Neutrino masses: Shedding light on unification and our origin

Nuclear Physics B - Proceedings Supplements

Volumn 137, Issue 1-3 SPEC. ISS., 2004, Pages 127-155

  Pati, Jogesh C ^a  

^a Bldg 142   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 10944226608     PISSN: 09205632     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2004.10.057     Document Type: Article

References (178)

1. Y. Fukuda et al. Super-Kamiokande Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 1998 1562, hep-ex/9807003
2. K. Nishikawa (K2K) Talk at Neutrino 2002, Munich, Germany
3. Q.R. Ahmad et al. SNO Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 2002 011301
4. B.T. Cleveland et al. Homestake Astrophys. J. 496 1998 505
5. W. Hampel et al. GALLEX Phys. Lett. B447 1999 127
6. J.N. Abdurashitov et al. SAGE astro-ph/0204245 2000
7. M. Altmann et al. GNO Phys. Lett. B490 2000 16
8. S. Fukuda et al. SuperKamiokande Phys. Lett. B539 2002 179
9. e's produced in earth-based reactors is established by the KamLAND data: K. Eguchi et al. hep-ex/0212021
10. For a recent review including analysis of several authors see, for example S. Pakvasa J.W.F. Valle hep-ph/0301061
11. For a historical overview of theoretical calculations of expected solar neutrino flux, see J. Bahcall astro-ph/0209080
12. J.C. Pati Abdus Salam Phys. Rev. D8 1973 1240
13. J.C. Pati Abdus Salam Phys. Rev. Lett. 31 1973 661
14. J.C. Pati Abdus Salam Phys. Rev. D10, 275 (1974)
15. H. Georgi edited by C. Carlson Particles and Fields 1975 AIP NY 575
16. H. Fritzsch P. Minkowski Ann. Phys. 93 1975 193
17. M. Gell-Mann P. Ramond R. Slansky eds. F. van Nieuwenhuizen D. Freedman in: Supergravity 1979 North Holland Amsterdam 315
18. T. Yanagida eds. O. Sawada A. Sugamoto in: Workshop on the Unified Theory and Baryon Number in the Universe 1979 KEK Tsukuba 95
19. S.L. Glashow eds. M. Levy et al. Quarks and Leptons, Cargése 1979 1980 Plenum 707
20. R.N. Mohapatra G. Senjanovic Phys. Rev. Lett. 44 1980 912
21. M. Fukugita T. Yanagida Phys. Lett. B174 1986 45
22. M.A. Luty Phys. Rev. D45 1992 455
23. W. Buchmuller M. Plumacher hep-ph/9608308
24. V. Kuzmin V. Rubakov M. Shaposhnikov Phys. Lett. BM155 1985 36
25. S. Dimopoulos S. Raby F. Wilczek Phys. Rev. D24 1981 1681
26. W. Marciano G. Senjanovic Phys. Rev. D25 1982 3092
27. M. Einhorn D.R.T. Jones Nucl. Phys. B196 1982 475
28. For work in recent years, see P. Langacker M. Luo Phys. Rev. D44 1991 817
29. U. Amaldi W. de Boer H. Furtenau Phys. Rev. Lett. B260 1991 131
30. F. Anselmo L. Cifarelli A. Peterman A. Zichichi Nuov. Cim. A104 1991 1817
31. H. Georgi S.L. Glashow Phys. Rev. Lett. 32 1974 438
32. H. Georgi H. Quinn S. Weinberg Phys. Rev. Lett. 33 1974 451
33. Y.A. Golfand E.S. Likhtman JETP Lett. 13 1971 323
34. J. Wess B. Zumino Nucl. Phys. B70 1974 139
35. D. Volkov V.P. Akulov JETP Lett. 16 1972 438
