Death, injury and disability from kinetic impact projectiles in crowd-control settings: A systematic review

BMJ Open

Volumn 7, Issue 12, 2017, Pages

  Haar, Rohini J ^a   Iacopino, Vincent ^b   Ranadive, Nikhil ^c   Dandu, Madhavi ^d   Weiser, Sheri D ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b Physicians for Human Rights   (United States)

^c EMORY UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

crowd control; less lethal weapons; plastic bullets; protests; riot; rubber bullets

Indexed keywords

PLASTIC; RUBBER;

BULLET; CROWD CONTROL; CROWDING (AREA); DEATH; DISABILITY; GUNSHOT INJURY; HEAD AND NECK INJURY; HEALTH CARE ACCESS; HUMAN; INJURY SEVERITY; KINETICS; LIMB INJURY; LITERATURE; MEDICAL CARE; MEDLINE; REVIEW; RISK FACTOR; SCOPUS; SKIN INJURY; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; CONFLICT; GLOBAL HEALTH; INJURY SCALE; LAW ENFORCEMENT; MORTALITY; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA; VIOLENCE;

CROWDING; DISSENT AND DISPUTES; GLOBAL HEALTH; HUMANS; LAW ENFORCEMENT; TRAUMA SEVERITY INDICES; VIOLENCE; WOUNDS, GUNSHOT;

EID: 85050284169     PISSN: None     EISSN: 20446055     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018154     Document Type: Review

References (63)

