Why is the evidence favoring hemodialysis over peritoneal dialysis misleading?

Seminars in Dialysis

Volumn 20, Issue 3, 2007, Pages 200-202

  Burkart, John ^a,b   Piraino, Beth ^c,d   Kaldas, Hoda ^c   Lee, Ji Yang Sophie ^c   Bender, Filitsa H ^c   Krediet, Raymond T ^e,h   Boeschoten, Elisabeth W ^f   Dekker, Friedo W ^g   Vonesh, Edward ⁱ   Mujais, Salim ⁱ  

^a WAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b WAKE FOREST SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^c University of Pittsburgh ^*  (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^e UNIVERSITY OF AMSTERDAM   (Netherlands)

^f Hans Mak Institute for Quality Management in Nephrology   (Netherlands)

^g LEIDEN UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

^h ACADEMIC MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

ⁱ BAXTER HEALTHCARE CORPORATION   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 34249977035     PISSN: 08940959     EISSN: 1525139X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1525-139X.2007.00274.x     Document Type: Review

References (75)

1. United States Renal Data Systems Annual (USRDS) 2006 Report. Am J Kidney Dis 49 (S1 2007
2. Verbal communication - John Moran, MD (Baxter Renal Healthcare)
3. Korevaar J, Feith GW, Dekker FW, van Manen J, Boeschoten E, Bossuyt P, Krediet R for the NECOSAD Study Group. Xxxxxx. Kidney Int 64 : 2222 2228, 2003
4. Guo M : Kidney Int 64 (Suppl. 88 S1 S10, 2003
5. United States Renal Data Systems Annual (USRDS) 2005 Report. Am J Kidney Dis, 48 (S1 2006
6. Collins AJ, Wenli Hao MS, Ebben JP, Everson SE, Constantini EG, Ma JZ : Mortality risks of peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis. Am J Kidney Dis 30 : 334 342, 1997
7. Vonesh EF, et al. The differential impact of risk factors on mortality in hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Kidney Int 66 : 2389 2401, 2004
8. Fenton SSA, et al. Hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis: A comparison of adjusted mortality rates. Am J Kidney Dis 30 : 334 342, 1997
9. Collins AJ, et al. Mortality risks of peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis. Am J Kidney Dis 34 : 1065 1074, 1999
10. Heaf JG, Lokkegaard H, Madsen M : Initial survival advantage of peritoneal dialysis relative to haemodialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 17 : 112 117, 2002
11. Jaar BG, Coresh J, Plantings LC, Fink NE, Klag MJ, Levey AS, Levin NW, Sadler JH, Kliger A, Powe NR : Comparing the risk for death with peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis in a national cohort of patients with chronic kidney disease. Ann Int Med 143 : 174 183, 2005
12. Rubin HR, Fink NE, Plantinga LC, Sadler JH, Kliger AS, Powe NR : Patient ratings of dialysis care with peritoneal dialysis vs hemodialysis. JAMA 291 : 697 703, 2004
13. Mehrotra R, Blake P, Berman N, Nolph KD : An analysis of dialysis training in the United States and Canada. Am J Kidney Dis 40 (1 152 60, 2002
14. National Kidney Foundation : KDOQI Clinical Practice Guidelines And Clinical Practice Recommendations for 2006 Updates: Hemodialysis Adequacy, Peritoneal Dialysis Adequacy and Vascular Access. Am J Kidney Dis 48 : S1 S322, 2006
15. Korevaar J, Feith GW, Dekker FW, Van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Bossuyt PM, Krediet RT : For the NECOSAD STUDY GROUP 1 Effect of starting with hemodialysis compared with peritoneal dialysis in patients new on dialysis treatment A randomized controlled trial. Kidney Int 64 : 2222 2228, 2003
16. Bass EB, Wills S, Fink NE, Jenckes MW, Sadler JH, Levey AS, Meyer K, Powe NR : For the Choice Study. How strong are patients' preferences in choices between dialysis modalities and doses?. Am J Kidney Dis 44 : 695 705, 2004
17. Fenton SS, Schaubel DE, Desmeules M, Morrison HI, Mao Y, Copleston P, Jeffery JR, Kjellstrand CM : Hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis: a comparison of adjusted mortality rates. Am J of Kidney Dis 30 (3 334 42, 1997
18. Heaf JG, Lokkegaard H, Madsen M : initial survival advantage of peritoneal dialysis relative to haemodialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 17 : 112 117, 2002
