Empirical advances in the assessment of the capacity to consent to medical treatment: Clinical implications and research needs

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 26, Issue 8, 2006, Pages 1054-1077

  Moye, Jennifer ^a   Gurrera, Ronald J ^a   Karel, Michele J ^a   Edelstein, Barry ^b   O'Connell, Christopher ^c  

^a HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^b WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c STONEHILL COLLEGE   (United States)

Author keywords

Aging; Competence; Informed consent

Indexed keywords

AGING; ARTICLE; CLINICAL ASSESSMENT; CLINICAL PRACTICE; CLINICAL PROTOCOL; COGNITION; COMPREHENSION; CONSTRUCT VALIDITY; DEMENTIA; EMPIRICISM; HUMAN; INFORMATION PROCESSING; INFORMED CONSENT; INSTRUMENT; INTERRATER RELIABILITY; INTERVIEW; INTRARATER RELIABILITY; MEDICAL DECISION MAKING; MEDICAL INSTRUMENTATION; MEDICAL RESEARCH; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST; PHYSICIAN ATTITUDE; QUALITY OF LIFE; SCHIZOPHRENIA; TEST RETEST RELIABILITY; WORKING MEMORY;

ATTITUDE; DECISION MAKING; EMPIRICAL RESEARCH; HEALTH SERVICES NEEDS AND DEMAND; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES; QUESTIONNAIRES;

