Major limitations to achieving “4 per 1000” increases in soil organic carbon stock in temperate regions: Evidence from long-term experiments at Rothamsted Research, United Kingdom

Global Change Biology

Volumn 24, Issue 6, 2018, Pages 2563-2584

  Poulton, Paul ^a   Johnston, Johnny ^a   Macdonald, Andy ^a   White, Rodger ^a   Powlson, David ^a  

^a ROTHAMSTED RESEARCH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

4 per 1000; carbon sequestration; climate change mitigation; long term experiments; management practices; organic amendments; Rothamsted; soil organic carbon

Indexed keywords

CARBON SEQUESTRATION; CLIMATE CHANGE; EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; MANAGEMENT PRACTICE; ORGANIC CARBON; SOIL AMENDMENT; SOIL ORGANIC MATTER; SOIL QUALITY; TEMPERATE ENVIRONMENT;

ENGLAND; HERTFORDSHIRE; ROTHAMSTED EXPERIMENTAL STATION; UNITED KINGDOM;

CARBON;

AGRICULTURE; CARBON SEQUESTRATION; CHEMISTRY; ENGLAND; PROCEDURES; SOIL;

AGRICULTURE; CARBON; CARBON SEQUESTRATION; ENGLAND; SOIL;

EID: 85042555981     PISSN: 13541013     EISSN: 13652486     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/gcb.14066     Document Type: Article

References (82)

