Zero tolerance drug driving laws in Australia: A gap between rationale and form?

International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy

Volumn 6, Issue 3, 2017, Pages 47-71

  Quilter, Julia ^a   McNamara, Luke ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF WOLLONGONG   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES   (Australia)

Author keywords

Criminalisation; Drug driving; Illicit drugs; Impaired driving; Road safety; Under the influence

Indexed keywords

EID: 85028635764     PISSN: 22027998     EISSN: 22028005     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.5204/ijcjsd.v6i3.416     Document Type: Article

References (84)

1. ACT Police (n.d.) Alcohol and Drug Impaired Driving. Available at https://www.police.act.gov.au/road-safety/safe-driving/alcohol-And-drug-impaired-driving (accessed 2 October 2016).
2. Adams K, Smith L and Hind N (2008) Drug driving among police detainees in Australia. Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice No. 357. Canberra, ACT: Australian Institute of Criminology.
3. Andrews D (2015) 200, 000 tests step up the fight against drug drivers. Media release, 11 October. Premier of Victoria, Minister for Police, The Hon. Daniel Andrews MP. Available at http://www.premier.vic.gov.au/200000-Tests-step-up-The-fight-Against-drug-drivers/(accessed 12 August 2016).
4. Armstrong K, Watling C and Davey J (2014) Deterrence of Drug Driving: The Impact of the ACT Drug Driving Legislation and Detection Techniques. Brisbane, Queensland: Centre for Accident Research and Road Safety - Queensland.
5. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2014) National Drug Strategy Household Survey Detailed Report 2013. Canberra, ACT: AIHW. Available at http://www.aihw.gov.au/WorkArea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=60129549848 (accessed 1 September 2016).
6. Barns G (2016) Australia's drug driving laws are grossly unfair. The Drum (ABC TV), 29 January. Available at http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-01-29/greg-barns-drug-drivinglaws-Are-unfair/7116994 (accessed 2 August 2016).
7. Barone T (2016) Police drug test accuracy in doubt. The West Australian, 8 March. Available at https://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/wa/a/31046715/police-drug-Test-Accuracy-in-doubt/(accessed 14 April 2016).
8. Batchelor P (2003) (Minister for Transport) Second reading speech, Road Safety (Drug Driving) Bill 2003. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Victorian Parliament, 30 October: 1418-1420.
9. Batchelor P (2006) (Minister for Transport) Second reading speech, Road Safety (Drugs) Bill 2006. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Victorian Parliament, 1 March: 389-390.
10. Bondallaz P, Favrat B, Chtioui H, Fornari E, Maeder P and Giroud C (2016) Cannabis and its effects on driving skills. Forensic Science International. Epub ahead of print 16 September. DOI:10.1016/j.forsciint.2016.09.007.
11. Bronitt S and McSherry B (2017) Principles of Criminal Law, 4th edn. Australia: Thomson Reuters.
12. Brown D (2006) Traffic Offences and Accidents, 4th edn. Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths.
13. Brown M (2006) (Parliamentary Secretary) Second reading speech, Road Transport Legislation Amendment (Drug Testing) Bill 2006. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, NSW Parliament, 19 September: 1854-1856.
14. Butler J (2015) Shoalhaven police to test for drug-drivers daily. Illawarra Mercury, 20 July. Available at http://www.illawarramercury.com.au/story/3224147/one-in-five-nabbed-fordrug-driving/(accessed 3 April 2016).
15. Cafaro T (2010) Slipping through the cracks: Why can't we stop drugged driving? Western New England Law Review 32(1): 33-72.
16. Chesher G (1992) The scientific basis for our drink-driving laws: Why we can't approach cannabis and prescribed drugs in the same way. Current Affairs Bulletin 68(10): 4-11.
