Moving from conflict to collaboration: Watershed governance in Lake Tahoe

Natural Resources Journal

Volumn 43, Issue 4, 2003, Pages 1009-1056

  Imperial, Mark T ^a   Kauneckis, Derek ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA WILMINGTON   (United States)

^b INDIANA UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

GOVERNANCE APPROACH; INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS; POLICY MAKING; WATER MANAGEMENT;

LAKE TAHOE; NORTH AMERICA; UNITED STATES;

EID: 2642528712     PISSN: 00280739     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Article

References (82)

1. Carol J. Boughton et al., Dep't of the Interior, Stream and Ground Water Monitoring Program, Lake Tahoe Basin, Nevada and California, FACT SHEET FS-100-97, U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY, June 1997, at 1.
2. Deborah L. Elliot-Fisk et al., Lake Tahoe Case Study, in SIERRA NEVADA ECOSYSTEM PROJECT: FINAL REPORT TO CONGRESS, ADDENDUM 217, 238 (Centers for Water & Wildland Res., Wildland Res. Center Report No. 40, Mar. 1997).
3. William D. Leach, Surveying Diverse Stakeholder Groups, 15 SOC'Y & NAT. RESOURCES 1, 641 (2002).
4. Derek Kauneckis et al., Tahoe Regional Planning Agency: The Evolution of Collaboration 3, 4 (Nat'l Academy of Public Admin., July 2000), available at http://www.napawash.org/pc_economy_environment/ trpa.pdf (last visited Nov. 6, 2003).
5. ROBERT K. YIN, CASE STUDY RESEARCH: DESIGN AND METHODS 91-93 (2d ed. 1994).
6. Laurence E. Lynn et al., Studying Governance and Public Management: Challenges and Prospects, 10 J. PUB. ADMIN. RES. & THEORY 233 (2000);
7. H. GEORGE FREDERICKSON, THE SPIRIT OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION (1996);
8. H. Brinton Milward & Keith G. Provan, Governing the Hollow State, 10 J. PUB. ADMIN. RES. & THEORY 359 (2000).
9. Mark T. Imperial & Timothy M. Hennessey, Environmental Governance in Watersheds: The Importance of Collaboration to Institutional Performance, in ENVIRONMENT.GOV: TRANSFORMING ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION FOR THE 21st CENTURY 8.7, 8.58 (Nat'l Acad. of Public Admin., Res. Papers 1-7, 2000).
10. Hans Bressers et al., Networks as Models of Analysis: Water Policy in Comparative Perspective, in NETWORKS FOR WATER POLICY: A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE 1,4 (Hans Bressers et al. eds., 1995).
11. EUGENE BARDACH, GETTING AGENCIES TO WORK TOGETHER: THE PRACTICE AND THEORY OF MANAGERIAL CRAFTSMANSHIP 8 (1998).
12. MARK H. MOORE, CREATING PUBLIC VALUE: STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT IN GOVERNMENT (1995).
13. Barbara Gray & Donna J. Wood, Collaborative Alliances: Moving from Practice to Theory, 27 J. APPLIED BEHAV. SCI. 3, 4 (1991).
14. Nelson Phillips et al., Interorganizational Collaboration and the Dynamic of Institutional Fields, 37 J. MGMT. STUD. 23 (2000);
15. Thomas B. Lawrence et al., Institutional Effects of Interorganizational Collaboration: The Emergence of Proto-institutions, 45 ACAD. OF MGMT. J. 281 (2002).
16. ELINOR OSTROM, GOVERNING THE COMMONS: THE EVOLUTION OF INSTITUTIONS FOR COLLECTIVE ACTION (1990).
17. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (TRPA), Regional Plan for the Lake Tahoe Basin: Goals and Policies (Apr. 1999).
18. CAROL A. MYERS & ANGELIA M. THACKER, U.S. GEOLOGICAL SURVEY, STREAM AND GROUND-WATER MONITORING PROGRAM: LAKE TAHOE BASIN, NEVADA AND CALIFORNIA 1 (June 1997).
19. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (TRPA), Regional Plan for the Lake Tahoe Basin: 2001 Threshold Evaluation Draft 3-29-3-35 (TRPA 2001), available at http://www.trpa.org/News/2001_Thresholds.html [hereinafter 2001 Threshold Evaluation] (last visited Nov. 20, 2003.
20. http://www.swrcb.ca.gov/rwqcb6/BPlan/BPlan_Index.htm
21. WES INGRAM & PAUL SABATIER, A DESCRIPTIVE HISTORY OF LAND USE AND WATER QUALITY PLANNING IN THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN 10-12 (Inst. of Ecology, Rep. No. 31, 1987).
22. DOUGLAS H. STRONG, TAHOE: AN ENVIRONMENTAL HISTORY 51 (1984).
23. DEP'T OF AGRIC., THE ROLE OF THE UNITED STATES FOREST SERVICE AND OTHER FEDERAL AGENCIES IN THE LAKE TAHOE REGION 9 (1979).
24. Mark Nechodom et al., Chapter 6: Social, Economic, and Institutional Assessment, in LAKE TAHOE WATERSHED ASSESSMENT 67 (1999) (unpublished draft, on file with author).
25. Paul A. Sabatier & Anne Brasher, From Vague Consensus to Clearly Differentiated Coalitions: Environmental Policy at Lake Tahoe, 1964-1985, in POLICY AND LEARNING: AN ADVOCACY COALITION APPROACH 177-208 (Paul Sabatier & J.A. Jenkins-Smith eds., 1993);
26. PAUL A. SABATIER & NEIL W. PELKEY, LAND DEVELOPMENT AND CHANGE AT LAKE TAHOE, 1960-84: THE EFFECTS OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONTROLS AND ECONOMIC COALITIONS ON HOUSING CONSTRUCTION (1990);
27. Paul Sabatier et al., The Devil Shift: Perceptions and Misperceptions of Opponents, 40 W. POL. Q. 449 (1987).
28. DOUGLAS H. STRONG, TAHOE: FROM TIMBER BARONS To ECOLOGISTS (1999);
29. SUSANNE BENTLEY, LAKE STORIES: AN EXPLORATION OF THE IMPACT OF HUMANS ON THE ENVIRONMENT IN THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN (1997) (unpublished dissertation, Univ. of Nevada at Reno) (on file with author);
30. Richard Fink, Public Land Acquisition for Environmental Protection: Structuring a Program for the Lake Tahoe Basin, 18 ECOLOGY L.Q. 485 (1991);
31. LAURENCE B. BAXTER, REGIONAL POLITICS AND THE CHALLENGE OF ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING (Inst. of Govtl. Affairs, Envtl. Quality Series No. 22, 1974);
32. ROBERT A. BURCO, POLICY AND PLANNING IN THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN: THE CASE OF TRANSPORTATION (Inst. of Govtl. Affairs, Envtl. Quality Series No. 22, 1973);
33. WILLIAM E. FELTS & GEOFFREY WANDESFORDE-SMITH, THE POLITICS OF DEVELOPMENTAL REVIEW IN THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN (Inst. of Govtl. Affairs, Envtl. Quality Series No. 16, 1973).
34. W. TURRENTINE JACKSON, EARLY PLANNING EFFORTS AT LAKE TAHOE: THE ROLE OF JOSEPH F. MCDONALD 1956-1963 (Inst. of Govtl. Affairs, Envtl. Quality Series No. 18, 1972).
35. LAKE TAHOE AREA COUNCIL, EPA, EUTROPHICATION OF SURFACE WATERS-LAKE TAHOE (1971).
36. JAMES E. PEPPER & ROBERT E. JORGENSEN, EPA, INFLUENCES OF WASTEWATER MANAGEMENT ON LAND USE: TAHOE BASIN, 1950-1972, at 34 (1974).
37. LAKE TAHOE JOINT STUDY COMMITTEE, REPORT OF THE LAKE TAHOE JOINT STUDY COMMITTEE 8 (1967).
38. PAUL T. HARDY, INTERSTATE COMPACTS: THE TIES THAT BIND (1982).
39. ROBERT G. BAILEY, DEP'T OF AGRIC. & TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, LAND-CAPABILITY CLASSIFICATION OF THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN, CALIFORNIA-NEVADA: A GUIDE FOR PLANNING (1974).
40. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, CODE OF ORDINANCES, ch. 37, subpart 3 (1999), available at http://www.trpa.org/Ordinances/pdffiles/ Code37.pdf (last visited Oct. 20, 2003).
41. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, BEYOND BAILEY: TRPA'SINDIVIDUAL PARCEL EVALUATION SYSTEM (Sept. 1988).
42. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, REGIONAL PLAN FOR THE LAKE TAHOE BASIN: GOALS AND POLICIES (1986), available at http://www.trpa.org/Goals/ preface.html (last visited Oct. 20, 2003).
43. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, SUMMARY & DRAFT 1996 EVALUATION REPORT: ENV'T THRESHOLD CARRYING CAPACITIES & REG'L PLAN PACKAGE FOR THE LAKE TAHOE REGION 1-3 (1996)).
44. Paul A. Sabatier & Hank C. Jenkins-Smith, The Advocacy Coalition Framework: An Assessment, in THEORIES OF THE POLICY PROCESS 117-66 (Paul A. Sabatier ed., 1999);
45. POLICY CHANGE AND LEARNING: AN ADVOCACY COALITION APPROACH (Paul A. Sabatier & Hank C. Jenkins-Smith eds., 1993) (discussing the concept of policy oriented learning).
46. CAL. TAHOE CONSERVANCY, CALIFORNIA TAHOE CONSERVANCY: PROGRESS REPORT (1997) (providing project expenditures authorized by the California Tahoe Coservancy since 1984).
47. Richard Fink, Public Land Acquisition for Environmental Protection: Structuring a Program for the Lake Tahoe Basin, 18 ECOLOGY L.Q. 485 (1991).
48. SOIL CONSERVATION SER., DEP'T. OF AGRIC., S. LAKE TAHOE, CAL., EVALUATION OF PROPOSED EROSION CONTROL PROJECTS WITHIN NEVADA'S LAKE TAHOE WATERS: THE COST EFFECTIVENESS OF REDUCING THE SEDIMENT ON LAKE TAHOE (1990).
49. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, VOL. 1: PROGRAM OVERVIEW (MAY 2001) hereinafter EJP VOL. 1], available at http://www.trpa.org/eipdocument/pdffiles/volume1.pdf (last visited Oct. 20, 2003).
50. TAHOE REGIONAL PLANNING AGENCY (TRPA), ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM FOR THE LAKE TAHOE REGION: THE COOPERATIVE EFFORT TO PRESERVE, RESTORE, AND ENHANCE THE UNIQUE NATURAL AND HUMAN ENVIRONMENT OF THE LAKE TAHOE REGION, VOL. 1: PROGRAM OVERVIEW 5 (2001), available at http://www.trpa.org/eipdocument/pdffiles/volume1.pdf (last visited Jan. 29, 2003).;
51. LAKE TAHOE FED. P'SHIP REVIEW OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM FOR THE LAKE TAHOE REGION 2 (1999).
52. LAKE TAHOE FED. INTERAGENCY P'SHIP, PRESIDENTIAL FORUM DELIVERABLES 1 (1997).
53. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, ANNUAL REPORT OF THE TAHOE REGIONAL PLANNING AGENCY 2 (1998).
54. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, VOL. 3: FINANCE PLAN (Apr. 2001) [hereinafter EIP VOL. III], availanle at http://www.trpa.org/eipdocument/pdffiles/volume3.pdf (last visited Oct. 20, 2003).
55. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, VOL. 2: MASTER LIST OF THRESHOLD NEEDS (Apr. 2001) [hereinafter EIP VOL. II), available at http://www.trpa.org/eipdocument/pdffiles/ volume2.pdf (last visited Oct. 20 2003);
56. TAHOE REG'L PLANNING AGENCY, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM, VOL. 4: ACCOMPLISHMENTS REPORT (Apr. 2001) [hereinafter EIP VOL. IV], available at http://www.trpa.org/eipdocument/pdffiles/ volume4.pdf (last visited Oct. 20, 2003).
57. MANAGING COMPLEX NETWORKS: STRATEGIES FOR THE PUBLIC SECTOR (WALTER J.M. KICKERT et al. eds., 1997) (discussing the concept of policy networks).
