An examination of the ethical commitment of professional accountants to auditor independence

Journal of Business Ethics

Volumn 64, Issue 2, 2006, Pages 169-193

  Gendron, Yves ^a,b   Suddaby, Roy ^b,c   Lam, Helen ^d,e  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

^c Depts of Accounting and Management Information Systems and Strategic Management and Organization   (Canada)

^d ATHABASCA UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^e Centre for Innovative Management   (Canada)

Author keywords

Auditor independence; Client commitment; Commercialism; Ethical commitment; Organizational change; Regulation; Work

Indexed keywords

EID: 32944481171     PISSN: 01674544     EISSN: 15730697     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s10551-005-3095-7     Document Type: Article

References (93)

1. Abbott, A. D.: 1988, The System of Professions (The University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
2. Aiken, L. S. and S. G. West: 1991, Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions (Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA).
3. Aranya, N., J. Pollock and J. Amernic: 1981, 'An Examination of Professional Commitment in Public Accounting', Accounting, Organizations and Society 6(4), 271-281.
4. Arens, A. A., J. K. Loebbecke, W. M. Lemon and I. B. Splettstoesser: 2002, Auditing and Other Assurance Services (Prentice Hall, Toronto) Canadian Ninth Edition.
5. Ashton, R. H. and A. H. Ashton: 1995, 'Perspectives on Judgment and Decision-Making Research in Accounting and Auditing', in R. H. Ashton and A. H. Ashton (eds.), Judgment and Decision-Making Research in Accounting and Auditing (Cambridge University Press, New York), pp. 3-25.
6. Babor, T. F., K. Steinberg, R. Anton and F. Del Boca: 2000, 'Talk is Cheap: Measuring Drinking Outcomes in Clinical Trials', Journal of Studies on Alcohol 61(1), 55-63.
7. Bailey, A. D., Jr.: 1995, 'The Practicing Professional's Mental Model: Are We Creating the Right Mental Models for New Professionals?', Issues in Accounting Education 10(1), 191-195.
8. Bamber, E. M. and V. M. Iyer: 2002, 'Big 5 Auditors' Professional and Organizational Identification: Consistency or Conflict?', Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory 21(2), 21-38.
9. Barley, S. R. and G. Kunda: 2001, 'Bringing Work Back In', Organization Science 12(1), 76-95.
10. Baum, G.: 1982, The Priority of Labor (Paulist Press, New York).
11. Bay, D.: 2002, 'A Critical Evaluation of the Use of the DIT in Accounting Ethics Research', Critical Perspectives on Accounting 13(2), 159-177.
12. Becker, H. S., B. Greer, E. C. Hughes and A. L. Strauss: 1961, Boys in White: Student Culture in Medical School. (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
13. Bédard, J.: 2001, 'The Disciplinary Process of the Accounting Profession: Protecting the Public or the Profession? The Québec Experience', Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 20(4/5), 399-437.
14. Bédard, J.: 2003, "On the Effectiveness of the Accounting Profession's Disciplinary System: An Empirical Study of Two Self-Regulatory Systems", Working paper, Université Laval.
15. Berger, P. L. and T. Luckmann: 1966, The Social Construction of Reality (Penguin Books, New York).
16. Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants (CICA): 1996, The Inter-Institute Vision Task Force (Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants, Toronto).
17. Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants (CICA): 2001, Focalisation sur l'avenir: Un siècle nouveau pour les CA (Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants, Toronto).
18. Charkham, J. P.: 1995, Keeping Good Company: A Study of Corporate Governance in Five Countries (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK).
19. Collins, D.: 2000, 'The Quest to Improve the Human Condition: The First 1,500 Articles Published in Journal of Business Ethics', Journal of Business Ethics 26(1), 1-73.
