A critique of statistical aspects of ecological studies in spatial epidemiology

Environmental and Ecological Statistics

Volumn 11, Issue 1, 2004, Pages 31-54

  Wakefield, Jonathan ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON   (United States)

^b IMPERIAL COLLEGE SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Confounding; Cross level bias; Ecological fallacy; Exposure misclassification; Pure specification bias; Spatial epidemiology; Within area variability

Indexed keywords

ECOLOGY; EPIDEMIOLOGY; SPATIAL ANALYSIS; STATISTICAL ANALYSIS;

EID: 1542442436     PISSN: 13528505     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1023/B:EEST.0000011363.12720.38     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. Aylin, P., Bottle, A., Wakefield, J., Jarup, L., and Elliott, P. (2001) Proximity to coke works and hospital admissions for respiratory and cardiovascular disease in England and Wales. Thorax, 56, 228-33.
2. Bernardinelli, L., Pascutto, C., Montomoli, C., Komakec, J., Gilks, W., Songini, M., Fiorani, O., Lisa, A., Zie, G., Solinas, G., and Bottazzo, G.G. (1999) Bayesian analysis of ecological data for studying the association between insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus and malaria. In Statistics for the Environment 4: Statistical Aspects of Health and the Environment, V. Barnett, A. Stein and K.F. Turkman, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester, pp. 29-47.
3. Besag, J., York, J., and Mollié, A. (1991) Bayesian image restoration with two applications in spatial statistics. Annals of the Institute of Statistics and Mathematics, 43, 1-59.
4. Best, N.G., Arnold, R.A., Thomas, A., Waller, L.A., and Conlon, E.M. (1999) Bayesian models for spatially correlated disease and exposure data. In Bayesian Statistics 6, J.M. Bernardo, J.O. Berger, A.P. Dawid, and A.F.M. Smith (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 131-56.
5. Best, N.G., Cockings, S., Bennett, J., Wakefield, J., and Elliott, P. (2001) Ecological regression analysis of environmental benzene exposure and childhood leukaemia: sensitivity to data inaccuracies, geographical scale and ecological bias. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 164, 155-74.
6. Best, N.G. and Wakefield, J.C. (1999) Accounting for inaccuracies in populations counts and case registration in cancer mapping studies. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 162, 363-82.
7. Best, N.G., Ickstadt, K., and Wolpert, R.L. (2001) Spatial Poisson regression for health and exposure data measured at disparate spatial scales. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 95, 1076-88.
8. Bithell, J.F. and Stone, R.A. (1989) On statistical methods for analysing the geographical distribution of cancer cases near nuclear installations. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 43, 79-85.
9. Blanchard, J.F., Bernstein, C.N., Wajda, A., and Rawsthorne, P. (2001) Small-area variations and sociodemographic correlates for the incidence of Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis. American Journal of Epidemiology, 154, 328-35.
10. Blot, W.J., Morris, L.E., Stroube, R., Tagnon, I., and Fraumeni, J.F. (1980) Lung and laryngeal cancers in relation to shipyard employment in coastal Virginia. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 65, 571-5.
11. Breslow, N.E. and Cain, K.C. (1988) Logistic regression for two-stage case-control data. Biometrika, 75, 11-20.
12. Breslow, N.E. and Chatterjee, N. (1999) Design and analysis of two-phase studies with binary outcome applied to Wilms tumor prognosis. Applied Statistics, 48, 457-68.
13. Breslow, N.E. and Holubkov, R. (1997) Maximum likelihood estimation of logistic regression parameters under two-phase outcome-dependent sampling. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 59, 447-61.
14. Carroll, R.J., Ruppert, D., and Stefanski, L.A. (1995) Measurement Error in Non-linear Models, Chapman and Hall.
15. Christiansen, C. and Morris, C. (1997) Hierarchical Poisson regression models. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 92, 618-32.
16. Clayton, D., Bernardinelli, L., and Montomoli, C. (1993) Spatial correlation in ecological analysis. International Journal of Epidemiology, 22, 1193-202.
