Analysis of a failed jurisdictional claim: The rhetoric and politics surrounding the AICPA global credential project

Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal

Volumn 18, Issue 4, 2005, Pages 453-491

  Shafer, William E ^a   Gendron, Yves ^b  

^a LINGNAN UNIVERSITY   (Hong Kong)

^b UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

Author keywords

Accounting; Organizational change; Professional associations

Indexed keywords

EID: 23444435256     PISSN: 09513574     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1108/09513570510609324     Document Type: Article

References (135)

1. Abbott, A. (1988), The System of Professions, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
2. AccountingWeb (2000a), “Scots and Irish pull out of global qualification scheme”, available at: www.accountingweb.com.
3. AccountingWeb (2000b), “Brits pull out of global qualification scheme”, available at: www.accountingweb.com.
4. AccountingWeb (2001), “BDO Seidman contacts AICPA members re global credential”, available at: www.accountingweb.com.
5. Akrich, M., Callon, M. and Latour, B. (2002), “The key to success in innovation – part II: the art of choosing good spokespersons”, International Journal of Innovation Management, Vol. 6 No. 2, pp. 207-25.
6. Albert, S. and Whetten, D.A. (1985), “Organizational identity”, Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 7, pp. 263-95.
7. AICPA (1997), Overview of Assurance Services, American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, New York, NY.
8. AICPA (2000a), The Cognitor Concept: Turning Knowledge into Value, American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, New York, NY.
9. AICPA (2000b), Professional Standards: Volumes 1 and 2, American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, New York, NY.
10. AICPA (2001a), “The XYZ global business credential: a brief summary”, available at: www.globalcredential.aicpa.org/content/info/summary.htm.
11. AICPA (2001b), “Special report: the global business credential”, Journal of Accountancy, September, pp. 49-71.
12. AICPA (2002a), “AICPA members vote down bylaw amendment”, available at: www.aicpa.org/news/p010302.htm.
13. AICPA (2002b), Annual Report 2001-2002, AICPA, New York, NY.
14. Anderson-Gough, F., Grey, C. and Robson, K. (1998), Making Up Accountants, Ashgate Publishing, Brookfield, VT.
15. Anderson-Gough, F., Grey, C. and Robson, K. (2001), “Tests of time: organizational time-reckoning and the making of accountants in two multi-national accounting firms”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 26 No. 2, pp. 99-122.
16. Annisette, M. (2000), “Imperialism and the professions: the education and certification of accountants in Trinidad and Tobago”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 25 No. 7, pp. 631-59.
17. Ballas, A.A. (1998), “The creation of the auditing profession in Greece”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 23 No. 8, pp. 715-36.
18. Broadbent, J. and Laughlin, R. (1998), “Resisting the ‘new public management’: absorption and absorbing groups in schools and GP practices in the UK”, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 11 No. 4, pp. 403-35.
19. Broadbent, J., Jacobs, K. and Laughlin, R. (2001), “Organisational resistance strategies to unwanted accounting and finance changes: the case of general medical practice in the UK”, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 14 No. 5, pp. 565-86.
20. Burrage, M., Jarausch, K. and Siegrist, H. (1990), “An actor-based framework for the study of the professions”, in Burrage, M. and Torstendahl, R. (Eds), Professions in Theory and History, Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA, pp. 203-25.
21. California Society of CPAs (CSCPA) (2001), “XYZ: a great debate”, California CPA, October, pp. 34-44.
22. Cho, D. (2000), “Melancon explains proposed credential at chapter meeting”, The Trusted Professional, December, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
23. Chua, W.F. and Poullaos, C. (1998), “The dynamics of ‘closure’ amidst the construction of market, profession, empire and nationhood: an historical analysis of an Australian accounting association, 1886-1903”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 23 No. 2, pp. 155-87.
