Problem structuring methods in action

European Journal of Operational Research

Volumn 152, Issue 3, 2004, Pages 530-554

  Mingers, John ^a   Rosenhead, Jonathan ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK   (United Kingdom)

^b LONDON SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Multimethodology; OR applications; OR methodology; Problem structuring methods; Soft OR

Indexed keywords

PROBLEM SOLVING; UNCERTAIN SYSTEMS;

PROBLEM STRUCTURING METHODS (PSM);

OPERATIONS RESEARCH;

EID: 0141929590     PISSN: 03772217     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0377-2217(03)00056-0     Document Type: Review

References (138)

1. Abdel-Malek L., Wolf C., Johnson F., Spencer T. III OR practice: Survey results and reflections of practising INFORMS members. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 50:1999;994-1003.
2. Ackermann F. Participants' perceptions on the role of facilitators using group decision support systems. Group Decision and Negotiation. 5:1996;93-112.
3. Ackerman F., Eden C., Williams T. Modeling for litigation: Mixing qualitative and quantitative approaches. Interfaces. 27(2):1997;48-65.
4. Ackoff R. The future of operational research is past. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 30:1979;93-104.
5. Ackoff R. Creating the Corporate Future. 1981;Wiley, New York.
6. Bendeck M. Problem Structuring Methods for Development: A Conceptual Clarification, with an Application to Participative Health Services Planning in Mexico. 2001;Operational Research, London School of Economics, London.
7. Bennett P. Designing a Parliamentary briefing system - an OR look at the Commons. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 45(11):1994;1221-1232.
8. Bennett L.M., Kerr M.A. A systems approach to the implementation of total quality management. Total Quality Management. 7(6):1996;631-665.
9. Bennett J., Worthington D. An example of a good but partially successful OR engagement: Improving outpatient clinic operations. Interfaces. 28(5):1998;56-69.
10. Beynon H. Regulating research: Politics and decision making in industrial organisations. Bryman A. Doing Research in Organisations. 1988;21-33 Routledge, London.
11. Billman B., Courtney J.F. Automated discovery in managerial problem formulation - formation of causal hypotheses for cognitive mapping. Decision Sciences. 24(1):1993;23-41.
12. Blackett P. A Note on Certain Aspects of the Methodology of Operational Research. 1943;Admiralty, London.
13. Boardman J.T., Cole A.J. Integrated process improvement in design and manufacture using a systems approach. IEEE Proceedings - Control Theory and Applications. 143(2):1996;171-185.
14. Boden D. The Business of Talk. 1994;Polity Press, Oxford.
15. Bolton R., Gold J. Career management - matching the needs of individuals with the needs of organizations. Personnel Review. 23(1):1994;6-24.
16. Bowen K. In the Deep End: MSc Student Projects in Community Operational Research. 1995;Community Operational Research Unit, Northern College, Barnsley.
17. Brocklesby J. Using soft systems methodology to identify competence requirements in HRM. International Journal of Manpower. 16(5-6):1995;70.
18. Brocklesby J., Cummings S. Designing a viable organization structure. Long Range Planning. 29(1):1996;49-57.
19. Brown S.M. Cognitive mapping and repertory grids for qualitative survey research - some comparative observations. Journal of Management Studies. 29(3):1992;287-307.
20. Brown J.R., Macleod N.D. Integrating ecology into natural resource management policy. Environmental Management. 20(3):1996;289-296.
21. Bryson J., Anderson S. Applying large-group interaction methods in the planning and implementation of major change efforts. Public Administration Review. 60(2):2000;143-162.
22. Bunker B., Alban B. Large Group Interventions: Engaging the Whole System for Rapid Change. 1997;Jossey-Bass, San Francisco.
23. Calori R., Johnson G., Sarnin P. CEOs' cognitive maps and the scope of the organization. Strategic Management Journal. 15(6):1994;437-457.
24. Chambers R. Whose Reality Counts? Putting the Last First. 1997;Intermediate Technology Publications, London.
25. Checkland P. Systems Thinking, Systems Practice. 1981;Wiley, Chichester.
