Determinants of objective and subjective success of men and women

International Review of Administrative Sciences

Volumn 71, Issue 4, 2005, Pages 607-624

  Lortie Lussier, Monique ^a   Rinfret, Natalie ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OTTAWA   (Canada)

^b ÉCOLE NATIONALE D'ADMINISTRATION PUBLIQUE   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COMPARATIVE STUDY; GENDER DISPARITY;

CANADA; NORTH AMERICA; QUEBEC [CANADA];

EID: 30644475921     PISSN: 00208523     EISSN: 14617226     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0020852305059601     Document Type: Article

References (61)

1. Association des cadres du gouvernement du Québec (2004) 'Les effectifs de l'Association au 31 décembre 2003', Visions et Action 6(1): 3.
2. Bass, Bernard M. (1999) 'Two Decades of Research and Development in Transformational Leadership', European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology 8: 9-27.
3. Bass, Bernard M. and Avolio, Bruce J. (1994) 'Shatter the Glass Ceiling: Women May Make Better Managers', Human Resource Management 33: 549-60.
4. Burke, Ronald J. and McKeen, Carol A (1993) 'Career Priority Patterns among Managerial and Professional Women', Applied Psychology: An International Review 42: 341-52.
5. Burke, Sarah and Collins, Karen M. (2001) 'Gender Differences in Leadership Styles and Management Skills', Women in Management Review 16: 244-56.
6. Carli, Linda L. (2001)'Gender and Social Influence, Journal of Social Issues 57: 725-41.
7. Chambers, Julia M. (1999) 'The Job Satisfaction of Managerial and Executive Women: Revisiting the Assumptions', Journal of Education for Business November-December: 69-74.
8. Commission canadienne des droits de la personne (2004)'Progrès réalisés par les groupes désignés'. Ottawa.
9. Commission de la fonction publique fédérale (2001) 'Profil démographique de la fonction fédérale pour les exercices de 1994 à 1997'. Ottawa.
10. Conseil du Trésor (1992) 'Le défi de l'égalité: des compétences à utiliser. Programme d'accés à l'égalité la fonction publique pour les femmes 1992-1997'. Québec.
11. Dreher, George F. and Ash, Ronald A. (1990) 'A Comparative Study of Mentoring among Men and Women in Managerial, Professional and Technical Positions', Journal of Applied Psychology 75: 539-46.
12. Duxbury, Linda and Higgins, Chris (2003) Work-Life Conflict in Canada in the New Millennium. A Status Report. Health Canada.
13. Eagly, Alice H. and Johannesen-Schmidt, Mary C. (2001) The Leadership Styles of Women and Men', Journal of Social Issues 57: 781-97.
14. Eagly, Alice H. and Karau, Steven J. (2002) 'Role Congruity Theory of Prejudice Toward Female Leaders', Psychological Review 109(3): 573-98.
15. Fagenson, Ellen A. (1989) 'The Mentor Advantage: Perceived Career-job Experiences of Proteges Versus Non-proteges', Journal of Organizational Behavior 10: 309-20.
16. Fox, Richard L. and Schuhmann, Robert A (2001)'Mentoring Experiences of Women City Managers: Are Women Disadvantaged?, American Review of Public Administration 31(4): 381-92.
17. Gagnon, Yves C. and Létoumeau, Francine (11997) 'Les facteurs qui influencent l'accès des femmes aux postes supérieurs', Gestion 22: 37-43.
18. Gattiker, Urs E. and Larwood, Laurie (1989) 'Career Success, Mobility and Extrinsic Satisfaction of Corporate Managers', Social Science Journal 26: 75-92.
19. Goffee, Rob and Scase, Richard (1992) 'Organizational Change and the Corporate Career: The Restructuring of Managers' Job Aspirations', Human Relations 45: 363-84.
20. Hale, Mary M. (1995) 'Mentoring Women in Organizations: Practice in Search of Theory', American Review of Public Administration 25: 327-39.