36. C. N. Yang, "Necessary Subtlety and Unnecessary Subtlety", Proceedings of the Int'l Conference on "Neutrinos and Implications for Physics Beyond the Standard Model", Ed. by R. Shrock, Publ. By World Scientific, pp5 (October 11, 2002). In this talk, Yang states: "Personally I tend to disbelieve unnecessary subtleties. That is perhaps why Dyson called me conservative. I did not believe in neutrino oscillations, even after Davis' painstaking work and Bahcall's careful analysis: The oscillations were, I believed, uncalled for. Now, after the beautiful experiments which we shall hear about in the next few days, I have to surrender and accept neutrino oscillations, as reality, but still as unnecessary subtleties";. Relative to Yang's remark it seems appropriate to mention that neutrino oscillations (and thus neutrino masses) now appear to be a very necessary subtlety of nature in the sense that, (a) as discussed in Secs. 1-4, the tiny neutrino masses seem to be the nature's way to provide a clue to physics at the unification scale including the nature of the unification symmetry, and (b) as discussed in Sec. 6, they also seem to be at the root of the origin of matter-antimatter asymmetry, and thus at the root of our own origin
37. A. Salam Nuovo cim. 5 1957 299
38. L.D. Landau Nucl. Phys. 3 1957 127
39. T.D. Lee C.N. Yang Phys. Rev. 105 1957 1671
40. S. Weinberg Phys. Rev. Lett. 19 1967 1264
41. A. Salam Ed. by N. Svartholm Proceedings of the 8th Nobel Symposium 1968 Almquist and Wiksell Stockholm 367
42. S.L. Glashow Nucl. Phys. 22 1961 579
43. S. Weinberg Phys. Rev. Lett. 43 1979 1566
44. E. Akhmedov Z. Berezhiani G. Senjanovic Phys. Rev. D47 1993 3245
45. J. C. Pati, "Implications of the Su- perKamiokande Result on the Nature of New Physics", Proceedings of the Neutrino-98 Conference, held at Takayama, Japan (June 4-9, 1998), Published in Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 77, 299 (1999)
46. J.C. Pati Abdus Salam Phys. Rev. D10 1974 275
47. R.N. Mohapatra J.C. Pati Phys. Rev. D11 1975 566
48. G. Senjanovic R.N. Mohapatra Phys. Rev. D12 1975 1502
49. D. Chang R.N. Mohapatra M.K. Parida Phys. Rev. Lett. 52 1984 1072
50. F. Gursey P. Ramond P. Sikivie Phys. Lett. B60 1976 177
51. M. Green J.H. Schwarz Phys. Lett. 149B 1984 117
52. D.J. Gross J.A. Harvey E. Martinec R. Rohm Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 1985 502
53. P. Candelas G.T. Horowitz A. Strominger E. Witten Nucl. Phys. B258 1985 46
54. For introductions and reviews, see: M. B. Green, J. H. Schwarz and E. Witten, "Superstring Theory" Vols. 1 and 2 (Cambridge University Press)
55. J. Polchinski, "String Theory" vols.1 and 2 (Cambridge University Press)
56. P. Ginsparg Phys. Lett. B197 1987 139
57. V.S. Kaplunovsky Nucl. Phys. B307 1988 145
58. V.S. Kaplunovsky Erratum: Ibid. B382 1992 436
59. For a recent discussion, see K. Dienes Phys. Rep. 287 1997 447 hep-th/9602045 and references therein
60. J.C. Pati "With Neutrino Masses Revealed, Proton Decay is the Missing Link" hep-ph/9811442
61. Pati J.C. Proc. Salam Memorial Meeting 1998 World Scientific Int'l Journal of Modern Physics A 14 1999 2949
62. I. Antoniadis G. Leontaris J. Rizos Phys. Lett. B245 1990 161
63. E. Witten Nucl. Phys. B 471 1996 135
64. 3: A Solution with Light Vector-Like Matter" hep-ph/9606215 Phys. Lett. B 384 1996 140
65. S. Dimopoulos and F. Wilczek, report No NSF-ITP-82-07 (1981), in The Unity of Fun- damental Interactions, Proc. Erice School (1981), Plenum Press (Ed. A. Zichichi)
66. K.S. Babu S.M. Barr Phys. Rev. D48 1993 5354
