An integrative assessment of water vulnerability in First Nation communities in Southern Ontario, Canada

Global Environmental Change

Volumn 23, Issue 4, 2013, Pages 749-763

  Plummer, Ryan ^a,b,c   de Grosbois, Danuta ^a   Armitage, Derek ^c   de Loë, Rob C ^c  

^a BROCK UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b STOCKHOLM UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WATERLOO   (Canada)

Author keywords

Adaptation; Governance; Knowledge co production; Policy; Water vulnerability

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING; GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE; GOVERNANCE APPROACH; INNOVATION; RESOURCE ALLOCATION; VULNERABILITY; WATER MANAGEMENT;

CANADA; ONTARIO [CANADA];

EID: 84878572547     PISSN: 09593780     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.03.005     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada, 2013. Registered Population. Available from (accessed 6.4.11). http://pse5-esd5.ainc-inac.gc.ca/fnp/Main/Search/FNRegPopulation.aspx%3FBAND_NUMBER=120%26lang=eng.
2. Adger, W.N, Brooks, N., Kelly, M., Bentham, G., Agnew, M., Eriksen, S., 2004. New indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. Technical Report 7. Available from: (accessed 26.01.12). http://tyndall.ac.uk/sites/default/files/it1_11.pdf.
3. Alessa L., Kliskey A., Lammers R., Arp C., White D., Hinzman L. An integrated freshwater resilience index for the arctic. Journal of Environment Management 2008, 42(3):523-541.
4. Armitage D., Berkes F., Dale A., Kocho-Schellenberg E., Patton E. Co-management and the co-production of knowledge: learning to adapt in Canada's Arctic. Global Environmental Change 2011, 21(3):995-1004.
5. Armitage D., Marschke M., Plummer R. Adaptive co-management and the paradox of learning. Global Environmental Change 2008, 18:86-98.
6. Babbie E.R. The Practice of Social Research 2010, Cengage Learning, Belmont, CA.
7. Babel M.S., Wahidm S.M. Freshwater Under Threat: South East Asia 2009, United Nations Environment Program, Nairobi, Kenya.
8. Baird, J., Carter, B., Dupont, D., General, P., King, C., Plummer, R., Varewyck, A. Gaining insights about water: the value of surveys in First Nations communities to inform water governance. Indigenous Policy Journal, in press.
9. Berkes F. Evolution of co-management: role of knowledge generation, bridging organizations and social learning. Journal of Environment Management 2009, 90:1692-1702.
10. Navigating Social-Ecological Systems: Building Resilience for Complexity and Change 2003, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. F. Berkes, J. Colding, C. Folke (Eds.).
11. Linking Social and Ecological Systems. Management Practices and Social Mechanisms for Building Resilience 1998, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK. F. Berkes, C. Folke (Eds.).
12. Blaikie N. Designing Social Research 2010, Polity Press, Boston, MA.
13. Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment Canadian Environmental Quality Guidelines, Publication No. 1299 2001, Environment Canada, Hull, Quebec.
14. Chaves H.M.L., Alipaz S. An integrated indicator based on basin hydrology, environment, life, and policy: the watershed sustainability index. Water Resources Management 2007, 21(5):883-895.
15. Christensen R. Waterproof 3: Canada's Drinking Water Report Card 2011, Ecojustice, Toronto, Ontario.
16. Christensen R., Goucher N., Phare M.-A. Seeking Water Justice: Strengthening Legal Protection for Canada's Drinking Water 2010, Ecojustice, Toronto, Ontario.
17. Cohen A., Sullivan C.A. Water poverty in rural China: developing an instrument to assess the multiple dimensions of water and poverty. Ecological Economics 2010, 69(5):999-1009.
18. de Loë R.C., Kreutzwiser R. Challenging the status quo: the evolution of water governance in Canada. Eau Canada: The Future of Canadian Water Governance 2006, University of British Columbia Press, Vancouver. K. Bakker (Ed.).
19. Downing T.E., Aerts J., Soussan J., Barthelemy O., Bharwani S., Ionescu C., Hinkel J., Klein R.J.T., Mata L.J., Martin N., Moss S., Purkey D., Ziervogel G. Integrating Social Vulnerability into Water Management, SEI Working Paper and Newater Working Paper No. 4 2006, Stockholm Environment Institute, Oxford.
20. Eakin H., Luers A.L. Assessing the vulnerability of social-environmental systems. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 2006, 31:365-394.
21. Eggertson L. Despite federal promises, First Nations' water problems persist. Canadian Medical Association Journal 2008, 178(8):985.
