The use of research in public health policy: A systematic review

Evidence and Policy

Volumn 16, Issue 1, 2020, Pages 7-43

  Masood, Sara ^a   Kothari, Anita ^a   Regan, Sandra ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN ONTARIO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Knowledge translation; Public health policy; Research evidence; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

EID: 85106798525     PISSN: 17442648     EISSN: 17442656     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1332/174426418X15193814624487     Document Type: Review

References (81)

1. Armstrong, R, Pettman, T, Burford, B, Doyle, J, Waters, E, 2012, Tracking and understanding the utility of Cochrane reviews for public health decision making, Public Health 34, 2, 309–13
2. Armstrong, R,Waters, E, Moore, L, Dobbins, M, Pettman,T, Burns, C, Swinburn, B, Anderson, L, Petticrew, M, 2014, Understanding evidence: A statewide survey to explore evidence-informed public health decision making in a local government setting, Implementation Science 9, 188
3. Atkins, D, Fink, K, Slutsky, J, 2005, Better information for better health care: The Evidence-based Practice Center Program and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Annals of Internal Medicine 142, 12 Pt 2, 1035–41
4. Beacham,B,Kalucy,L,McIntyre,E,2005,FOCUS on…Understanding and measuring research impact, www.phcris.org.au/publications/focuson/index.php
5. Best, A, Holmes, B, 2010, Systems thinking, knowledge and action: Towards better models and methods, Evidence & Policy 6, 2, 145–59
6. Boyko, JA, Lavis, JN,Abelson, J, Dobbins, M, Carter, N, 2012, Deliberative dialogues as a mechanism for knowledge translation and exchange in health systems decision making, Social Science & Medicine 75, 11, 1938–45
7. Browne,GR,Davern,M,Giles-Corti,B,2017,What evidence is being used to inform municipal strategic planning for health and wellbeing? Victoria, Australia, a case study, Evidence & Policy 13, 3, 401–16
8. Brownson, RC, Kreuter, MW,Arrington, BA,True,WR, 2006,Translating scientific discoveries into public health action: How can schools of public health move us forward? Public Health Reports 121, 1, 97–103
9. Brownson, RC, Chriqui, JF, Stamatakis, KA, 2009, Understanding evidence-based public health policy, American Journal of Public Health 99, 9, 1576–83
10. Buse, K, Mays, N,Walt, G, 2012, Making health policy (2nd edn), Maidenhead: McGrawHill Education
11. Cairney, P, 2015, How can policy theory have an impact on policymaking? The role of theory-led academic-practitioner discussions, Teaching Public Administration 33, 1, 22–39
12. Cairney, P, 2017, Evidence-based best practice is more political than it looks:A case study of the ‘Scottish Approach’, Evidence & Policy 13, 3, 499–515
13. Campbell, DM, Redman, S, Jorm, L, Cooke, M, Zwi, AB, Rychetnik, L, 2009, Increasing the use of evidence in health policy: Practice and views of policymakers and researchers, Australian New Zealand Health Policy 6, 21
14. CASP (Critical Appraisal Skills Programme): Making sense of evidence, 2014, CASP Tools &
15. Checklists, www.casp-uk.net/checklists
16. Dawes, M, Summerskill, W, Glasziou, P, Cartabellotta, A, Martin, J, Hopayian, K, Porzsolt, F, Burls,A, Osborne, J, 2005, Sicily statement on evidence-based practice, BMC Medical Education 5, 1, 1
17. Ellen, ME, Leon, G, Bouchard, G, Lavis, JN, Ouimet, M, Grimshaw, JM, 2013,What supports do health system organizations have in place to facilitate evidence-informed decision-making? A qualitative study, Implementation Science 8, 84
18. Ellen,ME,Léon,G,Bouchard,G,Ouimet,M,Grimshaw,JM,Lavis,JN,2014,Barriers, facilitators and views about next steps to implementing supports for evidence-informed decision making in health systems: A qualitative study, Implementation Science 9, 179
