Popcorn-worker lung caused by corporate and regulatory negligence: An avoidable tragedy

International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health

Volumn 13, Issue 1, 2007, Pages 85-98

  Egilman, David ^a   Mailloux, Caroline ^b   Valentin, Claire ^b  

^a BROWN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b Never Again Consulting   (United States)

Author keywords

Bronchiolitis obliterans; Butter flavorings; Corporate corruption; Diacetyl; GRAS; Occupational disease; Popcorn worker lung

Indexed keywords

2,3 BUTANEDIONE; FLAVORING AGENT;

BRONCHIOLITIS OBLITERANS; BUTTER; CONFIDENTIALITY; EMPLOYER; EPIDEMIC; FLAVOR; FOOD PROCESSING; HUMAN; INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE; INDUSTRIAL WORKER; LAW SUIT; LEGAL LIABILITY; OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE; OCCUPATIONAL LUNG DISEASE; OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY; POPCORN WORKER LUNG; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE; REVIEW;

EID: 33947519528     PISSN: 10773525     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1179/oeh.2007.13.1.85     Document Type: Review

References (98)

1. Kreiss K, Gomaa A, Kullman G, Fedan K, Simoes EJ, Enright PL. Clinical bronchiolitis obliterans in workers at a microwave-popcorn plant. N Engl J Med. 2002;347:330-8.
2. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. NIOSH Alert: Preventing Lung Disease in Workers Who Use or Make Flavorings. Cincinnati, OH: NIOSH; 2003 Dec 11.
3. Hubbs AF, Battelli LA, Goldsmith WT, et al. Necrosis of nasal and airway epithelium in rats inhaling vapors of artificial butter flavoring. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2002;185:128-35.
4. Pope C, Ziebland S, Mays N. Qualitative research in health care: analysing qualitative data. Br Med J. 2000;320:114-6.
5. Schneider A. Disease is swift, response is slow; government lets flavoring industry police itself, despite damage to workers' lungs. Baltimore Sun. 2006; Apr 23.
6. Thorpe J. Medical Records of Janice Irick. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Case number A0307157. 3/4/1992.
7. Memo of Janice Dees. Summary of worker diseases and work locations, undated but written before July 1997. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Case number A0307157. 1997.
8. Egilman D. Personal communication with RG. 8/29/2006.
9. Brown H. Letter to Ms. Bonar-Stewart from Montgomery County, Ohio, Office; exhibit in Timothy Arthur, et al., vs. IFF Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 11/17/1992.
10. Deposition of Karen Duros. Timothy Arthur, et al., vs. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 3/02/2006.
11. Spence, Mauney, Groll. Missouri Baptist Medical Center Surgical Pathology Report for DA. 6/19/2003.
12. Beck JR. History and physical, Memorial Hospital, Chester, Illinois, for DA. 3/18/2003.
13. Parmet AJ. Personal communication to AR Powell; Re: Linda J. Redman. Plaintiffs Exhibit LJR 30. Redman and Benavides, et al., v. International Flavor and Fragrances, et al. Case number 01-CV-683025 in the Jasper County, missouri, Court. 4/21/2001.
14. Parmet AJ. Bronchiolitis in popcorn-factory workers. N Engl J Med. 2002;347:1980-2.
15. Opdyke DL, Moreno OM. M B Research Laboratories Report to the Research Institute for Fragrance Materials, Inc. Exhibit 1723. Brand v. IFF, Inc., et al. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri, Division I. Case number 01CV683025-30 on 8/13/2002. 1/24/1977.
16. Research Institute for Fragrance Manufacturers. 〈http://www. rifm.org/〉 2006.
17. NIOSH. Hazard evaluation and technical assistance report: International Bakers Services, South Bend, IN. 1986. Report No.: NIOSH 85-171-1710.
18. Jones GM. Affidavit of Susan M. Daum, MD. Daniel J. Kois v. A. E. Staley Manufacturing Company, et al. Case number CTC 86-117. State of Indiana, County of Marshall. 1/9. 4/3/1989.
19. Jones GM. Appendix B. Affidavit of Jay A. Young, Ph.D. Daniel J. Kois v. A. E. Staley Manufacturing Company, et al. Case number CTC 86-117. State of Indiana, County of Marshall. 4/3/1989.
20. Personal communication between David Egilman and Jay Young. 7/27/2006.
21. 50 of diacetyl FCC as a vapor in rats 4-hour exposure. BASF Aktiengesellschaft. 1993; Jun 8.