17. Conlon, P (2005) (Minister for Transport) Second reading speech, Road Traffic (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill 2005. Hansard, House of Assembly, South Australian Parliament, 14 September: 3358-3362.
18. Dawkins K and Briggs M (2008) Criminal law [2008]. New Zealand Law Review: 541-587.
19. Department of Planning, Transport and Infrastructure (n.d.) Towards Zero Together - Drug Driving FAQs. Adelaide, South Australia: South Australian Government. Available at http://www.dpti.sa.gov.au/towardszerotogether/Safer-behaviours/Drug-driving2/drug-driving-faqs (accessed 2 October 2016).
20. Department of Police and Emergency Management (2010) Tasmania Police Manual - Orders, Instructions and Operational Guidance for Members of Tasmania Police. Hobart, Tasmania: Tasmanian Government. Available at http://tasmaniantimes.com/downloads/Tasmania-Police-Manual-RTIInternetVersiondated-11November2010.pdf (accessed 5 August 2016).
21. Department of Transport and Main Roads (2009) Drug Driving Fact Sheet. Brisbane, Queensland: Queensland Government. Available at https://www.police.qld.gov.au/programs/roadSafety/Documents/drug-driving-fact-sheet.pdf (accessed 26 August 2016).
22. Dräger (n.d.) Customer Support for Your DrugTest 5000. Lübeck, Germany: Drägerwerk AG & Co. Available at http://www.draeger.com/sites/enus-us/Pages/Alcohol-And-Drug-Detection/DrugTest-5000-CS.aspx (accessed 15 August 2016).
23. Ducharme P (1975) Impaired driving. Chitty's Law Journal 23(10): 338-355.
24. Elvik R (2013) Risk of road accident associated with the use of drugs: A systematic review and meta-Analysis of evidence from epidemiological studies. Accident Analysis & Prevention 60: 254-267. DOI:10.1016/j.aap.2012.06.017.
25. Farmer L (2014) Criminal law as an institution: Rethinking theoretical approaches to criminalisation. In Duff R, Farmer L, Marshall S, Renzo M and Tadros V (eds) Criminalization: The Political Morality of the Criminal Law: 80-100. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
26. Fell J and Voas R (2014) The effectiveness of a 0.05 blood alcohol concentration (BAC) limit for driving in the United States. Addiction 109(6): 869-874. DOI:10.1111/add.12365.
27. Griffith AF (1968) (Minister for Mines) Second reading speech, Traffic Act Amendment Bill (No.2). Hansard, Legislative Council, Western Australian Parliament, 31 October: 2025-2028.
28. Gulbin M (2016) Drug driving case highlights 'nonsensical' laws. The Northern Star, 15 March. Available at http://www.northernstar.com.au/news/drug-driving-case-highlightsnonsensical-laws/2964281/(accessed 15 March 2016).
29. Hall W and Homel R (2007) Reducing cannabis-impaired driving: Is there sufficient evidence for drug testing of drivers? Addiction 102(12): 1918-9. DOI:10.1111/j.1360-0443.2007.02042.x.
30. Hickey P (2016) WA's drug-driving court convictions reach record levels as meth addiction soars. Perth Now Sunday Times, 14 August. Available at http://www.perthnow.com.au/news/western-Australia/was-drugdriving-court-convictionsreach-record-levels-As-meth-Addiction-soars/newsstory/770febb88932c6ca81a6a649475c9bb9 (accessed 14 August 2016).
31. Hogg R and Brown D (1998) Rethinking Law and Order. London: Pluto Press.
32. Howat P, Sleet D and Smith I (1991) Alcohol and driving: Is the 0.05% blood alcohol concentration justified? Drug Alcohol Review 10(2): 151-166. DOI:10.1080/09595239100185211.
33. Jones C, Donnelly N, Swift W and Weatherburn D (2005) Driving under the influence of cannabis: The problem and potential countermeasures. NSW BOCSAR Crime and Justice Bulletin, No 87. Available at http://www.bocsar.nsw.gov.au/Documents/CJB/cjb87.pdf (accessed 15 September 2016).
34. Kelly E and Dillon P (2005) Drugs and Driving. Sydney, New South Wales: The National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre.