19. Evans, BA, Snooks, H, Howson, H, Davies, M, 2013, How hard can it be to include research evidence and evaluation in local health policy implementation? Results from a mixed methods study, Implementation Science 8, 17
20. Francis, D, Turley, R, Thompson, H, Weightman, A, Waters, E, Moore, L, 2015, Supporting the needs of public health decision makers and review authors in the UK, Public Health 37, 1, 172–4
21. Graham, ID, Logan, J, Harrison, MB, Straus, SE,Tetroe, J, Caswell,W, Robinson, N, Lost in knowledge translation:Time for a map? Continuing Education in the Health Professions 26, 1, 13
22. Greenhalgh, T, Wieringa, S, 2011, Is it time to drop the ‘knowledge translation’ metaphor? A critical literature review, Royal Society of Medicine 104, 12, 501–09
23. Grimshaw,JM,Eccles,MP,Lavis,JN,Hill,SJ,Squires,JE,2012,Knowledge translation of research findings, Implementation Science 7, 50
24. Hanney, SR, Gonzalez-Block, MA, Buxton, MJ, Kogan, M, 2003,The utilisation of health research in policy-making: Concepts, examples and methods of assessment, Health Research Policy and Systems, 1, 1, 2
25. Huckel Schneider, C, Campbell, D, Milat,A, Haynes,A, Quinn, E, 2014,What are the key organizational capabilities that facilitate research use in public health policy? Public Health Research & Practice 25, 1, e2511406
26. Innvær, S,Vist, G,Trommald, M, Oxman,A, 2002, Health policymakers’ perceptions of their use of evidence:A systematic review, Health Services Research & Policy 7, 4, 239–44
27. Jacobs, JA, Dodson, EA, Baker, EA, Deshpande, AD, Brownson, RC, 2010, Barriers to evidence-based decision making in public health: A national survey of chronic disease practitioners, Public Health Reports 125, 5, 736–42
28. Kemm, J, 2006,The limitations of ‘evidence-based’ public health, Evaluation in Clinical Practice 12, 3, 319–24
29. Klein, R, 2003, Evidence and policy: Interpreting the Delphic oracle, Royal Society of Medicine 96, 9, 429–31
30. Kothari, AR, Bickord, JJ, Edwards, N, Dobbins, MJ, Meyer, M, 2011, Uncovering tacit knowledge:A pilot study to broaden the concept of knowledge in knowledge translation, BMC Health Services Research 11, 198
31. Kothari, A, Wathen, CN, 2013, A critical second look at integrated knowledge translation, Health Policy 109, 2, 187–91
32. LaRocca, R, Yost, J, Dobbins, M, Ciliska, D, Butt, M, 2012, The effectiveness of knowledge translation strategies used in public health: A systematic review, BMC Public Health 12, 751
33. Larsen, M, Gulis, G, Pedersen, KM, 2012, Use of evidence in local public health work in Denmark, International Journal of Public Health 57, 3, 477–83
34. Latham, J, Murajda, L, Forland, F, Jansen, A, 2013, Capacities, practices and perceptions of evidence-based public health in Europe, Eurosurveillance Edition 18, 10, 1–5
35. Lavis, JN, 2006, Research, public policymaking and knowledge-translation processes: Canadian efforts to build bridges, Continuing Education in the Health Professions 26, 1, 37–45
36. Lavis, JN, Rottingen, J, Bosch-Capblanch, X, Atun, R, El-Jardali, F, Gilson, L., Lewin, S, Oliver, S, Ongolo-Zogo, P, Haines, A, 2012, Guidance for evidence-informed policies about health systems: Linking guidance development to policy development, PLoS Medicine 9, 3, e1001186
37. Lavis, JN, Boyko, JA, Gauvin, FP, 2014, Evaluating deliberative dialogues focused on healthy public policy, BMC Public Health 14, 1287
38. Laws, R, King, L, Hardy, LL, Milat, A, Rissel, C, Newson, R, Rychetnik, L, Bauman, AR, 2013, Utilization of a population health survey in policy and practice: A case study, Health Research Policy and Systems 11, 4
39. Lillefjell, M, Knudtsen, MS, Wist, G, Ihlebæk, C, 2013, From knowledge to action in public health management: experiences from a Norwegian context, Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 41, 8, 771–7
40. Liverani, M, Hawkins, B, Parkhurst, JO, 2013, Political and institutional influences on the use of evidence in public health policy: A systematic review, PLoS One 8, 10, e77404