26. Checkland P. From optimizing to learning: A development of systems thinking for the 1990s. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 36(9):1985;757-768.
27. Checkland P. OR and social science: Fundamental thoughts. Operational Research and the Social Sciences. 1989;Plenum Press, Cambridge.
28. Checkland P., Scholes J. Soft Systems Methodology in Action. 1990;Wiley, Chichester.
29. Clark D., Scott J. Strategic level MS/OR tool usage in the UK: An empirical survey. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46:1995;1041-1051.
30. Connell N. Evaluating soft OR: Some reflections on an apparently unsuccessful implementation using a soft systems methodology (SSM) based approach. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 52:2001;150-160.
31. Coyle R.G., Alexander M.D.W. Two approaches to qualitative modeling of a nation's drugs trade. Systems Dynamics Review. 13(3):1997;205-222.
32. DeSanctis G., Gallupe R. A foundation for the study of group decision support systems. Management Science. 33(5):1987;589-609.
33. Dickover N. Reflection in action - modeling a specific organization through the viable systems model. Systems Practice. 7(1):1994;43-62.
34. Dyson R., O'Brien F. Strategic Development: Methods and Models. 1998;Wiley, Chichester.
35. Eden C. On evaluating the performance of 'wide-band' GDSS's. European Journal of Operational Research. 81:1995;302-311.
36. Eden C. On evaluating the performance of GSS: Furthering the debate, by Paul Finlay. A response from Colin Eden. European Journal of Operational Research. 120:2000;218-222.
37. Eden C., Ackerman F. Making Strategy: The Journey of Strategic Management. 1998;Sage, London.
38. Fielden D., Jacques J.K. Systemic approach to energy rationalisation in island communities. International Journal of Energy Research. 22(2):1998;107-129.
39. Fildes R., Ranyard J. Success and survival of operational research groups - a review. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 48:1997;336-360.
40. Fildes R., Ranyard J., Crymble W. The management of OR groups: Results of a survey. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 50:1999;563-580.
41. Finlay P. On evaluating the performance of GSS: Furthering the debate. European Journal of Operational Research. 107:1998;193-201.
42. Flood R., Jackson M. Creative Problem Solving. 1991;Wiley, London.
43. Flood R., Romm N. Diversity Management: Triple Loop Learning. 1996;Wiley, Chichester.
44. Franco L., Cushman M., Rosenhead J. Project review and learning in the construction industry: Embedding a problem structuring method within a partnership context. European Journal of Operational Research. 152(3):2004;586-601.
45. Friend J. The strategic choice approach. Rosenhead J., Mingers J. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited: Problem Structuring Methods for Complexity, Uncertainty and Conflict. 2001;115-150 Wiley, Chichester.
46. Gains A., Rosenhead J. Problem Structuring for Medical Quality Assurance. 1993;Department of OR, London School of Economics, London.
47. Gott R. In the Shadow of the Liberator: Hugo Chaves and the Transformation of Venezuela. 2000;Verso, London.
48. Gough J.D., Ward J.C. Environmental decision making and lake management. Journal of Environmental Management. 48(1):1996;1-15.
49. Gregory A.J., Jackson M.C. Evaluating organizations - a systems and contingency approach. Systems Practice. 5(1):1992;37-60.
50. Hammersley M., Atkinson P. Ethnography: Principles in Practice. 1995;Routledge, London.
51. Harnden R. The languaging of models: The understanding and communication of models with particular reference to Stafford Beer's cybernetic model of organization structure. Systems Practice. 3(3):1990;289-302.
52. Haynes M.G., McGregor A.G., Stewart N.D. The business team standard: A means of improving the effectiveness of individual businesses in a multibusiness corporation. Systems Practice. 10(3):1997;219-239.
53. Hindle T., Checkland P., Mumford M., Worthington D. Development of a methodology for multidisciplinary action research - a case-study. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46(4):1995;453-464.
54. Horlick-Jones T., Rosenhead J. Investigating risk, organisations and decision support through action research. Risk Management: An International Journal. 4(4):2002;45-63.
