Eco-efficiency analysis of Spanish WWTPs using the LCA+DEA method

Water Research

Volumn 68, Issue , 2015, Pages 651-666

  Lorenzo Toja, Yago ^a   Vázquez Rowe, Ian ^a,b   Chenel, Sergio ^c   Marín Navarro, Desirée ^c   Moreira, María Teresa ^a   Feijoo, Gumersindo ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SANTIAGO DE COMPOSTELA   (Spain)

^b PONTIFICIA UNIVERSIDAD CATÓLICA DEL PERÚ   (Peru)

^c Water Technology Centre ^*  (Spain)

Author keywords

Data envelopment analysis; Eutrophication; Life cycle assessment; Wastewater

Indexed keywords

DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS; EUTROPHICATION; GREENHOUSE GASES; WASTEWATER TREATMENT;

ANALYSIS METHOD; CASE-STUDIES; ECO-EFFICIENCY; ECO-EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS; ENERGY; ENVIRONMENTAL BENCHMARKS; GREENHOUSES GAS; LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT; OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCIES; WASTE WATER TREATMENT PLANTS;

LIFE CYCLE;

DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS; ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS; EFFICIENCY MEASUREMENT; EUTROPHICATION; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; SEWAGE TREATMENT;

ARTICLE; ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT; EUTROPHICATION; LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT; MODEL; SPAIN; WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT; WASTE WATER TREATMENT PLANT; ALGORITHM; ANALYSIS; CHEMISTRY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; POLLUTION; PROCEDURES; REPRODUCIBILITY; SEWAGE; THEORETICAL MODEL; WASTE WATER; WATER QUALITY;

SPAIN;

SEWAGE; WASTE WATER;

ALGORITHMS; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION; EUTROPHICATION; MODELS, THEORETICAL; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SEWAGE; SPAIN; WASTE DISPOSAL, FLUID; WASTE WATER; WATER QUALITY;

EID: 85047592151     PISSN: 00431354     EISSN: 18792448     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2014.10.040     Document Type: Article

References (66)