67. P. Candelas G.T. Horowitz A. Strominger E. Witten Nucl. Phys. B258 1985 46
68. E. Witten Nucl. Phys. B258 1985 75
69. A. Faraggi Phys. Lett. B278 1992 131
70. Faraggi A. Nucl. Phys. B403, 101 (1993)
71. A. Faraggi E. Halyo Nucl. Phys. B416 1994 63
72. K.S. Babu J.C. Pati F. Wilczek "Fermion Masses, Neutrino Oscillations and Proton Decay in the Light of the SuperKamiokande" hep-ph/981538V3; Nucl. Phys. B (to appear)
73. A. Faraggi J.C. Pati "A Family Universal Anomalous U(1) in String Models as the Origin of Supersymmetry Breaking and Squark-degeneracy" hep-ph/9712516v3 Nucl. Phys. B256 1998 526
74. K.S. Babu and J.C. Pati, "A Resolution of Supersymmetric Flavor-changing CP Problems Through String Flavor symmetries" UMD-PP0067, to appear
75. J.C. Pati "The Essential Role of String Derived Symmetries in Ensuring Proton Stability and Light Neutrino Masses" hep-ph/9607446 Phys. Lett. B388 1996 532
76. Promising string-theory solutions yielding the G(224)-symmetry in 4D have been obtained using different approaches, by a number of authors. They include: I. Antoniadis G. Leontaris J. Rizos Phys. Lett. B245 1990 161
77. G.K. Leontaris Phys. Lett. B372 1996 212 hep-ph/9601337
78. A. Murayama T. Toon Phys. Lett. B318 1993 298
79. Z. Kakushadze Phys. Rev. D58 1998 101901
80. G. Aldazabal L.I. Ibanez F. Quevedo hep-th/9909172
81. C. Kokorelis hep-th/0203187; hep-th/0209202
82. M. Cvetic G. Shiu A.M. Uranga Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 2001 201801 hep-th/0107143, and Nucl. Phys. B615, 3 (2001), hep-th/0107166
83. M. Cvetic I. Papadimitriou hep-th/0303197
84. R. Blumenhagen L. Gorlich T. Ott hep-th/0211059
85. For a type I string-motivated scenario leading to the G(224) symmetry in 4D, see L.I. Everett G.L. Kane S.F. King S. Rigolin L.T. Wang hep-th/0202100
86. A promising class of four dimensional three-family G(224)-string models has recently been obtained by T. Kobayashi S. Raby R.J. Zhang hep-ph/0409098
87. Another class of solutions leading to the G(224)-symmetry from Type II-A orientifolds with interesting D6-branes is obtained in M. Cvetic T. Li T. Liu hep-th/0403061
88. For alternative attempts based on flux compactification of Type II-B string theory leading to the G(224)-symmetry, see F. Marchesano G. Shiu hep-th/0409132
89. Recently there also have been several attempts based on compactifications of five and six-dimensional GUT-theories which lead to the G(224) symmetry in 4D with certain very desirable features. See e.g. R. Dermisek A. Mafi Phys. Rev. D65 2002 055002 [hep-ph/0108139]
90. Q. Shafi Z. Tavartkiladze hep-ph/0108247; hep-ph/0303150
91. C.H. Albright S.M. Barr hep-ph/0209173
92. H.D. Kim S. Raby hep-ph/0212348
93. I. Gogoladze Y. Mimura S. Nandi hep-ph/0302176
94. B. Kyae Q. Shafi hep-ph/0211059
95. H. Baer et al. hep-ph/0204108
96. Y. Nomura D. Tucker-Smith hep-ph/0403171
97. For a global phenomenological analysis of a realistic stringinspired supersymmetric model based on the G(224) symmetry see T. Blazek S.F. King J.K. Perry (hep-ph/0303192) and also references therein
98. J.C. Pati "Confronting The Conventional ideas on Grand Unification With Fermion Masses, Neutrino Oscillations and Proton Decay" hep-ph/0204240
