Neural correlates of motor memory consolidation

Science

Volumn 277, Issue 5327, 1997, Pages 821-825

  Shadmehr, Reza ^a   Holcomb, Henry H ^b,c  

^a Johns Hopkins University   (United States)

^b MARYLAND PSYCHIATRIC RESEARCH CENTER   (United States)

^c JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; BRAIN; HUMAN; LEARNING; MEMORY CONSOLIDATION; MOTOR PERFORMANCE; POSITRON EMISSION TOMOGRAPHY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; TASK PERFORMANCE;

ADULT; BRAIN MAPPING; CEREBELLAR CORTEX; HUMANS; LEARNING; MALE; MEMORY; MOTOR CORTEX; MOTOR SKILLS; PARIETAL LOBE; PREFRONTAL CORTEX; PUTAMEN; REGIONAL BLOOD FLOW; TIME FACTORS; TOMOGRAPHY, EMISSION-COMPUTED;

EID: 0030763775     PISSN: 00368075     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1126/science.277.5327.821     Document Type: Article

References (83)

1. T. E. Milner and C. Cloutier, Exp. Brain Res. 94, 522 (1993).
2. A. Hreljac, Biol. Cybern. 68, 375 (1993).
3. B. Conrad, K. Matsunami, J. Meyer-Lohmann, M. Wiesendanger, V. B. Brooks, Brain Res. 71, 507 (1974); T. Vilis and J. Hore, J. Neurophysiol. 43, 279 (1980).
4. B. Conrad, K. Matsunami, J. Meyer-Lohmann, M. Wiesendanger, V. B. Brooks, Brain Res. 71, 507 (1974); T. Vilis and J. Hore, J. Neurophysiol. 43, 279 (1980).
5. G. L. Gottlieb, Exp. Brain Res. 97, 545 (1994).
6. D. M. Wolpert, Z. Ghahramani, M.I. Jordan, Science 269, 1880 (1995); J. R. Flanagan and A. M. Wing, J. Neurosci. 17, 1519 (1997); J. R. Lackner and P. Dizio, J. Neurophysiol. 72, 299 (1994); C. Ghez and R. Sainburg, Can. J. Physiol. Pharm. 73, 273 (1995); M. Kawato, M. Isobe, Y. Maeda, R. Suzuki, Biol. Cybern. 59, 161 (1988).
7. D. M. Wolpert, Z. Ghahramani, M.I. Jordan, Science 269, 1880 (1995); J. R. Flanagan and A. M. Wing, J. Neurosci. 17, 1519 (1997); J. R. Lackner and P. Dizio, J. Neurophysiol. 72, 299 (1994); C. Ghez and R. Sainburg, Can. J. Physiol. Pharm. 73, 273 (1995); M. Kawato, M. Isobe, Y. Maeda, R. Suzuki, Biol. Cybern. 59, 161 (1988).
8. D. M. Wolpert, Z. Ghahramani, M.I. Jordan, Science 269, 1880 (1995); J. R. Flanagan and A. M. Wing, J. Neurosci. 17, 1519 (1997); J. R. Lackner and P. Dizio, J. Neurophysiol. 72, 299 (1994); C. Ghez and R. Sainburg, Can. J. Physiol. Pharm. 73, 273 (1995); M. Kawato, M. Isobe, Y. Maeda, R. Suzuki, Biol. Cybern. 59, 161 (1988).
9. D. M. Wolpert, Z. Ghahramani, M.I. Jordan, Science 269, 1880 (1995); J. R. Flanagan and A. M. Wing, J. Neurosci. 17, 1519 (1997); J. R. Lackner and P. Dizio, J. Neurophysiol. 72, 299 (1994); C. Ghez and R. Sainburg, Can. J. Physiol. Pharm. 73, 273 (1995); M. Kawato, M. Isobe, Y. Maeda, R. Suzuki, Biol. Cybern. 59, 161 (1988).
10. D. M. Wolpert, Z. Ghahramani, M.I. Jordan, Science 269, 1880 (1995); J. R. Flanagan and A. M. Wing, J. Neurosci. 17, 1519 (1997); J. R. Lackner and P. Dizio, J. Neurophysiol. 72, 299 (1994); C. Ghez and R. Sainburg, Can. J. Physiol. Pharm. 73, 273 (1995); M. Kawato, M. Isobe, Y. Maeda, R. Suzuki, Biol. Cybern. 59, 161 (1988).
11. R. Shadmehr and F. A. Mussa-Ivaldi, J. Neurosci. 14, 3208 (1994).
12. A. M. Gordon, G. Westling, K. J. Cole, R. S. Johansson, J. Neurophysiol. 69, 1789 (1993).
13. R. Shadmehr and T. Brashers-Krug, J. Neurosci. 17, 409 (1997).
14. T. Brashers-Krug, R. Shadmehr, E. Bizzi, Nature 382, 252 (1996).
15. P. Alvarez and L. R. Squire, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 7041 (1994); S. M. Zola-Morgan and L. R. Squire, Science 250, 288 (1990); J. F. Guzowski and J. L. McGaugh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 94, 2693 (1997); J. J. Kim, R. E. Clark, R. F. Thompson, Behav. Neurosci. 109, 195 (1995).
16. P. Alvarez and L. R. Squire, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 7041 (1994); S. M. Zola-Morgan and L. R. Squire, Science 250, 288 (1990); J. F. Guzowski and J. L. McGaugh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 94, 2693 (1997); J. J. Kim, R. E. Clark, R. F. Thompson, Behav. Neurosci. 109, 195 (1995).