1. AQUAENVEC Assessment and Improvement of the Urban Water Cycle Eco-efficiency using LCA and LCC 2012, Environment LIFE Programme, European Commission. Available at:. http://www.life-aquaenvec.eu/.
2. Asmild M., Paradi J.C., Aggarwall V., Schaffnit C. Combining DEA window analysis with the Malmquist index approach in a study of the Canadian banking industry. J. Product. Anal. 2004, 21:67-89.
3. Avadí Á., Vázquez-Rowe I., Fréon P. Eco-efficiency assessment of the Peruvian anchoveta steel and wooden fleets using the LCA+DEA framework. J. Clean. Prod. 2014, 70:118-131.
4. Balkema A.J., Preisig H.A., Otterpohl R., Lambert F.J.D. Indicators for the sustainability assessment of wastewater treatment systems. Urban Water 2002, 4:153-161.
5. Banker R., Charnes A., Copper W. Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis. Manage. Sci. 1984, 30:1078-1092.
6. Bare J.C., Hofstetter P., Pennington D.W., Haes H.a.U. Midpoints versus endpoints: the sacrifices and benefits. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2000, 5:319-326.
7. Byrnes J., Crase L., Dollery B., Villano R. The relative economic efficiency of urban water utilities in regional New South Wales and Victoria. Resour. Energy Econ. 2010, 3:439-455.
8. Charnes A., Clark C.T., Cooper W.W., Golany B. A developmental study of data envelopment analysis in measuring the efficiency of maintenance units in the U.S. Air Forces. Ann. Oper. Res. 1985, 2:95-112.
9. Cooper W.W., Seiford L.M., Tone K. Data Envelopment Analysis: a Comprehensive Text with Models, Applications, References and DEA-solver Software 2007, Springer, New York.
10. Doka G. MIXTRI 2.0 - an MS Excel 97 VBA Macro to Draw LCA Results in a Mixing Triangle (Aka Ternary Plot) 2011, Zurich, (accessed 15.01.11.). http://www.doka.ch/EI99/mixtri.htm, 2.0 ed.
11. Domínguez D., Gujer W. Evolution of a wastewater treatment plant challenges traditional design concepts. Water Res. 2006, 40:1389-1396.
12. Emmerson R.H.C., Morse G.K., Lester J.N., Edge D.R. The life-cycle analysis of small-scale sewage-treatment processes. Water Environ. J. 1995, 9:317-325.
13. Frischknecht R., Jungbluth N., Althaus H.J., Doka G., Heck T., Hellweg S., Hischier R., Nemecek T., Rebitzer G., Spielmann M., Wernet G. Overview and Methodology 2007, Ecoinvent report No. 1, Swiss Centre for Life Cycle Inventories, Dübendorf, Switzerland.
14. Gallego A., Hospido A., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Environmental performance of wastewater treatment plants for small populations. Resour. Conserv. Recy. 2008, 52:931-940.
15. Garnier J., Brion N., Callens J., Passy P., Deligne C., Billen G., Servais P., Billen C. Modeling historical changes in nutrient delivery and water quality of the Zenne river (1790s-2010): the role of land use, waterscape and urban wastewater management. J. Mar. Syst. 2013, 128:62-76.
16. Godin D., Bouchard C., Vanrolleghem P.A. Net environmental benefit: introducing a new LCA approach on wastewater treatment systems. Water Sci. Technol. 2012, 65:1624-1631.
17. Goedkoop M., Heijungs R., Huijbregts M., de Schryver A., Struijs J., van Zelm R. ReCiPe 2008. A Life Cycle Impact Assessment Method Which Comprises Harmonised Category Indicators at the Midpoint and the Endpoint Level 2009, Report I: Characterisation, Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment (VROM), Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment (VROM). http://www.lcia-recipe.info.
18. Goedkoop M., de Schryver A., Oele M., Durksz S., de Roest D. Introduction to LCA with SimaPro 7 2010, Pré Consultants, Retrieved from, Last accessed: May 25th 2014. http://www.pre-sustainability.com/download/manuals/SimaPro7IntroductionToLCA.pdf.
19. Gracia-Lor E., Sancho J.V., Serrano R., Hernández F. Occurrence and removal of pharmaceuticals in wastewater treatment plants at the Spanish Mediterranean area of Valencia. Chemosphere 2012, 87:453-462.
20. Hauschild M.Z., Goedkoop M., Guinée J., Heijungs R., Huijbregts M., Jolliet O., Margni M., De Schryver A., Humbert S., Laurent A., Sala S., Pant R. Identifying best existing practice for characterization modeling in life cycle impact assessment. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2013, 18:683-697.
21. Hernández-Sancho F., Sala-Garrido R. Technical efficiency and cost analysis in wastewater treatment processes: a DEA approach. Desalination 2009, 249(1):230-234.
22. Hofstetter P., Braunschweig A., Mettier T., Müller-Wenk R., Tietje O. The mixing triangle: correlation and graphical decision support for LCA-based comparisons. J. Ind. Ecol. 1999, 3:97-115.