21. Hale, Mary M. (1999) 'He Says, She Says: Gender and Work Life', Public Administration Review 59: 410-24.
22. Hall, Douglas (1996) The Career is Dead, Long Live the Career: A Relational Approach to Careers. New York: Josey-Bass.
23. Heilman, Madeline E. (2001) 'Description and Prescription: How Gender Stereotypes Prevent Women's Ascent up the Organizational Ladder', Journal of Social Issues 57: 657-74.
24. Jaskolka, Gabriel, Beyer, Janice M. and Trice, Harrison M. (11985) 'Measuring and Predicting Success', Journal of Vocational Behavior 26: 189-205.
25. Judge, Timothy A, Cable, Daniel M, Boudreau, John W. and Bretz, Robert D. (11995) 'An Empirical Investigation of the Predictors of Career Success', Personnel Psychology 48: 485-519.
26. Kelly, Rita M. and Marin, Amy J.D. (11998) 'Position Power and Women's Career Advancement, Women in Management Review 13(2): 53-66.
27. Kirchmeyer, Catherine (1998) 'Determinants of Managerial Career Success: Evidence and Explanation of Male/Female Differences', Journal of Management 24: 673-92.
28. Kossek, Ellen E. and Ozeki, Cynthia (1998) Work-Family Conflict, Policies and the Job-Life Satisfaction Relationship: A Review and Directions for Organizational Behavior and Human Resource Research', Journal of Applied Psychology 83: 139-49.
29. Lemire, Louise and Saba, Tania (2002) 'Le défi de la gestion des carrières dans les organisations publiques. Un examen de la notion de succès de carrière, de ses déterminants et de ses conséquences', Revue de la gestion des ressources humaines 43: 50-67.
30. Lewis, Gregory B. (1992) 'Men and Women toward the Top: Backgrounds, Careers and Potential of Federal Middle-Managers', Public Personnel Management 21: 473-91.
31. Lyness, Karen S. and Thompson, Diana E. (2000) 'Climbing the Corporate Ladder: Do Male and Female Executives Follow the Same Route?', Journal of Applied Psychology 85: 86-101.
32. Mani, Bonnie G. (1997) 'Gender and the Federal Senior Executive Service: Where is the Glass Ceiling?', Public Personnel Management 26(4): 545-63.
33. Mason, E. Sharon (1997) 'A Case Study of Gender Differences in Job Satisfaction Subsequent to Implementation of an Employment Equity and Equality Programme', British Journal of Management 8:163-73.
34. Melamed, Tuvia (1995) 'Barriers to Women's Career Success: Human Capital, Career Choices, Structural Determinants, or Simply Sex Discrimination?', Applied Psychology: An International Review 44: 295-314.
35. Melamed, Tuvia (1996) 'Career Success: An Assessment of a Gender Specific Model', Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 69: 217-42.
36. Ministère des approvisionnements et services (1990) 'Au deltà des apparences; Rapport du comité de travail sur les femmes dans la foriction publique fédérale'. Ottawa: Gouvernement du Canada.
37. Murrell, Audrey J., Crosby, Faye J. and Ely, Robin J. (1995) Mentoring Dilemmas: Developmental Relationships within Multi-cultural Organizations. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
38. Naff, Katherine C. and Kellough, J. Edward (2003) 'Ensuring Employment Equity: Are Federal Diversity Programs Making a Difference?', International Journal of Public Administration 26: 1307-36.
39. Noe, Raymond A (1988) Women and Mentoring: A Review and a Research Agenda, Academy of Management Review 13: 65-78.
40. Nutley, Sandra and Mudd, Jane (2005) 'Has the Glass Cliff Replaced the Glass Ceiling for Women Employed in the Public Sector?', Public Money and Management January: 3-4.
41. OCDE (Page consulted in 23 March 2005) OCDE site [on-line]: http:// www.oecd.org/LongAbstract/ 0,2546,fr_33873108_33873870_19107301_1_1_1,00.html