1. Global Database of Events, Language and Tone. The GDELT Project. http:// gdeltproject. org/
2. Ortiz I, Burke S, Berrada M, et al. World Protests 2006-2013, IPD/FES Working Paper, 2013. http:// policydialogue. org/ files/ publications/ World- Protests- 2006-2013-Complete- and- Final- 4282014. pdf
3. Payne-James JJ, Rivers E, Green P, et al. Trends in less-lethal use of force techniques by police services within England and Wales: 2007-2011. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2014;10:50-5.
4. Alpert GP, Dunham RG. Understanding police use of force: Officers, suspects, and reciprocity: Cambridge University Press, 2004. http:// w ww. s co pus. c om/inward/re cord. url?e id= 2-s2. 0-8 4922 9181 80&p artn erID =40&m d5= 002 5588 c09b911 e490bb9808d9d8fd03.
5. Bylander J, Unrest C. Police Use Of Force, And The Public's Health. Health Aff 2015;34:1264-8.
6. Downs RL. Less lethal weapons: a technologist's perspective. Policing 2007;30:358-84.
7. Vilke GM, Chan TC. Less lethal technology: medical issues. Policing: 2007;30:341-57.
8. Hughes E, Osborne R, ed, A Guidebook for Less-Lethal Devices: Planning for, Selecting, and Implementing Technology Solutions. First. U. S. National Institute of Justice. Weapons Protective Systems Technologies Center, 2010.
9. Gobinet P. Procurement Policy: Police Use of Emerging Weapons Technology. In: States of Security. Geneva, Switzerland: Cambridge University Press, 2011:68-99. http://www. smallarmssurvey. org/ fileadmin/ docs/ H-Research- Notes/ SAS-Research-Note-8. pdf. (accessed 3 Dec 2014).
10. Global Non-Lethal Weapons Market 2015-2019. Techinavio 2015. http://www. reportlinker. com/ p01911331-summary/ Global-Nonlethal-Weapons-Market. html.
11. Omega Research Foundation, Amnesty International. The Human Rights Impact of Less Lethal Weapons and Other Law Enforcement Equipment. London, UK: Amnesty International, 2015.
12. U. S. Department of Justice. Review of the Department of Justice's Use of Less Lethal Weapons. 2009 https:// oig. justice. gov/ reports/ plus/ e0903/ final. pdf.
13. Crowley M. Regulation of Riot Control Agents and Incapacitants Under the Chemical Weapons Convention. http://www. omegaresearchfoundation. org/ assets/ downloads/ publ icat ions/ 02. pdf (accessed 3 Dec 2014).
14. Maiden N. Ballistics reviews: mechanisms of bullet wound trauma. Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2009;5:204-9.
15. Hollerman JJ, Fackler ML, Coldwell DM, et al. Gunshot wounds: 1. Bullets, ballistics, and mechanisms of injury. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1990;155:685-90.
16. Bir C, Biomechanics BI. Accidental Injury: biomechanics and prevention. New York: Springer New York, 2015:829. 39. http:// link. springer. com/ chapter/.
17. Omega Research Foundation. Crowd Control Technologies: An appraisal of technologies for political control. Manchester, UK: European Parliament, Directorate General for Research, 2000. The STOA Programme. http://www. omegaresearchfoundation. org/ assets/ downloads/ publications / 19 9914 01a- en. pdf. (accessed 3 Dec 2014).
18. Metress EK, Metress SP. The anatomy of plastic bullet damage and crowd control. Int J Health Serv 1987;17:333-42.
19. Millar R, Rutherford WH, Johnson S, et al. Injuries caused by rubber bullets: a report on 90 patients. Br J Surg 1975;62:480-6.
20. Rocke L. Injuries caused by plastic bullets compared with those caused by rubber bullets. Lancet 1983;1:919-20.
21. The Associated Press. Spain: Police Fired Rubber Bullets at Migrants: N. Y. Times, 2014. http://www. nytimes. com/ 2014/ 02/ 22/ world/ europe/ spain-police-fired-rubber-bullets-at-migrants. html. (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
22. Cohen G. "Israeli Troops Use Rubber Bullets Against IDF Regulations. ". Haaretz. 2014 http://www. haaretz. com/ news/ diplomacy-defense/ 1. 596208 (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
23. South African police fire rubber bullets at school protest: Reuters, 2015. ht tp://www. reut ers. co m/a rticle/2 015/08/ 18/u s-sa fric a-un restidUSKCN0 QN16020150818. (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
24. Jr TF AM, Myers AL, et al. Riots, looting in Baltimore over man's death in police custody: WAVY-TV. http:// wavy. com/ 2015/ 04/ 27/ latest-on-police-custody-death-officers-hurt-at-mall-riot/. (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
25. Huffington Post. Ferguson Police Reportedly Shot A Female Pastor. http://www. huffingtonpost. com/ 2014/ 08/ 14/ ferguson-pastor-shotpolice-rubber-bullet- n- 5678973. html. (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
26. International Business Time. Migrant crisis: Hungary approves use of army, rubber bullets and tear gas against refugees. http://www. ibtimes. co. uk/ migrant-crisis-hungary-approves-use-army-rubberbullets-tear-gas-against-refugees-1520596 (accessed 24 Sep 2015).
27. Turkish police use tear gas, water cannon to disperse protest in Ankara-daily. BBC Monit Eur-Polit Supplied BBC Worldw Monit, 2013.
28. Venezuelan opposition march broken up with tear gas-daily. BBC Summ WORLD BROADCAST, 2009.