23. Høibye L., Clauson-Kaas J., Wenzel H., Larsen H.F., Jacobsen B.N., Dalgaard O. Sustainability assessment of advanced wastewater treatment technologies. Water Sci. Technol. 2008, 58:963-968.
24. Hopkins L.N., Lant P.a, Newell R.B. Increasing flexibility in the design of wastewater treatment processes. Water Environ. Res. 2001, 73:486-493.
25. Hospido A., Moreira M.T., Fernández-Couto M., Feijoo G. Environmental performance of a municipal wastewater treatment plant. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2004, 9:261-271.
26. Hospido A., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. LCA Case Studies a Comparison of Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants for Big Centres of Population in Galicia ( Spain ) 2008, vol. 13:57-64.
27. Hospido A., Carballa M., Moreira M., Omil F., Lema J.M., Feijoo G. Environmental assessment of anaerobically digested sludge reuse in agriculture: potential impacts of emerging micropollutants. Water Res. 2010, 44:3225-3233.
28. Igos E., Benetto E., Venditti S., Kohler C., Cornelissen A., Moeller R., Biwer A. Is it better to remove pharmaceuticals in decentralized or conventional wastewater treatment plants? A life cycle assessment comparison. Sci. Total Environ. 2012, 438:533-540.
29. Iribarren D., Vázquez-Rowe I., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Further potentials in the joint implementation of Life Cycle Assessment and Data Envelopment Analysis. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408:5265-5272.
30. Iribarren D., Hospido A., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Benchmarking environmental and operational parameters through eco-efficiency criteria for dairy farms. Sci. Total Environ. 2011, 409:1786-1798.
31. Iribarren D., Martín-Gamboa M., Dufour J. Environmental benchmarking of wind farms according to their operational performance. Energy 2013, 61:589-597.
32. Iribarren D., Vázquez-Rowe I., Rugani B., Benetto E. On the feasibility of using emergy analysis as a source of benchmarking criteria through data envelopment analysis: a case study for wind energy. Energy 2014, 67:527-537.
33. ISO ISO 14040. Environmental Management and Life Cycle Assessment - Principles and Framework 2006, International Organization for Standardization.
34. ISO ISO 14044. Environmental Management and Life Cycle Assessment - Requirements and Guidelines 2006, International Organization for Standardization.
35. Lundin M., Bengtsson M., Molander S. Life cycle assessment of wastewater systems: influence of system boundaries and scale on calculated environmental loads. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2000, 34:180-186.
36. Macleod C.J.A., Haygarth P.M. Integrating water and agricultural management under climate change. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408:5619-5622.
37. Marques R.C., Monteiro A. Measuring productivity and efficiency of water and sewerage utilities. A Factor Productivity Approach, II International Conference: Efficiency Use and Management of Urban Water Supply. Tenerife, Spain 2003.
38. Metcalf & Eddy Inc Wastewater Engineering. Treatment and Reuse 2003, McGraw-Hill, New York. fourth ed.
39. Ministry of the Environment - Spain Banco publico de indicadores ambientales. Depuracion de aguas residuales urbanas. Grado de conformidad de la carga contaminante de aguas residuales tratadas en estaciones depuradoras segun Directiva 91/271/CE 2014.
40. Mohammadi A., Dalgaard T., Trydeman Knudsen M., Rafiee S., Mousavi-Avval S.H., Hermansen J.E. Potential greenhouse gas emission reductions in soybean farming: a combined use of life cycle assessment and data envelopment analysis. J. Clean. Prod. 2013, 54:89-100.
41. Molinos-Senante M., Hernández-Sancho F., Sala-Garrido R. Cost-benefit analysis of water-reuse projects for environmental purposes: a case study for Spanish wastewater treatment plants. J. Environ. Manage. 2011, 92:3091-3097.
42. Molinos-Senante M., Hernández-Sancho F., Sala-Garrido R., Cirelli G. Economic feasibility study for intensive and extensive wastewater treatment considering greenhouse gases emissions. J. Environ. Manage. 2013, 123:98-104.
43. Muñoz J., Caus J.M. Maximizing the environmental benefits in the operation of a WWTP of a seaside tourist area. Technical Workshop: the Integration of Reclaimed Water in Water Resource Management, Lloret Del Mar, Spain 2005.
