Variety is the spice of life: Combining soft and hard OR/MS methods

International Transactions in Operational Research

Volumn 7, Issue 6, 2000, Pages 673-691

  Mingers, J ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Critical management science; Critical systems thinking; Methodological pluralism; Methodology; Multimethodology; Problem structuring methods; Soft OR

Indexed keywords

EID: 0001384621     PISSN: 09696016     EISSN: 14753995     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1475-3995.2000.tb00224.x     Document Type: Article

References (102)

1. Ackerman, F., Eden, C., et al., 1997. Modeling for litigation: mixing qualitative and quantitative approaches. Interfaces 27 (2), 48–65.
2. Ackoff, R., 1977. Optimization + objectivity = opt out. European Journal of Operational Research 1 (1), 1–7.
3. Ackoff, R., 1979a. The future of operational research is past. Journal of the Operational Research Society 30, 93–104.
4. Ackoff, R., 1979b. Resurrecting the future of operational research. Journal of the Operational Research Society 30, 189–199.
5. Ackoff, R., 1981. Creating the Corporate Future. Wiley, New York.
6. Ackoff, R., 1987. OR: A post mortem. Operations Research 35, 471–474.
7. Beer, S., 1985. Diagnosing the System for Organizations. Wiley, Chichester.
8. Bennett, J., Worthington, D., 1998. An example of a good but partially successful OR engagement: Improving outpatient clinic operations. Interfaces 28 (5), 56–69.
9. Bennett, L.M., Kerr, M.A., 1996. A systems approach to the implementation of total quality management. Total Quality Management 7 (6), 631–665.
10. Bennett, P., 1994. Designing a Parliamentary briefing system—an OR look at the Commons. Journal of the Operational Research Society45 (11), 1221–1232.
11. Billman, B., Courtney, J.F., 1993. Automated discovery in managerial problem formulation—formation of causal hypotheses for cognitive mapping. Decision Sciences 24 (1), 23–41.
12. Boardman, J.T., Cole, A.J., 1996. Integrated process improvement in design and manufacture using a systems approach. IEEE Proceedings—Control Theory and Applications 143 (2), 171–185.
13. Bolton, R., Gold, J., 1994. Career management—matching the needs of individuals with the needs of organizations. Personnel Review 23 (1), 6–24.
14. Brocklesby, J., 1995. Using soft systems methodology to identify competence requirements in HRM. International Journal of Manpower 16 (5–6), 70.
15. Brocklesby, J., Cummings, S., 1995. Designing a viable organization structure. Long Range Planning 29 (1), 49–57.
16. Brown, J.R., Macleod, N.D., 1996. Integrating ecology into natural resource management policy. Environmental Management 20 (3), 289–296.
17. Brown, S.M., 1992. Cognitive mapping and repertory grids for qualitative survey research—some comparative observations. Journal of Management Studies 29 (3), 287–307.
18. Calori, R., Johnson, G., et al., 1994. CEOs’ cognitive maps and the scope of the organization. Strategic Management Journal 15 (6), 437–457.
19. Checkland, P., Holwell, S., 1998. Information, Systems and Information Systems: Making Sense of the Field. Wiley, Chichester.
20. Checkland, P., Scholes, J., 1990. Soft Systems Methodology in Action. Wiley, Chichester.
21. Corbett, C., Van Wassenhove, L., 1993. The natural drift: what happened to operations research. Operations Research 41 (4), 625–640.
22. Coyle, R.G., Alexander, M.D.W., 1977. Two approaches to qualitative modeling of a nation’s drugs trade. Systems Dynamics Review 13 (3), 205–222.
23. Dando, M., Bennett, P., 1981. A Kuhnian crisis in management science Journal of the Operational Research Society 32, 91–104.
24. de Bono, E., 1985. Conflicts: A Better Way to Resolve Them, Six Thinking Hats. Penguin, London.
25. Dickover, N., 1994. Reflection in action—modeling a specific organization through the viable systems model. Systems Practice 7 (1), 43–62.