22. Farley K.A., Tague C., Grant G.E. Vulnerability of water supply from the Oregon Cascades to changing climate: linking science to users and policy. Global Environmental Change 2011, 21(1):110-122.
23. Faugier J., Sargeant M. Sampling hard to reach populations. Journal of Advanced Nursing 1997, 26:790-797.
24. Fazey I., Kesby M., Evely A., Latham I., Wagatora D., Hagasua J.-E., Reed M.S., Christie M. A three-tiered approach to participatory vulnerability assessment in the Solomon Islands. Global Environmental Change 2010, 20(4):713-728.
25. Feitelson E., Chenoweth J. Water poverty: towards a meaningful indicator. Water Policy 2002, 4:263-281.
26. Fobes B.C., Stammler F. Arctic climate change discourse: the contrasting politics of research agendas in the West and Russia. Polar Research 2009, 28:28-42.
27. Folke C., Hahn T., Olsson P., Norberg J. Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 2005, 30:441-473.
28. Füssel H.-M., Klein R.J.T. Climate change vulnerability assessments: an evolution of conceptual thinking. Climatic Change 2006, 75:301-329.
29. Gadgil A. Drinking water in developing countries. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment 1998, 22:253-286.
30. George A.L.A., Bennett A.A.B. Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences 2005, MIT Press, Boston, MA.
31. Hadipuro W. Water supply vulnerability assessment for sustainable livelihoods. Polar Research 2007, 9(1):121-135.
32. Hahn M.B., Riederer A.M., Foster S.O. The Livelihood Vulnerability Index: a pragmatic approach to assessing risks from climate variability and change-a case study in Mozambique. Global Environmental Change 2009, 19(1):74-88.
33. Hinkel J. Transdisciplinary Knowledge Integration - Cases from Integrated Assessment and Vulnerability Assessment. FAVAIA Working Paper 7 2008, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, and Stockholm Environmental Institute.
34. Hinkel J. Indicators of vulnerability and adaptive capacity: towards a clarification of the science-policy interface. Global Environmental Change 2011, 21(1):198-208.
35. Hrudey S.E., Hrudey E.J. Safe Drinking Water: Lessons from Recent Outbreaks in Affluent Nations 2004, IWA Publishing, London, UK.
36. Huitema D., Mostert E., Egas W., Moellenkamp S., Pahl-Wostl C., Yalcin R. Adaptive water governance: assessing the institutional prescriptions of adaptive (co-)management from a governance perspective and defining a research agenda. Ecology and Society 2009, 14(1):26. Available from: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol14/iss1/art26/ (accessed 20.01.12).
37. Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC) National Assessment of Water and Wastewater Systems in First Nation Communities 2003, Author, Ottawa, Ontario, Available from: http://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/DAM/DAM-INTER-HQ/STAGING/texte-text/watw_1100100016374_eng.pdf (accessed 01.11.11).
38. INAC Detailed Tables - Registered Indian Population by Sex and Type of Residence by Group, Responsibility Centre and Region 2010 - Region 4 - Ontario 2010, Available from http://ainc-inac.gc.ca/eng/1309371330667 (accessed 27.10.11).
39. Ingram, H., 2008. Beyond universal remedies for good water governance: a political and contextual approach. Paper presented at the Rosenberg International Forum on Water Policy. Zaragoza, 24-27 June 2008.
40. Jimenez-Cisneros B. Water availability index based on quality and quantity: its application in Mexico. Water Science and Technology 1996, 34(12):165-172.
41. Johnston L.G., Sabin K. Sampling hard-to-reach populations with respondent drive sampling. Methodological Innovations Online 2010, 5(2):38-48.
42. Kundzewicz Z.W., Mata L.J., Arnell N.W., Döll P., Jimenez B., Miller K., Oki T., Şen Z., Shiklomanov I. The implications of projected climate change for freshwater resources and their management. Hydrological Sciences Journal 2008, 53(1):3-10.
43. Lake Erie Region Source Protection Committee, 2010. Six Nations and the Grand River. Grand River Source Protection Area Draft Assessment Report (1-22) Cambridge, Ontario.
44. Mascarenhas M. Where the waters divide: First Nations, tainted water and environmental justice in Canada. Local Environment 2007, 12(6):565-577.
45. Maykut P.S., Morehouse R.E. Beginning Qualitative Research: A Philosophic and Practical Guide 1994, The Falmer Press, Bristol, PA.
46. McGregor D. Honouring our relations: an Anishnaabe perspective on environmental justice. Speaking for Ourselves: Environmental Justice in Canada 2009, UBC Press, Vancouver. J. Agyeman, P. Cole, R. Haluza-DeLay, P. O'Riley (Eds.).
