Problematizing water vulnerability indices at a local level: A critical review and proposed solution

Water Resources Management

Volumn 29, Issue 14, 2015, Pages 5015-5035

  De Grosbois, Danuta ^a   Plummer, Ryan ^a,b  

^a BROCK UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b STOCKHOLM UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

Author keywords

Index design; Water vulnerability; Water vulnerability indices

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY OF INFORMATION; COMPOSITE INDEX; CRITICAL REVIEW; GOOD PRACTICES; INDEX DESIGNS; WATER VULNERABILITIES;

WATER RESOURCES;

DESIGN; INDEX METHOD; RESOURCE ASSESSMENT; VULNERABILITY; WATER MANAGEMENT; WATER RESOURCE;

EID: 85027938249     PISSN: 09204741     EISSN: 15731650     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11269-015-1101-0     Document Type: Article

References (40)

1. Alessa L, Kliskey A, Lammers R, Arp C, White D, Hinzman L, Busey R (2008) The Arctic water resource vulnerability index: an integrated assessment tool for community resilience and vulnerability with respect to freshwater. Environ Manag 42:523–541
2. Armitage D, Berkes F, Dale A, Kocho-Schellenberg E, Patton E (2011) Co-management and the co-production of knowledge: learning to adapt in Canada’s Arctic. Glob Environ Chang 21:995–1004
3. Aydin NY, Mays L, Schmitt T (2014) Technical and environmental sustainability assessment of water distribution systems. Water Resour Manag 28(13):4699–4713
4. Babel MS, Wahid SM (2009) Freshwater under threat: South East Asia – vulnerability assessment of freshwater resources to environmental change: Mekong River Basin. United Nations Environment Programme and Asia Institute of Technology, Thailand
5. Baird J, Plummer R, Dupont D, Carter B (2015) Can context help to understand the perceptions of water quality in First Nation communities? Nat Cult 10(2):225–249
6. Baird J, Carter B, Cave K, Dupont D, General P, King C, Plummer R (2013) Local perspectives on water quality and governance: the value of surveys to First Nation communities. Indigenous Policy J (Special Issue: Exploring the Governance Landscape of Indigenous People and Water in Canada), 23(4), [online] URL: http://www.indigenouspolicy.org/index.php/ipj/article/view/144/132.
7. Catano N, Marchand M, Staley S, Wang Y (2009) Development and validation of the Watershed Sustainability Index (WSI) for the watershed of the Reventazón River. COMCURE, Costa Rica. http://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/E-project-121609-171302/unrestricted/UNESCO-COMCURE.pdf
8. Cave K, Plummer R, de Loë R (2013) Exploring water governance and management in Oneida Nation of the Thames: an application of the institutional analysis development framework. Indigenous Policy J (Special Issue: Exploring the Governance Landscape of Indigenous People and Water in Canada), 23(4), [online] URL: http://www.indigenouspolicy.org/index.php/ipj/article/view/145/133.
9. Chavez HML, Alipaz S (2007) An integrated indicator based on basin hydrology, environment, life, and policy: The Watershed Sustainability Index. Water Resour Manag 21:883–895
10. Cohen A, Sullivan CA (2010) Water and poverty in rural China: developing an instrument to assess the multiple dimensions of water and poverty. Ecol Econ 69:999–1009
11. Dupont D, Waldner C, Bharadwaj L, Plummer R, Carter B, Cave K, Zagozewski R (2014) Drinking water management: Health risk perceptions and choices in First Nations and non-first nations communities in Canada. Int J Environ Res Public Health 11(6):5889–5903. doi:10.3390/ijerph110605889
12. Feitelson E, Chenoweth J (2002) Water poverty: towards a meaningful indicator. Water Policy 4:263–281
13. Jubeh G, Mimi Z (2012) Govenrance and climate vulnerability index. Water Resour Manag 26(14):4147–4162
14. Malone EL, LaRovere EL (2005) Assessing current an changing socio-economic conditions. In: Burton I, Malone EL, Huq S (eds) Adaptation policy framework for climate change: developing strategies, policies and measures. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
