Consumer-directed health care: Early evidence about effects on cost and quality

Health Affairs

Volumn 25, Issue 6, 2006, Pages

  Buntin, Melinda Beeuwkes ^a   Damberg, Cheryl ^a   Haviland, Amelia ^a   Kapur, Kanika ^b,c   Lurie, Nicole ^a   McDevitt, Roland ^d   Marquis, M Susan ^a  

^a RAND CORPORATION   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN   (Ireland)

^c RAND   (United States)

^d Watson Wyatt Worldwide   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; CONSUMER; COST; ECONOMICS; HEALTH CARE COST; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HEALTH CARE QUALITY; HEALTH INSURANCE; HUMAN; INFORMATION SERVICE; INSURANCE; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; STANDARD; UNITED STATES; UTILIZATION REVIEW;

CONSUMER SATISFACTION; DEDUCTIBLES AND COINSURANCE; HEALTH BENEFIT PLANS, EMPLOYEE; HEALTH CARE REFORM; HEALTH EXPENDITURES; HUMANS; INFORMATION SERVICES; INSURANCE SELECTION BIAS; MEDICAL SAVINGS ACCOUNTS; PATIENT PARTICIPATION; QUALITY OF HEALTH CARE; UNITED STATES;

EID: 33845289408     PISSN: 02782715     EISSN: 02782715     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1377/hlthaff.25.w516     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. HSAs were established as part of the Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act (MMA) of 2003.
2. J. Cogan, G. Hubbard, and D. Kessler, "Keep Government Out," Wall Street Journal, 13 January 2006;
3. and J.F. Cogan, R.G. Hubbard, and D.P. Kessler, "Making Markets Work: Five Steps to a Better Health Care System," Health Affairs 24, no. 6 (2005): 1447-1457.
4. J. Frogue, "The Future of Medicaid: Consumer-directed Care," Backgrounder no. 1618 (Washington: Heritage Foundation, 2003).
5. M.B. Buntin et al., "Consumer-directed" Health Plans: Implications for Health Care Quality and Cost, June 2005, http://www.chcf.org/ documents/insurance/ConsumerDirHealthPlansQualityCost.pdf (accessed 28 March 2006).
6. G. Claxton et al., "What High-Deductible Plans Look Like: Findings froma National Survey of Employers, 2005," Health Affairs 24 (2005): w434-w441 (published online 14 September 2005; 10.1377/hlthaff.w5.434).
7. J. Gabel et al., "Health Benefits in 2004: Four Years of Double-Digit Premium Increases Take Their Toll on Coverage," Health Affairs 23, no. 5 (2004): 200-209;
8. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Educational Trust, Employer Health Benefits: 2002 Annual Survey, September 2002, http://www.kff.org/insurance/3251.pdf (accessed 5 January 2005);
9. and P. Fronstin and S.R. Collins, "Early Experience with High-Deductible and Consumer-driven Health Plans: Findings from the EBRI/Commonwealth Fund Consumerism in Health Care Survey," Issue Brief no. 288 (Washington: Employee Benefit Research Institute, 2005).
10. S. Trude, "Patient Cost Sharing: How Much Is Too Much?" Issue Brief no. 72 (Washington: Center for Studying Health System Change, 2003).
11. U.S. Department of the Treasury, "Indexed Amounts for Health Savings Accounts," Press Brief no. js-2996, 28 October 2005, http://www.ustreas. gov/press/releases/js2996.htm (accessed 3 April 2006);
12. America's Health Insurance Plans, "January 2006 Census Shows 3.2 Million People Covered by HSA Plans," January 2006, http://www. ahipresearch.org/pdfs/HSAHDHPReportJanuary2006.pdf (20 March 2006);
13. and S. Davis and J. Gutman, "CDH Enrollment Increases to 4.9 Million; HSA-qualified HDHPs Gain on HRA Plans," Inside Consumer-directed Care, 27 January 2006.
14. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, CMS Legislative Summary, April 2004, Summary of H.R. 1 Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act of 2003, Public Law 108-173, April 2004, http://cms.hhs.gov/ MMAUpdate/downloads/PL108-173summary.pdf (accessed 30 March 2006).
15. This has since been increased to $1,050 and $2,100, respectively, although many plans on the market have higher deductibles. J.C. Robinson, "Health Savings Accounts - The Ownership Society in Health Care," New England Journal of Medicine 353, no. 12 (2005): 1199-1202.
16. Flexible spending accounts (FSAs), enacted in 1978, are even more restricted in that they do not roll over fromyear to year. Medical savings accounts (MSAs)were the precursors to HRAs and HSAs, but the legislation that authorized them has now expired.
17. Fronstin and Collins, "Early Experience."