17. P. Alvarez and L. R. Squire, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 7041 (1994); S. M. Zola-Morgan and L. R. Squire, Science 250, 288 (1990); J. F. Guzowski and J. L. McGaugh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 94, 2693 (1997); J. J. Kim, R. E. Clark, R. F. Thompson, Behav. Neurosci. 109, 195 (1995).
18. P. Alvarez and L. R. Squire, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91, 7041 (1994); S. M. Zola-Morgan and L. R. Squire, Science 250, 288 (1990); J. F. Guzowski and J. L. McGaugh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 94, 2693 (1997); J. J. Kim, R. E. Clark, R. F. Thompson, Behav. Neurosci. 109, 195 (1995).
19. R. J. Nudo, B. M. Wise, F. SiFuentes, G. W. Milliken, Science 272, 1791 (1996); D. A. Koztowski, D. C James, T. Schallert, J. Neurosci. 16, 4776 (1996).
20. R. J. Nudo, B. M. Wise, F. SiFuentes, G. W. Milliken, Science 272, 1791 (1996); D. A. Koztowski, D. C James, T. Schallert, J. Neurosci. 16, 4776 (1996).
21. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
22. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
23. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
24. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
25. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
26. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
27. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
28. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
29. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
30. H. Aizawa, M. Inase, H. Mushiake, K. Shima, J. Tanji Exp. Brain Res. 84, 668 (1991); C. Pavlides, E. Miyashita, H. Asanuma, J. Neurophysiol. 70, 733 (1993); A. Kami et al., Nature 377, 155 (1995); A. Pascual-Leone, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Science 263 1287 (1994); S. T. Grafton, R. P. Woods, M. Tyszka, Hum. Brain Mapp. 1, 221 (1994); R. Kawashima, P. E. Roland, B. T. O'Sullivan, Cereb. Cortex 5, 111 (1995); G. Schlaug, U. Knorr, R. Seitz, Exp. Brain Res. 98, 523 (1994); R. J. Seitz and P. E. Roland, Eur. J. Neurosci. 4, 154 (1992); R. J. Seitz et al., Neuroreport 5, 2541 (1994); R. M. Carelli, M. Wolske, M. O. West, J. Neurosci. 17, 1804 (1997).
31. M. Mata et al. J. Neurochem. 34, 213 (1980); M. Kadekaro, A. M. Crane, L. Sokoloff, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 82, 6010 (1985); P. E. Roland, Brain Activation (Wiley, New York, 1993).
32. M. Mata et al. J. Neurochem. 34, 213 (1980); M. Kadekaro, A. M. Crane, L. Sokoloff, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 82, 6010 (1985); P. E. Roland, Brain Activation (Wiley, New York, 1993).
33. M. Mata et al. J. Neurochem. 34, 213 (1980); M. Kadekaro, A. M. Crane, L. Sokoloff, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 82, 6010 (1985); P. E. Roland, Brain Activation (Wiley, New York, 1993).
34. Right-handed, healthy male participants (n = 16, age = 23.6 ± 3.2 years) were recruited and gave written consent. Participants lay in a supine position in a dimly lit sound-attenuated room, on the gurney of a GE 4096+ PET tomograph. A catheter was placed in the left cubital vein for injection of the radioisotope. Each man gripped the handle of a robot manipulandum with his right hand. The robot is a portable, light-weight, very low friction planar mechanism equipped with two pairs of optical position and velocity encoders, a force transducer at the handle, and brushless dc motors that deliver torques independently to each joint (8). Participants viewed a monitor that displayed a cursor corresponding to the handle's position. The task was to take the handle to a series of targets. Participants were instructed that they should reach for the displayed target and that their movement time should be within 500 ± 50 ms (targets were at 10 cm). A target randomly appeared in one of eight directions (Fig. 1 B). The target turned blue if a participant reached it too late, red if he reached it too soon, and "exploded" if the reach was in time. One second after a target was reached, the next target appeared. The experiment was approved by the Johns Hopkins University Joint Committee on Clinical Investigation.