99. J.C. Pati Proceedings of the ICTP, Trieste School 2001 and Proceedings of the DAE Meeting, Allahabad, India (2002)
100. See e.g. K.R. Dienes J. March-Russell hep-th/9604112
101. K.R. Dienes hep-ph/9606467
102. These have been introduced in various forms in the literature. For a sample, see e.g. C.D. Frogatt H.B. Nielsen Nucl. Phys. B147 1979 277
103. L. Hall H. Murayama Phys. Rev. Lett. 75 1995 3985
104. P. Binetruy S. Lavignac P. Ramond Nucl. Phys. B477 1996 353
105. In the string theory context, see e.g. A. Faraggi Phys. Lett. B278 1992 131
106. C. Albright S. Barr Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 2000 244
107. H - together with a singlet S, and write a superpotential analogous to Eq. (9)
108. H〉/M′ ∼ 1, rather than 1/10
109. d. This turns out to be the origin of non-trivial CKM mixings (See Ref. [29])
110. H) would get determined depending upon whether p(q) is one or zero (see below)
111. string
112. F. Gursey P. Ramond R. Slansky Phys. Lett. B60 1976 177
113. Y. Achiman B. Stech Phys. Lett. B77 1978 389
114. Q. Shafi Phys. Lett. B79 1978 301
115. A. deRujula H. Georgi S.L. Glashow edited by K. Kang 5th Workshop on Grand Unification 1984 World Scientific p88
116. J.C. Pati A. Salam Phys. Rev. D10 1974 275
117. R.N. Mohapatra J.C. Pati Phys. Rev. D11 1975 566
118. S.M. Barr Phys. Lett. B112 1982 219
119. J.P. Derendinger J.E. Kim D.V. Nanopoulos Phys. Lett. B139 1984 170
120. I. Antoniadis J. Ellis J. Hagelin D.V. Nanopoulos Phys. Lett. B194 1987 231
121. J.C. Pati "Probing Grand Unification Through Neutrino Oscillations, Leptogenesis and Proton Decay" hep-ph/0305221 Procedings Erice School, Sept. 2002, Ed. by A. Zichichi (Publ. World Scientific), p. 194-236
122. osc ≈ 0.92 - 0.99 emerge as predictions of the model [29]
123. 12 by flavor symmetry
124. 3
125. See e.g. P. Vogel Review of Particle Physics Phys. Rev. D66 2002 010001for a review of current status and a discussion of the Heidelberg-Moscow collaboration data which suggest a possible signal at the level of 2.2-3.15σ
126. K. S. Babu, J. C. Pati and Parul Rastogi, "A Unified Picture of Fermion Masses, Neutrino Oscillations, CP and Flavor violations Within SUSY Grand Unification-I" to appear
127. K. S. Babu, J. C. Pati and Parul Rastogi, "A Unified Picture of Fermion Masses, Neutrino Oscillations, CP and Flavor violations Within SUSY Grand Unification-II" to appear
128. H 〉 in turn would induce phases (other than "0" and π) in some of the other VEV's as well, and may itself become complex rather than pure imaginary
129. See e.g. S. Raby hep-ph/0401155 for an overview & references on some of these models
130. See e.g. R. Barbieri L.J. Hall A. Strumia Nucl. Phys. B445 1995 219 hep-ph/9501334
131. K. S. Babu and J. C. Pati. "Link Between Neutrino Oscillations and CP Violation within Supersymmetric Unification". In G. Branco, Q. Shafi, and J. I. Silva-Marcos, editors, Recent Developments in Particle Physics and Cosmology. NATO Advanced Study Institute, June 6-July 7, 2000. Abstract only (paper to appear)
132. D. Chang A. Masiero H. Murayama Phys. Rev. D67 2003 075013 hep-ph/0205111
133. See e.g. M. Ciuccini et al. Talk at "Workshop on the CKM Unitarity Triangle", Durham, April 2003 hep-ph/0307195