24. Citron, D.B. (1991), “The UK's framework approach to auditor independence and the commercialization of the accounting profession”, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 16 No. 2, pp. 244-74.
25. Colson, R. (2001), “In the interest of the investor: an interview with Lynn Turner”, The CPA Journal, Vol. 7 No. 11, pp. 20-9.
26. Covaleski, M.A., Dirsmith, M.W. and Rittenberg, L. (2003), “Jurisdictional disputes over professional work: the institutionalization of the global knowledge expert”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 28 No. 4, pp. 323-55.
27. Craig, J.L. Jr (1999), “AICPA Chairman for the new millennium: an interview with Robert K. Elliott”, The CPA Journal, October, pp. 40-5.
28. Craig, J.L. Jr (2000), “Moving the AICPA into the new millennium: an interview with Barry C. Melancon”, The CPA Journal, July, pp. 14-16.
29. Daly, B.A. and Schuler, D.K. (1998), “Redefining a certified public accounting firm”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 23 Nos 5/6, pp. 549-67.
30. Derber, C. and Schwartz, W.A. (1991), “New mandarins or new proletariat? Professional power at work”, in Tolbert, P.S. and Barley, S.R. (Eds), Research in the Sociology of Organizations, Vol. 8, JAI Press, Greenwich, CT, pp. 71-96.
31. Demery, P. (1997), “AICPA: racing for a new identity before it's too late”, The Practical Accountant, January, pp. 26-34.
32. Dezalay, Y. (1991), “Territorial battles and tribal disputes”, The Modern Law Review, Vol. 54 No. 6, pp. 792-809.
33. Dezalay, Y. (1995), “‘Turf battles’ or ‘class struggles’: the internationalization of the market for expertise in the ‘professional society’”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 20 No. 5, pp. 331-44.
34. Dismukes, J. (2001), “XYZ forums wrap up, New York members still opposed”, The Trusted Professional, September, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
35. Dismukes, J. and Woehlke, J. (2001), “AICPA Council defeats NYSSCPA resolution to terminate global credential”, The Trusted Professional, May, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
36. Dowling, J. and Pfeffer, J. (1975), “Organizational legitimacy: social values and organizational behavior”, Pacific Sociological Review, Vol. 18, pp. 122-36.
37. ElectronicAccountant (2001a), “AICPA: XYZ designation is ‘inevitable’”, available at: www.electronicaccountant.com.
38. ElectronicAccountant (2001b), “Texas Society weighs in against global credential”, available at: www.electronicaccountant.com.
39. Elliott, R.K. (1997), “Assurance services opportunities: implications for academia”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 11 No. 4, pp. 61-74.
40. Elliott, R.K. (2000), “Who are we as a profession – and what must we become?”, Journal of Accountancy, February, pp. 81-5.
41. Elliott, R.K. (2001), “A perspective on the proposed global professional credential”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 15 No. 4, pp. 359-72.
42. Esposito, D., Aronowitz, S., Chancer, L., DiFazio, W. and Yard, M. (1998), “The (in)spectre returns! global capitalism and the future of work”, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 9 No. 1, pp. 7-54.
43. Fogarty, T.J. and Radcliffe, V.S. (1999), “Extending practice: accountants' constructions of the industrial relations arena in the USA”, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 12 No. 5, pp. 525-60.
44. Freidson, E. (1970), Professional Dominance, Aldine, Chicago, IL.
45. Freidson, E. (1994), Professionalism Reborn: Theory, Prophecy, and Policy, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
46. Freidson, E. (2001), Professionalism, The Third Logic, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL.
47. General Accounting Office of the United States (GAO) (1996), The Accounting Profession – Major Issues: Progress and Concerns, General Accounting Office of the United States, Washington, DC.
48. Gendron, Y. (2002), “On the role of the organization in auditors' client-acceptance decisions”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 27 No. 7, pp. 659-84.