22. Ames EC. Draft of Interim of Health and Safety Brochure, Health Aspects of Fiberglass. Exhibit No.1. Dominic Forte and Josephine Forte, his wife, v. Johns-Manville, et al. Civil Action number 78-2509, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey. 6/12/1941.
23. Restatement of the law, second, torts, 2d, 552, American Law Institute Publishers, 1965.
24. Trigg E. National Paint, Varnish and Lacquer Association, Inc. To Class A Members. 1-4. 7/18/1939.
25. Williams KJ, Kalsher MJ, Laughery KR. Allocation of responsibility for injuries. In: Wogalter MS (ed). Handbook of Warnings. First ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2006: 617-28.
26. Parmet AJ, Von Essen S. Rapidly progressive, fixed airway obstructive disease in popcorn workers: a new occupational pulmonary illness? J Occup Environ Med. 2002;44:216-8.
27. Testimony of Dr. David Egilman. Kenneth "Junior" Moenning and Alisha Moenning, vs. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. Division I. Case number 01 CV 683025-04. 7/5/2005.
28. Akpinar-Elci M, Travis WD, Lynch DA, Kreiss K. Bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome in popcorn production plant workers. Eur Respir J. 2004;24:298-302.
29. Personal communication between David Egilman and Ken Haubein. 3/11/2004.
30. Personal communication David Egilman with Hank Brand [index case 1 in Akapinar-Elci]. 3/24/2005.
31. Personal communication, David Egilman with various mixing room workers, including Eric Peoples, Hank Brand, and Ed Pennell. 2006.
32. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Important Worker Health Notice for the GML Popcorn Plant in Jasper, Missouri. Exhibit 1479.26. Brand v. IFF, Inc., et al. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. Division I. Case number 01CV683025-30. 2003.
33. Boylstein R, Piacitelli C, Grote A, Kanwal R, Kullman G, Kreiss K. Diacetyl Emissions and airborne dust from butter flavorings used in microwave popcorn production. J Occup Environmental Hyg. 2006;3:530-5.
34. Hubbs, Battelli, Merceri. Inhalation toxicity of the flavoring agent, diacetyl (2,3 butanedione) in the upper respiratory tract of rats. Toxicologist. 2004;78 (suppl 1):4389.
35. Fedan JS, Dowdy JA, Fedan KB, Hubbs AF. Popcorn worker's lung: in vitro exposure to diacetyl, an ingredient in microwave popcorn butter flavoring, increases reactivity to methacholine. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2006;215:17-22.
36. White S. Biopsy report of JW to Dr. R. Baughman. 8/18/1994.
37. Baughman R. Letter to Dr. James Lockey re: MSM. 1/26/1996.
38. Baughman R. Letter to RL Goodman Re: RG. 2/14-/1996.
39. Bureau of Workers Compensation Original Claim No. 95-605174. Industrial Commission of Ohio, 4/20/1998.
40. Packer D. Record of Proceedings for Claim No. 95-605274. Industrial Commission of Ohio. 4-28-1998.
41. Packer D. Record of Proceedings for Claim No 94-579964. Industrial Commission of Ohio. 4-28-1998.
42. Deposition of John Hochstrasser Vol II. Timothy Arthur, et al., vs. International Flavor & Fragrances Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 3/10/2006.
43. Deposition of Stewart Brooks. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 2/21/2005.
44. Brooks S. Bill of Stewart Brooks. TM004728-TM004732. 7-15-1995. Exhibit 66 Deposition of John Hochstrasser Volume II. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Case number A0307157. 3/10/2005.
45. Deposition of Nancy Higley. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 4/6/2006.
46. Deposition of James Lockey, MD. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 11/16/2004.
47. Mace DR. Givaudan Flavors Corporation's Motion for Summary Judgment, Including Attached Interrogatory Responses and Affidavits of Patricia Wehrung and Dave Bratton. Beverly Mitchell v. International Flavors & Fragrances, Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0404929. Judge David P. Davis. 2006.
48. Biscopink J. E-mail from Jerry Biscopink to Jeff Christ and Paul Farrell. Exhibit 12 in deposition of Paul Farrell 03/15/2006. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 6-/21/1995.
49. Deposition of Roy McKay. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 7/13/2006.
50. Deposition of John M. Hochstrasser John M. Hochstrasser v. Givaudan Roure Flavors Corporation. District Court of Southern District of Ohio, Western Division. Case number C-1-98-572. 5/11/1999.