35. Kelly E, Darke S and Ross J (2004) A review of drug use and driving: Epidemiology, impairment, risk factors and risk perceptions. Drug and Alcohol Review 23: 319-344. DOI:10.1080/09595230412331289482.
36. Knox WE (1968) (Minister for Transport) Second reading speech, Traffic Acts Amendment Bill. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Queensland Parliament, 5 April: 3021-3026.
37. Kobelke JC (2006) (Minister for Community Safety) Second reading speech, Road Traffic Amendment (Drugs) Bill 2006. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Western Australian Parliament, 18 October: 7206-7207.
38. Kristoffersen L, Strand D, Liane V, Vindenes V, Tvete I and Aldrin (2016) Determination of safety margins for whole blood concentrations of alcohol and nineteen drugs in driving under the influence cases. Forensic Science International 259: 119-126. DOI:10.1016/j.forsciint.2015.12.009.
39. Lawrence S and Zhou T (2016) Drug driving offences (and defences) in New South Wales. Paper presented at the 2016 Sir Owen Dixon Chambers Floor Conference, 5 March, Sydney, New South Wales. Available at http://www.criminalcle.net.au/attachments/Drug-Driving-Stephen-Lawrence-Ands-Tina-Zhou.pdf (accessed 16 August 2016).
40. Llewellyn D (2005) (Minister for Police and Public Safety) Second reading speech, Road Safety (Alcohol and Drugs) Act Bill 2005. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Tasmanian Parliament, 13 April: 28-30.
41. Lucas PT (2006) (Minister for Transport and Main Roads) Second reading speech, Transport Legislation and Another Act Amendment Bill 2006. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Queensland Parliament, 29 November: 728-731.
42. Mann R, Macdonald S, Stoduto LG, Bondy S, Jonah B and Shaikh A (2001) The effects of introducing or lowering legal per se blood alcohol limits for driving: An international review. Addiction 33: 569-583.
43. McBarnet D (1981) Conviction: The Law, the State and the Construction of Justice. Basingstoke: UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
44. McNamara L (2015) Criminalisation research in Australia: Building a foundation for normative theorising and principled law reform. In Crofts T and Loughnan A (eds) Criminalisation and Criminal Responsibility in Australia: 33-51. Melbourne, Victoria: Oxford University Press.
45. McNamara L and Quilter J (2014) Turning the spotlight on 'offensiveness' as a basis for criminal liability. Alternative Law Journal 39(1): 36-39.
46. McNamara L and Quilter J (2015) Public intoxication in NSW: The contours of criminalisation. Sydney Law Review 37(1): 1-35. Available at https://sydney.edu.au/law/slr/slr-37/slr37-1/SLRv37n1McNamaraQuilter.pdf (accessed 29 May 2017).
47. McNamara L and Quilter J (2016) The 'bikie effect' and other forms of demonisation: The origins and effects of hyper-criminalisation. Law in Context 34(2): 5-35.
48. McNamara L, Quilter J, Seear K and Room R (forthcoming) Evidence of intoxication in Australian criminal courts: A complex variable with multiple effects. Monash University Law Review 43(1).
49. Morris M (1968) (Minister for Transport) Second reading speech, Motor Traffic (Amendment) Bill 1968. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, NSW Parliament, 4 December: 3412-3422.
50. Norwegian Ministry of Transport and Communications (2014) Driving Under the Influence of Non-Alcohol Drugs: Legal Limits Implemented in Norway. Oslo, Norway: Norwegian Ministry of Transport and Communications.
51. NSW Government (2015) New drug driving campaign launched: MDT-There's no escaping it. Media release, Department of Transport, 1 December. Sydney, New South Wales. Available at http://www.transport.nsw.gov.au/newsroom/mediareleases/new-drug-driving-campaign-launched-mdt-Theres-no-escaping-it (accessed 29 May 2017).