55. Horlick-Jones T., Rosenhead J., Georgiou I., Ravetz J., Lofstedt R. Decision support for organizational risk management by problem structuring. Health, Risk and Society. 3(2):2001;141-165.
56. Jackson M. Towards coherent pluralism in management science. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 50(1):1999;12-22.
57. Jackson M., Keys P. Towards a system of system methodologies. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 35(6):1984;473-486.
58. Jeffrey P., Seaton R. The use of operational research tools: A survey of operational research practitioners in the UK. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46:1995;797-808.
59. Kartowisastro H., Kijima K. An enriched soft systems methodology (SSM) and its application to cultural-conflict under a paternalistic value system. Systems Practice. 7(3):1994;241-253.
60. Kennedy B. Soft systems methodology in applying psychology. Australian Psychologist. 31(1):1996;52-59.
61. Khisty C.J. Soft systems methodology as learning and management tool. Journal of Urban Planning and Development. 121(3):1995;91-107.
62. Knowles J. A soft systems analysis of a CD-Rom network for a multisite polytechnic. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science. 25(1):1993;15-21.
63. Landry M., Malouin J.-L., Oral M. Model validation in operations research. European Journal of Operational Research. 14:1983;207-220.
64. Landry M., Banville C., Oral M. Model legitimisation in operational research. European Journal of Operational Research. 92:1996;443-457.
65. Lane D. Should system dynamics be described as a 'hard' or 'deterministic' systems approach? Systems Research and Behavioural Science. 17:2000;3-22.
66. Lartindrake J.M., Curran C.R. All together now - the circular organization in a university hospital. Systems Practice. 9(5):1996;391-401.
67. Ledington P. Intervention and the management process - an action-based research study. Systems Practice. 5(1):1992;17-36.
68. Ledington P., Donaldson J. Soft OR and management practice: A study of the adoption and use of soft systems methodology. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 48(3):1997;229-240.
69. Lee S., Courtney J.F., O'Keefe R.M. A system for organizational learning using cognitive maps. Omega. 20(1):1992;23-36.
70. Lehaney B., Hlupic V. Simulation modeling for resource allocation and planning in the health sector. Journal of the Royal Society of Health. 115(6):1995;382-385.
71. Lehaney B., Paul R.J. Using soft systems methodology to develop a simulation of outpatient services. Journal of the Royal Society of Health. 114(5):1994;248-251.
72. Lehaney B., Paul R.J. The use of soft systems methodology in the development of a simulation of outpatient services at Watford General Hospital. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 47(7):1996;864-870.
73. Macadam R., Vanasch R., Hedley B., Pitt E. A case study in development planning using a systems learning approach - generating a master plan for the livestock sector in Nepal. Agricultural Systems. 49(3):1995;299-323.
74. Maciaschapula C.A. Development of a soft systems model to identify information values, impact and barriers in a health-care information system. Journal of Information Science. 21(4):1995;283-288.
75. Magidson J. Systems practice in several communities in Philadelphia. Systems Practice. 5(5):1992;493-508.
76. Mason R., Mitroff I. Challenging Strategic Planning Assumptions. 1981;Wiley, New York.
77. Midgley, G., 1989. Critical systems: The theory and practice of partitioning methodologies. In: 33rd Annual Meeting of the ISSS, Edinburgh, Scotland.
78. Midgley G. Creative methodology design. Systemist. 12(3):1990;108-113.
79. Midgley G., Milne A. Creating employment opportunities for people with mental health problems - a feasibility study for new initiatives. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46(1):1995;35-42.
80. Mikkelsen B. Methods for Development Work and Research. 1995;Sage, New Delhi.
81. Millspacko P.A., Wilson K., Rotar P. Highlights from the use of the soft systems methodology to improve agrotechnology transfer in Kona, Hawaii. Agricultural Systems. 36(4):1991;409-425.
82. Mingers J. Recent developments in critical management science. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 43(1):1992;1-10.