51. Deposition of John M. Hochstrasser. Timothy Arthur, et al., v. IFF, et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 1/5/2006.
52. Baughman RP. Interstitial lung and sarcoidosis clinic report; letter to Dr. Lamping. Industrial Commission of Ohio, Re: RP. 3/1/2005.
53. Baughman RP. Ohio Bureau of Worker's Compensation Claim for RP No. 05-802737. Industrial Commission of Ohio. 4/21/2005.
54. Personal communication between J. Sweeney and David Egilman. 10/5/2006.
55. Deposition of John B. Hallagan, Esq. Kevin Remmes v. International Flavors & Fragrances, Inc., Givaudan Flavors Corporation, Flavors of North America, Inc., and Sensient Flavors, Inc. Case number c04-4061MWB. Volume 1. 7/28/2006.
56. Flavor & Extract Manufacturers Association. Respiratory Safety in the Flavor & Fragrance Workplace. Plaintiff Exhibit 1532: Deposition of Cecile Rose. Richard S. Brand, v. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. Division I. Case number 01cv683025-30. 03/04/2005.
57. Deposition of Stephen Block. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 4/26/2006.
58. Deposition of James E. Lockey, MD. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 8/11/2006.
59. Deposition of David Carroll. Richard S. Brand v. International Flavors & Fragrances, Inc., et al. Division I. Case number 01cv683025-30. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 1/23/2003.
60. Deposition of Michael Davis. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 3/16/2006.
61. Deposition of Elizabeth D. O'Connor. Kevin Reemes v. International Flavors &? Fragrances, Inc., et al. Case number C04-4061MWB. 6/7/2006.
62. Berje International. Material Safety Data Sheet, Plaintiff's Exhibit 2222. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 2/19/1991.
63. Gist Brocades Diacetyl MSDS 1997. Exhibit No. 10. Deposition of Robert Brogus in Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 4/25/2006.
64. Woodside. Responses and Objections of Defendant Bush Boake Allen, Inc., to Plaintiffs' First Request for Production. Exhibit 1695. Rafaela Benavides, et al., individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated v International Flavors and Fragrances, Inc., et al. Division I. Case number 01CV683025. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 8/13/2002.
65. Malloy J M. Air Sampling for Diacetyl. Plaintiff Exhibit 1762. Brand v. IFF, Inc., et al. Division I. Case number 01CV683025-30. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 4/1/1992.
66. Gillen J. Safety Committee Meeting Minutes, March 17, 1993. Exhibit No. 26 in Deposition of James Lockey, November 16, 2004. Timothy Arthur et al., vs. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. Case number A0307157. 3/18/1993.
67. Deposition of Carlos Montenegro. Benavides et al. v. Interntaional Flavor and Fragrances Inc. Case number 01cv683025. Division I. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 4/3/2003.
68. Lindberg L. Bush Boake Allen Inc. Internal Memo Subject: Butter Processing Manufacturing Procedures. IFF 010543. 9/15/1995.
69. Bohme SR, Egilman D. Consider the Ssource: warnings and anti-warnings in the tobacco, automobile, beryllium, and pharmaceutical industries. In: Wogalter MS (ed). Handbook of Warnings. 1st ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 2006: 635-44
70. Sall D. Subject: Respirators for Compounding. Exhibit 41. McNeely v. BBA, et al. Case number 01cv-683025-23 (August 2005). Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 11/12/1993.
71. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc. International Flavors and Fragrances Material Data Safety Sheet for Nat. and Art. Butter Flavor 85032. Exhibit No. 30 in Deposition of David Rosen. Timothy Arthur et al., vs. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A 0307157. 4/13/1993.
72. Sall D. Internal Memo to G. Adams from Dennis Sall. Industrial Hygiene Recommendations. Exhibit 1646. Brand v. IFF, Inc., et al. Division I. Case number 01CV683025-30. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 6/29/1995.
73. Label for Bush Boake Allen Inc. Natural & Artificial Butter Flavor No. 85032. Exhibit 1565 in Brand v. IFF, Inc., et al. Division I. Case number 01CV683025-30. Circuit Court of Jasper County, Missouri. 8/13/2002.