49. Gendron, Y. and Barrett, M. (2004), “Professionalization in action: accountants' attempt at building a network of support for the WebTrust e-commerce seal of assurance”, Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 563-602.
50. Gendron, Y. and Suddaby, R. (2004), “Professional insecurity and the erosion of accountancy's jurisdictional boundaries”, Canadian Accounting Perspectives, Vol. 3 No. 1, pp. 85-115.
51. Glater, J.D. (2001), “Risking ridicule, some accountants talk of becoming ‘cognitors’”, The New York Times, April 5, pp. C1.
52. Greenwood, R., Suddaby, R. and Hinings, C.R. (2002), “Theorizing change: the role of professional associations in the transformation of institutionalized fields”, Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 45 No. 1, pp. 58-80.
53. Grumet, L. (2000), “A global professional credential – by whatever name – is no quick fix”, The CPA Journal, November, pp. 10.
54. Grumet, L. (2001a), “Peeling away the layers of CPA2Biz”, The CPA Journal, July, pp. 9.
55. Grumet, L. (2001b), “A membership at the crossroads of disenfranchisement”, The CPA Journal, May, pp. 8-9.
56. Grumet, L. (2001c), “Global credential and the law of unintended consequences”, Accounting Today, October 22-November 4, pp. 7-38.
57. Grumet, L. (2001d), “Brilliant vision, but the wrong galaxy”, Accounting Today, May 7-20, pp. 6-17.
58. Grumet, L. (2002), “Reading the writing on the wall: CPA2Biz? Why?”, The CPA Journal, May, pp. 9.
59. Hanlon, G. (1997), “Commercialising the service class and economic restructuring – a response to my critics”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 22 No. 8, pp. 843-55.
60. Hansen, M.K. (2001), “A new credential”, ABA Journal, Vol. 87, pp. 18-19.
61. Henry, D. and McNamee, M. (2003), “Bloodied and bowed: CPAs are trying to salvage some political clout. But they can't even rally behind their chief trade group”, Business Week, January 20, pp. 56.
62. Hopwood, A.G. (1990), “Ambiguity, knowledge and territorial claims: some observations on the doctrine of substance over form”, British Accounting Review, Vol. 22, pp. 79-87.
63. Huefner, R.J. (2000), “The XYZ Certification: an early analysis”, The CPA Journal, July, pp. 18-19.
64. ICPAS (2001), XYZ: Action of the ICPAS Board of Directors, Illinois CPA Society, IL, available at: www.icpas.org/icpas/xyz/board-action.htm.
65. Johnson, T.J. (1972), Professions and Power, Macmillan, London.
66. Johnson, T. (1989), “Review of Abbott”, Work, Employment and Society, Vol. 3 No. 3, p. 413.
67. Katz, D.M. (2003), “Troubled times at the AICPA”, available at: CFO.com, July 1, pp. 1.
68. Klein, M. (2001a), “PwC joins opposition to XYZ global credential”, Accounting Today, May 7-20, pp. 5-45.
69. Klein, M. (2001b), “Nebraska Society, BDO Seidman veto global credential”, Accounting Today, September 24-October 7, pp. 3-4.
70. Kliegman, E.J. (2001a), “Commentary: AICPA plans are out of step with CPA community”, Accounting Today, December 18, 2000-January 7, 2001, pp. 56-8.
71. Kliegman, E.J. (2001b), “XYZ is good PR but bad for profession”, Accounting Today, October 22-November 4, pp. 49-50.
72. Kurunmäki, L. (2004), “A hybrid profession: the appropriation of management accounting expertise by medical professionals”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 29 Nos 3/4, pp. 327-47.
73. Larson, M.S. (1977), The Rise of Professionalism, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
74. Leicht, K.T. and Fennell, M.L. (2001), Professional Work: A Sociological Approach, Blackwell Publishers, Malden, MA.
75. Levitt, A. (2000a), “Renewing the covenant with investors”, speech delivered at the New York University Center for Law and Business, New York, NY, May 10.
76. Levitt, A. (2000b), “A profession at the crossroads”, speech delivered to the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy, Boston, MA, September 18.
77. Macdonald, K.M. (1995), The Sociology of the Professions, Sage Publications, London.
78. Mano, R. (2001), “First CPA2Biz, now XYZ: what is next for AICPA?”, Accounting Today, October 22-November 4, pp. 9.
79. Mason, E. (2000), “Short shots: http://www.melancon.bucks”, Accounting Today, July 10-23, pp. 6.
80. Mason, E. (2001a), “Somebody must go”, Accounting Today, March 19-April 1, pp. 6-7.