1. Albanito, F., Beringer, T., Corstanje, R., Poulter, B., Stephenson, A., Zawadzka, J., & Smith, P. (2016). Carbon implications of converting cropland to bioenergy crops or forest for climate mitigation: A global assessment. Global Change Biology Bioenergy, 8, 81–95. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcbb.12242
2. Austin, R. B., Ford, M. A., Morgan, C. L., & Yeoman, D. (1993). Old and modern wheat cultivars compared on the Broadbalk wheat experiment. European Journal of Agronomy, 2, 141–147. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1161-0301(14)80144-5
3. Bajželj, B., Richards, K. S., Allwood, J. M., Smith, P., Dennis, J. S., Curmi, E., & Gilligan, C. A. (2014). Importance of food-demand management for climate mitigation. Nature Climate Change, 4, 924–929. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate2353
4. Baveye, P. C., Berthelin, J., Tessier, D., & Lemaire, G. (2018). The “4 per 1000” initiative: A credibility issue for the soil science community? Geoderma, 309, 118–123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.005
5. Bijaya, K. A., Barrington, S., & Martinez, J. (2006). Predicted growth of world urban food waste and methane production. Waste Management and Research, 24, 421–433. https://doi.org/10.1177/0734242X06067767
6. Blair, N., Faulkner, R. D., Till, A. R., & Poulton, P. R. (2006). Long-term management impacts on soil C, N and physical fertility. Part 1: Broadbalk experiment. Soil Tillage Research, 91, 30–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.still.2005.11.002
7. Brentrup, F., & Pallière, C. (2008). GHG emissions and energy efficiency in European nitrogen fertiliser production and use. Proceeding 639, International Fertiliser Society, York, UK, pp. 26
8. Chabbi, A., Lehmann, J., Ciais, P., Loescher, H. W., Cotrufo, M. F., Don, A., … Rumpel, C. (2017). Aligning agriculture and climate policy. Nature Climate Change, 7, 307–309. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3286
9. Chadwick, D., Wei, J., Yan'an, T., Guanghui, Y., Qirong, S., & Qing, C. (2015). Improving manure nutrient management towards sustainable agricultural intensification in China. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 209, 34–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2015.03.025
10. Chambers, A., Lal, R., & Paustian, K. (2016). Soil carbon sequestration potential of US croplands and grasslands: Implementing the 4 per Thousand Initiative. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 71, 68A–74A. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.71.3.68A
11. Chater, M., & Gasser, J. K. R. (1970). Effects of green manuring, farmyard manure, and straw on the organic matter of soil and of green manuring on available nitrogen. Journal of Soil Science, 21, 127–137. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2389.1970.tb01160.x
12. Copeland, J., & Turley, D. (2008). National and regional supply/demand for agricultural straw in Great Britain. Report prepared for the National Non-Food Crops Centre, York, p. 17.
13. Foged, L. H., Flotats, X., Blasi, A. B., Palatsi, J., Magri, A., & Schelde, K. M. (2011). Inventory of manure processing activities in Europe. Technical Report No. I concerning “Manure Processing Activities in Europe” to the European Commission, Directorate-General Environment. 138 pp.
14. Fornara, D. A., Steinbeiss, S., McNamara, N. P., Gleixner, G., Oakley, S., Poulton, P. R., … Bardgett, R. D. (2011). Increases in soil organic carbon sequestration can reduce the global warming potential of long-term liming to permanent grassland. Global Change Biology, 17, 1925–1934. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2486.2010.02328.x
15. ® (2016). Sixteenth Edition, © VSN International, Hemel Hempstead, UK.
16. Giller, K. E., Andersson, J. A., Corbeels, M., Kirkegaard, J., Mortensen, D., Erenstein, O., & Vanlauwe, B. (2015). Beyond conservation agriculture. Frontiers in Plant Science, 6, article 870, 1–14.
17. Giller, K. E., Corbeels, M., Nyamangara, J., Triomphe, B., Affholder, F., Scopel, E., & Tittonell, P. (2011). A research agenda to explore the role of conservation agriculture in African smallholder farming systems. Field Crops Research, 124, 468–472. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2011.04.010
18. Glendining, M. J., Powlson, D. S., Poulton, P. R., Bradbury, N. J., Palazzo, D., & Li, X. (1996). The effects of long-term applications of inorganic nitrogen fertilizer on soil nitrogen in the Broadbalk Wheat Experiment. Journal of Agricultural Science, 127, 347–363. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021859600078527
19. Gollany, H. T., Rickman, R. W., Liang, Y., Albrecht, S. L., Machado, S., & Kang, S. (2011). Predicting agricultural management influence on long-term soil organic carbon dynamics: Implications for biofuel production. Agronomy Journal, 103, 234–246. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2010.0203s
20. Goulding, K. W. T., Poulton, P. R., Webster, C. P., & Howe, M. T. (2000). Nitrate leaching from the Broadbalk Wheat Experiment, Rothamsted, UK, as influenced by fertilizer and manure inputs and the weather. Soil Use and Management, 16, 244–250. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-2743.2000.tb00203.x
21. van Groenigen, K. J., Hastings, A., Forristal, D., Roth, B., Jones, M., & Smith, P. (2011). Soil C storage as affected by tillage and straw management: An assessment using field measurements and model predictions. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment, 140, 218–225. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2010.12.008
