Reliable determination of binding affinity and kinetics using surface plasmon resonance biosensors

Current Opinion in Biotechnology

Volumn 8, Issue 4, 1997, Pages 498-502

  Schuck, Peter ^a  

^a NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ANALYTIC METHOD; BINDING AFFINITY; BINDING KINETICS; BIOSENSOR; CHEMICAL REACTION KINETICS; CONTROLLED STUDY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROPRIOCEPTION; SHORT SURVEY; THERMODYNAMICS;

EID: 0030795295     PISSN: 09581669     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0958-1669(97)80074-2     Document Type: Article

References (43)

1. Garland PB: Optical evanescent wave methods for the study of biomolecular interactions. Q Rev Biophys 1996, 29:91-117.
2. Schuck P: Use of surface plasmon resonance to probe the equilibrium and dynamic aspects of interactions between biological macromolecules. Ann Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 1997, 26:541-566.
3. Van der Merwe PA, Barclay AN: Analysis of cell-adhesion molecule interactions using surface plasmon resonance. Curr Opin Immunol 1996, 8:257-261.
4. Margulies DH, Plaksin D, Khilko SN, Jelonek MT: Studying interactions involving the T-cell antigen receptor by surface plasmon resonance. Curr Opin Immunol 1996, 8:262-270.
5. Malmborg AC, Borrebaeck CA: BIAcore as a tool in antibody engineering. J Immunol Methods 1995, 183:7-13.
6. Karlsson R, Roos H, Fägerstam L, Persson B: Kinetic and concentration analysis using BIA technology. Methods: A Companion to Methods in Enzymology 1994, 6:99-110.
7. O'Shannessy DJ, Winzor DJ: Interpretation of deviations from pseudo-first-order kinetic behavior in the characterization of ligand binding by biosensor technology. Anal Biochem 1996, 236:275-283.
8. Karlsson R, Michaelsson A, Mattson L: Kinetic analysis of monoclonal antibody-antigen interactions with a new biosensor based analytical system. J Immunol Methods 1991, 145:229-240.
9. Nieba L, Krebber A, Plückthun A: Competition BIAcore for measuring true affinities: large differences from values determined from binding kinetics. Anal Biochem 1996, 234:155-165. This paper demonstrates that large errors in the equilibrium constants (here up to a factor of 500) can be introduced by their determination via kinetic experiments and kinetic analysis. In this study, even the ranking of different mobile reactants was affected. It is cautioned about rebinding and bivalency effects. A more reliable competition approach is described. It uses the change of the observed rate constant in the association phase upon addition of, for example, a soluble form of the immobilized binding sites as a competitor.
10. O'Shannessy DJ: Determination of kinetic rate and equilibrium binding constants for macromolecular interactions: a critique of the surface plasmon resonance literature. Curr Opin Biotechnol 1994, 5:65-71.
11. mass transport is discussed in detail.
12. Schuck P, Minton AP: Analysis of mass transport limited binding kinetics in evanescent wave biosensors. Anal Biochem 1996, 240:262-272. In this theoretically oriented paper, it is shown that traditional approaches to account for mass transport influence [8] can lead to concentration-dependent errors in the obtained apparent rate constants. A compartment model to quantify mass transport influence can be used only if restricted to the approach to equilibrium and to the dissociation phase. Analytical corrections for mass transport influence are derived, including a differential equation for combined dissociation and rebinding.
13. Schuck P, Minton AP: Minimal requirements for internal consistency of the analysis of surface plasmon resonance biosensor data. Trends Biochem Sci 1996, 252:458-460. Elementary tests for the internal consistency of the biosensor data analyses based on the 1:1 pseudo-first order kinetics are proposed. Many published data analyses fail these tests.
14. Ladbury JE, Lemmon MA, Zhou M, Green J, Botfield MC, Schlessinger J: Measurement of the binding of tyrosyl phosphopeptides to SH2 domains: a reappraisal. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1995, 92:3199-3203.
15. Fisher RJ, Fivash M: Surface plasmon resonance based methods for measuring the kinetics and binding affinities of biomolecular interactions. Curr Opin Biotechnol 1994, 5:389-395.
16. MacKenzie CR, Hirama T, Deng S-J, Bundle DR, Narang SA, Young NM: Analysis by surface plasmon resonance of the influence of valence on the ligand binding affinity and kinetics of an anti-carbohydrate antibody. J Biol Chem 1996, 271:1527-1533.
17. Myszka D, Arulanantham PR, Sana T, Wu Z, Morton TA, Ciardelli TL: Kinetic analysis of ligand binding to interleukin-2 receptor complexes created on an optical biosensor surface. Protein Sci 1996, 5:2468-2478.
18. Fisher RJ, Fivash M, Casas-Finet J, Bladen S, McNitt KL: Real-time BIAcore measurement of Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA binding (SSB) protein to polydeoxythymidylic acid reveal single-state kinetics with steric cooperativity. Methods: A Companion to Methods in Enzymology 1994, 6:121-133.
19. Glaser RW, Hausdorf G: Binding kinetics of an antibody against HIV p24 core protein measured with real-time biomolecular interaction analysis suggest a slow conformational change in antigen p24. J Immunol Methods 1996, 189:1-14. A very careful study on p24 interaction with a monoclonal antibody. Global analysis did not lead to a satisfactory fit of the data, but a number of experiments qualitatively suggest the presence of a slow conformational change.