47. Milly P.C.D., Betancourt J., Falkenmark M., Lettenmaier D., Stouffer R.J. Stationarity is dead: whither water management. Science 2008, 319(5863):573-574.
48. Molle F., Mollinga P. Water poverty indicators: conceptual problems and policy issues. Water Policy 2003, 5:529-544.
49. Muhib F.B., Lin L.S., Stueve A., Miller R.L., Ford W.L., Johnson W.D., Smith P.J. A venue-based method for sampling hard-to-reach populations. Public Health Reports 2001, 116(1):216-222.
50. Munda G. Social Multi-criteria Evaluation for Sustainable Economy 2008, Springer, Berlin.
51. National Aboriginal Health Organization Terminology 2012, Available from: http://www.naho.ca/publications/topics/terminology/ (accessed 05.11.11).
52. Neegan Burnside Engineering and Environmental Ltd. Six Nations of the Grand River Hydrogeological Study 2005, Six Nations Council, Ohsweken, ON.
53. Novak J.D. Learning, Creating and Using Knowledge: Concept Maps as Facilitative Tools in Schools and Corporations 1998, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc., Mahwah, NJ.
54. Oneida Nation of the Thames, 2009.Oneida Nation of the Thames engineer's assessment of the water treatment facility draft final report. Prepared by First Nation Engineering Services Ltd. Oneida Nation of the Thames, Ohsweken, Ontario.
55. Ontario Clean Water Agency Assessment Study of Water and Wastewater Systems and Associated Water Management Practices in Ontario First Nations Communities 2001, Oneida Nation of the Thames (Band No.169), Toronto, ON.
56. Ontario Clean Water Agency Assessment Study of Water and Wastewater Systems and Associated Water Management Practices in Ontario First Nations Communities 2002, Six Nations of the Grand River (Band No. 121), Toronto, ON.
57. Ontario Ministry of the Environment Nanticoke Drinking Water System 2010, Available from: http://www.ene.gov.on.ca/environment/dwo/en/mapping/report/system?dws=210001558 (accessed 10.10.12).
58. Ontario Ministry of the Environment The Drinking Water Surveillance Program (DWSP) Water Quality Dataset 2009, Available from: http://www.ene.gov.on.ca/environment/en/resources/collection/data_downloads/index.htm#DWSP (accessed 10.10.12).
59. Pahl-Wostl C. Transition towards adaptive management of water facing climate and global change. Water Resources Management 2007, 21(1):49-62.
60. Parkins J.R., MacKendrick N.A. Assessing community vulnerability: a study of the mountain pine beetle outbreak in British Columbia, Canada. Global Environmental Change 2007, 17(3-4):460-471.
61. Pelling M., Uitto J.I. Small island developing states: natural disaster vulnerability and global change. Environmental Hazards 2001, 3:49-62.
62. Phare M.-A. Denying the Source: The Crisis of First Nations Water Rights 2009, Rocky Mountain Books, Surrey, BC.
63. Petticrew M., Roberts H. Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences: A Practical Guide 2006, Blackwell Publishers, Malden, MA, USA.
64. Plummer R., Armitage D. Integrating perspectives on adaptive capacity and environmental governance. Adaptive Capacity and Environmental Governance 2010, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany. D. Armitage, R. Plummer (Eds.).
65. Plummer R., de Loë R., Armitage D. A systematic review of water vulnerability assessment tools. Water Resources Management 2012, 26(15):4327-4346. 10.1007/s11269-012-0147-5.
66. Pollution Probe The Drinking Water Primer 2002, Author, Toronto, ON.
67. Pullin A.S., Knight T.M. Doing more good than harm-building an evidence-base for conservation and environmental management. Biological Conservation 2009, 142:931-934.
68. Ruiz-Primo M.A., Shavelson R.J. Problems and issues in the use of concept maps in science assessment. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1996, 33(6):569-600.
69. Saisana M., d'Hombres B., Saltelli A. Rickety numbers: volatility of university rankings and policy implications. Research Policy 2011, 40:165-177.
70. Saisana M., Saltelli A., Tarantola S. Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis techniques as tools for the quality assessment of composite indicators. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society (Series A) 2005, 168:307-323.
71. Saravanan V.S., McDonald G.T., Mollinga P.P. Critical review of integrated water resources management: moving beyond polarised discourse. Natural Resources Forum 2009, 33:76-86.
72. Schröter D., Polsky C., Patt A.G. Assessing vulnerabilities to the effects of global change: an eight step approach. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 2005, 10(4):573-595.