EID: 33846264587     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2005.04.013     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Allen-Burge R., and Haley W.E. Individual differences ad surrogate medical decisions: Differing preferences for life-sustaining treatments. Aging and Mental Health 1 (1997) 121-131
2. Anderer S.J. Determining competency in guardianship proceedings (1990), American Bar Association, Washington, DC
3. Appelbaum P.S., and Grisso T. Assessing patients' capacities to consent to treatment. New England Journal of Medicine 319 (1988) 1635-1638
4. Appelbaum P.S., and Grisso T. Manual for perceptions of disorder (1992), University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, MA
5. Astrom A.N., and Blay D. Multidimensional health locus of control scales: Applicability among Ghanaian adolescents. East African Medical Journal 79 (2002) 128-133
6. Barton C.D., Mallik H.S., Orr W.B., and Janofsky J.S. Clinicians' judgement of capacity of nursing home patients to give informed consent. Psychiatric Services 47 (1996) 956-960
7. Bean G., Nishisato S., Rector N.A., and Glancy G. The assessment of competence to make a treatment decision: An empirical approach. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 41 (1996) 85-92
8. Beisecker A. Aging and the desire for information and input in medical decisions: Patient consumerism in medical encounters. The Gerontologist 28 (1988) 330-335
9. Birren J.E., Lubben J.E., Rowe J.C., and Deutschman D.E. The concept and measurement of quality of life in the frail elderly (1991), Academic Press, San Diego
10. Blackhall L.J., Murphy S.T., Frank G., Michel V., and Azen S. Ethnicity and attitudes toward patient autonomy. Journal of the American Medical Association 274 (1995) 820-825
11. Blanchard-Fields F. Emotion and everyday problem solving in adult development. In: Magai C., and McFadden S.H. (Eds). Handbook of emotion, adult development, and aging (1996), Academic Press, London 149-165
12. Caralis P.V., Davis B., Wright K., and Marcial E. The influence of ethnicity and race on attitudes towards advance directives, life-prolonging treatments, and euthanasia. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 4 (1993) 155-165
13. Carney M.T., Neugroschl J., Morrison R.S., Marin D., and Siu A.L. The development and piloting of a capacity assessment tool. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 12 (2001) 17-23
14. Collopy B.J. The moral underpinning of the proxy-provider relationship: Issues of trust and distrust. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 27 (1999) 37-45
15. Craik F.I.M. Memory changes in normal aging. Current Directions in Psychological Science 3 (1994) 155-158
16. Craik F.I.M., and Byrd M. Aging and cognitive deficits: The role of attentional resources. In: Craik F.I.M., and Trehub S. (Eds). Aging and cognitive processes (1982), Plenum, New York 191-211
17. Craik F.I.M., and Jennings J.M. Human memory. In: Craik F.I.M., and Salthouse T.A. (Eds). The handbook of aging and cognition (1992), Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ 51-110
18. Degner L., and Sloan J. Decision making during serious illness: What role do patients really want to play?. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 45 (1992) 941-950
19. Deimling G.T., Smerglia V.L., and Barresi C.M. Health care professionals and family involvement in care-related decisions concerning older patients. Journal of Aging and Health 2 (1990) 310-325
20. Dellasega C., Frank L., and Smyer M. Medical decision-making capacity in elderly hospitalized patients. Journal of Ethics, Law and Aging 2 (1996) 65-74
21. Department of Veterans Affairs. Clinical assessment for competency determination: A practice guideline for psychologists (1997), Department of Veterans Affairs, National Center for Cost Containment, Milwaukee
22. Ditto P.H., Druley J.A., Moore K.A., Danks J.H., and Smucker W.D. Fates worse than death: The role of valued life activities in health-state evaluations. Health Psychology 15 (1996) 332-343
23. Drane J.F. The many faces of competency. Hastings Center Report 15 (1985) 17-21
24. Dunn L.B., and Jeste D.V. Enhancing informed consent for research and treatment. Neuropsychopharmacology 24 (2001) 595-607
25. Dymek M.P., Atchison P., Harrell L., and Marson D.C. Competency to consent to medical treatment in cognitively impaired patients with Parkinson's disease. Neurology 56 (2001) 17-24
26. Earnst K.S., Marson D.C., and Harrell L.E. Cognitive model of physicians' legal standard and personal judgments of competency in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Journal of The American Geriatric Society 48 (2000) 919-927
27. Edelstein B. Hopemont capacity assessment interview manual and scoring guide (1999), West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV
28. Edelstein B., Nygren M., Northrop L., Staats N., and Pool D. Assessment of capacity to make financial and medical decisions. Paper presented at meeting of the American Psychological Association, Toronto (1993, August)