15. Meinzen-Dick R (2007) Beyond panaceas in water institutions. Proc Natl Acad Sci 104(39):15200–15205
16. Moldan B, Dahl A (2007) Challenges to sustainability indicators. In: Hak T, Moldan B, Dal A (eds) Sustainability indicators: a scientific assessment. Island Press, Washington
17. Molle F, Mollinga P (2003)Water poverty indicators: conceptual problems and policy issues. Water Policy 5:529–544
18. Norman ES, Dunn G, Bakker K, Allen DM, de Albuquerque RC (2013) Water security assessment: integrating governance and freshwater indicators. Water Resour Manag 27(2):535–551
19. OECD (2008) Handbook on constructing composite indicators. Methodology and user guide. OECD, Paris
20. Petticrew M, Roberts H (2006) Systematic reviews in the social sciences: a practical guide. Blackwell Publishers, Malden
21. Plummer R, de Loë R, Armitage D (2012) A systematic review of water vulnerability assessment tools. Water Resour Manag 26(15):4327–4346
22. Plummer R, de Grosbois D, Armitage D, de Loë R (2013) An integrative assessment of water vulnerability in First Nation communities in Southern Ontario, Canada. Glob Environ Chang 23(4):749–763
23. Pintér L, Bizikova L, Kutics K, Vári A (2008) Developing a system of sustainability indicators for the Lake Balaton Region. Hung J Landsc Ecol 6(3):271–295
24. Saisana M, Tarantola S (2002) State-of-the-art report on current methodologies and practices for composite indicator development, EUR Report 20408 EN. European Commission, JRC-IPSC, Italy
25. Saisana M, Saltelli A, Tarantola S (2005) Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis techniques as tools for the analysis and validation of composite indicators. J R Stat Soc Ser A 168(2):307–323
26. Saltelli A, Ratto M, Andres T, Campolongo F, Cariboni J, Gatelli D, Saisana M, Tarantola S (2008) Global sensitivity analysis: the primer. Wiley, Oxford
27. Scoones I (1998) Sustainable rural livelihoods: a framework for analysis. Institute of Development Studies, Brighton
28. Sen A (1984) Rights and capabilities. In: Sen A (ed) Resources, values and development. Blackwell, Basil, pp 307–324
29. Sen (2000) Development as freedom. Anchor Books, New York
30. Singh RK, Murty HR, Gupta SK, Dikshit A (2007) Development of composite sustainability performance index for steel industry. Ecol Indic 7:565–588
31. Sullivan C (2001) The potential for calculating a meaningful Water Poverty Index. Water Int 26(4):471–480
32. Sullivan C (2002) Calculating a Water Poverty Index. World Dev 30:1195–1210
33. Sullivan CA (2010) Quantifying water vulnerability: a multi-dimensional approach. Stoch Env Res Risk A 25(4): 627–640
34. Sullivan CA, Meigh J (2007) Integration of the biophysical and social sciences using an indicator approach: addressing water problems at different scales. Water Resour Manag 21:111–128
35. Sullivan CA, Meigh JR, Giacomello AM (2003) The Water Poverty Index: development and application at the community scale. Nat Res Forum 27:189–199
36. Sullivan C, Cohen A, Faures JM, Santini G (2009) The rural water livelihoods index. Working Paper. Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, Rome. http://www.fao.org/nr/water/docs/FAOW_RWLI_paper.pdf. Accessed 6 May 2010
37. Tarantola S, Jesinghaus J, Puolamaa M (2000) Global sensitivity analysis: a quality assurance tool in environmental policy modelling. In: Saltelli A, Chan K, Scott M (eds) Sensitivity analysis. Wiley, New York, pp 385–397
38. Van Beynen P, Townsend K (2005) A disturbance index for Karst environments. Environ Manag 36(1):101–116
39. Vörösmarty CJ, McIntyre PB, Gessner MO, Dudgeon D, Prusevich A, Green P, Glidden S, Bunn SE, Sullivan CA, Reidy Liermann C, Davies PM (2010) Global threats to human water security and river biodiversity. Nature 467:555–561. doi:10.1038/nature09440
40. Winograd M, Aguilar M, Farrow A, Segnestam L, Linddal M, Dixon J (1999) Conceptual framework to develop and use water indicators. CIAT, Cali. http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTEEI/811099-1115809852605/20486439/ConceptualFrameworktoDevelopandUseWaterIndicators1999.pdf