134. See e.g. A. Soni Talk at PACOS, 2003 Conference, Mumbai (India) hep-ph/0307107
135. S) hep-ex/0403026
136. S) hep-ex/0403026
137. H.S. Goh R.N. Mohapatra Siew-Pang NG hep-ph/0308197
138. For a recent analysis and relevant references see e.g. J. Ellis K. Olive Y. Santoso V. Spanos hep-ph/0310356
139. F. Borzumati A. Masiero Phys. Rev. Lett. 57 1986 961
140. G.K. Leontaris K. Tamavakis J.D. Verdagos Phys. Lett. B171 1986 412
141. J. Hisano T. Moroi K. Tobe M. Yamaguchi T. Yanagida Phys. Lett. B357 1995 579
142. J. Hisano D. Nomura Phys. Rev. D59 1999 116005
143. For a list of references including recent works, see e.g. A. Masiero S. Vempati O. Vives hep-ph/0405017 (Talk by A. Masiero at the Fujihara Conference (Feb, 2004)) http://www.elsevier.com/xml/linking-roles/ preprint
144. See e.g. A. Campbell S. Davidson J. Ellis K. Olive Phys. Lett. B256 1991 457
145. See e.g. A. Brandenberg F. Steffen hep-ph/0406021
146. For a discussion of this issue with very low reheat temperature, see L. Covi hep-ph/0402240
147. M.L. Brooks et al. MEGA collaboration Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 1999 1521 hep-ex/9905013
148. K. Abe et al. BELLE Collaboration hep-ex/0310029
149. P. Harris et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 1999 94
150. E.D. Commins et al. Phys. Rev. A50 1994 2960
151. J.C. Pati Leptogenesis and Neutrino Oscillations Within a Predictive G(224)/SO(10)-framework Phys. Rev. D68 2003 072002 hep-ph/0209160
152. W. Buchmuler P. Di Bari M. Plumacher hep-ph/0401240
153. G.F. Giudice A. Notart M. Raidal A. Riotto A. Strumia hep-ph/0310123
154. WMAP Collaboration D.N. Spergel et al. Astrophys. J. Suppl. 148 2003 175 astro-ph/0310723
155. See R. Jannerot S. Khalil G. Lazarides Q. Shafi JHEO 010 2000 012 hep-ph/0002151 and references there in
156. M. Kawasaki K. Kohri T. Moroi astro-ph/0402990
157. N. Sakai T. Yanagida Nucl. Phys. B197 1982 533
158. S. Weinberg Phys. Rev. D26 1982 287
159. S. Dimopoulos S. Raby F. Wilczek Phys. Lett. B112 1982 133
160. J. Ellis D.V. Nanopoulos S. Rudaz Nucl. Phys. B202 1982 43
161. P. Nath A.H. Chemseddine R. Arnowitt Phys. Rev. D32 1985 2348
162. P. Nath R. Arnowitt hep-ph/9708469
163. J. Hisano H. Murayama T. Yanagida Nucl. Phys. B402 1993 46
164. 0-mode, see J. Hisano hep-ph/0004266
165. K.S. Babu S.M. Barr Phys. Rev. D50 1994 3529
166. V. Lucas S. Raby Phys. Rev. D55 1997 6986
167. R. Darmisek A. Mafi S. Raby hep-ph/0007213 V2
168. H. Murayama A. Pierce hep-ph/0108104
169. K.S. Babu J.C. Pati F. Wilczek "Suggested New Modes in Supersymmetric Proton Decay" Phys. Lett. B423 1998 337
170. K. Turznyski hep-ph/0110282 V2
171. S. Aoki et al. JLQCD collaboration hep-latt/9911026 Phys. Rev. D62 2000 014506
172. N. Tsutsui et al. CP-PACS and JLQCD Collaboration hep-lat/0402026
173. SuperK Collaboration: Y. Hayato, Proc. ICHEP, Vancouver (1998)
174. M. Earl, NNN2000 Workshop, Irvine, Calif (Feb, 2000)
175. Y. Totsuka (private comm. May, 2001)
176. M. Vagins, Report on SuperK Results presented at WHEPP-7 meeting, Allahabad, India (January 6, 2002)
177. B. Bajac P. Fileviez Perez G. Senjanovic hep-ph/0204311 and hep-ph/0210374
178. D. Emmanuel-Costa S. Wiesenfeldt hep-ph/0302272