18. Claxton et al., "What High-Deductible Plans Look Like."
19. AHIP, "January 2006 Census."
20. S. Duxbury, "Consumers Not Driving New Health Vehicles," San Francisco Business Times, 1 October 2004;
21. and Celent Communications LLC, "Health Savings Accounts: How Will the Stars Align?" Press Release, 22 September 2005, http://celent.com/ PressReleases/20050922/HealthSavingsAccounts.htm (accessed 30 March 2006).
22. Claxton et al., "What High-Deductible Plans Look Like."
23. Authors' calculations based on AHIP and census data.
24. Some believe that CDHC will also lead to an increase in the number of insured people. Our review does not include estimates of this benefit.
25. E.B. Keeler et al., "Can Medical Savings Accounts for the Nonelderly Reduce Health Care Costs?" Journal of the American Medical Association 275, no. 21 (1996): 1666-1671.
26. S.T. Parente, R. Feldman, and J.B. Christianson, "Evaluation of the Effect of a Consumer-driven Health Plan on Medical Care Expenditures and Utilization," Health Services Research 39, no. 4, Part 2 (2004): 1189-1210;
27. U.S. Government Accountability Office, Federal Employees Health Benefits Program: First Year Experience with High-Deductible Health Plans and Health Savings Accounts, Pub. no. GAO-06-271 (Washington: GAO, 2006);
28. L.A. Tollen, M.N. Ross, and S. Poor, "Risk Segmentation Related to the Offering of a Consumer-directed Health Plan: A Case Study of Humana Inc.," Health Services Research 39, no. 4, Part 2 (2004): 1167-1188;
29. eHealthInsurance, "Health Savings Accounts: The First Year in Review," 2005, http://www.flinthills.org/component/option,com_docman/task, doc_view/gid,112/Itemid,52 (accessed 14 September 2006);
30. Fronstin and Collins, "Early Experience";
31. A.T. Lo Sasso et al., "Tales from the New Frontier: Pioneers' Experiences with Consumer-driven Health Care," Health Services Research 39, no. 4, Part 2 (2004): 1071-1090;
32. and J.B. Fowles et al., "Early Experience with Employee Choice of Consumer-directed Health Plans and Satisfaction with Enrollment," Health Services Research 39, no. 4, Part 2 (2004): 1141-1158.
33. Tollen et al., "Risk Segmentation."
34. J.P. Newhouse and the Insurance Experiment Group, Free for All? Lessons from the RAND Health Insurance Experiment (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1993).
35. The average deductible for enrollees in group plans in 2004 was $221 (based on Gabel et al., "Health Benefits in 2004"),
36. and the average deductible in preferred provider organization (PPO) plans was about $1900 (based on KFF/HRET, Employer Health Benefits: 2002 Annual Survey, inflated to 2004 dollars).
37. Keeler et al., "Can Medical Savings Accounts?";
38. and E.B. Keeler and J.E. Rolph, "The Demand for Episodes of Treatment in the Health Insurance Experiment," Journal of Health Economics 7, no. 4 (1988): 337-367.
39. L. Ozanne, "How Will Medical Savings Accounts Affect Medical Spending?" Inquiry 33, no. 3 (1996): 225-236.
40. J.S. Lee and L. Tollen, "How Low Can You Go? The Impact of Reduced Benefits and Increased Cost Sharing," Health Affairs 21 (2002):w229-w241 (published online 19 June 2002; 10.1377/hlthaff.w2.229);
41. and L.M. Nichols, M. Moon, and S. Wall, Tax-preferred Medical Savings Accounts and Catastrophic Health Insurance Plans: A Numerical Analysis of Winners and Losers, April 1996, http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/winlose.pdf (accessed 14 September 2006).
42. S. Glied, "Is Something Better than Nothing? Health Insurance Expansions and the Content of Coverage," in Frontiers in Health Policy Research, vol. 6, ed. D. Cutler and A. Garber (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 2003), 55-86.
43. Keeler et al., "Can Medical Savings Accounts?";
44. Ozanne, "How Will Medical Savings Accounts?"
45. Ozanne, "How Will Medical Savings Accounts?"
46. Parente et al., "Evaluation";
47. Lo Sasso et al., "Tales from the New Frontier";
48. PricewaterhouseCoopers, "Employers Embrace Consumerism to Control Healthcare Costs: New PwC White Paper," September 2005, http://pwc.com/us/eng/about/ind/healthcare/pubconsumerism.html (accessed 14 September 2006);
49. T.E. Ehrbeck and K. Packard, Will Consumer-driven Health Care Take Off? Expert Voices (Washington: National Institute for Health Care Management Foundation, May 2005);
