Process analytical technology beyond real-time analyzers: The role of multivariate analysis

Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry

Volumn 36, Issue 3-4, 2006, Pages 257-278

  Kourti, Theodora ^a  

^a MCMASTER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Latent variables; Multivariate analysis; Multivariate statistical process control; Process analytical technology; Process understanding; Scale up

Indexed keywords

REAL TIME SYSTEMS; STATISTICAL METHODS; STATISTICAL PROCESS CONTROL;

CHEMOMETRICS; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; PROCESS SCALE-UP;

PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY;

PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY; REAL TIME SYSTEMS; STATISTICAL METHODS; STATISTICAL PROCESS CONTROL;

CHEMICAL PROCESS; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; REAL TIME;

EID: 33845391516     PISSN: 10408347     EISSN: 15476510     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/10408340600969957     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Callis, J. and Illman, D. and Kowalski, B. (1987) Process analytical chemistry Analytical Chemistry, 59, pp. 624A-635A.
2. Workman, J., Jr. and Koch, M. and Veltkamp, D. (2005) Process analytical chemistry, Analytical Chemistry, 77, pp. 3789-3806.
3. Guidance for Industry, PAT A Framework for Innovative Pharmaceutical Development, Manufacturing, and Quality Assurance.(2004) Department U.S. of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER), Center for Veterinary, Medicine (CVM), Office of Regulatory Affairs (ORA). Pharmaceutical CGMPs. http://www.fda.gov/cder/guidance/6419fnl.htm
4. Pharmaceutical CGMPs for the 21st Century-A Risk-Based Approach, Final Report, September 29, 2004. http://www.fda.gov/cder
5. Kourti, T. (2004) Process Analytical technology and multivariate statistical process control. Wellness index of process and product - Part 1 The Journal of Process Analytical Technology, 1(1), pp. 13-19.
6. Workman, J., Jr. and Koch, M. and Veltkamp, D. (2003) Process analytical chemistry Analytical Chemistry, 75(12), pp. 2859.
7. Workman, J., Jr. and Creasy, K. and Doherty, S. and Leonard, B. and Koch, M. and Ullman, A. and Veltkamp, D. (2001) Process analytical chemistry, Analytical Chemistry, 73(12), pp. 2705.
8. Workman, J., Jr. and Veltkamp, D. and Dohe, S. and Anderson, B. and Creasy, K. and Koch, M. and Tatera, J. and Robinson, A. and Bond, L. and Burgess, L. and Bokerman, G. and Ullman, A. and Darsey, G. and Mozayeni, F. and Bamberger, J. and Greenwood, M. (1999) Process analytical chemistry, Analytial Chemistry, 71(12), pp. 121R.
9. Blaser, W. and Bedeweg, R. and Harner, R. and LaPack, M. and Leugers, A. and Martin, D. and Pell, R. and Workman, J., Jr. and Wright, L. (1995) Analytical Chemistry, 67, pp. 47R.
10. Beebe, K. and Blaser, W. and Bredeweg, R. and Chauvel, J., Jr. and Harner, R. and LaPack, M. and Leugers, A. and Martin, D. and Wright, L. and Yalvac, E. (1993) Process analytical chemistry, Analytical Chemistry, 65, pp. 199R.
11. Lavine, B. and Workman, J., Jr. (2004) Chemometrics, Analytical Chemistry, 76, pp. 3365-3372.
12. Lavine, B. and Workman, J., Jr. (2002) Chemometrics Analytical Chemistry, 74, pp. 2763-2770.
13. Lavine, B. (2000) Chemometrics, Analytical Chemistry, 72, pp. 91R-97R.
14. Miller, C. (2000) Chemometrics for on-line spectroscopy applications - Theory and practice J. Chemometrics, 14, pp. 513-528.
15. Brereton, R. (2000) Introduction to multivariate calibration in analytical chemistry Analyst, 125, pp. 2125-2154.
16. Bakeev, K.(2005) Process Analytical Technology Spectroscopic Tools and Implementation Strategies for the Chemical and Pharmaceutical Industries. Blackwell Pub Professional.
