What do unions do to productivity? A meta-analysis

Industrial Relations

Volumn 42, Issue 4, 2003, Pages 650-691

  Doucouliagos, Christos ^a   Laroche, Patricia ^b  

^a DEAKIN UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITÉ DE LORRAINE   (France)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE; INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON; LABOR RELATIONS; META-ANALYSIS; PRODUCTIVITY; TRADE UNION;

UNITED KINGDOM; UNITED STATES;

EID: 0242381265     PISSN: 00198676     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1468-232X.00310     Document Type: Article

References (141)

1. Addison, John T. 1982. "Are Unions Good for Productivity?" Journal of Labor Research 3(Spring):125-38.
2. Addison, John T. 1983. "The Evolving Debate on Unions and Productivity." Journal of Industrial Relations 25:286-300.
3. Addison, John T. 1985. "What Do Unions Really Do? A Review Article." Journal of Labor Research 6(Spring):127-46.
4. Addison, John T. and A. Barnett. 1982. "The Impact of Unions on Productivity." British Journal of Industrial Relations 20(July): 145 62.
5. Addison, John T. and Barry Hirsch. 1989. "Union Effects on Productivity, Profits, and Growth: Has the Long Run Arrived?" Journal of Labor Economics 7(January):72-105.
6. Allen, Steven G. 1984. "Unionized Construction Workers are More Productive." Quarterly Journal of Economics 99(May):251-74.
7. Allen, Steven G. 1985. "Why Construction Industry Productivity Is Declining." Review of Economics and Statistics 67(November):661 9.
8. Allen, Steven G. 1986a. "The Effect of Unionism on Productivity in Privately and Publicly Owned Hospitals and Nursing Homes." Journal of Labor Research 7(Winter):59-68.
9. Allen, Steven G. 1986b. "Unionization and Productivity in Office Building and School Construction." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 39(January):187 201.
10. Allen, Steven G. 1988a. "Declining Unionization in Construction: The Facts and the Reasons." Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 41(April):343-59.
11. Allen, Steven G. 1988b. "Further Evidence on Union Efficiency in Construction." Industrial Relations 27(Spring):232-40.
12. Argys, Laura, and Rees D. 1995. "Unionization and School Productivity: A Reexamination." Research in Labor Economics 14:49-68.
13. Arthur, Jeffrey B. 1994, "Effects of Human Resource Systems on Manufacturing Performance and Turnover." Academy of Management Journal 37(June):670-87.
14. Baldwin, John. 1992. "Industrial Efficiency and Plant Turnover in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector." In Industrial Efficiency in Six Nations, edited Richard E. Caves, pp. 273-310. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
15. Bairam, Erkin. 1994. Homogenous and Nonhomogenous Production Functions. Aldershot: Avebury.
16. Bartel, Ann P. 1994. "Productivity Gains from the Implementation of Employee Training Programs" Industrial Relations 33(October):411-25.
17. Batt, Rosemary. 1999. "Work Organisation, Technology, and Performance in Customer Service and Sales." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 52(July):539-64.
18. Belman, Dale. 1992. "Unions, Quality of Labor Relations, and Firm Performance." In Unions and American Economic Competitiveness, edited by Lawrence Mishel and Paula B. Voos, pp. 41-107. New York: Economic Policy Institute and M. E. Sharpe.
19. Bemmels, Brian. 1987. "How Unions Affect Productivity in Manufacturing Plants." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 40(January):241-53.
20. Black, Sandra E., and Lisa M. Lynch. 2001. "How to Compete: The Impact of Workplace Practices and Information Technology on Productivity" Review of Economics and Statistics 83(August): 434-45.
21. Boal, William M. 1990. "Unionism and Productivity in West Virginia Coal Mining." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 43(April):390-405.
22. Booth, Alison. 1995. The Economics of the Trade Union. New York: Cambridge University Press.
23. Bronars, Stephen G., and Donald R. Deere. 1990. "Union Representation Elections and Firm Profitability." Industrial Relations 29(Winter):15 37.