17. Cook, D.G. and Pocock, S.J. (1983). Multiple regression in goegraphical mortality studies, with allowance for spatially correlated errors. Biometrics, 39, 361-71.
18. Cleave, N., Brown, P.J., and Payne, C.D. (1995) Methods for ecological inference: an evaluation. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 158, 55-75.
19. Davey Smith, G., Wentworth, D., Neaton, J.D., Stamler, R., and Stamler, J. (1996a) Socioeconomic differentials in mortality among men screened for Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial. I: white men. American Journal of Public Health, 86, 486-96.
20. Davey Smith, G., Wentworth, D., Neaton, J.D., Stamler, R., and Stamler, J. (1996b) Socioeconomic differentials in mortality among men screened for Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial. II: black men. American Journal of Public Health, 86, 497-504.
21. Diggle, P.J. (1990) A point process modeling approach to raised incidence of a rare phenomenon in the vicinity of a pre-specified point. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A, 153, 349-62.
22. Diggle, P.J. and Rowlingson, B.S. (1994) A conditional approach to point process modeling of raised incidence. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 157, 433-40.
23. Diggle, P.J. and Elliott, P. (1995) Statistical issues in the analysis of disease risk near point sources using individual or spatially aggregated data. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 49, S20-7.
24. Diggle, P.J., Morris, S.E., Elliott, P., and Shaddick, G. (1997) Regression modeling of disease risk in relation to point sources. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 160, 491-505.
25. Diggle, P.J., Tawn, J.A., and Moyeed, R.A. (1998) Model-based geostatistics. Applied Statistics, 47, 299-350.
26. Dockery, D.W., Pop, C.A. III. Xu, X., Spengler, J.D., Ware, J.H., Fay, M.E., Ferris, B.G., and Speizer, F.E. (1993) Mortality risks of air pollution: a prospective cohort study. New England Journal of Medicine, 329, 1753-9.
27. Dolk, H., Elliott, P., Shaddick, G., Walls, P., and Thakrar, B. (1997a) Cancer incidence near radio and television transmitters in Great Britain: all high power transmitters, American Journal of Epidemiology, 145, 10-17.
28. Dolk, H., Shaddick, G., Walls, P., Grundy, C., Thakrar, B., Kleinschmidt, I., and Elliott, P. (1997b) Cancer incidence near radio and television transmitters in Great Britain: Sutton Coldfield transmitter, American Journal of Epidemiology, 145, 1-9.
29. Dolk, H., Thakrar, B., Walls, P., Landon, M., Grundy, C., Suez-Lloret, I., Wilkinson, P., and Elliott, P. (1999) Mortality among residents near cokeworks in Great Britain. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 56, 34-40.
30. Dolk, H., Vrijheid, M., Armstrong, B., Abramsky, L., Bianche, F., Garne, E., Nelen, V., Robert, E., Scott, J.E.S., Stone, D., and Tenconi, R. (1998) Risk of congenital anomalies near hazardouswaste landfill sites in Europe: The EUROHAZCON study. Lancet, 352, 423-7.
31. Elliott, P., Hills, M.. Beresford, J., Kleinschmidt, I., Jolley, D., Pattenden, S., Rodrigues, L., Westlake, A., and Rose, G. (1992a) Incidence of cancer of the larynx and lung near incinerators of waste solvents and oils in Great Britain. Lancet, 339, 854-8.
32. Elliott, P. and Wakefield, J.C. (1999) Small-area studies of environment and health. Statistics for the Environment 4: Health and the Environment, V. Barnett, A. Stein, and K.F. Turkman (eds), John Wiley, New York, pp. 3-27.
33. Elliott, P., Westlake, A., Hills, M., Kleinschmidt, I., Rodrigues, L., McGale, P., Marshall, K., and Rose, G. (1992b) The Small Area Health Statistics Unit: a national facility for investigating health around point sources of environmental pollution in the United Kingdom. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 46, 345-9.
34. Elliott, P., Shaddick, G., Kleinschmidt, I., Jolley, D., Walls, P., Beresford, J., and Grundy, C. (1996) Cancer incidence near municipal solid waste incinerators in Great Britain. British Journal of Cancer, 73, 702-10.
35. Elliott, P., Wakefield, J.C., Best, N.G., and Briggs, D.B. (2000) Spatial Epidemiology: Methods and Applications, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
36. Gelman, A., Park, D.K., Ansolabehere, S., Price, P.N., and Minnite, L.C. (2001) Models, assumptions and model checking in ecological regressions. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 164, 101-18.