20. Cooper, A. M., M. B. Sobell, L. C. Sobell and S. A. Maisto: 1981, 'Validity of Alcoholics Self-Reports: Duration Data', International Journal of Addiction 16, 401-406.
21. Covaleski, M. A., M. W. Dirsmith, J. B. Heian and S. Samuel: 1998, 'The Calculated and the Avowed: Techniques of Discipline and Struggles over Identity in Big Six Public Accounting Firms', Administrative Science Quarterly 43(2), 293-327.
22. Crozier, M. and E. Friedberg: 1980, Actors and Systems (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
23. Dirsmith, M. W. and M. A. Covaleski: 1985, 'Informal Communications, Nonformal Communications and Mentoring in Public Accounting Firms', Accounting, Organizations and Society 10(2), 149-169.
24. Dirsmith, M. W.J. B. Heian and M. A. Covaleski: 1997, 'Structure and Agency in an Institutionalized Setting: The Application and Social Transformation of Control in the Big Six', Accounting, Organizations and Society 22(1), 1-27.
25. Dwyer, P. D., R. B. Welker and A. H. Friedberg: 2000, 'A Research Note Concerning the Dimensionality of the Professional Commitment Scale', Behavioral Research in Accounting 12, 279-296.
26. Elias, R. Z.: 2002, 'Determinants of Earnings Management Ethics Among Accountants', Journal of Business Ethics 40(1), 33-45.
27. Elliott, R. K. and P. D. Jacobson: 1997, 'Adding Value to Audits', CA Magazine 130(9), 35-37.
28. Everett, J., D. Green and D. Neu: 2005, 'Independence, Objectivity and the Canadian CA Profession1, Critical Perspectives on Accounting 16(4), 415-440.
29. Fogarty, T. J.: 1992, 'Organizational Socialization in Accounting Firms: A Theoretical Framework and Agenda for Future Research', Accounting, Organizations and Society 17(2), 129-149.
30. Fogarty, T. J., V. S. Radcliffe and D. R. Campbell: 2005 (Forthcoming), "Accountancy Before the Fall: The AICPA Vision Project and Related Professional Enterprises", Accounting, Organizations and Society.
31. Foucault, M.: 1975, Surveiller et punir (Éditions Gallimard, Paris).
32. Freidson, E.: 2001, Professionalism, The Third Logic: On the Practice of Knowledge (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
33. Freier, M. C., R. M. Bell and P. Ellickson: 1991, Do Teens Tell the Truth? The Validity of Self-Reported Tobacco Use by Adolescents (The RAND Publication Series, Santa Monica, CA).
34. Geertz, C.: 1973, The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays (Basic Books, New York).
35. Gendron, Y.: 2001, 'The Difficult Client-Acceptance Decision in Canadian Audit Firms: A Field Investigation', Contemporary Accounting Research 18(2), 283-310.
36. Gendron, Y.: 2002, 'On the Role of the Organization in Auditors' Client-Acceptance Decisions', Accounting, Organizations and Society 27(7), 659-684.
37. Gendron, Y., D.J. Cooper and B. Townley: 2001, In the Name of Accountability: State Auditing, Independence and New Public Management', Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 14(3), 278-310.
38. Gibbins, M. and R. J. Swieringa: 1995, 'Twenty Years of Judgment Research in Accounting and Auditing', in R. H. Ashton and A. H. Ashton (eds.), Judgment and Decision-Making Research in Accounting and Auditing (Cambridge University Press, New York), pp. 231-249.
39. Giddens, A.: 1990, The Consequences of Modernity (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA).
40. Gini, A.: 2000, My Job, My Self: Work and the Creation of the Modern Individual (Routledge, New York).
41. Goodridge, M.: 1991, 'Do Accountants Need A Cultural Revolution?', Accountancy 107(1173), 75-76.
42. Hall, M., D. Smith and K. Langfield-Smith: 2005, 'Accountants' Commitment to Their Profession: Multiple Dimensions of Professional Commitment and Opportunities for Future Research', Behavioral Research in Accounting 17, 89-109.
43. Hanlon, G.: 1994, The Commercialization of Accountancy: Flexible Accumulation and the Transformation of the Service Class (Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK).