24. Bronars, Stephen G., and Donald R. Deere. 1994. "Unionization and Profitability: Evidence of Spillover Effects." Journal of Political Economy 102(December):15-37.
25. Bronars, Stepehn G., Donald R. Deere, and Joseph S. Tracy. 1994. "The Effect of Unions on Firm Behavior: An Empirical Analysis Using Firm-Level Data." Industrial Relations 33(October):426 51.
26. Brown, Charles, and James L. Medoff. 1978. "Trade Unions in the Production Process." Journal of Political Economy 86(June ):355-78.
27. Brunello, Giorgio. 1992. "The Effect of Unions on Firm Performance in Japanese Manufacturing." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 45(April):471-87.
28. Bycio, Peter. 1992. "Job Performance and Absenteeism: A Review and Meta-Analysis." Human Relations 45(February):193 220.
29. Byrne, Dennis, Hashem Dezhbakhsh, and Randall King. 1996. "Unions and Police Productivity: An Econometric Investigation." Industrial Relations 35(October):566-84.
30. Byrnes, Patricia, and Rolf Fare. 1987. "Surface Mining of Coal: Efficiency of U.S. Interior Mines." Applied Economics 19(December):1665-73.
31. " Management Science 34(September):1037-53.
32. Card, David. and Alan B. Krueger. 1995. "Time-Series Minimum-Wage Studies: A Meta-Analysis." American Economic Review 85(May):238-43.
33. Cavalluzzo, Linda, and Dennis Baldwin. 1993. "Unionization and Productive Efficiency." In The Measurement of Productive Efficiency, edited by Harold Fried, C. A. Knox Lovell, and Shelton Schmidt, pp. 210-20. New York: Oxford University Press.
34. Caves, Richard E. 1980. "Productivity Differences among Industries." In Britain's Economic Performance, edited by Richard E. Caves and Lawrence B. Krause, pp. 135-99. Washington: Brookings Institution.
35. Caves, Richard E. and David R. Barton. 1990. Efficiency in U.S. Manufacturing Industries. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
36. Chezum, Brian, and John E. Garen. 1998. "Are Union Productivity Effects Overestimated? Evidence from Coal Mining." Applied Economics 30(July):913-8.
37. Clark, Kim. 1980a. "The Impact of Unionization on Productivity: A Case Study." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 33(July):451 69.
38. Clark, Kim. 1980b, "Unionization and Productivity: Microeconomic Evidence." Quarterly Journal of Economics 45(December :613 40.
39. Clark, Kim. 1984. "Unionization and Firm Performance: The Impact on Profits, Growth and Productivity." American Economic Review 74(December):893 919.
40. Coelli, Tim, D. S. Prasada Rao, and George E. Battese. 1998. An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis. Boston: Kluwer.
41. Connolly, Robert A., Barry T. Hirsch, and Mark Hirschey. 1986. "Union Rent Seeking, Intangible Capital and Market Value of the Firm." Review of Economics and Statistics 68(November):567-77.
42. Conte, Michael A., and Jan Svejnar. 1988. "Productivity Effects of Worker Participation in Management, Profit-Sharing, Worker Ownership of Assets and Unionization in U.S. Firms." International Journal of Industrial Organization 6(March):139-51.
43. Conte, Michael A., and Jan Svejnar. 1990. "The Effects of Worker Participation in Management, Profits, and Ownership of Assets on Enterprise Performance." In New Developments in the Labor Market, edited by K. Abraham and R. B. McKersie. pp. 59-84. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
44. Canyon, Martin J., and Richard B. Freeman. 2002. "Shared Modes of Compensation and Firm Performance: U.K. Evidence." In Seeking a Premiere League Economy, edited by R. Blundell, D. Card, and R. Freeman. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
45. Cook, Thomas D., Harris Cooper, David S. Cordray, Heidi Hartmann, Larry V. Hedges, Richard J. Light, Thomas A. Louis, and Frederick Mosteller. 1992. Meta-Analysis for Explanation: A Casebook. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
46. Cooke, William N. 1994. "Employee Participation Programs, Group-Based Incentives, and Company Performance: A Union-Nonunion Comparison." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 47(July):594 609.