20. Karlsson R, Fält A: Experimental design for kinetic analysis of protein-protein interactions with surface plasmon resonance biosensors. J Immunol Methods 1997, 200:121-133. An exemplary demonstration of the potential difficulty of kinetic biosensor data interpretation is the analysis of the interaction of myoglobin with a monoclonal antibody. Whereas the simple 1:1 pseudo-first order model does not fit, several other models can globally fit experimental data comparably well. The importance of experimental controls is emphasized.
21. Hall DR, Winzor DJ: Use of a resonant mirror biosensor to characterize the interaction of carboxypeptidase A with an elicited monoclonal antibody. Anal Biochem 1997, 244:152-160. Origins of the deviations from pseudo-first order kinetics are discussed, and new methods for the determination of the thermodynamic equilibrium constants are described. For cuvette-based biosensors, an equilibrium titration technique is proposed. An empirical, purely operational interpretation of binding rate constants can be used (in the absence of a model for kinetics) to measure the thermodynamic equilibrium constant in a solution competition approach.
22. Bowles MR, Hall DR, Pond SM, Winzor DJ: Studies of protein interactions by biosensor technology: an alternative approach to the analysis of sensorgrams deviating from pseudo-first-order kinetic behavior. Anal Biochem 1997, 244:133-143.
23. Dall'Aqua W, Goldman ER, Eisenstein E, Mariuzza RA: A mutational analysis of the binding of two different proteins to the same antibody. Biochemistry 1996, 35:9667-9676. It is shown that for the binding of anti-lysozyme antibody D1.3 to an anti-D1.3 antibody the results of an equilibrium Scatchard analysis of biosensor data agree with those obtained from fluorescence quenching and analytical ultracentrifugation (sedimentation equilibrium) experiments within a factor of three or better.
24. Oddie GW, Gruen LC, Odgers GA, King LG, Kortt AA: Identification and minimization of nonideal binding effects in BIAcore analysis: ferritin/anti-ferritin Fab′ interaction as as a model system. Anal Biochem 1997, 244:301-311.
25. Edwards PR, Gill A, Pollard-Knight DV, Hoare M, Buckle PE, Lowe PA, Leatherbarrow RJ: Kinetics of protein-protein interactions at the surface of an optical biosensor. Anal Biochem 1995, 231:210-217.
26. Yarmush ML, Patankar DB, Yarmush DM: An analysis of transport resistances in the operation of BIAcore: implications for kinetic studies of biospecific interactions. Mol Immunol 1996, 33:1203-1214. Computer models for the reaction/diffusion/convection in the flow cell above the sensor surface and for the diffusion/reaction in the immobilization matrix show the presence of substantial concentration gradients already at moderately transport influenced binding. These inhomogeneities have a significant effect on the observed binding progress.
27. Gorti S, Ware BR: Probe diffusion in an aqueous polyelectrolyte solution. J Chem Phys 1985, 83:6449-6456.
28. Crank J: The Mathematics of Diffusion. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1975.
29. Stenberg E, Persson B, Roos H, Urbaniczky C: Quantitative determination of surface concentration of protein with surface plasmon resonance using radiolabeled proteins. J Coll Interface Sci 1991, 143:513-526.
30. Yeung D, Gill A, Maule CH, Davies RJ: Detection and quantification of biomolecular interactions with optical biosensors. Trends Anal Chem 1995, 14:49-56.
31. Berg OG, von Hippel PH: Diffusion-controlled macromolecular interactions. Ann Rev Biophys Biophys Chem 1985, 14:131-160.
32. Glaser RW: Antigen-antibody binding and mass transport by convection and diffusion to a surface: a two-dimensional computer model of binding and dissociation kinetics. Anal Biochem 1993, 213:152-161.
33. Hall DR, Cann JR, Winzor DJ: Demonstration of an upper limit to the range of association rate constants amenable to study by biosensor technology based on surface plasmon resonance. Anal Biochem 1996, 235:175-184.
34. DeLisi C: The biophysics of ligand-receptor interactions. Q Rev Biophys 1980, 13:201-230.
35. Nash JC, Quon TK: Software for modeling kinetic phenomena. Am Statist 1996, 50:368-377.
36. Stein T, Gerisch G: Oriented binding of a lipid-anchored cell adhesion protein onto a biosensor surface using hydrophobic immobilization and photoactive crosslinking. Anal Biochem 1996, 237:252-259.
37. Gershon PD, Khilko S: Stable chelating linkage for reversible immobilization of oligohistidine tagged proteins in the BIAcore surface plasmon resonance detector. J Immunol Methods 1995, 183:65-76.
38. O'Shannessy DJ, O'Donnell KC, Martin J, Brigham-Burke M: Detection and quantitation of hexa-histidine-tagged recombinant proteins on western blots and by a surface plasmon resonance biosensor technique. Anal Biochem 1995, 229:119-124.
39. Sigal GB, Bamdad C, Barberis A, Strominger J, Whitesides GM: A self-assembled monolayer for the binding and study of histidine-tagged proteins by surface plasmon resonance. Anal Chem 1996, 68:490-497.
40. Plant AL, Brigham-Burke M, Petrella EC, O'Shannessy DJ: Phospholipid/alkanethiol bilayers for cell-surface receptor studies by surface plasmon resonance. Anal Biochem 1995, 226:342-348.
41. Ramsden JJ, Bachmanova GI, Archakov AI: Immobilization of proteins to lipid bilayers. Biosens Bioelectron 1996, 11:523-528.
42. Salamon Z, Tollin G: Surface plasmon resonance studies of complex formation between cytochrome c and bovine cytochrome c oxidase incorporated into a supported planar lipid bilayer. I. Binding of cytochrome c to cardiolipin/phosphatidylcholine membranes in the absence of oxidase. Biophys J 1996, 71:848-857.
43. Heyse S, Vogel H, Sänger M, Sigrist H: Covalent attachment of functionalized lipid bilayers to planar waveguides for measuring protein binding to biomimetic membranes. Protein Sci 1995, 4:2532-2544.