29. Eleazer G.P., Hornung C.A., Egbert C.B., Egbert J.R., Eng C., Hedgepeth J., et al. The relationship between ethnicity and advance directives in a frail older population. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 44 (1996) 938-943
30. Engleman H.M., and Wild M.R. Improving CPAP use by patients with the sleep apnoea/hypoponea syndrome (SAHS). Sleep Medicine Reviews 7 (2003) 81-99
31. Etchells E., Darzins P., Silberfeld M., Singer P.A., McKenny J., Naglie G., et al. Assessment of patients capacity to consent to treatment. Journal of General Internal Medicine 14 (1999) 27-34
32. Eth S., and Leong G.B. Forensic and ethical issues. In: Birren J.E., Sloane R.B., and Cohen G.D. (Eds). Handbook of mental health and aging. 2nd ed. (1992), Academic Press, New York 854-872
33. Finucane M.L., Alhakami A., Slovic P., and Johnson S.M. The affect heuristic in judgments of risks and benefits. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 13 (2000) 1-17
34. Fitten L.J., Lusky R., and Hamann C. Assessing treatment decision-making capacity in elderly nursing home residents. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 38 (1990) 1097-1104
35. Fitten L.J., and Waite M.S. Impact of medical hospitalization on treatment decision making capacity in the elderly. Archives of Internal Medicine 150 (1990) 1717-1721
36. Fowers B.J. Perceived control, illness status, stress, and adjustment to cardiac illness. The Journal of Psychology 128 (1994) 567-576
37. Frank L., Smyer M., Grisso T., and Applebaum P. Measurement of advance directive and medical treatment decision-making capacity of older adults. Journal of Mental Health and Aging 5 (1999) 257-274
38. Ganzini L., Volicer L., Nelson W., and Derse A. Pitfalls in the assessment of decision-making capacity. Psychosomatics 44 (2003) 237-243
39. Garrett J.M., Harris R.P., Norburn J.K., Patrick D.L., and Danis M. Life-sustaining treatments during a terminal illness: Who wants what?. Journal of General Internal Medicine 8 (1993) 361-368
40. Grisso T. Evaluating competences. 2nd ed. (2003), Plenum, New York
41. Grisso T., and Appelbaum A. MacArthur competency assessment tool for treatment (MacCAT-T) (1998), Professional Resource Press, Sarasota, FL
42. Grisso T., and Appelbaum P.S. Manual for understanding treatment disclosures (1992), University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, MA
43. Grisso T., and Appelbaum P.S. Manual for thinking rationally about treatment (1993), University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, MA
44. Grisso T., and Appelbaum P.S. Comparison of standards for assessing patient's capacities to make treatment decisions. American Journal of Psychiatry 152 (1995) 1033-1037
45. Grisso T., and Appelbaum P.S. The MacArthur treatment competency study: III. Abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatment. Law and Human Behavior 19 (1995) 149-174
46. Grisso T., and Applebaum P.S. Assessing competence to consent to treatment (1998), Oxford, New York
47. Grisso T., Appelbaum P.S., Mulvey E.P., and Fletcher K. The MacArthur treatment competency study: II. Measures of abilities related to competence to consent to treatment. Law and Human Behavior 19 (1995) 127-148
48. Hardwig J. What about the family?. Hastings Center Report (1990) 5-10
49. Hasher L., and Zacks R.T. Working memory, comprehension, and aging: A review and new view. In: Bower G.H. (Ed). The Psychology of Learning and Motivation vol. 22 (1988), Academic Press, New York 193-225
50. High D.M. All in the family: Extended autonomy and expectations in surrogate health care decision-making. The Gerontologist 28 (1988) 46-51
51. Hopp F.P., and Duffy S.A. Racial variations in end-of-life care. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 48 (2000) 658-663
52. Hornung C.A., Eleazer G.P., Strothers H.S., Wieland G.D., Eng C., McCann R., et al. Ethnicity and decision-makers in a group of frail older people. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 46 (1998) 280-286
53. Janofsky J.S., McCarthy R.J., and Folstein M.F. The Hopkins competency assessment test: A brief method for evaluating patients' capacity to give informed consent. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 43 (1992) 132-136
54. Johansson B., Grant J.D., Plomin R., Pedersen N.L., Ahern F., Berg S., et al. Health locus of control in late life: A study of genetic and environmental influences in twins aged 80 years and older. Health Psychology 20 (2001) 33-40
55. Johnson M.M.S. Age differences in decision making: A process methodology for examining strategic information processing. Journal of Gerontology 45 (1990) 75-78
56. Kahneman D., Slovic P., and Tversky A. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases (1982), Cambridge University Press, New York
57. Karel M.J. The assessment of values in medical decision making. Journal of Aging Studies 14 (2000) 403-422
58. Karel M.J., and Gatz M. Factors influencing life-sustaining treatment decisions in a community sample of families. Psychology and Aging 11 (1996) 226-234