50. Deloitte, "2005 Consumer-driven Health Care Survey," Press Release, 15 November 2005, http://deloitte.com/dtt/press_release/0,1014, sid%253D2283%2526cid%253D100463,00.html (accessed 14 September 2006);
51. Humana, Health Care Consumers: Passive or Active?, June 2005, http://apps.humana.com/marketing/documents.asp?file=519272 (accessed 23March 2006);
52. H. Leach, head of Human Resources, Logan Aluminum Inc., "Consumer-directed Health Plans," Testimony before the Joint Economic Committee, U.S. Congress, 25 February 2004;
53. and R. Downey, "The Changing Model of Consumer-directed Health Care: HRAs and HSAs," Aetna presentation, Washington, D.C., 30 November 2004.
54. In a few reports it was not possible to determine whether the outcome measure included total utilization or just the employer cost.
55. D.K. Remler and S.A. Glied, "How Much More Cost Sharing Will Health Savings Accounts Bring?" Health Affairs 25, no. 4 (2006): 1070-1078.
56. G.M. Turner, "New Studies Show Consumer-directed Care Reduces Costs and Improves Access," 21 July 2004, http://www.galen.org/ccbdocs.asp?docID= 679 (accessed 10 December 2004);
57. G. Gonzalez, "Consumerism Brings Savings, Member Satisfaction," Business Insurance 38, no. 26 (2004): T12-T13;
58. and M. Prince, "Consumer-driven Health Plans Seeing Some Initial Successes; Employers Expanding Programs Following Trial Periods," Business Insurance 7, no. 13 (2003): 3-4.
59. Newhouse et al., Free for All?
60. Claxton et al., "What High-Deductible Plans Look Like."
61. Downey, "The Changing Model";
62. Humana, Health Care Consumers;
63. V. Agrawal et al., "Consumer-directed Health Plan Report - Early Evidence Is Promising," June 2005, http://www.mckinsey.com/clientservice/ payorprovider/Health_Plan_Report.pdf (accessed 2 October 2006);
64. J. Greene, J. Hibbard, and M. Tusler, "Consumers' Use of Health Care Decision Making Tools and Cost Conscious Decision Making" (Paper presented at the National Academy for State Health Policy's Eighteenth Annual State Health Policy Conference, Consumer Directed Health Care: Research Findings and State Policy Implications, Nashville, Tennessee, 7 August 2005);
65. K. Davis, M.M. Doty, and A. Ho, "How High Is Too High? Implications of High-Deductible Health Plans," Pub. no. 816 (New York: Commonwealth Fund, April 2005);
66. and Fronstin and Collins, "Early Experience."
67. M. Rosenthal, C. Hsuan, and A. Milstein, "A Report Card on the Freshman Class of Consumer-directed Health Plans," Health Affairs 24, no. 6 (2005): 1592-1600;
68. and M. Rosenthal and A. Milstein, "Awakening Consumer Stewardship of Health Benefits: Prevalence and Differentiation of New Health Plan Models," Health Services Research 39, no. 4, Part 2 (2004): 1055-1070.
69. V. Fuhrmans, "Insurer Reveals What Doctors Really Charge,"Wall Street Journal, 18 August 2005.
70. iHealthBeat, "Insurance Companies Post Health Care Cost Info Online," 25 August 2005, http://www.ihealthbeat.org/index.cfm?Action= dspItem&itemID=113563 (accessed 14 September 2006).
71. K. Henrickson, "CDHP Top Employer To-Do Lists, EBN-Forrester Research Reveals," Employee Benefit News, 15 September 2005, http://www.benefitnews.com/detail.cfm?id=8045 (accessed 14 September 2006).
72. Agrawal et al., "Consumer-directed Health Plan Report."
73. Fronstin and Collins, "Early Experience."
74. Aetna, "Aetna Research Shows Positive Impact of Consumerism on Health Care Decisions," Press Release, 16 February 2004, http://www.aetna.com/news/2004/pr_20040216a.htm (accessed 14 September 2006).
75. J.H. Hibbard, J. Dubow, and E. Peters, Decision Making in Consumer-directed Health Plans, Pub. no. 2003-05 (Washington: AARP Public Policy Institute, May 2003);
76. and Agrawal et al., "Consumer-directed Health Plan Report."
77. Agrawal et al., "Consumer-directed Health Plan Report."Ibid.
78. Fronstin and Collins, "Early Experience."
79. C. Schoen et al., "Primary Care and Health System Performance: Adults' Experiences in Five Countries," Health Affairs 23 (2004): w487-w503 (published online 28 October 2004; 10.1377/hlthaff.w4.487).
80. W.R. Boyles, "HSAs May Get New Tiered Contributions, Moving Them Closer to HRA Incentives," Consumer Driven Market Report, 16 September 2005.
81. Institute of Medicine, "Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion," Report Brief, April 2004, http://fermat.nap.edu/html/ health_literacy/reportbrief.pdf (accessed 19 September 2005).