44. Muñoz I., Rodríguez A., Rosal R., Fernández-Alba A.R. Life Cycle Assessment of urban wastewater reuse with ozonation as tertiary treatment: a focus on toxicity-related impacts. Sci. Total Environ. 2009, 407(4):1245-1256.
45. Ortiz M., Raluy R.G., Serra L. Life cycle assessment of water treatment technologies: wastewater and water-reuse in a small town. Desalination 2007, 204:121-131.
46. Pai T.Y., Yang P.Y., Wang S.C., Lo M.H., Chiang C.F., Kuo J.L., Chu H.H., Su H.C., Yu L.F., Hu H.C., Chang Y.H. Predicting effluent from the wastewater treatment plant of industrial park based on fuzzy network and influent quality. Appl. Math. Model. 2011, 35:3674-3684.
47. Pasqualino J.C., Meneses M., Abella M., Castells F. LCA as a decision support tool for the environmental improvement of the operation of a municipal wastewater treatment plant. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43:3300-3307.
48. Pasqualino J.C., Meneses M., Castells F. Life Cycle Assessment of urban wastewater reclamation and reuse alternatives. J. Ind. Ecol. 2011, 15:49-63.
49. Red Eléctrica Española (REE) El sistema eléctrico español 2011 (Spanish Electric System 2011) 2011, Red Eléctrica de España, Alcobendas, Madrid (Spain).
50. Rodríguez-Garcia G., Molinos-Senante M., Hospido, Hernández-Sancho F., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Environmental and economic profile of six typologies of wastewater treatment plants. Water Res. 2011, 45:5997-6010.
51. Rodríguez-Garcia G., Molinos-Senante M., Hospido A., Hernández-Sancho F., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Environmental and economic performance of wastewater treatment plants: comparison between Atlantic and Mediterranean scenarios. IWA Spec. Conf. Water Ind 2011.
52. Saal D.S., Parker D. The impact of privatization and regulation on the water and sewerage industry in England and Wales: a Translog cost function model. Manage. Decis. Econ. 2000, 21:253-268.
53. Saal D.S., Parker D. Productivity and price performance in the privatized water and sewerage companies of England and Wales. J. Regul. Econ. 2001, 20:61-90.
54. Saitech Data Envelopment Analysis Software 2014, Available from:, (accessed 28.05.14.). http://www.saitech-inc.com/Products/Prod-DSP.asp.
55. Sala-Garrido R., Hernández-Sancho F., Molinos-Senante M. Assessing the efficiency of wastewater treatment plants in an uncertain context: a DEA with tolerances approach. Environ. Sci. Pol. 2012, 18:34-44.
56. Schmidheiny S. Changing Course e a Global Business Perspective on Development and the Environment 1992, World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD).
57. Schmidheiny S., Stigson B. Eco-efficiency: Creating More Value with Less Impact 2000, WBCSD: World Business Council for Sustainable Development. http://www.wbcsd.org/web/publications/eco_efficiency_creating_more_value.pdf.
58. Silva C., Quadros S., Ramalho P., Alegre H., Rosa M.J. Translating removal efficiencies into operational performance indices of wastewater treatment plants. Water Res. 2014, 10.1016/j.watres.2014.03.025.
59. Thrall R. Duality, classification and slacks in DEA. Ann. Oper. Res. 1996, 66:109-138.
60. Tillman A.-M., Svingby M., Lundström H. Life cycle assessment of municipal waste water systems. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 1998, 3:145-157.
61. Tone K. A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 2001, 130:498-509.
62. Vázquez-Rowe I., Iribarren D. Life-cycle benchmarking approaches oriented towards energy policy making: launching the CFP+DEA method. Sci. World J. 2014, 10.1155/2014/813921.
63. Vázquez-Rowe I., Tyedmers P. Identifying the importance of the "skipper effect" within sources of measured inefficiency in fisheries through data envelopment analysis (DEA). Mar. Policy 2013, 38:387-396.
64. Vázquez-Rowe I., Iribarren D., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Combined application of life cycle assessment and data envelopment analysis as a methodological approach for the assessment of fisheries. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2010, 15:272-283.
65. Vázquez-Rowe I., Iribarren D., Hospido A., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Computation of operational and environmental benchmarks within selected Galician fishing fleets (NW Spain). J. Ind. Ecol. 2011, 15:776-795.
66. Vázquez-Rowe I., Villanueva-Rey P., Iribarren D., Moreira M.T., Feijoo G. Joint life cycle assessment and data envelopment analysis of grape production for vinification in the Rías Baixas appellation (NW Spain). J. Clean. Prod. 2012, 27:92-102.