59. Karel M.J., Powell J., and Cantor M. Using a values discussion guide to facilitate communication in advance care planning. Patient Education and Counseling 55 (2004) 22-31
60. Kim S.Y.H., and Caine E.D. Utility and limits of the Mini Mental State Examination in evaluating consent capacity in Alzheimer's disease. Psychiatric Services 53 (2002) 1322-1324
61. Kim S.Y.H., Caine E.D., Currier G.W., Leibovici A., and Ryan J.M. Assessing the competence of persons with Alzheimer's disease in providing informed consent for participation in research. American Journal of Psychiatry 158 (2001) 712-717
62. Kim S.Y.H., Karlawish J.H.T., and Caine E.D. Current state of research on decision-making competence of cognitively impaired elderly persons. American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 10 (2002) 151-165
63. Klessig J. Cross-cultural medicine: A decade later - The effect of values and culture on life-support decisions. Western Journal of Medicine 157 (1992) 316-322
64. Kuhberger A. The influence of framing on risky decisions: A meta-analysis. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 75 (1998) 23-55
65. Lawton M.P., Moss M., Hoffman C., Grant R., Have T.T., and Kleban M.H. Health, valuation of life, and the wish to live. The Gerontologist 39 (1999) 406-416
66. Marson D.C., Annis S.M., McInturf B., Bartolucci A., and Harrell L.E. Error behaviors associated with loss of competency in Alzheimer's disease. Neurology 53 (1999) 1983-1992
67. Marson D.C., Chatterjee A., Ingram K.K., and Harrell L.E. Toward a neurologic model of competency: Cognitive predictors of capacity to consent in Alzheimer's disease using three different legal standards. Neurology 46 (1996) 666-672
68. Marson D.C., Cody H.A., Ingram K.K., and Harrell L.E. Neuropsychological predictors of competency in Alzheimer's disease using a rational reasons legal standard. Archives of Neurology 52 (1995) 955-959
69. Marson D.C., Earnst K., Jamil F., Bartolucci A., and Harell L.E. Consistency of physicians' legal standard and personal judgments of competency in patients with Alzheimer's disease. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 2000 (2000) 911-918
70. Marson D.C., Hawkins L., McInturff B., and Harrell L.E. Cognitive models that predict physician judgments of capacity to consent in mild Alzheimer's disease. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 45 (1997) 458-464
71. Marson D.C., Ingram K.K., Cody H.A., and Harrell L.E. Assessing the competency of patients with Alzheimer's disease under different legal standards. Archives of Neurology 52 (1995) 949-954
72. Marson D.C., McInturff B., Hawkins L., Bartolucci A., and Harrell L.E. Consistency of physician judgments of capacity to consent in mild Alzheimer's disease. The American Geriatrics Society 45 (1997) 453-457
73. Mazur D.J., and Merz J.F. How the manner of presentation of data influences older patients in determining their treatment preferences. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 41 (1993) 223-228
74. McKee, D. R. (2001). The effects of framing on younger and older adults' medical decision making. Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, West Virginia University, Morgantown.
75. McNeil B.J., Pauker S.G., Sox H.C., and Tversky A. On the elicitation of preferences for alternative therapies. The New England Journal of Medicine 305 (1982) 1259-1262
76. Meyer B.J.F., Russo C., and Talbot A. Discourse comprehension and problem solving: Decisions about the treatment of breast cancer by women across the lifespan. Psychology and Aging 10 (1995) 84-103
77. Mezey M., Kluger M., Maislin G., and Mittelman M. Life-sustaining treatment decisions by spouses of patients with Alzheimer's disease. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 44 (1996) 144-150
78. Moye J. Assessment of competency and decision making capacity. In: Lichtenberg P. (Ed). Handbook of assessment in clinical gerontology (1999), Wiley, New York
79. Moye J., and Karel M. Evaluating decisional capacities in older adults: Results of two clinical studies. Advances in Medical Psychology 10 (1999) 71-84
80. Moye J., Karel M.J., Azar A.R., and Gurrera R.J. Capacity to consent to treatment: Empirical comparison of three instruments in older adults with and without dementia. The Gerontologist 44 (2004) 166-175
81. Moye J., Karel M.J., Azar A.R., and Gurrera R.J. Hopes and cautions for instrument-based evaluations of consent capacity: Results of a construct validity study of three instruments. Ethics, Law, and Aging Review 10 (2004) 39-61
82. Nash D.L., and Giles S.L. Assessing competency competently. VA Practitioner (1989, August) 93-100
83. Park D. The basic mechanisms accounting for age-related decline in cognitive functioning. In: Park D. (Ed). Cognitive aging: A primer (2000), Psychology Press, Philadelphia 3-21
84. Pearlman R.A., Cain K.C., Patrick D.L., Appelbaum-Maizel M., Starks H.E., Jecker N.S., et al. Insights pertaining to patient assessments of states worse than death. Journal of Clinical Ethics 4 (1993) 33-41