44. Hopwood, A. G.: 1996, 'Introduction', Accounting, Organizations and Society 21(2/3), 217-218.
45. Hugues, E. C.: 1951, 'Work and the Self, in J. H. Rohrer and M. Sherif (eds.), Social Psychology at the Crossroads (Harper, New York), pp. 313-323.
46. Humphrey, C. and P. Moizer: 1990, 'From Techniques to Ideologies: An Alternative Perspective on the Audit Function', Critical Perspectives on Accounting 1(3), 217-238.
47. Institute of Chartered Accountants of Alberta (ICAA): 2005, "Alberta CAs", http://www.icaa.ab.ca/about/albertacas.shtml (retrieved on August 10, 2005).
48. Jones, J., D. W. Massey and L. Thorne: 2003, 'Auditors' Ethical Reasoning: Insights from Past Research and Implications for the Future', Journal of Accounting Literature 22, 45-103.
49. Kaplan, R. L.: 1987, 'Accountants' Liability and Audit Failures: When the Umpire Strikes Out', Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 6(1), 1-8.
50. Karcher, J.: 1996, 'Accountants' Ability to Discern the Presence of Ethical Problems', Journal of Business Ethics 15(10), 1033-1050.
51. La Bier, D.: 1986, Modern Madness: The Emotional Fallout of Success (Addison Publications, Reading, Mass).
52. Leicht, K. T. and M. L. Fenneil: 2001, Professional Work: A Sociological Approach (Blackwell Publishers, Maiden, Mass).
53. Levitt, A.: 2000 (May 10), "Renewing the Covenant with Investors", speech by the Chair of the SEC at the New York University Center for Law and Business.
54. Macdonald, K. M.: 1995, The Sociology of the Professions (Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA).
55. Macey, J. and H. A. Sale: 2003, 'Observations on the Role of Commodification, Independence and Governance in the Accounting Industry', Villanova Law Review 48, 1167-1188.
56. Marx, K.: 1967, 'The German Ideology', in L. Eastern and K. Guddat (eds. and trans.), Writings of the Younger Marx on Philosophy and Society (Doubleday, New York).
57. McNair, C. J.: 1991, 'Proper Compromises: The Management Control Dilemma in Public Accounting and its Impact on Auditor Behavior', Accounting, Organizations and Society 16(7), 635-653.
58. Meyer, M. and J. T. Rigsby: 2001, 'A Descriptive Analysis of the Content and Contributors of Behavioral Research in Accounting 1989-1998', Behavioral Research in Accounting 13, 253-278.
59. Miles, M. B. and A. M. Huberman: 1984, Qualitative Data Analysis: A Sourcebook of New Methods (Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, CA).
60. Pasquero, J.: 1997, 'Business Ethics and National Identity in Quebec: Distinctiveness and Directions', Journal of Business Ethics 16(6), 621-633.
61. Patrick, D. L., A. Cheadle, D. C. Thompson, P. Diehr, T. Koepsell and S. Kinne: 1994, 'The Validity of Self-Reported Smoking: A Review and Meta-Analysis', American Journal of Public Health 84(7), 1086-1093.
62. Piaget, M. and C. Baumann: 2003, La chute de l'empire Andersen (Dunod, Paris).
63. Porter, L. W., R. M. Steers, R. T. Mowday and P. V. Boulian: 1974, 'Organizational Commitment, Job Satisfaction, and Turnover Among Psychiatric Technicians', Journal of Applied Psychology 59, 603-609.
64. Preston, A. M., D. J. Cooper, D. P. Scarbrough and R. C. Chilton: 1995, 'Changes in the Code of Ethics of the U.S. Accounting Profession, 1917 and 1988: The Continual Quest for Legitimation', Accounting, Organizations and Society 20(6), 507-546.
65. Randall, D. M. and M. F. Fernandes: 1991, 'The Social Desirability Response Bias in Ethics Research', Journal of Business Ethics 10(11), 805-817.
66. Reiter, S. A. and P. F. Williams: 2004, 'The Philosophy and Rhetoric of Auditor Independence Concepts', Business Ethics Quarterly 14(3), 355-376.
67. Roberts, E. S.: 1999, 'In Defense of the Survey Method: An Illustration From a Study of User Information Satisfaction', Accounting and Finance 39(1), 53-77.
68. Roberts, R. W.: 2001, 'Commercialism and its Impact on the Integrity of Professional Tax Services in the US', Critical Perspectives on Accounting 12(5), 589-605.