52. NSW Police (2015) Random drug testing standard operating procedures. Information released pursuant to a 2015 Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 Application. Sydney, New South Wales.
53. NSW Police (2016) Roadside drug testing. Information release pursuant to a Government Information (Public Access) Act 2009 application. Sydney, New South Wales. Available at http://www.police.nsw.gov.au/services/information-Access-unit-gipa/disclosure-logs/2016 (accessed 12 August 2016).
54. Pritchard J, Matthews AJ, Bruno RB, Rayment K and Cockburn H (2010) Detouring civil liberties? Drug-driving laws in Australia. Griffith Law Review 19(2): 330-349.
55. Queensland Police (2016) Drug driving. Brisbane, Queensland. Available at https://www.police.qld.gov.au/programs/roadsafety/drugdriving.htm (accessed 2 October 2016).
56. Quilter J (2014) One-punch laws, mandatory minimums and 'alcohol-fuelled' as an aggravating factor: Implications for NSW criminal law. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 3(1): 81-106. DOI:10.5204/ijcjsd.v3i1.145.
57. Quilter J (2015) Criminalisation of alcohol-fuelled violence: One-punch laws. In Crofts T and Loughnan A (eds) Criminalisation and Criminal Responsibility in Australia: 82-121. Melbourne, Victoria: Oxford University Press.
58. Quilter J and McNamara L (2013) Time to define 'the cornerstone of public order legislation': The elements of offensive conduct and language under the Summary Offences Act 1988 (NSW). University of New South Wales Law Journal 36(2): 534-562.
59. Quilter J and McNamara L (forthcoming) The meaning of 'intoxication' in Australian criminal cases: Origins and operation. New Criminal Law Review.
60. Quilter J, McNamara L, Seear K and Room R (2016a) Criminal law and the effects of alcohol and other drugs: A national study of the significance of 'intoxication' under Australian legislation. UNSWLJ 39(3): 488-511. Available at http://ro.uow.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3522&context=lhapapers (accessed 29 May 2017).
61. Quilter J, McNamara L, Seear K and Room R (2016b) The definition and significance of 'intoxication' in Australian criminal law: A case study of Queensland's 'safe night out' legislation. QUT Law Review 16(2): 42-58. DOI:10.5204/qutlr.v16i2.654.
62. Ramsey S and Fitzgerald J (2017) Recent trends in arrests for drug driving. NSW BOCSAR Crime and Justice Statistics, No 125. Available at http://www.bocsar.nsw.gov.au/Documents/BB/Report-2017-Recent-Trends-in-Arrests-for-Drug-Driving-BB125.pdf (accessed 30 May 2017).
63. Redfern Legal Centre (2016) NSW Police increase mobile drug testing. Sydney, New South Wales. Available at http://rlc.org.au/article/nsw-police-increase-mobile-drug-Testing (accessed 12 August 2016).
64. Road Safety Commission (2013) FAQ-drug driving. Perth, Western Australia: Western Australian Government. Available at https://rsc.wa.gov.au/Documents/Drug-Driving/orsdrug-driving-faq.aspx (accessed 2 October 2016).
65. Roth A (2015) The uneasy case for marijuana as chemical impairment under a science-based jurisprudence of dangerousness. California Law Review 103(4): 841-917. Available at http://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4294&context=californialawreview (accessed 29 May 2017).
66. Rylah A (1965) (Chief Secretary) Second reading speech, Motor Car (Driving Offence) Bill. Hansard, Legislative Assembly, Victorian Parliament, 19 October: 858-859.
67. Schwartz M (2015) Criminalisation and drugs: What should we do about cannabis? In Crofts T and Loughnan A (eds) Criminalisation and Criminal Responsibility in Australia: 68-81. Melbourne, Victoria: Oxford University Press.
68. Schwartz R, Cohen V and Abramson F (1977) Drugs, driving and the Law: A prospective review. Contemporary Drug Problems 6(3): 283-306.