41. Mays, N, Pope, C, Popay, J, 2005, Systematically reviewing qualitative and quantitative evidence to inform management and policymaking in the health field, Health Services Research & Policy 10, Suppl 1, 6–20
42. McCormack, L, Sheridan, S, Lewis, M, Boudewyns, V, Melvin, CL, Kistler, C, Lux, LJ, Cullen, K, Lohr, KN, 2013, Communication and dissemination strategies to facilitate the use of health-related evidence, Evidence Reports / Technology Assessments 213
43. Meagher-Stewart, D, Solberg, SM, Warner, G, MacDonald, JA, McPherson, C, Seaman, P, 2012, Understanding the role of communities of practice in evidence-informed decision making in public health, Qualitative Health Research 22, 6, 723–39
44. Mendeley, 2010, Getting started with Mendeley, community.mendeley.com/guides/ desktop
45. Milat, AJ, King, L, Newson, R, Wolfenden, L, Rissel, C, Bauman, A, Redman, S, 2014, Increasing the scale and adoption of population health interventions: Experiences and perspectives of policymakers, practitioners, and researchers, Health Research Policy and Systems 12, 18
46. Mitton, C, Adair, CE, McKenzie, E, Patten, SB, Waye Perry, B, 2007, Knowledge transfer and exchange: Review and synthesis of the literature, Milbank Quarterly 85, 4, 729–68
47. Moher, D, Tsertsvadze, A, 2006, Systematic reviews: When is an update an update? Lancet 367, 9514, 881–3
48. Moher, D, Liberati, A, Tetzlaff, J, Altman, DG, the PRISMA Group, 2009, Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement, BMJ 339, b2535
49. Oliver, KA, de Vocht, F, 2015, Defining ‘evidence’ in public health: A survey of policymakers’ uses and preferences, European Journal of Public Health 27, Suppl 2, 112–17
50. Oliver, KA, de Vocht, F, Money, A, Everett, M, 2015, Identifying public health policymakers’ sources of information: Comparing survey and network analyses, European Journal of Public Health 27, Suppl 2, 118–23
51. Orton, L, Lloyd-Williams, F,Taylor-Robinson, D, O’Flaherty, M, Capewell, S, 2011, The use of research evidence in public health decision making processes:Systematic review, PloS ONE 6, 7, e21704
52. Ovretveit, J, 2007, Research-informed public health, in Hunter, DJ (ed), Managing for health, London: Routledge, 129–47
53. Perrier, L, Mrklas, K, Lavis, JN, Straus, SE, 2011, Interventions encouraging the use of systematic reviews by health policymakers and managers: A systematic review, Implementation Science 6, 43
54. Pluye, P, Robert, E, Cargo, M, Bartlett, G, O’Cathain, A, Griffiths, F, Boardman, F, Gagnon, MP, Rousseau, MC, 2011, Proposal: A mixed methods appraisal tool for systematic mixed studies reviews, http://mixedmethodsappraisaltoolpublic.pbworks. com, archived by WebCite® at http://www.webcitation.org/5tTRTc9yJ
55. Reardon, R, Lavis, J, Gibson, J, 2006, From research to practice:A knowledge transfer planning guide, www.iwh.on.ca/from-research-to-practice
56. Rosella, LC, Wilson, K, Crowcroft, NS, Chu, A, Upshur, R, Willison, D, Deeks, SL, Schwartz, B,Tustin, J, Sider, D, Goel,V, 2013, Pandemic H1N1 in Canada and the use of evidence in developing public health policies:A policy analysis, Social Science & Medicine 83, 1–9
57. Sackett,DL,Rosenberg,WM,Gray,JA,Haynes,RB,Richardson,WS,1996,Evidence-based medicine:What it is and what it isn’t, BMJ 312, 7023, 71–2
58. Shlonsky, A, Mildon, R, 2014, Methodological pluralism in the age of evidence-informed practice and policy, Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 42, Suppl 13, 18–27
59. Smith, KE, Katikireddi, SV, 2013, A glossary of theories for understanding policymaking, Epidemiology and Community Health 67, 2, 198–202
60. Stoneham, M, Dodds, J, 2014, An exploratory study identifying where local government public health decision makers source their evidence for policy, Health Promotion Journal of Australia 25, 2, 139–42