35. 2O was administered [M. E. Raichle et al., J. Nucl. Med. 24, 790, (1983)]. Accumulated radioactivity in the 90 s after initiation of the scan was used as an index of rCBF. Scans were acquired at 10-min intervals. The motor task was initiated 1 min before administration of the bolus and continued until completion of the scan. Participants practiced in the field for 5 min between scans 6 and 7 and rested between all other scans. Arterial blood was not sampled. Blood flow data reported here are changes in units of flow relative to the mean of the flow acquired for the whole brain.
36. A.
37. Other measures of motor output, including total force, mechanical work, and integrated electromyogram, are correlated with movement length during learning of a force field.
38. Images were realigned and normalized with SPM96 software [K. Friston et al., Hum. Brain Mapp. 2, 189 (1995)]. The scans from each participant were realigned with the first image used as a reference. AT1 weighted magnetic resonance image (MRI) was coregistered to the mean PET image for each participant and then stereotactically transformed to a standard MRI template in the Talairach and Tournoux space. The resulting transformation matrix was applied to the PET images. The normalized PET images were smoothed with an Isotropic Gaussian filter (ful width at half maximum of 12 mm). The normalized MRI scans were combined to generate a population-specific anatomic atlas. Based on a distance measure [R. P. Woods, S. R. Cherry, J. C. Mazziotta, J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 115, 565 (1992)] between the individual MRIs and the atlas, the median brain among the population of participants was labeled as typical. Smoothed, normalized PET data were analyzed with the use of SPM software with a multisubject block design, two replications per condition, and an analysis of covariance global normalization. Participant and global brain activity were two covariates of no interest, and the conditions of the task were the covariates of interest. The search volume was from z = -30 mm to z = 60 mm and did not allow a complete view of the cerebellum. In the parametric test, the contrasts represented the average movement length per condition. In the subtraction tests, the contrasts were -1 and 1 (or 1 and -1) for the conditions of interest. We considered as significant regions where voxel-level Z valrues exceeded 4.4 so that the corrected P < 0.05. We also considered as significant regions in the sensorimotor system that we had selected a priori, where voxel-level Z values exceeded 3.09. These regions were the primary sensorimotor, the premotor, and the supplementary motor areas, the striaturn, and the cerebellum.
39. Images were realigned and normalized with SPM96 software [K. Friston et al., Hum. Brain Mapp. 2, 189 (1995)]. The scans from each participant were realigned with the first image used as a reference. AT1 weighted magnetic resonance image (MRI) was coregistered to the mean PET image for each participant and then stereotactically transformed to a standard MRI template in the Talairach and Tournoux space. The resulting transformation matrix was applied to the PET images. The normalized PET images were smoothed with an Isotropic Gaussian filter (ful width at half maximum of 12 mm). The normalized MRI scans were combined to generate a population-specific anatomic atlas. Based on a distance measure [R. P. Woods, S. R. Cherry, J. C. Mazziotta, J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 115, 565 (1992)] between the individual MRIs and the atlas, the median brain among the population of participants was labeled as typical. Smoothed, normalized PET data were analyzed with the use of SPM software with a multisubject block design, two replications per condition, and