17. Siesler, H. and Ozaki, Y. and Kawata, S. and Heise, H.(2002) Near Infared Spectroscopy Principles, Instruments, Applications. Wiley VCH Verlag.
18. Feudale, R. and Woody, N. and Tan, H. and Myles, A. and Brown, S. and Ferre, J. (2002) Transfer of multivariate calibration models; A review, Chemometrics and Intelligent Lab Systems, 64, pp. 181-192.
19. Kourti, T. and MacGregor, J. (1995) Process analysis, monitoring and diagnosis using multivariate projection methods - A tutorial. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 28, pp. 3-21.
20. Kourti, T. (1999) Optimization and control. In Design and Analysis in Chemical Research. (pp. 314-364). Boca Raton FL: Sheffield Analytical Chemistry, CRC Press. Ch. 9
21. Muirhead, G.T. Process Analytical Technology at GlaxoSmithKline. Presented at the 19th IFPAC, International Forum Process Analytical Technology ArlingtonVAJan10-132005. In [pp.]. © Gordon T. Muirhead, GlaxoSmithKline, Reproduced with permission)
22. Graffner, C. (2005) PAT - European Regulatory Perspective. The Journal of Process Analytical Technology, 2(6), pp. 8-11.
23. Dushesne, C. and Kourti, T. and MacGregor, F. (2002) Application of multivariate methods to start-Up, re-start and grade transition problems AICHE J. 48, pp. 2890-2901.
24. Kresta, J. and Marlin, T. and MacGregor, J. (1994) Development of inferential process models using PLS. Computers Chem. Engng. 18, pp. 597-611.
25. Burnham, A. and Viveros, R. and MacGregor, J. (1996) Frameworks for latent variable multivariate regression. J. Chemometrics, 10, pp. 31-45.
26. Jolliffe, I. (1982) A Note on the Use of Principal Components in Regression. Applied Statistics, 31(3), pp. 300-303.
27. Sutter, J. and Kalivas, J. and Lang, P. (1992) Which principal components to utilize for principal component regression. Journal of Chemometrics, 6, pp. 217-225.
28. Nelson, P. and Taylor, P. and MacGregor, J. (1996) Missing data methods in PCA and PLS: Score calculations with incomplete observations. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 35, pp. 45-65.
29. Arteaga, F. and Ferrer, A. (2002) Dealing with missing data in MSPC: Several methods, different interpretations, some examples. Journal of Chemometrics, 16, pp. 408-418.
30. Nelson, P. and MacGregor, J. and Taylor, P. (2006) The impact of missing measurements on PCA and PLS prediction and monitoring applications. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 80, pp. 1-12.
31. Kourti, T. (2002) Process analysis and abnormal situation detection: From theory to practice. IEEE control systems, 22(5), pp. 10-25.
32. Kourti, T. (2005) Application of latent variable methods to process control and multivariate statistical process control in industry. International Journal of Adaptive Control and Signal Processing, 19, pp. 213-246.
33. Miletic, I. and Quinn, S. and Dudzic, M. and Vaculik, V. and Champagne, M. (2004) An industrial perspective on implementing on-line applications of multivariate statistics. Journal Process Control, 14, pp. 821-836.
34. KOURTI,T. (2005) Symposium report on abnormal situation detection and projection methods. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 76, pp. 215-220.
35. MacGregor, J. and Kourti, T. and Kresta, J.(1991). Multivariate identification: A study of several methods. International Symposium on Advanced Control of Chemical Processes ADCHEM 1991, (an IFAC Symposium) ToulouseFranceOctober14-16. In [pp. 369-375]. Proceedings
36. Nomikos, P. and MacGregor, J. (1995) Multivariate SPC charts for monitoring batch processes. Technometrics, 37(1), pp. 41-59.
37. Nomikos, P. and MacGregor, J. (1994) Monitoring of batch processes using multi-way principal component analysis. AIChE Journal, 40(8), pp. 1361-1375.