83. Mingers J. What are real friends for? A reply to Mike Jackson. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 43(7):1992;732-735.
84. Mingers, J., 1994. "Multimethodology - a framework for mixing and matching methodologies", EURO XII/OR 36, Strathclyde University, Scotland.
85. Mingers J. Variety is the spice of life: Combining soft and hard OR/MS methods. International Transactions in Operational Research. 7:2000;673-691.
86. Mingers, J. A framework for comparing the philosophical assumptions of management science methodologies. Journal of the Operational Research Society, in press.
87. Mingers J., Brocklesby J. Multimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies. Omega. 25(5):1997;489-509.
88. Mingers J., Gill A. Multimethodology: Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. 1997;Wiley, Chichester.
89. Mingers J., Rosenhead J. Diverse unity: Looking inward and outward. Rosenhead J., Mingers J. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited: Problem Structuring Methods for Complexity, Uncertainty and Conflict. 2001;337-355 Wiley, Chichester.
90. Mingers J., Taylor S. The use of soft systems methodology in practice. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 43(4):1992;321-332.
91. Morse P., Kimball G. Methods of Operations Research. 1951;MIT Technology Press/Wiley, New York.
92. Munro I., Mingers J. The use of multimethodology in practice - results of a survey of practitioners. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 59(4):2002;369-378.
93. Nakano M., Nobutomo H., Okada M., Mizushima A. Research on how to develop R&D strategies using the soft systems approach. International Journal of Technology Management. 14(6-8):1997;822-833.
94. O'Connor A.D. Soft systems methodology - a case-study of its use within an Australian organization. Australian Computer Journal. 24(4):1992;130-138.
95. Oral M., Kettani O. The facets of the modeling and validation process in operations research. European Journal of Operational Research. 66:1993;216-234.
96. Ormerod R. Putting soft OR methods to work: Information systems strategy development at Sainsbury's. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46(3):1995;277-293.
97. Ormerod R. Information systems strategy development at Sainsbury's supermarkets using soft OR. Interfaces. 26(1):1996;102-130.
98. Ormerod R. Putting soft OR methods to work - information systems strategy development at Richards Bay. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 47(9):1996;1083-1097.
99. Ormerod R. Putting soft OR methods to work: Information systems strategy development at Palabora. Omega. 26(1):1998;75-98.
100. Pauley G., Ormerod R. The evolution of a performance measurement project at RTZ. Interfaces. 28:1998;94-118.
101. Phillips L. People-centered group decision support. Doukidis G., Land F., Miller G. Knowledge-Based Management Support Systems. 1989;208-224 Ellis-Horwood, Chichester.
102. Phillips L., Phillips M. Facilitated work groups: Theory and practice. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 44:1993;533-549.
103. Platt D.G. Building process models for design management. Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering. 10(3):1996;194-203.
104. Popper R., Andino K., Bustamante M., Hernandez B., Rodas L. Knowledge and beliefs regarding agricultural pesticides in rural Guatemala. Environmental Management. 20(2):1996;241-248.
105. Pratt B., Loizos P. Choosing Research Methods: Data Collection for Development Workers. 1992;Oxfam, Oxford.
106. Pratt J., Gordon P., Plamping D. Working Whole Systems: Putting Theory into Practice in Organisations. 1999;King's Fund, London.
107. Rasegard S. A comparative-study of Beer and Miller systems designs as tools when analyzing the structure of a municipal organization. Behavioral Science. 36(2):1991;83-99.
108. Ritchie C., Taket A., Bryant J. Community Works. 1994;Community Operational Research Unit, Northern College, Barnsley.
109. Rittel H., Webber M. Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences. 4:1973;155-169.
110. Robbins L. Using interactive planning in the entrepreneurial class - a live fieldwork-based case and simulation exercise. Simulation & Gaming. 25(3):1994;353-367.