an analysis of covariance global normalization. Participant and global brain activity were two covariates of no interest, and the conditions of the task were the covariates of interest. The search volume was from z = -30 mm to z = 60 mm and did not allow a complete view of the cerebellum. In the parametric test, the contrasts represented the average movement length per condition. In the subtraction tests, the contrasts were -1 and 1 (or 1 and -1) for the conditions of interest. We considered as significant regions where voxel-level Z valrues exceeded 4.4 so that the corrected P < 0.05. We also considered as significant regions in the sensorimotor system that we had selected a priori, where voxel-level Z values exceeded 3.09. These regions were the primary sensorimotor, the premotor, and the supplementary motor areas, the striaturn, and the cerebellum.
40. C. Dettmers et al., J. Neurophysiol. 74, 802 (1995).
41. Principal component analysis [K. J. Friston, C. D. Frith, R. S. J. Frackowiak, Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. B 254, 47 (1993)] of the data in session 1 showed that changes in rCBF in regions of the left BA 18, thalamus, and right BA 46 were highly correlated. The images from each participant were projected through the eigenimage that represented this network. The result was a score that was minimum in the random field condition and maximum during early learning. This suggests that the network was least active when the task was most novel (participants experienced a field for the first time in the random condition) yet unleamable, and was most active only when the task was being rapidly learned. Therefore, it is likely that the increase in BA 46 (Fig. 2B) in early learning versus the random condition is learning-related and not due to confounding factors such as the novelty or attention requirements of the task.
42. G. S. Brindley, Int. Brain Res. Org. Bull. 3, 80 (1964); J. M. Fuster, Memory in the Cerebral Cortex: An Empirical Approach to Neural Networks in the Human and Nonhuman Primates (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995); W. T. Thach, Behav. Brain Sci. 19, 411 (1996).
43. G. S. Brindley, Int. Brain Res. Org. Bull. 3, 80 (1964); J. M. Fuster, Memory in the Cerebral Cortex: An Empirical Approach to Neural Networks in the Human and Nonhuman Primates (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995); W. T. Thach, Behav. Brain Sci. 19, 411 (1996).
44. G. S. Brindley, Int. Brain Res. Org. Bull. 3, 80 (1964); J. M. Fuster, Memory in the Cerebral Cortex: An Empirical Approach to Neural Networks in the Human and Nonhuman Primates (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1995); W. T. Thach, Behav. Brain Sci. 19, 411 (1996).
45. A. Pascual-Leone, E. M. Wassermann, J. Grafman, M. Hallett, Exp. Brain Res. 107, 479 (1996).
46. Previous experiments (8) suggest that after 400 targets in a field, up to 50% further practice during session 1 does not result in significantly improved performance.
47. S. Grafton et al., J. Neurosci. 12, 2542 (1992); K. J. Friston, C. D. Frith, R. E. Passingham, P. F. Liddle, R. S. Frackowiak, Proc. H. Soc. London Ser. B 248, 223 (1992); D. M. Glower et al., Nature 383, 618 (1996).
48. S. Grafton et al., J. Neurosci. 12, 2542 (1992); K. J. Friston, C. D. Frith, R. E. Passingham, P. F. Liddle, R. S. Frackowiak, Proc. H. Soc. London Ser. B 248, 223 (1992); D. M. Glower et al., Nature 383, 618 (1996).
49. S. Grafton et al., J. Neurosci. 12, 2542 (1992); K. J. Friston, C. D. Frith, R. E. Passingham, P. F. Liddle, R. S. Frackowiak, Proc. H. Soc. London Ser. B 248, 223 (1992); D. M. Glower et al., Nature 383, 618 (1996).
50. R. J. Seitz, P. E. Roland, C. Bohm, T. Greitz, S. Stone-Elander, Neuroreport 1, 57 (1990); I. H. Jenkins, O. J. Brooks, P. D. Nixon, R. S. J. Frackowiak, R. E. Passingham, J. Neurosci. 14, 3775 (1994).