29. U. S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs. National Institute of Justice. Police Use of Force, Tasers and Other Less-Lethal Weapons. Washington, D. C: U. S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs. National Institute of Justice, 2011. https://www. ncjrs. gov/ pdffiles1/ nij/ 232215. pdf.
30. Nolan B, Ackery A. Collaborating With Police in the Emergency Department While Maintaining Patient Confidentiality: How Can We Improve? CJEM 2015;17:437-42.
31. Atkinson H, Sollom R. Weaponizing Tear Gas: Bahrain's Unprecedented Use of Toxic Chemical Agents Against Civilians. Boston, MA: Physicians for Human Rights, 2012. https:// s3. amazonaws. com/ PHR- Reports/ Bahrain-TearGas-Aug2012-small. pdf. (accessed 3 Dec 2014).
32. Vilke GM, Chan TC. Less lethal technology: medical issues. Polic Int J Police Strateg Manag 2007;30:341-57.
33. Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med 2009;6:e1000097.
34. NIH-National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Quality assessment tool for case series studies. 2014 http://www. nhlbi. nih. gov/ healthpro/ guidelines/ in-develop/ cardiovascular-risk-reduction/ tools/ case- series (accessed 18 Apr 2015).
35. Balouris CA. Rubber and plastic bullet eye injuries in Palestine. Lancet 1990;335:415.
36. de Brito D, Challoner KR, Sehgal A, et al. The injury pattern of a new law enforcement weapon: the police bean bag. Ann Emerg Med 2001;38:383-90.
37. Elder MJ. Penetrating eye injuries in children of the West Bank and Gaza strip. Eye 1993;7:429-32.
38. Lavy T, Asleh SA. Ocular rubber bullet injuries. Eye 2003;17:821-4.
39. Maguire K, Hughes DM, Fitzpatrick MS, et al. Injuries caused by the attenuated energy projectile: the latest less lethal option. Emerg Med J 2007;24:103-5.
40. Mahajna A, Aboud N, Harbaji I, et al. Blunt and penetrating injuries caused by rubber bullets during the Israeli-Arab conflict in a retrospective study. The Lancet 2000;2002:1795-800.
41. Schnitzker JJ. Gunshot injuries with plastic bullets treated in a small community hospital in the gaza strip. Physicians Soc Responsib Q 1992;2:25.
42. Sutter FK. Ocular injuries caused by plastic bullet shotguns in Switzerland. Injury 2004;35:963-7.
43. Suyama J, Panagos PD, Sztajnkrycer MD, et al. Injury patterns related to use of less-lethal weapons during a period of civil unrest. J Emerg Med 2003;25:219-27.
44. Wani ML, Ahangar AG, Ganie FA, et al. Pattern, presentation and management of vascular injuries due to pellets and rubber bullets in a conflict zone. J Emerg Trauma Shock 2013;6:155-8.
45. Hirshberg A, Or J, Stein M, et al. Transaxial gunshot injuries. J Trauma 1996;41:460-1.
46. Hiss J, Hellman FN, Kahana T. Rubber and plastic ammunition lethal injuries: the Israeli experience. Med Sci Law 1997;37:139-44.
47. Jaouni ZM, O'Shea JG. Surgical management of ophthalmic trauma due to the Palestinian Intifada. Eye 1997;11:392-7.
48. Khan S, Maqbool A, Abdullah N, et al. Pattern of ocular injuries in stone pelters in Kashmir valley. Saudi J Ophthalmol 2012;26:327-30.
49. Mir M, Malik U, Buch M, et al. Is Use Of Rubber Bullets Justified? Internet J Surg 2013;29 https:// ispub. com/ IJS/ 29/ 1/ 14477
50. Paret G, Dekel B, Yellin A, et al. Pediatric craniocerebral wounds from plastic bullets: prognostic implications, course, and outcome. J Trauma 1996;41:859-63.
51. Ritchie AJ. Plastic bullets: significant risk of serious injury above the diaphragm. Injury 1992;23:265-6.
52. Schnitzer JJ, Fitzgerald D. Peripheral vascular injuries from plastic bullets in children. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1993;176:172-4.
53. Yellin A, Golan M, Klein E, et al. Penetrating thoracic wounds caused by plastic bullets. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1992;103:381-5.
54. Hubbs K. Less-lethal munitions as extended-range impact weapons. 1997; 37:42.
55. Ritchie AJ, Gibbons JR. Life threatening injuries to the chest caused by plastic bullets. BMJ 1990;301:1027.
56. Sharma AK, Shah DN, Shrestha JK, et al. Ocular injuries in the people's uprising of April 2006 in Kathmandu, Nepal. Nepal J Ophthalmol 2014;6:71-9.
57. Hughes D, Maguire K, Dunn F, et al. Plastic baton round injuries. Emerg Med J 2005;22:111-2.
58. Dhar SA, Dar TA, Wani SA, et al. Pattern of rubber bullet injuries in the lower limbs: a report from Kashmir. Chin J Traumatol 2016;19:129-33.
59. Unuvar U, Yilmaz D, Ozyildirim I, et al. Usage of Riot Control Agents and other methods resulting in physical and psychological injuries sustained during civil unrest in Turkey in 2013. J Forensic Leg Med 2017;45:47-52.
60. United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders. Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials. 1990 http://www. ohchr. org/ Documents/ ProfessionalInterest/ firearms. pdf (accessed 5 Dec 2014).
61. General Assembly. Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials. 1979 h ttp://www. ohchr. org/E N/Prof essi onal Inte rest /Pages/ LawEnfor cement Offi cials. aspx (accessed 5 Dec 2014).
62. Cappitelli P. POST Guidelines: Crowd management, intervention, and control. Sacramento, CA: Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, 2012.
63. Steele JA, McBride SJ, Kelly J, et al. Plastic bullet injuries in Northern Ireland: experiences during a week of civil disturbance. J Trauma 1999;46:711-4.