37. Greenland, S. (1992) Divergent biases in ecologic and individual-level studies. Statistics in Medicine, 11, 1209-23.
38. Greenland, S. and Morgenstern, H. (1989) Ecological bias, confounding, and effect modification. International Journal of Epidemiology, 18, 269-74.
39. Greenland, S. and Robins, J. (1994) Ecological studies-biases, misconceptions and counterexamples. American Journal Epidemiology, 139, 747-60.
40. Guest, A.M., Almgren, G., and Hussey, J.M. (1998) The ecology of race and socioeconomic distress: infant and working-age mortality in Chicago. Demography, 35, 23-34.
41. IARC (1997) Epstein-Barr virus and Kaposi's sarcoma herpesvirus/human herpesvirus 8. IARC Monograph on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, IARC Scientific Publication 70.
42. INTERSALT Cooperative Research Group (1988) INTERSALT: an international study of electrolyte excretion and blood pressure. Results for 24-hour urinary sodium and potassium excretion. British Medical Journal, 297, 319-28.
43. Kelsall, J.E. and Wakefield, J.C. (2002) Modeling spatial variability in disease risk. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 97, 692-701.
44. King, G. (1997) A Solution to the Ecological Inference Problem, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
45. Korn, E.L. and Graubard, B.I. (1999) Analysis of Health Surveys, John Wiley and Sons.
46. Krieger, N. (1990) Social class and the black/white crossover in the age-specific incidence of breast cancer: a study linking census-derived data to population-based registry records. American Journal of Epidemiology, 131, 804-14.
47. Krieger, N., Williams, D.R., and Moss, N.E. (1997) Measuring social class in U.S. public health research: concepts, methodologies and guidelines. Annual Review of Public Health, 18, 342-78
48. Lawson, A.B. (1993) On the analysis of mortality events associated with a prespecified fixed point. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 156, 363-77.
49. McCullagh, P. and Nelder, J.A. (1989) Generalized Linear Models, second edition, Chapman and Hall, London.
50. Maheswaran, R., Morris, S., Falconer, S., Grossinho, A., Perry, I., Wakefield, J., and Elliott, P. (1999) Magnesium in drinking water supplies and mortality from acute myocardial infarction in north west England. Heart, 82, 455-60.
51. Morgenstern, H. (1998) Ecologic studies. In Modern Epidemiology, K.J. Rothman and S. Greenland (eds), second edition, Lipincott-Raven, pp. 459-80.
52. Openshaw, S. (1984) The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem, CATMOG No. 38, Geo Books, Norwich.
53. Pekkanen, J. and Pearce, N. (2001) Environmental epidemiology: challenges and opportunities. Environmental Health Perspectives, 109, 1-5.
54. Piantadosi, S., Byar, D.P., and Green, S. B. (1988) The ecological fallacy. American Journal of Epidemiology, 127, 893-904.
55. Plummer, M. and Clayton, D. (1996) Estimation of population exposure in ecological studies (with discussion). Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 58, 113-26.
56. Pope, A. and Dockery, D. (1996) Epidemiology of chronic health effects: cross-sectional studies. In Particles in Our Air: Concentrations and Health Effects, R. Wilson and J. Spengler (eds), Harvard University Press, Boston pp. 149-67.
57. Prentice, R.L. and Sheppard, L. (1990) Dietary fat and cancer: consistency of the epidemiologic data, and disease prevention that may follow from a practical reduction in fat reduction. Cancer Causes Control, 1, 81-97.
58. Prentice, R.L. and Sheppard, L. (1995) Aggregate data studies of disease risk factors. Biometrika, 82, 113-25.
59. Riboli, E. (1992) Nutrition and cancer: background and rationale of the European perspective investigation into cancer and nutrition (EPIC). Ann. Onc., 3, 783-91.
60. Richardson, S. and Montfort, C. (2000) Ecological correlation studies. In Spatial Epidemiology: Methods and Applications, P. Elliott, J.C. Wakefield, N.G. Best, and D.B. Briggs, (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 205-20.
61. Richardson, S., Stucker, I., and Hemon, D. (1987) Comparison of relative risks obtained in ecological and individual studies: some methodological considerations. International Journal of Epidemiology, 16, 111-20.