26. Eden, C., Jones, S., et al., 1983. Messing About in Problems. Pergamon, Oxford.
27. Ellis, K., Gregory, A., et al., (Eds.), 1995. Critical Issues in Systems Theory and Practice. Plenum Press, New York.
28. Espejo, R., Harnden, R., 1989. The Viable Systems Model: Interpretations and Applications of Stafford Beer’s VSM. Wiley, Chichester.
29. Fielden, D., Jacques, J.K., 1998. Systemic approach to energy rationalisation in island communities. International Journal of Energy Research 22 (2), 107–129.
30. Flood, R., Jackson, M., 1991. Creative Problem Solving. Wiley, London.
31. Flood, R., Romm, N., 1996. Diversity Management: Triple Loop Learning. Wiley, Chichester.
32. Gough, J.D., Ward, J.C., 1996. Environmental decision making and lake management. Journal of Environmental Management 48 (1), 1–15.
33. Gregory, A.J., Jackson, M.C., 1992. Evaluating organizations—a systems and contingency approach. Systems Practice 5 (1), 37–60.
34. Habermas, J., 1979. Communication and the Evolution of Society. Heinemann, London.
35. Haynes, M.G., McGregor, A.G., et al., 1997. The business team standard: A means of improving the effectiveness of individual businesses in a multibusiness corporation. Systems Practice 10 (3), 219–239.
36. Hindle, T., Checkland, P., et al., 1995. Development of a methodology for multidisciplinary action research—a case-study. Journal of the Operational Research Society 46 (4), 453–464.
37. Jackson, M., 1990. Beyond a system of systems methodologies. Journal of the Operational Research Society 41 (8), 657–668.
38. Jackson, M., Keys, P., 1984. Towards a system of system methodologies. Journal of the Operational Research Society 35 (6), 473–486.
39. Kartowisastro, H., Kijima, K., 1994. An enriched soft systems methodology (SSM) and its application to cultural-conflict under a paternalistic value system. Systems Practice 7 (3), 241–253.
40. Kennedy, B., 1996. Soft systems methodology in applying psychology. Australian Psychologist 31 (1), 52–59.
41. Khisty, C.J., 1995. Soft systems methodology as learning and management tool. Journal of Urban Planning and Development 121 (3), 91–107.
42. Knowles, J., 1993. A soft systems analysis of a CD-Rom network for a multisite polytechnic. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science 25 (1), 15–21.
43. Lartindrake, J.M., Curran, C.R., 1996. All together now—the circular organization in a university hospital. Systems Practice 9 (5), 391–401.
44. Ledington, P., 1992. Intervention and the management process—an action-based research study. Systems Practice 5 (1), 17–36.
45. Ledington, P., Donaldson, J., 1997. Soft OR and management practice: A study of the adoption and use of soft systems methodology. Journal of the Operational Research Society 48 (3), 229–240.
46. Lee, S., Courtney, J.F., et al., 1992. A system for organizational learning using cognitive maps. Omega 20 (1), 23–36.
47. Lehaney, B., Hlupic, V., 1995. Simulation modeling for resource allocation and planning in the health sector. Journal of the Royal Society of Health 115 (6), 382–385.
48. Lehaney, B., Paul, R.J., 1994. Using soft systems methodology to develop a simulation of outpatient services. Journal of the Royal Society of Health 114 (5), 248–251.
49. Lehaney, B., Paul, R.J., 1996. The use of soft systems methodology in the development of a simulation of outpatient services at Watford General Hospital. Journal of the Operational Research Society 47 (7), 864–870.
50. Macadam, R., Vanasch, R., et al., 1995. A case study in development planning using a systems learning approach—generating a master plan for the livestock sector in Nepal. Agricultural Systems 49 (3), 299–323.
51. Maciaschapula, C.A., 1995. Development of a soft systems model to identify information values, impact and barriers in a health-care information system. Journal of Information Science 21 (4), 283–288.