47. Coutrol, Thomas. 1996. "Relations Sociales et Performance Economique: Une Premiere Analyse du Cas Français." Travail et Emploi 66:39-66.
48. Craig, Ben, and John Pencavel. 1995. "Participation and Productivity: A Comparison of Worker Cooperatives and Conventional Firms in the Plywood Industry." Brookings Papers in Microeconomics, pp. 121-60.
49. Dalton, Dan R., Catherine M. Daily, Jonathan L. Johnson, and Alan E. Ellstrand. 1999. "Number of Directors and Financial Performance: A Meta-Analysis." Academy of Management Journal 42(December):674-85.
50. Davies, Stephen, and Richard E. Caves. 1987. Britain's Productivity Gap. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
51. Dickerson, A. P., P. A. Geroski, and K. G. Knight. 1997. "Productivity, Efficiency and Strike Activity." International Review of Applied Economics 11(January):l19-34.
52. Doucouliagos, Chris. 1995. "Worker Participation and Productivity in Labor-Managed and Participatory Capitalist Firms: A Meta-Analysis." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 49(October ):58-77.
53. Dworkin James B., and Dennis A. Ahlburg. 1985. "Unions and Productivity: A Review of the Research." Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations (A Research Annual Series) 2:51 68.
54. Eberts, Randall W. 1984. "Union Effects on Teacher Productivity" Industrial and Labor Relations Review 37(April):346 58.
55. Edwards, Linda N., and Elizabeth Field-Hendrey 1996. "Unions and Productivity in the Public Sector: The Case of Sanitation Workers." Research in Labor Economics 15:305 28.
56. Ehrenberg, Ronald G., Daniel R. Sherman, and Joshua L. Schwarz. 1983 "Unions and Productivity in the Public Sector: A Study of Municipal Libraries." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 36(January):199 213.
57. Ehrenberg, Ronald G., 1998. "Gasoline Demand Revisited: An International Meta-Analysis of Elasticities." Energy Economics 20(June):273 95.
58. Espey, Molly, J. Espey, and W. Douglass Shaw. 1997. "Price Elasticity of Residential Demand for Water: A Meta-Analysis." Water Resources Research 33:1369-74.
59. Fitzroy, Felix R., and Kornelius Kraft. 1987a. "Cooperation, Productivity and Profit Sharing." Quarterly Journal of Economics 102(February):23-35.
60. Fitzroy, Felix R., and Kornelius Kraft. 1987b. "Efficiency and Internal Organization: Works Council in West German firms." Economica 54(November):493-504.
61. Flaherty, Sean. 1987. "Strike Activity, Worker Militancy, and Productivity Change in Manufacturing, 1961 1981." Industrial and Labor Relations Rewiew 40(July):585 600.
62. Freeman, Richard B. 1976. "Individual Mobility and Union Voice in the Labor Market." American Economic Review 66(May):361 8.
63. Freeman, Richard B. 1988. "Union Density and Economic Performance: An Analysis of U.S. States." European Economic Review 32(March):707 16
64. Freeman, Richard B., and James L. Medoff. 1979. "The Two Faces of Unionism." Public Interest 57:69-93.
65. Freeman, Richard B., and James L. Medoff. 1984. What Do Unions Do? New York: Basic Books.
66. Fried, Harold O., C. A. Knox Lovell, and Shelton Schmidt, eds. 1993. The Measurement of Productive Efficiency New York: Oxford University Press.
67. Graddy, Duane B., and Gary Hall. 1985. "Unionization and Productivity in Commercial Banking." Journal of Labor Research 6(Summer):249-62.
68. Greene, W. H. 2000. Econometric Analysis, 4th ed. London: Prentice-Hall.
69. Grimes, Paul W., and Charles A. Register. 1991. "Teacher Unions and Black Student's Scores on College Entrance Exams." Industrial Relations 30(Fall):492-9.