81. Mason, E. (2001b), “A declaration of independence”, Accounting Today, October 22-November 4, pp. 6-39.
82. Melancon, B.C. (1997), “Letter from the AICPA President: the CPA vision project”, Journal of Accountancy, August, pp. 4.
83. Melancon, B.C. (1998a), “The changing strategy for the profession, the CPA and the AICPA: what this means for the education community”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 12 No. 4, pp. 397-406.
84. Melancon, B.C. (1998b), “A path for the future”, Journal of Accountancy, February, pp. 82-6.
85. Melancon, B.C. (1998c), “Letter from the AICPA President: vision project update”, Journal of Accountancy, September, pp. 4.
86. Melancon, B.C. (1999), “Letter from the AICPA President: a new initiative for accreditations”, Journal of Accountancy, February, pp. 4.
87. Miller, P.B. and Bahnson, P.R. (2002a), “12 reasons to change things at the top level of the AICPA”, Accounting Today, May 20-June 2.
88. Miller, P.B. and Bahnson, P.R. (2002b), “Make that 14 reasons to change the tone at the top of the AICPA”, Accounting Today, July 8-21.
89. NYSSCPA (2000a), “Cognitor is not the answer”, The Trusted Professional, November, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
90. NYSSCPA (2000b), “CPAdirectory.com opposes Cognitor”, The Trusted Professional, November, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
91. NYSSCPA (2001a), “Cognitor lambasted by radio/TV personality”, available at: www.nysscpa.org/home/.
92. NYSSCPA (2001b), “NYSSCPA Board Resolution”, available at: www.nysscpa.org/home/xyz.
93. NYSSCPA (2001c), “XYZ has a new name”, available at: www.nysscpa.org/home/.
94. NYSSCPA (2001d), “Speech given by NYSSCPA President opposing global credential” The Trusted Professional, May, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
95. NYSSCPA (2001e), “A letter to New York CPAs: save the CPA, vote ‘no’”, available at: www.nysscpa.org/.
96. Newman-Limata, N. (2001), “Stepping through the portal”, The Trusted Professional, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/archive/0701/main.htm.
97. Nowicki, R.M. (2001), “Is the XYZ really your vision?”, The Trusted Professional, August, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
98. Palmer, J.M. (2000a), “Commentary: the AICPA portal”, The Trusted Professional, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/archive/1200/main.htm.
99. Palmer, J.M. (2000b), “Commentary: the proposed international professional designation”, The Trusted Professional, December, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/.
100. Parsons, T. (1954), “The professions and social structure”, in Parsons, T. (Ed.), Essays in Sociological Theory, Free Press, Glencoe, IL, pp. 34-49.
101. Parsons, T. (1960), Structure and Process in Modern Societies, Free Press, Glencoe, IL.
102. Partner's Report (2001), “XYZ: amorphous brand or value enhancer? You decide”, June Partner's Report, pp. 1-2.
103. Pethley, L.S. and Fremgen, R.I. (2001), “XYZ: two credentials for one profession? A case of double vision”, The CPA Journal, September, pp. 13-15.
104. Power, M. (1996), “Making things auditable”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 21 Nos 2/3, pp. 289-315.
105. Power, M. (1997a), The Audit Society: Rituals of Verification, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
106. Power, M. (1997b), “Expertise and the construction of relevance: accountants and environmental audit”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 22 No. 2, pp. 123-46.
107. Power, M. (2000), The Audit Implosion: Regulating Risk from the Inside, Centre for Business Performance, The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England & Wales, London.
108. (The) Practical Accountant (2003), “AICPA report sets credentials debate”, The Practical Accountant, May, pp. 6.
109. PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) (2001), “Memo to PwC members of the AICPA Council”, available at: www.nysscpa.org/XYZMemoPwC.htm.
110. Rankin, K. (2000), “Cognitor, new POB charter headline AICPA conference”, American Banker, Vol. 14 No. 22, p. 3.
111. Richardson, A.J. (1987), “Professionalization and intraprofessional competition in the Canadian accounting profession”, Work and Occupations, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 591-615.