52. Magidson, J., 1992. Systems practice in several communities in Philadelphia. Systems Practice 5 (5), 493–508.
53. Mason, R., Mitroff, I., 1981. Challenging Strategic Planning Assumptions. Wiley, New York.
54. Midgley, G., 1989. Critical systems: The theory and practice of partitioning methodologies. In: 33rd Annual Meeting of the ISSS, Edinburgh, Scotland.
55. Midgley, G., 1990. Creative methodology design. Systemist 12 (3), 108–113.
56. Midgley, G., 1992. Pluralism and the legitimation of systems science. Systems Practice 5 (2), 147–172.
57. Midgley, G., 1997a. Developing the methodology of TSI: From oblique use of methods to creative design. Systems Practice 10 (3), 305–319.
58. Midgley, G., 1997b. Mixing methods: developing systemic intervention. In: Mingers, J., Gill, A. (Eds.), Multimethodology: The Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley, Chichester, pp. 250–290.
59. Midgley, G., Milne, A., 1995. Creating employment opportunities for people with mental health problems—a feasibility study for new initiatives. Journal of the Operational Research Society 46 (1), 35–42.
60. Millspacko, P.A., Wilson, K., et al., 1991. Highlights from the use of the soft systems methodology to improve agrotechnology transfer in Kona, Hawaii. Agricultural Systems 36 (4), 409–425.
61. Mingers, J. 1994. Multimethodology—a framework for mixing and matching methodologies. EURO XII/OR 36, Strathclyde University, Scotland.
62. Mingers, J., 1997a. Combining research methods in IS: multi-paradigm methodology. In: Galliers, B., Murphy, C., Carlsson, S., etal. (Eds.), Proceedings of 5th European Conference on Information Systems, II. Cork Publishing, Cork, pp. 760–776.
63. Mingers, J., 1997b. Towards critical pluralism. In: Mingers, J., Gill, A. (Eds.), Multimethodology: Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley, Chichester, pp. 407–440.
64. Mingers, J., Brocklesby, J., 1997. Multimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies. Omega 25 (5), 489–509.
65. Mingers, J., Gill, A., (Eds.), 1997. Multimethodology: Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley, Chichester.
66. Mingers, J., Taylor, S., 1992. The use of soft systems methodology in practice. Journal of the Operational Research Society 43 (4), 321–332.
67. Mintzberg, H., 1983. Structure in Fives: Designing Effective Organizations. Prentice Hall, New Jersey.
68. Miser, H., (Ed.), 1995. Handbook of Systems Analysis: Cases. Wiley, New York.
69. Miser, H., Quade, E., (Eds.), 1985. Handbook of Systems Analysis: Overview of Uses, Procedures, Applications, and Practice. Wiley, New York.
70. Miser, H., Quade, E., (Eds.), 1988. Handbook of Systems Analysis: Craft Issues and Procedural Choices. Wiley, New York.
71. Munro, I., Mingers, J., 2000. An Empirical Survey of the Use of Multimethodology in Practice. Warwick Business School, Coventry.
72. Nakano, M., Nobutomo, H., et al., 1997. Research on how to develop R&D strategies using the soft systems approach. InternationalJournal of Technology Management 14 (6–8), 822–833.
73. O’Connor, A.D., 1992. Soft systems methodology—a case-study of its use within an Australian organization. Australian Computer Journal 24 (4), 130–138.
74. Ormerod, R., 1995. Putting soft OR methods to work: Information systems strategy development at Sainsbury’s. Journal of the Operational Research Society 46 (3), 277–293.
75. Ormerod, R., 1996a. Information systems strategy development at Sainsbury’s supermarkets using “Soft” OR. Interfaces 26 (1), 102–130.
76. Ormerod, R., 1996b. Putting soft OR methods to work—information systems strategy development at Richards Bay. Journal of the Operational Research Society 47 (9), 1083–1097.
77. Ormerod, R., 1997a. The design of organizational intervention: Choosing the approach. Omega 25 (4), 415–435.