70. Guthrie, James P. 2001. "High-Involvement Work Practices, Turnover, and Productivity: Evidence from New Zealand." Academy of Management Journal 44(February):180-90.
71. Guthrie, James P., C. S. Spell, and R. O. Nyamori. 2002. "Correlates and Consequences of High Involvement Work Practices: The Role of Competitive Strategy." International Journal of Human Resource Management 13(February):183-97.
72. Hedges, Larry V., and Ingram Olkin. 1985. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis London: Academic Press.
73. Hedges, Larry V., and J. L. Vevea. 1998. "Fixed- and Random-Effects Models in Meta-Analysis." Psychological Methods 3:486-504.
74. Hendry, David. 1995. Dynamic Econometrics. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
75. Hendry, David. 1991. Labor Unions and the Economic Performance of Firms. Kalamazoo, MI: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
76. Hendry, David. 1997. "Unionization and Economic Performance: Evidence on Productivity, Profits, Investment, and Growth." In Unions and Right-to-Work Laws, edited by F Mihlar, pp. 35-70. Vancouver, BC: Frazer Institute.
77. Hendry, David., and John T. Addison. 1986. The Economic Analysis of Unions: New Approaches and Evidence. London: Allen & Unwin.
78. Hendry, David., and Robert A. Connolly 1987. "Do Unions Capture Monopoly Profits?" Industrial and Labor Relations Review 41(October):118-35.
79. Hendry, David., and Albert N. Link. 1987. "Labor Union Effects on Innovative Activity." Journal of Labor Research 8(Fall):323-32.
80. Hirschman, Albert O. 1970. Exit, Voice and Loyalty. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
81. Holzer, Harry J. 1990. "The Determinants of Employee Productivity and Earnings." Industrial Relations 29(Fall):403-22.
82. Hunter, John E., and Frank L. Schmidt. 1990. Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
83. Hunter, John E., Frank L. Schmidt, and Gregg B. Jackson. 1982. Meta-Analysis: Cumulating Research Findings across Studies. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
84. Huselid, Mark A. 1995. "The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Turnover, Productivity, and Corporate Financial Performance." Academy of Management Journal 38(June):635-72.
85. Huselid, Mark A. and Giovanna Prennushi. 1997. "The Effects of HRM Practices on Productivity: A Study of Steel Finishing Lines." American Economic Review 87(June):291-313.
86. Kalirajan, K. P., and Ric T. Shand. 1994. Economics in Disequilibrium: An Approach from the Frontier. New Delhi Macmillan.
87. Katz Harry C., Thomas A. Kochan, and Kenneth R. Gobeille. 1983. "Industrial Relations Performance, Economic Performance and QWL Programs: An Inter-Plant Analysis." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 37(October):3-17.
88. Katz Harry C., Thomas A. Kochan, and Jeffrey H. Keefe. 1987. "Industrial Relations and Productivity in the U.S. Automobile Industry: Comment and Discussion." Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 3:685-727.
89. Kaufman, Robert S., and Kaufman Roger T. 1987. "Unions Effects on Productivity, Personnel Practices and Survival in the Automative Parts Industry." Journal of Labor Research 8(Fall ):333-50.
90. Kleiner, Morris M., and Daniel L. Petree. 1988. "Unionism and Licensing of Public School Teachers: Impact on Wages and Educational Output." In When Public Sector Workers Unionize, edited by R. Freeman and C. Ichniowski. Chicago: National Bureau of Economic Research.
91. Kleiner, Morris M., and Chang-Ruey Ay. 1996. "Unionization, Employee Representation, and Economic Performance: Comparisons among OECD Nations." Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations 7:97-121.
92. Kleiner, Morris M., and Myon Lee Young. 1997. "Works Councils and Unionization: Lessons from South Korea." Industrial Relations 36(January):1-16.