74. Deposition of Thomas Bates. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. International Flavors & Fragrances, Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas Hamilton County, Ohio. 8/16/2006.
75. Deposition of David Rosen. 62. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 4/23-/2006.
76. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc. IFF Implementation of FEMA Labeling Recommendations Q&A, 5 December 2005. Plaintiffs Exhibit 2228, Bates 7. Deposition of Thomas Bates. Timothy Arthur, et al., vs. International Flavors & Fragrances Inc., et al. Court of Common Pleas. Hamilton County, Ohio. Case number A0307157. 12/5/2005.
77. Brogus R. E-mail from Rob Brogus, Manager of Hazard Communication IFF Corporate Safety Assurance, to Mark Fukayama. Plaintiff's Exhibit 2230, Bates 9. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 3/25/2004.
78. Gibson K. E-mail from Kip Gibson. FEMA labeling Impact Analysis-Sales Advance. Plaintiffs Exhibit 2231, Bates. 10. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 7/27/2005.
79. Senna R. Letter to Michael O'Donnell of ConAgra from International Flavors and Fragrances, Inc. Exhibit 48. Deposition of David Rosen. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 9/1/2004.
80. Rosen D. E-mail to John Heffernan Re: Conagra Sales. Exhibit No. D357939, Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 9/22/2005.
81. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Section E. Toxic Substances Control Act Law: Toxic Substances Control Act, 15 U.S.C. Sections 2601 to 2692 (Regulations found at 40 CFR 700 to 799). 〈http://www epa gov〉. 2006, September 6. 〈http:// www.epa.gov/dfe/pubs/pwb/tech_rep/fedregs/regsecte. htm〉.
82. Smith RL, Cohen SM, Doull J, et al. The Expert Panel of the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association criteria for the safety evaluation of flavoring substances. Toxicol. 2005;43:1141-77.
83. Smith RL, Cohen J, Doull J, et al. GRAS Flavoring Substances 21. Food Technology. 2003;57(5):46-59.
84. Bowman C. Flavoring suspected in lung disease cases. Sacramento Bee. 2006; September 4.
85. Personal communication between David Egilman and XX. 8/31/2006.
86. Research Institute for Fragrance Materials (RIFM). Flavor or Fragrance Ingredient Data Sheet, Exhibit 16 in Deposition of Michael Davis. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 3/16/2006
87. Martyny J. Presentation by John Martyny, PhD. C.I.H. at Flavor & Extract Manufacturers' Association of the United States Workshop on Respiratory Health and Safety in the Workplace. 3/27/1997.
88. Deposition of Glenn Ingraham. Timothy Arthur, et al. v. IFF Inc., et al. Case number A0307157. Court of Common Pleas, Hamilton County, Ohio. 3/3/2006.
89. US Department of Labor Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Description of OSHAMSDS Initiative and Sample - MSDSs. 〈http://www osha gov/dsg/hazcom/MSDSenforce mentInitiative html〉. 2006 October 5.
90. Freund E, Seligman P, Chorba T, et al. Mandatory Reporting of Occupational Diseases by Clinicians. Centers for Disease Control Recommendations and Reports. 1990;June 22;39(RR-9):19-23.
91. Ohio Administrative Code. Reporting of Occupational Diseases 3701-3-02.1. 〈http://onlinedocs andersonpublishing com〉. 2003; July 23.
92. Constitution of the State of Ohio. Article 2, Section 35, as amended 1924. 2006.
93. CW. CW Affidavit. 2/3/1999.
94. Ohio Bureau of Workers Compensation Medical Claims for Case No. 95-632546. Industrial Commission of Ohio Re: CW. 2/19/1999.
95. United States District Court for the District of Columbia, USA and Tobacco-Free Kids Action Fund, American Cancer Society, American Health Association, American Lung Association, Americans for Non-smokers' Rights and National African American Tobacco Prevention Network v. Philip Morris USA, Inc. Civil Action NO99-2496 (GK). Final Opinion by Gladys Kessler, United States District Court Judge. 9/22/1999. United States District Court for the District of Columbia. 8/17/2006.
96. Personal communication between David Egilman and Scott Hall. 3/16/2005.
97. US Department of Labor Occupational Safety and Health Administration. OSH Act of 1970. Section 5. Duties. 〈http:// www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp. show_document?p_table= OSHACT&p_id=3359〉.
98. George Santayana. Reason in common sense. In: Life of Reason. 1905.