69. Roxas, M. L. and J. Y. Stoneback: 2004, 'The Importance of Gender Across Cultures in Ethical Decisionmaking', Journal of Business Ethics 50(2), 149-165.
70. Scofield, S. B, T. J. Phillips, Jr. and C. D. Bailey: 2004, 'An Empirical Reanalysis of the Selection-socialization Hypothesis: A Research Note', Accounting, Organizations and Society 29(5/6), 543-563.
71. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): 2000a (June 27), Fact Sheet: The Commission's Proposal to Modernize the Rules Governing the Independence of the Accounting Profession, http://www.sec.gov/news/extra/audfact.htm (retrieved on August 27, 2002).
72. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): 2000b (September 20), Hearing on Auditor Independence, http://www.sec.gov/rules/extra/audmin3.htm (retrieved on August 26, 2002).
73. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): 2000c (November 15), Fact Sheet: The Modernization of the Rules Governing the Independence of the Accounting Profession, http://www.sec.gov/news/extra/faqaud.htm (retrieved on August 27, 2002).
74. Shafer, W. E. and Y. Gendron: 2005, 'Analysis of a Failed Jurisdictional Claim: The Rhetoric and Politics Surrounding the AICPA Global Credential Project', Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 18(4), 453-491.
75. Shafer, W. E., D. J. Lowe and T. J. Fogarty: 2002, 'The Effects of Corporate Ownership on Public Accountants' Professionalism and Ethics', Accounting Horizons 16(2), 109-124.
76. Sikka, P. and H. Willmott: 1995, 'The Power of 'Independence': Defending and Extending the Jurisdiction of Accounting in the United Kingdom', Accounting, Organizations and Society 20(6), 547-581.
77. Simunic, D. A. and M. T. Stein: 1995, 'The Auditing Marketplace', CA Magazine 128(1), 53-58.
78. Skinner, B. F.: 1971, Beyond Freedom and Dignity (Knopf, New York).
79. Squires, S. E., C.J. Smith, L. McDougall and W. R. Yeack: 2003, Inside Arthur Andersen: Shifting Values, Unexpected Consequences (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ).
80. Strauss, A. and J. Corbin: 1990, Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques (Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA).
81. Suddaby, R. and R. Greenwood: 2005, 'Rhetorical Strategies of Legitimacy', Administrative Science Quarterly 50(1), 35-67.
82. Suddaby, R., D. Cooper and R. Greenwood: 2005, "Trans-national Regulation of Professional Services: Governance Dynamics of Field Level Organizational Change', Working paper, University of Alberta.
83. The Bottom Line: 2002 (April), "Accounting's Top 30 Results Are In".
84. Tinker, T.: 2002, 'Beyond the Brilovian Critique: Traditional vs. Organic Intellectuals in Critical Accounting Research', Accounting and the Public Interest 2, 68-87.
85. Toffler, B. L. (with J. Reingold): 2003, Final Accounting: Ambition, Greed, and the Fall of Arthur Andersen (Broadway Books, New York).
86. Valentine, S. and G. Fleischman: 2003, 'The Impact of Self-esteem, Machiavellianism, and Social Capital on Attorney's Traditional Gender Outlook', Journal of Business Ethics 43(4), 323-335.
87. Wallace, J.: 1995, 'Organizational and Professional Commitment in Professional and Nonprofessional Organizations', Administrative Science Quarterly 40(2), 228-255.
88. Wyatt, A. R.: 2004, 'Accounting Professionalism - They Just Don't Get It!', Accounting Horizons 18(1), 45-53.
89. Wyatt, A. R. and J. Gaa: 2005, 'Accounting Professionalism: A Fundamental Problem and the Quest for Fundamental Solutions', The CPA Journal 74(3), 22-32.
90. Yuthas, K.J. F. Dillard and R. K. Rogers: 2004, 'Beyond Agency and Structure: Triple-loop Learning', Journal of Business Ethics 51(2), 229-243.
91. Zeff, S. A.: 1987, 'Does the CPA Belong to a Profession?', Accounting Horizons 1(2), 65-68.
92. Zeff, S. A.: 2003a, 'How the U.S. Accounting Profession Got Where It Is Today: Part I', Accounting Horizons 17(3), 189-205.
93. Zeff, S. A.: 2003b, 'How the U.S. Accounting Profession Got Where It Is Today: Part II', Accounting Horizons 17(4), 267-286.