61. Tabak, RG, Eyler, AA, Dodson, EA, Brownson, RC, 2015, Accessing evidence to inform public health policy: A study to enhance advocacy, Public Health 129, 6, 698–704
62. Tetroe, JM, Graham, ID, Foy, R, Robinson, N, Eccles, MP,Wensing, M, Durieux, P, Légaré, F, Nielson, CP,Adily,A,Ward, JE, Porter, C, Shea, B, Grimshaw, JM, 2008, Health research funding agencies’support and promotion of knowledge translation: An international study, Milbank Quaterly 86, 1, 125–55
63. Thomson, H, 2013, Improving utility of evidence synthesis for healthy public policy: The three Rs (relevance, rigor, and readability [and resources]), American Journal of Public Health 103, 8, e17–23
64. Tricco, AC, Cardoso, R, Thomas, SM, Motiwala, S, Sullivan, S, Kealey, MR, Hemmelgarn, B, Ouimet, M, Hillmer, MP, Perrier, L, Shepperd, S, Straus, SE, 2016,Barriers and facilitators to uptake of systematic reviews by policymakers and healthcare managers:A scoping review, Implementation Science 11, 4
65. Tuohy, CH, Flood, CM, Stabile, M, 2004, How does private finance affect public healthcare systems? Marshalling the evidence from OECD nations, Health Politics, Policy and Law 29, 3, 359–96
66. Turner, JC, 1991, Mapping social psychology series, in Turner, JC (ed) Social influence, Belmont, CA:Thomson Brooks / Cole Publishing
67. Upshur, REG, 2012, Evidence and ethics in public health:The experience of SARS in Canada, NSW Public Health Bulletin 23, 5–6, 108–10
68. Van de Ven, AH, Johnson, PE, 2006, Knowledge for theory and practice. Academy of Management Review 31, 4, 802–21
69. Ward, M, Mowat, D, 2012, Creating an organizational culture for evidence-informed decision making, Healthcare Management Forum 25, 3, 146–50
70. Wathen, CN, Sibbald, SL, Jack, SM, Macmillan, HL, 2011, Talk, trust, and time: A longitudinal study evaluating knowledge translation and exchange processes for research on violence against women, Implementation Science 6, 102
71. Weiss, CH, 1979, The many meanings of research utilization, Public Administration Review 39, 5, 426–31
72. Wilson, M, Lavis, J, Grimshaw, J, 2012, Supporting the use of research evidence in the Canadian health sector, Healthcare Quarterly 15, Special Issue, 58–62
73. Wimmelmann, CL, 2017, Performing compliance:The work of local policy workers during the implementation of national health promotion guidelines, Evidence & Policy 13, 3, 417–32
74. Woolf, SH, Purnell, JQ, Simon, SM, Zimmerman, EB, Camberos, GJ, Haley,A, Fields, RP, 2015,Translating evidence into population health improvement: Strategies and barriers, Annual Review of Public Health 36, 463–82
75. Yost, J, Dobbins, M, Traynor, R, DeCorby, K, Workentine, S, Greco, L, 2014, Tools to support evidence-informed public health decision making, BMC Public Health 14, 728
76. Yousefi-Nooraei, R, Dobbins, M, Brouwers, M, Wakefield, P, 2012, Information seeking for making evidence-informed decisions:A social network analysis on the staff of a public health department in Canada, BMC Health Services Research 12, 118
77. Yousefi-Nooraei, R, Dobbins, M, Alexandra, M, 2014, Social and organizational factors affecting implementation of evidence-informed practice in a public health department in Ontario:A network modelling approach, Implementation Science 9, 29
78. Zardo, P, Collie, A, Livingstone, C, 2014, External factors affecting decision making and use of evidence in an Australian public health policy environment, Social Science & Medicine 108, 120–7
79. Zardo,P,Collie,A,2014a,Measuring use of research evidence in public health policy: A policy content analysis, BMC Public Health 14, 496
80. Zardo,P,Collie,A,2014b,Predicting research use in a public health policy environment: Results of a logistic regression analysis, Implementation Science 9, 142
81. Zardo, P, Collie,A, 2015,Type, frequency and purpose of information used to inform public health policy and program decision making, BMC Public Health 15, 381