 1785 1793.
76. Ray NJ, Fowler S, Stein JF. Yellow filters can improve magnocellular function: motion sensitivity, convergence, accommodation and reading. Ann N Y Acad Sci 2005 1039 : 283 293.
77. Ciuffreda KJ, Scheiman M, Ong E, Rosenfield M, Solan HA. Irlen lenses do not improve accommodative accuracy at near. Optom Vis Sci 1997 74 : 298 302.
78. The Institute of Optometry. Available at: http://www.ioosales.co.uk. Accessed March 24 2007.