93. Koch, Marianne J., and Rita G. McGrath. 1996. "Improving Labor Productivity: Human Resource Management Policies Do Matter." Strategic Management Journal 17(May):335-54.
94. Kuhn, Peter. 1985. "Union Productivity Effects and Economic Efficiency." Journal of Labor Research 6(Summer):229-47.
95. Kuhn, Peter. 1998. "Unions and the Economy: What We Know; What We Should Know." Canadian Journal of Economics 31(November):1033-56.
96. Kurth, Michael M. 1987. "Teacher's Unions and Excellence in Education: An Analysis of the Decline in SAT Scores." Journal of Labor Research 8(Fall):351-67.
97. Laband, David N., and Michael J. Piette. 1994. "The Relative Impacts of Economics Journals: 1970-1990." Journal of Economic Literature 32(June):640-66.
98. Laporta, P., and A. Jenkins. 1996. "Unionization and Profitability in the Canadian Sector." Relations Industrielles 51(4):756-77.
99. Lee, Michael B., and Yinsog Rhee. 1996. "Bonuses, Unions, and Labor Productivity in South Korea." Journal of Labor Research 17(Spring):219-38.
100. Leibenstein, Harvey. 1966. "Allocative Efficiency vs X-efficiency." American Economic Review 56(3):392-415.
101. Lewis, Harold G. 1963. Unionism and Relative Wages in the United States: An Empirical Inquiry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
102. Lovell, C. A. Knox, Robin C. Sickles, and Ronald S. Warren. 1988. "The Effects of Unionization on Labor Productivity: Some Additional Evidence." Journal of Labor Research 9(Winter):55-63.
103. Machin, Stephen J. 1991. "The Productivity Effects of Unionization and Firm Size in British Engineering Firms." Economica 58(November):479-90.
104. Machin, Stephen J., and Mark Stewart. 1990. "Unions and the Financial Performance of British Private Sector Establishments." Journal of Applied Econometrics 5(October):327-50.
105. Machin, Stephen J., and Mark Stewart. 1996. "Trade Unions and Financial Performance." Oxford Economic Papers 48(April):213-41.
106. McKersie, Robert B., and J. A. Klein. 1983. "Productivity: The Industrial Relations Connection." National Productivity Review 3(1):26 35.
107. Maki, Dennis R. 1983. "Trade Unions and Productivity: Conventional Estimates." Relations industrielles 38(2):211-29.
108. Mandelstamm, Allan. 1965. "The Effect of Unions on Efficiency in the Residential Construction Industry: A Case Study." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 18(4):503-20.
109. Meador, Mark, and Stephen Walters. 1994. "Unions and Productivity: Evidence from Academy." Journal of Labor Research 15(Fall):373-86.
110. Mefford, Robert. 1986. "The Effect of Unions on Productivity in a Multinational Manufacturing Firm." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 40(October):105-14.
111. Milkman, Martin. 1997. "Teacher's Unions, Productivity and Minority Student Achievement." Journal of Labor Research 18(Winter):137-50.
112. Miller, Katherine, and Peter R. Monge. 1986. "Participation, Satisfaction, and Productivity: A Meta-Analytic Review." Academy of Management Journal 29(December):727-53.
113. Mitchell, Merwin W., and Joe A. Stone. 1992. "Union Effects on Productivity: Evidence from Western U.S. Sawmills." Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46(October):135 45.
114. Mitchell, Daniel J. B., David Lewin, and Edward E. Lawler, III. 1990. "Alternative Pay Systems, Firm Performance and Productivity." In Paying for Productivity: A Look at the Evidence, edited by Alan S. Blinder, pp. 15 88. Washington: Brookings Institution.
115. Morishima, Motohiro. 1991. "Information Sharing and Firm Performance in Japan." Industrial Relations 30(Winter):37-61.