42. Olsson, Su and Pringle, Judith K. (2004) Women Executives: Public and Private Sectors as Sites of Advancement?', Women in Management Review 19: 29-39.
43. Orser, Barbara (2000) 'Creating High Performance Organizations: Leveraging Women's Leadership'. Ottawa: The Conference Board of Canada.
44. Oshagbemi, Titusand and Gill, Roger (2003) 'Gender Differences and Similarities in the Leadership Styles and Behavior of UK Managers, Women in Management Review 18(6): 288-98.
45. Powell, Gary N. and Butterfield, D. Anthony (1994) 'Investigation of the Glass Ceiling Phenomenon: An Empirical Investigation of Actual Promotions to Top Management', Academy of Management Journal 37: 68-86.
46. Rinfret Natalie and Lortie-Lussier, Monique (1997) 'Le style de gestion des hommes et des femmes: Convergence ou divergence? Canadian Public Administration lAdministration Publique du Canada 40: 599-613.
47. Rinfret Natalie and Ngo Manguelle, Christiane (2004) 'L'impact de la décroissance organisationnelle chez les fonctionnaires: Différent ou non selon le sexe et le niveau hiérarchique?', Actes du Colloque, de l'Association des Scences Administratives du Canada (ASAC), Quebec, June.
48. Rolland, Gabrielle and Serien Hervé (1995) Colère à deux voix; quand les organisations laminent les talents. Paris: Inter Editions.
49. Rosener, Judy B. (1996) 'Ways Women Lead', in N. Nichols (ed.), Reach for the Top, pp. 13-24. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
50. Saba, Tania and Lemire, Louise (2002) 'Gestion des carrières dans l'administration publique canadienne: Une étude comparative selon le sexe, Conférence de l'Association Internationale des Écoles et Instituts d'Administration, Istanbul.
51. Schein, Virginia E. (2001) 'A Global Look at the Psychological Barriers to Women's Progress in Management', Journal of Social Issues 57: 675-88.
52. Schneer, Joy A and Reitman, Frieda (1995) 'The Impact of Gender as Careers Unfold', Journal of Vocational Behavior 47: 290-305.
53. Secrétariat du conseil du trésor (1998) Rapport annuel 1997-1998. Sainte-Foy: Les Publications du Québec, Gouvernement du Québec
54. Secrétariat du conseil du trésor (2002) Le rajeunissement de la foriction publique québéoise: orientations et plan d'action. Québec: Gouvernement du Québec
55. Stroh, Linda K, Brett, Jeanne M. and Reilly, Ann H. (1996) 'Family Structure, Glass Ceiling and Traditional Explanation for the Differential Rate of Turnover of Male and Female Managers', Journal of Vocational Behavior 49: 99-118.
56. Sturges, Jane (1999) What it Means to Succeed: Personal Conceptions of Career Success Held by Male and Female Managers at Different Ages', British Journal of Management 10: 239-52.
57. Tharenou, Phyllis (1999) 'Is There a Link between Family Structures and Women's and Men's Managerial Career Advancement?', Journal of Organizational Behavior 20: 837-63.
58. Tharenou, Phyllis and Conroy, Denise (1994) 'Men and Women Managers' Advancement: Personal or Situational Determinants?', Applied Psychology: An International Review 43: 5-31.
59. Tougas, Francine, Brown, Rupert Beaton, Ann M. and Joly, Stéphane (1995) 'Neosexism: Plus ça change, plus cest pareil', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 21: 842-9.
60. Tsui, Anne S. and Gutek Barbara A (1984) 'A Role-set Analysis of Gender Differences in Performance, Affective Relationships and Career Success of Industrial Middle Managers', Academy of Management Journal 27:619-35.
61. Wyse, Alison and Vilkinas, Tricia (2004) 'Executive Leadership Roles in the Australian Public Service', Women in Management Review 19:205-11.