22. van Groeningen, J. W., van Kessel, C., Hungate, B. A., & Oenema, O. (2017). Powlson DS & van Groeningen KJ (2017) Sequestering soil organic carbon: A nitrogen dilemma. Environmental Science & Technology, 51, 4738–4739. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.7b01427
23. Han, P., Zhang, W., Wang, G., Sun, W., & Huang, Y. (2016). Changes in soil organic carbon in croplands subjected to fertilizer management: A global metaanalysis. Scientific Reports, 6, 27199. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep27199
24. Haynes, R. J., Swift, R. S., & Stephen, R. C. (1991). Influence of mixed cropping rotations (pasture-arable) on organic matter content, water stable aggregation and clod porosity in a group of soils. Soil Tillage Research, 19, 77–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/0167-1987(91)90111-A
25. Hesketh, N., & Brookes, P. C. (2000). Development of an indicator for risk of phosphorus leaching. Journal of Environmental Qualiy, 29, 105–110. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2000.00472425002900010013x
26. Hijbeek, R., van Ittersum, M. K., ten Berge, H. F. M., Gort, G., Spiegel, H., & Whitmore, A. P. (2017). Do organic inputs matter - a meta-analysis of additional yield effects for arable crops in Europe. Plant and Soil, 411, 293–303. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11104-016-3031-x
27. Houot, S., Molina, J. A. E., Chaussod, R., & Clapp, C. E. (1989). Simulation by NCSOIL of net mineralization in soils from the Deherain and 36 Parcelles fields at Grignon. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 53, 451–455. https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1989.03615995005300020023x
28. IUSS Working Group WRB (2015). World Reference Base for Soil Resources 2014, update 2015. International soil classification system for naming soils and creating legends for soil maps. World Soil Resources Reports No. 106. FAO, Rome.
29. Janzen, H. H. (2015). Beyond carbon sequestration: Soil as conduit of solar energy. European Journal of Soil Science, 66, 19–32. https://doi.org/10.1111/ejss.12194
30. Jenkinson, D. S., Poulton, P. R., & Bryant, C. (2008). The turnover of organic carbon in subsoils. Part 1. Natural and bomb radiocarbon in soil profiles from the Rothamsted long-term field experiments. European Journal of Soil Science, 59, 391–399. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2389.2008.01025.x
31. Jenkinson, D. S., & Johnston, A. E. (1977). Soil organic matter in the Hoosfield continuous barley experiment. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1976, Part 2, 87-101. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34448
32. Johnston, A. E. (1973). The effects of ley and arable cropping systems on the amounts of soil organic matter in the Rothamsted and Woburn Ley-Arable experiments. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1972, Part 2, 131-159. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34692
33. Johnston, A. E. (1975). The Woburn Market Garden Experiment, 1942-69: II. The effects of the treatments on soil ph, soil carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1974, Part 2, 102-131. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-33162
34. Johnston, A. E., & Garner, H. V. (1969). The Broadbalk Wheat experiment: historical introduction. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1968, Part 2, 12-25. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34916
35. Johnston, A. E., & Poulton, P. R. (1977). Yields on the exhaustion land and changes in the NPK content of the soils due to cropping and manuring, 1852–1975. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1976, Part 2, 53–85. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34447
36. Johnston, A. E., Poulton, P. R., & Coleman, K. (2009). Soil organic matter: Its importance in sustainable agriculture and carbon dioxide fluxes. Advances in Agronomy, 101, 2–57.
37. Johnston, A. E., Poulton, P. R., Coleman, K., Macdonald, A. J., & White, R. P. (2017). Changes in soil organic matter over 70 years in continuous arable and ley-arable rotations on a sandy loam soil in England. European Journal of Soil Science, 68, 305–316. https://doi.org/101111/ejss.12415
38. Kalembasa, S. J., & Jenkinson, D. S. (1973). Comparative study of titrimetric and gravimetric methods for determination of organic carbon in soil. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 24, 1085–1090. https://doi.org/10.1002/(ISSN)1097-0010
39. Ketcheson, J. W., & Beauchamp, E. G. (1978). Effects of stover, manure and nitrogen on soil properties and crop yield. Agronomy Journal, 70, 792–797. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj1978.00021962007000050003x
40. Ladha, J. K., Reddy, C. K., Padre, A. T., & van Kessel, C. (2011). Role of nitrogen fertilization in sustaining organic matter in cultivated soils. Journal of Environmental Quality, 40, 1756–1766. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2011.0064
41. Lal, R. (2016). Beyond COP21: Potential and challenges of the “4 per Thousand” initiative. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 71, 20A–25A. https://doi.org/10.2489/jswc.71.1.20A