19. U.S. Renal Data System : USRDS 2005 Annual Data Report: Atlas of End-Stage Renal Disease in the United States. Bethesda, MD : National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Disease, 2005
20. Korevaar JC, Van Manen JG, Dekker FW, De Waart D, Boeschoten E, Krediet RT : For the NECOSAD Study Group Effect of an increase in C-Reactive Protein Level during a Hemodialysis Session on Mortality. J Am Soc Nephrol 15 : 2916 2922, 2004
21. Jaar BG, Coresh J, Plantinga LC, Fink NE, Klag MJ, Levey AS, Levin NW, Sadler JH, Kliger A, Powe NR : Comparing the risk for death with peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis in a national cohort of patients with chronic kidney disease. Ann Intern Med 143 (3 174 83, 2005
22. Tokars JI, Light P, Anderson J, Miller ER, Parrish J, Armistead N, Jarvis WR, Gehr T : A prospective study of vascular access infections at seven outpatient hemodialysis centers. Am J Kidney Dis 37 : 1232 1240, 2001
23. Aslam N, Bernardini J, Fried L, Burr RA, Piraino B : Comparison of Infectious Complications between Incident Hemodialysis and Peritoneal Dialysis Patients. Clin Am Soc Nephrol 1 : 1226 1233, 2006
24. Fried LF, Bernardini J, Johnston JR, Piraino B : Peritonitis influences mortality in peritoneal dialysis patients. J Am Soc Nephrol 7 : 2176 2182, 1996
25. Metcalfe W, Khan IH, Prescott GJ, Simpson K, MacLeod A : On behalf of the Scottish Renal Registry: Can we improve early mortality in patients receiving renal replacement therapy Kid Int 57 : 2539 2545, 2000
26. Shemin D, Bostom AG, Laliberty P, Dworkin LD : Residual renal function and mortality risk in hemodialysis patients. Am J Kidney Dis 38 : 85 90, 2001
27. Moist LM, Port FK, Orzol SM, Young EW, Ostbye T, Wolfe RA, Hulbert-Shearon T, Jones CA, Bloembergen WE : Predictors of loss of residual renal function among new dialysis patients. J Am Soc Nephrol 11 : 556 564, 2000
28. Kronenber F, Konig P, Neyer U, Auinger M, Pribasnig A, Lang U, Reitinger J, Pinter G, Utermann G, Dieplinger H : Multicenter study of lipoprotein (a) and apoliprotein (a) phenotypes in patients with end-stage renal disease treated by hemodialysis or continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis. J Am Soc Nephrol 6 : 110 120, 1995
29. Attman P, Samuelsson O, Johansson A, Moberly J, Alaupovic P : Dialysis modalities and dyslipidemia. Kidney Int 84 (supplement S110 S112, 2003
30. Ganesh SK, Hulbert-Shearon T, Port FK, Eagel K, Stack AG : Mortality differences by dialysis modality among incident ESRD patients with and without coronary artery disease. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 : 415 424, 2003
31. Xue JL, Dahl D, Ebben J, Collins A : The association of initial hemodialysis access type with mortality outcomes in elderly medicare ESRD patients. Am J Kidney Dis 42 : 1013 1019, 2003
32. Collins AJ, Hao W, Xia H, Ebben JP, Everson SE, Constantini EG, Ma JZ : Mortality risks of peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis. Am J Kidney Dis 34 (6 1065 74, 1999
33. Winkelmayer WC, Glynn RJ, Levin R, Owen W, Avorn J : Late referral and modality choice in end-stage renal disease. Kidney Int 60 : 1547 1554, 2001
34. Termorshuizen F, Korevaar JC, Dekker FW, van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Krediet RT Hemodialysis, Peritoneal Dialysis : Comparison of Adjusted Mortality Rates According to the Duration of Dialysis: Analysis of the Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 : 2851 2860, 2003
35. Churchill DN, Taylor DW, Keshaviah PR for the Canada-USA (CANUSA) peritoneal dialysis study group. Adequacy of dialysis and nutrition in continuous peritoneal dialysis: association with clinical outcomes. J Am Soc Nephrol 7 : 198 207, 1996
36. Junor BJR for the specialty Section in Nephrology UEMS. Programme for harmonization of training in nephrology in the European Union. Nephrol Dial Transplant 11 : 1657 1660, 1996
37. Jager KJ, Korevaar JC, Dekker FW, Krediet RT, Boeschoten EW for the Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis (NECOSAD) study group : The effect of contraindications and patient preference on dialysis modality selection in ESRD patients in The Netherlands. Am J Kidney Dis 43 : 891 899, 2004
38. Little J, Irwin A, Marshall T, Raynes H, Smith S : Predicting a patient's choice of dialysis modality: experience in a United Kingdom renal department. Am J Kidney Dis 37 : 981 986, 2001