111. Rosenhead J. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World. 1989;Wiley, Chichester.
112. Rosenhead J. Enabling analysis: Across the developmental divide. Systems Practice. 6:1993;117-138.
113. Rosenhead J. What's the problem. An introduction to problem structuring methods. Interfaces. 26(6):1996;117-131.
114. Rosenhead J., Mingers J. Rational Analysis for a Problematic World Revisited. 2001;Wiley, Chichester.
115. Schoemaker P. Scenario planning: A tool for strategic thinking. Dyson R., O'Brien F. Strategic Development: Methods and Models. 1998;185-208 Wiley, Chichester.
116. Schon D. Educating the Reflective Practitioner: Toward a New Design for Teaching and Learning in the Professions. 1987;Jossey-Bass, San Francisco.
117. Schuhman W. Strategy for information systems in the film division of Hoechst AG. Systems Practice. 3(3):1990;265-287.
118. Schwartzman H. Ethnography in Organizations. 1993;Sage, Newbury Park.
119. Sorensen L., Vidal R. Strategi Som Laererproces - Seks Blode Metoder. 1999;Handelshojskole Forlag, Copenhagen.
120. Strumpfer J.P. Planning as a means of social change: The Durban functional region forum case. Systems Practice. 10(5):1997;549-566.
121. Taket A., White L. Wanted dead OR alive - ways of using problem-structuring methods in community OR. International Transactions in Operational Research. 4:1997;99-108.
122. Thoren M. Systems approach to clothing for disabled users - why is it difficult for disabled users to find suitable clothing. Applied Ergonomics. 27(6):1996;389-396.
123. Thunhurst C. Doing OR with the community. Dragon. 2:1987;143-153.
124. Thunhurst C., Ritchie C. Housing in the Dearne Valley: Doing community OR with the Thurnscoe Tenants Housing Co-operative. Part 2 - an evaluation. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 43:1992;677-690.
125. Thunhurst C., Ritchie C., Friend J., Booker P. Housing in the Dearne Valley: Doing community OR with the Thurnscoe Tenants Housing Co-operative. Part 1 - the involvement of the Community OR Unit. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 43:1992;81-94.
126. Trist E., Murray H. The social engagement of social science - a tavistock anthology. The Socio-Technical Perspective. vol. II:1993;University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA.
127. Ulengin F., Topcu I. Cognitive map: KBDSS, integration in transportation planning. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 48(11):1997;1065-1075.
128. Ulrich W. Reflective practice in the civil society: The contribution of critically systemic thinking. Reflective Practice. 1(2):2000;247-268.
129. Vennix J. Group Model Building: Facilitating Team Learning Using Systems Dynamics. 1996;Wiley, London.
130. Vos B., Akkermans H. Capturing the dynamics of facility allocation. International Journal of Operations & Production Management. 16(11):1996;57.
131. Walker J. Diagnosis and implementation: How a large cooperative employed a series of proposals for restructuring based on the viable systems model. Systems Practice. 3(5):1990;441-451.
132. Watson S., Buede D. Decision Synthesis: The Principles and Practice of Decision Analysis. 1987;Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
133. Weihrich H. Daimler-Benz's move towards the next century with the TOWS matrix. Dyson R., O'Brien F. Strategic Development: Methods and Models. 1998;69-80 Wiley, Chichester.
134. Wells J.S.G. Discontent without focus - an analysis of nurse management and activity on a psychiatric inpatient facility using a soft systems approach. Journal of Advanced Nursing. 21(2):1995;214-221.
135. White L. Size matters: Large group methods and the process of operational research. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 53:2002;149-160.
136. White L., Taket A. Beyond appraisal: Participatory appraisal of needs and the development of action. Omega, International Journal of Management Science. 25:1997;523-524.
137. Williams T., Eden C., Ackermann F., Tait A. The effects of design changes and delays on project costs. Journal of the Operational Research Society. 46(7):1995;809-818.
138. Winch G.W. Consensus building in the planning process - benefits from a hard modeling approach. System Dynamics Review. 9(3):1993;287-300.