112. Robson, K. and Cooper, D.J. (1990), “Understanding the development of the accountancy profession in the United Kingdom”, in Cooper, D.J. and Hopper, T.M. (Eds), Critical Accounts, Macmillan, London, pp. 366-90.
113. Rosedale, M. (2000), “Is the AICPA's vision prehistoric?”, The Practical Accountant, December, pp. 80.
114. Rosenberg, M. (2001), “Letter from Marty Rosenberg, President of the Illinois CPA Society, to the Secretary/Treasurer of the State Societies Network, Inc.”, available at: www.accountingweb.com.
115. Rosso, C. (2001), “Reaching critical mass: grassroots campaign stirs up debate on AICPA's proposed global credential”, California CPA, June, pp. 24-30.
116. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) (2002a), “Fact sheet: the commission's proposal to modernize the rules governing the independence of the accounting profession”, available at: www.sec.gov/news/extra/audfact.htm (accessed August 27, 2002).
117. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) (2002b), “Fact sheet: the modernization of the rules governing the independence of the accounting profession”, available at: www.sec.gov/news/extra/faqaud.htm (accessed August 27, 2002).
118. Sikka, P. and Willmott, H. (1995), “The power of independence: defending and extending the jurisdiction of accounting in the United Kingdom”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 20 No. 6, pp. 547-81.
119. Sikka, P. and Willmott, H. (1997), “Practising critical accounting”, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 8 Nos 1/2, pp. 149-65.
120. Somerville, L. (2001), “CPAs, attorneys question need for new credential”, The Business Journal, Vol. 4 No. 11, p. 35.
121. Suchman, M.C. (1995), “Managing legitimacy: strategic and institutional approaches”, Academy of Management Review, Vol. 20 No. 3, pp. 571-610.
122. Telberg, R. (2000), “Dot-com or dot-org? Melancon & Co. envision AICPA Inc.”, Accounting Today, May 22-June 11, pp. 6.
123. Toffler, B.L. and Reingold, J. (2003), Final Accounting: Ambition, Greed, and the Fall of Arthur Andersen, Broadway Books, New York, NY.
124. Van Brunt, R.T. and Steinberg, R.B. (2001), “Highlights of the 28th annual AICPA conference on SEC developments”, Insights: The Corporate and Securities Law Advisor, Vol. 15 No. 1, pp. 25-9.
125. Velayutham, S. and Rahman, A. (2000), “Towards market differentiation in the accounting profession: the case of Australia and New Zealand”, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 11 No. 6, pp. 691-711.
126. Walker, S.P. (2000), “Benign sacerdotalist or pious assailant: the rise of the professional accountant in British management”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 25 No. 3, pp. 313-23.
127. Walker, S.P. (2004), “The genesis of professional organisation in English accountancy”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 29 No. 2, pp. 127-56.
128. Walker, S.P. and Shackleton, K. (1998), “A ring fence for the profession: advancing the closure of British accountancy 1957-1970”, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol. 11 No. 1, pp. 34-71.
129. Weber, M. (1978), Economy and Society, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
130. Weil, J., Emshwiller, J. and Paltrow, S.J. (2002), “Audit nightmare: Arthur Andersen says it disposed of documents that related to Enron”, The Wall Street Journal, January 11, p. A1.
131. Woehlke, J.A. (2000), “AICPA council approves internet portal”, The Trusted Professional, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/archive/0600/main.htm.
132. Woehlke, J.A. (2002), “Council increases AICPA dues, reviews game plan: will take up governance issues in the fall”, The Trusted Professional, available at: www.nysscpa.org/trustedprof/archive/0602/main.htm.
133. Wolosky, H.W. (2000), “Editor's note: missed the boat”, The Practical Accountant, April, p. 4.
134. Wolosky, H.W. (2001), “Editor's note: a watershed event”, The Practical Accountant, December, pp. 4.
135. Zeff, S.A. (2003), “How the US accounting profession got where it is today: part II”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 17 No. 4, pp. 267-86.