39. Gentil MA, Carriazo A, Paron MI, Rosado M, Castillo D, Ramos B, Algarra GR, Tejuca F, Baňasco VP, Milan JA : Comparison of survival in continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis and hospital haemodialysis: a multicentric study. Nephrol Dial Transplant 6 : 444 451, 1991
40. Maicorca R, Vonesh EF, Cavalli PL, De Vecchi A, Giangrande A, La Greca G, Scarpioni LL, Bragranti L, Cancarini G, Cantalupri A, Custelnova C, Custigliodi A, Poisetti PG, Viglino G : A multicenter, selection-adjusted compariosn of patient and technique survivals on CAPD and hemodialysis. Perit Dial Int 11 : 118 127, 1991
41. Van Biesen W, Vanholder RC, Veys N, Dhondt A, Lameire NH : An evaluation of an integrative care approach for end-stage renal disease patients. J Am Soc Nephrol 11 : 116 125, 2000
42. Davies SJ, van Biesen W, Nicholas J, Lameire N : Integrated care. Perit Dial Int 21 (Suppl. 3 S269 S274, 2001
43. Jager KJ, Merkus MP, Boeschoten EW, Dekker FW, Tijssen JCP, Krediet RT for the NECOSAD Study Group. What happens to patients starting dialysis in The Netherlands? Neth J Med 58 : 163 173, 2001
44. Locatelli F, Marcello D, Conte F, D'Amico M, Del Vecchio L, Limido A, Malberti F, Spotti D : Survival and development of cardiovascular disease by modality of treatment in pateints with end-stage renal disease. J Am Soc Nephrol 12 : 2411 2417, 2001
45. Heaf JG, Løkkegaard H, Madsen M : Initial survival advantage of peritoneal dialysis relative to haemodialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 17 : 112 117, 2002
46. Termorshuizen F, Korevaar JC, Dekker FW, Van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Krediet RT for the Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis Study Group : Hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis: comparison of adjusted mortality rates according to the duration of dialysis: analysis of the Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis 2. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 : 2851 2860, 2003
47. Liem YS, Wong JB, Hunnik MGM, De Charro FTh, Winkelmayer WC : Comparison of hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis survival in The Netherlands. Kidney Int 72 : 153 158, 2007
48. Fenton SSA, Schaubel DE, Desmenles M, Morrison HI, Mao Y, Copleston P, Jeffery JR, Kjellstrand CM : Hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis: a comparison of adjusted mortality rates. Am J Kidney Dis 30 : 334 342, 1997
49. Korevaar JC, Feith GW, Dekker FW, Van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Bossuyt PMM, Krediet RT for the NECOSAD Study Group. Effect of starting with hemodialysis compared with peritoneal dialysis in patients new on dialysis treatment: a randomized controlled trial. Kidney Int 64 : 2222 2228, 2003
50. Jansen MAM, Hart AAM, Korevaar JC, Dekker FW, Boeschoten EW, Krediet RT for the NECOSAD study group. Predictors of the rate of decline of residual renal function in incident dialysis patients. Kidney Int 62 : 1046 1053, 2002
51. Huisman RM, Nieuwenhuizen MGM, De Charro FTh : Patient-related and centre-related factors influencing technique survival of peritoneal dialysis in The Netherlands. Nephrol Dial Transplant 17 : 1655 1660, 2002
52. Van Dijk PCW, Jager KJ, De Charro F, Collart F, Cornet R, Dekker FW, Grönhagen-Riska C, Kramar R, Leivestad T, Simpson K, Briggs JD : Renal replacement therapy in Europe: the results of a collaborative effort by the ERA-EDTA registry and six national or regional registries. Nephrol Dial Transplant 16 : 1120 1129, 2001
53. Korevaar JC, Feith GW, Dekker FW, van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Bossuyt PM, Krediet RT : Effect of starting with hemodialysis compared with peritoneal dialysis in patients new on dialysis treatment: a randomized controlled trial. Kidney Int 64 : 2222 2228, 2003
54. Vonesh EF : Choice of statistical models for assessing the clinical outcomes of efforts to provide high quality care for the ESRD patient. In : Henderson LW, Thuma RS (eds). Assurance in Dialysis, 2nd edn. Boston, MA : Academic Publishers, 1999 : 39 54
55. Vonesh EF, Schaubel DE, Hao W, Collins AJ : Statistical methods for comparing mortality among ESRD patients: examples of regional/international variations. Kidney Int 57 : S19 S27, 2000