116. Muramatsu, Kuramitsu. 1984. "The Effect of Trade Unions on Productivity in Japanese Manufacturing Industries." In The Economic Analysis of the Japanese Firm, edited by Masahiko Aoki, pp. 103-23. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
117. Noam, Eli. 1983. "The Effect of Unionization and Civil Service on the Salaries and Productivity of Regulators." Research in Labor Economics: New Approaches to Labor Unions, Suppl. 2, pp. 157-70. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
118. Pencavel, John H. 1977. "Distributional and Efficiency Effects of Trade Unions in Britain." British Journal of Industrial Relations 15(July):137-56.
119. Petitti, Diana B. 2000. Meta-Analysis, Decision Analysis, and Cost-Effectiveness Analysis. New York: Oxford University Press.
120. Raudenbush, S. W. 1994. "Random-Effects Models." In The Handbook of Research Synthesis, edited by Harris Cooper and Larry V. Hedges, pp. 301-21. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
121. Rees, Albert. 1962. The Economics of Trade Unions. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
122. Rees, Albert. 1963. "The Effects of Unions on Resource Allocation." Journal of Law and Economics 6:69-78.
123. Register, Charles A. 1988. "Wages, Productivity, and Costs in Union and Nonunion Hospitals." Journal of Labor Research 9(Fall :325 45.
124. Register, Charles A. and Paul W. Grimes. 1991. "Collective Bargaining. Teachers, and Student Achievement." Journal of Labor Research 12(Spring):99 109.
125. Rosenberg, Michael S., Dean C. Adams, and Jessica Gurevitch. 2000. Meta Win: Statistical Software for Meta-Analysis, Version 2.0. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates.
126. Rosenthal, Robert. 1979. "The 'File Drawer Problem' and Tolerance for Null Results." Psychological Bulletin 86:638-41.
127. Rosenthal, Robert. 1984. Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
128. Schuster, Michael. 1983. "The Impact of Union-Management Cooperation on Productivity and Employment." Industrial and Labor Relation Review 36(April):415-30.
129. Slichter, S., J. Healy, and R. Livernash. 1960. The Impact of Collective Bargaining on Management. Washington: Brookings Institution.
130. Stanley, T. D. 2001. "Wheat from Chaff: Meta-Analysis as Quantitative Literature Review." Journal of Economic Perspectives 15(Summer):131-50.
131. Stanley, T. D., and Stephen B. Jarell. (1998). "Gender Wage Discrimination Bias? A Meta-Regression Analysis." Journal of Human Resources 33(Fall):947-73.
132. Tachibanaki, Toshiaki, and Noda Tomohiko. 2000. The Economic Effects of Trade Unions in Japan. London: Macmillan.
133. Thiam, Abdourahmane, Boris E. Bravo-Ureta, and Teodoro Rivas. 2001. "Technical Efficiency in Developing Country Agriculture: A Meta-Analysis." Agricultural Economics 25(September):235-43.
134. Torii, Akio. 1992. "Technical Efficiency in Japanese Industries." In Industrial Efficiency in Six Nations, edited by Richard E. Caves, pp. 31 120. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
135. Torii, Akio., and Richard E. Caves. 1992. "Technical Efficiency in Japanese and U.S. Manufacturing Industries." In Industrial Efficiency in Six Nations, edited by Richard E. Caves, pp. 423-57. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
136. Turnbull, Peter J. 1991. "Trade Unions and Productivity: Opening the Harvard "Black Boxes" Journal of Labor Research 12(Spring):135 50.
137. Warren, Ronald S. 1985. "The Effect of Unionization on Labor Productivity: Some Time-Series Evidence." Journal of Labor Research 6(Spring):199-207.
138. Wessels, Walter J. 1994. "Do Unionized Firms Hire Better Workers?" Economic Inquiry 32(October):616-29.
139. Wilson, Kenneth G. 1995. The Impact of Unions on United States Economy-wide Productivity. New York: Garland.
140. Wilson, Nicholas, and John R. Cable. 1991. "Unions, Wages and Productivity: Some Evidence from U.K. Engineering Firms." Applied Economics 23(January):219 26.
141. Wolf, Fredric M. 1986. Meta-Analysis: Quantitative Methods for Research Synthesis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.