42. Lawes, J. B., & Gilbert, J. H. (1885). On some points in the composition of soils; with results illustrating the sources of the fertility of Manitoba prairie soils. Journal of the Chemical Society, 47, 380–422.
43. Lawes, J. B., & Gilbert, J. H. (1885). The Rothamsted Experiments; being an account of some of the results of the agricultural investigations conducted at Rothamsted, in the field, the feeding shed, and the laboratory, over a period of fifty years. Transactions of the Highland and Agricultural Society of Scotland, Fifth Series, 7, 1–354.
44. Linquist, B., van Groenigen, K. J., Adviento-Borbe, M. A., Pittelkow, C., & van Kessel, C. (2012). An agronomic assessment of greenhouse gas emissions from major cereal crops. Global Change Biology, 18, 194–209. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2486.2011.02502.x
45. Macdonald, A. J., Powlson, D. S., Poulton, P. R., Watts, C. J., Clark, I. M., Storkey, J., … McGrath, S. P. (2015). The Rothamsted long-term experiments. Aspects of Applied Biology, 128, 1–10.
46. Mackey, B., Prentice, I. C., Steffen, W., House, J. I., Lindenmayer, D., Keith, H., & Berry, S. (2013). Untangling the confusion around land carbon science and climate change mitigation policy. Nature Climate Change, 3, 552–558. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate1804
47. Malhi, S. S., & Lemke, R. (2007). Tillage, crop residue and N fertilizer effects on crop yield, nutrient uptake, soil quality and nitrous oxide gas emissions in a second 4-yr rotation cycle. Soil Tillage Research, 96, 269–283. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.still.2007.06.011
48. Mattingly, G. E. G. M., Chater, M., & Poulton, P. R. (1974). The Woburn Organic Manuring Experiment: II. Soil analyses, 1964–72, with special reference to changes in carbon and nitrogen. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1973, Part 2, 134-151. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34636
49. Mattingly, G. E. G. M., Johnston, A. E., & Chater, M. (1969). The residual value of farmyard manure and superphosphate in the Saxmundham rotation II experiment, 1899–1968. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1969, Part 2, 91–112. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34865
50. Minasny, B., Arrouays, D., McBratney, A. B., Angers, D. A., Chambers, A., Chaplot, V., … Winowiecki, L. (2018). Rejoinder to Comments on Minasny et al., 2017 Soil carbon 4 per mille Geoderma, 292, 59–86. Geoderma, 309, 124–129. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.026
51. Minasny, B., Malone, B. P., McBratney, A. B., Angers, D. A., Arrouays, D., Chambers, A., … Field, D. J. (2017). Soil carbon 4 per mille. Geoderma, 292, 59–86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.01.002
52. Piñeiro, G., Jobbágy, E. G., Baker, J., Murray, B. C., & Jackson, R. B. (2009). Set-asides can be better climate investment than corn ethanol. Ecological Applications, 19, 277–282. https://doi.org/10.1890/08-0645.1
53. Poulton, P. R., Pye, E., Hargreaves, P. R., & Jenkinson, D. S. (2003). Accumulation of carbon and nitrogen by old arable land reverting to woodland. Global Change Biology, 9, 942–955. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2486.2003.00633.x
54. Powlson, D. S., Bhogal, A., Chambers, B. J., Macdonald, A. J., Goulding, K. W. T., & Whitmore, A. P. (2012). The potential to increase soil carbon stocks through reduced tillage or organic material additions in England and Wales: A case study. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment, 146, 23–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2011.10.004
55. Powlson, D. S., Glendining, M. J., Coleman, K., & Whitmore, A. P. (2011). Implications for soil properties of removing cereal straw: Results from long-term studies. Agronomy Journal, 103, 279–287. https://doi.org/10.2134/agronj2010.0146s
56. Powlson, D. S., Stirling, C. M., Thierfelder, C., White, R. P., & Jat, M. L. (2016). Does conservation agriculture deliver climate change mitigation through soil carbon sequestration in tropical agro-ecosystems? Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment, 220, 164–174. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2016.01.005
57. Powlson, D. S., Whitmore, A. P., & Goulding, K. W. T. (2011). Soil carbon sequestration to mitigate climate change: A critical re-examination to identify the true and the false. European Journal of Soil Science, 62, 42–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2389.2010.01342.x
58. Rothamsted Research (2006). Guide to the Classical and other Long-term Experiments, Datasets and Sample Archive. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ROTHAMSTED-LONG-TERM-EXPERIMENTS-GUIDE-2006
59. Schlesinger, W. H. (2000). Carbon sequestration in soils: Some cautions amidst optimism. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 82, 121–127. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-8809(00)00221-8
60. Scott, T., Macdonald, A., & Goulding, K. (2014). The U.K. Environmental Change Network, Rothamsted. Physical and Atmospheric Measurements: The first 20 years. Lawes Agricultural Trust, 32 pp. ISBN 978-0-9564424-0-6 (Revised edition, 2015. ISBN 978-0-9564424-1-3).
61. Smith, P. (2004). How long before a change in soil organic carbon can be detected? Global Change Biology, 10, 1878–1883. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2486.2004.00854.x
62. Smith, P. (2014). Do grasslands act as a perpetual sink for carbon? Global Change Biology, 20, 2708–2711. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.12561