38. Nomikos, P. and MacGregor, J. (1995) Multiway partial least squares in monitoring batch processes. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 30, pp. 97-108.
39. Kourti, T. (2003) Multivariate dynamic data modelling for analysis and statistical process control of batch processes, start-ups and grade transitions. Journal of Chemometrics, 17, pp. 93-109.
40. Kourti, T. (2003) Abnormal situation detection, three way data and projection methods - robust data archiving and modeling for industrial applications. Annual Reviews in Control, 27(2), pp. 131-138.
41. Kourti, T. and Lee, J. and MacGregor, J. (1996) Experiences with industrial applications of projection methods for multivariate statistical process control. Computers and Chemical Engineering, 20(Suppl.), pp. S745-S750.
42. Neogi, D. and Schlags, C. (1998) Multivariate statistical analysis of an emulsion batch process. Industrial Engineering Chemistry Research, 37, pp. 3971-3979.
43. Kassidas, A. and MacGregor, J. and Taylor, P. (1998) Synchronization of batch trajectories using dynamic time warping. AIChE J., 44, pp. 864-875.
44. Taylor, P.(1998) Hamilton, Ontario: Computing and Software Dept., McMaster University. personal communication
45. Westerhuis, J. and Kassidas, A. and Kourti, T. and Taylor, P. and MacGregor, J.F. On-line synchronization of the trajectories of process variables for monitoring batch processes with varying duration. Presented at the 6th Scandinavian Symposium on ChemometricsPorsgrunnNorwayAug.15-191999. In [pp.].
46. García-Mũnoz, S. and Kourti, T. and MacGregor, J. and Mateos, A. and Murphy, G. (2003) Troubleshooting of an Industrial Batch Process Using Multivariate Methods. Industrial Engineering Chemistry Research, 42, pp. 3592-3601.
47. Garća-Mũoz, S.(2004) Batch Process improvement using latent variable methods. Hamilton, Ontario: McMaster university.
48. García-Mũnoz, S. and Kourti, T. and MacGregor, J.F. Ninth Scandinavian Chemometrics Conference, ReykjavicIcelandAugust21-25 2005
49. Garcia-Munoz, Salvador and Neogi, Debashis and Mehta, Sanjay and MacGregor, John and Kourti, Theodora. J. Optimization of Batch Processes using Data Driven Latent Variable Models. Annual Meeting of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers Cincinnati Ohio October 30-November 4 2005.
50. Tomasi, G. and van den Berg, F. and Andersson, C. (2004) Correlation optimized warping and dynamic time warping as preprocessing methods for chromatographic data. Journal of Chemometrics, 18, pp. 231-241.
51. Kourti, T. and Nomikos, P. and MacGregor, J. (1995) Analysis, monitoring and fault diagnosis of batch processes using multiblock and multiway PLS. Journal of Process Control, 5(4), pp. 277-284.
52. Duchesne, C. and MacGregor, J. (2000) Multivariate analysis and optimization of process variable trajectories for batch processes. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 51, pp. 125-137.
53. MacGregor, J. and Kourti, T. and Nomikos, P. (1996). Analysis, Monitoring and Fault Diagnosis of Industrial Processes using Multivariate Statistical Projection Methods. Preprints, 13 World Congress of International Federation of Automatic Control San Fransisco-USAJune30 - July 5. In [pp. 145-150].
54. Nomikos, P. (1996) Detection and diagnosis of abnormal batch operations based on multiway principal component analysis. ISA Transactions, 35, pp. 259-267.
55. Lennox, B. and Montague, G. and Hiden, H. and Kornfeld, G. and Goulding, P. (2001) Process Monitoring of an Industrial Fed-Batch Fermentation. Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 74(2), pp. 125-135.
56. Albert, S. and Kinley, R. (2001) Multivariate statistical monitoring of batch processes: An industrial case study of fermentation supervision. Trends in Biotechnology, 19, pp. 53-62.