51. R. J. Seitz, P. E. Roland, C. Bohm, T. Greitz, S. Stone-Elander, Neuroreport 1, 57 (1990); I. H. Jenkins, O. J. Brooks, P. D. Nixon, R. S. J. Frackowiak, R. E. Passingham, J. Neurosci. 14, 3775 (1994).
52. M. Jueptnerefal, J. Neurophysiol. 77, 1313 (1997).
53. J. Quintana and J. M. Fuster, Neuroreport 3, 721 (1992); W. W. Shindy, K. A. Posley, J. M. Fuster, Cereb. Cortex 4, 443 (1994).
54. J. Quintana and J. M. Fuster, Neuroreport 3, 721 (1992); W. W. Shindy, K. A. Posley, J. M. Fuster, Cereb. Cortex 4, 443 (1994).
55. P. S. Goldman-Rakic, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 93, 13473 (1996).
56. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
57. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
58. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
59. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
60. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
61. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
62. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
63. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
64. D. Marr, J. Physiol. London 202, 437 (1969); J. S. Albus, Math. Biosci. 10, 25 (1971); M. Ito, Brain Res. 40, 80 (1972); K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Exp. Brain Res. 48, 429 (1982); M. Kawato and H. Gorni, Biol. Cybern. 68, 95 (1992); M. Shidara, K. Kawano, H. Gorni, M. Kawato, Nature 365, 50 (1993); J. C. Houk and S. P. Wise, Cereb. Cortex 5, 95 (1995); J. L. Raymond, S. G. Usberger, M. O. Mauk, Science 272, 1126 (1996); J. A. Kleim, K. Vij, D. H. Ballard, W. T. Greenough, J. Neurosci. 17, 717 (1997).
65. R. Shadmehr and K. A. Thoroughman, in Neuro-Mechanical Interaction in Posture and Movement Control, J. Winters and P. Crago, Eds. (Springer-Verlag, New York, in press).
66. H. P. Goodkin, J. G. Keating, T. A. Martin, W. T. Thach, Can. J. Neurol. Sci. 20, S93 (1993); A. J. Bastian, T. A. Martin, J. G. Keating, W. T. Thach, J. Neurophysiol. 76, 492 (1996).
67. H. P. Goodkin, J. G. Keating, T. A. Martin, W. T. Thach, Can. J. Neurol. Sci. 20, S93 (1993); A. J. Bastian, T. A. Martin, J. G. Keating, W. T. Thach, J. Neurophysiol. 76, 492 (1996).
68. C. L. Ojakangas and T. J. Ebner, J. Neurophysiol. 68, 2222 (1992).
69. N. W. Seeds, B. L. Williams, P. C. Bickford, Science 270, 1992 (1995).
70. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
71. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
72. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
73. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
74. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
75. K. Sasaki and H. Gemba, Brain Res. 374, 278 (1986); R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 70, 590 (1988); Brain Behav. Evol. 33, 189 (1989); U. Halsband and H.-J. Freund, Brain 113, 207 (1990); L. Germain and Y. Lamarre, Brain Res. 611, 175 (1993); Y.-C. Chen, D. Thaler, P. D. Nixon, C. E. Stem, R. E. Passingham, Exp. Brain Res. 102, 461 (1995).
76. A. R. Mitz, M. Godschalk, S. P. Wise, J. Neurosci. 11, 1855 (1991); D. Boussaoud and S. P. Wise, Exp. Brain Res. 95, 28 (1993).
77. A. R. Mitz, M. Godschalk, S. P. Wise, J. Neurosci. 11, 1855 (1991); D. Boussaoud and S. P. Wise, Exp. Brain Res. 95, 28 (1993).
78. S. P. Wise, in The Acquisition of Motor Behavior in Vertebrates, J. R. Bloedel, T. J. Ebner, S. P. Wise, Eds. (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1996), pp. 261-286.
79. J. Tanne, D. Boussaoud, N. Boyer-Zeller, E. M. Rouiller, Neuroreport 7, 267 (1995).
80. P. B. Johnson, S. Ferraina, L. Bianchi, R. Caminfti, Cereb. Cortex 6, 102 (1996).
81. H. Poizner et al., Brain 118, 227 (1995); A. Sirigu et al., Science 273, 1564 (1996).
82. H. Poizner et al., Brain 118, 227 (1995); A. Sirigu et al., Science 273, 1564 (1996).
83. We thank K. Akhavan-Toyserkani, Z. Zhao, K. Thoroughman, M. Smith, B. S. Yu, S. Wise, and the scientists at the Johns Hopkins PET facility, led by R. Dannals. This work was funded in part by the Whitaker Foundation, the National Institute of Mental Health, and the Office of Naval Research.