63. Smith, P. (2016). Soil carbon sequestration and biochar as negative emission technologies. Global Change Biology, 22, 1315–1324. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.13178
64. Smith, P., Haberl, H., Popp, A., Erb, K. H., Lauk, C., Harper, R., … Rose, S. (2013). How much land-based greenhouse gas mitigation can be achieved without compromising food security and environmental goals? Global Change Biology, 19, 2285–2302. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.12160
65. Smith, P., Martino, D., Cai, Z., Gwary, D., Janzen, H., Kumar, P., … Smith, J. (2008). Greenhouse gas mitigation in agriculture. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 363, 789–813. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2007.2184
66. Snyder, V. A., & Vazquez, M. A. (2005). Structure. In D. Hillell, et al. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of soils in the environment (Vol. 4, pp. 54–68). Oxford, UK: Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B0-12-348530-4/00533-6
67. Song, X., Peng, C., Zhou, G., Jiang, H., & Wang, W. (2014). Chinese Grain for Green Program led to highly increased soil organic carbon levels: A meta-analysis. Scientific Reports, 4, 4460. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep04460
68. Storkey, J., Macdonald, A. J., Bell, J. R., Clark, I. M., Gregory, A. S., Hawkins, N. J., … Whitmore, A. P. (2016). The unique contribution of Rothamsted to ecological research at large temporal scales. In A. J. Dumbrell, R. L. Kordas, & G. Woodward (Eds.), Advances in ecological research (Vol. 55, pp. 3–42), Chapter 1, Cambridge: MA: Academic Press.
69. Thierfelder, C., Cheesman, S., & Rusinamhodzi, L. (2013). Benefits and challenges of crop rotations in maize-based conservation agriculture (CA) cropping systems of southern Africa. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 11, 108–124. https://doi.org/10.1080/14735903.2012.703894
70. Thierfelder, C., & Wall, P. C. (2012). Effects of conservation agriculture on soil quality and productivity in contrasting agro-ecological environments of Zimbabwe. Soil Use and Management., 28, 209–220. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-2743.2012.00406.x
71. Tian, H., Lu, C., Ciais, P., Michalak, A. M., Canadell, J. G., Saikawa, E., … Wofsy, S. C. (2016). The terrestrial biosphere as a net source of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere. Nature, 531, 225–228. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature16946
72. Tinsley, J. (1950). The determination of organic carbon in soils by dichromic mixtures. In: vanBaren F. A., J. Doeksen, W. R. Domingo, J. Ch. L Favejee, H. J. Hardon, E. G. Mulder, P. K. Peerlkamp, A. C. Schuffelen, J. G. Vermaat, W. C. Visser, A. J. Zuur, & J. J. Schuurman (Eds.), Transactions of the 4th International Congress of Soil Science (Vol. 1, pp. 161–164), Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Hoitsema Brothers.
73. UNCCD (2017). The Global Land Outlook, first edition. Bonn, Germany. SBN: 978-92-95110-48-9. Retrieved from https://global-land-outlook.squarespace.com/the-outlook/#the-bokk
74. VandenBygaart, A. J. (2018). Comments on soil carbon 4 per mille by Minasny et al. 2017. Geoderma, 309, 113–114. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.024
75. Verhulst, N., Govaerts, B., Verachtert, E., Castellanos-Navarrete, A., Mezzalama, M., Wall, P., … Sayre, K. D. (2010). Conservation agriculture, improving soil quality for sustainable production systems. In R. Lal, & B. A. Srewart (Eds.), Advances in soil science: Food security and soil quality (pp. 137–208). Boca Roton, FL: CRC Press.
76. de Vries, W. (2018). Soil carbon 4 per mille: A good initiative but let's manage not only the soil but also the expectations. Geoderma, 309, 111–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.023
77. Warren, R. G., & Johnston, A. E. (1964). The Park Grass Experiment. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1963, 240–262. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-38770
78. Watts, C. W., Clark, J., Poulton, P. R., Powlson, D. S., & Whitmore, A. P. (2006). The role of clay, organic carbon and long-term management on mouldboard plough draught measured on the Broadbalk Wheat experiment at Rothamsted. Soil Use and Management, 22, 334–341. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-2743.2006.00054.x
79. White, R. E., Davidson, B., Lam, S. K., & Chen, D. (2018). A critique of the paper ‘Soil carbon 4 per mille' by Minasny et al. (2017). Geoderma, 309, 115–117. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2017.05.025
80. Williams, R. J. B., & Cooke, G. W. (1971). Results of the Rotation I Experiment at Saxmundham, 1964–69. Rothamsted Experimental Station, Report for 1970, Part 2, 68–97. Lawes Agricultural Trust, Harpenden, UK. https://doi.org/10.23637/ERADOC-1-34801
81. Zhang, W. F., Dou, Z. X., He, P., Ju, X. T., Powlson, D., Chadwick, D., … Zhang, F. S. (2013). New technologies reduce greenhouse gas emissions from nitrogenous fertilizer in China. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 110, 8375–8380. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1210447110
82. 2O emission by manure application to agricultural soils may largely offset carbon benefits: A global meta-analysis. Global Change Biology, 23, 4068–4083. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.13648