56. Heaf JG, Lokkegaard H, Madsen M : Initial survival advantage of peritoneal dialysis relative to haemodialysis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 17 : 112 117, 2002
57. Fenton SS, Schaubel DE, Desmeules M, Morrison HI, Mao Y, Copleston P, Jeffery JR, Kjellstrand CM : Hemodialysis versus peritoneal dialysis: a comparison of adjusted mortality rates. Am J Kidney Dis 30 : 334 342, 1997
58. Bloembergen WE, Port FK, Mauger EA, Wolfe RA : A comparison of mortality between patients treated with hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. J Am Soc Nephrol 6 : 177 183, 1995
59. Vonesh EF, Snyder JJ, Foley RN, Collins AJ : The differential impact of risk factors on mortality in hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Kidney Int 66 : 2389 2401, 2004
60. Xue JL, Chen SC, Ebben JP, Constantini EG, Everson SE, Frazier ET, Agodoa LY, Collins AJ : Peritoneal and hemodialysis: I. Differences in patient characteristics at initiation. Kidney Int 61 : 734 740, 2002
61. Ganesh SK, Hulbert-Shearon T, Port FK, Eagle K, Stack AG : Mortality differences by dialysis modality among incident ESRD patients with and without coronary artery disease. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 : 415 424, 2003
62. Stack AG, Molony DA, Rahman NS, Dosekun A, Murthy B : Impact of dialysis modality on survival of new ESRD patients with congestive heart failure in the United States. Kidney Int 64 : 1071 1079, 2003
63. Misra M, Vonesh E, Churchill DN, Moore HL, Van Stone JC, Nolph KD : Preservation of glomerular filtration rate on dialysis when adjusted for patient dropout. Kidney Int 57 : 691 696, 2000
64. Misra M, Vonesh E, Van Stone JC, Moore HL, Prowant B, Nolph KD : Effect of cause and time of dropout on the residual GFR: a comparative analysis of the decline of GFR on dialysis. Kidney Int 59 : 754 763, 2001
65. Lysaght MJ, Vonesh EF, Gotch F, Ibels L, Keen M, Lindholm B, Nolph KD, Pollock CA, Prowant B, Farrell PC : The influence of dialysis treatment modality on the decline of remaining renal function. ASAIO Trans 37 : 598 604, 1991
66. Chung SH, Heimburger O, Stenvinkel P, Qureshi AR, Lindholm B : Association between residual renal function, inflammation and patient survival in new peritoneal dialysis patients. Nephrol Dial Transplant 18 : 590 597, 2003
67. Jaar BG, Coresh J, Plantinga LC, Fink NE, Klag MJ, Levey AS, Levin NW, Sadler JH, Kliger A, Powe NR : Comparing the risk for death with peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis in a national cohort of patients with chronic kidney disease. Ann Intern Med 143 : 174 183, 2005
68. Lee HY, Choi HY, Park HC, Seo BJ, Do JY, Yun SR, Song HY, Kim YH, Kim YL, Kim DJ, Kim YS, Kim MJ, Shin SK : Changing prescribing practice in CAPD patients in Korea: increased utilization of low GDP solutions improves patient outcome. Nephrol Dial Transplant 21 : 2893 2899, 2006
69. Mujais S, Story K : Peritoneal dialysis in the US: evaluation of outcomes in contemporary cohorts. Kidney Int 70 (Suppl 103 S21 26, 2006
70. Ware JH : The limitations of risk factors as prognostic tools. N Engl J Med 355 : 2615 2617, 2006
71. Schaubel DE, Morrison HI, Fenton SS : Comparing mortality rates on CAPD/CCPD and hemodialysis. The Canadian experience: fact or fiction? Perit Dial Int 18 : 478 484, 1998
72. Collins AJ, Hao W, Xia H, Ebben JP, Everson SE, Constantini EG, Ma JZ : Mortality risks of peritoneal dialysis and hemodialysis. Am J Kidney Dis 34 : 1065 1074, 1999
73. Vonesh EF, Moran J : Mortality in end-stage renal disease: a reassessment of differences between patients treated with hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. J Am Soc Nephrol 10 : 354 365, 1999
74. Xue JL, Everson SE, Constantini EG, Ebben JP, Chen SC, Agodoa LY, Collins AJ : Peritoneal and hemodialysis: II. Mortality risk associated with initial patient characteristics. Kidney Int 61 : 741 746, 2002
75. Termorshuizen F, Korevaar JC, Dekker FW, Van Manen JG, Boeschoten EW, Krediet RT : Hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis: comparison of adjusted mortality rates according to the duration of dialysis: analysis of The Netherlands Cooperative Study on the Adequacy of Dialysis 2. J Am Soc Nephrol 14 : 2851 2860, 2003