69. Shoebridge D (2015) Roadside drug testing shouldn't ignore the commonly used drugs that impair driving: prescription medication. The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 October. Available at http://www.smh.com.au/comment/roadside-drug-Testing-shouldnt-ignore-The-commonlyused-drugs-That-impair-driving-prescription-medication-20151019-gkcfex.html (accessed 5 June 2016).
70. Terer K and Brown R (2014) Effective drink driving prevention and enforcement strategies: Approaches to improving practice. Trends & Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice No. 472. Canberra, ACT: Australian Institute of Criminology.
71. Transport for NSW (2016) Information relating to the cost and results of mobile drug testing. Sydney, New South Wales. Available upon request at http://www.transport.nsw.gov.au/about/access-nsw-government-Transport-informationgipa/disclosure-log.
72. Transport for NSW-Centre for Road Safety (2016) Drugs and driving. Sydney, New South Wales. Available at http://roadsafety.transport.nsw.gov.au/stayingsafe/alcoholdrugs/drugdriving/(accessed 20 August 2016).
73. Verster J, van de Loo A and Roth T (2017) Effects of hypnotic drugs on driving performance. In Kryger M, Roth T and Dement W (eds) Principles and Practice of Sleep Medicine, 6th edn: 499- 505. USA: Elsevier. DOI:10.1016/B978-0-323-24288-2.00179-3.
74. Verstraete A and Raes E (eds) (2006) Rosita-2 Project: Final Report. Ghent, Belgium: Academia Press. Available at http://www.rosita.org/docs/Rosita2%20Final%20report%20May2006.pdf (accessed 26 July 2016).
75. Victoria Police (2010) Alcohol, Drugs & the Law. Melbourne, Victoria. Available at http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?a=internetBridgingPage&Media-ID=56941 (accessed 2 October 2016).
76. Victoria Police (2013) Annual Report 2012-13. Melbourne, Victoria. Available at http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?Document-ID=49 (accessed 20 August 2016).
77. Victoria Police (2014) Annual Report 2013-14. Melbourne, Victoria. vailable at http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?Document-ID=49 (accessed 20 August 2016).
78. Victoria Police (2015) Annual Report 2014-15. Melbourne, Victoria. Available at http://www.police.vic.gov.au/content.asp?a=internetBridgingPage&Media-ID=112492 (accessed 20 August 2016).
79. Vindenes V, Jordbru D, Knapskog AB, Kvan E, Mathisrud G, Slørdal L and Mørland J (2012) Impairment based legislative limits for driving under the influence of non-Alcohol drugs in Norway. Forensic Science International 219(1-3): 1-11. DOI:10.1016/j.forsciint.2011.11.004.
80. Visentin L (2016) Roadside drug driving tests mysterious and uncertain, magistrate says. The Sydney Morning Herald, 2 February. Available at http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/roadsidedrug-driving-Tests-mysterious-And-uncertain-magistrate-says-20160202-gmjus2.html(accessed 2 February 2016).
81. Wilson L (2012) Exploring illicit drug use and drug driving as edgework. Current Issues in Criminal Justice 24(2): 223-240. Available at http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/CICrimJust/2012/31.pdf (accessed 29 May 2017).
82. Wodak A and McDonald D (2016) What would effective, fair and just drug-driving laws look like? The Conversation, 26 February. Available at https://theconversation.com/what-wouldeffective-fair-And-just-drug-driving-laws-look-like-55379 (accessed 26 February 2016).
83. Wolff K et al. (2013) Driving Under the Influence of Drugs: Report from the Expert Panel on Drug Driving. London: UK Department of Transport. Available at http://www.antoniocasella.eu/archila/drug-driving-march2013.pdf (accessed 29 May 2017).
84. Woolley J and Baldock M (2009) Review of Western Australian drug driving laws. Centre for Automotive Safety Research, CASR Report Series, CASR064. Adelaide, South Australia: The University of Adelaide. Available at https://hekyll.services.adelaide.edu.au/dspace/bitstream/2440/50002/1/CASR064.pdf (accessed 29 May 2017).