57. Zhang, Y. and Dudzic, M. and Vaculik, V. (2003) Integrated monitoring solution to start-up and run-time operations for continuous casting. Annual Reviews in Control, 27, pp. 141-149.
58. Westerhuis, J. and Kourti, T. and MacGregor, J. (1998) Analysis of multiblock and hierarchical PCA and PLS models. Journal of Chemometrics, 12, pp. 301-321.
59. Taube, D.J. Process analytical technology in API: Issues, opportunities and challenges, IFPAC Conference Scottsdale Arizona January, 2003. In [pp.].
60. Westerhuis, J. and Coenegracht, P. (1997) Multivariate modelling of the pharmaceutical two-step process of wet granulation and tableting with multiblock partial least squares. Journal of Chemometrics, 11, pp. 379-392.
61. Frank, I. and Feikema, J. and Constantine, N. and Kowalski, B. (1984) Prediction of product quality from spectral data using the partial least-squares method. Journal of Chemical Information and Computing Science, 24, pp. 20-24.
62. Flores-Cerrillo, J. and MacGregor, J. (2004) Multivariate monitoring of batch processes using batch-to-batch information. AIChE Journal, 50(6), pp. 1219-1228.
63. Dushesne, C. and MacGregor, J. (2004) Establishing multivariate specification regions for incoming materials. Journal of Quality Technology, 36, pp. 78-94.
64. Ohmori, S. and Ohno, Y. and Makino, T. and Kashihara, T. (2005) Application of an electronic nose system for evaluation of unpleasant odor in coated tablets. European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, 59(2), pp. 289-297.
65. Esbensen, K. and Halstensen, M. and Tonnesen, L. and Saudland, A. and Svalestuen, J. and de Silva, S. and Hope, B. (1998) Acoustic chemometrics - From noise to information. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 44(1), pp. 61-76.
66. Tan, C. and Thornhill, N. and Belchamber, R. (2002) Principal component analysis of spectra with application to acoustic emissions from mechanical equipment. Transaction of Institute Measurement and Control, 24(4), pp. 333-353.
67. Halstensen, M. and Esbensen, K. (2000) New developments in acoustic chemometric prediction of particle size distribution - The problem is the solution. Journal of Chemometrics, 14, pp. 463-481.
68. Bruwer, M.-J. and MacGregor, J. and Bourg, W. and Malvaiz, C.S). Multivariate Acoustic Imaging for Product Property Prediction. Presented at AIChE Annual Meeting AustinTexas November 7-122004. In [pp.].
69. BHARATI, M. and MacGregor, J. (2003) Softwood lumber grading through on line multivariate image analysis. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 42, pp. 5345-5353.
70. Liu, J. and Bharati, M. and Dunn, K. and MacGregor, J. (2005) Automatic masking in multivariate image analysis using support vector machines. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 79(1-2), pp. 42-54.
71. Liu, J. and MacGregor, J. (2006) Estimation and monitoring of product aesthetics: Application to manufacturing of "engineered stone" countertops. Machine Vision and Applications, 16(6), pp. 374-383.
72. Vlasov, Y. and Legin, A. and Rudnitskaya, A. (2002) Electronic tongues and their analytical application. Analytical Bioanalytical Chemistry, 373(3), pp. 136-46.
73. Esbensen, K. and Kirsanov, D. and Legin, A. and Rudnitskaya, A. and Mortensen, J. and Pedersen, J. and Vognsen, L. and Makarychev-Mikhailov, S. and Vlasov, Y. (2004) Fermentation monitoring using multisensor systems: Feasibility study of the electronic tongue. Analytical Bioanalytical Chemistry, 378, pp. 391-395.
74. Yu, H. and MacGregor, J. and Haarsma, G. and Bourg, W. (2003) Digital Imaging for On-line Monitoring and Control of Industrial Snack Food Processes. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 42, pp. 3036-3044.