58. James E. Fletcher et al., Assessing Public Recreation Service Facility Preferences of Tourists and Residents at North Lake Tahoe, California, 11 J. PARK & RECREATION ADMIN. 60 (1993).
59. DESIGN WORKSHOP, INC. ET AL., NORTH LAKE TAHOE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT MASTER PLAN 4 (1995).
60. SOUTH TAHOE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, SOUTH TAHOE DEMONSTRATION REDEVELOPMENT PLAN: FOR SKI RUN AND STATELINE AREAS 4-12 (Draft, City of South Lake Tahoe 1999).
61. LAURENCE D. BAXTER, REGIONAL POLITICS AND THE CHALLENGE OF ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING (Inst. of Govtl. Affairs, Envtl. Quality Series No. 22, 1974).
62. JULIA M. WONDOLLECK & STEVEN L. YAFFEE, MAKING COLLABORATION WORK: LESSONS FROM INNOVATION IN NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (2000);
63. Matthew S. Kraatz, Learning by Association? Interorganizational Networks and Adaptation to Environmental Change, 41 ACAD. OF MGMT. J. 621 (1998).
64. Bernard L. Simonin, The Importance of Collaborative Know-How. An Empirical Test of the Learning Organization, 40 ACAD. OF MGMT. REV. 1150 (1997).
65. Jeffrey H. Dyer & Harbir Singh, The Relational View: Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganizational Competitive Advantage, 23 ACAD. OF MGMT. REV. 660 (1998);
66. Ranjay Gulati, Social Structure and Alliance Formation Patterns: A Longitudinal Study, 40 ADMIN. SCI. Q. 619 (1995);
67. ROBERT D. PUTNAM, Bowling Alone: America's Declining Social Capital, 6 J. DEMOCRACY 65 (1995);
68. JAMES S. COLEMAN, FOUNDATIONS OF SOCIAL THEORY (1990);
69. Carrie R. Leana & Harry J. Van Buren III, Organizational Social Capital and Employment Practices, 24 ACAD. OF MGMT. REV. 538 (1999);
70. RONALD S. BURT, STRUCTURAL HOLES: THE SOCIAL STRUCTURE OF COMPETITION (1992);
71. Jane Fountain, Social Capital: Its Relationship to Innovation in Science and Technology, 25 SCI. & PUB. POL'Y 103 (1998).
72. Wenpin Tsai & Sumantra Ghoshal, Social Capital and Value Creation: The Role of Intrafirm Networks, 41 ACAD. OF MGMT. J. 464, 467-68 (1998);
73. Andrew C. Wicks et al., The Structure of Optimal Trust: Moral and Strategic Implications, 24 ACAD. OF MGMT. REV. 99, 99-100 (1999).
74. Mark Granovetter, Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problems of Embeddedness, 91 Am. J. SOC. 481, 490 (1985).
75. David P. McCaffrey et al., The Appeal and Difficulties of Participative Systems, 6 ORG. SCI. 603 (1995).
76. ROBERT AXELROD, THE EVOLUTION OF COOPERATION (1984).
77. Larry L. Kiser & Elinor Ostrom, The Three Worlds of Action: A Metatheoretical Synthesis of Institutional Approaches, in STRATEGIES FOR POLTICAL INQUIRY 179, 203 (Elinor Ostrom ed., 1982).
78. Richard F. Elmore, Forward and Backward Mapping: Reversible Logic in the Analyses of Public Policy, in POLICY IMPLEMENTATION IN FEDERAL AND UNITARY SYSTEMS: QUESTIONS OF ANALYSIS AND DESIGN 33 (Kenneth Hanf & Theo A. J. Toonen eds., 1985).
79. Christine Oliver, Network Relations and Loss of Organizational Autonomy, 44 HUM. REL. 943 (1991).
80. Mark T. Imperial, Analyzing Institutional Arrangements for Ecosystem-Based Management: The Institutional Analysis and Development Framework, 24 ENVTL. MGMT. 461 (1999);
81. WILLIAM A. BLOMQUIST, DIVIDING THE WATERS: GOVERNING GROUNDWATER IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA 360 (1992);
82. VINCENT OSTROM, THE MEANING OF AMERICAN FEDERALISM: CONSTITUTING A SELF-GOVERNING SOCIETY 258 (1991).