78. Ormerod, R., 1997b. Mixing methods in practice: A transformation—competence perspective. In: Mingers, J., Gill, A. (Eds.), Multimethodology: Theory and Practice of Combining Management Science Methodologies. Wiley, Chichester, pp. 29–58.
79. Ormerod, R., 1998a. Putting soft OR methods to work: Information systems strategy development at Palabora. Omega 26 (1), 75–98
80. Ormerod, R., 1998b. Putting soft OR methods to work: The case of the business improvement project at Powergen. European Journal of Operational Research, in press.
81. Ormerod, R., Kiossis, I., 1997. OR/MS publications: Extension of the analysis of U.S. flagship journals to the United Kingdom. Operations Research 45 (2), 178–187.
82. Pauley, G., Ormerod, R., 1998. The evolution of a performance measurement project at RTZ. Interfaces 28, 94–118.
83. Platt, D.G., 1996. Building process models for design management. Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering 10 (3), 194–203.
84. Popper, R., Andino, K., et al., 1996. Knowledge and beliefs regarding agricultural pesticides in rural Guatemala. Environmental Management 20 (2), 241–248.
85. Porter, M., 1985. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Advantage. Free Press, New York.
86. Rasegard, S., 1991. A comparative-study of Beer and Miller systems designs as tools when analyzing the structure of a municipal organization. Behavioral Science 36 (2), 83–99.
87. Reisman, A., Kirschnik, F., 1994. The devolution of OR/MS: Implications from a statistical content analysis of papers in flagship journals. Operations Research 42 (4), 577–587.
88. Ritchie, C. Taket, A. etal., (Eds.), 1994. Community Works. Barnsley, Community Operational Research Unit, Northern College.
89. Robbins, L., 1994. Using interactive planning in the entrepreneurial class—a live fieldwork-based case and simulation exercise. Simulation and Gaming 25 (3), 353–367.
90. Schuhman, W., 1990. Strategy for information systems in the film division of Hoechst AG. Systems Practice 3 (3), 265–287.
91. Society, O.R., 1986. Report of the commission on the future practice of operational research. Journal of the Operational Research Society 37 (9), 829–886.
92. Stowell, F., (Ed.), 1995. Information Systems Provision: The Contribution of Soft Systems Methodology. McGraw Hill, London.
93. Stowell, F., Ison, R., et al., (Eds.), 1997. Systems for Sustainability: People, Organizations, and Environments. Plenum, New York.
94. Strumpfer, J.P., 1997. Planning as a means of social change: The Durban functional region forum case. Systems Practice 10 (5), 549–566.
95. Thoren, M., 1996. Systems approach to clothing for disabled users—why is it difficult for disabled users to find suitable clothing. Applied Ergonomics 27 (6), 389–396.
96. Tsoukas, H., Papoulias, D., 1996. Creativity in OR/MS: From technique to epistemology. Interfaces 26 (2), 73–79.
97. Ulengin, F., Topcu, I., 1997. Cognitive map: KBDSS, integration in transportation planning. Journal of the Operational Research Society 48 (11), 1065–1075.
98. Ulrich, W., 1994. Critical Heuristics of Social Planning. Wiley, Chichester.
99. Vos, B., Akkermans, H., 1996. Capturing the dynamics of facility allocation. International Journal of Operations and Production Management 16 (11), 57.
100. Walker, J., 1990. Diagnosis and implementation: how a large cooperative employed a series of proposals for restructuring based on the viable systems model. Systems Practice 3 (5), 441–451.
101. Wells, J.S.G., 1995. Discontent without focus—an analysis of nurse management and activity on a psychiatric inpatient facility using a soft systems approach. Journal of Advanced Nursing 21 (2), 214–221.
102. Winch, G.W., 1993. Consensus building in the planning process—benefits from a hard modeling approach. System Dynamics Review 9 (3), 287–300.