73. Schultz D., Boyd D., Cooke S., Anderson M., Nelson G. Quantity and quality of water in the Grand River watershed. Towards a Grand Sense of Place 2004, Author, Waterloo, ON. G. Nelson (Ed.).
74. Shaw A., Sheppard S., Burch S., Flanders D., Wiek A., Carmichael J., Robinson J., Cohen S. Making local futures tangible-synthesizing, downscaling, and visualizing climate change scenarios for participatory capacity building. Global Environmental Change 2009, 19(4):447-463.
75. Six Nations of the Grand River Six Nations Community Profile 2010, Six Nations of the Grand River Ohsweken, Ontario.
76. Strauss A., Corbin J. Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques 1990, Sage Publications, Newbury Park, CA.
77. Sullivan C.A. Calculating a water poverty index. World Development 2002, 30(7):1195-1210.
78. Sullivan C.A. Quantifying water vulnerability: a multi-dimensional approach. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment 2010, 25(4):627-640.
79. Sullivan C.A., Meigh J. Integration of the biophysical and social sciences using an indicator approach: addressing water problems at different scales. Water Resources Management 2007, 21:111-128.
80. Sullivan C.A., Meigh J.R., Giacomello A.M., Fediw T., Lawrence P., Samad M., Mlote S., Hutton C., Allan J.A., Schulze R.E., Dlamini D.J.M., Cosgrove W., Delli Priscoli J., Gleick P., Smout I., Cobbing J., Calow R., Hunt C., Hussain A., Acremen M.C., King J., Malomo S., Tate E.L., O'Regan T.D., Milner S., Steyl I. The water poverty index: development and application at the community scale. Natural Resources Forum 2003, 27:189-199.
81. Sullivan, C.A., Cohen, A., Faurès, J.M., Santini, G., 2009. The rural water livelihoods index. Working paper. Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, Rome. Available from: (accessed 6.05.2010). http://www.fao.org/nr/water/docs/FAOW_RWLI_paper.pdf.
82. Sullivan C.A. Quantifying water vulnerability: a multi-dimensional approach. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk Assessment 2011, 25(4):627-640.
83. The Adaptiveness of IWRM: Analysing European IWRM Research 2008, IWA Publishing, London, UK. J.G. Timmerman, C. Pahl-Wostl, J. Moltgen (Eds.).
84. Turner B.L., Kasperson R.E., Matson P.A., McCarthy J.J., Corell R.W., Christensen L., Eckley N., Kasperson J.X., Luers A., Martello M.L., Polsky C., Pulsipher A., Schiller A. A framework for vulnerability analysis in sustainability science. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 2003, 100(14):8074-8079.
85. UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme) Global Environment Outlook 3: Past, Present and Future Perspectives 2002, Earthscan Publications, London, UK.
86. Union of Ontario Indians First Nations Launch Court Action over Toronto Landfill 2007, Available from: http://www.anishinabek.ca/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=118&Itemid=47 (accessed 02.11.11).
87. van Aalst M.K., Cannon T., Burton I. Community level adaptation to climate change: the potential role of participatory community risk assessment. Global Environmental Change 2008, 18:165-179.
88. Van Beynen P., Townsend K. A disturbance index for Karst environments. Environmental Management 2005, 36:101-116.
89. van Vliet N. Participatory vulnerability assessment in the context of conservation and development projects: a case study of local communities in Southwest Cameroon. Ecology and Society 2010, 15(2). Available at: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol15/iss2/art6/ (accessed 05.01.12).
90. Vörösmarty C.J., Green P., Salisbury J., Lammers R.B. Global water resources: vulnerability from climate change and population growth. Science 2000, 289:284-288.
91. Walkem A. The land is dry: indigenous peoples, water, and environmental justice. Eau Canada: The Future of Canadian Water 2006, UBC Press, Vancouver. K. Bakker (Ed.).
92. Wolfe B., Armitage D., Wesche S., Brock B., Sokal M., Clogg-Wright K., Mongeon C., Adam M., Hall R., Edwards T. From isotopes to TK interviews: towards interdisciplinary research in Fort Resolution and the Slave River Delta, NWT. Arctic 2007, 60(1):75-87.
93. World Health Organization and UNICEF Meeting the MDG Drinking Water and Sanitation Target: the Urban and Rural Challenge of the Decade 2006, Authors, Geneva, CH.
94. World Water Council Water Crisis 2011, Available from: http://www.worldwatercouncil.org/index.php?id=25 (accessed 12.01.12).
95. Yin R. Applications of Case Study Research 1993, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
96. Yin R. Case Study Research: Design and Methods 1994, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.