85. Petrisek A.C., Laliberte L.L., Allen S.M., and Mor V. The treatment decision-making process: Age differences in a sample of women recently diagnosed with nonrecurrent, early-stage breast cancer. The Gerontologist 37 (1997) 598-608
86. Pruchno R.A., Smyer M.A., Rose M.S., Hartman-Stein P.E., and Laribee-Henderson D.L. Competence of long-term care residents to participate in decisions about their medical care: A brief, objective assessment. The Gerontologist 35 (1995) 622-629
87. Puchalski C.M., Zhong Z., Jacobs M.M., Fox E., Lynn J., Harrold J., et al. Patients who want their family and physician to make resuscitation decisions for them: Observations from SUPPORT and HELP. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 48 (2000) S84-S90
88. Rolland J.D. Families, illness, and disability: An integrative treatment model (1994), Basic Books, New York
89. Roth L.H., Meisel C.A., and Lidz C.A. Tests of competency to consent to treatment. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 134 (1997) 279-284
90. Rothchild E. Family dynamics in end-of-life treatment decisions. General Hospital Psychiatry 16 (1994) 251-258
91. Royall D.R., Cordes J., and Polk M. Executive control and the comprehension of medical information by elderly retirees. Experimental Aging Research 23 (1997) 301-313
92. Sabatino C.P., and Basinger S.L. Competency: Reforming our legal fictions. Journal of Mental Health and Aging 6 (2000) 119-143
93. Sachs G.A., Stocking C.B., and Stern R. Ethical aspects of dementia research: Informed consent and proxy consent. Clinical Research 42 (1994) 403-412
94. Salthouse T.A. Why do adult age differences increase with task complexity. Developmental Psychology 28 (1992) 905-918
95. Salthouse T.A. The process-speed theory of adult age differences in cognition. Psychological Review 103 (1996) 403-428
96. Salthouse T.A., and Babcock R.L. Decomposing adult age differences in working memory. Developmental Psychology 27 (1991) 763-776
97. Schmand B., Gouwenberg B., Smit J.H., and Jonker C. Assessment of mental competency in community-swelling elderly. Alzheimer Disease and Associated Disorders 13 (1999) 80-87
98. Shiffrin R.M., and Schneider W. Controlled and automatic human information processing: II. Perceptual, learning, automatic attending, and a general theory. Psychological Review 84 (1977) 127-190
99. Singer P.A., Martin D.K., Lavery J.V., Theil E.C., Kelner M., and Mendelssohn D.C. Reconceptualizing advance care planning from the patient's perspective. Archives of Internal Medicine 158 (1998) 879-884
100. Snyder A.C. Competency to refuse lifesaving treatment: Valuing the nonlogical aspects of a person's decisions. Issues in Law and Medicine 10 (1994) 299-320
101. Staats N., Edelstein B., and Null J. Neuropsychological correlates of thinking rationally about treatment tests. Paper presented at the Gerontological Society of America, Los Angeles (1995)
102. Stanley B., Guido J., Stanley M., and Shortell D.S. The elderly patient and informed consent. Journal of the American Medical Association 252 (1984) 1302-1306
103. Streufert S., Pogash R., Piasecki M., and Post G.M. Age and management team performance. Psychology and Aging 5 (1990) 551-559
104. Taub H.A., Baker M.T., Kline G.E., and Sturr J.F. Comprehension of informed consent by young-old and old-old volunteers. Experimental Aging Research 13 (1987) 173-178
105. Tepper A., and Elwork A. Competency to consent to treatment as a psychol legal construct. Law and Human Behavior 8 (1984) 205-223
106. Titov N., and Knight R.G. Adult age differences in controlled and automatic memory processing. Psychology and Aging 12 (1997) 565-573
107. Tversky A., and Kahneman D. The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science 211 (1981) 453-458
108. Von Neuman J., and Morganstern O. Theory of games and economic behavior. 2nd ed. (1947), Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
109. Walker L., Bradley E., Blechner B., and Gruman C. Assessment of capacity to discuss advance directives in nursing homes: Approaches and implications. Paper presented at the Gerontological Society of America, Washington, DC (1996)
110. Wallston K.A., Wallston B.S., and DeVellis R. Development of the multidimensional health locus of control (MHLC) scale. Health Education Monographs 6 (1978) 160-170
111. Wardle J., and Steptoe A. Socioeconomic differences in attitudes and beliefs about healthy lifestyles. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 57 (2003) 440-443
112. Wong J.G., Clare I.C.H., Holland A.J., Watson P.C., and Gunn M. The capacity of people with a "mental disability" to make a health care decision. Psychological Medicine 30 (2000) 295-306
113. Yates J.F., and Patalano A.L. Decision making and aging. In: Park D.C., Morrell R.W., and Shifren K. (Eds). Processing of medical information in aging patients: Cognition and human factors perspective (1999), Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ 31-54
114. Zwahr M.D., Park D.C., and Shifren K. The role of age, cognitive abilities, and beliefs. Psychology and Aging 14 (1999) 179-191