75. Yu, H. and MacGregor, J. (2003) Multivariate image analysis and regression for prediction of coating content and distribution in the production of snack foods. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 67, pp. 125-144.
76. Westerhuis, J. and Coenegracht, P. and Coenraad, F. (1997) Multivariate modelling of the tablet manufacturing process with wet granulation for tablet optimization and in-process control. International Journal of Pharmaceutical, 156, pp. 109-117.
77. Osborne, B. (2000) Near-infrared spectroscopy in food analysis. In Encyclopedia of Analytical Chemistry. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
78. Findlay, P. and Morris, K. and Kildsig, D. (2003). PAT in fluid bed granulation. Presented at AICHE, San FranciscoCA. In [pp.].
79. Shi, D. and Mhaskar, P. and El-Farra, N. and Christofides, P. (2005) Predictive control of crystal size distribution in protein crystallization. Nanotechnology, 16, pp. S562-S574.
80. Marjanovic, O. and Lennox, B. and Sandoz, D. and Smith, K. and Crofts, M. Real-time monitoring of an industrial batch process. Presented at CPC7: Chemical Process Control Lake Louise Alberta, Canada Jan8-132006. In [pp.].
81. Zhang, H. and Lennox, B. (2004) Integrated condition monitoring and control of fed-batch fermentation processes. Journal of Process Control, 14, pp. 41-50.
82. Flores-Cerrillo, J. and MacGregor, J. (2004) Control of batch product quality by trajectory manipulation using latent variable models. Journal of Process Control, 14, pp. 539-553.
83. Moteki, Y. and Arai, Y.(1986) Operation planning and quality design of a polymer process. Bournemouth UK: Pergamon Press. ZFAC DYCORD
84. Jaeckle, C. and MacGregor, J. (1998) Product design through multivariate statistical analysis of process data. AICHE Journal, 44(5), pp. 1105-1118.
85. Lakshminarayanan, S. and Fujii, H. and Grosman, B. and Dassau, E. and Lewin, D. (2000) New product design via analysis of historical databases. Computers and Chemical Engineering, 24, pp. 671-676.
86. García-Mũnoz, S. and Kourti, T. and MacGregor, J. and Apruzzece, F. and Champagne, M.(2006) Optimization of batch operating policies, Part I - handling multiple solutions. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research. ASAP Web Release Date: 10-Oct-2006; (Article) DOI: 10.1021/ie060314g
87. Muteki, K. and MacGregor, J. and Ueda, T. (2006) The rapid development of new polymer blends: The optimal selection of materials and blend ratios. Industrial Engineering Chemical Research. in press
88. Muteki, K. and MacGregor, J. and Ueda, T. (2006) Mixture designs and models for the simultaneous selection of ingredients and their ratios. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems. submitted
89. García-Muñoz, S. and MacGregor, J. and Kourti, T. (2005) Product Transfer between Sites using Joint Y_PLS. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems, 79, pp. 101-114.
90. Lange, A. (2005) Guarding against PAT hype. The Journal of Process Analytical Technology, 2(3), pp. 18-20.
91. Kourti, T. (2005) Process analytical technology and multivariate statistical process control. Index of wellness of product and process - Part 2 The Journal of Process Analytical Technology, 2(1), pp. 24-28.
92. Park, S. and Han, C. (2000) A nonlinear soft sensor based on multivariate smoothing procedure for quality estimation in distillation columns. Computers and Chemical Engineering, 24(2), pp. 871-877.
93. García-Muñoz, S. and MacGregor, J. and Kourti, T. (2004) Model predictive monitoring for batch processes with multivariate methods. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research, 43, pp. 5929-5941.