62. Robinson, W.D. (1950) Ecological correlations and the behavior of individuals. American Sociological Reviews, 15, 351-7.
63. Rosenbaum, P.R. and Rubin, D.B. (1984) Difficulties with regression analyses of age-adjusted rates, Biometrics, 40, 437-43.
64. Rothman, K.J. and Greenland, S. (1998) Modern Epidemiology, (second edition), Lipincott-Raven.
65. Sans, S., Elliott, P., Kleinschmidt, I., Shaddick, G., Pattenden, S., Walls, P., Grundy, C., and Dolk, H. (1995) Cancer incidence and mortality near the Baglan Bay petrochemical works, South Wales. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 52, 217-24.
66. Scott, A.J. and Wild, C.J. (1997) Fitting regression models to case-control data by maximum likelihood. Biometrika, 84, 57-71.
67. Shaddick, G. and Wakefield, J. (2001) Modeling multivariate pollutants at multiple sites. Applied Statistics, 51, 351-72.
68. Sheppard, L., Prentice, R.L., and Rossing, M.A. (1996) Design considerations for estimation of exposure effects on disease risk, using aggregate data studies. Statistics in Medicine, 15, 1849-58.
69. Siemiatyeki, J., Wacholder, S., Dewar, R., Cardis, E., Greenwood, C., and Richardson, L. (1988) Degree of confounding bias related to smoking, ethnic group, and socioeconomic status in estimates of the associations between occupation and cancer. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 30, 617-25.
70. Stone, R.A. (1988) Investigations of excess environmental risks around putative sources: Statistical problems and a proposed test. Statistics in Medicine, 7, 649-60.
71. Wakefield, J.C. (2003) Sensitivity analyzes for ecological regression. Biometrics, 59, 9-17.
72. Wakefield, J.C. (2004) Ecological inference for 2 × 2 tables (with discussion). To appear in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A.
73. Wakefield, I.C., Best, N.G., and Waller, L.A. (2000) Bayesian approaches to disease mapping. Spatial Epidemiology: Methods and Applications, P. Elliott, J.C. Wakefield, N.G. Best, and D. Briggs (eds), Oxford University Press, pp. 104-27.
74. Wakefield, J.C. and Morris, S.E. (1999) Spatial dependence and errors-in-variables in environmental epidemiology. In Bayesian Statistics, 6. J.M. Bernardo, J.O. Berger, A.P. Dawid, and A.F.M. Smith (eds), Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 657-84.
75. Wakefield, J.C. and Morris, S.E. (2001) The Bayesian modeling of disease risk in relation to a point source. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 96, 77-91.
76. Wakefield, J.C. and Salway, R. (2001) A statistical framework for ecological and aggregate studies. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A, 164, 119-37.
77. White, J.E. (1982) A two stage design for the study of the relationship between a rare exposure and a rare disease. American Journal of Epidemiology, 115, 119-28.
78. Whitley, E. and Darby, S.C. (1999) Quantifying the risks from residential radon. In Statistics for the Environment 4: Statistical Aspects of Health and the Environment, V. Barnett, A. Stein, and K.F. Turkman (eds), John Wiley and Sons, Chichester, pp. 71-89.
79. Wilkinson, P., Thakrar, B., Shaddick, G., Stevenson, S., Pattenden, S., Landon, M., Grundy, C., and Elliott, P. (1997) Cancer incidence around the Pan Britannica industries pesticide factory, Waltham Abbey. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 54, 101-7.
80. Wilkinson, P., Thakrar, B., Walls, P., Landon, M., Falconer, S., Grundy, C., and Elliott, P. (1999) Lymphohaematopoietic malignancy around all industrial complexes that include major oil refineries in Great Britain. Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 56, 577-80.
81. Williams, D.R. and Collins, C. (1995) US socioeconomic and racial differences in health: patterns and explanations. Annual Review of Sociology, 21, 349-86.
82. Winn, D.M., Blot, W.J., Shy, C.M., Pickle, L.W., Toledo, A., and Fraumeni, J.F. (1981) Snuff dipping and oral cancer among women in the southern United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 304, 745-9.
83. Wolpert, R.L. and Ickstadt, K. (1998) Poisson/gamma random field models for spatial statistics. Biometrika, 85, 251-67.
84. Yasui, Y., Potter, J.D., Stanford, J.L., Rossing, M.A., Winget, M.D., Bronner, M., and Daling, J. (2001) Breast cancer risk and "delayed" primary Epstein-Barr virus infection. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, 10, 9-16.